-
Effect of architecture disorder on the elastic response of two-dimensional lattice materials
Authors:
Antoine Montiel,
Thuy Nguyen,
Cindy Rountree,
Valérie Geertsen,
Patrick Guenoun,
Daniel Bonamy
Abstract:
We examine how disordering joint position influences the linear elastic behavior of lattice materials via numerical simulations in two-dimensional beam networks. Three distinct initial crystalline geometries are selected as representative of mechanically isotropic materials low connectivity, mechanically isotropic materials with high connectivity, and mechanically anisotropic materials with interm…
▽ More
We examine how disordering joint position influences the linear elastic behavior of lattice materials via numerical simulations in two-dimensional beam networks. Three distinct initial crystalline geometries are selected as representative of mechanically isotropic materials low connectivity, mechanically isotropic materials with high connectivity, and mechanically anisotropic materials with intermediate connectivity. Introducing disorder generates spatial fluctuations in the elasticity tensor at the local (joint) scale. Proper coarse-graining reveals a well-defined continuum-level scale elasticity tensor. Increasing disorder aids in making initially anisotropic materials more isotropic. The disorder impact on the material stiffness depends on the lattice connectivity: Increasing the disorder softens lattices with high connectivity and stiffens those with low connectivity, without modifying the scaling between elastic modulus and density (linear scaling for high connectivity and cubic scaling for low connectivity). Introducing disorder in lattices with intermediate fixed connectivity reveals both scaling: the linear scaling occurs for low density, the cubic one at high density, and the crossover density increases with disorder. Contrary to classical formulations, this work demonstrates that connectivity is not the sole parameter governing elastic modulus scaling. It offers a promising route to access novel mechanical properties in lattice materials via disordering the architectures.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Role of particle aggregation on the structure of dried colloidal silica layers
Authors:
Arnaud Lesaine,
Daniel Bonamy,
Cindy Rountree,
Georges Gauthier,
Marianne Impéror-Clerc,
Veronique Lazarus
Abstract:
The process of colloidal drying gives way to particle self-assembly in numerous elds including photonics or biotechnology. Yet, the mechanisms and conditions driving the nal particle arrangement in dry colloidal layers remain elusive. Here, we examine how the drying rate selects the nanostructure of thick dried layers in four dierent suspensions of silica nanospheres. Depending on particle size an…
▽ More
The process of colloidal drying gives way to particle self-assembly in numerous elds including photonics or biotechnology. Yet, the mechanisms and conditions driving the nal particle arrangement in dry colloidal layers remain elusive. Here, we examine how the drying rate selects the nanostructure of thick dried layers in four dierent suspensions of silica nanospheres. Depending on particle size and dispersity, either an amorphous arrangement, a crystalline arrangement, or a rate-dependent amorphous-to-crystalline transition occurs at the drying surface. Amorphous arrangements are observed in the two most polydisperse suspensions while crystallinity occurs when dispersity is lower. Counter-intuitively in the latter case, a higher drying rate favors ordering of the particles. To complement these measurements and to take stock of the bulk properties of the layer, tests on the layer porosity were undertaken. For all suspensions studied herein, faster drying yields denser dry layers. Crystalline surface arrangement implies large bulk volume fraction ($\sim$ 0.65) whereas amorphous arrangements can be observed in layers with either low (down to $\sim$ 0.53) or high ($\sim$ 0.65) volume fraction. Lastly, we demonstrate via targeted additional experiments and SAXS measurements, that the packing structure of the layers is mainly driven by the formation of aggregates and their subsequent packing, and not by the competition between Brownian diusion and convection. This highlights that a second dimensionless ratio in addition to the Peclet number should be taken into account, namely the aggregation over evaporation timescale.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Highly porous layers of silica nano-spheres sintered by drying: Scaling up of the elastic properties from the beads to the macroscopic mechanical properties
Authors:
Arnaud Lesaine,
Daniel Bonamy,
Georges Gauthier,
Cindy Rountree,
Véronique Lazarus
Abstract:
Layers obtained by drying a colloidal dispersion of silica spheres are found to be a good benchmark to test the elastic behaviour of porous media, in the challenging case of high porosities and nano-sized microstructures. Classically used for these systems, Kendall's approach explicitely considers the effect of surface adhesive forces onto the contact area between the particles. This approach prov…
▽ More
