-
Implementation of Morse-Witten theory for a polydisperse wet 2D foam simulation
Authors:
Friedrich F. Dunne,
Jens Winkelmann,
Denis Weaire,
Stefan Hutzler
Abstract:
The Morse-Witten theory (D. Morse and T. Witten, EPL 22 (1993) 549-555) provides a formulation for the inter-bubble forces and corresponding deformations in a liquid foam, accurate in the limit of high liquid fraction. Here we show how the theory may be applied in practice, including allowing for polydispersity in the bubble sizes. The resulting equilibrated 2D structures are consistent with direc…
▽ More
The Morse-Witten theory (D. Morse and T. Witten, EPL 22 (1993) 549-555) provides a formulation for the inter-bubble forces and corresponding deformations in a liquid foam, accurate in the limit of high liquid fraction. Here we show how the theory may be applied in practice, including allowing for polydispersity in the bubble sizes. The resulting equilibrated 2D structures are consistent with direct calculations, within the limitations of the theory. The path to developing a 3D model is outlined for future work.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Equilibrium configurations of hard spheres in a cylindrical harmonic potential
Authors:
Jens Winkelmann,
Adil Mughal,
Denis Weaire,
Stefan Hutzler
Abstract:
A line of hard spheres confined by a transverse harmonic potential, with hard walls at its ends, exhibits a variety of buckled structures as it is compressed longitudinally. Here we show that these may be conveniently observed in a rotating liquid-filled tube (originally introduced by Lee et al. [T. Lee, K. Gizynski, and B. Grzybowski, Adv. Mater. 29, 1704274 (2017)] to assemble ordered three dime…
▽ More
A line of hard spheres confined by a transverse harmonic potential, with hard walls at its ends, exhibits a variety of buckled structures as it is compressed longitudinally. Here we show that these may be conveniently observed in a rotating liquid-filled tube (originally introduced by Lee et al. [T. Lee, K. Gizynski, and B. Grzybowski, Adv. Mater. 29, 1704274 (2017)] to assemble ordered three dimensional structures at higher compressions). The corresponding theoretical model is transparent and easily investigated numerically, as well as by analytic approximations. Hence we explore a wide range of predicted structures occurring via bifurcation, of which the stable ones are also observed in our experiments. Qualitatively similar structures have previously been found in trapped ion systems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2019; v1 submitted 26 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Demonstration and interpretation of "scutoid" cells in a quasi-2D soap froth
Authors:
A. Mughal,
S. J. Cox,
D. Weaire,
S. R. Burke,
S. Hutzler
Abstract:
Recently a novel type of epithelial cell has been discovered and dubbed the "scutoid". It is induced by curvature of the bounding surfaces. We show by simulations and experiments that such cells are to be found in a dry foam subjected to this boundary condition.
