-
Better upper bounds on the Füredi-Hajnal limits of permutations
Authors:
Josef Cibulka,
Jan Kynčl
Abstract:
A binary matrix is a matrix with entries from the set $\{0,1\}$. We say that a binary matrix $A$ contains a binary matrix $S$ if $S$ can be obtained from $A$ by removal of some rows, some columns, and changing some $1$-entries to $0$-entries. If $A$ does not contain $S$, we say that $A$ avoids $S$. A $k$-permutation matrix $P$ is a binary $k \times k$ matrix with exactly one $1$-entry in every row…
▽ More
A binary matrix is a matrix with entries from the set $\{0,1\}$. We say that a binary matrix $A$ contains a binary matrix $S$ if $S$ can be obtained from $A$ by removal of some rows, some columns, and changing some $1$-entries to $0$-entries. If $A$ does not contain $S$, we say that $A$ avoids $S$. A $k$-permutation matrix $P$ is a binary $k \times k$ matrix with exactly one $1$-entry in every row and one $1$-entry in every column.
The Füredi-Hajnal conjecture, proved by Marcus and Tardos, states that for every permutation matrix $P$, there is a constant $c_P$ such that for every $n \in \mathbb{N}$, every $n \times n$ binary matrix $A$ with at least $c_P n$ $1$-entries contains $P$.
We show that $c_P \le 2^{O(k^{2/3}\log^{7/3}k / (\log\log k)^{1/3})}$ asymptotically almost surely for a random $k$-permutation matrix $P$. We also show that $c_P \le 2^{(4+o(1))k}$ for every $k$-permutation matrix $P$, improving the constant in the exponent of a recent upper bound on $c_P$ by Fox. Moreover, we improve the upper bound on $c_P$ in terms of the Stanley-Wilf limit $s_P$ to $c_P \le O\big(s_P^{2.75} \log s_P\big)$.
We also consider a higher-dimensional generalization of the Stanley-Wilf conjecture about the number of $d$-dimensional $n$-permutation matrices avoiding a fixed $d$-dimensional $k$-permutation matrix, and prove almost matching upper and lower bounds of the form $(2^k)^{O(n)} \cdot (n!)^{d-1-1/(d-1)}$ and $n^{-O(k)} k^{Ω(n)} \cdot (n!)^{d-1-1/(d-1)}$, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2019; v1 submitted 25 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Peeling potatoes near-optimally in near-linear time
Authors:
Sergio Cabello,
Josef Cibulka,
Jan Kynčl,
Maria Saumell,
Pavel Valtr
Abstract:
We consider the following geometric optimization problem: find a convex polygon of maximum area contained in a given simple polygon $P$ with $n$ vertices. We give a randomized near-linear-time $(1-\varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm for this problem: in $O(n( \log^2 n + (1/\varepsilon^3) \log n + 1/\varepsilon^4))$ time we find a convex polygon contained in $P$ that, with probability at least…
▽ More
We consider the following geometric optimization problem: find a convex polygon of maximum area contained in a given simple polygon $P$ with $n$ vertices. We give a randomized near-linear-time $(1-\varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm for this problem: in $O(n( \log^2 n + (1/\varepsilon^3) \log n + 1/\varepsilon^4))$ time we find a convex polygon contained in $P$ that, with probability at least $2/3$, has area at least $(1-\varepsilon)$ times the area of an optimal solution. We also obtain similar results for the variant of computing a convex polygon inside $P$ with maximum perimeter.
To achieve these results we provide new results in geometric probability. The first result is a bound relating the probability that two points chosen uniformly at random inside $P$ are mutually visible and the area of the largest convex body inside $P$. The second result is a bound on the expected value of the difference between the perimeter of any planar convex body $K$ and the perimeter of the convex hull of a uniform random sample inside $K$.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2017; v1 submitted 5 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Three-monotone interpolation
Authors:
Josef Cibulka,
Jiří Matoušek,
Pavel Paták
Abstract:
A function $f\colon\mathbb R\to\mathbb R$ is called \emph{$k$-monotone} if it is $(k-2)$-times differentiable and its $(k-2)$nd derivative is convex. A point set $P\subset\mathbb R^2$ is \emph{$k$-monotone interpolable} if it lies on a graph of a $k$-monotone function. These notions have been studied in analysis, approximation theory etc. since the 1940s.
