-
Agent Interpolation for Knowledge
Authors:
Marta Bílková,
Wesley Fussner,
Roman Kuznets
Abstract:
We define a new type of proof formalism for multi-agent modal logics with S5-type modalities. This novel formalism combines the features of hypersequents to represent S5 modalities with nested sequents to represent the T-like modality alternations. We show that the calculus is sound and complete, cut-free, and terminating and yields decidability and the finite model property for multi-agent S5. We…
▽ More
We define a new type of proof formalism for multi-agent modal logics with S5-type modalities. This novel formalism combines the features of hypersequents to represent S5 modalities with nested sequents to represent the T-like modality alternations. We show that the calculus is sound and complete, cut-free, and terminating and yields decidability and the finite model property for multi-agent S5. We also use it to prove the Lyndon (and hence Craig) interpolation property for multi-agent S5, considering not only propositional atoms but also agents to be part of the common language. Finally, we discuss the difficulties on the way to extending these results to the logic of distributed knowledge and to deductive interpolation.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Bisimulation for Impure Simplicial Complexes
Authors:
Marta Bílková,
Hans van Ditmarsch,
Roman Kuznets,
Rojo Randrianomentsoa
Abstract:
As an alternative to Kripke models, simplicial complexes are a versatile semantic primitive on which to interpret epistemic logic. Given a set of vertices, a simplicial complex is a downward closed set of subsets, called simplexes, of the vertex set. A maximal simplex is called a facet. Impure simplicial complexes represent that some agents (processes) are dead. It is known that impure simplicial…
▽ More
As an alternative to Kripke models, simplicial complexes are a versatile semantic primitive on which to interpret epistemic logic. Given a set of vertices, a simplicial complex is a downward closed set of subsets, called simplexes, of the vertex set. A maximal simplex is called a facet. Impure simplicial complexes represent that some agents (processes) are dead. It is known that impure simplicial complexes categorically correspond to so-called partial epistemic (Kripke) models. In this contribution, we define a notion of bisimulation to compare impure simplicial complexes and show that it has the Hennessy-Milner property. These results are for a logical language including atoms that express whether agents are alive or dead. Without these atoms no reasonable standard notion of bisimulation exists, as we amply justify by counterexamples, because such a restricted language is insufficiently expressive.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Epistemic Logics of Structured Intensional Groups
Authors:
Marta Bílková,
Igor Sedlár
Abstract:
Epistemic logics of intensional groups lift the assumption that membership in a group of agents is common knowledge. Instead of being represented directly as a set of agents, intensional groups are represented by a property that may change its extension from world to world. Several authors have considered versions of the intensional group framework where group-specifying properties are articulated…
▽ More
Epistemic logics of intensional groups lift the assumption that membership in a group of agents is common knowledge. Instead of being represented directly as a set of agents, intensional groups are represented by a property that may change its extension from world to world. Several authors have considered versions of the intensional group framework where group-specifying properties are articulated using structured terms of a language, such as the language of Boolean algebras or of description logic. In this paper we formulate a general semantic framework for epistemic logics of structured intensional groups, develop the basic theory leading to completeness-via-canonicity results, and show that several frameworks presented in the literature correspond to special cases of the general framework.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Paraconsistent Gödel modal logic on bi-relational frames
Authors:
Marta Bilkova,
Sabine Frittella,
Daniil Kozhemiachenko
Abstract:
We further develop the paraconsistent Gödel modal logic. In this paper, we consider its version endowed with Kripke semantics on $[0,1]$-valued frames with two fuzzy relations $R^+$ and $R^-$ (degrees of trust in assertions and denials) and two valuations $v_1$ and $v_2$ (support of truth and support of falsity) linked with a De Morgan negation $\neg$.
We demonstrate that it \emph{does not} exte…
▽ More
We further develop the paraconsistent Gödel modal logic. In this paper, we consider its version endowed with Kripke semantics on $[0,1]$-valued frames with two fuzzy relations $R^+$ and $R^-$ (degrees of trust in assertions and denials) and two valuations $v_1$ and $v_2$ (support of truth and support of falsity) linked with a De Morgan negation $\neg$.
We demonstrate that it \emph{does not} extend Gödel modal logic and that $\Box$ and $\lozenge$ are not interdefinable. We also show that several important classes of frames are $\birelKGsquare$ definable (in particular, crisp, mono-relational, and finitely branching). For $\birelKGsquare$ over finitely branching frames, we create a sound and complete constraint tableaux calculus and a decision procedure based upon it. Using the decision procedure we show that $\birelKGsquare$ satisfiability and validity are in PSPACE.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Revisiting Epistemic Logic with Names
Authors:
Marta Bílková,
Zoé Christoff,
Olivier Roy
Abstract:
This paper revisits the multi-agent epistemic logic presented in [10], where agents and sets of agents are replaced by abstract, intensional "names". We make three contributions. First, we study its model theory, providing adequate notions of bisimulation and frame morphisms, and use them to study the logic's expressive power and definability. Second, we show that the logic has a natural neighborh…
▽ More
This paper revisits the multi-agent epistemic logic presented in [10], where agents and sets of agents are replaced by abstract, intensional "names". We make three contributions. First, we study its model theory, providing adequate notions of bisimulation and frame morphisms, and use them to study the logic's expressive power and definability. Second, we show that the logic has a natural neighborhood semantics, which in turn allows to show that the axiomatization in [10] does not rely on possibly controversial introspective properties of knowledge. Finally, we extend the logic with common and distributed knowledge operators, and provide a sound and complete axiomatization for each of these extensions. These results together put the original epistemic logic with names in a more modern context and opens the door for a logical analysis of epistemic phenomena where group membership is uncertain or variable.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
How to reason with inconsistent probabilistic information?
