-
Coevolving aerodynamic and impact ripples on Earth
Authors:
Hezi Yizhaq,
Katharina Tholen,
Lior Saban,
Nitzan Swet,
Conner Lester,
Simone Silvestro,
Keld R. Rasmussen,
Jonathan P. Merrison,
Jens J. Iversen,
Gabriele Franzese,
Klaus Kroy,
Thomas Pähtz,
Orencio Durán,
Itzhak Katra
Abstract:
Windblown sand creates multiscale bedforms on Earth, Mars, and other planetary bodies. According to conventional wisdom, decameter-scale dunes and decimeter-scale ripples emerge via distinct mechanisms on Earth: a hydrodynamic instability related to a phase shift between the turbulent flow and the topography, and a granular instability related to a synchronization of hopping grains with the topogr…
▽ More
Windblown sand creates multiscale bedforms on Earth, Mars, and other planetary bodies. According to conventional wisdom, decameter-scale dunes and decimeter-scale ripples emerge via distinct mechanisms on Earth: a hydrodynamic instability related to a phase shift between the turbulent flow and the topography, and a granular instability related to a synchronization of hopping grains with the topography. Here, we report the reproducible creation of coevolving centimeter and decimeter-scale ripples on fine-grained monodisperse sand beds in ambient-air and low-pressure wind-tunnels, revealing two adjacent mesoscale growth instabilities. Their morphological traits and our quantitative grain-scale numerical simulations authenticate the smaller structures as impact ripples but point at a hydrodynamic origin for the larger ones. This suggests that the aeolian transport layer would have to partially respond to the topography on a scale comparable to the average hop length, hence faster than previously thought, but consistent with the phase lag of the inferred aeolian sand flux relative to the wind. Hydrodynamic modelling supports the existence of hydrodynamic aerodynamic ripples on Earth, connecting them mechanistically to megaripples and to the debated Martian ripples. We thereby propose a unified framework for mesoscale granular bedforms found across the Solar System.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Unified Flow Rule of Undeveloped and Fully Developed Dense Granular Flows Down Rough Inclines
Authors:
Yanbin Wu,
Thomas Pähtz,
Zixiao Guo,
Lu Jing,
Zhao Duan,
Zhiguo He
Abstract:
We report on chute measurements of the free-surface velocity $v$ in dense flows of spheres and diverse sands and spheres-sand mixtures down rough inclines. These and previous measurements are inconsistent with standard flow rules, in which the Froude number $v/\sqrt{gh}$ scales linearly with $h/h_s$ or $(\tanθ/μ_r)^2h/h_s$, where $μ_r$ is the dynamic friction coefficient, $h$ the flow thickness, a…
▽ More
We report on chute measurements of the free-surface velocity $v$ in dense flows of spheres and diverse sands and spheres-sand mixtures down rough inclines. These and previous measurements are inconsistent with standard flow rules, in which the Froude number $v/\sqrt{gh}$ scales linearly with $h/h_s$ or $(\tanθ/μ_r)^2h/h_s$, where $μ_r$ is the dynamic friction coefficient, $h$ the flow thickness, and $h_s(θ)$ its smallest value that permits a steady, uniform dense flow state at a given inclination angle $θ$. This is because the characteristic length $L$ a flow needs to fully develop can exceed the chute or travel length $l$ and because neither rule is universal for fully developed flows across granular materials. We use a dimensional analysis motivated by a recent unification of sediment transport to derive a flow rule that solves both problems in accordance with our and previous measurements: $v=v_\infty[1-\exp(-l/L)]^{1/2}$, with $v_\infty\proptoμ_r^{3/2}\left[(\tanθ-μ_r)h\right]^{4/3}$ and $L\proptoμ_r^3\left[(\tanθ-μ_r)h\right]^{5/3}h$.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Effects of particle elongation on dense granular flows down a rough inclined plane
Authors:
Jixiong Liu,
Lu Jing,
Thomas Pähtz,
Yifei Cui,
Gordon G. D. Zhou,
Xudong Fu
Abstract:
Granular materials in nature are nearly always non-spherical, but particle shape effects in granular flow remain largely elusive. This study uses discrete element method simulations to investigate how elongated particle shapes affect the mobility of dense granular flows down a rough incline. For a range of systematically varied particle length-to-diameter aspect ratios (AR), we run simulations wit…
▽ More
Granular materials in nature are nearly always non-spherical, but particle shape effects in granular flow remain largely elusive. This study uses discrete element method simulations to investigate how elongated particle shapes affect the mobility of dense granular flows down a rough incline. For a range of systematically varied particle length-to-diameter aspect ratios (AR), we run simulations with various flow thicknesses $h$ and slope angles $θ$ to extract the well-known $h_\textrm{stop}(θ)$ curves (below which the flow ceases) and the $Fr$-$h/h_\textrm{stop}$ relations following Pouliquen's approach, where $Fr=u/\sqrt{gh}$ is the Froude number, $u$ is the mean flow velocity, and $g$ is the gravitational acceleration. The slope $β$ of the $Fr$-$h/h_\textrm{stop}$ relations shows an intriguing S-shaped dependence on AR, with two plateaus at small and large AR, respectively, transitioning with a sharp increase. We understand this S-shaped dependence by examining statistics of particle orientation, alignment, and hindered rotation. We find that the rotation ability of weakly elongated particles ($\textrm{AR}\lesssim1.3$) remains similar to spheres, leading to the first plateau in the $β$-AR relation, whereas the effects of particle orientation saturates beyond $\textrm{AR}\approx2.0$, explaining the second plateau. An empirical sigmoidal function is proposed to capture this non-linear dependence. The findings are expected to enhance our understanding of how particle shape affects the flow of granular materials from both the flow- and particle-scale perspectives.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Dispersive wave propagation in disordered flexible fibers enhances stress attenuation
Authors:
Peng Wang,
Thomas Pähtz,
Kun Luo,
Yu Guo
Abstract:
We experimentally and computationally analyze impact-shock-induced stress wave propagation in packings of disordered flexible fibers. We find that dispersive wave propagation, associated with large stress attenuation, occurs much more prevalently in systems with larger fiber aspect ratios and moderate fiber flexibility. We trace these features to the microstructural properties of fiber contact cha…
▽ More
We experimentally and computationally analyze impact-shock-induced stress wave propagation in packings of disordered flexible fibers. We find that dispersive wave propagation, associated with large stress attenuation, occurs much more prevalently in systems with larger fiber aspect ratios and moderate fiber flexibility. We trace these features to the microstructural properties of fiber contact chains and the energy-trapping abilities of deformable fibers. These findings provide new insights into physics of the shock-impacted flexible fiber packings and open the way towards an improved granular-material-based damping technology.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Rectifying bedload flux variability from channel geometry and grain shape effects
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Yulan Chen,
Jiafeng Xie,
Rémi Monthiller,
Raphaël Maurin,
Katharina Tholen,
Yen-Cheng Lin,
Hao-Che Ho,
Peng Hu,
Zhiguo He,
Orencio Durán
Abstract:
Bedload transport occurs when a bed composed of sedimentary grains becomes mobile in response to the shearing by a flow of liquid. It shapes the landscapes of Earth and other planetary bodies by promoting the formation and growth of various multiscale geological features. Estimating the rate at which such processes take place requires accurate bedload flux predictions. However, even for highly ide…
▽ More
Bedload transport occurs when a bed composed of sedimentary grains becomes mobile in response to the shearing by a flow of liquid. It shapes the landscapes of Earth and other planetary bodies by promoting the formation and growth of various multiscale geological features. Estimating the rate at which such processes take place requires accurate bedload flux predictions. However, even for highly idealized conditions in the laboratory, study-to-study variability of reported bedload flux measurements borders an order of magnitude. This uncertainty stems from physically poorly supported, typically empirical methods to account for channel geometry effects in the determination of the transport-driving bed shear stress and from study-to-study grain shape variations. Here, we derive and validate a universal method of bed shear stress determination and apply it to a number of independent grain-shape-controlled data sets from experiments and CFD-DEM simulations for a very diverse range of transport conditions. An existing physical bedload flux model, here generalized to account for grain shape variability, predicts almost all these data within a factor of 1.3, whereas a recently proposed grain shape correction of the bed shear stress (Deal et al., Nature 613, 298-302, 2023) substantially increases the bedload flux scatter across weak and intense transport conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2024; v1 submitted 11 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Influence of slope angle on deposit morphology and propagation of laboratory landslides
Authors:
Yan-Bin Wu,
Zhao Duan,
Jian-Bing Peng,
Qing Zhang,
Thomas Pähtz
Abstract:
Landslide deposits often exhibit surface features, such as transverse ridges and X-shaped conjugate troughs, whose physical formation origins are not well understood. To study the deposit morphology, laboratory studies typically focus on the simplest landslide geometry: an inclined plane accelerating the sliding mass immediately followed by its deceleration on a horizontal plane. However, existing…
▽ More
Landslide deposits often exhibit surface features, such as transverse ridges and X-shaped conjugate troughs, whose physical formation origins are not well understood. To study the deposit morphology, laboratory studies typically focus on the simplest landslide geometry: an inclined plane accelerating the sliding mass immediately followed by its deceleration on a horizontal plane. However, existing experiments have been conducted only for a limited range of the slope angle $θ$. Here, we study the effect of $θ$ on the kinematics and deposit morphology of laboratory landslides along a low-friction base, measured using an advanced 3D scanner. At low $θ$ (30°-35°), we find transverse ridges formed by overthrusting on the landslide deposits. At moderate $θ$ (40°-55°), conjugate troughs form. A Mohr-Coulomb failure model predicts the angle enclosed by the X-shaped troughs as 90°-$φ$, with $φ$ the internal friction angle, in agreement with our experiments and a natural landslide. This supports the speculation that conjugate troughs form due to failure associated with a triaxial shear stress. At high $θ$ (60°-85°), a double-upheaval morphology forms because the rear of the sliding mass impacts the front during the transition from the slope to the horizontal plane. The overall surface area of the landslides increases during their downslope motion and then decreases during their runout.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Shear thinning of non-Brownian suspensions and its variation at different ambient conditions
Authors:
Yuan Lin,
Peiwen Lin,
Ying Wang,
Jiawang Chen,
Zhiguo He,
Thomas Pähtz,
Nhan Phan-Thien
Abstract:
Immiscible contaminants are commonly involved in naturally occurring suspensions. The resulting variations of their flow behavior has rarely been evaluated. Here, we investigate the variation of the viscosity of the oil-based two-phase suspension over a period of two years, which is exposed to the ambient air at the production stage. We find that the air's absolute humidity, which strongly varies…
▽ More
