Showing 1–10 of 10 results for author: van der Meer, J

Thermodynamic bounds and error correction for faulty coarse graining

Authors: Jann van der Meer, Keiji Saito

Abstract: At the nanoscale, random effects govern not only the dynamics of a physical system but may also affect its observation. This work introduces a novel paradigm for coarse graining that eschews the assignment of a unique coarse-grained trajectory to a microscopic one. Instead, observations are not only coarse-grained but are also accompanied by a small chance of error. Formulating the problem in term… ▽ More At the nanoscale, random effects govern not only the dynamics of a physical system but may also affect its observation. This work introduces a novel paradigm for coarse graining that eschews the assignment of a unique coarse-grained trajectory to a microscopic one. Instead, observations are not only coarse-grained but are also accompanied by a small chance of error. Formulating the problem in terms of path weights, we identify a condition on the structure of errors that ensures that the observed entropy production does not increase. As a result, the framework of stochastic thermodynamics for estimating entropy production can be extended to this broader class of systems. As an application, we consider Markov networks in which individual transitions can be observed but may be mistaken for each other. We motivate, derive, and illustrate thermodynamic bounds that relate the error sensitivity of the observed entropy production to the strength of the driving and are valid for arbitrary network topologies. If sufficiently many transitions in the network can be observed, redundancies in the coarse-grained trajectories can be used to detect and correct errors, which potentially improves naive estimates of entropy production. We conclude with an outlook on subsequent research on thermodynamic bounds for erroneous coarse graining. △ Less

Submitted 3 July, 2025; originally announced July 2025.

From observed transitions to hidden paths in Markov networks

Authors: Alexander M. Maier, Udo Seifert, Jann van der Meer

Abstract: The number of observable degrees of freedom is typically limited in experiments. Here, we consider discrete Markov networks in which an observer has access to a few visible transitions and the waiting times between these transitions. Focusing on the underlying structure of a discrete network, we present methods to infer local and global properties of the network from observed data. First, we deriv… ▽ More The number of observable degrees of freedom is typically limited in experiments. Here, we consider discrete Markov networks in which an observer has access to a few visible transitions and the waiting times between these transitions. Focusing on the underlying structure of a discrete network, we present methods to infer local and global properties of the network from observed data. First, we derive bounds on the microscopic entropy production along the hidden paths between two visible transitions, which complement extant bounds on mean entropy production and affinities of hidden cycles. Second, we demonstrate how the operationally accessible data encodes information about the topology of shortest hidden paths, which can be used to identify potential clusters of states or exclude their existence. Finally, we outline a systematic way to combine the inferred data, resulting in an algorithm that finds the candidates for a minimal graph of the underlying network, i.e., a graph that is part of the original one and compatible with the observations. Our results highlight the interplay between thermodynamic methods, waiting-time distributions and topological aspects like network structure, which can be expected to provide novel insights in other set-ups of coarse graining as well. △ Less

Submitted 22 April, 2025; originally announced April 2025.

Stroboscopic measurements in Markov networks: Exact generator reconstruction vs. thermodynamic inference

Authors: Malena T. Bauer, Udo Seifert, Jann van der Meer

Abstract: A major goal of stochastic thermodynamics is to estimate the inevitable dissipation that accompanies particular observable phenomena in an otherwise not fully accessible system. Quantitative results are often formulated as lower bounds on the total entropy production, which capture the part of the total dissipation that can be determined based on the available data alone. In this work, we discuss… ▽ More A major goal of stochastic thermodynamics is to estimate the inevitable dissipation that accompanies particular observable phenomena in an otherwise not fully accessible system. Quantitative results are often formulated as lower bounds on the total entropy production, which capture the part of the total dissipation that can be determined based on the available data alone. In this work, we discuss the case of a continuous-time dynamics on a Markov network that is observed stroboscopically, i.e., at discrete points in time in regular intervals. We compare the standard approach of deriving a lower bound on the entropy production rate in the steady state to the less common method of reconstructing the generator from the observed propagators by taking the matrix logarithm. Provided that the timescale of the stroboscopic measurements is smaller than a critical value that can be determined from the available data, this latter method is able to recover all thermodynamic quantities like entropy production or cycle affinities and is therefore superior to the usual approach of deriving lower bounds. Beyond the critical value, we still obtain tight upper and lower bounds on these quantities that improve on extant methods. We conclude the comparison with numerical illustrations and a discussion of the requirements and limitations of both methods. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2025; v1 submitted 20 December, 2024; originally announced December 2024.

