-
Is Lindblad for me?
Authors:
Martino Stefanini,
Aleksandra A. Ziolkowska,
Dmitry Budker,
Ulrich Poschinger,
Ferdinand Schmidt-Kaler,
Antoine Browaeys,
Atac Imamoglu,
Darrick Chang,
Jamir Marino
Abstract:
The Lindblad master equation is a foundational tool for modeling the dynamics of open quantum systems. As its use has extended far beyond its original domain, the boundaries of its validity have grown opaque. In particular, the rise of new research areas including open quantum many-body systems, non-equilibrium condensed matter, and the possibility to test its limits in driven-open quantum simulat…
▽ More
The Lindblad master equation is a foundational tool for modeling the dynamics of open quantum systems. As its use has extended far beyond its original domain, the boundaries of its validity have grown opaque. In particular, the rise of new research areas including open quantum many-body systems, non-equilibrium condensed matter, and the possibility to test its limits in driven-open quantum simulators, call for a critical revision of its regimes of applicability. In this pedagogical review, we re-examine the folklore surrounding its three standard approximations (Born, Markov, and Rotating Wave Approximation), as we build our narrative by employing a series of examples and case studies accessible to any reader with a solid background on the fundamentals of quantum mechanics. As a synthesis of our work, we offer a checklist that contrasts common lore with refined expectations, offering a practical guideline for assessing the breakdown of the Lindblad framework in the problem at hand.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Variational approach to the dynamics of dissipative quantum impurity models
Authors:
Yi-Fan Qu,
Martino Stefanini,
Tao Shi,
Tilman Esslinger,
Sarang Gopalakrishnan,
Jamir Marino,
Eugene Demler
Abstract:
Recent experiments with quantum simulators using ultracold atoms and superconducting qubits have demonstrated the potential of controlled dissipation as a versatile tool for realizing correlated many-body states. However, determining the dynamics of dissipative quantum many-body systems remains a significant analytical and numerical challenge. In this work, we focus on a dissipative impurity probl…
▽ More
Recent experiments with quantum simulators using ultracold atoms and superconducting qubits have demonstrated the potential of controlled dissipation as a versatile tool for realizing correlated many-body states. However, determining the dynamics of dissipative quantum many-body systems remains a significant analytical and numerical challenge. In this work, we focus on a dissipative impurity problem as a testbed for new methodological developments. We introduce an efficient non-perturbative framework that combines the superposition of Gaussian states (SGS) variational ansatz with the quantum trajectory approach to simulate open systems featuring a dissipative impurity. Applying this method to a spinful impurity subject to two-body losses and embedded in a bath of noninteracting fermions, we explore the full crossover from weak to strong dissipation regimes. The non-perturbative nature of the SGS ansatz allows us to thoroughly examine this crossover, providing comprehensive insights into the system's behavior. In the strong dissipation regime, our approach reproduces the finding that localized two-body losses can induce the Kondo effect [arXiv:2406.03527], characterized by a slowdown of spin relaxation and an enhancement of charge conductance. Furthermore, we reveal an exotic ``negative conductance" phenomenon at zero potential bias -- a counter-intuitive single-body effect resulting from intermediate dissipation and finite bandwidth. Finally, we investigate the formation of ferromagnetic domains and propose an extension to realize a higher-spin Kondo model using localized dissipation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2025; v1 submitted 20 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Dissipative realization of Kondo models
Authors:
Martino Stefanini,
Yi-Fan Qu,
Tilman Esslinger,
Sarang Gopalakrishnan,
Eugene Demler,
Jamir Marino
Abstract:
We demonstrate that the Kondo effect can be induced through non-linear dissipative channels, without requiring any coherent interaction on the impurity site. Specifically, we consider a reservoir of noninteracting fermions that can hop on a few impurity sites that are subjected to strong two-body losses. In the simplest case of a single lossy site, we recover the Anderson impurity model in the reg…
▽ More
We demonstrate that the Kondo effect can be induced through non-linear dissipative channels, without requiring any coherent interaction on the impurity site. Specifically, we consider a reservoir of noninteracting fermions that can hop on a few impurity sites that are subjected to strong two-body losses. In the simplest case of a single lossy site, we recover the Anderson impurity model in the regime of infinite repulsion, with a small residual dissipation as a perturbation. While the Anderson model gives rise to the Kondo effect, this residual dissipation competes with it, offering an instance of a nonlinear dissipative impurity where the interplay between coherent and incoherent dynamics emerges from the same underlying physical process. We further outline how this dissipative engineering scheme can be extended to two or more lossy sites, realizing generalizations of the Kondo model with spin 1 or higher. Our results suggest alternative implementations of Kondo models using ultracold atoms in transport experiments, where localized dissipation can be naturally introduced, and the Kondo effect observed through conductance measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2025; v1 submitted 5 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Orthogonality catastrophe beyond bosonization from post-selection
Authors:
Martino Stefanini,
Jamir Marino
Abstract:
We show that the dynamics induced by post-selected measurements can serve as a controlled route to access physical processes beyond the boundaries of Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid physics. We consider a one-dimensional fermionic wire whose dynamics results from a sequence of weak measurements of the fermionic density at a given site, interspersed with unitary hopping dynamics. This realizes a non-Herm…
▽ More