Immiscible contaminants are commonly involved in naturally occurring suspensions. The resulting variations of their flow behavior has rarely been evaluated. Here, we investigate the variation of the viscosity of the oil-based two-phase suspension over a period of two years, which is exposed to the ambient air at the production stage. We find that the air's absolute humidity, which strongly varies with the seasons, causes exchanges of water droplets with the suspension, substantially altering its shear-thinning behavior. Only in winter, when the humidity is low, is the latter close to that of ideal two-phase suspensions. Our measurements suggest that, when the surface roughness of the suspended solid particles is sufficiently low, immersed droplets remain in a free state, effectively increasing repulsion between particles, weakening shear thinning. In contrast, when the roughness is sufficiently high, immersed droplets become trapped on the particle surfaces, inducing an attractive particle interaction via water bridging, enhancing shear thinning.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Anomalous Scaling of Aeolian Sand Transport Reveals Coupling to Bed Rheology
Authors:
Katharina Tholen,
Thomas Pähtz,
Sandesh Kamath,
Eric J. R. Parteli,
Klaus Kroy
Abstract:
Predicting transport rates of windblown sand is a central problem in aeolian research, with implications for climate, environmental, and planetary sciences. Though studied since the 1930s, the underlying many-body dynamics is still incompletely understood, as underscored by the recent empirical discovery of an unexpected third-root scaling in the particle-fluid density ratio. Here, by means of gra…
▽ More
Predicting transport rates of windblown sand is a central problem in aeolian research, with implications for climate, environmental, and planetary sciences. Though studied since the 1930s, the underlying many-body dynamics is still incompletely understood, as underscored by the recent empirical discovery of an unexpected third-root scaling in the particle-fluid density ratio. Here, by means of grain-scale simulations and analytical modeling, we elucidate how a complex coupling between grain-bed collisions and granular creep within the sand bed yields a dilatancy-enhanced bed erodibility. Our minimal saltation model robustly predicts both the observed scaling and a new undersaturated steady transport state that we confirm by simulations for rarefied atmospheres.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Megaripple mechanics: bimodal transport ingrained in bimodal sands
Authors:
Katharina Tholen,
Thomas Pähtz,
Hezi Yizhaq,
Itzhak Katra,
Klaus Kroy
Abstract:
Aeolian sand transport is a major process shaping landscapes on Earth and on diverse celestial bodies. Conditions favoring bimodal sand transport, with fine-grain saltation driving coarse-grain reptation, give rise to the evolution of megaripples with a characteristic bimodal sand composition. Here, we derive a unified phase diagram for this special aeolian process and the ensuing nonequilibrium m…
▽ More
Aeolian sand transport is a major process shaping landscapes on Earth and on diverse celestial bodies. Conditions favoring bimodal sand transport, with fine-grain saltation driving coarse-grain reptation, give rise to the evolution of megaripples with a characteristic bimodal sand composition. Here, we derive a unified phase diagram for this special aeolian process and the ensuing nonequilibrium megaripple morphodynamics by means of a conceptually simple quantitative model, grounded in the grain-scale physics. We establish a well-preserved quantitative signature of bimodal aeolian transport in the otherwise highly variable grain size distributions, namely, the log-scale width (Krumbein phi scale) of their coarse-grain peaks. A comprehensive collection of terrestrial and extraterrestrial data, covering a wide range of geographical sources and environmental conditions, supports the accuracy and robustness of this unexpected theoretical finding. It could help to resolve ambiguities in the classification of terrestrial and extraterrestrial sedimentary bedforms.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Scaling laws for planetary sediment transport from DEM-RANS numerical simulations
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Orencio Duŕan
Abstract:
We use an established discrete element method (DEM) Reynolds-averaged Navier--Stokes (RANS)-based numerical model to simulate non-suspended sediment transport across conditions encompassing almost seven orders of magnitude in the particle--fluid density ratio $s$, ranging from subaqueous transport ($s=2.65$) to aeolian transport in the highly rarefied atmosphere of Pluto ($s=10^7$), whereas previo…
▽ More
We use an established discrete element method (DEM) Reynolds-averaged Navier--Stokes (RANS)-based numerical model to simulate non-suspended sediment transport across conditions encompassing almost seven orders of magnitude in the particle--fluid density ratio $s$, ranging from subaqueous transport ($s=2.65$) to aeolian transport in the highly rarefied atmosphere of Pluto ($s=10^7$), whereas previous DEM-based sediment transport studies did not exceed terrestrial aeolian conditions ($s\approx2000$). Guided by these simulations and by experiments, we semi-empirically derive simple scaling laws for the cessation threshold and rate of equilibrium aeolian transport, both exhibiting a rather unusual $s^{1/3}$-dependence. They constitute a simple means to make predictions of aeolian processes across a large range of planetary conditions. The derivation consists of a first-principle-based proof of the statement that, under relatively mild assumptions, the cessation threshold physics is controlled by only one dimensionless control parameter, rather than two expected from dimensional analysis. Crucially, unlike existing models, this proof does not resort to coarse-graining the particle phase of the aeolian transport layer above the bed surface. From the pool of existing models, only that by Pähtz et al. (\textit{J. Geophys. Res. Earth. Surf.}~126, e2020JF005859, 2021) is somewhat consistent with the combined numerical and experimental data. It captures the scaling of the cessation threshold and the $s^{1/3}$-dependence of the transport rate, but fails to capture the latter's superimposed grain size dependence. This hints at a lack of understanding of the transport rate physics and calls for future studies on this issue.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2023; v1 submitted 1 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Aeolian sand transport: Scaling of mean saltation length and height and implications for mass flux scaling
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Katharina Tholen
Abstract:
Wind tunnel measurements of the mean saltation length $L$ and of different proxies of the mean saltation height $H$ in saturated aeolian sand transport indicate that $L$ and $H$ are relatively insensitive to both the wind speed and grain diameter $d$. The latter result is currently unexplained and contradicts the theoretical prediction $L\propto H\propto d$. This prediction is based on the assumpt…
▽ More
Wind tunnel measurements of the mean saltation length $L$ and of different proxies of the mean saltation height $H$ in saturated aeolian sand transport indicate that $L$ and $H$ are relatively insensitive to both the wind speed and grain diameter $d$. The latter result is currently unexplained and contradicts the theoretical prediction $L\propto H\propto d$. This prediction is based on the assumption that the characteristic velocity $\sqrt{\tilde gd}$ of bed grains ejected by the splash of an impacting grain controls the average saltation kinematics. Here, we show that a recent analytical saltation model that considers only rebounds of saltating grains, but neglects splash ejection, is consistent with the measurements. The model suggests that the buffer layer of the inner turbulent boundary layer, which connects the viscous sublayer with the log-layer, is partially responsible for the insensitivity of $L$ and $H$ to $d$. In combination, the measurements and model therefore indicate that splash ejection, though important to sustain saltation, does not significantly affect the average saltation kinematics. This finding represents a strong argument against the Ungar and Haff (1987)-scaling and in favor of the Durán et al. (2011)-scaling of the saturated saltation mass flux, with implications for ripple formation on Mars. Furthermore, it supports the recent controversial claim that this flux is insensitive to soil cohesion.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
The physics of sediment transport initiation, cessation, and entrainment across aeolian and fluvial environments
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Abram H. Clark,
Manousos Valyrakis,
Orencio Durán
Abstract:
Predicting the morphodynamics of sedimentary landscapes due to fluvial and aeolian flows requires answering the following questions: Is the flow strong enough to initiate sediment transport, is the flow strong enough to sustain sediment transport once initiated, and how much sediment is transported by the flow in the saturated state (i.e., what is the transport capacity)? In the geomorphological a…
▽ More
Predicting the morphodynamics of sedimentary landscapes due to fluvial and aeolian flows requires answering the following questions: Is the flow strong enough to initiate sediment transport, is the flow strong enough to sustain sediment transport once initiated, and how much sediment is transported by the flow in the saturated state (i.e., what is the transport capacity)? In the geomorphological and related literature, the widespread consensus has been that the initiation, cessation, and capacity of fluvial transport, and the initiation of aeolian transport, are controlled by fluid entrainment of bed sediment caused by flow forces overcoming local resisting forces, whereas aeolian transport cessation and capacity are controlled by impact entrainment caused by the impacts of transported particles with the bed. Here the physics of sediment transport initiation, cessation, and capacity is reviewed with emphasis on recent consensus-challenging developments in sediment transport experiments, two-phase flow modeling, and the incorporation of granular physics' concepts. Highlighted are the similarities between dense granular flows and sediment transport, such as a superslow granular motion known as creeping (which occurs for arbitrarily weak driving flows) and system-spanning force networks that resist bed sediment entrainment; the roles of the magnitude and duration of turbulent fluctuation events in fluid entrainment; the traditionally overlooked role of particle-bed impacts in triggering entrainment events in fluvial transport; and the common physical underpinning of transport thresholds across aeolian and fluvial environments. This sheds a new light on the well-known Shields diagram, where measurements of fluid entrainment thresholds could actually correspond to entrainment-independent cessation thresholds.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2020; v1 submitted 18 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Unified model of sediment transport threshold and rate across weak and intense subaqueous bedload, windblown sand, and windblown snow
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Yonghui Liu,
Yuezhang Xia,
Peng Hu,
Zhiguo He,
Katharina Tholen
Abstract:
Nonsuspended sediment transport (NST) refers to the sediment transport regime in which the flow turbulence is unable to support the weight of transported grains. It occurs in fluvial environments (i.e., driven by a stream of liquid) and in aeolian environments (i.e., wind-blown) and plays a key role in shaping sedimentary landscapes of planetary bodies. NST is a highly fluctuating physical process…
▽ More
Nonsuspended sediment transport (NST) refers to the sediment transport regime in which the flow turbulence is unable to support the weight of transported grains. It occurs in fluvial environments (i.e., driven by a stream of liquid) and in aeolian environments (i.e., wind-blown) and plays a key role in shaping sedimentary landscapes of planetary bodies. NST is a highly fluctuating physical process because of turbulence, surface inhomogeneities, and variations of grain size and shape and packing geometry. Furthermore, the energy of transported grains varies strongly due to variations of their flow exposure duration since their entrainment from the bed. In spite of such variability, we here propose a deterministic model that represents the entire grain motion, including grains that roll and/or slide along the bed, by a periodic saltation motion with rebound laws that describe an average rebound of a grain after colliding with the bed. The model simultaneously captures laboratory and field measurements and discrete element method (DEM)-based numerical simulations of the threshold and rate of equilibrium NST within a factor of about 2, unifying weak and intense transport conditions in oil, water, and air (oil only for threshold). The model parameters have not been adjusted to these measurements but determined from independent data sets. Recent DEM-based numerical simulations (Comola, Gaume, et al., 2019, https://doi.org/10.1029/2019GL082195) suggest that equilibrium aeolian NST on Earth is insensitive to the strength of cohesive bonds between bed grains. Consistently, the model captures cohesive windblown sand and windblown snow conditions despite not explicitly accounting for cohesion.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2021; v1 submitted 16 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Unification of Aeolian and Fluvial Sediment Transport Rate from Granular Physics
