-
Capillary jet in a slab of foam
Authors:
Théophile Gaichies,
Bryan Giraud,
Anniina Salonen,
Arnaud Antkowiak,
Emmanuelle Rio
Abstract:
A capillary jet plunging into a quasi-2D slab of monodisperse foam of the same solution is studied experimentally. We show that the jet can have a drastic impact on the foam. At small speeds it inflates the channels separating the bubbles. At intermediate speeds, impact with channels creates very small bubbles. At higher speeds, the jet thins the foam films, which can result in bubble rupture. We…
▽ More
A capillary jet plunging into a quasi-2D slab of monodisperse foam of the same solution is studied experimentally. We show that the jet can have a drastic impact on the foam. At small speeds it inflates the channels separating the bubbles. At intermediate speeds, impact with channels creates very small bubbles. At higher speeds, the jet thins the foam films, which can result in bubble rupture. We study the mechanisms behind these processes using an elementary foam formed by three soap films in contact through a Plateau border. We obtain scaling laws, which transfer quantitatively from the elementary foam to the 2D foam.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Rheological response of soft Solid/Liquid Composites
Authors:
Elina Gilbert,
Christophe Poulard,
Anniina Salonen
Abstract:
Understanding a material's dissipative response is important for their use in many applications, such as adhesion. In dispersions the interplay between matrix and inclusions complicates any description. Fractional rheology is conveniently used to fit the storage and loss moduli of complex materials, although the physical picture is often elusive. We study the rheology of soft solid/liquid composit…
▽ More
Understanding a material's dissipative response is important for their use in many applications, such as adhesion. In dispersions the interplay between matrix and inclusions complicates any description. Fractional rheology is conveniently used to fit the storage and loss moduli of complex materials, although the physical picture is often elusive. We study the rheology of soft solid/liquid composites of liquid poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) droplets in a soft poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) matrix. We analyze the influence of the droplets through fractional rheology and a time-concentration superposition. Viscous dissipation increases proportionally with volume fraction, and we show that a simple, well-fitting model can induce misinterpretation of the physics in a complex material.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2025; v1 submitted 17 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Flat-cupped transition in freezing drop impacts
Authors:
Marion Berry,
Christophe Josserand,
Anniina Salonen,
François Boulogne
Abstract:
We present an experimental study on the freezing of alkane drops impacted on a liquid bath. More specifically, for drops of hexadecane and tetradecane on brine, we found a morphological transition of the solid between a flat disk and a cupped shape. We show that this transition depends mainly on melting temperature and thermal shock, and varies weakly with impact velocity. We observed that the imp…
▽ More
We present an experimental study on the freezing of alkane drops impacted on a liquid bath. More specifically, for drops of hexadecane and tetradecane on brine, we found a morphological transition of the solid between a flat disk and a cupped shape. We show that this transition depends mainly on melting temperature and thermal shock, and varies weakly with impact velocity. We observed that the impact dynamics does not depend on the thermal shock before the drop starts to solid ify, which allows a rationalization of the solid size by models established for impact without phase change. Finally, we show that the relevant timescale setting the onset of solidification is associated with the formation of a thin solid layer between the drop and the bath, a timescale much shorter than the total solidification time. These findings offer the possibility to collapse the data for both liquids in a single phase diagram.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Anomalous relaxation of coarsening foams with viscoelastic continuous phase
Authors:
Chiara Guidolin,
Emmanuelle Rio,
Roberto Cerbino,
Anniina Salonen,
Fabio Giavazzi
Abstract:
We investigate the ultraslow structural relaxation of ageing foams with rheologically-tunable continuous phases. We probe the bubble dynamics associated with pressure-driven foam coarsening using differential dynamic microscopy, which allows characterizing the sample dynamics in the reciprocal space with imaging experiments. Similar to other out-of-equilibrium jammed soft systems, these foams exhi…
▽ More