Recently a novel type of epithelial cell has been discovered and dubbed the "scutoid". It is induced by curvature of the bounding surfaces. We show by simulations and experiments that such cells are to be found in a dry foam subjected to this boundary condition.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Theory of rotational columnar structures of soft spheres
Authors:
Jens Winkelmann,
Adil Mughal,
David B. Williams,
Denis Weaire,
Stefan Hutzler
Abstract:
There is a growing interest in cylindrical structures of hard and soft particles. A promising new method to assemble such structures has recently been introduced by Lee et al. [T. Lee, K. Gizynski, and B. Grzybowski, Adv. Mater. 29, 1704274 (2017)]. They used rapid rotation around a central axis to drive spheres of lower density than the surrounding fluid towards this axis. This resulted in differ…
▽ More
There is a growing interest in cylindrical structures of hard and soft particles. A promising new method to assemble such structures has recently been introduced by Lee et al. [T. Lee, K. Gizynski, and B. Grzybowski, Adv. Mater. 29, 1704274 (2017)]. They used rapid rotation around a central axis to drive spheres of lower density than the surrounding fluid towards this axis. This resulted in different structures as the number of spheres is varied. Here we present comprehensive analytic energy calculations for such self-assembled structures, based on a generic soft sphere model, from which we obtain a phase diagram. It displays interesting features, including peritectoid points. These analytic calculations are complemented by preliminary numerical simulations for finite sample sizes with soft spheres. A similar analytic approach could be used to study packings of spheres inside cylinders of fixed dimensions, but with a variation in the number of spheres.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2019; v1 submitted 8 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Columnar structures of soft spheres: Metastability and hysteresis
Authors:
Adil Mughal,
Jens Winkelmann,
Denis Weaire,
Stefan Hutzler
Abstract:
Previously we reported on the stable (i.e. minimal enthalpy) structures of soft monodisperse spheres in a long cylindrical channel. Here, we present further simulations, which significantly extend the original phase diagram up to D/d = 2.714 (ratio of cylinder and sphere diameters), where the nature of densest sphere packing changes. However, macroscopic systems of this kind are not confined to th…
▽ More
Previously we reported on the stable (i.e. minimal enthalpy) structures of soft monodisperse spheres in a long cylindrical channel. Here, we present further simulations, which significantly extend the original phase diagram up to D/d = 2.714 (ratio of cylinder and sphere diameters), where the nature of densest sphere packing changes. However, macroscopic systems of this kind are not confined to the ideal equilibrium states of this diagram. Consequently, we explore some of the structural transitions to be expected as experimental conditions are varied; these are in general hysteretic. We represent these transitions in a stability diagram for a representative case. Illustrative videos are included in the supplemental material.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2018; v1 submitted 19 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Ideal wet two-dimensional foams and emulsions with finite contact angle
Authors:
S. J. Cox,
A. M. Kraynik,
D. Weaire,
S. Hutzler
Abstract:
We present simulations that show that an ideal two-dimensional foam with a finite contact angle develops an inhomogeneity for high liquid fraction $φ$. In liquid-liquid emulsions this inhomogeneity is known as flocculation. In the case of an ordered foam this requires a perturbation, but in a disordered foam inhomogeneity grows steadily and spontaneously with $φ$, as demonstrated in our simulation…
▽ More
We present simulations that show that an ideal two-dimensional foam with a finite contact angle develops an inhomogeneity for high liquid fraction $φ$. In liquid-liquid emulsions this inhomogeneity is known as flocculation. In the case of an ordered foam this requires a perturbation, but in a disordered foam inhomogeneity grows steadily and spontaneously with $φ$, as demonstrated in our simulations performed with the Surface Evolver.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Rheological properties of the soft-disk model of two-dimensional foams
Authors:
Vincent J. Langlois,
Stefan Hutzler,
Denis Weaire
Abstract:
The soft-disk model previously developed and applied by Durian [D. J. Durian, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 4780 (1995)] is brought to bear on problems of foam rheology of longstanding and current interest, using two-dimensional systems. The questions at issue include the origin of the Herschel-Bulkley relation, normal stress effects (dilatancy), and localization in the presence of wall drag. We show that…
▽ More
