-
Spontaneous Optimal Mixing via Defect-Vortex Coupling in Confined Active Nematics
Authors:
Brandon Klein,
Alejandro J. Soto Franco,
Md Mainul Hasan Sabbir,
Matthew J. Deutsch,
Ross Kliegman,
Robin L. B. Selinger,
Kevin A. Mitchell,
Daniel A. Beller
Abstract:
Active nematic flows in two dimensions, largely driven by motile $+1/2$ disclinations, mix themselves efficiently and exhibit chaos in the bulk steady state. Motivated by recent experimental findings for three-defect braiding in cardioid-shaped domains, we investigate how this tendency toward chaotic fluid mixing can, counterintuitively, produce certain ordered, periodic flows in confinement with…
▽ More
Active nematic flows in two dimensions, largely driven by motile $+1/2$ disclinations, mix themselves efficiently and exhibit chaos in the bulk steady state. Motivated by recent experimental findings for three-defect braiding in cardioid-shaped domains, we investigate how this tendency toward chaotic fluid mixing can, counterintuitively, produce certain ordered, periodic flows in confinement with a controllable net topological charge. We study two-dimensional active nematics in systems with boundary conditions requiring a prescribed number of excess $+1/2$ disclinations, using Beris-Edwards nematohydrodynamics simulations, alongside an agent-based, hydrodynamic simulation approach. We find ordered flows for systems of three and four defects, and we use tools from braid theory to show that spontaneously occurring periodic defect motions produce maximal topological entropy. Our theory correctly predicts the generic absence of stable periodic orbits of more than four defects in strong confinement in simulation. Our results identify the parameter regime outside of which periodicity is lost, and allow us to probe the limits of topological entropy production.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2025; v1 submitted 13 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Strain stiffening due to stretching of entangled particles in random packings of granular materials
Authors:
Eric Brown,
Kevin A. Mitchell,
Alice Nasto,
Athanasios Athanassiadis,
Heinrich M. Jaeger
Abstract:
Stress-strain relations for random packings of entangling chains under triaxial compression can exhibit strain stiffening and sustain stresses several orders-of-magnitude beyond typical granular materials. X-ray tomography reveals the transition to this strong strain stiffening occurs when chains are long enough to entangle an average of about one chain each, which results in system-filling cluste…
▽ More
Stress-strain relations for random packings of entangling chains under triaxial compression can exhibit strain stiffening and sustain stresses several orders-of-magnitude beyond typical granular materials. X-ray tomography reveals the transition to this strong strain stiffening occurs when chains are long enough to entangle an average of about one chain each, which results in system-filling clusters of entangled chains. The number of entanglements is nearly proportional to the area surrounded by entangling particles with an excluded volume effect. A tendency was found for chain links to stretch when the packing was strained. The slope of the stress-strain relation of the packing can be calculated from a mean-field model consisting of the product of the effective extensional modulus of the chain, packing fraction, probability of stretched links, and the ratio of strain of stretched links to packing strain. The stress-strain model requires as input measurements of the ratio between local particle deformation and global average strain, and the probability of stretching for non-rigid particles. This results in a quadratic prediction for the stress-strain curve, with a curvature that agrees with experiments within the model uncertainties. This model explains that the strength of these packings comes from stretching of the links of chains, but only when the system-filling network of entanglements provides constraints that prevents failure by shear banding, so that particles must be deformed to move further under strain. In this model, the increasing slope of the stress-strain curve is mainly due to the fraction of stretched links increasing with strain. This model for the stress-strain relation is shown to be generalizable to different shapes of entangling particles by applying it to staples.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2025; v1 submitted 16 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Controlling chaos: Periodic defect braiding in active nematics confined to a cardioid
Authors:
Fereshteh L. Memarian,
Derek Hammar,
Md Mainul Hasan Sabbir,
Mark Elias,
Kevin A. Mitchell,
Linda Hirst
Abstract:
This work examines self-mixing in active nematics, a class of fluids in which mobile topological defects drive chaotic flows in a system comprised of biological filaments and molecular motors. We present experiments that demonstrate how geometrical confinement can influence the braiding dynamics of the defects. Notably, we show that confinement in cardioid-shaped wells leads to realization of the…
▽ More
This work examines self-mixing in active nematics, a class of fluids in which mobile topological defects drive chaotic flows in a system comprised of biological filaments and molecular motors. We present experiments that demonstrate how geometrical confinement can influence the braiding dynamics of the defects. Notably, we show that confinement in cardioid-shaped wells leads to realization of the golden braid, a maximally efficient mixing state of exactly three defects with no defect creation or annihilation. We characterize the golden braid state using different measures of topological entropy and the Lyapunov exponent. In particular, topological entropy measured from the stretching rate of material lines agrees well with an analytical computation from braid theory. Increasing the size of the confining cardioid produces a transition from the golden braid, to the fully chaotic active turbulent state.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Maximally mixing active nematics