We investigate the ultraslow structural relaxation of ageing foams with rheologically-tunable continuous phases. We probe the bubble dynamics associated with pressure-driven foam coarsening using differential dynamic microscopy, which allows characterizing the sample dynamics in the reciprocal space with imaging experiments. Similar to other out-of-equilibrium jammed soft systems, these foams exhibit compressed exponential relaxations, with a ballistic-like linear dependency of the relaxation rate on the scattering wavevector. By tuning the rheology of the continuous phase we observe changes in the relaxation shape, where stiffer matrices yield larger compressing exponents. Our results corroborate recent real-space observations obtained with bubble tracking, providing a comprehensive overview of structural relaxation in these complex systems, both in direct and reciprocal space.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Matrix viscoelasticity decouples bubble growth and dynamics in coarsening foams
Authors:
Chiara Guidolin,
Emmanuelle Rio,
Roberto Cerbino,
Fabio Giavazzi,
Anniina Salonen
Abstract:
Pressure-driven coarsening triggers bubble rearrangements in liquid foams. Our experiments show that changing the continuous phase rheology can alter these internal bubble dynamics without influencing the coarsening kinetics. Through bubble tracking, we find that increasing the matrix yield stress permits bubble growth without stress relaxation via neighbor-switching events, promoting more spatial…
▽ More
Pressure-driven coarsening triggers bubble rearrangements in liquid foams. Our experiments show that changing the continuous phase rheology can alter these internal bubble dynamics without influencing the coarsening kinetics. Through bubble tracking, we find that increasing the matrix yield stress permits bubble growth without stress relaxation via neighbor-switching events, promoting more spatially homogeneous rearrangements and decoupling bubble growth from dynamics. This eventually leads to a structural change which directly impacts the foam mechanical and stability properties, essential for applications in various technological and industrial contexts.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Effective water/water contact angle at the base of an impinging jet
Authors:
Théophile Gaichies,
Arnaud Antkowiak,
Anniiina Salonen,
Emmanuelle Rio
Abstract:
The base of a jet impinging on an ultrapure water bath is studied experimentally. At the impact point, a train of capillary waves develops along the jet. By performing Particle Tracking Velocity measurements, we show that there is a boundary layer separation between the jet and the meniscus. We thus describe the shape of this meniscus with a hydrostatic model. A striking observation is the existen…
▽ More
The base of a jet impinging on an ultrapure water bath is studied experimentally. At the impact point, a train of capillary waves develops along the jet. By performing Particle Tracking Velocity measurements, we show that there is a boundary layer separation between the jet and the meniscus. We thus describe the shape of this meniscus with a hydrostatic model. A striking observation is the existence of an effective non-zero water/water contact angle between the jet and the meniscus. The rationalization of this finite contact angle requires a full description of the shape of the interface. By doing an analytical matching between the meniscus and the jet, we show that the capillary waves can be considered as reflected waves present to ensure pressure continuity. It is finally shown that the value of the apparent contact angle is fixed by energy minimization, with an excellent agreement between prediction and experiment for small jets.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Interface-templated crystal growth in sodium dodecyl sulfate solutions with NaCl
Authors:
Anna Kharlamova,
François Boulogne,
Philippe Fontaine,
Stéphan Rouzière,
Arnaud Hemmerle,
Michel Goldmann,
Anniina Salonen
Abstract:
Many ionic surfactants, such as sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) crystallize out of solution if the temperature falls below the crystallization boundary. The crystallization temperature is impacted by solution properties, and can be decreased with the addition of salt. We have studied SDS crystallization a t the liquid/vapor interfaces from solutions at high ionic strength (sodium chloride). We show…
▽ More
Many ionic surfactants, such as sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) crystallize out of solution if the temperature falls below the crystallization boundary. The crystallization temperature is impacted by solution properties, and can be decreased with the addition of salt. We have studied SDS crystallization a t the liquid/vapor interfaces from solutions at high ionic strength (sodium chloride). We show that the surfactant crystals at the surface grow from adsorbed SDS molecules, as evidenced by the preferential orientation of the crystals identified using grazing incidence X-ray diffraction. We find a unique timescale f or the crystal growth from the evolution of structure, surface tension, and visual inspection, which can be controlled through varying the SDS or NaCl concentrations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2023; v1 submitted 6 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Hierarchical bubble size distributions in coarsening wet liquid foams
