-
Towards Dialogues for Joint Human-AI Reasoning and Value Alignment
Authors:
Elfia Bezou-Vrakatseli,
Oana Cocarascu,
Sanjay Modgil
Abstract:
We argue that enabling human-AI dialogue, purposed to support joint reasoning (i.e., 'inquiry'), is important for ensuring that AI decision making is aligned with human values and preferences. In particular, we point to logic-based models of argumentation and dialogue, and suggest that the traditional focus on persuasion dialogues be replaced by a focus on inquiry dialogues, and the distinct chall…
▽ More
We argue that enabling human-AI dialogue, purposed to support joint reasoning (i.e., 'inquiry'), is important for ensuring that AI decision making is aligned with human values and preferences. In particular, we point to logic-based models of argumentation and dialogue, and suggest that the traditional focus on persuasion dialogues be replaced by a focus on inquiry dialogues, and the distinct challenges that joint inquiry raises. Given recent dramatic advances in the performance of large language models (LLMs), and the anticipated increase in their use for decision making, we provide a roadmap for research into inquiry dialogues for supporting joint human-LLM reasoning tasks that are ethically salient, and that thereby require that decisions are value aligned.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Online Handbook of Argumentation for AI: Volume 4
Authors:
Lars Bengel,
Lydia Blümel,
Elfia Bezou-Vrakatseli,
Federico Castagna,
Giulia D'Agostino,
Isabelle Kuhlmann,
Jack Mumford,
Daphne Odekerken,
Fabrizio Russo,
Stefan Sarkadi,
Madeleine Waller,
Andreas Xydis
Abstract:
This volume contains revised versions of the papers selected for the fourth volume of the Online Handbook of Argumentation for AI (OHAAI). Previously, formal theories of argument and argument interaction have been proposed and studied, and this has led to the more recent study of computational models of argument. Argumentation, as a field within artificial intelligence (AI), is highly relevant for…
▽ More
This volume contains revised versions of the papers selected for the fourth volume of the Online Handbook of Argumentation for AI (OHAAI). Previously, formal theories of argument and argument interaction have been proposed and studied, and this has led to the more recent study of computational models of argument. Argumentation, as a field within artificial intelligence (AI), is highly relevant for researchers interested in symbolic representations of knowledge and defeasible reasoning. The purpose of this handbook is to provide an open access and curated anthology for the argumentation research community. OHAAI is designed to serve as a research hub to keep track of the latest and upcoming PhD-driven research on the theory and application of argumentation in all areas related to AI.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2023;
originally announced January 2024.
-
SHAPE: A Framework for Evaluating the Ethicality of Influence
Authors:
Elfia Bezou-Vrakatseli,
Benedikt Brückner,
Luke Thorburn
Abstract:
Agents often exert influence when interacting with humans and non-human agents. However, the ethical status of such influence is often unclear. In this paper, we present the SHAPE framework, which lists reasons why influence may be unethical. We draw on literature from descriptive and moral philosophy and connect it to machine learning to help guide ethical considerations when developing algorithm…
▽ More
Agents often exert influence when interacting with humans and non-human agents. However, the ethical status of such influence is often unclear. In this paper, we present the SHAPE framework, which lists reasons why influence may be unethical. We draw on literature from descriptive and moral philosophy and connect it to machine learning to help guide ethical considerations when developing algorithms with potential influence. Lastly, we explore mechanisms for governing algorithmic systems that influence people, inspired by mechanisms used in journalism, human subject research, and advertising.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2023; v1 submitted 8 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Online Handbook of Argumentation for AI: Volume 3
Authors:
Lars Bengel,
Elfia Bezou-Vrakatseli,
Lydia Blümel,
Federico Castagna,
Giulia D'Agostino,
Daphne Odekerken,
Minal Suresh Patil,
Jordan Robinson,
Hao Wu,
Andreas Xydis
Abstract:
This volume contains revised versions of the papers selected for the third volume of the Online Handbook of Argumentation for AI (OHAAI). Previously, formal theories of argument and argument interaction have been proposed and studied, and this has led to the more recent study of computational models of argument. Argumentation, as a field within artificial intelligence (AI), is highly relevant for…
▽ More
This volume contains revised versions of the papers selected for the third volume of the Online Handbook of Argumentation for AI (OHAAI). Previously, formal theories of argument and argument interaction have been proposed and studied, and this has led to the more recent study of computational models of argument. Argumentation, as a field within artificial intelligence (AI), is highly relevant for researchers interested in symbolic representations of knowledge and defeasible reasoning. The purpose of this handbook is to provide an open access and curated anthology for the argumentation research community. OHAAI is designed to serve as a research hub to keep track of the latest and upcoming PhD-driven research on the theory and application of argumentation in all areas related to AI.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
