-
Self-Organized Pattern Formation in Geological Soft Matter
Authors:
Julyan H. E. Cartwright,
Charles S. Cockell,
Lucas Goehring,
Silvia Holler,
Sean F. Jordan,
Pamela Knoll,
Electra Kotopoulou,
Corentin C. Loron,
Sean McMahon,
Stephen W. Morris,
Anna Neubeck,
Carlos Pimentel,
C. Ignacio Sainz-Díaz,
Noushine Shahidzadeh,
Piotr Szymczak
Abstract:
Geological materials are often seen as the antithesis of soft; rocks are hard. However, during the formation of minerals and rocks, all the systems we shall discuss, indeed geological materials in general, pass through a stage where they are soft. This occurs either because they are at a high temperature -- igneous or metamorphic rock -- or because they are at a lower temperature but in the presen…
▽ More
Geological materials are often seen as the antithesis of soft; rocks are hard. However, during the formation of minerals and rocks, all the systems we shall discuss, indeed geological materials in general, pass through a stage where they are soft. This occurs either because they are at a high temperature -- igneous or metamorphic rock -- or because they are at a lower temperature but in the presence of water -- sedimentary rock. For this reason it is useful to introduce soft-matter concepts into the geological domain. There is a universality in the diverse instances of geological patterns that may be appreciated by looking at the common aspect in their formation of having passed through a stage as soft matter.
△ Less
Submitted 25 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
On the origin and evolution of icicle ripples
Authors:
Antony Szu-Han Chen,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
Natural icicles often exhibit ripples about their circumference which are due to a morphological instability. We present an experimental study that explores the origin of the instability, using laboratory-grown icicles. Contrary to theoretical expectations, icicles grown from pure water do not exhibit growing ripples. The addition of a non-ionic surfactant, which reduces the surface tension, does…
▽ More
Natural icicles often exhibit ripples about their circumference which are due to a morphological instability. We present an experimental study that explores the origin of the instability, using laboratory-grown icicles. Contrary to theoretical expectations, icicles grown from pure water do not exhibit growing ripples. The addition of a non-ionic surfactant, which reduces the surface tension, does not produce ripples. Instead, ripples emerge on icicles grown from water with dissolved ionic impurities. We find that even very small levels of impurity are sufficient to trigger ripples, and that the growth speed of the ripples increases very weakly with ionic concentration.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2013; v1 submitted 20 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Autocatalytic plume pinch-off
Authors:
Michael C. Rogers,
Abdel Zebib,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
A localized source of buoyancy flux in a non-reactive fluid medium creates a plume. The flux can be provided by either heat, a compositional difference between the fluid comprising the plume and its surroundings, or a combination of both. For autocatalytic plumes produced by the iodate-arsenous acid reaction, however, buoyancy is produced along the entire reacting interface between the plume and i…
▽ More
A localized source of buoyancy flux in a non-reactive fluid medium creates a plume. The flux can be provided by either heat, a compositional difference between the fluid comprising the plume and its surroundings, or a combination of both. For autocatalytic plumes produced by the iodate-arsenous acid reaction, however, buoyancy is produced along the entire reacting interface between the plume and its surroundings. Buoyancy production at the moving interface drives fluid motion, which in turn generates flow that advects the reaction front. As a consequence of this interplay between fluid flow and chemical reaction, autocatalytic plumes exhibit a rich dynamics during their ascent through the reactant medium. One of the more interesting dynamical features is the production of an accelerating vortical plume head that in certain cases pinches-off and detaches from the upwelling conduit. After pinch-off, a new plume head forms in the conduit below, and this can lead to multiple generations of plume heads for a single plume initiation. We investigated the pinch-off process using both experimentation and simulation. Experiments were performed using various concentrations of glycerol, in which it was found that repeated pinch-off occurs exclusively in a specific concentration range. Autocatalytic plume simulations revealed that pinch-off is triggered by the appearance of accelerating flow in the plume conduit.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2010; v1 submitted 1 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Experiments on the morphology of icicles
Authors:
Antony Szu-Han Chen,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
Icicles form when cool water drips from an overhanging support under ambient conditions which are below freezing. Ice growth is controlled by the removal of latent heat, which is transferred into the surrounding air via a thin film of water flowing over the ice surface. We describe laboratory experiments in which icicles were grown under controlled conditions. We used image analysis to probe the e…
▽ More
Icicles form when cool water drips from an overhanging support under ambient conditions which are below freezing. Ice growth is controlled by the removal of latent heat, which is transferred into the surrounding air via a thin film of water flowing over the ice surface. We describe laboratory experiments in which icicles were grown under controlled conditions. We used image analysis to probe the evolution of the icicle shape under various conditions. A recent asymptotic theory suggests that, overall, icicles converge to self-similar shapes which are predicted to be attractors. On the other hand, stability theory predicts that the ice-water interface can become unstable to form ripple patterns on the icicle surface. Our experimental results show that the predicted self-similar profile is only found in certain cases, and that icicles can also exhibit unpredicted non-uniformities such as branching near the tip. We find that pure water icicles are more likely to be self-similar than those grown from tap water. Ripples, which are also deviations from the self-similar profile, were observed to climb upward during icicle growth.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2011; v1 submitted 11 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
Scaling and dynamics of washboard road
Authors:
Anne-Florence Bitbol,
Nicolas Taberlet,
Stephen W. Morris,
Jim N. McElwaine
Abstract:
Granular surfaces subjected to forces due to rolling wheels develop ripples above a critical speed. The resulting pattern, known as "washboard" or "corrugated" road, is common on dry, unpaved roads. We investigated this phenomenon theoretically and experimentally, using laboratory-scale apparatus and beds of dry sand. A thick layer of sand on a circular track was forced by a rolling wheel on an…
▽ More
Granular surfaces subjected to forces due to rolling wheels develop ripples above a critical speed. The resulting pattern, known as "washboard" or "corrugated" road, is common on dry, unpaved roads. We investigated this phenomenon theoretically and experimentally, using laboratory-scale apparatus and beds of dry sand. A thick layer of sand on a circular track was forced by a rolling wheel on an arm whose weight and moment of inertia could be varied. We compared the ripples made by the rolling wheel to those made using a simple inclined plow blade. We investigated the dependence of the critical speed on various parameters, and describe a scaling argument which leads to a dimensionless ratio, analogous to the hydrodynamic Froude number, which controls the instability. This represents the crossover between conservative, dynamic forces and dissipative, static forces. Above onset, wheel-driven ripples move in the direction of motion of the wheel, but plow-driven ripples move in the reverse direction for a narrow range of Froude numbers.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2009; v1 submitted 26 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Localized states in sheared electroconvection
Authors:
Peichun Tsai,
Stephen W. Morris,
Zahir A. Daya
Abstract:
Electroconvection in a thin, sheared fluid film displays a rich sequence of bifurcations between different flow states as the driving voltage is increased. We present a numerical study of an annular film in which a radial potential difference acts on induced surface charges to drive convection. The film is also sheared by independently rotating the inner edge of the annulus. This simulation mode…
▽ More
Electroconvection in a thin, sheared fluid film displays a rich sequence of bifurcations between different flow states as the driving voltage is increased. We present a numerical study of an annular film in which a radial potential difference acts on induced surface charges to drive convection. The film is also sheared by independently rotating the inner edge of the annulus. This simulation models laboratory experiments on electroconvection in sheared smectic liquid crystal films. The applied shear competes with the electrical forces, resulting in oscillatory and strongly subcritical bifurcations between localized vortex states close to onset. At higher forcing, the flow becomes chaotic via a Ruelle-Takens-Newhouse scenario. The simulation allows flow visualization not available in the physical experiments, and sheds light on previously observed transitions in the current-voltage characteristics of electroconvecting smectic films.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2008; v1 submitted 4 July, 2008;
originally announced July 2008.
