-
Multi-Objective Deep-Learning-based Biomechanical Deformable Image Registration with MOREA
Authors:
Georgios Andreadis,
Eduard Ruiz Munné,
Thomas H. W. Bäck,
Peter A. N. Bosman,
Tanja Alderliesten
Abstract:
When choosing a deformable image registration (DIR) approach for images with large deformations and content mismatch, the realism of found transformations often needs to be traded off against the required runtime. DIR approaches using deep learning (DL) techniques have shown remarkable promise in instantly predicting a transformation. However, on difficult registration problems, the realism of the…
▽ More
When choosing a deformable image registration (DIR) approach for images with large deformations and content mismatch, the realism of found transformations often needs to be traded off against the required runtime. DIR approaches using deep learning (DL) techniques have shown remarkable promise in instantly predicting a transformation. However, on difficult registration problems, the realism of these transformations can fall short. DIR approaches using biomechanical, finite element modeling (FEM) techniques can find more realistic transformations, but tend to require much longer runtimes. This work proposes the first hybrid approach to combine them, with the aim of getting the best of both worlds. This hybrid approach, called DL-MOREA, combines a recently introduced multi-objective DL-based DIR approach which leverages the VoxelMorph framework, called DL-MODIR, with MOREA, an evolutionary algorithm-based, multi-objective DIR approach in which a FEM-like biomechanical mesh transformation model is used. In our proposed hybrid approach, the DL results are used to smartly initialize MOREA, with the aim of more efficiently optimizing its mesh transformation model. We empirically compare DL-MOREA against its components, DL-MODIR and MOREA, on CT scan pairs capturing large bladder filling differences of 15 cervical cancer patients. While MOREA requires a median runtime of 45 minutes, DL-MOREA can already find high-quality transformations after 5 minutes. Compared to the DL-MODIR transformations, the transformations found by DL-MOREA exhibit far less folding and improve or preserve the bladder contour distance error.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Fitness-based Linkage Learning and Maximum-Clique Conditional Linkage Modelling for Gray-box Optimization with RV-GOMEA
Authors:
Georgios Andreadis,
Tanja Alderliesten,
Peter A. N. Bosman
Abstract:
For many real-world optimization problems it is possible to perform partial evaluations, meaning that the impact of changing a few variables on a solution's fitness can be computed very efficiently. It has been shown that such partial evaluations can be excellently leveraged by the Real-Valued GOMEA (RV-GOMEA) that uses a linkage model to capture dependencies between problem variables. Recently, c…
▽ More
For many real-world optimization problems it is possible to perform partial evaluations, meaning that the impact of changing a few variables on a solution's fitness can be computed very efficiently. It has been shown that such partial evaluations can be excellently leveraged by the Real-Valued GOMEA (RV-GOMEA) that uses a linkage model to capture dependencies between problem variables. Recently, conditional linkage models were introduced for RV-GOMEA, expanding its state-of-the-art performance even to problems with overlapping dependencies. However, that work assumed that the dependency structure is known a priori. Fitness-based linkage learning techniques have previously been used to detect dependencies during optimization, but only for non-conditional linkage models. In this work, we combine fitness-based linkage learning and conditional linkage modelling in RV-GOMEA. In addition, we propose a new way to model overlapping dependencies in conditional linkage models to maximize the joint sampling of fully interdependent groups of variables. We compare the resulting novel variant of RV-GOMEA to other variants of RV-GOMEA and VkD-CMA on 12 problems with varying degree of overlapping dependencies. We find that the new RV-GOMEA not only performs best on most problems, also the overhead of learning the conditional linkage models during optimization is often negligible.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
A Tournament of Transformation Models: B-Spline-based vs. Mesh-based Multi-Objective Deformable Image Registration
Authors:
Georgios Andreadis,
Joas I. Mulder,
Anton Bouter,
Peter A. N. Bosman,
Tanja Alderliesten
Abstract:
The transformation model is an essential component of any deformable image registration approach. It provides a representation of physical deformations between images, thereby defining the range and realism of registrations that can be found. Two types of transformation models have emerged as popular choices: B-spline models and mesh models. Although both models have been investigated in detail, a…
▽ More