Layers obtained by drying a colloidal dispersion of silica spheres are found to be a good benchmark to test the elastic behaviour of porous media, in the challenging case of high porosities and nano-sized microstructures. Classically used for these systems, Kendall's approach explicitely considers the effect of surface adhesive forces onto the contact area between the particles. This approach provides the Young's modulus using a single adjustable parameter (the adhesion energy) but provides no further information on the tensorial nature and possible anisotropy of elasticity. On the other hand, homogenization approaches (e.g. rule of mixtures, Eshelby, Mori-Tanaka and self-consistent schemes), based on continuum mechanics and asymptotic analysis, provide the stiffness tensor from the knowledge of the porosity and the elastic constants of the beads. Herein, the self-consistent scheme accurately predicts both bulk and shear moduli, with no adjustable parameter, provided the porosity is less than 35%, for layers composed of particles as small as 15 nm in diameter. Conversely, Kendall's approach is found to predict the Young's modulus over the full porosity range. Moreover, the adhesion energy in Kendall's model has to be adjusted to a value of the order of the fracture energy of the particle material. This suggests that sintering during drying leads to the formation of covalent siloxane bonds between the particles.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Roughness of oxide glass subcritical fracture surfaces
Authors:
Gael Pallares,
Frederic Lechenault,
Matthieu George,
Elisabeth Bouchaud,
Cédric Ottina,
Cindy L. Rountree,
Matteo Ciccotti
Abstract:
An original setup combining a very stable loading stage, an atomic force microscope and an environmental chamber, allows to obtain very stable sub-critical fracture propagation in oxide glasses under controlled environment, and subsequently to finely characterize the nanometric roughness properties of the crack surfaces. The analysis of the surface roughness is conducted both in terms of the class…
▽ More
An original setup combining a very stable loading stage, an atomic force microscope and an environmental chamber, allows to obtain very stable sub-critical fracture propagation in oxide glasses under controlled environment, and subsequently to finely characterize the nanometric roughness properties of the crack surfaces. The analysis of the surface roughness is conducted both in terms of the classical root mean square roughness to compare with the literature, and in terms of more physically adequate indicators related to the self-affine nature of the fracture surfaces. Due to the comparable nanometric scale of the surface roughness, the AFM tip size and the instrumental noise, a special care is devoted to the statistical evaluation of the metrologic properties. The 2 roughness amplitude of several oxide glasses was shown to decrease as a function of the stress intensity factor, to be quite insensitive to the relative humidity and to increase with the degree of heterogeneity of the glass. The results are discussed in terms of several modeling arguments concerning the coupling between crack propagation, material's heterogeneity, crack tip plastic deformation and water diffusion at the crack tip. A synthetic new model is presented combining the predictions of a model by Wiederhorn et al. [1] on the effect of the material's heterogeneity on the crack tip stresses with the self-affine nature of the fracture surfaces.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Role of evaporation rate on the particle organization and crack patterns obtained by drying a colloidal layer
Authors:
Keyvan Piroird,
Véronique Lazarus,
Georges Gauthier,
Arnaud Lesaine,
Daniel Bonamy,
Cindy Rountree
Abstract:
-- A scientific hurdle in manufacturing solid films by drying colloidal layers is preventing them from fracturing. This paper examines how the drying rate of colloidal liquids influences the particle packing at the nanoscale in correlation with the crack patterns observed at the macroscale. Increasing the drying rate results in more ordered, denser solid structures, and the dried samples have more…
▽ More
-- A scientific hurdle in manufacturing solid films by drying colloidal layers is preventing them from fracturing. This paper examines how the drying rate of colloidal liquids influences the particle packing at the nanoscale in correlation with the crack patterns observed at the macroscale. Increasing the drying rate results in more ordered, denser solid structures, and the dried samples have more cracks.Yet, introducing a holding period (at a prescribed point) during the drying protocol results in a more disordered solid structure with significantly less cracks. To interpret these observations, this paper conjectures that a longer drying protocol favors the formation of aggregates. It is further argued that the number and size of the aggregates increase as the drying rate decreases. This results in the formation of a more disordered, porous film from the viewpoint of the particle packing, and a more resistant film, i.e. less cracks, from the macroscale viewpoint.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Fractoluminescence characterization of the energy dissipated during fast fracture of glass
Authors:
Gael Pallares,
Cindy L. Rountree,
Ludovic Douillard,
Fabrice Charra,
Elisabeth Bouchaud
Abstract:
Fractoluminescence experiments are performed on two kinds of silicate glasses. All the light spectra collected during dynamic fracture reveal a black body radiator behaviour, which is interpreted as a crack velocity-dependent temperature rise close to the crack tip. Crack velocities are estimated to be of the order of 1300 m.s$^{-1}$ and fracture process zones are shown to extend over a few nanome…
▽ More
