-
Derivation of the free energy, entropy and specific heat for planar Ising models: Application to Archimedean lattices and their duals
Authors:
Laurent Pierre,
Bernard Bernu,
Laura Messio
Abstract:
The 2d ferromagnetic Ising model was solved by Onsager on the square lattice in 1944, and an explicit expression of the free energy density $f$ is presently available for some other planar lattices. An exact derivation of the critical temperature $T_c$ only requires a partial derivation of $f$ and has been performed on many lattices, including the 11 Archimedean lattices. We give general expressio…
▽ More
The 2d ferromagnetic Ising model was solved by Onsager on the square lattice in 1944, and an explicit expression of the free energy density $f$ is presently available for some other planar lattices. An exact derivation of the critical temperature $T_c$ only requires a partial derivation of $f$ and has been performed on many lattices, including the 11 Archimedean lattices. We give general expressions of the free energy, energy, entropy and specific heat for planar lattices with a single type of non-crossing links. The specific heat exhibits a logarithmic singularity at $T_c$: $c_V(T)\sim -A\ln|1-T_c/T|$, in all the ferromagnetic and some antiferromagnetic cases. While the non-universal weight $A$ of the leading term has often been evaluated, this is not the case for the sub-leading order term $B$ such that $c_V(T)+A\ln|1-T_c/T|\sim B$, despite its strong impact on $c_V(T)$ values in the vicinity of $T_c$, particularly important in experimental measurements. Explicit values of these thermodynamic quantities and of $A$ and $B$ are given for the Archimedean lattices and their dual for both ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
High temperature series expansions of S = 1/2 Heisenberg spin models: algorithm to include the magnetic field with optimized complexity
Authors:
Laurent Pierre,
Bernard Bernu,
Laura Messio
Abstract:
This work presents an algorithm for calculating high temperature series expansions (HTSE) of Heisenberg spin models with spin $S=1/2$ in the thermodynamic limit. This algorithm accounts for the presence of a magnetic field. The paper begins with a comprehensive introduction to HTSE and then focuses on identifying the bottlenecks that limit the computation of higher order coefficients. HTSE calcula…
▽ More
This work presents an algorithm for calculating high temperature series expansions (HTSE) of Heisenberg spin models with spin $S=1/2$ in the thermodynamic limit. This algorithm accounts for the presence of a magnetic field. The paper begins with a comprehensive introduction to HTSE and then focuses on identifying the bottlenecks that limit the computation of higher order coefficients. HTSE calculations involve two key steps: graph enumeration on the lattice and trace calculations for each graph. The introduction of a non-zero magnetic field adds complexity to the expansion because previously irrelevant graphs must now be considered: bridged graphs. We present an efficient method to deduce the contribution of these graphs from the contribution of sub-graphs, that drastically reduces the time of calculation for the last order coefficient (in practice increasing by one the order of the series at almost no cost). Previous articles of the authors have utilized HTSE calculations based on this algorithm, but without providing detailed explanations. The complete algorithm is publicly available, as well as the series on many lattice and for various interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2024; v1 submitted 2 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Finite-temperature phase transitions in $S=1/2$ three-dimensional Heisenberg magnets from high-temperature series expansions
Authors:
M. G. Gonzalez,
B. Bernu,
L. Pierre,
L. Messio
Abstract:
Many frustrated spin models on three-dimensional (3D) lattices are currently being investigated, both experimentally and theoretically, and develop new types of long-range orders in their respective phase diagrams. They present finite-temperature phase transitions, most likely in the Heisenberg 3D universality class. However, the combination between the 3D character and frustration makes them hard…
▽ More
Many frustrated spin models on three-dimensional (3D) lattices are currently being investigated, both experimentally and theoretically, and develop new types of long-range orders in their respective phase diagrams. They present finite-temperature phase transitions, most likely in the Heisenberg 3D universality class. However, the combination between the 3D character and frustration makes them hard to study. We present here several methods derived from high-temperature series expansions (HTSEs), which give exact coefficients directly in the thermodynamic limit up to a certain order; for several 3D lattices, supplementary orders than in previous literature are reported for the HTSEs. We introduce an interpolation method able to describe thermodynamic quantities at $T > T_c$, which we use here to reconstruct the magnetic susceptibility and the specific heat and to extract universal and non-universal quantities (for example critical exponents, temperature, energy, entropy, and other parameters related to the phase transition). While the susceptibility associated with the order parameter is not usually known for more exotic long-range orders, the specific heat is indicative of a phase transition for any kind of symmetry breaking. We present examples of applications on ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic models on various 3D lattices and benchmark our results whenever possible.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2023; v1 submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Ground-state and thermodynamic properties of the spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ Heisenberg model on the anisotropic triangular lattice