We show that 3-monotone interpolability…
▽ More
A function $f\colon\mathbb R\to\mathbb R$ is called \emph{$k$-monotone} if it is $(k-2)$-times differentiable and its $(k-2)$nd derivative is convex. A point set $P\subset\mathbb R^2$ is \emph{$k$-monotone interpolable} if it lies on a graph of a $k$-monotone function. These notions have been studied in analysis, approximation theory etc. since the 1940s.
We show that 3-monotone interpolability is very non-local: we exhibit an arbitrarily large finite $P$ for which every proper subset is $3$-monotone interpolable but $P$ itself is not. On the other hand, we prove a Ramsey-type result: for every $n$ there exists $N$ such that every $N$-point $P$ with distinct $x$-coordinates contains an $n$-point $Q$ such that $Q$ or its vertical mirror reflection are $3$-monotone interpolable. The analogs for $k$-monotone interpolability with $k=1$ and $k=2$ are classical theorems of Erdős and Szekeres, while the cases with $k\ge4$ remain open.
We also investigate the computational complexity of deciding $3$-monotone interpolability of a given point set. Using a known characterization, this decision problem can be stated as an instance of polynomial optimization and reformulated as a semidefinite program. We exhibit an example for which this semidefinite program has only doubly exponentially large feasible solutions, and thus known algorithms cannot solve it in polynomial time. While such phenomena have been well known for semidefinite programming in general, ours seems to be the first such example in polynomial optimization, and it involves only univariate quadratic polynomials.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
On the Geometric Ramsey Number of Outerplanar Graphs
Authors:
Josef Cibulka,
Pu Gao,
Marek Krčál,
Tomáš Valla,
Pavel Valtr
Abstract:
We prove polynomial upper bounds of geometric Ramsey numbers of pathwidth-2 outerplanar triangulations in both convex and general cases. We also prove that the geometric Ramsey numbers of the ladder graph on $2n$ vertices are bounded by $O(n^{3})$ and $O(n^{10})$, in the convex and general case, respectively. We then apply similar methods to prove an $n^{O(\log(n))}$ upper bound on the Ramsey numb…
▽ More
We prove polynomial upper bounds of geometric Ramsey numbers of pathwidth-2 outerplanar triangulations in both convex and general cases. We also prove that the geometric Ramsey numbers of the ladder graph on $2n$ vertices are bounded by $O(n^{3})$ and $O(n^{10})$, in the convex and general case, respectively. We then apply similar methods to prove an $n^{O(\log(n))}$ upper bound on the Ramsey number of a path with $n$ ordered vertices.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2013; v1 submitted 25 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Maximum size of reverse-free sets of permutations
Authors:
Josef Cibulka
Abstract:
Two words have a reverse if they have the same pair of distinct letters on the same pair of positions, but in reversed order. A set of words no two of which have a reverse is said to be reverse-free. Let F(n,k) be the maximum size of a reverse-free set of words from [n]^k where no letter repeats within a word. We show the following lower and upper bounds in the case n >= k: F(n,k) \in n^k k^{-k/2…
▽ More
Two words have a reverse if they have the same pair of distinct letters on the same pair of positions, but in reversed order. A set of words no two of which have a reverse is said to be reverse-free. Let F(n,k) be the maximum size of a reverse-free set of words from [n]^k where no letter repeats within a word. We show the following lower and upper bounds in the case n >= k: F(n,k) \in n^k k^{-k/2 + O(k/log k)}. As a consequence of the lower bound, a set of n-permutations each two having a reverse has size at most n^{n/2 + O(n/log n)}.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2013; v1 submitted 14 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Graph sharing games: complexity and connectivity
Authors:
Josef Cibulka,
Jan Kynčl,
Viola Mészáros,
Rudolf Stolař,
Pavel Valtr
Abstract:
We study the following combinatorial game played by two players, Alice and Bob, which generalizes the Pizza game considered by Brown, Winkler and others. Given a connected graph G with nonnegative weights assigned to its vertices, the players alternately take one vertex of G in each turn. The first turn is Alice's. The vertices are to be taken according to one (or both) of the following two rules:…
▽ More
We study the following combinatorial game played by two players, Alice and Bob, which generalizes the Pizza game considered by Brown, Winkler and others. Given a connected graph G with nonnegative weights assigned to its vertices, the players alternately take one vertex of G in each turn. The first turn is Alice's. The vertices are to be taken according to one (or both) of the following two rules: (T) the subgraph of G induced by the taken vertices is connected during the whole game, (R) the subgraph of G induced by the remaining vertices is connected during the whole game. We show that if rules (T) and/or (R) are required then for every epsilon > 0 and for every positive integer k there is a k-connected graph G for which Bob has a strategy to obtain (1-epsilon) of the total weight of the vertices. This contrasts with the original Pizza game played on a cycle, where Alice is known to have a strategy to obtain 4/9 of the total weight.