Authors:
Marta Bílková,
Sabine Frittella,
Ondrej Majer,
Sajad Nazari
Abstract:
A recent line of research has developed around logics of belief based on evidence. The approach of Bílková et al understands belief as based on information confirmed by a reliable source. We propose a finer analysis of how belief can be based on information, where the confirmation comes from multiple possibly conflicting sources and is of a probabilistic nature. We use Belnap-Dunn logic and its pr…
▽ More
A recent line of research has developed around logics of belief based on evidence. The approach of Bílková et al understands belief as based on information confirmed by a reliable source. We propose a finer analysis of how belief can be based on information, where the confirmation comes from multiple possibly conflicting sources and is of a probabilistic nature. We use Belnap-Dunn logic and its probabilistic extensions to account for potentially contradictory information on which belief is grounded. We combine it with an extension of Lukasiewicz logic, or a bilattice logic, within a two-layer modal logical framework to account for belief.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2020; v1 submitted 28 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Moss' logic for ordered coalgebras
Authors:
Marta Bílková,
Matěj Dostál
Abstract:
We present a finitary version of Moss' coalgebraic logic for $T$-coalgebras, where $T$ is a locally monotone endofunctor of the category of posets and monotone maps. The logic uses a single cover modality whose arity is given by the least finitary subfunctor of the dual of the coalgebra functor $T_ω^\partial$, and the semantics of the modality is given by relation lifting. For the semantics to wor…
▽ More
We present a finitary version of Moss' coalgebraic logic for $T$-coalgebras, where $T$ is a locally monotone endofunctor of the category of posets and monotone maps. The logic uses a single cover modality whose arity is given by the least finitary subfunctor of the dual of the coalgebra functor $T_ω^\partial$, and the semantics of the modality is given by relation lifting. For the semantics to work, $T$ is required to preserve exact squares. For the finitary setting to work, $T_ω^\partial$ is required to preserve finite intersections. We develop a notion of a base for subobjects of $T_ωX$. This in particular allows us to talk about the finite poset of subformulas for a given formula. The notion of a base is introduced generally for a category equipped with a suitable factorisation system.
We prove that the resulting logic has the Hennessy-Milner property for the notion of similarity based on the notion of relation lifting. We define a sequent proof system for the logic, and prove its completeness.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2022; v1 submitted 19 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Relation lifting, with an application to the many-valued cover modality
Authors:
Marta Bilkova,
Alexander Kurz,
Daniela Petrisan,
Jiri Velebil
Abstract:
We introduce basic notions and results about relation liftings on categories enriched in a commutative quantale. We derive two necessary and sufficient conditions for a 2-functor T to admit a functorial relation lifting: one is the existence of a distributive law of T over the "powerset monad" on categories, one is the preservation by T of "exactness" of certain squares. Both characterisations ar…
▽ More
We introduce basic notions and results about relation liftings on categories enriched in a commutative quantale. We derive two necessary and sufficient conditions for a 2-functor T to admit a functorial relation lifting: one is the existence of a distributive law of T over the "powerset monad" on categories, one is the preservation by T of "exactness" of certain squares. Both characterisations are generalisations of the "classical" results known for set functors: the first characterisation generalises the existence of a distributive law over the genuine powerset monad, the second generalises preservation of weak pullbacks. The results presented in this paper enable us to compute predicate liftings of endofunctors of, for example, generalised (ultra)metric spaces. We illustrate this by studying the coalgebraic cover modality in this setting.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2013; v1 submitted 17 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Relation Liftings on Preorders and Posets
Authors:
Marta Bilkova,
Alexander Kurz,
Daniela Petrisan,
Jiri Velebil
Abstract:
The category Rel(Set) of sets and relations can be described as a category of spans and as the Kleisli category for the powerset monad. A set-functor can be lifted to a functor on Rel(Set) iff it preserves weak pullbacks. We show that these results extend to the enriched setting, if we replace sets by posets or preorders. Preservation of weak pullbacks becomes preservation of exact lax squares. As…
▽ More
The category Rel(Set) of sets and relations can be described as a category of spans and as the Kleisli category for the powerset monad. A set-functor can be lifted to a functor on Rel(Set) iff it preserves weak pullbacks. We show that these results extend to the enriched setting, if we replace sets by posets or preorders. Preservation of weak pullbacks becomes preservation of exact lax squares. As an application we present Moss's coalgebraic over posets.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
