-
Unravelling the multiscale surface mechanics of soft solids
Authors:
Nicolas Bain,
Lawrence A. Wilen,
Dominic Gerber,
Mengjie Zu,
Carl P. Goodrich,
Senthilkumar Duraivel,
Kaarthik Varma,
Harsha Koganti,
Robert W. Style,
Eric R. Dufresne
Abstract:
The softer a material is, the more its mechanics are sensitive to interfaces. In soft gels, an elastic polymeric network is filled with free-flowing molecules. In theory, either of these components could dominate the material interfacial properties. In practice, current measurements cannot distinguish between the two, nor can they rule out material inhomogeneities, which could modulate the apparen…
▽ More
The softer a material is, the more its mechanics are sensitive to interfaces. In soft gels, an elastic polymeric network is filled with free-flowing molecules. In theory, either of these components could dominate the material interfacial properties. In practice, current measurements cannot distinguish between the two, nor can they rule out material inhomogeneities, which could modulate the apparent properties of the interfaces. Here, we introduce an experimental approach that elucidates the interfacial mechanics of soft solids. Coupling quantum dots, controlled deformations, and precise confocal measurements, we fully separate the material inhomogeneities of a silicone gel from its true interfacial properties. We quantify a gradient in bulk elastic properties near the surface, with a characteristic length scale of about 20 μm. In addition, we observe a surface excess elasticity, whose associated gradient is unresolvable with light microscopy. The composition of the external medium has a strong affect on the observed value of the surface elasticity. Thus, we conclude that the surface elasticity of this silicone network is an interfacial property.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Droplets sliding on soft solids shed elastocapillary rails
Authors:
Nan Xue,
Lawrence A. Wilen,
Robert W. Style,
Eric R. Dufresne
Abstract:
The surface tension of partially wetting droplets deforms soft substrates. These deformations are usually localized to a narrow region near the contact line, forming a so-called `elastocapillary ridge.' When a droplet slides along a substrate, the movement of the elastocapillary ridge dissipates energy in the substrate and slows the droplet down. Previous studies have analyzed isotropically spread…
▽ More
The surface tension of partially wetting droplets deforms soft substrates. These deformations are usually localized to a narrow region near the contact line, forming a so-called `elastocapillary ridge.' When a droplet slides along a substrate, the movement of the elastocapillary ridge dissipates energy in the substrate and slows the droplet down. Previous studies have analyzed isotropically spreading droplets and found that the advancing contact line `surfs' the elastocapillary ridge, with a velocity determined by a local balance of capillary forces and bulk rheology. Here, we experimentally explore the dynamics of a droplet sliding across soft substrates. At low velocities, the contact line is nearly circular, and dissipation increases logarithmically with speed. At higher droplet velocities, the contact line adopts a bullet-like shape, and the dissipation levels off. At the same time, droplets shed a pair of `elastocapillary rails' that fade away slowly behind it. These results suggest that droplets favor sliding along a stationary ridge over surfing atop a translating one.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2024; v1 submitted 30 August, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Polycrystallinity enhances stress build-up around ice
Authors:
Dominic Gerber,
Lawrence A. Wilen,
Eric R. Dufresne,
Robert W. Style
Abstract:
Damage caused by freezing wet, porous materials is a widespread problem, but is hard to predict or control. Here, we show that polycrystallinity makes a great difference to the stress build-up process that underpins this damage. Unfrozen water in grain-boundary grooves feeds ice growth at temperatures below the freezing temperature, leading to the fast build-up of localized stresses. The process i…
▽ More
Damage caused by freezing wet, porous materials is a widespread problem, but is hard to predict or control. Here, we show that polycrystallinity makes a great difference to the stress build-up process that underpins this damage. Unfrozen water in grain-boundary grooves feeds ice growth at temperatures below the freezing temperature, leading to the fast build-up of localized stresses. The process is very variable, which we ascribe to local differences in ice-grain orientation, and to the surprising mobility of many grooves -- which further accelerates stress build-up. Our work will help understand how freezing damage occurs, and in developing accurate models and effective damage-mitigation strategies.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2023; v1 submitted 23 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Stress accumulation around ice in a temperature gradient
Authors:
Dominic Gerber,
Lawrence A. Wilen,
Florian Poydenot,
Eric R. Dufresne,
Robert W. Style
Abstract:
When materials freeze, they often undergo damage due to ice growth. Although this damage is commonly ascribed to the volumetric expansion of water upon freezing, it is usually driven by suction of water towards growing ice crystals. The freezing of this additional water can cause a large build up of stress. Here, we study this process by producing a stable ice/water interface in a controlled tempe…
▽ More
When materials freeze, they often undergo damage due to ice growth. Although this damage is commonly ascribed to the volumetric expansion of water upon freezing, it is usually driven by suction of water towards growing ice crystals. The freezing of this additional water can cause a large build up of stress. Here, we study this process by producing a stable ice/water interface in a controlled temperature gradient, and measuring the deformation of the confining boundary. Analysis of the deformation field reveals stresses applied to the boundary with $\mathcal{O}(μ\mathrm{m})$ resolution. Globally, stresses increase steadily over time as liquid water is transported to more deeply undercooled regions. Locally, stresses increase until ice growth is stalled by the confining stresses. In accordance with the Clapeyron equation, the local limiting stress is proportional to the local undercooling. These results are closely connected to the crystallization pressure for growing crystals and condensation pressure during liquid-liquid phase separation.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Viscoelastic and poroelastic relaxations of soft solid surfaces
