-
Systematic analysis of Persson's contact mechanics theory of randomly rough elastic surfaces
Authors:
Wolf B. Dapp,
Nikolay Prodanov,
Martin H. Müser
Abstract:
We systematically check explicit and implicit assumptions of Persson's contact mechanics theory. It casts the evolution of the pressure distribution ${\rm Pr}(p)$ with increasing resolution of surface roughness as a diffusive process, in which resolution plays the role of time. The tested key assumptions of the theory are: (a) the diffusion coefficient is independent of pressure $p$, (b) the diffu…
▽ More
We systematically check explicit and implicit assumptions of Persson's contact mechanics theory. It casts the evolution of the pressure distribution ${\rm Pr}(p)$ with increasing resolution of surface roughness as a diffusive process, in which resolution plays the role of time. The tested key assumptions of the theory are: (a) the diffusion coefficient is independent of pressure $p$, (b) the diffusion process is drift-free at any value of $p$, (c) the point $p=0$ acts as an absorbing barrier, i.e., once a point falls out of contact, it never reenters again, (d) the Fourier component of the elastic energy is only populated if the appropriate wave vector is resolved, and (e) it no longer changes when even smaller wavelengths are resolved. Using high-resolution numerical simulations, we quantify deviations from these approximations and find quite significant discrepancies in some cases. For example, the drift becomes substantial for small values of $p$, which typically represent points in real space close to a contact line. On the other hand, there is a significant flux of points reentering contact. These and other identified deviations cancel each other to a large degree, resulting in an overall excellent description for contact area, contact geometry, and gap distribution functions. Similar fortuitous error cancellations cannot be guaranteed under different circumstances, for instance when investigating rubber friction. The results of the simulations may provide guidelines for a systematic improvement of the theory.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
On the contact area and mean gap of rough, elastic contacts: Dimensional analysis, numerical corrections and reference data
Authors:
Nikolay Prodanov,
Wolf B. Dapp,
Martin H. Müser
Abstract:
The description of elastic, nonadhesive contacts between solids with self-affine surface roughness seems to necessitate knowledge of a large number of parameters. However, few parameters suffice to determine many important interfacial properties as we show by combining dimensional analysis with numerical simulations. This insight is used to deduce the pressure dependence of the relative contact ar…
▽ More
The description of elastic, nonadhesive contacts between solids with self-affine surface roughness seems to necessitate knowledge of a large number of parameters. However, few parameters suffice to determine many important interfacial properties as we show by combining dimensional analysis with numerical simulations. This insight is used to deduce the pressure dependence of the relative contact area and the mean interfacial separation $Δ\bar{u}$ and to present the results in a compact form. Given a proper unit choice for pressure $p$, i.e., effective modulus $E^*$ times the root-mean-square gradient $\bar{g}$, the relative contact area mainly depends on $p$ but barely on the Hurst exponent $H$ even at large $p$. When using the root-mean-square height $\bar{h}$ as unit of length, $Δ\bar{u}$ additionally depends on the ratio of the height spectrum cutoffs at short and long wavelengths. In the fractal limit, where that ratio is zero, solely the roughness at short wavelengths is relevant for $Δ\bar{u}$. This limit, however, should not be relevant for practical applications. Our work contains a brief summary of the employed numerical method Green's function molecular dynamics including an illustration of how to systematically overcome numerical shortcomings through appropriate finite-size, fractal, and discretization corrections. Additionally, we outline the derivation of Persson theory in dimensionless units. Persson theory compares well to the numerical reference data.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2013; v1 submitted 29 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Frictional anisotropy of metal nanoparticles adsorbed on graphene
Authors:
A. V. Khomenko,
N. V. Prodanov,
M. A. Khomenko,
B. O. Krasulya
Abstract:
Friction force acting on silver and nickel nanoparticles sheared on a graphene sheet in different lateral directions is investigated using classical molecular dynamics simulations. The results reveal the existence of frictional anisotropy for both metals. In most cases, the maximum value of the friction force is about two times larger than the minimum one. The form of dependencies of instantaneous…
▽ More
Friction force acting on silver and nickel nanoparticles sheared on a graphene sheet in different lateral directions is investigated using classical molecular dynamics simulations. The results reveal the existence of frictional anisotropy for both metals. In most cases, the maximum value of the friction force is about two times larger than the minimum one. The form of dependencies of instantaneous values of the friction force components on the corresponding lateral components of the position of the centre of mass of the nanoislands strongly depends on sliding direction, varying between the sawtooth and the irregular one. A qualitative explanation of the results based on the "patch" model is proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Atomistic modelling of friction of Cu and Au nanoparticles adsorbed on graphene
Authors:
A. V. Khomenko,
