Showing 1–40 of 40 results for author: Dawar, A

Symmetric Proofs in the Ideal Proof System

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Erich Grädel, Leon Kullmann, Benedikt Pago

Abstract: We consider the Ideal Proof System (IPS) introduced by Grochow and Pitassi and pose the question of which tautologies admit symmetric proofs, and of what complexity. The symmetry requirement in proofs is inspired by recent work establishing lower bounds in other symmetric models of computation. We link the existence of symmetric IPS proofs to the expressive power of logics such as fixed-point logi… ▽ More We consider the Ideal Proof System (IPS) introduced by Grochow and Pitassi and pose the question of which tautologies admit symmetric proofs, and of what complexity. The symmetry requirement in proofs is inspired by recent work establishing lower bounds in other symmetric models of computation. We link the existence of symmetric IPS proofs to the expressive power of logics such as fixed-point logic with counting and Choiceless Polynomial Time, specifically regarding the graph isomorphism problem. We identify relationships and tradeoffs between the symmetry of proofs and other parameters of IPS proofs such as size, degree and linearity. We study these on a number of standard families of tautologies from proof complexity and finite model theory such as the pigeonhole principle, the subset sum problem and the Cai-Fürer-Immerman graphs, exhibiting non-trivial upper bounds on the size of symmetric IPS proofs. △ Less

Submitted 23 April, 2025; originally announced April 2025.

Undefinability of Approximation of 2-to-2 Games

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Bálint Molnár

Abstract: Recent work by Atserias and Dawar (J. Log. Comp 2019) and Tucker-Foltz (LMCS 2024) has established undefinability results in fixed-point logic with counting (FPC) corresponding to many classical complexity results from the hardness of approximation. In this line of work, NP-hardness results are turned into unconditional FPC undefinability results. We extend this work by showing the FPC undefinabil… ▽ More Recent work by Atserias and Dawar (J. Log. Comp 2019) and Tucker-Foltz (LMCS 2024) has established undefinability results in fixed-point logic with counting (FPC) corresponding to many classical complexity results from the hardness of approximation. In this line of work, NP-hardness results are turned into unconditional FPC undefinability results. We extend this work by showing the FPC undefinability of any constant factor approximation of weighted 2-to-2 games, based on the NP-hardness results of Khot, Minzer and Safra. Our result shows that the completely satisfiable 2-to-2 games are not FPC-separable from those that are not epsilon-satisfiable, for arbitrarily small epsilon. The perfect completeness of our inseparability is an improvement on the complexity result, as the NP-hardness of such a separation is still only conjectured. This perfect completeness enables us to show the FPC undefinability of other problems whose NP-hardness is conjectured. In particular, we are able to show that no FPC formula can separate the 3-colourable graphs from those that are not t-colourable, for any constant t. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2025; originally announced April 2025.

Comments: 25 pages. Full version of a paper that appeared in CSL 2025

MSC Class: 68Q19 (Primary); 68Q25; 68Q17

Symmetric Algebraic Circuits and Homomorphism Polynomials

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Benedikt Pago, Tim Seppelt

Abstract: The central open question of algebraic complexity is whether VP is unequal to VNP, which is saying that the permanent cannot be represented by families of polynomial-size algebraic circuits. For symmetric algebraic circuits, this has been confirmed by Dawar and Wilsenach (2020) who showed exponential lower bounds on the size of symmetric circuits for the permanent. In this work, we set out to deve… ▽ More The central open question of algebraic complexity is whether VP is unequal to VNP, which is saying that the permanent cannot be represented by families of polynomial-size algebraic circuits. For symmetric algebraic circuits, this has been confirmed by Dawar and Wilsenach (2020) who showed exponential lower bounds on the size of symmetric circuits for the permanent. In this work, we set out to develop a more general symmetric algebraic complexity theory. Our main result is that a family of symmetric polynomials admits small symmetric circuits if and only if they can be written as a linear combination of homomorphism counting polynomials of graphs of bounded treewidth. We also establish a relationship between the symmetric complexity of subgraph counting polynomials and the vertex cover number of the pattern graph. As a concrete example, we examine the symmetric complexity of immanant families (a generalisation of the determinant and permanent) and show that a known conditional dichotomy due to Curticapean (2021) holds unconditionally in the symmetric setting. △ Less

Submitted 10 February, 2025; originally announced February 2025.

Homomorphism Counts to Trees

Authors: Anuj Dawar

Abstract: We construct a pair of non-isomorphic, bipartite graphs which are not distinguished by counting the number of homomorphisms to any tree. This answers a question motivated by Atserias et al. (LICS 2021). In order to establish the construction, we analyse the equivalence relations induced by counting homomorphisms to trees of diameter two and three and obtain necessary and sufficient conditions for… ▽ More We construct a pair of non-isomorphic, bipartite graphs which are not distinguished by counting the number of homomorphisms to any tree. This answers a question motivated by Atserias et al. (LICS 2021). In order to establish the construction, we analyse the equivalence relations induced by counting homomorphisms to trees of diameter two and three and obtain necessary and sufficient conditions for two graphs to be equivalent. We show that three is the optimal diameter for our construction. △ Less

Submitted 12 December, 2024; v1 submitted 29 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 13 pages

MSC Class: 05C60 (primary) 68R10 (secondary) ACM Class: G.2.1; G.2.2

Preservation theorems on sparse classes revisited

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Ioannis Eleftheriadis

Abstract: We revisit the work studying homomorphism preservation for first-order logic in sparse classes of structures initiated in [Atserias et al., JACM 2006] and [Dawar, JCSS 2010]. These established that first-order logic has the homomorphism preservation property in any sparse class that is monotone and addable. It turns out that the assumption of addability is not strong enough for the proofs given. W… ▽ More We revisit the work studying homomorphism preservation for first-order logic in sparse classes of structures initiated in [Atserias et al., JACM 2006] and [Dawar, JCSS 2010]. These established that first-order logic has the homomorphism preservation property in any sparse class that is monotone and addable. It turns out that the assumption of addability is not strong enough for the proofs given. We demonstrate this by constructing classes of graphs of bounded treewidth which are monotone and addable but fail to have homomorphism preservation. We also show that homomorphism preservation fails on the class of planar graphs. On the other hand, the proofs of homomorphism preservation can be recovered by replacing addability by a stronger condition of amalgamation over bottlenecks. This is analogous to a similar condition formulated for extension preservation in [Atserias et al., SiCOMP 2008]. △ Less

Submitted 20 May, 2024; v1 submitted 17 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 16 pages