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Orencio Durán
Abstract:
One of the physically least understood characteristics of geophysical transport of sediments along sediment surfaces is the well known experimental observation that the sediment transport rate $Q$ is linearly dependent on the fluid shear stress $τ$ applied onto the surface in air, but is nonlinearly dependent on $τ$ in water. Using transport simulations for a wide range of driving conditions, we s…
▽ More
One of the physically least understood characteristics of geophysical transport of sediments along sediment surfaces is the well known experimental observation that the sediment transport rate $Q$ is linearly dependent on the fluid shear stress $τ$ applied onto the surface in air, but is nonlinearly dependent on $τ$ in water. Using transport simulations for a wide range of driving conditions, we show that the scaling depends on the manner in which the kinetic fluctuation energy of transported particles is dissipated: via predominantly fluid drag and quasistatic contacts (linear) versus fluid drag and quasistatic and collisional contacts (nonlinear). We use this finding to derive a scaling law (asymptotically $Q\simτ^2$) in simultaneous agreement with measurements in water and air streams.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2020; v1 submitted 25 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Local Rheology Relation with Variable Yield Stress Ratio across Dry, Wet, Dense, and Dilute Granular Flows
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Orencio Durán,
David N. de Klerk,
Indresan Govender,
Martin Trulsson
Abstract:
Dry, wet, dense, and dilute granular flows have been previously considered fundamentally different and thus described by distinct, and in many cases incompatible, rheologies. We carry out extensive simulations of granular flows, including wet and dry conditions, various geometries and driving mechanisms (boundary driven, fluid driven, and gravity driven), many of which are not captured by standard…
▽ More
Dry, wet, dense, and dilute granular flows have been previously considered fundamentally different and thus described by distinct, and in many cases incompatible, rheologies. We carry out extensive simulations of granular flows, including wet and dry conditions, various geometries and driving mechanisms (boundary driven, fluid driven, and gravity driven), many of which are not captured by standard rheology models. For all simulated conditions, except for fluid-driven and gravity-driven flows close to the flow threshold, we find that the Mohr-Coulomb friction coefficient $μ$ scales with the square root of the local Péclet number $\mathrm{Pe}$ provided that the particle diameter exceeds the particle mean free path. With decreasing $\mathrm{Pe}$ and granular temperature gradient $M$, this general scaling breaks down, leading to a yield condition with a variable yield stress ratio characterized by $M$.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2019; v1 submitted 15 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Universal friction law at granular solid-gas transition explains scaling of sediment transport load with excess fluid shear stress
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Orencio Durán
Abstract:
A key interest in geomorphology is to predict how the shear stress $τ$ exerted by a turbulent flow of air or liquid onto an erodible sediment bed affects the transport load $M\tilde g$ (i.e., the submerged weight of transported nonsuspended sediment per unit area) and its average velocity when exceeding the sediment transport threshold $τ_t$. Most transport rate predictions in the literature are b…
▽ More
A key interest in geomorphology is to predict how the shear stress $τ$ exerted by a turbulent flow of air or liquid onto an erodible sediment bed affects the transport load $M\tilde g$ (i.e., the submerged weight of transported nonsuspended sediment per unit area) and its average velocity when exceeding the sediment transport threshold $τ_t$. Most transport rate predictions in the literature are based on the scaling $M\tilde g\proptoτ-τ_t$, the physical origin of which, however, has remained controversial. Here we test the universality and study the origin of this scaling law using particle-scale simulations of nonsuspended sediment transport driven by a large range of Newtonian fluids. We find that the scaling coefficient is a universal approximate constant and can be understood as an inverse granular friction coefficient (i.e., the ratio between granular shear stress and normal-bed pressure) evaluated at the base of the transport layer (i.e., the effective elevation of energetic particle-bed rebounds). Usually, the granular flow at this base is gaslike and rapidly turns into the solidlike granular bed underneath: a liquidlike regime does not necessarily exist, which is accentuated by a nonlocal granular flow rheology in both the transport layer and bed. Hence, this transition fundamentally differs from the solid-liquid transition (i.e., yielding) in dense granular flows even though both transitions are described by a friction law. Combining this result with recent insights into the nature of $τ_t$, we conclude that the transport load scaling is a signature of a steady rebound state and unrelated to entrainment of bed sediment.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2018; v1 submitted 19 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Fluid forces or impacts: What governs the entrainment of soil particles in sediment transport mediated by a Newtonian fluid?