Authors:
Kevin A. Mitchell,
Md Mainul Hasan Sabbir,
Kevin Geumhan,
Spencer A. Smith,
Brandon Klein,
Daniel A. Beller
Abstract:
Active nematics are an important new paradigm in soft condensed matter systems. They consist of rod-like components with an internal driving force pushing them out of equilibrium. The resulting fluid motion exhibits chaotic advection, in which a small patch of fluid is stretched exponentially in length. Using simulation, this Letter shows that this system can exhibit stable periodic motion when su…
▽ More
Active nematics are an important new paradigm in soft condensed matter systems. They consist of rod-like components with an internal driving force pushing them out of equilibrium. The resulting fluid motion exhibits chaotic advection, in which a small patch of fluid is stretched exponentially in length. Using simulation, this Letter shows that this system can exhibit stable periodic motion when sufficiently confined to a square with periodic boundary conditions. Moreover, employing tools from braid theory, we show that this motion is maximally mixing, in that it optimizes the (dimensionless) ``topological entropy'' -- the exponential stretching rate of a material line advected by the fluid. That is, this periodic motion of the defects, counterintuitively, produces more chaotic mixing than chaotic motion of the defects. We also explore the stability of the periodic state. Importantly, we show how to stabilize this orbit into a larger periodic tiling, a critical necessity for it to be seen in future experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Noise-induced aggregation of swimmers in the Kolmogorov flow
Authors:
Simon A. Berman,
Kyle S. Ferguson,
Nathaniel Bizzak,
Thomas H. Solomon,
Kevin A. Mitchell
Abstract:
We investigate a model for the dynamics of ellipsoidal microswimmers in an externally imposed, laminar Kolmogorov flow. Through a phase-space analysis of the dynamics without noise, we find that swimmers favor either cross-stream or rotational drift, depending on their swimming speed and aspect ratio. When including noise, i.e. rotational diffusion, we find that swimmers are driven into certain pa…
▽ More
We investigate a model for the dynamics of ellipsoidal microswimmers in an externally imposed, laminar Kolmogorov flow. Through a phase-space analysis of the dynamics without noise, we find that swimmers favor either cross-stream or rotational drift, depending on their swimming speed and aspect ratio. When including noise, i.e. rotational diffusion, we find that swimmers are driven into certain parts of phase space, leading to a nonuniform steady-state distribution. This distribution exhibits a transition from swimmer aggregation in low-shear regions of the flow to aggregation in high-shear regions as the swimmer's speed, aspect ratio, and rotational diffusivity are varied. To explain the nonuniform phase-space distribution of swimmers, we apply a weak-noise averaging principle that produces a reduced description of the stochastic swimmer dynamics. Using this technique, we find that certain swimmer trajectories are more favorable than others in the presence of weak rotational diffusion. By combing this information with the phase-space speed of swimmers along each trajectory, we predict the regions of phase space where swimmers tend to accumulate. The results of the averaging technique are in good agreement with direct calculations of the steady-state distributions of swimmers. In particular, our analysis explains the transition from low-shear to high-shear aggregation.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Swimmer dynamics in externally-driven fluid flows: The role of noise
Authors:
Simon A. Berman,
Kevin A. Mitchell
Abstract:
We theoretically investigate the effect of random fluctuations on the motion of elongated microswimmers near hydrodynamic transport barriers in externally-driven fluid flows. Focusing on the two-dimensional hyperbolic flow, we consider the effects of translational and rotational diffusion as well as tumbling, i.e. sudden jumps in the swimmer orientation. Regardless of whether diffusion or tumbling…
▽ More
We theoretically investigate the effect of random fluctuations on the motion of elongated microswimmers near hydrodynamic transport barriers in externally-driven fluid flows. Focusing on the two-dimensional hyperbolic flow, we consider the effects of translational and rotational diffusion as well as tumbling, i.e. sudden jumps in the swimmer orientation. Regardless of whether diffusion or tumbling are the primary source of fluctuations, we find that noise significantly increases the probability that a swimmer crosses one-way barriers in the flow, which block the swimmer from returning to its initial position. We employ an asymptotic method for calculating the probability density of noisy swimmer trajectories in a given fluid flow, which produces solutions to the time-dependent Fokker-Planck equation in the weak-noise limit. This procedure mirrors the semiclassical approximation in quantum mechanics and similarly involves calculating the least-action paths of a Hamiltonian system derived from the swimmer's Fokker-Planck equation. Using the semiclassical technique, we compute (i) the steady-state orientation distribution of swimmers with rotational diffusion and tumbling and (ii) the probability that a diffusive swimmer crosses a one-way barrier. The semiclassical results compare favorably with Monte Carlo calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2021; v1 submitted 23 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Fractal generation in a two-dimensional active-nematic fluid
Authors:
Kevin A. Mitchell,
Amanda J. Tan,
Jorge Arteaga,
Linda S. Hirst
Abstract:
Active fluids, composed of individual self-propelled agents, can generate complex large-scale coherent flows. A particularly important laboratory realization of such an active fluid is a system composed of microtubules, aligned in a quasi-two-dimensional (2D) nematic phase, and driven by ATP-fueled kinesin motor proteins. This system exhibits robust chaotic advection and gives rise to a pronounced…