MSC Class: 03B70; 03C13; 68Q19; 05C10

Descriptive complexity of controllable graphs

Authors: Aida Abiad, Anuj Dawar, Octavio Zapata

Abstract: Let $G$ be a graph on $n$ vertices with adjacency matrix $A$, and let $\mathbf{1}$ be the all-ones vector. We call $G$ controllable if the set of vectors $\mathbf{1}, A\mathbf{1}, \dots, A^{n-1}\mathbf{1}$ spans the whole space $\mathbb{R}^n$. We characterize the isomorphism problem of controllable graphs in terms of other combinatorial, geometric and logical problems. We also describe a polynomia… ▽ More Let $G$ be a graph on $n$ vertices with adjacency matrix $A$, and let $\mathbf{1}$ be the all-ones vector. We call $G$ controllable if the set of vectors $\mathbf{1}, A\mathbf{1}, \dots, A^{n-1}\mathbf{1}$ spans the whole space $\mathbb{R}^n$. We characterize the isomorphism problem of controllable graphs in terms of other combinatorial, geometric and logical problems. We also describe a polynomial time algorithm for graph isomorphism that works for almost all graphs. △ Less

Submitted 9 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 14 pages

Quantifiers closed under partial polymorphisms

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Lauri Hella

Abstract: We study Lindstrom quantifiers that satisfy certain closure properties which are motivated by the study of polymorphisms in the context of constraint satisfaction problems (CSP). When the algebra of polymorphisms of a finite structure B satisfies certain equations, this gives rise to a natural closure condition on the class of structures that map homomorphically to B. The collection of quantifiers… ▽ More We study Lindstrom quantifiers that satisfy certain closure properties which are motivated by the study of polymorphisms in the context of constraint satisfaction problems (CSP). When the algebra of polymorphisms of a finite structure B satisfies certain equations, this gives rise to a natural closure condition on the class of structures that map homomorphically to B. The collection of quantifiers that satisfy closure conditions arising from a fixed set of equations are rather more general than those arising as CSP. For any such conditions P, we define a pebble game that delimits the distinguishing power of the infinitary logic with all quantifiers that are P-closed. We use the pebble game to show that the problem of deciding whether a system of linear equations is solvable in Z2 is not expressible in the infinitary logic with all quantifiers closed under a near-unanimity condition. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: Submitted. 17 pages

Monadic NIP in monotone classes of relational structures

Authors: Samuel Braunfeld, Anuj Dawar, Ioannis Eleftheriadis, Aris Papadopoulos

Abstract: We prove that for any monotone class of finite relational structures, the first-order theory of the class is NIP in the sense of stability theory if, and only if, the collection of Gaifman graphs of structures in this class is nowhere dense. This generalises to relational structures a result previously known for graphs and answers an open question posed by Adler and Adler (2014). The result is est… ▽ More We prove that for any monotone class of finite relational structures, the first-order theory of the class is NIP in the sense of stability theory if, and only if, the collection of Gaifman graphs of structures in this class is nowhere dense. This generalises to relational structures a result previously known for graphs and answers an open question posed by Adler and Adler (2014). The result is established by the application of Ramsey-theoretic techniques and shows that the property of being NIP is highly robust for monotone classes. We also show that the model-checking problem for first-order logic is intractable on any class of monotone structures that is not (monadically) NIP. This is a contribution towards the conjecture of Bonnet et al. that the hereditary classes of structures admitting fixed-parameter tractable model-checking are precisely those that are monadically NIP. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

MSC Class: 3C13; 03C45; 05C75; 68R05; 68Q27 ACM Class: F.4.1; G.2.1

Descriptive complexity of the generalized spectra of graphs

Authors: Aida Abiad, Anuj Dawar, Octavio Zapata

Abstract: Two graphs are cospectral if their respective adjacency matrices have the same multiset of eigenvalues, and generalized cospectral if they are cospectral and so are their complements. We study generalized cospectrality in relation to logical definability. We show that any pair of graphs that are elementary equivalent with respect to the three-variable counting first-order logic $C^3$ are generaliz… ▽ More Two graphs are cospectral if their respective adjacency matrices have the same multiset of eigenvalues, and generalized cospectral if they are cospectral and so are their complements. We study generalized cospectrality in relation to logical definability. We show that any pair of graphs that are elementary equivalent with respect to the three-variable counting first-order logic $C^3$ are generalized cospectral, and this is not the case with $C^2$, nor with any number of variables if we exclude counting quantifiers. Using this result we provide a new characterization of the well-known class of distance-regular graphs using the logic $C^3$. We also show that, for controllable graphs (it is known that almost all graphs are controllable), the elementary equivalence in $C^2$ coincides with isomorphism. △ Less

Submitted 11 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 17 pages

Limitations of the Invertible-Map Equivalences

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Erich Grädel, Moritz Lichter

Abstract: This note draws conclusions that arise by combining two recent papers, by Anuj Dawar, Erich Grädel, and Wied Pakusa, published at ICALP 2019 and by Moritz Lichter, published at LICS 2021. In both papers, the main technical results rely on the combinatorial and algebraic analysis of the invertible-map equivalences $\equiv^\text{IM}_{k,Q}$ on certain variants of Cai-Fürer-Immerman (CFI) structures.… ▽ More This note draws conclusions that arise by combining two recent papers, by Anuj Dawar, Erich Grädel, and Wied Pakusa, published at ICALP 2019 and by Moritz Lichter, published at LICS 2021. In both papers, the main technical results rely on the combinatorial and algebraic analysis of the invertible-map equivalences $\equiv^\text{IM}_{k,Q}$ on certain variants of Cai-Fürer-Immerman (CFI) structures. These $\equiv^\text{IM}_{k,Q}$-equivalences, for a number $k$ and a set of primes~$Q$, refine the well-known Weisfeiler-Leman equivalences used in algorithms for graph isomorphism. The intuition is that two graphs $G\equiv^\text{IM}_{k,Q}H$ cannot be distinguished by iterative refinements of equivalences on $k$-tuples defined via linear operators on vector spaces over fields of characteristic $p \in Q$. In the first paper it has been shown, using considerable algebraic machinery, that for a prime $q \notin Q$, the $\equiv^\text{IM}_{k,Q}$ equivalences do not distinguish between non-isomorphic CFI-structures over the field $\mathbb{F}_q$. In the second paper, a similar but not identical construction for CFI-structures over the rings $\mathbb{Z}_{2^i}$ has, again by rather involved combinatorial and algebraic arguments, been shown to be indistinguishable with respect to $\equiv^\text{IM}_{k,\{2\}}$. Together with earlier work, this second result separates rank logic from polynomial time. We unify the two approaches and prove that CFI-structures over the rings $\mathbb{Z}_{2^i}$ are indistinguishable with respect to $\equiv^\text{IM}_{k,\mathbb{P}}$, for the set $\mathbb{P}$ of all primes. This implies the following two results. 1. There is no fixed $k$ such that the invertible-map equivalence $\equiv^\text{IM}_{k,\mathbb{P}}$ coincides with isomorphism on all finite graphs. 2. No extension of fixed-point logic by linear-algebraic operators over fields can capture polynomial time. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2022; v1 submitted 15 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Lower Bounds for Symmetric Circuits for the Determinant