Inferring kinetics and entropy production from observable transitions in partially accessible, periodically driven Markov networks

Authors: Alexander M. Maier, Julius Degünther, Jann van der Meer, Udo Seifert

Abstract: For a network of discrete states with a periodically driven Markovian dynamics, we develop an inference scheme for an external observer who has access to some transitions. Based on waiting-time distributions between these transitions, the periodic probabilities of states connected by these observed transitions and their time-dependent transition rates can be inferred. Moreover, the smallest number… ▽ More For a network of discrete states with a periodically driven Markovian dynamics, we develop an inference scheme for an external observer who has access to some transitions. Based on waiting-time distributions between these transitions, the periodic probabilities of states connected by these observed transitions and their time-dependent transition rates can be inferred. Moreover, the smallest number of hidden transitions between accessible ones and some of their transition rates can be extracted. We prove and conjecture lower bounds on the total entropy production for such periodic stationary states. Even though our techniques are based on generalizations of known methods for steady states, we obtain original results for those as well. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Journal ref: Journal of Statistical Physics (2024) 191:104

General theory for localizing the where and when of entropy production meets single-molecule experiments

Authors: Julius Degünther, Jann van der Meer, Udo Seifert

Abstract: The laws of thermodynamics apply to biophysical systems on the nanoscale as described by the framework of stochastic thermodynamics. This theory provides universal, exact relations for quantities like work, which have been verified in experiments where a fully resolved description allows direct access to such quantities. Complementary studies consider partially hidden, coarse-grained descriptions,… ▽ More The laws of thermodynamics apply to biophysical systems on the nanoscale as described by the framework of stochastic thermodynamics. This theory provides universal, exact relations for quantities like work, which have been verified in experiments where a fully resolved description allows direct access to such quantities. Complementary studies consider partially hidden, coarse-grained descriptions, in which the mean entropy production typically is not directly accessible but can be bounded in terms of observable quantities. Going beyond the mean, we introduce a fluctuating entropy production that applies to individual trajectories in a coarse-grained description under time-dependent driving. Thus, this concept is applicable to the broad and experimentally significant class of driven systems in which not all relevant states can be resolved. We provide a paradigmatic example by studying an experimentally verified protein unfolding process. As a consequence, the entire distribution of the coarse-grained entropy production rather than merely its mean retains spatial and temporal information about the microscopic process. In particular, we obtain a bound on the distribution of the physical entropy production of individual unfolding events. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2024; v1 submitted 28 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Journal ref: Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 121, e2405371121 (2024)

Fluctuating Entropy Production on the Coarse-Grained Level: Inference and Localization of Irreversibility

Authors: Julius Degünther, Jann van der Meer, Udo Seifert

Abstract: Stochastic thermodynamics provides the framework to analyze thermodynamic laws and quantities along individual trajectories of small but fully observable systems. If the observable level fails to capture all relevant degrees of freedom, some form of effective, coarse-grained dynamics naturally emerges for which the principles of stochastic thermodynamics generally cease to be applicable straightfo… ▽ More Stochastic thermodynamics provides the framework to analyze thermodynamic laws and quantities along individual trajectories of small but fully observable systems. If the observable level fails to capture all relevant degrees of freedom, some form of effective, coarse-grained dynamics naturally emerges for which the principles of stochastic thermodynamics generally cease to be applicable straightforwardly. Our work unifies the notion of entropy production along an individual trajectory with that of a coarse-grained dynamics by establishing a framework based on snippets and Markovian events as fundamental building blocks. A key asset of a trajectory-based fluctuating entropy production is the ability to localize individual contributions to the total entropy production in time and space. As an illustration and potential application for inference we introduce a method for the detection of hidden driving. The framework applies equally to even and odd variables and, therefore, includes the peculiar case of entropy production in underdamped Langevin dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 14 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Waiting time distributions in hybrid models of motor-bead assays: A concept and tool for inference

Authors: Benjamin Ertel, Jann van der Meer, Udo Seifert

Abstract: In single-molecule experiments, the dynamics of molecular motors are often observed indirectly by measuring the trajectory of an attached bead in a motor-bead assay. In this work, we propose a method to extract the step size and stalling force for a molecular motor without relying on external control parameters. We discuss this method for a generic hybrid model that describes bead and motor via co… ▽ More In single-molecule experiments, the dynamics of molecular motors are often observed indirectly by measuring the trajectory of an attached bead in a motor-bead assay. In this work, we propose a method to extract the step size and stalling force for a molecular motor without relying on external control parameters. We discuss this method for a generic hybrid model that describes bead and motor via continuous and discrete degrees of freedom, respectively. Our deductions are solely based on the observation of waiting times and transition statistics of the observable bead trajectory. Thus, the method is non-invasive, operationally accessible in experiments and can, in principle, be applied to any model describing the dynamics of molecular motors. We briefly discuss the relation of our results to recent advances in stochastic thermodynamics on inference from observable transitions. Our results are confirmed by extensive numerical simulations for parameters values of an experimentally realized F1-ATPase assay. △ Less