The soft-disk model previously developed and applied by Durian [D. J. Durian, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 4780 (1995)] is brought to bear on problems of foam rheology of longstanding and current interest, using two-dimensional systems. The questions at issue include the origin of the Herschel-Bulkley relation, normal stress effects (dilatancy), and localization in the presence of wall drag. We show that even a model that incorporates only linear viscous effects at the local level gives rise to nonlinear (power-law) dependence of the limit stress on strain rate. With wall drag, shear localization is found. Its nonexponential form and the variation of localization length with boundary velocity are well described by a continuum model in the spirit of Janiaud et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 038302 (2006)]. Other results satisfactorily link localization to model parameters, and hence tie together continuum and local descriptions.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
2D foams above the jamming transition: Deformation matters
Authors:
Jens Winkelmann,
Friedrich F. Dunne,
Vicent J. Langlois,
Matthias E. Möbius,
Denis Weaire,
Stefan Hutzler
Abstract:
Jammed soft matter systems are often modelled as dense packings of overlapping soft spheres, thus ignoring particle deformation. For 2D (and 3D) soft disks packings, close to the critical packing fraction $\varphi_c$, this results in an increase of the average contact number $Z$ with a square root in $\varphi-\varphi_c$. Using the program PLAT, we find that in the case of idealised two-dimensional…
▽ More
Jammed soft matter systems are often modelled as dense packings of overlapping soft spheres, thus ignoring particle deformation. For 2D (and 3D) soft disks packings, close to the critical packing fraction $\varphi_c$, this results in an increase of the average contact number $Z$ with a square root in $\varphi-\varphi_c$. Using the program PLAT, we find that in the case of idealised two-dimensional foams, close to the wet limit, $Z$ increases linearly with $\varphi-\varphi_c$, where $\varphi$ is the gas fraction. This result is consistent with the different distributions of separations for soft disks and foams at the critical packing fraction. Thus, 2D foams close to the wet limit are not well described as random packings of soft disks, since bubbles in a foam are deformable and adjust their shape. This is not captured by overlapping circular disks.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Simulation and observation of line-slip structures in columnar structures of soft spheres
Authors:
Jens Winkelmann,
Benjamin Haffner,
Denis Weaire,
Adil Mughal,
Stefan Hutzler
Abstract:
We present the computed phase diagram of columnar structures of soft spheres under pressure, of which the main feature is the appearance and disappearance of line slips, the shearing of adjacent spirals, as pressure is increased. A comparable experimental observation is made on a column of bubbles under forced drainage, clearly exhibiting the expected line slip.
We present the computed phase diagram of columnar structures of soft spheres under pressure, of which the main feature is the appearance and disappearance of line slips, the shearing of adjacent spirals, as pressure is increased. A comparable experimental observation is made on a column of bubbles under forced drainage, clearly exhibiting the expected line slip.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2018; v1 submitted 2 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Beam model for the elastic properties of material with spherical voids
Authors:
Sascha Heitkam,
Wiebke Drenckhan,
Denis Weaire,
Jochen Froehlich
Abstract:
The elastic properties of a material with spherical voids of equal volume are analysed using a new model, with particular attention paid to the hexagonal close-packed and the face-centred cubic arrangement of voids. Void fractions well above 74 \% are considered, yielding overlapping voids as in an open-cell foam and hence a connected pore structure. The material is represented by a network of bea…
▽ More
The elastic properties of a material with spherical voids of equal volume are analysed using a new model, with particular attention paid to the hexagonal close-packed and the face-centred cubic arrangement of voids. Void fractions well above 74 \% are considered, yielding overlapping voids as in an open-cell foam and hence a connected pore structure. The material is represented by a network of beams. The elastic behaviour of each beam is derived analytically from the material structure. By computing the linear elastic properties of the beam network, the Young's moduli and Poisson ratios for different directions are evaluated. In the limit of rigidity loss a power law is obtained, describing the relation between Young's modulus and void fraction with an exponent of 5/2 for bending-dominated and 3/2 for stretching-dominated directions. The corresponding Poisson ratios vary between 0 and 1. With decreasing void fraction, these exponents become 2.3 and 1.3, respectively. The data obtained analytically and from the new beam model are compared to Finite Element simulations carried out in a companion study, and good agreement is found. The hexagonal close-packed void arrangement features very anisotropic behaviour, comparable to that of fibre-reinforced materials, This might allow for new applications of open-cell materials.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Elastic properties of solid material with various arrangements of spherical voids