Authors:
Qin Xu,
Lawrence A. Wilen,
Katharine E. Jensen,
Robert W. Style,
Eric R. Dufresne
Abstract:
Understanding surface mechanics of soft solids, such as soft polymeric gels, is crucial in many engineering processes, such as dynamic wetting and adhesive failure. In these situations, a combination of capillary and elastic forces drives the motion, which is balanced by dissipative mechanisms to determine the rate. While shear rheology (i.e. viscoelasticity) has long been assumed to dominate the…
▽ More
Understanding surface mechanics of soft solids, such as soft polymeric gels, is crucial in many engineering processes, such as dynamic wetting and adhesive failure. In these situations, a combination of capillary and elastic forces drives the motion, which is balanced by dissipative mechanisms to determine the rate. While shear rheology (i.e. viscoelasticity) has long been assumed to dominate the dissipation, recent works have suggested that compressibility effects (i.e. poroelasticity) could play roles in swollen networks. We use fast interferometric imaging to quantify the relaxation of surface deformations due to a displaced contact line. By systematically measuring the profiles at different time and length scales, we experimentally observe a crossover from viscoelastic to poroelastic surface relaxations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2020; v1 submitted 17 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation in an Elastic Network
Authors:
Robert W. Style,
Tianqi Sai,
Nicoló Fanelli,
Mahdiye Ijavi,
Katrina Smith-Mannschott,
Qin Xu,
Lawrence A. Wilen,
Eric R. Dufresne
Abstract:
Living and engineered systems rely on the stable coexistence of two interspersed liquid phases. Yet surface tension drives their complete separation. Here we show that stable droplets of uniform and tuneable size can be produced through arrested phase separation in an elastic matrix. Starting with an elastic polymer network swollen by a solvent mixture, we change the temperature or composition to…
▽ More
Living and engineered systems rely on the stable coexistence of two interspersed liquid phases. Yet surface tension drives their complete separation. Here we show that stable droplets of uniform and tuneable size can be produced through arrested phase separation in an elastic matrix. Starting with an elastic polymer network swollen by a solvent mixture, we change the temperature or composition to drive demixing. Droplets nucleate and grow to a stable size that is tuneable by the network cross-linking density, the cooling rate, and the composition of the solvent mixture. We discuss thermodynamic and mechanical constraints on the process. In particular, we show that the threshold for macroscopic phase separation is altered by the elasticity of the polymer network, and we highlight the role of internuclear correlations in determining the droplet size and polydispersity. This phenomenon has potential applications ranging from colloid synthesis and structural colour to phase separation in biological cells.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2017; v1 submitted 1 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Patterning droplets with durotaxis
Authors:
Robert W. Style,
Yonglu Che,
Su Ji Park,
Byung Mook Weon,
Jung Ho Je,
Callen Hyland,
Guy K. German,
Michael Power,
Larry A. Wilen,
John S. Wettlaufer,
Eric R. Dufresne
Abstract:
Numerous cell-types have shown a remarkable ability to detect and move along gradients in stiffness of an underlying substrate -- a process known as durotaxis. The mechanisms underlying durotaxis are still unresolved, but generally believed to involve active sensing and locomotion. Here, we show that simple liquid droplets also undergo durotaxis. By modulating substrate stiffness, we obtain fine c…
▽ More
Numerous cell-types have shown a remarkable ability to detect and move along gradients in stiffness of an underlying substrate -- a process known as durotaxis. The mechanisms underlying durotaxis are still unresolved, but generally believed to involve active sensing and locomotion. Here, we show that simple liquid droplets also undergo durotaxis. By modulating substrate stiffness, we obtain fine control of droplet position on soft, flat substrates. Unlike other control mechanisms, droplet durotaxis works without imposing chemical, thermal, electrical or topographical gradients. This enables a new approach to large-scale droplet patterning and is potentially useful for many applications, such as microfluidics, thermal control and microfabrication.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2013; v1 submitted 15 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Grain boundary melting in ice
Authors:
E. S. Thomson,
Hendrik Hansen-Goos,
L. A. Wilen,
J. S. Wettlaufer
Abstract:
We describe an optical scattering study of grain boundary premelting in water ice. Ubiquitous long ranged attractive polarization forces act to suppress grain boundary melting whereas repulsive forces originating in screened Coulomb interactions and classical colligative effects enhance it. The liquid enhancing effects can be manipulated by adding dopant ions to the system. For all measured grain…
▽ More
We describe an optical scattering study of grain boundary premelting in water ice. Ubiquitous long ranged attractive polarization forces act to suppress grain boundary melting whereas repulsive forces originating in screened Coulomb interactions and classical colligative effects enhance it. The liquid enhancing effects can be manipulated by adding dopant ions to the system. For all measured grain boundaries this leads to increasing premelted film thickness with increasing electrolyte concentration. Although we understand that the interfacial surface charge densities $q_s$ and solute concentrations can potentially dominate the film thickness, we can not directly measure them within a given grain boundary. Therefore, as a framework for interpreting the data we consider two appropriate $q_s$ dependent limits; one is dominated by the colligative effect and one is dominated by electrostatic interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2013; v1 submitted 21 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Universal deformation of soft substrates near a contact line and the direct measurement of solid surface stresses