We show that the problem of deciding whether Alice has a winning strategy (i.e., a strategy to obtain more than half of the total weight) is PSPACE-complete if condition (R) or both conditions (T) and (R) are required. We also consider a game played on connected graphs (without weights) where the first player who violates condition (T) or (R) loses the game. We show that deciding who has the winning strategy is PSPACE-complete.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2012; v1 submitted 3 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Tight bounds on the maximum size of a set of permutations with bounded VC-dimension
Authors:
Josef Cibulka,
Jan Kyncl
Abstract:
The VC-dimension of a family P of n-permutations is the largest integer k such that the set of restrictions of the permutations in P on some k-tuple of positions is the set of all k! permutation patterns. Let r_k(n) be the maximum size of a set of n-permutations with VC-dimension k. Raz showed that r_2(n) grows exponentially in n. We show that r_3(n)=2^Theta(n log(alpha(n))) and for every s >= 4,…
▽ More
The VC-dimension of a family P of n-permutations is the largest integer k such that the set of restrictions of the permutations in P on some k-tuple of positions is the set of all k! permutation patterns. Let r_k(n) be the maximum size of a set of n-permutations with VC-dimension k. Raz showed that r_2(n) grows exponentially in n. We show that r_3(n)=2^Theta(n log(alpha(n))) and for every s >= 4, we have almost tight upper and lower bounds of the form 2^{n poly(alpha(n))}. We also study the maximum number p_k(n) of 1-entries in an n x n (0,1)-matrix with no (k+1)-tuple of columns containing all (k+1)-permutation matrices. We determine that p_3(n) = Theta(n alpha(n)) and that p_s(n) can be bounded by functions of the form n 2^poly(alpha(n)) for every fixed s >= 4. We also show that for every positive s there is a slowly growing function zeta_s(m) (of the form 2^poly(alpha(m)) for every fixed s >= 5) satisfying the following. For all positive integers n and B and every n x n (0,1)-matrix M with zeta_s(n)Bn 1-entries, the rows of M can be partitioned into s intervals so that at least B columns contain at least B 1-entries in each of the intervals.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2012; v1 submitted 26 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Universal Sets for Straight-Line Embeddings of Bicolored Graphs
Authors:
Josef Cibulka,
Jan Kyncl,
Viola Mészáros,
Rudolf Stolar,
Pavel Valtr
Abstract:
A set S of n points is 2-color universal for a graph G on n vertices if for every proper 2-coloring of G and for every 2-coloring of S with the same sizes of color classes as G has, G is straight-line embeddable on S. We show that the so-called double chain is 2-color universal for paths if each of the two chains contains at least one fifth of all the points, but not if one of the chains is more t…
▽ More
A set S of n points is 2-color universal for a graph G on n vertices if for every proper 2-coloring of G and for every 2-coloring of S with the same sizes of color classes as G has, G is straight-line embeddable on S. We show that the so-called double chain is 2-color universal for paths if each of the two chains contains at least one fifth of all the points, but not if one of the chains is more than approximately 28 times longer than the other. A 2-coloring of G is equitable if the sizes of the color classes differ by at most 1. A bipartite graph is equitable if it admits an equitable proper coloring. We study the case when S is the double-chain with chain sizes differing by at most 1 and G is an equitable bipartite graph. We prove that this S is not 2-color universal if G is not a forest of caterpillars and that it is 2-color universal for equitable caterpillars with at most one half non-leaf vertices. We also show that if this S is equitably 2-colored, then equitably properly 2-colored forests of stars can be embedded on it.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Polynomial-time sortable stacks of burnt pancakes
Authors:
Anthony Labarre,
Josef Cibulka
Abstract:
Pancake flipping, a famous open problem in computer science, can be formalised as the problem of sorting a permutation of positive integers using as few prefix reversals as possible. In that context, a prefix reversal of length k reverses the order of the first k elements of the permutation. The burnt variant of pancake flipping involves permutations of signed integers, and reversals in that case…
▽ More
Pancake flipping, a famous open problem in computer science, can be formalised as the problem of sorting a permutation of positive integers using as few prefix reversals as possible. In that context, a prefix reversal of length k reverses the order of the first k elements of the permutation. The burnt variant of pancake flipping involves permutations of signed integers, and reversals in that case not only reverse the order of elements but also invert their signs. Although three decades have now passed since the first works on these problems, neither their computational complexity nor the maximal number of prefix reversals needed to sort a permutation is yet known. In this work, we prove a new lower bound for sorting burnt pancakes, and show that an important class of permutations, known as "simple permutations", can be optimally sorted in polynomial time.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Average number of flips in pancake sorting
Authors:
Josef Cibulka
Abstract:
We are given a stack of pancakes of different sizes and the only allowed operation is to take several pancakes from top and flip them. The unburnt version requires the pancakes to be sorted by their sizes at the end, while in the burnt version they additionally need to be oriented burnt-side down. We present an algorithm with the average number of flips, needed to sort a stack of n burnt pancake…
▽ More
We are given a stack of pancakes of different sizes and the only allowed operation is to take several pancakes from top and flip them. The unburnt version requires the pancakes to be sorted by their sizes at the end, while in the burnt version they additionally need to be oriented burnt-side down. We present an algorithm with the average number of flips, needed to sort a stack of n burnt pancakes, equal to 7n/4+O(1) and a randomized algorithm for the unburnt version with at most 17n/12+O(1) flips on average.