Authors:
Sascha Heitkam,
Wiebke Drenckhan,
Thomas Titscher,
Denis Weaire,
Daniel Christopher Kreuter,
David Hajnal,
Frederic Piechon,
Jochen Froehlich
Abstract:
In this work the linear elastic properties of materials containing spherical voids are calculated and compared using finite element simulations. The focus is on homogeneous solid materials with spherical, empty voids of equal size. The voids are arranged on crystalline lattices (SC, BCC, FCC and HCP structure) or randomly, and may overlap in order to produce connected voids. In that way, the entir…
▽ More
In this work the linear elastic properties of materials containing spherical voids are calculated and compared using finite element simulations. The focus is on homogeneous solid materials with spherical, empty voids of equal size. The voids are arranged on crystalline lattices (SC, BCC, FCC and HCP structure) or randomly, and may overlap in order to produce connected voids. In that way, the entire range of void fraction between 0.00 and 0.95 is covered, including closed-cell and open-cell structures. For each arrangement of voids and for different void fractions the full stiffness tensor is computed. From this, the Young's modulus and Poisson ratios are derived for different orientations. Special care is taken of assessing and reducing the numerical uncertainty of the method. In that way, a reliable quantitative comparison of different void structures is carried out. Among other things, this work shows that the Young's modulus of FCC in the (1 1 1) plane differs from HCP in the (0 0 0 1) plane, even though these structures are very similar. For a given void fraction SC offers the highest and the lowest Young's modulus depending on the direction. For BCC at a critical void fraction a switch of the elastic behaviour is found, as regards the direction in which the Young's modulus is maximised. For certain crystalline void arrangements and certain directions Poisson ratios between 0 and 1 were found, including values that exceed the bounds for isotropic materials. For subsequent investigations the full stiffness tensor for a range of void arrangements and void fractions are provided in the supplemental material.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
The surface tells it all: Relationship between volume and surface fraction of liquid dispersions
Authors:
Emilie Forel,
Emmanuelle Rio,
Maxime Schneider,
Sebastien Beguin,
Denis Weaire,
Stefan Hutzler,
Wiebke Drenckhan
Abstract:
The properties of liquid dispersions, such as foams or emulsions, depend strongly on the volume fraction $φ$ of the continuous phase. Concentrating on the example of foams, we show experimentally and theoretically that $φ$ may be related to the fraction $φ_s$ of the surface at a wall which is wetted by the continuous phase - given an expression for the interfacial energy or osmotic pressure of the…
▽ More
The properties of liquid dispersions, such as foams or emulsions, depend strongly on the volume fraction $φ$ of the continuous phase. Concentrating on the example of foams, we show experimentally and theoretically that $φ$ may be related to the fraction $φ_s$ of the surface at a wall which is wetted by the continuous phase - given an expression for the interfacial energy or osmotic pressure of the bulk system. Since the surface fraction $φ_s$ can be readly determined from optical measurement and since there are good general approximations available for interfacial energy and osmotic pressure we thus arrive at an advantageous method of estimating $φ$. The same relationship between $φ$ and $φ_s$ is also expected to provide a good approximation of the fraction of the bubble or drop surface which is wetted by the continuous phase. This is a parameter of great importance for the rheology and ageing of liquid dispersions.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Phyllotaxis, disk packing and Fibonacci numbers
Authors:
Adil Mughal,
Denis Weaire
Abstract:
We consider the evolution of the packing of disks (representing the position of buds) that are introduced at the top of a surface which has the form of a growing stem. They migrate downwards, while conforming to three principles, applied locally: dense packing, homogeneity and continuity. We show that spiral structures characterised by the widely observed Fibonacci sequence (1,1,2,3,5,8,13...), as…
▽ More
We consider the evolution of the packing of disks (representing the position of buds) that are introduced at the top of a surface which has the form of a growing stem. They migrate downwards, while conforming to three principles, applied locally: dense packing, homogeneity and continuity. We show that spiral structures characterised by the widely observed Fibonacci sequence (1,1,2,3,5,8,13...), as well as related structures, occur naturally under such rules. Typical results are presented in a animation.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2017; v1 submitted 20 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Theory of cylindrical dense packings of disks