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Orencio Durán
Abstract:
In steady sediment transport, sediment deposition is balanced by entrainment of bed particles by fluid forces or particle-bed impacts. Here we propose a proxy to determine the role of impact entrainment relative to entrainment by the mean turbulent flow: the "bed velocity" $V_b$, which is an effective near-bed-surface value of the average horizontal particle velocity that generalizes the classical…
▽ More
In steady sediment transport, sediment deposition is balanced by entrainment of bed particles by fluid forces or particle-bed impacts. Here we propose a proxy to determine the role of impact entrainment relative to entrainment by the mean turbulent flow: the "bed velocity" $V_b$, which is an effective near-bed-surface value of the average horizontal particle velocity that generalizes the classical slip velocity, used in studies of aeolian saltation transport, to sediment transport in an arbitrary Newtonian fluid. We study $V_b$ for a wide range of the particle-fluid-density ratio $s$, Galileo number $\mathrm{Ga}$, and Shields number $Θ$ using direct sediment transport simulations. We find that transport is fully sustained through impact entrainment (i.e., $V_b$ is constant in natural units) when the "impact number" $\mathrm{Im}=\mathrm{Ga}\sqrt{s+0.5}\gtrsim20$ or $Θ\gtrsim5/\mathrm{Im}$. These conditions are obeyed for the vast majority of transport regimes, including steady turbulent bedload, which has long been thought to be sustained solely through fluid entrainment. In fact, we find that transport is fully sustained through fluid entrainment (i.e., $V_b$ scales with the near-bed horizontal fluid velocity) only for sufficiently viscous bedload transport at grain scale (i.e., for $\mathrm{Im}\lesssim20$ and $Θ\lesssim1/\mathrm{Im}$). Finally, we do not find a strong correlation between, $V_b$, or the classical slip velocity, and the transport-layer-averaged horizontal particle velocity $\overline{v_x}$, which challenges the long-standing consensus that predominant impact entrainment is responsible for a linear scaling of the transport rate with $Θ$. For turbulent bedload in particular, $\overline{v_x}$ increases with $Θ$ despite $V_b$ remaining constant, which we propose is linked to the formation of a liquid-like bed on top of the static-bed surface.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2017; v1 submitted 24 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
The Cessation Threshold of Nonsuspended Sediment Transport Across Aeolian and Fluvial Environments
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Orencio Durán
Abstract:
Using particle-scale simulations of non-suspended sediment transport for a large range of Newtonian fluids driving transport, including air and water, we determine the bulk transport cessation threshold $Θ^r_t$ by extrapolating the transport load as a function of the dimensionless fluid shear stress (`Shields number') $Θ$ to the vanishing transport limit. In this limit, the simulated steady states…
▽ More
Using particle-scale simulations of non-suspended sediment transport for a large range of Newtonian fluids driving transport, including air and water, we determine the bulk transport cessation threshold $Θ^r_t$ by extrapolating the transport load as a function of the dimensionless fluid shear stress (`Shields number') $Θ$ to the vanishing transport limit. In this limit, the simulated steady states of continuous transport can be described by simple analytical model equations relating the average transport layer properties to the law of the wall flow velocity profile. We use this model to calculate $Θ^r_t$ for arbitrary environments and derive a general Shields-like threshold diagram in which a Stokes-like number replaces the particle Reynolds number. Despite the simplicity of our hydrodynamic description, the predicted cessation threshold, both from the simulations and analytical model, quantitatively agrees with measurements for transport in air and viscous and turbulent liquids despite not being fitted to these measurements. We interpret the analytical model as a description of a continuous rebound motion of transported particles and thus $Θ^r_t$ as the minimal fluid shear stress needed to compensate the average energy loss of transported particles during an average rebound at the bed surface. This interpretation, supported by simulations near $Θ^r_t$, implies that entrainment mechanisms are needed to sustain transport above $Θ^r_t$. While entrainment by turbulent events sustains intermittent transport, entrainment by particle-bed impacts sustains continuous transport. Combining our interpretations with the critical energy criterion for incipient motion by Valyrakis and coworkers, we put forward a new conceptual picture of sediment transport intermittency.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2018; v1 submitted 23 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Discrete Element Method simulations of the saturation of aeolian sand transport
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Amir Omeradžić,
Marcus V. Carneiro,
Nuno A. M. Araújo,
Hans J. Herrmann
Abstract:
The saturation length of aeolian sand transport ($L_s$), characterizing the distance needed by wind-blown sand to adapt to changes in the wind shear, is essential for accurate modeling of the morphodynamics of Earth's sandy landscapes and for explaining the formation and shape of sand dunes. In the last decade, it has become a widely-accepted hypothesis that $L_s$ is proportional to the characteri…
▽ More
The saturation length of aeolian sand transport ($L_s$), characterizing the distance needed by wind-blown sand to adapt to changes in the wind shear, is essential for accurate modeling of the morphodynamics of Earth's sandy landscapes and for explaining the formation and shape of sand dunes. In the last decade, it has become a widely-accepted hypothesis that $L_s$ is proportional to the characteristic distance needed by transported particles to reach the wind speed (the ``drag length''). Here we challenge this hypothesis. From extensive numerical Discrete Element Method simulations, we find that, for medium and strong winds, $L_s\propto V_s^2/g$, where $V_s$ is the saturated value of the average speed of sand particles traveling above the surface and $g$ the gravitational constant. We show that this proportionality is consistent with a recent analytical model, in which the drag length is just one of four similarly important length scales relevant for sand transport saturation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