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Gregory Wilsenach

Abstract: Dawar and Wilsenach (ICALP 2020) introduce the model of symmetric arithmetic circuits and show an exponential separation between the sizes of symmetric circuits for computing the determinant and the permanent. The symmetry restriction is that the circuits which take a matrix input are unchanged by a permutation applied simultaneously to the rows and columns of the matrix. Under such restrictions w… ▽ More Dawar and Wilsenach (ICALP 2020) introduce the model of symmetric arithmetic circuits and show an exponential separation between the sizes of symmetric circuits for computing the determinant and the permanent. The symmetry restriction is that the circuits which take a matrix input are unchanged by a permutation applied simultaneously to the rows and columns of the matrix. Under such restrictions we have polynomial-size circuits for computing the determinant but no subexponential size circuits for the permanent. Here, we consider a more stringent symmetry requirement, namely that the circuits are unchanged by arbitrary even permutations applied separately to rows and columns, and prove an exponential lower bound even for circuits computing the determinant. The result requires substantial new machinery. We develop a general framework for proving lower bounds for symmetric circuits with restricted symmetries, based on a new support theorem and new two-player restricted bijection games. These are applied to the determinant problem with a novel construction of matrices that are bi-adjacency matrices of graphs based on the CFI construction. Our general framework opens the way to exploring a variety of symmetry restrictions and studying trade-offs between symmetry and other resources used by arithmetic circuits. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2024; v1 submitted 22 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 29 Pages. Substantial revision, particularly in Section 4

ACM Class: F.1.3; F.2.1

Separating LREC from LFP

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Felipe Ferreira Santos

Abstract: LREC= is an extension of first-order logic with a logarithmic recursion operator. It was introduced by Grohe et al. and shown to capture the complexity class L over trees and interval graphs. It does not capture L in general as it is contained in FPC - fixed-point logic with counting. We show that this containment is strict. In particular, we show that the path systems problem, a classic P-complet… ▽ More LREC= is an extension of first-order logic with a logarithmic recursion operator. It was introduced by Grohe et al. and shown to capture the complexity class L over trees and interval graphs. It does not capture L in general as it is contained in FPC - fixed-point logic with counting. We show that this containment is strict. In particular, we show that the path systems problem, a classic P-complete problem which is definable in LFP - fixed-point logic - is not definable in LREC= This shows that the logarithmic recursion mechanism is provably weaker than general least fixed points. The proof is based on a novel Spoiler-Duplicator game tailored for this logic. △ Less

Submitted 12 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 21 pages. Submitted

MSC Class: 68Q19 ACM Class: F.1.3; F.4.1

Lovász-Type Theorems and Game Comonads

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Tomáš Jakl, Luca Reggio

Abstract: Lovász (1967) showed that two finite relational structures A and B are isomorphic if, and only if, the number of homomorphisms from C to A is the same as the number of homomorphisms from C to B for any finite structure C. Soon after, Pultr (1973) proved a categorical generalisation of this fact. We propose a new categorical formulation, which applies to any locally finite category with pushouts an… ▽ More Lovász (1967) showed that two finite relational structures A and B are isomorphic if, and only if, the number of homomorphisms from C to A is the same as the number of homomorphisms from C to B for any finite structure C. Soon after, Pultr (1973) proved a categorical generalisation of this fact. We propose a new categorical formulation, which applies to any locally finite category with pushouts and a proper factorisation system. As special cases of this general theorem, we obtain two variants of Lovász' theorem: the result by Dvořák (2010) that characterises equivalence of graphs in the k-dimensional Weisfeiler-Leman equivalence by homomorphism counts from graphs of tree-width at most k, and the result of Grohe (2020) characterising equivalence with respect to first-order logic with counting and quantifier depth k in terms of homomorphism counts from graphs of tree-depth at most k. The connection of our categorical formulation with these results is obtained by means of the game comonads of Abramsky et al. We also present a novel application to homomorphism counts in modal logic. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: 23 pages. To appear in the Proceedings of the 36th Annual ACM/IEEE Symposium on Logic in Computer Science (LICS 2021)

On the relative power of algebraic approximations of graph isomorphism

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Danny Vagnozzi

Abstract: We compare the capabilities of two approaches to approximating graph isomorphism using linear algebraic methods: the \emph{invertible map tests} (introduced by Dawar and Holm) and proof systems with algebraic rules, namely \emph{polynomial calculus}, \emph{monomial calculus} and \emph{Nullstellensatz calculus}. In the case of fields of characteristic zero, these variants are all essentially equiva… ▽ More We compare the capabilities of two approaches to approximating graph isomorphism using linear algebraic methods: the \emph{invertible map tests} (introduced by Dawar and Holm) and proof systems with algebraic rules, namely \emph{polynomial calculus}, \emph{monomial calculus} and \emph{Nullstellensatz calculus}. In the case of fields of characteristic zero, these variants are all essentially equivalent to the the Weisfeiler-Leman algorithms. In positive characteristic we show that the invertible map method can simulate the monomial calculus and identify a potential way to extend this to the monomial calculus. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

MSO Undecidability for Hereditary Classes of Unbounded Clique-Width

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Abhisekh Sankaran

Abstract: Seese's conjecture for finite graphs states that monadic second-order logic (MSO) is undecidable on all graph classes of unbounded clique-width. We show that to establish this it would suffice to show that grids of unbounded size can be interpreted in two families of graph classes: minimal hereditary classes of unbounded clique-width; and antichains of unbounded clique-width under the induced subg… ▽ More Seese's conjecture for finite graphs states that monadic second-order logic (MSO) is undecidable on all graph classes of unbounded clique-width. We show that to establish this it would suffice to show that grids of unbounded size can be interpreted in two families of graph classes: minimal hereditary classes of unbounded clique-width; and antichains of unbounded clique-width under the induced subgraph relation. We explore all the currently known classes of the former category and establish that grids of unbounded size can indeed be interpreted in them. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2023; v1 submitted 5 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 27 pages, 5 figures. The conference version of this paper appeared in Computer Science Logic (CSL) 2022. The only technical addition in this version over the previous version is in Section 4, where the $ω$-word $α$ is now over the alphabet $\{0, 1, 2, 3\}$ instead of over $\{0, 1, 2\}$. The other changes are about fixing typos and improving readability

MSC Class: 03C13 (Primary); 03C52; 05C75 (Secondary) ACM Class: F.2.2; F.4.1; G.2.2