Authors:
Robert W. Style,
Yonglu Che,
John. S. Wettlaufer,
Larry A. Wilen,
Eric R. Dufresne
Abstract:
Droplets deform soft substrates near their contact lines. Using confocal microscopy, we measure the deformation of silicone gel substrates due to glycerol and fluorinated-oil droplets for a range of droplet radii and substrate thicknesses. For all droplets, the substrate deformation takes a universal shape close to the contact line that depends on liquid composition, but is independent of droplet…
▽ More
Droplets deform soft substrates near their contact lines. Using confocal microscopy, we measure the deformation of silicone gel substrates due to glycerol and fluorinated-oil droplets for a range of droplet radii and substrate thicknesses. For all droplets, the substrate deformation takes a universal shape close to the contact line that depends on liquid composition, but is independent of droplet size and substrate thickness. This shape is determined by a balance of interfacial tensions at the contact line and provides a novel method for direct determination of the surface stresses of soft substrates. Moreover, we measure the change in contact angle with droplet radius and show that Young's law fails for small droplets when their radii approach an elastocapillary length scale. For larger droplets the macroscopic contact angle is constant, consistent with Young's law.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2012; v1 submitted 17 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
The Deformation of an Elastic Substrate by a Three-Phase Contact Line
Authors:
Elizabeth R. Jerison,
Ye Xu,
Larry A. Wilen,
Eric R. Dufresne
Abstract:
Young's classic analysis of the equilibrium of a three-phase contact line ignores the out-of-plane component of the liquid-vapor surface tension. While it has long been appreciated that this unresolved force must be balanced by elastic deformation of the solid substrate, a definitive analysis has remained elusive because conventional idealizations of the substrate imply a divergence of stress at t…
▽ More
Young's classic analysis of the equilibrium of a three-phase contact line ignores the out-of-plane component of the liquid-vapor surface tension. While it has long been appreciated that this unresolved force must be balanced by elastic deformation of the solid substrate, a definitive analysis has remained elusive because conventional idealizations of the substrate imply a divergence of stress at the contact line. While a number of theories of have been presented to cut off the divergence, none of them have provided reasonable agreement with experimental data. We measure surface and bulk deformation of a thin elastic film near a three-phase contact line using fluorescence confocal microscopy. The out-of-plane deformation is well fit by a linear elastic theory incorporating an out-of-plane restoring force due to the surface tension of the gel. This theory predicts that the deformation profile near the contact line is scale-free and independent of the substrate elastic modulus.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
A direct optical method for the study of grain boundary melting
Authors:
E. S. Thomson,
J. S. Wettlaufer,
L. A. Wilen
Abstract:
The structure and evolution of grain boundaries underlies the nature of polycrystalline materials. Here we describe an experimental apparatus and light reflection technique for measuring disorder at grain boundaries in optically clear material, in thermodynamic equilibrium. The approach is demonstrated on ice bicrystals. Crystallographic orientation is measured for each ice sample. The type and…
▽ More
The structure and evolution of grain boundaries underlies the nature of polycrystalline materials. Here we describe an experimental apparatus and light reflection technique for measuring disorder at grain boundaries in optically clear material, in thermodynamic equilibrium. The approach is demonstrated on ice bicrystals. Crystallographic orientation is measured for each ice sample. The type and concentration of impurity in the liquid can be controlled and the temperature can be continuously recorded and controlled over a range near the melting point. The general methodology is appropriate for a wide variety of materials.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2009; v1 submitted 3 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
Light scattering from an isotropic layer between uniaxial crystals
Authors:
Erik S. Thomson,
Larry A. Wilen,
John S. Wettlaufer
Abstract:
We develop a model for the reflection and transmission of plane waves by an isotropic layer sandwiched between two uniaxial crystals of arbitrary orientation. In the laboratory frame, reflection and transmission coefficients corresponding to the principal polarization directions in each crystal are given explicitly in terms of the c-axis and propagation directions. The solution is found by first…
▽ More
We develop a model for the reflection and transmission of plane waves by an isotropic layer sandwiched between two uniaxial crystals of arbitrary orientation. In the laboratory frame, reflection and transmission coefficients corresponding to the principal polarization directions in each crystal are given explicitly in terms of the c-axis and propagation directions. The solution is found by first deriving explicit expressions for reflection and transmission amplitude coefficients for waves propagating from an arbitrarily oriented uniaxial anisotropic material into an isotropic material. By combining these results with Lekner's (1991) earlier treatment of waves propagating from isotropic media to anisotropic media and employing a matrix method we determine a solution to the general form of the multiple reflection case. The example system of a wetted interface between two ice crystals is used to contextualize the results.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2009; v1 submitted 16 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