Authors:
Adil Mughal,
Denis Weaire
Abstract:
We have previously explored cylindrical packings of disks and their relation to sphere packings. Here we extend the analytical treatment of disk packings, analysing the rules for phyllotactic indices of related structures and the variation of the density for line-slip structures, close to the symmetric ones. We show that rhombic structures, which are of a lower density, are always unstable i.e. ca…
▽ More
We have previously explored cylindrical packings of disks and their relation to sphere packings. Here we extend the analytical treatment of disk packings, analysing the rules for phyllotactic indices of related structures and the variation of the density for line-slip structures, close to the symmetric ones. We show that rhombic structures, which are of a lower density, are always unstable i.e. can be increased in density by small perturbations
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Dense packings of spheres in cylinders I. Simulations
Authors:
A. Mughal,
H. K. Chan,
D. Weaire,
S. Hutzler
Abstract:
We study the optimal packing of hard spheres in an infinitely long cylinder, using simulated annealing, and compare our results with the analogous problem of packing disks on the unrolled surface of a cylinder. The densest structures are described and tabulated in detail up to D/d=2.873 (ratio of cylinder and sphere diameters). This extends previous computations into the range of structures which…
▽ More
We study the optimal packing of hard spheres in an infinitely long cylinder, using simulated annealing, and compare our results with the analogous problem of packing disks on the unrolled surface of a cylinder. The densest structures are described and tabulated in detail up to D/d=2.873 (ratio of cylinder and sphere diameters). This extends previous computations into the range of structures which include internal spheres that are not in contact with the cylinder.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2012; v1 submitted 15 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
Phyllotactic description of hard sphere packing in cylindrical channels
Authors:
Adil Mughal,
Ho Kei Chan,
Denis Weaire
Abstract:
We develop a simple analytical theory that relates dense sphere packings in a cylinder to corresponding disk packings on its surface. It applies for ratios R=D/d (where d and D are the diameters of the hard spheres and the bounding cylinder, respectively) up to R=1+1/sin(pi/5). Within this range the densest packings are such that all spheres are in contact with the cylindrical boundary. The detail…
▽ More
We develop a simple analytical theory that relates dense sphere packings in a cylinder to corresponding disk packings on its surface. It applies for ratios R=D/d (where d and D are the diameters of the hard spheres and the bounding cylinder, respectively) up to R=1+1/sin(pi/5). Within this range the densest packings are such that all spheres are in contact with the cylindrical boundary. The detailed results elucidate extensive numerical simulations by ourselves and others by identifying the nature of all competing phases.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2011; v1 submitted 16 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Shear localisation with 2D Viscous Froth and its relation to the Continuum Model
Authors:
Joseph D. Barry,
Denis Weaire,
Stefan Hutzler
Abstract:
Simulations of monodisperse and polydisperse ($μ_2(A)=0.13\pm0.002$) 2D foam samples undergoing simple shear are performed using the 2D Viscous Froth (VF) Model. These simulations clearly demonstrate shear localisation. The dependence of localisation length on the product $λV$ (shearing velocity $V$ times external wall friction coefficient $λ$) is examined and is shown to agree qualitatively wit…
▽ More
Simulations of monodisperse and polydisperse ($μ_2(A)=0.13\pm0.002$) 2D foam samples undergoing simple shear are performed using the 2D Viscous Froth (VF) Model. These simulations clearly demonstrate shear localisation. The dependence of localisation length on the product $λV$ (shearing velocity $V$ times external wall friction coefficient $λ$) is examined and is shown to agree qualitatively with other published experimental data. A wide range of localisation lengths is found at low $λV$, an effect which is attributed to the existence of distinct yield and limit stresses. The general Continuum Model is extended to incorporate such an effect and its parameters are subsequently related to those of the VF Model. A Herschel-Bulkley exponent of $a=0.3$ is shown to accurately describe the observed behaviour. The localisation length is found to be independent of $λV$ for monodisperse foam samples.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2010; v1 submitted 6 January, 2010;
originally announced January 2010.