The transformation model is an essential component of any deformable image registration approach. It provides a representation of physical deformations between images, thereby defining the range and realism of registrations that can be found. Two types of transformation models have emerged as popular choices: B-spline models and mesh models. Although both models have been investigated in detail, a direct comparison has not yet been made, since the models are optimized using very different optimization methods in practice. B-spline models are predominantly optimized using gradient-descent methods, while mesh models are typically optimized using finite-element method solvers or evolutionary algorithms. Multi-objective optimization methods, which aim to find a diverse set of high-quality trade-off registrations, are increasingly acknowledged to be important in deformable image registration. Since these methods search for a diverse set of registrations, they can provide a more complete picture of the capabilities of different transformation models, making them suitable for a comparison of models. In this work, we conduct the first direct comparison between B-spline and mesh transformation models, by optimizing both models with the same state-of-the-art multi-objective optimization method, the Multi-Objective Real-Valued Gene-pool Optimal Mixing Evolutionary Algorithm (MO-RV-GOMEA). The combination with B-spline transformation models, moreover, is novel. We experimentally compare both models on two different registration problems that are both based on pelvic CT scans of cervical cancer patients, featuring large deformations. Our results, on three cervical cancer patients, indicate that the choice of transformation model can have a profound impact on the diversity and quality of achieved registration outcomes.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
MOREA: a GPU-accelerated Evolutionary Algorithm for Multi-Objective Deformable Registration of 3D Medical Images
Authors:
Georgios Andreadis,
Peter A. N. Bosman,
Tanja Alderliesten
Abstract:
Finding a realistic deformation that transforms one image into another, in case large deformations are required, is considered a key challenge in medical image analysis. Having a proper image registration approach to achieve this could unleash a number of applications requiring information to be transferred between images. Clinical adoption is currently hampered by many existing methods requiring…
▽ More
Finding a realistic deformation that transforms one image into another, in case large deformations are required, is considered a key challenge in medical image analysis. Having a proper image registration approach to achieve this could unleash a number of applications requiring information to be transferred between images. Clinical adoption is currently hampered by many existing methods requiring extensive configuration effort before each use, or not being able to (realistically) capture large deformations. A recent multi-objective approach that uses the Multi-Objective Real-Valued Gene-pool Optimal Mixing Evolutionary Algorithm (MO-RV-GOMEA) and a dual-dynamic mesh transformation model has shown promise, exposing the trade-offs inherent to image registration problems and modeling large deformations in 2D. This work builds on this promise and introduces MOREA: the first evolutionary algorithm-based multi-objective approach to deformable registration of 3D images capable of tackling large deformations. MOREA includes a 3D biomechanical mesh model for physical plausibility and is fully GPU-accelerated. We compare MOREA to two state-of-the-art approaches on abdominal CT scans of 4 cervical cancer patients, with the latter two approaches configured for the best results per patient. Without requiring per-patient configuration, MOREA significantly outperforms these approaches on 3 of the 4 patients that represent the most difficult cases.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Multi-Objective Dual Simplex-Mesh Based Deformable Image Registration for 3D Medical Images -- Proof of Concept
Authors:
Georgios Andreadis,
Peter A. N. Bosman,
Tanja Alderliesten
Abstract:
Reliably and physically accurately transferring information between images through deformable image registration with large anatomical differences is an open challenge in medical image analysis. Most existing methods have two key shortcomings: first, they require extensive up-front parameter tuning to each specific registration problem, and second, they have difficulty capturing large deformations…
▽ More
Reliably and physically accurately transferring information between images through deformable image registration with large anatomical differences is an open challenge in medical image analysis. Most existing methods have two key shortcomings: first, they require extensive up-front parameter tuning to each specific registration problem, and second, they have difficulty capturing large deformations and content mismatches between images. There have however been developments that have laid the foundation for potential solutions to both shortcomings. Towards the first shortcoming, a multi-objective optimization approach using the Real-Valued Gene-pool Optimal Mixing Evolutionary Algorithm (RV-GOMEA) has been shown to be capable of producing a diverse set of registrations for 2D images in one run of the algorithm, representing different trade-offs between conflicting objectives in the registration problem. This allows the user to select a registration afterwards and removes the need for up-front tuning. Towards the second shortcoming, a dual-dynamic grid transformation model has proven effective at capturing large differences in 2D images. These two developments have recently been accelerated through GPU parallelization, delivering large speed-ups. Based on this accelerated version, it is now possible to extend the approach to 3D images. Concordantly, this work introduces the first method for multi-objective 3D deformable image registration, using a 3D dual-dynamic grid transformation model based on simplex meshes while still supporting the incorporation of annotated guidance information and multi-resolution schemes. Our proof-of-concept prototype shows promising results on synthetic and clinical 3D registration problems, forming the foundation for a new, insightful method that can include bio-mechanical properties in the registration.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Capelin: Data-Driven Capacity Procurement for Cloud Datacenters using Portfolios of Scenarios -- Extended Technical Report
