-
Harnessing AI data-driven global weather models for climate attribution: An analysis of the 2017 Oroville Dam extreme atmospheric river
Authors:
Jorge Baño-Medina,
Agniv Sengupta,
Allison Michaelis,
Luca Delle Monache,
Julie Kalansky,
Duncan Watson-Parris
Abstract:
AI data-driven models (Graphcast, Pangu Weather, Fourcastnet, and SFNO) are explored for storyline-based climate attribution due to their short inference times, which can accelerate the number of events studied, and provide real time attributions when public attention is heightened. The analysis is framed on the extreme atmospheric river episode of February 2017 that contributed to the Oroville da…
▽ More
AI data-driven models (Graphcast, Pangu Weather, Fourcastnet, and SFNO) are explored for storyline-based climate attribution due to their short inference times, which can accelerate the number of events studied, and provide real time attributions when public attention is heightened. The analysis is framed on the extreme atmospheric river episode of February 2017 that contributed to the Oroville dam spillway incident in Northern California. Past and future simulations are generated by perturbing the initial conditions with the pre-industrial and the late-21st century temperature climate change signals, respectively. The simulations are compared to results from a dynamical model which represents plausible pseudo-realities under both climate environments. Overall, the AI models show promising results, projecting a 5-6 % increase in the integrated water vapor over the Oroville dam in the present day compared to the pre-industrial, in agreement with the dynamical model. Different geopotential-moisture-temperature dependencies are unveiled for each of the AI-models tested, providing valuable information for understanding the physicality of the attribution response. However, the AI models tend to simulate weaker attribution values than the pseudo-reality imagined by the dynamical model, suggesting some reduced extrapolation skill, especially for the late-21st century regime. Large ensembles generated with an AI model (>500 members) produced statistically significant present-day to pre-industrial attribution results, unlike the >20-member ensemble from the dynamical model. This analysis highlights the potential of AI models to conduct attribution analysis, while emphasizing future lines of work on explainable artificial intelligence to gain confidence in these tools, which can enable reliable attribution studies in real-time.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Transferability and explainability of deep learning emulators for regional climate model projections: Perspectives for future applications
Authors:
Jorge Bano-Medina,
Maialen Iturbide,
Jesus Fernandez,
Jose Manuel Gutierrez
Abstract:
Regional climate models (RCMs) are essential tools for simulating and studying regional climate variability and change. However, their high computational cost limits the production of comprehensive ensembles of regional climate projections covering multiple scenarios and driving Global Climate Models (GCMs) across regions. RCM emulators based on deep learning models have recently been introduced a…
▽ More
Regional climate models (RCMs) are essential tools for simulating and studying regional climate variability and change. However, their high computational cost limits the production of comprehensive ensembles of regional climate projections covering multiple scenarios and driving Global Climate Models (GCMs) across regions. RCM emulators based on deep learning models have recently been introduced as a cost-effective and promising alternative that requires only short RCM simulations to train the models. Therefore, evaluating their transferability to different periods, scenarios, and GCMs becomes a pivotal and complex task in which the inherent biases of both GCMs and RCMs play a significant role. Here we focus on this problem by considering the two different emulation approaches proposed in the literature (PP and MOS, following the terminology introduced in this paper). In addition to standard evaluation techniques, we expand the analysis with methods from the field of eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI), to assess the physical consistency of the empirical links learnt by the models. We find that both approaches are able to emulate certain climatological properties of RCMs for different periods and scenarios (soft transferability), but the consistency of the emulation functions differ between approaches. Whereas PP learns robust and physically meaningful patterns, MOS results are GCM-dependent and lack physical consistency in some cases. Both approaches face problems when transferring the emulation function to other GCMs, due to the existence of GCM-dependent biases (hard transferability). This limits their applicability to build ensembles of regional climate projections. We conclude by giving some prospects for future applications.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Deep Ensembles to Improve Uncertainty Quantification of Statistical Downscaling Models under Climate Change Conditions
Authors:
Jose González-Abad,
Jorge Baño-Medina
Abstract:
Recently, deep learning has emerged as a promising tool for statistical downscaling, the set of methods for generating high-resolution climate fields from coarse low-resolution variables. Nevertheless, their ability to generalize to climate change conditions remains questionable, mainly due to the stationarity assumption. We propose deep ensembles as a simple method to improve the uncertainty quan…
▽ More
Recently, deep learning has emerged as a promising tool for statistical downscaling, the set of methods for generating high-resolution climate fields from coarse low-resolution variables. Nevertheless, their ability to generalize to climate change conditions remains questionable, mainly due to the stationarity assumption. We propose deep ensembles as a simple method to improve the uncertainty quantification of statistical downscaling models. By better capturing uncertainty, statistical downscaling models allow for superior planning against extreme weather events, a source of various negative social and economic impacts. Since no observational future data exists, we rely on a pseudo reality experiment to assess the suitability of deep ensembles for quantifying the uncertainty of climate change projections. Deep ensembles allow for a better risk assessment, highly demanded by sectoral applications to tackle climate change.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
On the use of Deep Generative Models for Perfect Prognosis Climate Downscaling
Authors:
Jose González-Abad,
Jorge Baño-Medina,
Ignacio Heredia Cachá
Abstract:
Deep Learning has recently emerged as a perfect prognosis downscaling technique to compute high-resolution fields from large-scale coarse atmospheric data. Despite their promising results to reproduce the observed local variability, they are based on the estimation of independent distributions at each location, which leads to deficient spatial structures, especially when downscaling precipitation.…
▽ More
Deep Learning has recently emerged as a perfect prognosis downscaling technique to compute high-resolution fields from large-scale coarse atmospheric data. Despite their promising results to reproduce the observed local variability, they are based on the estimation of independent distributions at each location, which leads to deficient spatial structures, especially when downscaling precipitation. This study proposes the use of generative models to improve the spatial consistency of the high-resolution fields, very demanded by some sectoral applications (e.g., hydrology) to tackle climate change.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Using Explainability to Inform Statistical Downscaling Based on Deep Learning Beyond Standard Validation Approaches
Authors:
Jose González-Abad,
Jorge Baño-Medina,
José Manuel Gutiérrez
Abstract:
Deep learning (DL) has emerged as a promising tool to downscale climate projections at regional-to-local scales from large-scale atmospheric fields following the perfect-prognosis (PP) approach. Given their complexity, it is crucial to properly evaluate these methods, especially when applied to changing climatic conditions where the ability to extrapolate/generalise is key. In this work, we interc…
▽ More
Deep learning (DL) has emerged as a promising tool to downscale climate projections at regional-to-local scales from large-scale atmospheric fields following the perfect-prognosis (PP) approach. Given their complexity, it is crucial to properly evaluate these methods, especially when applied to changing climatic conditions where the ability to extrapolate/generalise is key. In this work, we intercompare several DL models extracted from the literature for the same challenging use-case (downscaling temperature in the CORDEX North America domain) and expand standard evaluation methods building on eXplainable artifical intelligence (XAI) techniques. We show how these techniques can be used to unravel the internal behaviour of these models, providing new evaluation dimensions and aiding in their diagnostic and design. These results show the usefulness of incorporating XAI techniques into statistical downscaling evaluation frameworks, especially when working with large regions and/or under climate change conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
