-
Strategic Evolution of Adversaries Against Temporal Platform Diversity Active Cyber Defenses
Authors:
Michael L. Winterrose,
Kevin M. Carter
Abstract:
Adversarial dynamics are a critical facet within the cyber security domain, in which there exists a co-evolution between attackers and defenders in any given threat scenario. While defenders leverage capabilities to minimize the potential impact of an attack, the adversary is simultaneously developing countermeasures to the observed defenses. In this study, we develop a set of tools to model the a…
▽ More
Adversarial dynamics are a critical facet within the cyber security domain, in which there exists a co-evolution between attackers and defenders in any given threat scenario. While defenders leverage capabilities to minimize the potential impact of an attack, the adversary is simultaneously developing countermeasures to the observed defenses. In this study, we develop a set of tools to model the adaptive strategy formulation of an intelligent actor against an active cyber defensive system. We encode strategies as binary chromosomes representing finite state machines that evolve according to Holland's genetic algorithm. We study the strategic considerations including overall actor reward balanced against the complexity of the determined strategies. We present a series of simulation results demonstrating the ability to automatically search a large strategy space for optimal resultant fitness against a variety of counter-strategies.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Adaptive Attacker Strategy Development Against Moving Target Cyber Defenses
Authors:
M. L. Winterrose,
K. M. Carter,
N. Wagner,
W. W. Streilein
Abstract:
A model of strategy formulation is used to study how an adaptive attacker learns to overcome a moving target cyber defense. The attacker-defender interaction is modeled as a game in which a defender deploys a temporal platform migration defense. Against this defense, a population of attackers develop strategies specifying the temporal ordering of resource investments that bring targeted zero-day e…
▽ More
A model of strategy formulation is used to study how an adaptive attacker learns to overcome a moving target cyber defense. The attacker-defender interaction is modeled as a game in which a defender deploys a temporal platform migration defense. Against this defense, a population of attackers develop strategies specifying the temporal ordering of resource investments that bring targeted zero-day exploits into existence. Attacker response to two defender temporal platform migration scheduling policies are examined. In the first defender scheduling policy, the defender selects the active platform in each match uniformly at random from a pool of available platforms. In the second policy the defender schedules each successive platform to maximize the diversity of the source code presented to the attacker. Adaptive attacker response strategies are modeled by finite state machine (FSM) constructs that evolve during simulated play against defender strategies via an evolutionary algorithm. It is demonstrated that the attacker learns to invest heavily in exploit creation for the platform with the least similarity to other platforms when faced with a diversity defense, while avoiding investment in exploits for this least similar platform when facing a randomization defense. Additionally, it is demonstrated that the diversity-maximizing defense is superior for shorter duration attacker-defender engagements, but performs sub-optimally in extended attacker-defender interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Quantitative Analysis of Active Cyber Defenses Based on Temporal Platform Diversity
Authors:
Kevin M. Carter,
Hamed Okhravi,
James Riordan
Abstract:
Active cyber defenses based on temporal platform diversity have been proposed as way to make systems more resistant to attacks. These defenses change the properties of the platforms in order to make attacks more complicated. Unfortunately, little work has been done on measuring the effectiveness of these defenses. In this work, we use four different approaches to quantitatively analyze these defen…
▽ More
Active cyber defenses based on temporal platform diversity have been proposed as way to make systems more resistant to attacks. These defenses change the properties of the platforms in order to make attacks more complicated. Unfortunately, little work has been done on measuring the effectiveness of these defenses. In this work, we use four different approaches to quantitatively analyze these defenses; an abstract analysis studies the algebraic models of a temporal platform diversity system; a set of experiments on a test bed measures the metrics of interest for the system; a game theoretic analysis studies the impact of preferential selection of platforms and derives an optimal strategy; finally, a set of simulations evaluates the metrics of interest on the models. Our results from these approaches all agree and yet are counter-intuitive. We show that although platform diversity can mitigate some attacks, it can be detrimental for others. We also illustrate that the benefit from these systems heavily depends on their threat model and that the preferential selection of platforms can achieve better protection.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