-
Washboard Road: The dynamics of granular ripples formed by rolling wheels
Authors:
Nicolas Taberlet,
Stephen W. Morris,
Jim N. McElwaine
Abstract:
Granular surfaces tend to develop lateral ripples under the action of surface forces exerted by rolling wheels, an effect known as washboard or corrugated road. We report the results of both laboratory experiments and soft-particle direct numerical simulations. Above a critical speed, the ripple pattern appears as small patches of traveling waves which eventually spread to the entire circumferen…
▽ More
Granular surfaces tend to develop lateral ripples under the action of surface forces exerted by rolling wheels, an effect known as washboard or corrugated road. We report the results of both laboratory experiments and soft-particle direct numerical simulations. Above a critical speed, the ripple pattern appears as small patches of traveling waves which eventually spread to the entire circumference. The ripples drift slowly in the driving direction. Interesting secondary dynamics of the saturated ripples were observed, as well as various ripple creation and destruction events. All of these effects are captured qualitatively by 2D soft particle simulations in which a disk rolls over a bed of poly-disperse particles in a periodic box. These simulations show that compaction and segregation are inessential to the ripple phenomenon. We also discuss a simplified scaling model which gives some insight into the mechanism of the instability.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
An Experimental Investigation of the Scaling of Columnar Joints
Authors:
Lucas Goehring,
Zhenquan Lin,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
Columnar jointing is a fracture pattern common in igneous rocks in which cracks self-organize into a roughly hexagonal arrangement, leaving behind an ordered colonnade. We report observations of columnar jointing in a laboratory analog system, desiccated corn starch slurries. Using measurements of moisture density, evaporation rates, and fracture advance rates as evidence, we suggest an advectiv…
▽ More
Columnar jointing is a fracture pattern common in igneous rocks in which cracks self-organize into a roughly hexagonal arrangement, leaving behind an ordered colonnade. We report observations of columnar jointing in a laboratory analog system, desiccated corn starch slurries. Using measurements of moisture density, evaporation rates, and fracture advance rates as evidence, we suggest an advective-diffusive system is responsible for the rough scaling behavior of columnar joints. This theory explains the order of magnitude difference in scales between jointing in lavas and in starches. We investigated the scaling of average columnar cross-sectional areas due to the evaporation rate, the analog of the cooling rate of igneous columnar joints. We measured column areas in experiments where the evaporation rate depended on lamp height and time, in experiments where the evaporation rate was fixed using feedback methods, and in experiments where gelatin was added to vary the rheology of the starch. Our results suggest that the column area at a particular depth is related to both the current conditions, and hysteretically to the geometry of the pattern at previous depths. We argue that there exists a range of stable column scales allowed for any particular evaporation rate.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2006; v1 submitted 8 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
Charge Transport Scalings in Turbulent Electroconvection
Authors:
Peichun Tsai,
Zahir A. Daya,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
We describe a local-power law scaling theory for the mean dimensionless electric current $Nu$ in turbulent electroconvection. The experimental system consists of a weakly conducting, submicron thick liquid crystal film supported in the annulus between concentric circular electrodes. It is driven into electroconvection by an applied voltage between its inner and outer edges. At sufficiently large…
▽ More
We describe a local-power law scaling theory for the mean dimensionless electric current $Nu$ in turbulent electroconvection. The experimental system consists of a weakly conducting, submicron thick liquid crystal film supported in the annulus between concentric circular electrodes. It is driven into electroconvection by an applied voltage between its inner and outer edges. At sufficiently large voltage differences, the flow is unsteady and electric charge is turbulently transported between the electrodes. Our theoretical development, which closely parallels the Grossmann-Lohse model for turbulent thermal convection, predicts the local-power law $Nu \sim F(Γ) {\cal R}^γ {\cal P}^δ$. ${\cal R}$ and ${\cal P}$ are dimensionless numbers that are similar to the Rayleigh and Prandtl numbers of thermal convection, respectively. The dimensionless function $F(Γ)$, which is specified by the model, describes the dependence of $Nu$ on the aspect ratio $Γ$. We find that measurements of $Nu$ are consistent with the theoretical model.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