N. V. Prodanov,
B. N. J. Persson
Abstract:
We present classical molecular dynamics calculations of the behavior of copper and gold nanoparticles on a graphene sheet, sheared with a constant applied force $F_{\rm a}$. The force $F_{\rm s}$ acting on the particle from the substrate depends on the material of the nanoparticles (Au or Cu), and exhibits a sawtooth dependency on time, which we attribute to local commensurability between the meta…
▽ More
We present classical molecular dynamics calculations of the behavior of copper and gold nanoparticles on a graphene sheet, sheared with a constant applied force $F_{\rm a}$. The force $F_{\rm s}$ acting on the particle from the substrate depends on the material of the nanoparticles (Au or Cu), and exhibits a sawtooth dependency on time, which we attribute to local commensurability between the metal nanoparticle surface atomic positions with the graphene lattice. The time-averaged value of $F_{\rm s}$ (the friction force) acting on Au nanoparticles increases linearly with the contact area, having slopes close to the experimentally observable ones. A qualitative model is proposed to explain the observed results.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2013; v1 submitted 26 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
Finite-size scaling in the interfacial stiffness of rough elastic contacts
Authors:
Lars Pastewka,
Nikolay Prodanov,
Boris Lorenz,
Martin H. Müser,
Mark O. Robbins,
Bo N. J. Persson
Abstract:
The total elastic stiffness of two contacting bodies with a microscopically rough interface has an interfacial contribution K that is entirely attributable to surface roughness. A quantitative understanding of K is important because it can dominate the total mechanical response and because it is proportional to the interfacial contributions to electrical and thermal conductivity in continuum theor…
▽ More
The total elastic stiffness of two contacting bodies with a microscopically rough interface has an interfacial contribution K that is entirely attributable to surface roughness. A quantitative understanding of K is important because it can dominate the total mechanical response and because it is proportional to the interfacial contributions to electrical and thermal conductivity in continuum theory. Numerical simulations of the dependence of K on the applied squeezing pressure p are presented for nominally flat elastic solids with a range of surface roughnesses. Over a wide range of p, K rises linearly with p. Sublinear power-law scaling is observed at small p, but the simulations reveal that this is a finite-size effect. We derive accurate, analytical expressions for the exponents and prefactors of this low-pressure scaling of K by extending the contact mechanics theory of Persson to systems of finite size. In agreement with our simulations, these expressions show that the onset of the low-pressure scaling regime moves to lower pressure as the system size increases.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2013; v1 submitted 17 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Supplementary material to: Finite-size effects in the interfacial stiffness of rough elastic contacts
Authors:
Lars Pastewka,
Nikolay Prodanov,
Boris Lorenz,
Martin H. Müser,
Mark O. Robbins,
Bo N. J. Persson
Abstract:
In this supplementary materials section, we provide (i) additional information on the numerical simulations of the main work, (ii) the derivation of all prefactors in the analytical theory, and (iii) unpublished experiments of the contact stiffness of a polymer pressed against a rough substrate.
In this supplementary materials section, we provide (i) additional information on the numerical simulations of the main work, (ii) the derivation of all prefactors in the analytical theory, and (iii) unpublished experiments of the contact stiffness of a polymer pressed against a rough substrate.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Interfacial separation between elastic solids with randomly rough surfaces: comparison between theory and numerical techniques
Authors:
A. Almqvist,
C. Campana,
N. Prodanov,
B. N. J. Persson
Abstract:
We study the distribution of interfacial separations P(u) at the contact region between two elastic solids with randomly rough surfaces. An analytical expression is derived for P(u) using Persson's theory of contact mechanics, and is compared to numerical solutions obtained using (a) a half-space method based on the Boussinesq equation, (b) a Green's function molecular dynamics technique and (c) s…
▽ More
We study the distribution of interfacial separations P(u) at the contact region between two elastic solids with randomly rough surfaces. An analytical expression is derived for P(u) using Persson's theory of contact mechanics, and is compared to numerical solutions obtained using (a) a half-space method based on the Boussinesq equation, (b) a Green's function molecular dynamics technique and (c) smart-block classical molecular dynamics. Overall, we find good agreement between all the different approaches.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Study of friction of Ag and Ni nanoparticles: an atomistic approach
Authors:
Alexei V. Khomenko,
Nikolay V. Prodanov
Abstract:
Manipulation of metal nanoparticles using atomic force microscope is a promising new technique for probing tribological properties at the nanoscale. In spite of some advancements in experimental investigations, there is no unambiguous theoretical treatment of processes accompanying the movement of metallic nanoislands adsorbed on a flat surface and additional research is required. In this paper, w…
▽ More
