-
Information cascades and the distribution of economic recessions in the United States
Authors:
Paul Ormerod
Abstract:
The American economy can be thought of as a highly connected random network in terms of both its technological and informational connections. The cumulative size of economic recessions, the fall in output from peak to trough, is analysed for the US economy 1900-2002. A least squares fit of an exponential relationship between size and the rank of size gives a good description of most of the data.…
▽ More
The American economy can be thought of as a highly connected random network in terms of both its technological and informational connections. The cumulative size of economic recessions, the fall in output from peak to trough, is analysed for the US economy 1900-2002. A least squares fit of an exponential relationship between size and the rank of size gives a good description of most of the data. But the observation for the Great Depression of the 1930s stands out as a very distinct outlier. In other words, we observe a bimodal relationship of the type predicted by theory.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2004;
originally announced February 2004.
-
Scaling Behaviour in the Number of Criminal Acts Committed by Individuals
Authors:
William Cook,
Paul Ormerod,
Ellie Cooper
Abstract:
We find subtle deviations from power law behaviour in the number of crimes committed by individuals, analysing the two main criminology databases which track this behaviour, the Pittsburgh Young Offenders survey and the Cambridge UK Study in Delinquent Development. The description of the data when the number of boys committing or reporting zero crimes are excluded is different from that when the…
▽ More
We find subtle deviations from power law behaviour in the number of crimes committed by individuals, analysing the two main criminology databases which track this behaviour, the Pittsburgh Young Offenders survey and the Cambridge UK Study in Delinquent Development. The description of the data when the number of boys committing or reporting zero crimes are excluded is different from that when they are included. The crucial step in the criminal progress of an individual appears to be committing the first act. Once this is done, the number of criminal acts committed by an individual can take place on all scales.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2004;
originally announced February 2004.
-
The Medieval Inquisition: Scale-free Networks and the Suppression of Heresy
Authors:
Paul Ormerod,
Andrew Roach
Abstract:
Qualitative evidence suggests that heresy within the medieval Catholic Church had many of the characteristics of a scale-free network. From the perspective of the Church, heresy can be seen as a virus. The virus persisted for long periods of time, breaking out again even when the Church believed it to have been eradicated. A principal mechanism of heresy was through a small number of individuals…
▽ More
Qualitative evidence suggests that heresy within the medieval Catholic Church had many of the characteristics of a scale-free network. From the perspective of the Church, heresy can be seen as a virus. The virus persisted for long periods of time, breaking out again even when the Church believed it to have been eradicated. A principal mechanism of heresy was through a small number of individuals with very large numbers of social contacts.
Initial attempts by the Inquisition to suppress the virus by general persecution, or even mass slaughtering, of populations thought to harbour the "disease" failed. Gradually, however, the Inquisition learned about the nature of the social networks by which heresy both spread and persisted. Eventually, a policy of targeting key individuals was implemented, which proved to be much more successful.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2003;
originally announced June 2003.
-
Power Law Distribution of the Frequency of Demises of U.S Firms
Authors:
William Cook,
Paul Ormerod
Abstract:
Both theoretical and applied economics have a great deal to say about many aspects of the firm, but the literature on the extinctions, or demises, of firms is very sparse. We use a publicly available data base covering some 6 million firms in the US and show that the underlying statistical distribution which characterises the frequency of firm demises - the disappearances of firms as autonomous…
▽ More
Both theoretical and applied economics have a great deal to say about many aspects of the firm, but the literature on the extinctions, or demises, of firms is very sparse. We use a publicly available data base covering some 6 million firms in the US and show that the underlying statistical distribution which characterises the frequency of firm demises - the disappearances of firms as autonomous entities - is closely approximated by a power law. The exponent of the power law is, intriguingly, close to that reported in the literature on the extinction of biological species.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2002;
originally announced December 2002.
-
System Fitness and the Extinction Patterns of Firms under Pure Economic Competition
Authors:
P Ormerod,
H Johns
Abstract:
The relationships which characterise the outcomes of the interactions between firms in the economy appear to follow power law behaviour. In particular, there is evidence that the empirical power laws which relate the size of an extinction to its frequency are similar for both biological species and firms in the economy .Biological species interact with each other in ways which either increase or…
▽ More
The relationships which characterise the outcomes of the interactions between firms in the economy appear to follow power law behaviour. In particular, there is evidence that the empirical power laws which relate the size of an extinction to its frequency are similar for both biological species and firms in the economy .Biological species interact with each other in ways which either increase or decrease the fitness levels of individual species. In the same way, firms in the economy carry out strategies, and the net outcome of the interactions between firms is to increase or decrease the fitness of other firms.. Models which are used to describe the interactions of biological species can be given straightforward interpretations in terms of the interactions of firms in an industry. The general versions of models of interactions between agents allow for co-operative behaviour between pairs of agents. We contrast the properties of such a model with special cases of it, in which interactions are restricted so that only competitive interactions between pairs of agents are permitted. Such pure economic competition (PEC) behaviour is regarded as desirable by economic theory, The properties of the two models are strikingly different. A power law no longer provides a good description of the relationship between the size and frequency of extinctions in the PEC model, in which there are substantial numbers of very large extinctions. As a result, the level of fitness of the system as a whole remains considerably lower than in the general version of the model. This suggests that models of pure economic competition do not provide a good description of how many industries actually behave, and that a certain amount of collaboration and co-operation between firms is required for the survival of an industry.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2001;
originally announced October 2001.
