-
Validating N-body code Chrono for granular DEM simulations in reduced-gravity environments
Authors:
Cecily Sunday,
Naomi Murdoch,
Simon Tardivel,
Stephen R. Schwartz,
Patrick Michel
Abstract:
The Discrete Element Method (DEM) is frequently used to model complex granular systems and to augment the knowledge that we obtain through theory, experimentation, and real-world observations. Numerical simulations are a particularly powerful tool for studying the regolith-covered surfaces of asteroids, comets, and small moons, where reduced-gravity environments produce ill-defined flow behaviors.…
▽ More
The Discrete Element Method (DEM) is frequently used to model complex granular systems and to augment the knowledge that we obtain through theory, experimentation, and real-world observations. Numerical simulations are a particularly powerful tool for studying the regolith-covered surfaces of asteroids, comets, and small moons, where reduced-gravity environments produce ill-defined flow behaviors. In this work, we present a method for validating soft-sphere DEM codes for both terrestrial and small-body granular environments. The open-source code Chrono is modified and evaluated first with a series of simple two-body-collision tests, and then, with a set of piling and tumbler tests. In the piling tests, we vary the coefficient of rolling friction to calibrate the simulations against experiments with 1 mm glass beads. Then, we use the friction coefficient to model the flow of 1 mm glass beads in a rotating drum, using a drum configuration from a previous experimental study. We measure the dynamic angle of repose, the flowing layer thickness, and the flowing layer velocity for tests with different particle sizes, contact force models, coefficients of rolling friction, cohesion levels, drum rotation speeds and gravity levels. The tests show that the same flow patterns can be observed at Earth and reduced-gravity levels if the drum rotation speed and the gravity-level are set according to the dimensionless parameter known as the Froude number. Chrono is successfully validated against known flow behaviors at different gravity and cohesion levels, and will be used to study small-body regolith dynamics in future works.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
An experimental study of low-velocity impacts into granular material in reduced gravity
Authors:
Naomi Murdoch,
Iris Avila Martinez,
Cecily Sunday,
Emmanuel Zenou,
Olivier Cherrier,
Alexandre Cadu,
Yves Gourinat
Abstract:
In order to improve our understanding of landing on small bodies and of asteroid evolution, we use our novel drop tower facility to perform low-velocity (2-40 cm s^-1), shallow impact experiments of a 10 cm diameter aluminum sphere into quartz sand in low effective gravities (~0.2-1 m s^-2). Using in situ accelerometers, we measure the acceleration profile during the impacts and determine the peak…
▽ More
In order to improve our understanding of landing on small bodies and of asteroid evolution, we use our novel drop tower facility to perform low-velocity (2-40 cm s^-1), shallow impact experiments of a 10 cm diameter aluminum sphere into quartz sand in low effective gravities (~0.2-1 m s^-2). Using in situ accelerometers, we measure the acceleration profile during the impacts and determine the peak accelerations, collision durations and maximum penetration depth. We find that the penetration depth scales linearly with the collision velocity but is independent of the effective gravity for the experimental range tested, and that the collision duration is independent of both the effective gravity and the collision velocity. No rebounds are observed in any of the experiments. Our low-gravity experimental results indicate that the transition from the quasi-static regime to the inertial regime occurs for impact energies two orders of magnitude smaller than in similar impact experiments under terrestrial gravity. The lower energy regime change may be due to the increased hydrodynamic drag of the surface material in our experiments, but may also support the notion that the quasi-static regime reduces as the effective gravity becomes lower.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Numerical simulations of granular dynamics II. Particle dynamics in a shaken granular material
Authors:
Naomi Murdoch,
Patrick Michel,
Derek C. Richardson,
Kerstin Nordstrom,
Christian R. Berardi,
Simon F. Green,
Wolfgang Losert
Abstract:
Surfaces of planets and small bodies of our Solar System are often covered by a layer of granular material that can range from a fine regolith to a gravel-like structure of varying depths. Therefore, the dynamics of granular materials are involved in many events occurring during planetary and small-body evolution thus contributing to their geological properties.