We show that the dynamics induced by post-selected measurements can serve as a controlled route to access physical processes beyond the boundaries of Tomonaga-Luttinger liquid physics. We consider a one-dimensional fermionic wire whose dynamics results from a sequence of weak measurements of the fermionic density at a given site, interspersed with unitary hopping dynamics. This realizes a non-Hermitian variant of the celebrated instance of a local scatterer in a fermionic system and its ensuing orthogonality catastrophe. We observe a distinct crossover in the system's time evolution as a function of the fermion density. In the high-density regime, reminiscent of the Hermitian case, a bosonized version of the model properly describes the dynamics while, as we delve into the low-density regime, the validity of bosonization breaks down, giving rise to irreversible behavior. Notably, this crossover from reversible to irreversible dynamics is non-perturbative in the measurement rate and can manifest itself even with relatively shallow measurement rates, provided that the system's density remains below the crossover threshold. Our results render a conceptually transparent model for exploring non-perturbative effects beyond bosonization, which could be used as a stepping stone to explore novel routes for the control of non-linear dynamics in low-dimensional quantum systems.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2025; v1 submitted 29 September, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
A full view on the dynamics of an impurity coupled to two one-dimensional fermionic baths
Authors:
Martino Stefanini,
Massimo Capone,
Alessandro Silva
Abstract:
We consider a model for the motion of an impurity interacting with two parallel, one-dimensional (bosonized) fermionic baths. The impurity is able to move along any of the baths, and to jump from one to the other. We provide a perturbative expression for the state evolution of the system when the impurity is injected in one of the baths, with a given wave packet. The nontrivial choice of the unper…
▽ More
We consider a model for the motion of an impurity interacting with two parallel, one-dimensional (bosonized) fermionic baths. The impurity is able to move along any of the baths, and to jump from one to the other. We provide a perturbative expression for the state evolution of the system when the impurity is injected in one of the baths, with a given wave packet. The nontrivial choice of the unperturbed dynamics makes the approximation formally infinite-order in the impurity-bath coupling, allowing us to reproduce the orthogonality catastrophe. We employ the result for the state evolution to observe the dynamics of the impurity and its effect on the baths, in particular in the case when the wave packet is Gaussian. We observe and characterize the propagation of the impurity along the baths and the hopping between them. We also analyze the dynamics of the bath density and momentum density (i.e. the particle current), and show that fits an intuitive semi-classical interpretation. We also quantify the correlation that is established between the baths by calculating the inter-bath, equal-time spatial correlation functions of both bath density and momentum, finding a complex pattern. We show that this pattern contains information on both the impurity motion and on the baths themselves, and that these can be unveiled by taking appropriate "slices" of the time evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2022; v1 submitted 27 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Motion of an impurity in a two-leg ladder
Authors:
Martino Stefanini,
Massimo Capone,
Alessandro Silva
Abstract:
We study the motion of an impurity in a two-leg ladder interacting with two fermionic baths along each leg, a simple model bridging cold atom quantum simulators with an idealised description of the basic transport processes in a layered heterostructure. Using the linked-cluster expansion we obtain exact analytical results for the single-particle Green's function and find that the long-time behavio…
▽ More
We study the motion of an impurity in a two-leg ladder interacting with two fermionic baths along each leg, a simple model bridging cold atom quantum simulators with an idealised description of the basic transport processes in a layered heterostructure. Using the linked-cluster expansion we obtain exact analytical results for the single-particle Green's function and find that the long-time behaviour is dominated by an intrinsic orthogonality catastrophe associated to the motion of the impurity in each one-dimensional chain. We explore both the case of two identical legs as well as the case where the legs are characterised by different interaction strengths: in the latter case we observe a subleading correction which can be relevant for intermediate-time transport at an interface between different materials. In all the cases we do not find significant differences between the intra- and inter-leg Green's functions in the long-time limit.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Amplified biochemical oscillations in cellular systems
Authors:
A. J. McKane,
J. D. Nagy,
T. J. Newman,
M. O. Stefanini
Abstract:
We describe a mechanism for pronounced biochemical oscillations, relevant to microscopic systems, such as the intracellular environment. This mechanism operates for reaction schemes which, when modeled using deterministic rate equations, fail to exhibit oscillations for any values of rate constants. The mechanism relies on amplification of the underlying stochasticity of reaction kinetics within…
▽ More
We describe a mechanism for pronounced biochemical oscillations, relevant to microscopic systems, such as the intracellular environment. This mechanism operates for reaction schemes which, when modeled using deterministic rate equations, fail to exhibit oscillations for any values of rate constants. The mechanism relies on amplification of the underlying stochasticity of reaction kinetics within a narrow window of frequencies. This amplification allows fluctuations to beat the central limit theorem, having a dominant effect even though the number of molecules in the system is relatively large. The mechanism is quantitatively studied within simple models of self-regulatory gene expression, and glycolytic oscillations.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2006;
originally announced April 2006.