Authors:
Nicolo Galvani,
Marina Pasquet,
Arnab Mukherjee,
Alice Requier,
Sylvie Cohen-Addad,
Olivier Pitois,
Reinhard Höhler,
Emmanuelle Rio,
Anniina Salonen,
Douglas J. Durian,
Dominique Langevin
Abstract:
Coarsening of two-phase systems is crucial for the stability of dense particle packings such as alloys, foams, emulsions or supersaturated solutions. Mean field theories predict an asymptotic scaling state with a broad particle size distribution. Aqueous foams are good model systems for investigations of coarsening-induced structures, because the continuous liquid as well as the dispersed gas phas…
▽ More
Coarsening of two-phase systems is crucial for the stability of dense particle packings such as alloys, foams, emulsions or supersaturated solutions. Mean field theories predict an asymptotic scaling state with a broad particle size distribution. Aqueous foams are good model systems for investigations of coarsening-induced structures, because the continuous liquid as well as the dispersed gas phases are uniform and isotropic. We present coarsening experiments on wet foams, with liquid fractions up to their unjamming point and beyond, that are performed under microgravity to avoid gravitational drainage. As time elapses, a self-similar regime is reached where the normalized bubble size distribution is invariant. Unexpectedly, the distribution features an excess of small \textit{roaming} bubbles, mobile within the network of \textit{jammed} larger bubbles. These roaming bubbles are reminiscent of rattlers in granular materials (grains not subjected to contact forces). We identify a critical liquid fraction $φ^*$, above which the bubble assembly unjams and the two bubble populations merge into a single narrow distribution of bubbly liquids. Unexpectedly, $φ^*$ is larger than the random close packing fraction of the foam $φ_{rcp}$. This is because, between $φ_{rcp}$ and $φ^*$, the large bubbles remain connected due to a weak adhesion between bubbles. We present models that identify the physical mechanisms explaining our observations. We propose a new comprehensive view of the coarsening phenomenon in wet foams. Our results should be applicable to other phase-separating systems and they may also help to control the elaboration of solid foams with hierarchical structures.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2023; v1 submitted 23 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Coarsening transitions of wet liquid foams under microgravity conditions
Authors:
Marina Pasquet,
Nicolo Galvani,
Alice Requier,
Sylvie Cohen-Addad,
Reinhard Höhler,
Olivier Pitois,
Emmanuelle Rio,
Anniina Salonen,
Dominique Langevin
Abstract:
We report foam coarsening studies which were performed in the International Space Station (ISS) to suppress drainage due to gravity. Foams and bubbly liquids with controlled liquid fractions $φ$ between 15 and 50\% were investigated to study the transition between bubble growth laws previously reported near the dry limit $φ\rightarrow 0$ and the dilute limit $φ\rightarrow 1$ (Ostwald ripening). We…
▽ More
We report foam coarsening studies which were performed in the International Space Station (ISS) to suppress drainage due to gravity. Foams and bubbly liquids with controlled liquid fractions $φ$ between 15 and 50\% were investigated to study the transition between bubble growth laws previously reported near the dry limit $φ\rightarrow 0$ and the dilute limit $φ\rightarrow 1$ (Ostwald ripening). We determined the coarsening rates; for the driest foams and the bubbly liquids, they are in close agreement with theoretical predictions. We observe a sharp cross-over between the respective laws at a critical value $φ^*$. At liquid fractions beyond this transition, neighboring bubbles are no longer all in contact, like at a jamming transition. Remarkably $φ^*$ is significantly larger than the random close packing volume fraction of the bubbles $φ_{\text{rcp}}$ which was determined independently. We attribute the differences between $φ^*$ and $φ_{\text{rcp}}$ to a weakly adhesive bubble interaction that we have studied in complementary ground-based experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2023; v1 submitted 21 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Aqueous foams in microgravity, measuring bubble sizes
Authors:
Marina Pasquet,
Nicolo Galvani,
Olivier Pitois,
Sylvie Cohen-Addad,
Reinhard Höhler,
Anthony T. Chieco,
Sam Dillavou,
Jesse M. Hanlan,