Authors:
Matías G. Gonzalez,
Bernard Bernu,
Laurent Pierre,
Laura Messio
Abstract:
The spin-$\frac12$ triangular lattice antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model has been for a long time the prototypical model of magnetic frustration. However, only very recently this model has been proposed to be realized in the Ba$_8$CoNb$_6$O$_{24}$ compound. The ground-state and thermodynamic properties are evaluated from a high-temperature series expansions interpolation method, called "entropy me…
▽ More
The spin-$\frac12$ triangular lattice antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model has been for a long time the prototypical model of magnetic frustration. However, only very recently this model has been proposed to be realized in the Ba$_8$CoNb$_6$O$_{24}$ compound. The ground-state and thermodynamic properties are evaluated from a high-temperature series expansions interpolation method, called "entropy method", and compared to experiments. We find a ground-state energy $e_0 = -0.5445(2)$ in perfect agreement with exact diagonalization results. We also calculate the specific heat and entropy at all temperatures, finding a good agreement with the latest experiments, and evaluate which further interactions could improve the comparison. We explore the spatially anisotropic triangular lattice and provide evidence that supports the existence of a gapped spin liquid between the square and triangular lattices.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2022; v1 submitted 15 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Logarithmic divergent specific heat from high-temperature series expansions: application to the two-dimensional XXZ Heisenberg model
Authors:
M. G. Gonzalez,
B. Bernu,
L. Pierre,
L. Messio
Abstract:
We present an interpolation method for the specific heat $c_v(T)$, when there is a phase transition with a logarithmic singularity in $c_v$ at a critical temperature $T=T_c$. The method uses the fact that $c_v$ is constrained both by its high temperature series expansion, and just above $T_c$ by the type of singularity. We test our method on the ferro and antiferromagnetic Ising model on the two-d…
▽ More
We present an interpolation method for the specific heat $c_v(T)$, when there is a phase transition with a logarithmic singularity in $c_v$ at a critical temperature $T=T_c$. The method uses the fact that $c_v$ is constrained both by its high temperature series expansion, and just above $T_c$ by the type of singularity. We test our method on the ferro and antiferromagnetic Ising model on the two-dimensional square, triangular, honeycomb, and kagome lattices, where we find an excellent agreement with the exact solutions. We then explore the XXZ Heisenberg model, for which no exact results are available.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2021; v1 submitted 6 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Effect of perturbations on the kagome $S=1/2$ antiferromagnet at all temperatures
Authors:
Bernard Bernu,
Laurent Pierre,
Karim Essafi,
Laura Messio
Abstract:
The ground state of the $S=1/2$ kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet is now recognized as a spin liquid, but its precise nature remains unsettled, even if more and more clues point towards a gapless spin liquid. We use high temperature series expansions (HTSE) to extrapolate the specific heat $c_V(T)$ and the magnetic susceptibility $χ(T)$ over the full temperature range, using an improved entropy me…
▽ More
The ground state of the $S=1/2$ kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet is now recognized as a spin liquid, but its precise nature remains unsettled, even if more and more clues point towards a gapless spin liquid. We use high temperature series expansions (HTSE) to extrapolate the specific heat $c_V(T)$ and the magnetic susceptibility $χ(T)$ over the full temperature range, using an improved entropy method with a self-determination of the ground state energy per site $e_0$. Optimized algorithms give the HTSE coefficients up to unprecedented orders (20 in $1/T$) and as exact functions of the magnetic field. Three extrapolations are presented for different low-$T$ behaviors of $c_V$: exponential (for a gapped system), linear or quadratic (for two different types of gapless spin liquids). We study the effects of various perturbations to the Heisenberg Hamiltonian: Ising anisotropy, Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions, second and third neighbor interactions, and randomly distributed magnetic vacancies. We propose an experimental determination of $χ(T=0)$, which could be non zero, from $c_V$ measurements under different magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2020; v1 submitted 3 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Thermal destruction of chiral order in a two-dimensional model of coupled trihedra
