-
Patterns of Patterns III
Authors:
Joseph Corneli,
Charles J. Danoff,
Raymond S. Puzio,
Sridevi Ayloo,
Serge Belich,
Mary Tedeschi
Abstract:
Building on earlier installments, this paper re-examines the PLACARD pattern. We report on a series of workshops where PLACARD was used to scaffold collaborative reflection, speculative inquiry, and stimulate design pattern generation. These accounts are enriched by a comparison case: virtual workshops carried out with simple AI-based chatbots. We discuss limitations and lessons learned from both…
▽ More
Building on earlier installments, this paper re-examines the PLACARD pattern. We report on a series of workshops where PLACARD was used to scaffold collaborative reflection, speculative inquiry, and stimulate design pattern generation. These accounts are enriched by a comparison case: virtual workshops carried out with simple AI-based chatbots. We discuss limitations and lessons learned from both the human and multi-agent settings. We conclude by outlining a future development strategy at the intersection of AI agents, design patterns, and institutional governance.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
AI Future Envisioning with PLACARD
Authors:
Mary C. Tedeschi,
Paola Ricaurte,
Sridevi Ayloo,
Joseph Corneli,
Charles Jeffrey Danoff,
Sergio Belich
Abstract:
At EuroPLoP 2024 Mary Tedeschi led the "AI Future Envisioning with PLACARD" focus group in Germany. Three conference attendees joined in the room while Sridevi, Paola, and Charles co-facilitated remotely via a web conference. The participants were introduced to a Futures Studies technique with the goal of capturing envisionments of Artificial Intelligence (AI) going forward. To set an atmosphere a…
▽ More
At EuroPLoP 2024 Mary Tedeschi led the "AI Future Envisioning with PLACARD" focus group in Germany. Three conference attendees joined in the room while Sridevi, Paola, and Charles co-facilitated remotely via a web conference. The participants were introduced to a Futures Studies technique with the goal of capturing envisionments of Artificial Intelligence (AI) going forward. To set an atmosphere a technology focused card game was used to make the session more interactive. To close everyone co-created a Project Action Review to recap of the event to capture learnings that has been summarized in this paper. The Focus Group was structured based on lessons learned over six earlier iterations.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Patterns of Patterns II
Authors:
Joseph Corneli,
Noorah Alhasan,
Leo Vivier,
Alex Murphy,
Raymond S. Puzio,
Abby Tabor,
Sridevi Ayloo,
Charlotte Pierce,
Charles J. Danoff,
Mary Tedeschi,
Manvinder Singh,
Kajol Khetan
Abstract:
Our earlier paper "Patterns of Patterns" combined three techniques from training, futures studies, and design in a design pattern called PLACARD that helps groups of people work together effectively. We used that pattern in five hands-on workshop case studies which took place at various locations in the US and the UK. This experience report documents what we learned, including the way our thinking…
▽ More
Our earlier paper "Patterns of Patterns" combined three techniques from training, futures studies, and design in a design pattern called PLACARD that helps groups of people work together effectively. We used that pattern in five hands-on workshop case studies which took place at various locations in the US and the UK. This experience report documents what we learned, including the way our thinking about PLACARD evolved, together with additional patterns our work generated. We evaluate the reproducibility of our methods and results, and consider the broader economic implications of this way of working. We discuss implications of our prototyping work for the design of future platforms, drawing connections with recent developments in cognitive science and artificial intelligence. This positions our patterns of patterns as a toolkit for the design and governance of systems that combine social dynamics with technical components.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2024; v1 submitted 14 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Patterns of Patterns
Authors:
Joseph Corneli,
Alex Murphy,
Raymond S. Puzio,
Leo Vivier,
Noorah Alhasan,
Charles J. Danoff,
Vitor Bruno,
Charlotte Pierce
Abstract:
This paper shows how we combine and adapt methods from elite training, future studies, and collaborative design, and apply them to address significant problems in social networks. We focus on three such methods: we use Project Action Reviews to implement social perception, Causal Layered Analysis to implement social cognition, and Design Pattern Languages to implement social action. We present the…
▽ More
This paper shows how we combine and adapt methods from elite training, future studies, and collaborative design, and apply them to address significant problems in social networks. We focus on three such methods: we use Project Action Reviews to implement social perception, Causal Layered Analysis to implement social cognition, and Design Pattern Languages to implement social action. We present the results of two studies: firstly, we use Causal Layered Analysis to explore the ways in which the design pattern discourse has been evolving. Secondly, to illustrate the three methods in combination, we develop a case study, showing how we applied the methods to bootstrap a distributed cross-disciplinary research seminar. Building on these analyses, we elaborate several scenarios for the future use of design patterns in large-scale distributed collaboration. Our case study suggests ways in which progress could be made towards realizing these scenarios. We conclude that the combination of methods is robust to uncertainty, insofar as they support adaptations as circumstances change, and incorporate diverse perspectives. In particular, we show how methods drawn from other domains enrich and are enriched by design patterns; we believe the analysis will be of interest to all of the communities whose methods we draw upon.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2022; v1 submitted 22 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Patterns, anticipation and participatory futures
Authors:
Raymond Puzio,
Paola Ricaurte,
Charles Jeffrey Danoff,
Charlotte Pierce,
Analua Dutka-Chirichetti,
Vitor Bruno,
Hermano Cintra,
Joseph Corneli
Abstract:
Patterns embody repeating phenomena, and, as such, they are partly but not fully detachable from their context. 'Design patterns' and 'pattern languages' are established methods for working with patterns. They have been applied in architecture, software engineering, and other design fields, but have so far seen little application in the field of future studies. We reimagine futures discourse and a…
▽ More
Patterns embody repeating phenomena, and, as such, they are partly but not fully detachable from their context. 'Design patterns' and 'pattern languages' are established methods for working with patterns. They have been applied in architecture, software engineering, and other design fields, but have so far seen little application in the field of future studies. We reimagine futures discourse and anticipatory practices using pattern methods. We focus specifically on processes for coordinating distributed projects, integrating multiple voices, and on play that builds capability to face what's yet to come. One of the advantages of the method as a whole is that it deals with local knowledge and does not subsume everything within one overall 'global' strategy, while nevertheless offering a way to communicate between contexts and disciplines.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