Pattern scaling in the axial segregation of granular materials in a rotating tube
Authors:
Christopher R. J. Charles,
Zeina S. Khan,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
Granular mixtures frequently segregate by grain size along the axis of partially-filled, horizontal, rotating tubes. When segregation approaches saturation at the surface, a well-defined pattern of bands with wavelength $λ$ emerges. The long-term dynamics of the pattern involves a much slower coarsening process. We characterized the initial saturated wavelength $λ$ as a function of the diameter…
▽ More
Granular mixtures frequently segregate by grain size along the axis of partially-filled, horizontal, rotating tubes. When segregation approaches saturation at the surface, a well-defined pattern of bands with wavelength $λ$ emerges. The long-term dynamics of the pattern involves a much slower coarsening process. We characterized the initial saturated wavelength $λ$ as a function of the diameter of the tube $D$ for a filling fraction of 30 %, for $1.9 {\rm cm} \leq D \leq 11.5 {\rm cm}$. We also studied the initial growth-rate of the bands as $D$ varies. We find that $λ/D$ is not constant, but rather increases rapidly for small $D$. The growth-rate of bands decreases with smaller $D$ and segregation is suppressed completely for sufficiently small $D$. These relatively simple features are not captured by any of the existing models of axial segregation.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
Order and disorder in columnar joints
Authors:
Lucas Goehring,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
Columnar joints are three-dimensional fracture networks that form in cooling basalt and several other media. The network organizes itself into ordered, mostly hexagonal columns. The same pattern can be observed on a smaller scale in desiccating starch. We show how surface boundary conditions in the desiccation of starch affect the formation of columnar joints. Under constant drying power conditi…
▽ More
Columnar joints are three-dimensional fracture networks that form in cooling basalt and several other media. The network organizes itself into ordered, mostly hexagonal columns. The same pattern can be observed on a smaller scale in desiccating starch. We show how surface boundary conditions in the desiccation of starch affect the formation of columnar joints. Under constant drying power conditions, we find a power law dependence of columnar cross-sectional area with depth, while under constant drying rate conditions this coarsening is eventually halted. Discontinuous transitions in pattern scale can be observed under constant external conditions, which may prompt a reinterpretation of similar transitions found in basalt. Starch patterns are statistically similar to those found in basalt, suggesting that mature columnar jointing patterns contain inherent residual disorder, but are statistically scale invariant.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
Codimension-two points in annular electroconvection as a function of aspect ratio
Authors:
V. B. Deyirmenjian,
Zahir A. Daya,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
We rigorously derive from first principles the generic Landau amplitude equation that describes the primary bifurcation in electrically driven convection. Our model accurately represents the experimental system: a weakly conducting, submicron thick liquid crystal film suspended between concentric circular electrodes and driven by an applied voltage between its inner and outer edges. We explicitl…
▽ More
We rigorously derive from first principles the generic Landau amplitude equation that describes the primary bifurcation in electrically driven convection. Our model accurately represents the experimental system: a weakly conducting, submicron thick liquid crystal film suspended between concentric circular electrodes and driven by an applied voltage between its inner and outer edges. We explicitly calculate the coefficient $g$ of the leading cubic nonlinearity and systematically study its dependence on the system's geometrical and material parameters. The radius ratio $α$ quantifies the film's geometry while a dimensionless group ${\cal P}$, similar to the Prandtl number, fixes the ratio of the fluid's electrical and viscous relaxation times. Our calculations show that for fixed $α$, $g$ is a decreasing function of ${\cal P}$, as ${\cal P}$ becomes smaller, and is nearly constant for ${\cal P} \gtrsim 1$. As ${\cal P} \to 0$, $g \to \infty$. We find that $g$ is a nontrivial and discontinuous function of $α$. We show that the discontinuities occur at codimension-two points that are accessed by varying $α$.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2004;
originally announced November 2004.