Manipulation of metal nanoparticles using atomic force microscope is a promising new technique for probing tribological properties at the nanoscale. In spite of some advancements in experimental investigations, there is no unambiguous theoretical treatment of processes accompanying the movement of metallic nanoislands adsorbed on a flat surface and additional research is required. In this paper, we describe computer experiments based on classical molecular dynamics in which the behavior of silver and nickel nanoparticles interacting with a graphene sheet and sheared with constant force is studied. Frictional force acting on the nanoislands is measured as a function of their size. It is shown that its average value grows approximately linearly with contact area, and slopes of linear fits are close to the experimentally observable ones. The dependence of the friction force value and of the shape of the measured friction curves on the type of metal atom is revealed and its possible reasons originating from atomistic background are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Computational investigation of the temperature influence on the cleavage of a graphite surface
Authors:
N. V. Prodanov,
A. V. Khomenko
Abstract:
Mechanical exfoliation of a graphite surface with an adhesive nanoasperity is studied under different temperatures ranging from 298 K to 2 K using classical molecular dynamics. Two types of the interlayer interaction are investigated. For a pairwise Lennard-Jones potential the complete removal of the upper graphene layer during the retraction of the nanoasperity occurs in the whole range of the te…
▽ More
Mechanical exfoliation of a graphite surface with an adhesive nanoasperity is studied under different temperatures ranging from 298 K to 2 K using classical molecular dynamics. Two types of the interlayer interaction are investigated. For a pairwise Lennard-Jones potential the complete removal of the upper graphene layer during the retraction of the nanoasperity occurs in the whole range of the temperatures considered. The results obtained using registry dependent potential, which takes into account electronic delocalization contribution besides the van der Waals one, exhibit more pronounced temperature dependence. In this case the exfoliation takes place for temperatures higher than 16 K, but beginning from 8 K down to 2 K the system behavior manifests qualitative changes with the absence of cleavage of the sample. Analytical estimates combined with the results of the simulations reveal that the contribution of the overlap of pi orbitals of carbon atoms plays an important role in the exfoliation of graphite.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Molecular dynamics of cleavage and flake formation during the interaction of a graphite surface with a rigid nanoasperity
Authors:
A. V. Khomenko,
N. V. Prodanov
Abstract:
Computer experiments concerning interactions between a graphite surface and the rigid pyramidal nanoasperity of a friction force microscope tip when it is brought close to and retracted from the graphitic sample are presented. Covalent atomic bonds in graphene layers are described using a Brenner potential and tip-carbon forces are derived from the Lennard-Jones potential. For interlayer interacti…
▽ More
Computer experiments concerning interactions between a graphite surface and the rigid pyramidal nanoasperity of a friction force microscope tip when it is brought close to and retracted from the graphitic sample are presented. Covalent atomic bonds in graphene layers are described using a Brenner potential and tip-carbon forces are derived from the Lennard-Jones potential. For interlayer interactions a registry-dependent potential with local normals is used. The behavior of the system is investigated under conditions of different magnitudes of tip-sample interaction and indentation rates. Strong forces between the nanoasperity and carbon atoms facilitate the cleavage of the graphite surface. Exfoliation, i. e. total removal of the upper graphitic layer, is observed when a highly adhesive tip is moved relative to the surface at low rates, while high rates cause the formation of a small flake attached to the tip. The results obtained may be valuable for enhancing our understanding of the superlubricity of graphite.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Molecular dynamics simulations of ultrathin water film confined between flat diamond plates
Authors:
A. V. Khomenko,
N. V. Prodanov
Abstract:
Molecular dynamics simulations of ultrathin water film confined between atomically flat rigid diamond plates are described. Films with thickness of one and two molecular diameters are concerned and TIP4P model is used for water molecules. Dynamical and equilibrium characteristics of the system for different values of the external load and shear force are investigated. An increase of the external…
▽ More
Molecular dynamics simulations of ultrathin water film confined between atomically flat rigid diamond plates are described. Films with thickness of one and two molecular diameters are concerned and TIP4P model is used for water molecules. Dynamical and equilibrium characteristics of the system for different values of the external load and shear force are investigated. An increase of the external load causes the transition of the film to a solidlike state. This is manifested in the decreasing of the diffusion constant and in the ordering of the liquid molecules into quasidiscrete layers. For two-layer film under high loads molecules also become ordered parallel to the surfaces. Time dependencies of the friction force and the changes of its average value with the load are obtained. In general, the behaviour of the studied model is consistent with the experimental results obtained for simple liquids with spherical molecules.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