Douglas J. Durian,
Emmanuelle Rio,
Anniina Salonen,
Dominique Langevin
Abstract:
The paper describes a study of wet foams in microgravity whose bubble size distribution evolves due to diffusive gas exchange. We focus on the comparison between the size of bubbles determined from images of the foam surface and the size of bubbles in the bulk foam, determined from Diffuse Transmission Spectroscopy (DTS). Extracting the bubble size distribution from images of a foam surface is dif…
▽ More
The paper describes a study of wet foams in microgravity whose bubble size distribution evolves due to diffusive gas exchange. We focus on the comparison between the size of bubbles determined from images of the foam surface and the size of bubbles in the bulk foam, determined from Diffuse Transmission Spectroscopy (DTS). Extracting the bubble size distribution from images of a foam surface is difficult so we have used three different procedures : manual analysis, automatic analysis with a customized Python script and machine learning analysis. Once various pitfalls were identified and taken into account, all the three procedures yield identical results within error bars. DTS only allows the determination of an average bubble radius which is proportional to the photon transport mean free path $\ell^*$. The relation between the measured diffuse transmitted light intensity and {$\ell^*$} previously derived for slab-shaped samples of infinite lateral extent does not apply to the cuboid geometry of the cells used in the microgravity experiment. A new more general expression of the diffuse intensity transmitted with specific optical boundary conditions has been derived and applied to determine the average bubble radius. The temporal evolution of the average bubble radii deduced from DTS and of the same average radii of the bubbles measured at the sample surface are in very good agreement throughout the coarsening. Finally, ground experiments were performed to compare bubble size distributions in a bulk wet foam and at its surface at times so short that diffusive gas exchange is insignificant. They were found to be similar, confirming that bubbles seen at the surface are representative of the bulk foam bubbles.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2023; v1 submitted 7 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Viscoelastic coarsening of quasi-2D foam
Authors:
Chiara Guidolin,
Jonathan Mac Intyre,
Emmanuelle Rio,
Antti Puisto,
Anniina Salonen
Abstract:
Foams are unstable jammed materials. They evolve over timescales comparable to their "time of use", which makes the study of their destabilisation mechanisms crucial for applications. In practice, many foams are made from viscoelastic fluids, which are observed to prolong their lifetimes. Despite their importance we lack understanding of the coarsening mechanism in such systems. We probe the effec…
▽ More
Foams are unstable jammed materials. They evolve over timescales comparable to their "time of use", which makes the study of their destabilisation mechanisms crucial for applications. In practice, many foams are made from viscoelastic fluids, which are observed to prolong their lifetimes. Despite their importance we lack understanding of the coarsening mechanism in such systems. We probe the effect of continuous phase viscoelasticity on foam coarsening with foamed emulsions. We show that bubble size evolution is strongly slowed down and foam structure hugely impacted. The main mechanisms responsible are the absence of continuous phase redistribution and a non-trivial link between foam structure and mechanical properties. These combine to give spatially heterogeneous coarsening. Beyond their importance in the design of foamy materials, the results give a macroscopic vision of phase separation in a viscoelastic medium.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Stiffening attractive suspensions with solid inclusions or granularity effect in loaded colloidal gels
Authors:
Claudia Ferreiro-Córdova,
Giuseppe Foffi,
Olivier Pitois,
Chiara Guidolin,
Maxime Schneider,
Anniina Salonen
Abstract:
The elastic properties of a soft matter material can be greatly altered by the presence of solid inclusions whose microscopic properties, such as their size and interactions, can have a dramatic effect. In order to shed light on these effects we use extensive rheology computer simulations to investigate colloidal gels with solid inclusions of different size. We show that the elastic properties var…
▽ More