-
Subdiffusive axial transport of granular materials in a long drum mixer
Authors:
Zeina S. Khan,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
Granular mixtures rapidly segregate radially by size when tumbled in a partially filled horizontal drum. The smaller component moves toward the axis of rotation and forms a buried core, which then splits into axial bands. Models have generally assumed that the axial segregation is opposed by diffusion. Using narrow pulses of the smaller component as initial conditions, we have characterized axia…
▽ More
Granular mixtures rapidly segregate radially by size when tumbled in a partially filled horizontal drum. The smaller component moves toward the axis of rotation and forms a buried core, which then splits into axial bands. Models have generally assumed that the axial segregation is opposed by diffusion. Using narrow pulses of the smaller component as initial conditions, we have characterized axial transport in the core. We find that the axial advance of the segregated core is well described by a self-similar concentration profile whose width scales as $t^α$, with $α\sim 0.3 < 1/2$. Thus, the process is subdiffusive rather than diffusive as previously assumed. We find that $α$ is nearly independent of the grain type and drum rotation rate within the smoothly streaming regime. We compare our results to two one-dimensional PDE models which contain self-similarity and subdiffusion; a linear fractional diffusion model and the nonlinear porous medium equation.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2004;
originally announced August 2004.
-
Aspect ratio dependence of charge transport in turbulent electroconvection
Authors:
Peichun Tsai,
Zahir A. Daya,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
We present measurements of the normalized charge transport or Nusselt number $\rm Nu$ as a function of the aspect ratio $Γ$ for turbulent convection in an electrically driven film. In analogy with turbulent Rayleigh-B{é}nard convection, we develop the relevant theoretical framework in which we discuss the local-power-law-scaling of $\rm Nu$ with a dimensionless electrical forcing parameter…
▽ More
We present measurements of the normalized charge transport or Nusselt number $\rm Nu$ as a function of the aspect ratio $Γ$ for turbulent convection in an electrically driven film. In analogy with turbulent Rayleigh-B{é}nard convection, we develop the relevant theoretical framework in which we discuss the local-power-law-scaling of $\rm Nu$ with a dimensionless electrical forcing parameter $\cal R$. For these experiments where $10^4 \lesssim {\cal R} \lesssim 2 \times 10^5$ we find that ${\rm Nu} \sim {\rm F}(Γ){\cal R}^γ$ with $γ$ either $ = 0.26 (\pm 0.02)$ or $0.20 (\pm 0.03)$, in excellent agreement with the theoretical predictions of $γ= 1/4$ and 1/5. Our measurements of the aspect ratio-dependence of ${\rm Nu}$ for $0.3 \leq Γ\leq 17$ compares favorably with the function ${\rm F}(Γ)$ from the scaling theory.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2003;
originally announced September 2003.
-
Electrically driven convection in a thin annular film undergoing circular Couette flow
Authors:
Zahir A. Daya,
V. B. Deyirmenjian,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
We investigate the linear stability of a thin, suspended, annular film of conducting fluid with a voltage difference applied between its inner and outer edges. For a sufficiently large voltage, such a film is unstable to radially-driven electroconvection due to charges which develop on its free surfaces. The film can also be subjected to a Couette shear by rotating its inner edge. This combinati…
▽ More
We investigate the linear stability of a thin, suspended, annular film of conducting fluid with a voltage difference applied between its inner and outer edges. For a sufficiently large voltage, such a film is unstable to radially-driven electroconvection due to charges which develop on its free surfaces. The film can also be subjected to a Couette shear by rotating its inner edge. This combination is experimentally realized using films of smectic A liquid crystals. In the absence of shear, the convective flow consists of a stationary, azimuthally one-dimensional pattern of symmetric, counter-rotating vortex pairs. When Couette flow is applied, an azimuthally traveling pattern results. When viewed in a co-rotating frame, the traveling pattern consists of pairs of asymmetric vortices. We calculate the neutral stability boundary for arbitrary radius ratio $α$ and Reynolds number ${{\cal R} e}$ of the shear flow, and obtain the critical control parameter ${\cal R}_c (α, {{\cal R} e})$ and the critical azimuthal mode number ${m_c (α, {{\cal R} e})}$. The Couette flow suppresses the onset of electroconvection, so that ${\cal R}_c (α, {{\cal R} e}) > {\cal R}_c (α,0)$. The calculated suppression is compared with experiments performed at $α= 0.56 $ and $0 \leq {{\cal R} e} \leq 0.22 $.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2000; v1 submitted 12 June, 1998;
originally announced June 1998.