The fluctuation energy balance in non-suspended fluid-mediated particle transport
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Orencio Durán,
Tuan-Duc Ho,
Alexandre Valance,
Jasper F. Kok
Abstract:
Here we compare two extreme regimes of non-suspended fluid-mediated particle transport, transport in light and heavy fluids ("saltation" and "bedload", respectively), regarding their particle fluctuation energy balance. From direct numerical simulations, we surprisingly find that the ratio between collisional and fluid drag dissipation of fluctuation energy is significantly larger in saltation tha…
▽ More
Here we compare two extreme regimes of non-suspended fluid-mediated particle transport, transport in light and heavy fluids ("saltation" and "bedload", respectively), regarding their particle fluctuation energy balance. From direct numerical simulations, we surprisingly find that the ratio between collisional and fluid drag dissipation of fluctuation energy is significantly larger in saltation than in bedload, even though the contribution of interparticle collisions to transport of momentum and energy is much smaller in saltation due to the low concentration of particles in the transport layer. We conclude that the much higher frequency of high-energy particle-bed impacts ("splash") in saltation is the cause for this counter-intuitive behavior. Moreover, from a comparison of these simulations to Particle Tracking Velocimetry measurements which we performed in a wind tunnel under steady transport of fine and coarse sand, we find that turbulent fluctuations of the flow produce particle fluctuation energy at an unexpectedly high rate in saltation even under conditions for which the effects of turbulence are usually believed to be small.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Electric Field and Humidity Trigger Contact Electrification
Authors:
Yanzhen Zhang,
Thomas Pähtz,
Yonghong Liu,
Xiaolong Wang,
Rui Zhang,
Yang Shen,
Renjie Ji,
Baoping Cai
Abstract:
Here, we study the old problem of why identical insulators can charge one another on contact. We perform several experiments showing that, if driven by a preexisting electric field, charge is transferred between contacting insulators. This happens because the insulator surfaces adsorb small amounts of water from a humid atmosphere. We believe the electric field then separates positively from negat…
▽ More
Here, we study the old problem of why identical insulators can charge one another on contact. We perform several experiments showing that, if driven by a preexisting electric field, charge is transferred between contacting insulators. This happens because the insulator surfaces adsorb small amounts of water from a humid atmosphere. We believe the electric field then separates positively from negatively charged ions prevailing within the water, which we believe to be hydronium and hydroxide ions, such that at the point of contact, positive ions of one insulator neutralize negative ions of the other one, charging both of them. This mechanism can explain for the first time the observation made four decades ago that wind-blown sand discharges in sparks if and only if a thunderstorm is nearby.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Flux saturation length of sediment transport
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Jasper F. Kok,
Eric J. R. Parteli,
Hans J. Herrmann
Abstract:
Sediment transport along the surface drives geophysical phenomena as diverse as wind erosion and dune formation. The main length-scale controlling the dynamics of sediment erosion and deposition is the saturation length $L_\mathrm{s}$, which characterizes the flux response to a change in transport conditions. Here we derive, for the first time, an expression predicting $L_\mathrm{s}$ as a function…
▽ More
Sediment transport along the surface drives geophysical phenomena as diverse as wind erosion and dune formation. The main length-scale controlling the dynamics of sediment erosion and deposition is the saturation length $L_\mathrm{s}$, which characterizes the flux response to a change in transport conditions. Here we derive, for the first time, an expression predicting $L_\mathrm{s}$ as a function of the average sediment velocity under different physical environments. Our expression accounts for both the characteristics of sediment entrainment and the saturation of particle and fluid velocities, and has only two physical parameters which can be estimated directly from independent experiments. We show that our expression is consistent with measurements of $L_\mathrm{s}$ in both aeolian and subaqueous transport regimes over at least five orders of magnitude in the ratio of fluid and particle density, including on Mars.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Midair collisions enhance saltation
Authors:
Marcus V. Carneiro,
Nuno A. M. Araújo,
Thomas Pähtz,
Hans J. Herrmann
Abstract:
Here we address the old question in Aeolian particle transport about the role of midair collisions. We find that, surprisingly, these collisions do enhance the overall flux substantially. The effect depends strongly on restitution coefficient and wind speed. We can explain this observation as a consequence of a soft-bed of grains which floats above the ground and reflects the highest flying partic…
▽ More
Here we address the old question in Aeolian particle transport about the role of midair collisions. We find that, surprisingly, these collisions do enhance the overall flux substantially. The effect depends strongly on restitution coefficient and wind speed. We can explain this observation as a consequence of a soft-bed of grains which floats above the ground and reflects the highest flying particles. We make the unexpected observation that the flux is maximized at an intermediate restitution coefficient of about 0.7, which is comparable to values experimentally measured for collisions between sand grains.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2015; v1 submitted 19 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Analytical model for flux saturation in sediment transport