▽ More
Active fluids, composed of individual self-propelled agents, can generate complex large-scale coherent flows. A particularly important laboratory realization of such an active fluid is a system composed of microtubules, aligned in a quasi-two-dimensional (2D) nematic phase, and driven by ATP-fueled kinesin motor proteins. This system exhibits robust chaotic advection and gives rise to a pronounced fractal structure in the nematic contours. We characterize such experimentally derived fractals using the power spectrum and discover that the power spectrum decays as $k^{-β}$ for large wavenumbers $k$. The parameter $β$ is measured for several experimental realizations. Though $β$ is effectively constant in time, it does vary with experimental parameters, indicating differences in the scale-free behavior of the microtubule-based active nematic. Though the fractal patterns generated in this active system are reminiscent of passively advected dye in 2D chaotic flows, the underlying mechanism for fractal generation is more subtle. We provide a simple, physically inspired mathematical model of fractal generation in this system that relies on the material being locally compressible, though the total area of the material is conserved globally. The model also requires that large-scale density variations be injected into the material periodically. The model reproduces the power spectrum decay $k^{-β}$ seen in experiments. Linearizing the model of fractal generation about the equilibrium density, we derive an analytic relationship between $β$ and a single dimensionless quantity $r$, which characterizes the compressibility.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Matter, Energy, and Heat Transfer in a Classical Ballistic Atom Pump
Authors:
Tommy A. Byrd,
Kunal K. Das,
Kevin A. Mitchell,
Seth Aubin,
John B. Delos
Abstract:
A ballistic atom pump is a system containing two reservoirs of neutral atoms or molecules and a junction connecting them containing a localized time-varying potential. Atoms move through the pump as independent particles. Under certain conditions, these pumps can create net transport of atoms from one reservoir to the other. While such systems are sometimes called "quantum pumps," they are also mo…
▽ More
A ballistic atom pump is a system containing two reservoirs of neutral atoms or molecules and a junction connecting them containing a localized time-varying potential. Atoms move through the pump as independent particles. Under certain conditions, these pumps can create net transport of atoms from one reservoir to the other. While such systems are sometimes called "quantum pumps," they are also models of classical chaotic transport, and their quantum behavior cannot be understood without study of the corresponding classical behavior. Here we examine classically such a pump's effect on energy and temperature in the reservoirs, in addition to net particle transport. We show that the changes in particle number, of energy in each reservoir, and of temperature in each reservoir vary in unexpected ways as the incident particle energy is varied.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Ballistic atom pumps
Authors:
Megan K. Ivory,
Tommy A. Byrd,
Andrew J. Pyle,
Kunal K. Das,
Kevin A. Mitchell,
Seth Aubin,
John B. Delos
Abstract:
We examine a classically-chaotic system consisting of two reservoirs of particles connected by a channel containing oscillating potential-energy barriers. We investigate whether such a system can preferentially pump particles from one reservoir to the other, a process often called "quantum pumping." We show how to make a "particle diode" which under specified conditions permits net particle pumpin…
▽ More
We examine a classically-chaotic system consisting of two reservoirs of particles connected by a channel containing oscillating potential-energy barriers. We investigate whether such a system can preferentially pump particles from one reservoir to the other, a process often called "quantum pumping." We show how to make a "particle diode" which under specified conditions permits net particle pumping in only one direction. Then we examine systems having symmetric barriers. We find that if all initial particle energies are considered, a system with symmetric barriers cannot preferentially pump particles. However, if only finite initial energy bands are considered, the system can create net particle transport in either direction. We study the system classically, semiclassically, and quantum mechanically, and find that the quantum description cannot be fully understood without the insight gained from classical and semiclassical analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Scattering by an oscillating barrier: quantum, classical, and semiclassical comparison
Authors:
Tommy A. Byrd,
Megan K. Ivory,
Andrew J. Pyle,
Seth Aubin,
Kevin A. Mitchell,
John B. Delos,
Kunal K. Das
Abstract:
We present a detailed study of scattering by an amplitude-modulated potential barrier using three distinct physical frameworks: quantum, classical, and semiclassical. Classical physics gives bounds on the energy and momentum of the scattered particle, while also providing the foundation for semiclassical theory. We use the semiclassical approach to selectively add quantum-mechanical effects such a…
▽ More
We present a detailed study of scattering by an amplitude-modulated potential barrier using three distinct physical frameworks: quantum, classical, and semiclassical. Classical physics gives bounds on the energy and momentum of the scattered particle, while also providing the foundation for semiclassical theory. We use the semiclassical approach to selectively add quantum-mechanical effects such as interference and diffraction. We find good agreement between the quantum and semiclassical momentum distributions. Our methods and results can be used to understand quantum and classical aspects of transport mechanisms involving time-varying potentials, such as quantum pumping.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