-
The Dynamics of Granular Segregation Patterns in a Long Drum Mixer
Authors:
Kiam Choo,
Michael W. Baker,
T. C. A. Molteno,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
We have studied the early time evolution of granular segregation patterns in a horizontal rotating cylinder partially filled with a sand/salt mixture. The growth of concentration fluctuations starting from premixed initial conditions was analyzed using Fourier techniques. In one mixture, we observed generally merging dynamics in the segregated bands up to the onset of saturation. At the threshol…
▽ More
We have studied the early time evolution of granular segregation patterns in a horizontal rotating cylinder partially filled with a sand/salt mixture. The growth of concentration fluctuations starting from premixed initial conditions was analyzed using Fourier techniques. In one mixture, we observed generally merging dynamics in the segregated bands up to the onset of saturation. At the threshold of saturation, we found a spectrum of wavelengths with a broad peak. The peak position was nearly independent of the tube rotation rate. The overall growth rate of Fourier modes had a maximum at a particular value of the angular rotation frequency. In a slightly different mixture, we observed transient traveling waves when the larger grains were in the majority. We measured the wave speed as a function of several parameters using presegregated initial conditions to launch waves of various wavelengths.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 1998; v1 submitted 28 April, 1998;
originally announced April 1998.
-
Annular electroconvection with shear
Authors:
Zahir A. Daya,
V. B. Deyirmenjian,
Stephen W. Morris,
John R. de Bruyn
Abstract:
We report experiments on convection driven by a radial electrical force in suspended annular smectic A liquid crystal films. In the absence of an externally imposed azimuthal shear, a stationary one-dimensional (1D) pattern consisting of symmetric vortex pairs is formed via a supercritical transition at the onset of convection. Shearing reduces the symmetries of the base state and produces a tra…
▽ More
We report experiments on convection driven by a radial electrical force in suspended annular smectic A liquid crystal films. In the absence of an externally imposed azimuthal shear, a stationary one-dimensional (1D) pattern consisting of symmetric vortex pairs is formed via a supercritical transition at the onset of convection. Shearing reduces the symmetries of the base state and produces a traveling 1D pattern whose basic periodic unit is a pair of asymmetric vortices. For a sufficiently large shear, the primary bifurcation changes from supercritical to subcritical. We describe measurements of the resulting hysteresis as a function of the shear at radius ratio $η\sim 0.8$. This simple pattern forming system has an unusual combination of symmetries and control parameters and should be amenable to quantitative theoretical analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 1997;
originally announced October 1997.
-
Traveling Granular Segregation Patterns in a Long Drum Mixer
Authors:
Kiam Choo,
T. C. A. Molteno,
Stephen W. Morris
Abstract:
Mixtures of granular media often exhibit size segregation along the axis of a partially-filled, horizontal, rotating cylinder. Previous experiments have observed axial bands of segregation that grow from concentration fluctuations and merge in a manner analogous to spinodal decomposition. We have observed that a new dynamical state precedes this effect in certain mixtures: bi-directional traveli…
▽ More
Mixtures of granular media often exhibit size segregation along the axis of a partially-filled, horizontal, rotating cylinder. Previous experiments have observed axial bands of segregation that grow from concentration fluctuations and merge in a manner analogous to spinodal decomposition. We have observed that a new dynamical state precedes this effect in certain mixtures: bi-directional traveling waves. By preparing initial conditions, we found that the wave speed decreased with wavelength. Such waves appear to be inconsistent with simple PDE models which are first order in time.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 1997; v1 submitted 27 June, 1997;
originally announced June 1997.