Extension Preservation in the Finite and Prefix Classes of First Order Logic

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Abhisekh Sankaran

Abstract: It is well known that the classic Łoś-Tarski preservation theorem fails in the finite: there are first-order definable classes of finite structures closed under extensions which are not definable (in the finite) in the existential fragment of first-order logic. We strengthen this by constructing for every $n$, first-order definable classes of finite structures closed under extensions which are not… ▽ More It is well known that the classic Łoś-Tarski preservation theorem fails in the finite: there are first-order definable classes of finite structures closed under extensions which are not definable (in the finite) in the existential fragment of first-order logic. We strengthen this by constructing for every $n$, first-order definable classes of finite structures closed under extensions which are not definable with $n$ quantifier alternations. The classes we construct are definable in the extension of Datalog with negation and indeed in the existential fragment of transitive-closure logic. This answers negatively an open question posed by Rosen and Weinstein. △ Less

Submitted 24 October, 2020; v1 submitted 10 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Comments: 15 pages, to appear in the proceedings of CSL 2021

MSC Class: 03C40; 03C52; 03C13 ACM Class: F.4.1

Game Comonads & Generalised Quantifiers

Authors: Adam Ó Conghaile, Anuj Dawar

Abstract: Game comonads, introduced by Abramsky, Dawar and Wang and developed by Abramsky and Shah, give an interesting categorical semantics to some Spoiler-Duplicator games that are common in finite model theory. In particular they expose connections between one-sided and two-sided games, and parameters such as treewidth and treedepth and corresponding notions of decomposition. In the present paper, we ex… ▽ More Game comonads, introduced by Abramsky, Dawar and Wang and developed by Abramsky and Shah, give an interesting categorical semantics to some Spoiler-Duplicator games that are common in finite model theory. In particular they expose connections between one-sided and two-sided games, and parameters such as treewidth and treedepth and corresponding notions of decomposition. In the present paper, we expand the realm of game comonads to logics with generalised quantifiers. In particular, we introduce a comonad graded by two parameters $n \leq k$ such that isomorphisms in the resulting Kleisli category are exactly Duplicator winning strategies in Hella's $n$-bijection game with $k$ pebbles. We define a one-sided version of this game which allows us to provide a categorical semantics for a number of logics with generalised quantifiers. We also give a novel notion of tree decomposition that emerges from the construction. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2024; v1 submitted 29 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

MSC Class: 68Q19

Journal ref: Logical Methods in Computer Science, Volume 20, Issue 3 (July 23, 2024) lmcs:7643

Symmetric Arithmetic Circuits

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Gregory Wilsenach

Abstract: We introduce symmetric arithmetic circuits, i.e. arithmetic circuits with a natural symmetry restriction. In the context of circuits computing polynomials defined on a matrix of variables, such as the determinant or the permanent, the restriction amounts to requiring that the shape of the circuit is invariant under simultaneous row and column permutations of the matrix. We establish unconditional… ▽ More We introduce symmetric arithmetic circuits, i.e. arithmetic circuits with a natural symmetry restriction. In the context of circuits computing polynomials defined on a matrix of variables, such as the determinant or the permanent, the restriction amounts to requiring that the shape of the circuit is invariant under simultaneous row and column permutations of the matrix. We establish unconditional exponential lower bounds on the size of any symmetric circuit for computing the permanent. In contrast, we show that there are polynomial-size symmetric circuits for computing the determinant over fields of characteristic zero. △ Less

Submitted 19 January, 2024; v1 submitted 15 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 30 pages. Final version, to appear in Theory of Computing. A preliminary version of this work was presented at the International Colloquium on Automata, Languages and Programming (ICALP) 2020

ACM Class: F.1.3; F.2.1

Relativization of Gurevich's Conjectures

Authors: Anatole Dahan, Anuj Dawar

Abstract: Gurevich (1988) conjectured that there is no logic for $\textsf{P}$ or for $\textsf{NP}\cap \textsf{coNP}$. For the latter complexity class, he also showed that the existence of a logic would imply that $\textsf{NP} \cap \textsf{coNP}$ has a complete problem under polynomial time reductions. We show that there is an oracle with respect to which $\textsf P$ does have a logic and… ▽ More Gurevich (1988) conjectured that there is no logic for $\textsf{P}$ or for $\textsf{NP}\cap \textsf{coNP}$. For the latter complexity class, he also showed that the existence of a logic would imply that $\textsf{NP} \cap \textsf{coNP}$ has a complete problem under polynomial time reductions. We show that there is an oracle with respect to which $\textsf P$ does have a logic and $\textsf P \ne\textsf{NP}$. We also show that a logic for $\textsf{NP} \cap \textsf{coNP}$ follows from the existence of a complete problem and a further assumption about canonical labelling. For intersection classes $Σ^p_n \cap Π^p_n$ higher in the polynomial hierarchy, the existence of a logic is equivalent to the existence of complete problems. △ Less

Submitted 10 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: accepted for publication in a volume of papers dedicated to Yuri Gurevich's 80th birthday

MSC Class: 68Q19 ACM Class: F.1.3; F.4.1

Generalizations of $k$-Weisfeiler-Leman stabilization

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Danny Vagnozzi

Abstract: The family of Weisfeiler-Leman equivalences on graphs is a widely studied approximation of graph isomorphism with many different characterizations. We study these, and other approximations of isomorphism defined in terms of refinement operators and Schurian Polynomial Approximation Schemes (SPAS). The general framework of SPAS allows us to study a number of parameters of the refinement operators b… ▽ More The family of Weisfeiler-Leman equivalences on graphs is a widely studied approximation of graph isomorphism with many different characterizations. We study these, and other approximations of isomorphism defined in terms of refinement operators and Schurian Polynomial Approximation Schemes (SPAS). The general framework of SPAS allows us to study a number of parameters of the refinement operators based on Weisfeiler-Leman refinement, logic with counting, lifts of Weisfeiler-Leman as defined by Evdokimov and Ponomarenko, and the invertible map test introduced by Dawar and Holm, and variations of these, and establish relationships between them. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 2020; v1 submitted 3 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: To appear on the 'Moscow International Journal of Number Theory and Combinatorics'