Fractoluminescence experiments are performed on two kinds of silicate glasses. All the light spectra collected during dynamic fracture reveal a black body radiator behaviour, which is interpreted as a crack velocity-dependent temperature rise close to the crack tip. Crack velocities are estimated to be of the order of 1300 m.s$^{-1}$ and fracture process zones are shown to extend over a few nanometers.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Evidence of deep water penetration in silica during stress corrosion fracture
Authors:
F. Lechenault,
C. L. Rountree,
F. Cousin,
J. -P. Bouchaud,
L. Ponson,
E. Bouchaud
Abstract:
We measure the thickness of the heavy water layer trapped under the stress corrosion fracture surface of silica using neutron reflectivity experiments. We show that the penetration depth is 65-85 ångströms, suggesting the presence of a damaged zone of $\approx$ 100 ångströms extending ahead of the crack tip during its propagation. This estimate of the size of the damaged zone is compatible with ot…
▽ More
We measure the thickness of the heavy water layer trapped under the stress corrosion fracture surface of silica using neutron reflectivity experiments. We show that the penetration depth is 65-85 ångströms, suggesting the presence of a damaged zone of $\approx$ 100 ångströms extending ahead of the crack tip during its propagation. This estimate of the size of the damaged zone is compatible with other recent results.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Effects of finite probe size on self-affine roughness measurements
Authors:
F. Lechenault,
G. Pallares,
M. George,
C. Rountree,
E. Bouchaud,
M. Ciccotti
Abstract:
The roughness of fracture surfaces has been shown to exhibit self-affne scale invariance for a wide variety of materials and loading conditions. The range of scales over which this regime extends remains a matter of debate, together with the universality of the associated exponents. The topography of these surfaces is however often investigated with a contact probe that is larger than the micro-…
▽ More
The roughness of fracture surfaces has been shown to exhibit self-affne scale invariance for a wide variety of materials and loading conditions. The range of scales over which this regime extends remains a matter of debate, together with the universality of the associated exponents. The topography of these surfaces is however often investigated with a contact probe that is larger than the micro-structure. In this case, we show that the correlation function of the roughness and the corresponding Hurst exponent $ζ$ can only be measured down to a length scale $Δxc$ which depends on the probe size $R$, on $ζ$ and on the surface topothesy $l$, and exhibit spurious behavior at smaller scales. First, we derive the dependence of $Δxc$ on these parameters from a simple scaling argument. Then we study this dependence numerically and verify our theoretical prediction. Finally, we establish the relevance of this analysis from AFM measurements on an experimental glass fracture surface and provide a metrological procedure for roughness measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Plasticity-induced structural anisotropy of silica glass
Authors:
Cindy Linn Rountree,
Damien Vandembroucq,
Mehdi Talamali,
Elisabeth Bouchaud,
Stéphane Roux
Abstract:
Amorphous silica density at ambient pressure is known to depend on thermal history (through the quenching rate) but also, at room temperature, on the maximum pressure applied in the past. Here we show that beyond density, a mechanical loading can endow the structure with an orientational order. Molecular dynamics simulations show evidence that amorphous silica develops a permanent anisotropic st…
▽ More
Amorphous silica density at ambient pressure is known to depend on thermal history (through the quenching rate) but also, at room temperature, on the maximum pressure applied in the past. Here we show that beyond density, a mechanical loading can endow the structure with an orientational order. Molecular dynamics simulations show evidence that amorphous silica develops a permanent anisotropic structure after extended shear plastic flow. This anisotropy which survives for an unstressed specimen is revealed markedly by the fabric tensor computed over the Si-O-Si orientations, albeit the SiO4 tetrahedra microstructure remains mostly unaltered.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
Nanoscale damage during fracture in silica glass
Authors:
Daniel Bonamy,
Silke Prades,
Cindy Rountree,
Laurent Ponson,
Davy Dalmas,
Elisabeth Bouchaud,
K. Ravi-Chandar,
Claude Guillot
Abstract:
We report here atomic force microscopy experiments designed to uncover the nature of failure mechanisms occuring within the process zone at the tip of a crack propagating into a silica glass specimen under stress corrosion. The crack propagates through the growth and coalescence of nanoscale damage spots. This cavitation process is shown to be the key mechanism responsible for damage spreading w…
▽ More
We report here atomic force microscopy experiments designed to uncover the nature of failure mechanisms occuring within the process zone at the tip of a crack propagating into a silica glass specimen under stress corrosion. The crack propagates through the growth and coalescence of nanoscale damage spots. This cavitation process is shown to be the key mechanism responsible for damage spreading within the process zone. The possible origin of the nucleation of cavities, as well as the implications on the selection of both the cavity size at coalescence and the process zone extension are finally discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2006;
originally announced August 2006.