We demonstrate that the new adapt…
▽ More
Surfaces of planets and small bodies of our Solar System are often covered by a layer of granular material that can range from a fine regolith to a gravel-like structure of varying depths. Therefore, the dynamics of granular materials are involved in many events occurring during planetary and small-body evolution thus contributing to their geological properties.
We demonstrate that the new adaptation of the parallel N-body hard-sphere code pkdgrav has the capability to model accurately the key features of the collective motion of bidisperse granular materials in a dense regime as a result of shaking. As a stringent test of the numerical code we investigate the complex collective ordering and motion of granular material by direct comparison with laboratory experiments. We demonstrate that, as experimentally observed, the scale of the collective motion increases with increasing small-particle additive concentration.
We then extend our investigations to assess how self-gravity and external gravity affect collective motion. In our reduced-gravity simulations both the gravitational conditions and the frequency of the vibrations roughly match the conditions on asteroids subjected to seismic shaking, though real regolith is likely to be much more heterogeneous and less ordered than in our idealised simulations. We also show that collective motion can occur in a granular material under a wide range of inter-particle gravity conditions and in the absence of an external gravitational field. These investigations demonstrate the great interest of being able to simulate conditions that are to relevant planetary science yet unreachable by Earth-based laboratory experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Granular Shear Flow in Varying Gravitational Environments
Authors:
N. Murdoch,
B. Rozitis,
S. F. Green,
T-L de Lophem,
P. Michel,
W. Losert
Abstract:
Despite their very low surface gravities, asteroids exhibit a number of different geological processes involving granular matter. Understanding the response of this granular material subject to external forces in microgravity conditions is vital to the design of a successful asteroid sub-surface sampling mechanism, and in the interpretation of the fascinating geology on an asteroid. We have design…
▽ More
Despite their very low surface gravities, asteroids exhibit a number of different geological processes involving granular matter. Understanding the response of this granular material subject to external forces in microgravity conditions is vital to the design of a successful asteroid sub-surface sampling mechanism, and in the interpretation of the fascinating geology on an asteroid. We have designed and flown a Taylor-Couette shear cell to investigate granular flow due to rotational shear forces under the conditions of parabolic flight microgravity. The experiments occur under weak compression. First, we present the technical details of the experimental design with particular emphasis on how the equipment has been specifically designed for the parabolic flight environment. Then, we investigate how a steady state granular flow induced by rotational shear forces differs in varying gravitational environments. We find that the effect of constant shearing on the granular material, in a direction perpendicular to the effective acceleration, does not seem to be strongly influenced by gravity. This means that shear bands can form in the presence of a weak gravitational field just as on Earth.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Granular Convection in Microgravity
Authors:
N. Murdoch,
B. Rozitis,
K. Nordstrom,
S. F. Green,
P. Michel,
T. -L. de Lophem,
W. Losert
Abstract:
We investigate the role of gravity on convection in a dense granular shear flow. Using a microgravity modified Taylor-Couette shear cell under the conditions of parabolic flight microgravity, we demonstrate experimentally that secondary, convective-like flows in a sheared granular material are close to zero in microgravity and enhanced under high-gravity conditions, though the primary flow fields…
▽ More
We investigate the role of gravity on convection in a dense granular shear flow. Using a microgravity modified Taylor-Couette shear cell under the conditions of parabolic flight microgravity, we demonstrate experimentally that secondary, convective-like flows in a sheared granular material are close to zero in microgravity and enhanced under high-gravity conditions, though the primary flow fields are unaffected by gravity. We suggest that gravity tunes the frictional particle-particle and particle-wall interactions, which have been proposed to drive the secondary flow. In addition, the degree of plastic deformation increases with increasing gravitational forces, supporting the notion that friction is the ultimate cause.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