-
The origin of the strain-rate discontinuity in 2D foam rheometry with circular geometry
Authors:
Denis Weaire,
Robert J. Clancy,
Stefan Hutzler
Abstract:
The observed discontinuity in strain-rate for a two-dimensional foam undergoing shear in a (circular) Couette system is explained in terms of the continuum (Herschel-Bulkley) model. It is attributed to the finite difference between yield and limit stress.
The observed discontinuity in strain-rate for a two-dimensional foam undergoing shear in a (circular) Couette system is explained in terms of the continuum (Herschel-Bulkley) model. It is attributed to the finite difference between yield and limit stress.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
-
Curvature in conformal mappings of 2D lattices and foam structure
Authors:
A. Mughal,
D. Weaire
Abstract:
The elegant properties of conformal mappings, when applied to two dimensional (2D) lattices, find interesting applications in 2D foams and other cellular or close packed structures. In particular the 2D honeycomb (whose dual is the triangular lattice) may be transformed into various conformal patterns, which compare approximately to experimentally realisable 2D foams. We review and extend the math…
▽ More
The elegant properties of conformal mappings, when applied to two dimensional (2D) lattices, find interesting applications in 2D foams and other cellular or close packed structures. In particular the 2D honeycomb (whose dual is the triangular lattice) may be transformed into various conformal patterns, which compare approximately to experimentally realisable 2D foams. We review and extend the mathematical analysis of such transformations, with several illustrative examples, and an account is given of the related work in energy minimisation problems. New results are adduced for the local curvature generated by the transformation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2011; v1 submitted 16 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Two dimensional foam rheology with viscous drag
Authors:
E. Janiaud,
D. Weaire,
S. Hutzler
Abstract:
We formulate and apply a continuum model that incorporates elasticity, yield stress, plasticity and viscous drag. It is motivated by the two-dimensional foam rheology experiments of Debregeas et al. [G. Debregeas, H. Tabuteau, and J.-M. di Meglio, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 178305 (2001)] and Wang et al [Y. Wang, K. Krishan, and M. Dennin, Phys. Rev. E 73, 031401 (2006)], and is successful in exhibiti…
▽ More
We formulate and apply a continuum model that incorporates elasticity, yield stress, plasticity and viscous drag. It is motivated by the two-dimensional foam rheology experiments of Debregeas et al. [G. Debregeas, H. Tabuteau, and J.-M. di Meglio, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 178305 (2001)] and Wang et al [Y. Wang, K. Krishan, and M. Dennin, Phys. Rev. E 73, 031401 (2006)], and is successful in exhibiting their principal features an exponentially decaying velocity profile and strain localisation. Transient effects are also identified.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2006; v1 submitted 1 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
-
Optimizing transport in a homogeneous network
Authors:
Marc Durand,
Denis Weaire
Abstract:
Many situations in physics, biology, and engineering consist of the transport of some physical quantity through a network of narrow channels. The ability of a network to transport such a quantity in every direction can be described by the average conductivity associated with. When the flow through each channel is conserved and derives from a potential function, we show that there exist an upper…
▽ More
Many situations in physics, biology, and engineering consist of the transport of some physical quantity through a network of narrow channels. The ability of a network to transport such a quantity in every direction can be described by the average conductivity associated with. When the flow through each channel is conserved and derives from a potential function, we show that there exist an upper bound of the average conductivity, and explicitly give the expression for this upper bound as a function of the channel permeability and channel length distributions. Moreover, we express the necessary and sufficient conditions on the network structure to maximize the average conductivity. These conditions are found to be independent of the connectivity of the vertices.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2005;
originally announced April 2005.