In addition, we show that in the burnt version, the average number of flips of any algorithm is at least n+Ω(n/log n) and conjecture that some algorithm can reach n+Θ(n/log n).
We also slightly increase the lower bound on g(n), the minimum number of flips needed to sort the worst stack of n burnt pancakes. This bound, together with the upper bound found by Heydari and Sudborough in 1997, gives the exact number of flips to sort the previously conjectured worst stack -I_n for n=3 mod 4 and n>=15. Finally we present exact values of f(n) up to n=19 and of g(n) up to n=17 and disprove a conjecture of Cohen and Blum by showing that the burnt stack -I_{15} is not the worst one for n=15.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2009; v1 submitted 20 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
-
Solution of Peter Winkler's Pizza Problem
Authors:
Josef Cibulka,
Jan Kynčl,
Viola Mészáros,
Rudolf Stolař,
Pavel Valtr
Abstract:
Bob cuts a pizza into slices of not necessarily equal size and shares it with Alice by alternately taking turns. One slice is taken in each turn. The first turn is Alice's. She may choose any of the slices. In all other turns only those slices can be chosen that have a neighbor slice already eaten. We prove a conjecture of Peter Winkler by showing that Alice has a strategy for obtaining 4/9 of t…
▽ More
Bob cuts a pizza into slices of not necessarily equal size and shares it with Alice by alternately taking turns. One slice is taken in each turn. The first turn is Alice's. She may choose any of the slices. In all other turns only those slices can be chosen that have a neighbor slice already eaten. We prove a conjecture of Peter Winkler by showing that Alice has a strategy for obtaining 4/9 of the pizza. This is best possible, that is, there is a cutting and a strategy for Bob to get 5/9 of the pizza. We also give a characterization of Alice's best possible gain depending on the number of slices. For a given cutting of the pizza, we describe a linear time algorithm that computes Alice's strategy gaining at least 4/9 of the pizza and another algorithm that computes the optimal strategy for both players in any possible position of the game in quadratic time. We distinguish two types of turns, shifts and jumps. We prove that Alice can gain 4/9, 7/16 and 1/3 of the pizza if she is allowed to make at most two jumps, at most one jump and no jump, respectively, and the three constants are the best possible.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
Untangling polygons and graphs
Authors:
Josef Cibulka
Abstract:
Untangling is a process in which some vertices of a planar graph are moved to obtain a straight-line plane drawing. The aim is to move as few vertices as possible. We present an algorithm that untangles the cycle graph C_n while keeping at least Ω(n^{2/3}) vertices fixed. For any graph G, we also present an upper bound on the number of fixed vertices in the worst case. The bound is a function of…
▽ More
Untangling is a process in which some vertices of a planar graph are moved to obtain a straight-line plane drawing. The aim is to move as few vertices as possible. We present an algorithm that untangles the cycle graph C_n while keeping at least Ω(n^{2/3}) vertices fixed. For any graph G, we also present an upper bound on the number of fixed vertices in the worst case. The bound is a function of the number of vertices, maximum degree and diameter of G. One of its consequences is the upper bound O((n log n)^{2/3}) for all 3-vertex-connected planar graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2008; v1 submitted 10 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