-
The Convergence of European Business Cycles 1978-2000
Authors:
P Ormerod,
C Mounfield
Abstract:
The degree of convergence of the business cycles of the economies of the European Union is a key policy issue. In particular, a substantial degree of convergence is needed if the European Central Bank is to be capable of setting a monetary policy which is appropriate to the stage of the cycle of the Euro zone economies.
We consider the annual rates of real GDP growth on a quarterly basis in th…
▽ More
The degree of convergence of the business cycles of the economies of the European Union is a key policy issue. In particular, a substantial degree of convergence is needed if the European Central Bank is to be capable of setting a monetary policy which is appropriate to the stage of the cycle of the Euro zone economies.
We consider the annual rates of real GDP growth on a quarterly basis in the large core economies of the EU (France, Germany and Italy, plus the Netherlands) over the period 1978Q1 - 2000Q3. An important empirical question is the degree to which the correlations between these growth rates contain true information rather than noise. The technique of random matrix theory is able to answer this question, and has been recently applied successfully in the physics journals to financial markets data.
We find that the correlations between the growth rates of the core EU economies contain substantial amounts of true information, and exhibit considerable stability over time. Even in the late 1970s and early 1980s, these economies moved together closely over the course of the business cycle. There was a slight loosening at the time of German re-unification, but the economies are now, if anything, even more closely correlated.
In contrast, the results obtained with a data set of the EU core plus the UK show no such trend. In the late 1970s and early 1980s, the UK economy did exhibit some degree of correlation with those of the core EU. However, there is no clear evidence to suggest that the UK business cycle has moved more closely into line with that of the core EU economies over the 1978-2000 period.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2001;
originally announced March 2001.
-
Assessing the Predictability of Social and Economic Time-Series Data: the example of crime in the UK
Authors:
Paul Ormerod,
Laurence Smith
Abstract:
Policy targets are being set increasingly for social and economic variables in the UK. This approach requires that reasonably successful ex ante forecasts can be made. We propose a general methodology for assessing the extent to which this can be done. It has already been applied to GDP growth rate data. In this paper, we illustrate the technique with reference to property and violent crime in t…
▽ More
Policy targets are being set increasingly for social and economic variables in the UK. This approach requires that reasonably successful ex ante forecasts can be made. We propose a general methodology for assessing the extent to which this can be done. It has already been applied to GDP growth rate data. In this paper, we illustrate the technique with reference to property and violent crime in the UK over the post-war period. The forecasting record of the Home Office is poor. We show that this arises from an inherent property of the data, namely a lack of genuine information content. It is not possible in the current state of scientific knowledge to improve significantly on the Home Office record. We relate these findings to the econometric methodology of co-integration, and show that the correlation matrix of the data used in the Home Office models is dominated by noise.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2001;
originally announced February 2001.
-
Power Law Distribution of the Duration and Magnitude of Recessions in Capitalist Economies : Breakdown of Scaling
Authors:
P Ormerod,
C Mounfield
Abstract:
Power law distributions of macroscopic observables are ubiquitous in both the natural and social sciences. They are indicative of correlated, cooperative phenomena between groups of interacting agents at the microscopic level. In this paper we argue that when one is considering aggregate macroeconomic data (annual growth rates in real per capita GDP in the seventeen leading capitalist economies…
▽ More
Power law distributions of macroscopic observables are ubiquitous in both the natural and social sciences. They are indicative of correlated, cooperative phenomena between groups of interacting agents at the microscopic level. In this paper we argue that when one is considering aggregate macroeconomic data (annual growth rates in real per capita GDP in the seventeen leading capitalist economies from 1870 through to 1994) the magnitude and duration of recessions over the business cycle do indeed follow power law like behaviour for a significant proportion of the data (demonstrating the existence of cooperative phenomena amongst economic agents). Crucially, however, there are systematic deviations from this behaviour when one considers the frequency of occurrence of large recessions. Under these circumstances the power law scaling breaks down. It is argued that it is the adaptive behaviour of the agents (their ability to recognise the changing economic environment) which modifies their cooperative behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2001;
originally announced February 2001.
-
Random Matrix Theory and the Failure of Macroeconomic Forecasts
Authors:
P Ormerod,
C Mounfield
Abstract:
By scientific standards, the accuracy of short-term economic forecasts has been poor, and shows no sign of improving over time. We form a delay matrix of time-series data on the overall rate of growth of the economy, with lags spanning the period over which any regularity of behaviour is postulated by economists to exist. We use methods of random matrix theory to analyse the correlation matrix o…
▽ More
By scientific standards, the accuracy of short-term economic forecasts has been poor, and shows no sign of improving over time. We form a delay matrix of time-series data on the overall rate of growth of the economy, with lags spanning the period over which any regularity of behaviour is postulated by economists to exist. We use methods of random matrix theory to analyse the correlation matrix of the delay matrix. This is done for annual data from 1871 to 1994 for 17 economies, and for post-war quarterly data for the US and the UK. The properties of the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of these correlation matrices are similar, though not identical, to those implied by random matrix theory. This suggests that the genuine information content in economic growth data is low, and so forecasting failure arises from inherent properties of the data.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2001;
originally announced February 2001.