The elastic properties of a soft matter material can be greatly altered by the presence of solid inclusions whose microscopic properties, such as their size and interactions, can have a dramatic effect. In order to shed light on these effects we use extensive rheology computer simulations to investigate colloidal gels with solid inclusions of different size. We show that the elastic properties vary in a highly non trivial way as consequence of the interactions between the gel backbone and the inclusions. In particular, we show that the key aspects are the presence of the gel backbone and its mechanical alteration originated by the inclusions. To confirm our observations and their generality, we performed experiments on an emulsion that presents strong analogies with colloidal gels and confirms the trends observed in the simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Blowing Big Bubbles
Authors:
Christopher A. E. Hamlett,
Dolachai N. Boniface,
Anniina Salonen,
Emmanuelle Rio,
Connor Perkins,
Alastair Clark,
Sang Nyugen,
David J. Fairhurst
Abstract:
Although street artists have the know-how to blow bubbles over one meter in length, the bubble width is typically determined by the size of the hoop, or wand they use. In this article we explore a regime in which, by blowing gently, we generate bubbles with radius up to ten times larger than the wand. We observe the big bubbles at lowest air speeds, analogous to the dripping mode observed in dropl…
▽ More
Although street artists have the know-how to blow bubbles over one meter in length, the bubble width is typically determined by the size of the hoop, or wand they use. In this article we explore a regime in which, by blowing gently, we generate bubbles with radius up to ten times larger than the wand. We observe the big bubbles at lowest air speeds, analogous to the dripping mode observed in droplet formation. We also explore the impact of the surfactant chosen to stabilize the bubbles. We are able to create bubbles of comparable size using either Fairy liquid, a commercially available detergent often used by street artists, or sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) solutions. The bubbles obtained from Fairy liquid detach from the wand and are stable for several seconds, however those from SDS tend to burst just before detachment.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Drop freezing: fine detection of contaminants by measuring the tip angle
Authors:
François Boulogne,
Anniina Salonen
Abstract:
In this Letter, we show that the shape of a freezing drop of water can be sensitive to the presence of impurities. We measure the tip angle of water drops frozen on a cold plate. The fine changes in tip angle are robustly captured by our image analysis method, which shows a deviation from that of pure water in solutions with salt (NaCl), polymer (PEG) and surfactant (TTAB) starting at concentratio…
▽ More
In this Letter, we show that the shape of a freezing drop of water can be sensitive to the presence of impurities. We measure the tip angle of water drops frozen on a cold plate. The fine changes in tip angle are robustly captured by our image analysis method, which shows a deviation from that of pure water in solutions with salt (NaCl), polymer (PEG) and surfactant (TTAB) starting at concentrations of $10^{-6}$, $10^{-4}$ and $10^{-6}$ M respectively. The method could be adapted into a portable water purity tester, but the work also highlights the complexity of water freezing as it is influenced by trace concentrations of impurities.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Foamed emulsion drainage: flow and trapping of drops
Authors:
Maxime Schneider,
Ziqiang Zou,
Dominique Langevin,
Anniina Salonen
Abstract:
Foamed emulsions are ubiquitous in our daily life but the ageing of such systems is still poorly understood. In this study we investigate foam drainage and measure the evolution of the gas, liquid and oil volume fractions inside the foam. We evidence three regimes of ageing. During an initial period of fast drainage, both bubbles and drops are very mobile. As the foam stabilises drainage proceeds…
▽ More
Foamed emulsions are ubiquitous in our daily life but the ageing of such systems is still poorly understood. In this study we investigate foam drainage and measure the evolution of the gas, liquid and oil volume fractions inside the foam. We evidence three regimes of ageing. During an initial period of fast drainage, both bubbles and drops are very mobile. As the foam stabilises drainage proceeds leading to a gradual decrease of the liquid fraction and slowing down of drainage. Clusters of oil drops are less sheared, their dynamic viscosity increases and drainage slows down even further, until the drops become blocked. At this point the oil fraction starts to increase in the continuous phase. The foam ageing leads to an increase of the capillary pressure until the oil acts as an antifoaming agent and the foam collapses.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Electrical conductivity of quasi-two-dimensional foams
Authors:
Pavel Yazhgur,
Clement Honorez,
Wiebke Drenckhan,
Dominique Langevin,
Anniina Salonen
Abstract:
Quasi-two-dimensional (quasi-2D) foams consist of monolayers of bubbles squeezed between two narrowly spaced plates. These simplified foams have served successfully in the past to shed light on numerous issues in foam physics. Here we consider the electrical conductivity of such model foams. We compare experiments to a model which we propose, and which successfully relates the structural and the c…
▽ More
Quasi-two-dimensional (quasi-2D) foams consist of monolayers of bubbles squeezed between two narrowly spaced plates. These simplified foams have served successfully in the past to shed light on numerous issues in foam physics. Here we consider the electrical conductivity of such model foams. We compare experiments to a model which we propose, and which successfully relates the structural and the conductive properties of the foam over the full range of the investigated liquid content. We show in particular that in the case of quasi-2D foams the liquid in the nodes needs to be taken into account even at low liquid content. We think that these results may provide different approaches for the characterization of foam properties and for the in situ characterization of the liquid content of foams in confining geometries, such as microfluidics
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Gas pressure in bubble attached to tube circular outlet
Authors:
A Salonen,
Cyprien Gay,
A Maestro,
W Drenckhan,
Emmanuelle Rio
Abstract:
In the present Supplementary notes to our work "Arresting bubble coarsening: A two-bubble experiment to investigate grain growth in presence of surface elasticity" (accepted in EPL), we derive the expression of the gas pressure inside a bubble located above and attached to the circular outlet of a vertical tube.
In the present Supplementary notes to our work "Arresting bubble coarsening: A two-bubble experiment to investigate grain growth in presence of surface elasticity" (accepted in EPL), we derive the expression of the gas pressure inside a bubble located above and attached to the circular outlet of a vertical tube.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Arresting bubble coarsening: A two-bubble experiment to investigate grain growth in presence of surface elasticity
Authors:
Anniina Salonen,
Cyprien Gay,
Armando Maestro,
Wiebke Drenckhan,
Emmanuelle Rio
Abstract:
Many two-phase materials suffer from grain-growth due to the energy cost which is associated with the interface that separates both phases. While our understanding of the driving forces and the dynamics of grain growth in different materials is well advanced by now, current research efforts address the question of how this process may be slowed down, or, ideally, arrested. We use a model system of…
▽ More
Many two-phase materials suffer from grain-growth due to the energy cost which is associated with the interface that separates both phases. While our understanding of the driving forces and the dynamics of grain growth in different materials is well advanced by now, current research efforts address the question of how this process may be slowed down, or, ideally, arrested. We use a model system of two bubbles to explore how the presence of a finite surface elasticity may interfere with the coarsening process and the final grain size distribution. Combining experiments and modelling in the analysis of the evolution of two bubbles, we show that clear relationships can be predicted between the surface tension, the surface elasticity and the initial/final size ratio of the bubbles. We rationalise these relationships by the introduction of a modified Gibbs criterion. Besides their general interest, the present results have direct implications for our understanding of foam stability.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2017; v1 submitted 22 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Non-equilibrium behavior of lysozyme solutions: beads, clusters and gels
Authors:
H. Sedgwick,
K. Kroy,
A. Salonen,
M. B. Robertson,
S. U. Egelhaaf,
W. C. K. Poon
Abstract:
Observation of salt-induced aggregation of lysozyme at pH = 4.5, 22$^{\circ}$C by optical microscopy revealed four regimes: bicontinuous texture, `beads', large aggregates, and transient gelation. The interaction of a metastable liquid-liquid binodal and an ergodic to non-ergodic transition boundary inside the equilibrium crystallization region can explain our findings. Lysozyme data at -2…
▽ More
Observation of salt-induced aggregation of lysozyme at pH = 4.5, 22$^{\circ}$C by optical microscopy revealed four regimes: bicontinuous texture, `beads', large aggregates, and transient gelation. The interaction of a metastable liquid-liquid binodal and an ergodic to non-ergodic transition boundary inside the equilibrium crystallization region can explain our findings. Lysozyme data at -2$^{\circ}$C, as well as many literature results, are consistent with the relative movement of these boundaries.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2003;
originally announced September 2003.