-
Measuring collective diffusion properties by counting particles in boxes
Authors:
Adam Carter,
Eleanor K. R. Mackay,
Brennan Sprinkle,
Alice L. Thorneywork,
Sophie Marbach
Abstract:
The collective diffusion coefficient $D_\mathrm{coll}$ is a key quantity for describing the macroscopic transport properties of soft matter systems. However, measuring $D_\mathrm{coll}$ is a fundamental experimental and numerical challenge, as it either relies on nonequilibrium techniques that are hard to interpret or, at equilibrium, on Fourier-based approaches which are fraught with difficulties…
▽ More
The collective diffusion coefficient $D_\mathrm{coll}$ is a key quantity for describing the macroscopic transport properties of soft matter systems. However, measuring $D_\mathrm{coll}$ is a fundamental experimental and numerical challenge, as it either relies on nonequilibrium techniques that are hard to interpret or, at equilibrium, on Fourier-based approaches which are fraught with difficulties associated with Fourier transforms. In this work, we investigate the equilibrium diffusive dynamics of a 2D colloidal suspension experimentally and numerically. We use a "Countoscope" technique, which analyses the statistics of particle number counts $N(t)$ in virtual observation boxes of a series of microscopy images at equilibrium, to measure $D_\mathrm{coll}$ for the first time. We validate our results against Fourier-based approaches and establish best practices for measuring $D_\mathrm{coll}$ using fluctuating counts. We show that Fourier techniques yield inaccurate long-range collective measurements because of the non-periodic nature of an experimental image, yet counting exploits this property by using finite observation windows. Finally, we discuss the potential of our method to advance our understanding of collective properties in suspensions, particularly the role of hydrodynamic interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2025; v1 submitted 18 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
The Countoscope: Measuring Self and Collective Dynamics without Trajectories
Authors:
Eleanor K. R. Mackay,
Sophie Marbach,
Brennan Sprinkle,
Alice L. Thorneywork
Abstract:
Driven by physical questions pertaining to quantifying particle dynamics, microscopy can now resolve complex systems at the single particle level, from cellular organisms to individual ions. Yet, available analysis techniques face challenges reconstructing trajectories in dense and heterogeneous systems where accurately labelling particles is difficult. Furthermore, the inescapable finite field of…
▽ More
Driven by physical questions pertaining to quantifying particle dynamics, microscopy can now resolve complex systems at the single particle level, from cellular organisms to individual ions. Yet, available analysis techniques face challenges reconstructing trajectories in dense and heterogeneous systems where accurately labelling particles is difficult. Furthermore, the inescapable finite field of view of experiments hinders the measurement of collective effects. Inspired by Smoluchowski, we introduce a broadly applicable analysis technique that probes dynamics of interacting particle suspensions based on a remarkably simple principle: counting particles in finite observation boxes. Using colloidal experiments, advanced simulations and theory, we first demonstrate that statistical properties of fluctuating counts can be used to determine self-diffusion coefficients, so alleviating the hurdles associated with trajectory reconstruction. We also provide a recipe for practically extracting the diffusion coefficient from experimental data at variable particle densities, which is sensitive to steric and hydrodynamic interactions. Remarkably, by increasing the observation box size, counting naturally enables the study of collective dynamics in dense suspensions. Using our novel analysis of particle counts, we uncover a surprising enhancement of collective behaviour, as well as a new length scale associated with hyperuniform-like structure. Our counting framework, the Countoscope, thus enables efficient measurements of self and collective dynamics in dense suspensions and opens the way to quantifying dynamics and identifying novel physical mechanisms in diverse complex systems where single particles can be resolved.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2024; v1 submitted 1 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Sedimentation of a Colloidal Monolayer Down an Inclined Plane
Authors:
Brennan Sprinkle,
Sam Wilken,
Shake Karapetyan,
Michio Tanaka,
Zhe Chen,
Joseph R. Cruise,
Blaise Delmotte,
Michelle M. Driscoll,
Paul Chaikin,
Aleksandar Donev
Abstract:
We study the driven collective dynamics of a colloidal monolayer sedimentating down an inclined plane. The action of the gravity force parallel to the bottom wall creates a flow around each colloid, and the hydrodynamic interactions among the colloids accelerate the sedimentation as the local density increases. This leads to the creation of a universal "triangular" inhomogeneous density profile, w…
▽ More
We study the driven collective dynamics of a colloidal monolayer sedimentating down an inclined plane. The action of the gravity force parallel to the bottom wall creates a flow around each colloid, and the hydrodynamic interactions among the colloids accelerate the sedimentation as the local density increases. This leads to the creation of a universal "triangular" inhomogeneous density profile, with a traveling density shock at the leading front moving in the downhill direction. Unlike density shocks in a colloidal monolayer driven by applied torques rather than forces [Phys. Rev. Fluids, 2(9):092301, 2017], the density front during sedimentation remains stable over long periods of time even though it develops a roughness on the order of tens of particle diameters. Through experimental measurements and particle-based computer simulations, we find that the Burgers equation can model the density profile along the sedimentation direction as a function of time remarkably well, with a modest improvement if the nonlinear conservation law accounts for the sub-linear dependence of the collective sedimentation velocity on density.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Driven dynamics in dense suspensions of microrollers
Authors:
Brennan Sprinkle,
Ernest B. van der Wee,
Yixiang Luo,
Michelle Driscoll,
Aleksandar Donev
Abstract:
We perform detailed computational and experimental measurements of the driven dynamics of a dense, uniform suspension of sedimented microrollers driven by a magnetic field rotating around an axis parallel to the floor. We develop a lubrication-corrected Brownian Dynamics method for dense suspensions of driven colloids sedimented above a bottom wall. The numerical method adds lubrication friction b…
▽ More
We perform detailed computational and experimental measurements of the driven dynamics of a dense, uniform suspension of sedimented microrollers driven by a magnetic field rotating around an axis parallel to the floor. We develop a lubrication-corrected Brownian Dynamics method for dense suspensions of driven colloids sedimented above a bottom wall. The numerical method adds lubrication friction between nearby pairs of particles, as well as particles and the bottom wall, to a minimally-resolved model of the far-field hydrodynamic interactions. Our experiments combine fluorescent labeling with particle tracking to trace the trajectories of individual particles in a dense suspension, and to measure their propulsion velocities. Previous computational studies [B. Sprinkle et al., J. Chem. Phys., 147, 244103, 2017] predicted that at sufficiently high densities a uniform suspension of microrollers separates into two layers, a slow monolayer right above the wall, and a fast layer on top of the bottom layer. Here we verify this prediction, showing good quantitative agreement between the bimodal distribution of particle velocities predicted by the lubrication-corrected Brownian Dynamics and those measured in the experiments. The computational method accurately predicts the rate at which particles are observed to switch between the slow and fast layers in the experiments. We also use our numerical method to demonstrate the important role that pairwise lubrication plays in motility-induced phase separation in dense monolayers of colloidal microrollers, as recently suggested for suspensions of Quincke rollers [D. Geyer et al., Physical Review X, 9(3), 031043, 2019].