Authors:
Laura Messio,
Jean-Christophe Domenge,
Claire Lhuillier,
Laurent Pierre,
Pascal Viot,
Gregoire Misguich
Abstract:
We introduce a minimal model describing the physics of classical two-dimensional (2D) frustrated Heisenberg systems, where spins order in a non-planar way at T=0. This model, consisting of coupled trihedra (or Ising-$\mathbb{R}P^3$ model), encompasses Ising (chiral) degrees of freedom, spin-wave excitations and $\Z_2$ vortices. Extensive Monte Carlo simulations show that the T=0 chiral order dis…
▽ More
We introduce a minimal model describing the physics of classical two-dimensional (2D) frustrated Heisenberg systems, where spins order in a non-planar way at T=0. This model, consisting of coupled trihedra (or Ising-$\mathbb{R}P^3$ model), encompasses Ising (chiral) degrees of freedom, spin-wave excitations and $\Z_2$ vortices. Extensive Monte Carlo simulations show that the T=0 chiral order disappears at finite temperature in a continuous phase transition in the 2D Ising universality class, despite misleading intermediate-size effects observed at the transition. The analysis of configurations reveals that short-range spin fluctuations and $\Z_2$ vortices proliferate near the chiral domain walls explaining the strong renormalization of the transition temperature. Chiral domain walls can themselves carry an unlocalized $\Z_2$ topological charge, and vortices are then preferentially paired with charged walls. Further, we conjecture that the anomalous size-effects suggest the proximity of the present model to a tricritical point. A body of results is presented, that all support this claim: (i) First-order transitions obtained by Monte Carlo simulations on several related models (ii) Approximate mapping between the Ising-$\mathbb{R}P^3$ model and a dilute Ising model (exhibiting a tricritical point) and, finally, (iii) Mean-field results obtained for Ising-multispin Hamiltonians, derived from the high-temperature expansion for the vector spins of the Ising-$\mathbb{R}P^3$ model.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
-
Chirality and $Z_2$ vortices in an Heisenberg spin model on the kagomé lattice
Authors:
J. -C. Domenge,
C. Lhuillier,
L. Messio,
L. Pierre,
P. Viot
Abstract:
The phase diagram of the classical \jj model on the \kag lattice is investigated using extensive \mc simulations. In a realistic range of parameters, this model has a low-temperature chiral-ordered phase without long-range spin order. We show that the critical transition marking the destruction of chiral order is preempted by the first order proliferation of \Zdeux point defects. The core energy…
▽ More
The phase diagram of the classical \jj model on the \kag lattice is investigated using extensive \mc simulations. In a realistic range of parameters, this model has a low-temperature chiral-ordered phase without long-range spin order. We show that the critical transition marking the destruction of chiral order is preempted by the first order proliferation of \Zdeux point defects. The core energy of these vortices appears to vanish when approaching the T=0 phase boundary, where both \Zdeux defects and gapless magnons contribute to disordering the system at very low temperature. This situation might be typical of a large class of frustrated magnets. Possible relevance for real materials is also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2008; v1 submitted 9 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
Twelve sublattice ordered phase in the J1-J2 model on the kagome lattice
Authors:
Jean-Christophe Domenge,
Philippe Sindzingre,
Claire Lhuillier,
Laurent Pierre
Abstract:
Motivated by recent experiments on an S=1/2 antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice, we investigate the Heisenberg J1-J2 model with ferromagnetic J1 and antiferromagnetic J2. Classically the ground state displays Neel long range order with 12 non-coplanar sublattices. The order parameter has the symmetry of a cuboctahedron so that it fully breaks SO(3) as well as the spin-flip symmetry, and we exp…
▽ More