Journal ref: Moscow J. Comb. Number Th. 9 (2020) 229-252

Approximations of Isomorphism and Logics with Linear-Algebraic Operators

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Erich Grädel, Wied Pakusa

Abstract: Invertible map equivalences are approximations of graph isomorphism that refine the well-known Weisfeiler-Leman method. They are parametrised by a number k and a set Q of primes. The intuition is that two graphs G and H which are equivalent with respect to k-Q-IM-equivalence cannot be distinguished by a refinement of k-tuples given by linear operators acting on vector spaces over fields of charact… ▽ More Invertible map equivalences are approximations of graph isomorphism that refine the well-known Weisfeiler-Leman method. They are parametrised by a number k and a set Q of primes. The intuition is that two graphs G and H which are equivalent with respect to k-Q-IM-equivalence cannot be distinguished by a refinement of k-tuples given by linear operators acting on vector spaces over fields of characteristic p, for any p in Q. These equivalences first appeared in the study of rank logic, but in fact they can be used to delimit the expressive power of any extension of fixed-point logic with linear-algebraic operators. We define an infinitary logic with k variables and all linear-algebraic operators over finite vector spaces of characteristic p in Q and show that the k-Q-IM-equivalence is the natural notion of elementary equivalence for this logic. By means of a new and much deeper algebraic analysis of a generalized variant, for any prime p, of the CFI-structures due to Cai, Fürer, and Immerman, we prove that, as long as Q is not the set of all primes, there is no k such that k-Q-IM-equivalence is the same as isomorphism. It follows that there are polynomial-time properties of graphs which are not definable in the infinitary logic with all Q-linear-algebraic operators and finitely many variables, which implies that no extension of fixed-point logic with linear-algebraic operators can capture PTIME, unless it includes such operators for all prime characteristics. Our analysis requires substantial algebraic machinery, including a homogeneity property of CFI-structures and Maschke's Theorem, an important result from the representation theory of finite groups. △ Less

Submitted 27 August, 2019; v1 submitted 18 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 46 pages. Pre-submission version

MSC Class: 03C13; 03C80; 68Q19 ACM Class: F.4.1

On the Power of Symmetric Linear Programs

Authors: Albert Atserias, Anuj Dawar, Joanna Ochremiak

Abstract: We consider families of symmetric linear programs (LPs) that decide a property of graphs (or other relational structures) in the sense that, for each size of graph, there is an LP defining a polyhedral lift that separates the integer points corresponding to graphs with the property from those corresponding to graphs without the property. We show that this is equivalent, with at most polynomial blo… ▽ More We consider families of symmetric linear programs (LPs) that decide a property of graphs (or other relational structures) in the sense that, for each size of graph, there is an LP defining a polyhedral lift that separates the integer points corresponding to graphs with the property from those corresponding to graphs without the property. We show that this is equivalent, with at most polynomial blow-up in size, to families of symmetric Boolean circuits with threshold gates. In particular, when we consider polynomial-size LPs, the model is equivalent to definability in a non-uniform version of fixed-point logic with counting (FPC). Known upper and lower bounds for FPC apply to the non-uniform version. In particular, this implies that the class of graphs with perfect matchings has polynomial-size symmetric LPs while we obtain an exponential lower bound for symmetric LPs for the class of Hamiltonian graphs. We compare and contrast this with previous results (Yannakakis 1991) showing that any symmetric LPs for the matching and TSP polytopes have exponential size. As an application, we establish that for random, uniformly distributed graphs, polynomial-size symmetric LPs are as powerful as general Boolean circuits. We illustrate the effect of this on the well-studied planted-clique problem. △ Less

Submitted 23 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Constructing Hard Examples for Graph Isomorphism

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Kashif Khan

Abstract: We describe a method for generating graphs that provide difficult examples for practical Graph Isomorphism testers. We first give the theoretical construction, showing that we can have a family of graphs without any non-trivial automorphisms which also have high Weisfeiler-Leman dimension. The construction is based on properties of random 3XOR-formulas. We describe how to convert such a formula in… ▽ More We describe a method for generating graphs that provide difficult examples for practical Graph Isomorphism testers. We first give the theoretical construction, showing that we can have a family of graphs without any non-trivial automorphisms which also have high Weisfeiler-Leman dimension. The construction is based on properties of random 3XOR-formulas. We describe how to convert such a formula into a graph which has the desired properties with high probability. We validate the method by an experimental implementation. We construct random formulas and validate them with a SAT solver to filter through suitable ones, and then convert them into graphs. Experimental results demonstrate that the resulting graphs do provide hard examples that match the hardest known benchmarks for graph isomorphism. △ Less

Submitted 18 March, 2019; v1 submitted 21 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Comments: 20 pages. A revised version incorporating new experimental results

ACM Class: F.2.2; G.2.2; G.4

Definable Inapproximability: New Challenges for Duplicator

Authors: Albert Atserias, Anuj Dawar

Abstract: We consider the hardness of approximation of optimization problems from the point of view of definability. For many NP-hard optimization problems it is known that, unless P = NP, no polynomial-time algorithm can give an approximate solution guaranteed to be within a fixed constant factor of the optimum. We show, in several such instances and without any complexity theoretic assumption, that no alg… ▽ More We consider the hardness of approximation of optimization problems from the point of view of definability. For many NP-hard optimization problems it is known that, unless P = NP, no polynomial-time algorithm can give an approximate solution guaranteed to be within a fixed constant factor of the optimum. We show, in several such instances and without any complexity theoretic assumption, that no algorithm that is expressible in fixed-point logic with counting (FPC) can compute an approximate solution. Since important algorithmic techniques for approximation algorithms (such as linear or semidefinite programming) are expressible in FPC, this yields lower bounds on what can be achieved by such methods. The results are established by showing lower bounds on the number of variables required in first-order logic with counting to separate instances with a high optimum from those with a low optimum for fixed-size instances. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2019; v1 submitted 29 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 29 pages. Long version of paper accepted for CSL 2018. To appear in Journal of Logic and Computation

Symmetric Circuits for Rank Logic

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Gregory Wilsenach

Abstract: Fixed-point logic with rank (FPR) is an extension of fixed-point logic with counting (FPC) with operators for computing the rank of a matrix over a finite field. The expressive power of FPR properly extends that of FPC and is contained in PTime, but not known to be properly contained. We give a circuit characterization for FPR in terms of families of symmetric circuits with rank gates, along the l… ▽ More Fixed-point logic with rank (FPR) is an extension of fixed-point logic with counting (FPC) with operators for computing the rank of a matrix over a finite field. The expressive power of FPR properly extends that of FPC and is contained in PTime, but not known to be properly contained. We give a circuit characterization for FPR in terms of families of symmetric circuits with rank gates, along the lines of that for FPC given by [Anderson and Dawar 2017]. This requires the development of a broad framework of circuits in which the individual gates compute functions that are not symmetric (i.e., invariant under all permutations of their inputs). In the case of FPC, the proof of equivalence of circuits and logic rests heavily on the assumption that individual gates compute such symmetric functions and so novel techniques are required to make this work for FPR. △ Less

Submitted 19 August, 2020; v1 submitted 9 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: 40 Pages. A conference version of this paper appeared in Computer Science Logic (CSL) 2018. A journal submission is in progress

