-
Aqueous Laponite Dispersions are Attractive Gels, Not Repulsive Wigner Glasses: A Critical Commentary
Authors:
Yogesh M Joshi,
Shrajesh Patel,
Khushboo Suman
Abstract:
An aqueous dispersion of Laponite has been studied in the literature for over the past three decades. Typically, the aqueous dispersion of Laponite undergoes incessant evolution of its microstructure, wherein its elastic modulus and the mean relaxation time show a continuous increase as a function of time. A considerable amount of discussion has revolved around the nature of this dispersion, speci…
▽ More
An aqueous dispersion of Laponite has been studied in the literature for over the past three decades. Typically, the aqueous dispersion of Laponite undergoes incessant evolution of its microstructure, wherein its elastic modulus and the mean relaxation time show a continuous increase as a function of time. A considerable amount of discussion has revolved around the nature of this dispersion, specifically whether it can be classified as a repulsive Wigner glass state, characterized by disconnected Laponite particles stabilized by electrostatic repulsions, or an attractive gel state, in which the particles form a percolated space-spanning network. The proponents of the Wigner glass state also conjecture that this system experiences a glass-glass transition after a period of two days has elapsed since its preparation. In this commentary, we explore this topic from a rheological point of view analyzing the published literature and performing new experiments. Aided by additional evidence from the literature, we propose that rheological behavior overwhelmingly suggests that an aqueous dispersion of Laponite undergoes sol - attractive gel transition and remains in the attractive gel state over at least up to 7 days without undergoing any additional transition. Importantly, rheology, despite being a macroscopic tool governed by principles of mechanics, offers profound insight into the microstructure of this particular system. The corresponding analysis conclusively determines the state of an aqueous dispersion of Laponite to be an attractive gel.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Large Amplitude Oscillatory Shear Study of a Colloidal Gel at the Critical State
Authors:
Khushboo Suman,
Sachin Shanbhag,
Yogesh M. Joshi
Abstract:
We investigate the nonlinear viscoelastic behavior of a colloidal dispersion at the critical gel state using large amplitude oscillatory shear (LAOS) rheology. The colloidal gel at the critical point is subjected to oscillatory shear flow with increasing strain amplitude at different frequencies. We observe that the first harmonic of the elastic and viscous moduli exhibits a monotonic decrease as…
▽ More
We investigate the nonlinear viscoelastic behavior of a colloidal dispersion at the critical gel state using large amplitude oscillatory shear (LAOS) rheology. The colloidal gel at the critical point is subjected to oscillatory shear flow with increasing strain amplitude at different frequencies. We observe that the first harmonic of the elastic and viscous moduli exhibits a monotonic decrease as the material undergoes a linear to nonlinear transition. We analyze the stress waveform across this transition and obtain the nonlinear moduli and viscosity as a function of frequency and strain amplitude. The analysis of the nonlinear moduli and viscosities suggests intracycle strain stiffening and intracycle shear thinning in the colloidal dispersion. Based on the insights obtained from the nonlinear analysis, we propose a potential scenario of the microstructural changes occurring in the nonlinear region. We also develop an integral model using the time-strain separable K-BKZ constitutive equation with a power-law relaxation modulus and damping function obtained from experiments. At low strain amplitudes, this model compares well with experimental data at all frequencies. However, a stronger damping function, which can be efficiently inferred using a spectral method, is required to obtain quantitative fits across the entire range of strain amplitudes and the explored frequencies.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Gel-Sol Transition of Thermoresponsive Poly(vinyl alcohol) Solution: Validation of the Universal Critical Scaling Relations
Authors:
Tulika Bhattacharyya,
Khushboo Suman,
Yogesh M. Joshi
Abstract:
While undergoing gelation transition, a material passes through a distinctive state called the critical gel state. In the neighborhood of this critical gel state, how viscosity, equilibrium modulus, and relaxation times evolve are correlated by scaling relations, and their universality has been validated for materials undergoing the sol to gel transition. In this work, we extend this approach for…
▽ More