Authors:
Georgios Andreadis,
Fabian Mastenbroek,
Vincent van Beek,
Alexandru Iosup
Abstract:
Cloud datacenters provide a backbone to our digital society. Inaccurate capacity procurement for cloud datacenters can lead to significant performance degradation, denser targets for failure, and unsustainable energy consumption. Although this activity is core to improving cloud infrastructure, relatively few comprehensive approaches and support tools exist for mid-tier operators, leaving many pla…
▽ More
Cloud datacenters provide a backbone to our digital society. Inaccurate capacity procurement for cloud datacenters can lead to significant performance degradation, denser targets for failure, and unsustainable energy consumption. Although this activity is core to improving cloud infrastructure, relatively few comprehensive approaches and support tools exist for mid-tier operators, leaving many planners with merely rule-of-thumb judgement. We derive requirements from a unique survey of experts in charge of diverse datacenters in several countries. We propose Capelin, a data-driven, scenario-based capacity planning system for mid-tier cloud datacenters. Capelin introduces the notion of portfolios of scenarios, which it leverages in its probing for alternative capacity-plans. At the core of the system, a trace-based, discrete-event simulator enables the exploration of different possible topologies, with support for scaling the volume, variety, and velocity of resources, and for horizontal (scale-out) and vertical (scale-up) scaling. Capelin compares alternative topologies and for each gives detailed quantitative operational information, which could facilitate human decisions of capacity planning. We implement and open-source Capelin, and show through comprehensive trace-based experiments it can aid practitioners. The results give evidence that reasonable choices can be worse by a factor of 1.5-2.0 than the best, in terms of performance degradation or energy consumption.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
A Reference Architecture for Datacenter Scheduling: Extended Technical Report
Authors:
Georgios Andreadis,
Laurens Versluis,
Fabian Mastenbroek,
Alexandru Iosup
Abstract:
Datacenters act as cloud-infrastructure to stakeholders across industry, government, and academia. To meet growing demand yet operate efficiently, datacenter operators employ increasingly more sophisticated scheduling systems, mechanisms, and policies. Although many scheduling techniques already exist, relatively little research has gone into the abstraction of the scheduling process itself, hampe…
▽ More
Datacenters act as cloud-infrastructure to stakeholders across industry, government, and academia. To meet growing demand yet operate efficiently, datacenter operators employ increasingly more sophisticated scheduling systems, mechanisms, and policies. Although many scheduling techniques already exist, relatively little research has gone into the abstraction of the scheduling process itself, hampering design, tuning, and comparison of existing techniques. In this work, we propose a reference architecture for datacenter schedulers. The architecture follows five design principles: components with clearly distinct responsibilities, grouping of related components where possible, separation of mechanism from policy, scheduling as complex workflow, and hierarchical multi-scheduler structure. To demonstrate the validity of the reference architecture, we map to it state-of-the-art datacenter schedulers. We find scheduler-stages are commonly underspecified in peer-reviewed publications. Through trace-based simulation and real-world experiments, we show underspecification of scheduler-stages can lead to significant variations in performance.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Massivizing Computer Systems: a Vision to Understand, Design, and Engineer Computer Ecosystems through and beyond Modern Distributed Systems
Authors:
Alexandru Iosup,
Alexandru Uta,
Laurens Versluis,
Georgios Andreadis,
Erwin van Eyk,
Tim Hegeman,
Sacheendra Talluri,
Vincent van Beek,
Lucian Toader
Abstract:
Our society is digital: industry, science, governance, and individuals depend, often transparently, on the inter-operation of large numbers of distributed computer systems. Although the society takes them almost for granted, these computer ecosystems are not available for all, may not be affordable for long, and raise numerous other research challenges. Inspired by these challenges and by our expe…
▽ More
Our society is digital: industry, science, governance, and individuals depend, often transparently, on the inter-operation of large numbers of distributed computer systems. Although the society takes them almost for granted, these computer ecosystems are not available for all, may not be affordable for long, and raise numerous other research challenges. Inspired by these challenges and by our experience with distributed computer systems, we envision Massivizing Computer Systems, a domain of computer science focusing on understanding, controlling, and evolving successfully such ecosystems. Beyond establishing and growing a body of knowledge about computer ecosystems and their constituent systems, the community in this domain should also aim to educate many about design and engineering for this domain, and all people about its principles. This is a call to the entire community: there is much to discover and achieve.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2018; v1 submitted 15 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.