ACM Class: F.1.3; F.4.1; F.1.1

Logical properties of random graphs from small addable classes

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Eryk Kopczyński

Abstract: We establish zero-one laws and convergence laws for monadic second-order logic (MSO) (and, a fortiori, first-order logic) on a number of interesting graph classes. In particular, we show that MSO obeys a zero-one law on the class of connected planar graphs, the class of connected graphs of tree-width at most $k$ and the class of connected graphs excluding the $k$-clique as a minor. In each of thes… ▽ More We establish zero-one laws and convergence laws for monadic second-order logic (MSO) (and, a fortiori, first-order logic) on a number of interesting graph classes. In particular, we show that MSO obeys a zero-one law on the class of connected planar graphs, the class of connected graphs of tree-width at most $k$ and the class of connected graphs excluding the $k$-clique as a minor. In each of these cases, dropping the connectivity requirement leads to a class where the zero-one law fails but a convergence law for MSO still holds. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2019; v1 submitted 7 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

MSC Class: 03C13 ACM Class: F.4.1

Journal ref: Logical Methods in Computer Science, Volume 15, Issue 3 (July 25, 2019) lmcs:3780

The pebbling comonad in finite model theory

Authors: Samson Abramsky, Anuj Dawar, Pengming Wang

Abstract: Pebble games are a powerful tool in the study of finite model theory, constraint satisfaction and database theory. Monads and comonads are basic notions of category theory which are widely used in semantics of computation and in modern functional programming. We show that existential k-pebble games have a natural comonadic formulation. Winning strategies for Duplicator in the k-pebble game for str… ▽ More Pebble games are a powerful tool in the study of finite model theory, constraint satisfaction and database theory. Monads and comonads are basic notions of category theory which are widely used in semantics of computation and in modern functional programming. We show that existential k-pebble games have a natural comonadic formulation. Winning strategies for Duplicator in the k-pebble game for structures A and B are equivalent to morphisms from A to B in the coKleisli category for this comonad. This leads on to comonadic characterisations of a number of central concepts in Finite Model Theory: - Isomorphism in the co-Kleisli category characterises elementary equivalence in the k-variable logic with counting quantifiers. - Symmetric games corresponding to equivalence in full k-variable logic are also characterized. - The treewidth of a structure A is characterised in terms of its coalgebra number: the least k for which there is a coalgebra structure on A for the k-pebbling comonad. - Co-Kleisli morphisms are used to characterize strong consistency, and to give an account of a Cai-Fürer-Immerman construction. - The k-pebbling comonad is also used to give semantics to a novel modal operator. These results lay the basis for some new and promising connections between two areas within logic in computer science which have largely been disjoint: (1) finite and algorithmic model theory, and (2) semantics and categorical structures of computation. △ Less

Submitted 17 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: To appear in LiCS 2017

Bounded degree and planar spectra

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Eryk Kopczyński

Abstract: The finite spectrum of a first-order sentence is the set of positive integers that are the sizes of its models. The class of finite spectra is known to be the same as the complexity class NE. We consider the spectra obtained by limiting models to be either planar (in the graph-theoretic sense) or by bounding the degree of elements. We show that the class of such spectra is still surprisingly rich… ▽ More The finite spectrum of a first-order sentence is the set of positive integers that are the sizes of its models. The class of finite spectra is known to be the same as the complexity class NE. We consider the spectra obtained by limiting models to be either planar (in the graph-theoretic sense) or by bounding the degree of elements. We show that the class of such spectra is still surprisingly rich by establishing that significant fragments of NE are included among them. At the same time, we establish non-trivial upper bounds showing that not all sets in NE are obtained as planar or bounded-degree spectra. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2017; v1 submitted 6 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 21 pages. Accepted for publication in Logical Methods in Computer Science

MSC Class: 03C13; 68Q19 ACM Class: F.4.1; F.1.3

Journal ref: Logical Methods in Computer Science, Volume 13, Issue 4 (November 6, 2017) lmcs:2024

Descriptive complexity of graph spectra

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Simone Severini, Octavio Zapata

Abstract: Two graphs are co-spectral if their respective adjacency matrices have the same multi-set of eigenvalues. A graph is said to be determined by its spectrum if all graphs that are co-spectral with it are isomorphic to it. We consider these properties in relation to logical definability. We show that any pair of graphs that are elementarily equivalent with respect to the three-variable counting first… ▽ More Two graphs are co-spectral if their respective adjacency matrices have the same multi-set of eigenvalues. A graph is said to be determined by its spectrum if all graphs that are co-spectral with it are isomorphic to it. We consider these properties in relation to logical definability. We show that any pair of graphs that are elementarily equivalent with respect to the three-variable counting first-order logic $C^3$ are co-spectral, and this is not the case with $C^2$, nor with any number of variables if we exclude counting quantifiers. We also show that the class of graphs that are determined by their spectra is definable in partial fixed-point logic with counting. We relate these properties to other algebraic and combinatorial problems. △ Less

Submitted 14 September, 2016; v1 submitted 22 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Comments: 17 pages

Journal ref: Logic, Language, Information, and Computation: 23rd International Workshop, WoLLIC 2016, Puebla, Mexico, August 16-19th, 2016

Lasserre Lower Bounds and Definability of Semidefinite Programming

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Pengming Wang

Abstract: For a large class of optimization problems, namely those that can be expressed as finite-valued constraint satisfaction problems (VCSPs), we establish a dichotomy on the number of levels of the Lasserre hierarchy of semi-definite programs (SDPs) that are required to solve the problem exactly. In particular, we show that if a finite-valued constraint problem is not solved exactly by its basic linea… ▽ More For a large class of optimization problems, namely those that can be expressed as finite-valued constraint satisfaction problems (VCSPs), we establish a dichotomy on the number of levels of the Lasserre hierarchy of semi-definite programs (SDPs) that are required to solve the problem exactly. In particular, we show that if a finite-valued constraint problem is not solved exactly by its basic linear programming relaxation, it is also not solved exactly by any sub-linear number of levels of the Lasserre hierarchy. The lower bounds are established through logical undefinability results. We show that the linear programming relaxation of the problem, as well as the SDP corresponding to any fixed level of the Lasserre hierarchy is interpretable in a VCSP instance by means of formulas of fixed-point logic with counting. We also show that the solution of an SDP can be expressed in this logic. Together, these results give a way of translating lower bounds on the number of variables required in counting logic to express a VCSP into lower bounds on the number of levels required in the Lasserre hierarchy to eliminate the integrality gap. As a special case, we obtain the same dichotomy for the class of MAXCSP problems, generalizing some earlier Lasserre lower bound results of Schoenebeck. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2016; v1 submitted 17 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: Substantial update and edits on 25th September 2016