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Eric J. R. Parteli,
Jasper F. Kok,
Hans J. Herrmann
Abstract:
The transport of sediment by a fluid along the surface is responsible for dune formation, dust entrainment and for a rich diversity of patterns on the bottom of oceans, rivers, and planetary surfaces. Most previous models of sediment transport have focused on the equilibrium (or saturated) particle flux. However, the morphodynamics of sediment landscapes emerging due to surface transport of sedime…
▽ More
The transport of sediment by a fluid along the surface is responsible for dune formation, dust entrainment and for a rich diversity of patterns on the bottom of oceans, rivers, and planetary surfaces. Most previous models of sediment transport have focused on the equilibrium (or saturated) particle flux. However, the morphodynamics of sediment landscapes emerging due to surface transport of sediment is controlled by situations out-of-equilibrium. In particular, it is controlled by the saturation length characterizing the distance it takes for the particle flux to reach a new equilibrium after a change in flow conditions. The saturation of mass density of particles entrained into transport and the relaxation of particle and fluid velocities constitute the main relevant relaxation mechanisms leading to saturation of the sediment flux. Here we present a theoretical model for sediment transport which, for the first time, accounts for both these relaxation mechanisms and for the different types of sediment entrainment prevailing under different environmental conditions. Our analytical treatment allows us to derive a closed expression for the saturation length of sediment flux, which is general and can thus be applied under different physical conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2015; v1 submitted 13 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
The apparent roughness of a sand surface blown by wind from an analytical model of saltation
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Jasper F. Kok,
Hans J. Herrmann
Abstract:
We present an analytical model of aeolian sand transport. The model quantifies the momentum transfer from the wind to the transported sand by providing expressions for the thickness of the saltation layer and the apparent surface roughness. These expressions are derived from basic physical principles and a small number of assumptions. The model further predicts the sand transport rate (mass flux)…
▽ More
We present an analytical model of aeolian sand transport. The model quantifies the momentum transfer from the wind to the transported sand by providing expressions for the thickness of the saltation layer and the apparent surface roughness. These expressions are derived from basic physical principles and a small number of assumptions. The model further predicts the sand transport rate (mass flux) and the impact threshold (the smallest value of the wind shear velocity at which saltation can be sustained). We show that, in contrast to previous studies, the present model's predictions are in very good agreement with a range of experiments, as well as with numerical simulations of aeolian saltation. Because of its physical basis, we anticipate that our model will find application in studies of aeolian sand transport on both Earth and Mars.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2015; v1 submitted 5 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Jump at the onset of saltation
Authors:
M. V. Carneiro,
T. Pähtz,
H. J. Herrmann
Abstract:
We reveal a discontinuous transition in the saturated flux for aeolian saltation by simulating explicitly particle motion in turbulent flow. The discontinuity is followed by a coexistence interval with two metastable solutions. The modification of the wind profile due to momentum exchange exhibits a second maximum at high shear strength. The saturated flux depends on the strength of the wind as…
▽ More
We reveal a discontinuous transition in the saturated flux for aeolian saltation by simulating explicitly particle motion in turbulent flow. The discontinuity is followed by a coexistence interval with two metastable solutions. The modification of the wind profile due to momentum exchange exhibits a second maximum at high shear strength. The saturated flux depends on the strength of the wind as $q_s=q_0+A(u_*-u_t)(u_*^2+u_t^2)$.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2011; v1 submitted 14 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Why do Particle Clouds Generate Electric Charges?
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Hans J. Herrmann,
Troy Shinbrot
Abstract:
Grains in desert sandstorms spontaneously generate strong electrical charges; likewise volcanic dust plumes produce spectacular lightning displays. Charged particle clouds also cause devastating explosions in food, drug and coal processing industries. Despite the wide-ranging importance of granular charging in both nature and industry, even the simplest aspects of its causes remain elusive, becaus…
▽ More
Grains in desert sandstorms spontaneously generate strong electrical charges; likewise volcanic dust plumes produce spectacular lightning displays. Charged particle clouds also cause devastating explosions in food, drug and coal processing industries. Despite the wide-ranging importance of granular charging in both nature and industry, even the simplest aspects of its causes remain elusive, because it is difficult to understand how inert grains in contact with little more than other inert grains can generate the large charges observed. Here, we present a simple yet predictive explanation for the charging of granular materials in collisional flows. We argue from very basic considerations that charge transfer can be expected in collisions of identical dielectric grains in the presence of an electric field, and we confirm the model's predictions using discrete-element simulations and a tabletop granular experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2015; v1 submitted 26 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