Submitted 4 May, 2023; v1 submitted 3 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Journal ref: Int. J. Mol. Sci. 2023, 24(8), 7610

Time-resolved statistics of snippets as general framework for model-free entropy estimators

Authors: Jann van der Meer, Julius Degünther, Udo Seifert

Abstract: Irreversibility is commonly quantified by entropy production. An external observer can estimate it through measuring an observable that is antisymmetric under time-reversal like a current. We introduce a general framework that, inter alia, allows us to infer a lower bound on entropy production through measuring the time-resolved statistics of events with any symmetry under time-reversal, in partic… ▽ More Irreversibility is commonly quantified by entropy production. An external observer can estimate it through measuring an observable that is antisymmetric under time-reversal like a current. We introduce a general framework that, inter alia, allows us to infer a lower bound on entropy production through measuring the time-resolved statistics of events with any symmetry under time-reversal, in particular, time-symmetric instantaneous events. We emphasize Markovianity as a property of certain events rather than of the full system and introduce an operationally accessible criterion for this weakened Markov property. Conceptually, the approach is based on snippets as particular sections of trajectories, for which a generalized detailed balance relation is discussed. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Thermodynamic inference in partially accessible Markov networks: A unifying perspective from transition-based waiting time distributions

Authors: Jann van der Meer, Benjamin Ertel, Udo Seifert

Abstract: The inference of thermodynamic quantities from the description of an only partially accessible physical system is a central challenge in stochastic thermodynamics. A common approach is coarse-graining, which maps the dynamics of such a system to a reduced effective one. While coarse-graining states of the system into compound ones is a well studied concept, recent evidence hints at a complementary… ▽ More The inference of thermodynamic quantities from the description of an only partially accessible physical system is a central challenge in stochastic thermodynamics. A common approach is coarse-graining, which maps the dynamics of such a system to a reduced effective one. While coarse-graining states of the system into compound ones is a well studied concept, recent evidence hints at a complementary description by considering observable transitions and waiting times. In this work, we consider waiting time distributions between two consecutive transitions of a partially observable Markov network. We formulate an entropy estimator using their ratios to quantify irreversibility. Depending on the complexity of the underlying network, we formulate criteria to infer whether the entropy estimator recovers the full physical entropy production or whether it just provides a lower bound that improves on established results. This conceptual approach, which is based on the irreversibility of underlying cycles, additionally enables us to derive estimators for the topology of the network, i.e., the presence of a hidden cycle, its number of states and its driving affinity. Adopting an equivalent semi-Markov description, our results can be condensed into a fluctuation theorem for the corresponding semi-Markov process. This mathematical perspective provides a unifying framework for the entropy estimators considered here and established earlier ones. The crucial role of the correct version of time-reversal helps to clarify a recent debate on the meaning of formal versus physical irreversibility. Extensive numerical calculations based on a direct evaluation of waiting-time distributions illustrate our exact results and provide an estimate on the quality of the bounds for affinities of hidden cycles. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2022; v1 submitted 22 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. X 12, 031025, August 2022

Operationally Accessible Uncertainty Relations for Thermodynamically Consistent Semi-Markov Processes

Authors: Benjamin Ertel, Jann van der Meer, Udo Seifert

Abstract: Semi-Markov processes generalize Markov processes by adding temporal memory effects as expressed by a semi-Markov kernel. We recall the path weight for a semi-Markov trajectory and the fact that thermodynamic consistency in equilibrium imposes a crucial condition called direction-time independence for which we present an alternative derivation. We prove a thermodynamic uncertainty relation that fo… ▽ More Semi-Markov processes generalize Markov processes by adding temporal memory effects as expressed by a semi-Markov kernel. We recall the path weight for a semi-Markov trajectory and the fact that thermodynamic consistency in equilibrium imposes a crucial condition called direction-time independence for which we present an alternative derivation. We prove a thermodynamic uncertainty relation that formally resembles the one for a discrete-time Markov process. The result relates the entropy production of the semi-Markov process to mean and variance of steady-state currents. We prove a further thermodynamic uncertainty relation valid for semi-Markov descriptions of coarse-grained Markov processes that emerge by grouping states together. A violation of this inequality can be used as an inference tool to conclude that a given semi-Markov process cannot result from coarse-graining an underlying Markov one. We illustrate these results with representative examples. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2022; v1 submitted 25 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 105 (4), 044113, April 2022