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2020; v1 submitted 12 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Brownian Dynamics of Fully Confined Suspensions of Rigid Particles Without Green's Functions
Authors:
Brennan Sprinkle,
Aleksandar Donev,
Amneet Pal Singh Bhalla,
Neelesh Patankar
Abstract:
We introduce a Rigid-Body Fluctuating Immersed Boundary (RB-FIB) method to perform large-scale Brownian dynamics simulations of suspensions of rigid particles in fully confined domains, without any need to explicitly construct Green's functions or mobility operators. In the RB-FIB approach, discretized fluctuating Stokes equations are solved with prescribed boundary conditions in conjunction with…
▽ More
We introduce a Rigid-Body Fluctuating Immersed Boundary (RB-FIB) method to perform large-scale Brownian dynamics simulations of suspensions of rigid particles in fully confined domains, without any need to explicitly construct Green's functions or mobility operators. In the RB-FIB approach, discretized fluctuating Stokes equations are solved with prescribed boundary conditions in conjunction with a rigid-body immersed boundary method to discretize arbitrarily-shaped colloidal particles with no-slip or active-slip prescribed on their surface. We design a specialized Split--Euler--Maruyama temporal integrator that uses a combination of random finite differences to capture the stochastic drift appearing in the overdamped Langevin equation. The RB-FIB method presented in this work only solves mobility problems in each time step using a preconditioned iterative solver, and has a computational complexity that scales linearly in the number of particles and fluid grid cells. We demonstrate that the RB-FIB method correctly reproduces the Gibbs-Boltzmann equilibrium distribution, and use the method to examine the time correlation functions for two spheres tightly confined in a cuboid. We model a quasi--two-dimensional colloidal crystal confined in a narrow microchannel and hydrodynamically driven across a commensurate periodic substrate potential mimicking the effect of a corrugated wall. We observe partial and full depinning of the colloidal monolayer from the substrate potential above a certain wall speed, consistent with a transition from static to kinetic friction through propagating kink solitons. Unexpectedly, we find that particles nearest the boundaries of the domain are the first to be displaced, followed by particles in the middle of the domain.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Large Scale Brownian Dynamics of Confined Suspensions of Rigid Particles
Authors:
B. Sprinkle,
F. Balboa Usabiaga,
N. A. Patankar,
A. Donev
Abstract:
We introduce methods for large scale Brownian Dynamics (BD) simulation of many rigid particles of arbitrary shape suspended in a fluctuating fluid. Our method adds Brownian motion to the rigid multiblob method at a cost comparable to the cost of deterministic simulations. We demonstrate that we can efficiently generate deterministic and random displacements for many particles using preconditioned…
▽ More
We introduce methods for large scale Brownian Dynamics (BD) simulation of many rigid particles of arbitrary shape suspended in a fluctuating fluid. Our method adds Brownian motion to the rigid multiblob method at a cost comparable to the cost of deterministic simulations. We demonstrate that we can efficiently generate deterministic and random displacements for many particles using preconditioned Krylov iterative methods, if kernel methods to efficiently compute the action of the Rotne-Prager-Yamakawa (RPY) mobility matrix and it "square" root are available for the given boundary conditions. We address a major challenge in large-scale BD simulations, capturing the stochastic drift term that arises because of the configuration-dependent mobility. Unlike the widely-used Fixman midpoint scheme, our methods utilize random finite differences and do not require the solution of resistance problems or the computation of the action of the inverse square root of the RPY mobility matrix. We construct two temporal schemes which are viable for large scale simulations, an Euler-Maruyama traction scheme and a Trapezoidal Slip scheme, which minimize the number of mobility solves per time step while capturing the required stochastic drift terms. We validate and compare these schemes numerically by modeling suspensions of boomerang shaped particles sedimented near a bottom wall. Using the trapezoidal scheme, we investigate the steady-state active motion in a dense suspensions of confined microrollers, whose height above the wall is set by a combination of thermal noise and active flows. We find the existence of two populations of active particles, slower ones closer to the bottom and faster ones above them, and demonstrate that our method provides quantitative accuracy even with relatively coarse resolutions of the particle geometry.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2017; v1 submitted 7 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