While undergoing gelation transition, a material passes through a distinctive state called the critical gel state. In the neighborhood of this critical gel state, how viscosity, equilibrium modulus, and relaxation times evolve are correlated by scaling relations, and their universality has been validated for materials undergoing the sol to gel transition. In this work, we extend this approach for the gel to sol transition of a thermoresponsive polymeric system of aqueous Poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVOH) gel that passes through the critical state upon increasing temperature. We observe that, in the neighborhood of the critical gel state, the equilibrium modulus and viscosity demonstrate a power law dependence on the relative distance from the critical state in terms of normalized temperature. Furthermore, the relaxation times in the gel and the sol state shows symmetric power law divergence near the critical state. The corresponding critical power law exponents and the dynamic critical exponents computed at the critical gel to sol transition state validate the scaling and hyperscaling relations originally proposed for the critical sol to gel transition very well. Remarkably, the dependence of complex viscosity on frequency at different temperatures shows a comprehensive mastercurve irrespective of the temperature ramp rate independently in the gel and the sol state. This observation demonstrates how the shape of relaxation time spectrum is independent of both the temperature as well as the ramp rate. Since sol to gel as well as the gel to sol transitions are opposite to each other, the applicability of the scaling relations validated in this work suggests broader symmetry associated with how the structure evolves around the critical state irrespective of the direction.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Effect of sodium pyrophosphate and understanding microstructure of aqueous LAPONITE(R) dispersion using dissolution study
Authors:
Khushboo Suman,
Mohit Mittal,
Yogesh M Joshi
Abstract:
We investigate physical origin of ergodicity breaking in an aqueous colloidal dispersion of synthetic hectorite clay, LAPONITE(R), by performing dissolution and rheological experiments with monovalent salt and tetrasodium pyrophosphate solution. We also study the effect of interface, nitrogen and paraffin oil on the same. Dissolution experiments carried out for dispersions with both the interfaces…
▽ More
We investigate physical origin of ergodicity breaking in an aqueous colloidal dispersion of synthetic hectorite clay, LAPONITE(R), by performing dissolution and rheological experiments with monovalent salt and tetrasodium pyrophosphate solution. We also study the effect of interface, nitrogen and paraffin oil on the same. Dissolution experiments carried out for dispersions with both the interfaces show similar results. However, for samples with nitrogen interface, all the effects are observed to get expedited in time compared to paraffin oil interface. When kept in contact with water, 1.5 wt. % and 2.8 wt. % colloidal dispersion at pH 10 swell at small ages, while do not swell at large ages. The solution of tetrasodium pyrophosphate, interestingly, dissolves the entire colloidal dispersion samples with pH 10 irrespective of the clay concentration. Experiments carried out on colloidal dispersions prepared in water having pH 13 demonstrate no effect of water as well as sodium pyrophosphate solution on the same suggesting a possibility of the presence of negative charge on edge at that pH. We believe that all the behaviors observed for samples at pH 10 can be explained by an attractive gel microstructure formed by edge-to-face contact. Furthermore, the absence of swelling in old colloidal dispersion at pH 10 and dissolution of the same by sodium pyrophosphate solution cannot be explained by merely repulsive interactions. This behavior suggests that attractive interactions play an important role in causing ergodicity breaking in the colloidal dispersions at pH 10 at all the ages irrespective of the clay concentration. We substantiate the presence of fractal network structure formed by interparticle edge-face association using rheological tools and cryo-TEM imaging. We also conduct a comprehensive study of the effect of sodium pyrophosphate in the sol-gel transition of LAPONITE(R) dispersion.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
On the universality of the critical scaling exponents during sol-gel transition
Authors:
Khushboo Suman,
Yogesh M. Joshi
Abstract:
The evolution of viscoelastic properties near the sol-gel transition is studied by performing oscillatory rheological measurements on two different types of systems: a colloidal dispersion and a thermo-responsive polymer solution under isothermal and non-isothermal conditions. While undergoing sol-gel transition, both the systems pass through a critical point. An approach to the critical point is…
▽ More
The evolution of viscoelastic properties near the sol-gel transition is studied by performing oscillatory rheological measurements on two different types of systems: a colloidal dispersion and a thermo-responsive polymer solution under isothermal and non-isothermal conditions. While undergoing sol-gel transition, both the systems pass through a critical point. An approach to the critical point is characterized in terms of divergence of zero shear viscosity and the subsequent appearance of the low frequency modulus. In the vicinity of the critical gel state, both the viscosity and the modulus show a power-law dependence on relative distance from the critical point. Interestingly, the longest relaxation time has been observed to diverge symmetrically on both the sides of the critical point and also shows a power-law dependence on relative distance from the critical point. The critical (power-law) exponents of the zero-shear viscosity and modulus are observed to be related to the exponents of the longest relaxation time by the hyper scaling laws. The dynamic critical exponent has also been calculated from the growth of the dynamic moduli. Remarkably, the critical relaxation exponent and dynamic critical exponent predicted from the scaling laws precisely agree with the experimental values from the isothermal as well as non-isothermal experiments. The associated critical exponents show remarkable internal consistency and universality for different kinds of systems undergoing the sol-gel transition.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Analyzing Onset of Nonlinearity of a Colloidal Gel at the Critical Point