Motivated by recent experiments on an S=1/2 antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice, we investigate the Heisenberg J1-J2 model with ferromagnetic J1 and antiferromagnetic J2. Classically the ground state displays Neel long range order with 12 non-coplanar sublattices. The order parameter has the symmetry of a cuboctahedron so that it fully breaks SO(3) as well as the spin-flip symmetry, and we expect from the latter a Z2 symmetry breaking pattern. As might be expected from the Mermin-Wagner theorem in two dimensions, the SO(3) symmetry is restored by thermal fluctuations while the Z2 symmetry breaking persists up to a finite temperature. A complete study of S=1/2 exact spectra reveals that the classical order subsists for quantum spins in a finite range of parameters. First order spin wave calculations give the range of existence of this phase and the renormalisations at T=0 of the order parameters associated to both symmetry breakings. This phase is destroyed by quantum fluctuations for a small but finite J2/|J1|\simeq3 consistently with exact spectra studies which indicate a gapped phase.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2005; v1 submitted 17 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
Determination of the exchange energies in Li2VOSiO4 from a high-temperature series analysis of the square lattice J1-J2 Heisenberg model
Authors:
G. Misguich,
B. Bernu,
L. Pierre
Abstract:
We present a high-temperature expansion (HTE) of the magnetic susceptibility and specific heat data of Melzi et al. on Li2VOSiO4 [Phys. Rev. B 64, 024409 (2001)]. The data are very well reproduced by the J1-J2 Heisenberg model on the square lattice with exchange energies J1=1.25+-0.5 K and J2=5.95+-0.2 K. The maximum of the specific heat Cv^{max}(T_{max}) is obtained as a function J2/J1 from an…
▽ More
We present a high-temperature expansion (HTE) of the magnetic susceptibility and specific heat data of Melzi et al. on Li2VOSiO4 [Phys. Rev. B 64, 024409 (2001)]. The data are very well reproduced by the J1-J2 Heisenberg model on the square lattice with exchange energies J1=1.25+-0.5 K and J2=5.95+-0.2 K. The maximum of the specific heat Cv^{max}(T_{max}) is obtained as a function J2/J1 from an improved method based on HTE.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2003;
originally announced February 2003.
-
Magneto-thermodynamics of the spin-1/2 Kagome antiferromagnet
Authors:
Philippe Sindzingre,
Gregoire Misguich,
Claire Lhuillier,
Bernard Bernu,
Laurent Pierre,
Christian Waldtmann,
Hans U. Everts
Abstract:
In this paper, we use a new hybrid method to compute the thermodynamic behavior of the spin-1/2 Kagome antiferromagnet under the influence of a large external magnetic field. We find a T^2 low-temperature behavior and a very low sensitivity of the specific heat to a strong external magnetic field. We display clear evidence that this low temperature magneto-thermal effect is associated to the exi…
▽ More
In this paper, we use a new hybrid method to compute the thermodynamic behavior of the spin-1/2 Kagome antiferromagnet under the influence of a large external magnetic field. We find a T^2 low-temperature behavior and a very low sensitivity of the specific heat to a strong external magnetic field. We display clear evidence that this low temperature magneto-thermal effect is associated to the existence of low-lying fluctuating singlets, but also that the whole picture (T^2 behavior of Cv and thermally activated spin susceptibility) implies contribution of both non magnetic and magnetic excitations. Comparison with experiments is made.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2000; v1 submitted 15 July, 1999;
originally announced July 1999.
-
First excitations of the spin 1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagomé lattice
Authors:
Ch. Waldtmann,
H. -U. Everts,
B. Bernu,
P. Sindzingre,
C. Lhuillier,
P. Lecheminant,
L. Pierre
Abstract:
We study the exact low energy spectra of the spin 1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on small samples of the kagomé lattice of up to N=36 sites. In agreement with the conclusions of previous authors, we find that these low energy spectra contradict the hypothesis of Néel type long range order. Certainly, the ground state of this system is a spin liquid, but its properties are rather unusual. The mag…
▽ More
We study the exact low energy spectra of the spin 1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on small samples of the kagomé lattice of up to N=36 sites. In agreement with the conclusions of previous authors, we find that these low energy spectra contradict the hypothesis of Néel type long range order. Certainly, the ground state of this system is a spin liquid, but its properties are rather unusual. The magnetic ($ΔS=1$) excitations are separated from the ground state by a gap. However, this gap is filled with nonmagnetic ($ΔS=0$) excitations. In the thermodynamic limit the spectrum of these nonmagnetic excitations will presumably develop into a gapless continuum adjacent to the ground state. Surprisingly, the eigenstates of samples with an odd number of sites, i.e. samples with an unsaturated spin, exhibit symmetries which could support long range chiral order. We do not know if these states will be true thermodynamic states or only metastable ones. In any case, the low energy properties of the spin 1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagomé lattice clearly distinguish this system from either a short range RVB spin liquid or a standard chiral spin liquid. Presumably they are facets of a generically new state of frustrated two-dimensional quantum antiferromagnets.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 1998;
originally announced February 1998.