A Definability Dichotomy for Finite Valued CSPs

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Pengming Wang

Abstract: Finite valued constraint satisfaction problems are a formalism for describing many natural optimization problems, where constraints on the values that variables can take come with rational weights and the aim is to find an assignment of minimal cost. Thapper and Zivny have recently established a complexity dichotomy for finite valued constraint languages. They show that each such language either g… ▽ More Finite valued constraint satisfaction problems are a formalism for describing many natural optimization problems, where constraints on the values that variables can take come with rational weights and the aim is to find an assignment of minimal cost. Thapper and Zivny have recently established a complexity dichotomy for finite valued constraint languages. They show that each such language either gives rise to a polynomial-time solvable optimization problem, or to an NP-hard one, and establish a criterion to distinguish the two cases. We refine the dichotomy by showing that all optimization problems in the first class are definable in fixed-point language with counting, while all languages in the second class are not definable, even in infinitary logic with counting. Our definability dichotomy is not conditional on any complexity-theoretic assumption. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2015; originally announced April 2015.

Comments: 23 pages

MSC Class: 68Q19 ACM Class: F.1.3

Fixed-parameter Tractable Distances to Sparse Graph Classes

Authors: Jannis Bulian, Anuj Dawar

Abstract: We show that for various classes C of sparse graphs, and several measures of distance to such classes (such as edit distance and elimination distance), the problem of determining the distance of a given graph G to C is fixed-parameter tractable. The results are based on two general techniques. The first of these, building on recent work of Grohe et al. establishes that any class of graphs that is… ▽ More We show that for various classes C of sparse graphs, and several measures of distance to such classes (such as edit distance and elimination distance), the problem of determining the distance of a given graph G to C is fixed-parameter tractable. The results are based on two general techniques. The first of these, building on recent work of Grohe et al. establishes that any class of graphs that is slicewise nowhere dense and slicewise first-order definable is FPT. The second shows that determining the elimination distance of a graph G to a minor-closed class C is FPT. △ Less

Submitted 20 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Graph Isomorphism Parameterized by Elimination Distance to Bounded Degree

Authors: Jannis Bulian, Anuj Dawar

Abstract: A commonly studied means of parameterizing graph problems is the deletion distance from triviality (Guo et al. 2004), which counts vertices that need to be deleted from a graph to place it in some class for which efficient algorithms are known. In the context of graph isomorphism, we define triviality to mean a graph with maximum degree bounded by a constant, as such graph classes admit polynomial… ▽ More A commonly studied means of parameterizing graph problems is the deletion distance from triviality (Guo et al. 2004), which counts vertices that need to be deleted from a graph to place it in some class for which efficient algorithms are known. In the context of graph isomorphism, we define triviality to mean a graph with maximum degree bounded by a constant, as such graph classes admit polynomial-time isomorphism tests. We generalise deletion distance to a measure we call elimination distance to triviality, based on elimination trees or tree-depth decompositions. We establish that graph canonisation, and thus graph isomorphism, is FPT when parameterized by elimination distance to bounded degree, extending results of Bouland et al. (2012). △ Less

Submitted 16 October, 2014; v1 submitted 18 June, 2014; originally announced June 2014.

Comments: 19 pages

ACM Class: F.2.2; G.2.2

On Symmetric Circuits and Fixed-Point Logics

Authors: Matthew Anderson, Anuj Dawar

Abstract: We study properties of relational structures such as graphs that are decided by families of Boolean circuits. Circuits that decide such properties are necessarily invariant to permutations of the elements of the input structures. We focus on families of circuits that are symmetric, i.e., circuits whose invariance is witnessed by automorphisms of the circuit induced by the permutation of the input… ▽ More We study properties of relational structures such as graphs that are decided by families of Boolean circuits. Circuits that decide such properties are necessarily invariant to permutations of the elements of the input structures. We focus on families of circuits that are symmetric, i.e., circuits whose invariance is witnessed by automorphisms of the circuit induced by the permutation of the input structure. We show that the expressive power of such families is closely tied to definability in logic. In particular, we show that the queries defined on structures by uniform families of symmetric Boolean circuits with majority gates are exactly those definable in fixed-point logic with counting. This shows that inexpressibility results in the latter logic lead to lower bounds against polynomial-size families of symmetric circuits. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 22 pages. Full version of a paper to appear in STACS 2014

ACM Class: F.1.3; F.4.1; F.1.1

On the dynamic width of the 3-colorability problem

Authors: Albert Atserias, Anuj Dawar, Oleg Verbitsky

Abstract: A graph $G$ is 3-colorable if and only if it maps homomorphically to the complete 3-vertex graph $K_3$. The last condition can be checked by a $k$-consistency algorithm where the parameter $k$ has to be chosen large enough, dependent on $G$. Let $W(G)$ denote the minimum $k$ sufficient for this purpose. For a non-3-colorable graph $G$, $W(G)$ is equal to the minimum $k$ such that $G$ can be distin… ▽ More A graph $G$ is 3-colorable if and only if it maps homomorphically to the complete 3-vertex graph $K_3$. The last condition can be checked by a $k$-consistency algorithm where the parameter $k$ has to be chosen large enough, dependent on $G$. Let $W(G)$ denote the minimum $k$ sufficient for this purpose. For a non-3-colorable graph $G$, $W(G)$ is equal to the minimum $k$ such that $G$ can be distinguished from $K_3$ in the $k$-variable existential-positive first-order logic. We define the dynamic width of the 3-colorability problem as the function $W(n)=\max_G W(G)$, where the maximum is taken over all non-3-colorable $G$ with $n$ vertices. The assumption $\mathrm{NP}\ne\mathrm{P}$ implies that $W(n)$ is unbounded. Indeed, a lower bound $W(n)=Ω(\log\log n/\log\log\log n)$ follows unconditionally from the work of Nesetril and Zhu on bounded treewidth duality. The Exponential Time Hypothesis implies a much stronger bound $W(n)=Ω(n/\log n)$ and indeed we unconditionally prove that $W(n)=Ω(n)$. In fact, an even stronger statement is true: A first-order sentence distinguishing any 3-colorable graph on $n$ vertices from any non-3-colorable graph on $n$ vertices must have $Ω(n)$ variables. On the other hand, we observe that $W(G)\le 3\,α(G)+1$ and $W(G)\le n-α(G)+1$ for every non-3-colorable graph $G$ with $n$ vertices, where $α(G)$ denotes the independence number of $G$. This implies that $W(n)\le\frac34\,n+1$, improving on the trivial upper bound $W(n)\le n$. We also show that $W(G)>\frac1{16}\, g(G)$ for every non-3-colorable graph $G$, where $g(G)$ denotes the girth of $G$. Finally, we consider the function $W(n)$ over planar graphs and prove that $W(n)=Θ(\sqrt n)$ in the case. △ Less

Submitted 17 February, 2014; v1 submitted 20 December, 2013; originally announced December 2013.