Authors:
Khushboo Suman,
Yogesh M. Joshi
Abstract:
In this work we study onset of nonlinear rheological behavior of a colloidal dispersion of a synthetic hectorite clay, Laponite, at the critical gel state while undergoing sol-gel transition. When subjected to step strain in the nonlinear regime, the relaxation modulus shifts vertically to the lower values such that the deviation from linearity can be accommodated using a strain dependent damping…
▽ More
In this work we study onset of nonlinear rheological behavior of a colloidal dispersion of a synthetic hectorite clay, Laponite, at the critical gel state while undergoing sol-gel transition. When subjected to step strain in the nonlinear regime, the relaxation modulus shifts vertically to the lower values such that the deviation from linearity can be accommodated using a strain dependent damping function. We also perform creep-recovery and start-up shear experiments on the studied colloidal dispersion at the critical gel state and monitor deviation in response as the flow becomes nonlinear. A quasi-linear integral model is developed with the time-strain separable relaxation modulus to account for the effect of nonlinear deformation. Remarkably, the proposed model predicts the deviation from linearity in the creep-recovery and start-up shear experiments very well leading to a simple formulation to analyze the onset of nonlinear rheological behavior in the critical gels. We also analyze the energy dissipation during the nonlinear deformation and validate the Bailey criterion using the developed viscoelastic framework.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
In Situ Ion Induced Gelation of Colloidal Dispersion of Laponite: Relating Microscopic Interactions to Macroscopic Behavior
Authors:
Rashmi P. Mohanty,
Khushboo Suman,
Yogesh M. Joshi
Abstract:
Aqueous dispersion of Laponite, when exposed to carbon dioxide environment leads to in situ inducement of magnesium and lithium ions, which is, however absent when dispersion is exposed to air. Consequently, in the rheological experiments, Laponite dispersion preserved under carbon dioxide shows more spectacular enhancement in the elastic and viscous moduli as a function of time compared to that e…
▽ More
Aqueous dispersion of Laponite, when exposed to carbon dioxide environment leads to in situ inducement of magnesium and lithium ions, which is, however absent when dispersion is exposed to air. Consequently, in the rheological experiments, Laponite dispersion preserved under carbon dioxide shows more spectacular enhancement in the elastic and viscous moduli as a function of time compared to that exposed to air. By measuring concentration of all the ions present in a dispersion as well as change in pH, the evolving inter-particle interactions among the Laponite particles is estimated. DLVO analysis of a limiting case is performed, wherein two particles approach each other in a parallel fashion a situation with maximum repulsive interactions. Interestingly it is observed that DLVO analysis explains the qualitative details of an evolution of elastic and viscous moduli remarkably well thereby successfully relating the macroscopic phenomena to the microscopic interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Microstructure and Soft Glassy Dynamics of Aqueous Laponite Dispersion
Authors:
Khushboo Suman,
Yogesh M. Joshi
Abstract:
Synthetic hectorite clay Laponite RD/XLG is composed of disk-shaped nanoparticles that acquire dissimilar charges when suspended in an aqueous media. Owing to their property to spontaneously self-assemble, Laponite is used as a rheology modifier in a variety of commercial water-based products. Particularly, aqueous dispersion of Laponite undergoes liquid - to - solid transition at about 1 volume %…
▽ More
Synthetic hectorite clay Laponite RD/XLG is composed of disk-shaped nanoparticles that acquire dissimilar charges when suspended in an aqueous media. Owing to their property to spontaneously self-assemble, Laponite is used as a rheology modifier in a variety of commercial water-based products. Particularly, aqueous dispersion of Laponite undergoes liquid - to - solid transition at about 1 volume % concentration. The evolution of the physical properties as dispersion transforms to solid state is reminiscent of physical aging in molecular as well as colloidal glasses. The corresponding soft glassy dynamics of an aqueous Laponite dispersion, including the rheological behavior, has been extensively studied in the literature. In this feature article we take an overview of recent advances in understanding soft glassy dynamics and various efforts taken to understand the peculiar rheological behaviors. Furthermore, the continuously developing microstructure that is responsible for eventual formation of soft solid state that supports its own weight against gravity has also been a topic of intense debate and discussion. Particularly extensive experimental and theoretical studies lead to two types of microstructures for this system: an attractive gel-like or repulsive glass like. We carefully examine and critically analyze the literature and propose a state diagram that suggests aqueous Laponite dispersion to be present in an attractive gel state.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