-
Order versus Disorder in the Quantum Heisenberg Antiferromagnet on the Kagom{é} lattice: an approach through exact spectra analysis
Authors:
P. Lecheminant,
B. Bernu,
C. Lhuillier,
L. Pierre,
P. Sindzingre
Abstract:
A group symmetry analysis of the low lying levels of the spin-1/2 kagomé Heisenberg antiferromagnet is performed for small samples up to N=27. This approach allows to follow the effect of quantum fluctuations when the sample size increases. The results contradict the scenario of ``order by disorder'' which has been advanced on the basis of large S calculations. A large enough second neighbor fer…
▽ More
A group symmetry analysis of the low lying levels of the spin-1/2 kagomé Heisenberg antiferromagnet is performed for small samples up to N=27. This approach allows to follow the effect of quantum fluctuations when the sample size increases. The results contradict the scenario of ``order by disorder'' which has been advanced on the basis of large S calculations. A large enough second neighbor ferromagnetic exchange coupling is needed to stabilize the $\sqrt 3 \times \sqrt 3$ pattern: the finite size analysis indicates a quantum critical transition at a non zero coupling.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 1997;
originally announced June 1997.
-
$J_1-J_2$ quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the triangular lattice: a group symmetry analysis of order by disorder
Authors:
P. Lecheminant,
B. Bernu,
C. Lhuillier,
L. Pierre
Abstract:
On the triangular lattice, for $J_2/J_1$ between $1/8$ and $1$, the classical Heisenberg model with first and second neighbor interactions presents four-sublattice ordered ground-states. Spin-wave calculations of Chubukov and Jolicoeur\cite{cj92} and Korshunov\cite{k93} suggest that quantum fluctuations select amongst these states a colinear two-sublattice order. From theoretical requirements, w…
▽ More
On the triangular lattice, for $J_2/J_1$ between $1/8$ and $1$, the classical Heisenberg model with first and second neighbor interactions presents four-sublattice ordered ground-states. Spin-wave calculations of Chubukov and Jolicoeur\cite{cj92} and Korshunov\cite{k93} suggest that quantum fluctuations select amongst these states a colinear two-sublattice order. From theoretical requirements, we develop the full symmetry analysis of the low lying levels of the spin-1/2 Hamiltonian in the hypotheses of either a four or a two-sublattice order. We show on the exact spectra of periodic samples ($N=12,16$ and $28$) how quantum fluctuations select the colinear order from the four-sublattice order.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 1995;
originally announced April 1995.
-
Exact spectra, spin susceptibilities and order parameter of the quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the triangular lattice
Authors:
B. Bernu,
P. Lecheminant,
C. Lhuillier,
L. Pierre
Abstract:
Exact spectra of periodic samples are computed up to $ N=36 $.
Evidence of an extensive set of low lying levels, lower than the softest magnons, is exhibited.
These low lying quantum states are degenerated in the thermodynamic limit; their symmetries and dynamics as well as their finite-size scaling are strong arguments in favor of Néel order.
It is shown that the Néel order parameter agre…
▽ More
Exact spectra of periodic samples are computed up to $ N=36 $.
Evidence of an extensive set of low lying levels, lower than the softest magnons, is exhibited.
These low lying quantum states are degenerated in the thermodynamic limit; their symmetries and dynamics as well as their finite-size scaling are strong arguments in favor of Néel order.
It is shown that the Néel order parameter agrees with first-order spin-wave calculations. A simple explanation of the low energy dynamics is given as well as the numerical determinations of the energies, order parameter and spin susceptibilities of the studied samples. It is shown how suitable boundary conditions, which do not frustrate Néel order, allow the study of samples with $ N=3p+1 $ spins.
A thorough study of these situations is done in parallel with the more conventional case $ N=3p $.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 1994;
originally announced July 1994.