Comments: 18 pages, 2 figures

Maximum Matching and Linear Programming in Fixed-Point Logic with Counting

Authors: Matthew Anderson, Anuj Dawar, Bjarki Holm

Abstract: We establish the expressibility in fixed-point logic with counting (FPC) of a number of natural polynomial-time problems. In particular, we show that the size of a maximum matching in a graph is definable in FPC. This settles an open problem first posed by Blass, Gurevich and Shelah, who asked whether the existence of perfect matchings in general graphs could be determined in the more powerful for… ▽ More We establish the expressibility in fixed-point logic with counting (FPC) of a number of natural polynomial-time problems. In particular, we show that the size of a maximum matching in a graph is definable in FPC. This settles an open problem first posed by Blass, Gurevich and Shelah, who asked whether the existence of perfect matchings in general graphs could be determined in the more powerful formalism of choiceless polynomial time with counting. Our result is established by showing that the ellipsoid method for solving linear programs can be implemented in FPC. This allows us to prove that linear programs can be optimised in FPC if the corresponding separation oracle problem can be defined in FPC. On the way to defining a suitable separation oracle for the maximum matching problem, we provide FPC formulas defining maximum flows and canonical minimum cuts in capacitated graphs. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2013; originally announced April 2013.

Comments: Full version of paper to appear in LICS 2013

MSC Class: 68Q19; 90C60 ACM Class: F.1.3; F.2.2; F.4.1

Pebble games with algebraic rules

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Bjarki Holm

Abstract: We define a general framework of partition games for formulating two-player pebble games over finite structures. We show that one particular such game, which we call the invertible-map game, yields a family of polynomial-time approximations of graph isomorphism that is strictly stronger than the well-known Weisfeiler-Lehman method. The general framework we introduce includes as special cases the p… ▽ More We define a general framework of partition games for formulating two-player pebble games over finite structures. We show that one particular such game, which we call the invertible-map game, yields a family of polynomial-time approximations of graph isomorphism that is strictly stronger than the well-known Weisfeiler-Lehman method. The general framework we introduce includes as special cases the pebble games for finite-variable logics with and without counting. It also includes a matrix-equivalence game, introduced here, which characterises equivalence in the finite-variable fragments of matrix-rank logic. We show that the equivalence defined by the invertible-map game is a refinement of the equivalence defined by each of these games for finite-variable logics. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2012; v1 submitted 4 May, 2012; originally announced May 2012.

Definability of linear equation systems over groups and rings

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Eryk Kopczynski, Bjarki Holm, Erich Grädel, Wied Pakusa

Abstract: Motivated by the quest for a logic for PTIME and recent insights that the descriptive complexity of problems from linear algebra is a crucial aspect of this problem, we study the solvability of linear equation systems over finite groups and rings from the viewpoint of logical (inter-)definability. All problems that we consider are decidable in polynomial time, but not expressible in fixed-point lo… ▽ More Motivated by the quest for a logic for PTIME and recent insights that the descriptive complexity of problems from linear algebra is a crucial aspect of this problem, we study the solvability of linear equation systems over finite groups and rings from the viewpoint of logical (inter-)definability. All problems that we consider are decidable in polynomial time, but not expressible in fixed-point logic with counting. They also provide natural candidates for a separation of polynomial time from rank logics, which extend fixed-point logics by operators for determining the rank of definable matrices and which are sufficient for solvability problems over fields. Based on the structure theory of finite rings, we establish logical reductions among various solvability problems. Our results indicate that all solvability problems for linear equation systems that separate fixed-point logic with counting from PTIME can be reduced to solvability over commutative rings. Moreover, we prove closure properties for classes of queries that reduce to solvability over rings, which provides normal forms for logics extended with solvability operators. We conclude by studying the extent to which fixed-point logic with counting can express problems in linear algebra over finite commutative rings, generalising known results on the logical definability of linear-algebraic problems over finite fields. △ Less

Submitted 11 November, 2013; v1 submitted 13 April, 2012; originally announced April 2012.

Journal ref: Logical Methods in Computer Science, Volume 9, Issue 4 (November 14, 2013) lmcs:725

Domination Problems in Nowhere-Dense Classes of Graphs

Authors: Anuj Dawar, Stephan Kreutzer

Abstract: We investigate the parameterized complexity of generalisations and variations of the dominating set problem on classes of graphs that are nowhere dense. In particular, we show that the distance-d dominating-set problem, also known as the (k,d)-centres problem, is fixed-parameter tractable on any class that is nowhere dense and closed under induced subgraphs. This generalises known results about… ▽ More We investigate the parameterized complexity of generalisations and variations of the dominating set problem on classes of graphs that are nowhere dense. In particular, we show that the distance-d dominating-set problem, also known as the (k,d)-centres problem, is fixed-parameter tractable on any class that is nowhere dense and closed under induced subgraphs. This generalises known results about the dominating set problem on H-minor free classes, classes with locally excluded minors and classes of graphs of bounded expansion. A key feature of our proof is that it is based simply on the fact that these graph classes are uniformly quasi-wide, and does not rely on a structural decomposition. Our result also establishes that the distance-d dominating-set problem is FPT on classes of bounded expansion, answering a question of Ne{\v s}et{ř}il and Ossona de Mendez. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2009; originally announced July 2009.

ACM Class: G.2.1; G.2.2

Homomorphism Preservation on Quasi-Wide Classes

Authors: Anuj Dawar

Abstract: A class of structures is said to have the homomorphism-preservation property just in case every first-order formula that is preserved by homomorphisms on this class is equivalent to an existential-positive formula. It is known by a result of Rossman that the class of finite structures has this property and by previous work of Atserias et al. that various of its subclasses do. We extend the latte… ▽ More A class of structures is said to have the homomorphism-preservation property just in case every first-order formula that is preserved by homomorphisms on this class is equivalent to an existential-positive formula. It is known by a result of Rossman that the class of finite structures has this property and by previous work of Atserias et al. that various of its subclasses do. We extend the latter results by introducing the notion of a quasi-wide class and showing that any quasi-wide class that is closed under taking substructures and disjoint unions has the homomorphism-preservation property. We show, in particular, that classes of structures of bounded expansion and that locally exclude minors are quasi-wide. We also construct an example of a class of finite structures which is closed under substructures and disjoint unions but does not admit the homomorphism-preservation property. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2009; v1 submitted 27 November, 2008; originally announced November 2008.

Comments: 13 pages