-
The impact of alloying elements on the precipitation stability and kinetics in iron based alloys: An atomistic study
Authors:
Giovanni Bonny,
Christophe Domain,
Nicolas Castin,
Pär Olsson,
Lorenzo Malerba
Abstract:
Iron based industrial steels typically contain a large number of alloying elements, even so-called low alloyed steels. Under irradiation, these alloying elements form clusters that have a detrimental impact of the mechanical properties of the steel. The stability and formation mechanisms of such clusters are presently not fully understood. Therefore, in this work, we study the thermal stability an…
▽ More
Iron based industrial steels typically contain a large number of alloying elements, even so-called low alloyed steels. Under irradiation, these alloying elements form clusters that have a detrimental impact of the mechanical properties of the steel. The stability and formation mechanisms of such clusters are presently not fully understood. Therefore, in this work, we study the thermal stability and formation kinetics of small solute clusters in the bcc Fe matrix. We use density functional theory (DFT) to characterize the binding energy of vacancy/solute clusters containing Cr, Mn, Ni, Cu, Si and P, thereby exploring>700 different configurations. The constructed DFT data base is used to fit a cluster expansion (CE) for the vacancy-FeCrMnNiCuSiP system. In turn, the obtained CE is applied in atomistic kinetic Monte Carlo simulations to study the effect of Mn, Ni, Cr, Si and P on the precipitation formation in the FeCu alloy. We conclude that the addition of Mn and Ni delay the precipitation kinetics by an order of magnitude. The additional alloying with traces of P/Si further delays the kinetics by an additional order of magnitude. We found that Si plays an essential role in the formation of spatially mixed MnNiCuSi cluster.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
How precisely are solute clusters in RPV steels characterized by atom probe experiments?
Authors:
N. Castin,
P. Klups,
M. Konstantinovic,
G. Bonny,
M. I. Pascuet,
M. Moody,
L. Malerba
Abstract:
Atom probe tomography (APT) is a powerful microscopy technique to characterize nano-sized clusters of the alloying elements in the bulk of reactor pressure vessel (RPV) steels. These clusters are known to dominantly determine the evolution of mechanical properties under irradiation. The results are conventionally summarized as the overall number density N and the average diameter D of the solute c…
▽ More
Atom probe tomography (APT) is a powerful microscopy technique to characterize nano-sized clusters of the alloying elements in the bulk of reactor pressure vessel (RPV) steels. These clusters are known to dominantly determine the evolution of mechanical properties under irradiation. The results are conventionally summarized as the overall number density N and the average diameter D of the solute clusters identified in the material. Here, we demonstrate that these descriptors are intrinsically imprecise because they are steered by the parameters involved in the measurement and data processing, some of which are directly under the control of the operators, but some others not. Consequently, a direct comparison between data derived at different laboratories is compromised, and key trends such as the evolution with dose, are masked. This study relies on a state-of-the-art physical model for neutron irradiation in steels to make reliable estimates of the true microstructure before the measurement is performed, which allows the prediction of the population of solute clusters that are not seen by APT. We mimic APT measurements from simulated microstructures, performing a detailed study of the effects of the parameters of the analysis. We show that the values of N and D reported in the scientific literature can be matched by the predictions of our theoretical model only if specific sets of parameters are used for each laboratory that issued the measurements. We also show that if, on the contrary, all studied cases are analyzed in a consistent way, the scatter of N and D values is reduced.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Multiscale modelling in nuclear ferritic steels: from nano-sized defects to embrittlement
Authors:
N. Castin,
G. Bonny,
M. J. Konstantinović,
A. Bakaev,
F. Bergner,
C. Courilleau,
C. Domain,
B. Gómez-Ferrer,
J. M. Hyde,
L. Messina,
G. Monnet,
M. I. Pascuet,
B. Radiguet,
M. Serrano,
L. Malerba
Abstract:
Radiation-induced embrittlement of nuclear steels is one of the main limiting factors for safe long-term operation of nuclear power plants. In support of accurate and safe reactor pressure vessel (RPV) lifetime assessments, we developed a physics-based model that predicts RPV steel hardening and subsequent embrittlement as a consequence of the formation of nano-sized clusters of minor alloying ele…
▽ More
Radiation-induced embrittlement of nuclear steels is one of the main limiting factors for safe long-term operation of nuclear power plants. In support of accurate and safe reactor pressure vessel (RPV) lifetime assessments, we developed a physics-based model that predicts RPV steel hardening and subsequent embrittlement as a consequence of the formation of nano-sized clusters of minor alloying elements. This model is shown to provide reliable assessments of embrittlement for a very wide range of materials, with higher accuracy than industrial correlations. The core of our model is a multiscale modelling tool that predicts the kinetics of solute clustering, given the steel chemical composition and its irradiation conditions. It is based on the observation that the formation of solute clusters ensues from atomic transport driven by radiation-induced mechanisms, differently from classical nucleation-and-growth theories. We then show that the predicted information about solute clustering can be translated into a reliable estimate for radiation-induced embrittlement, via standard hardening laws based on the dispersed barrier model. We demonstrate the validity of our approach by applying it to hundreds of nuclear reactors vessels from all over the world.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
The dominant mechanisms for the formation of solute-rich clusters in low-Cu steels under irradiation
Authors:
N. Castin,
G. Bonny,
A. Bakaev,
F. Bergner,
C. Domain,
J. M. Hyde,
L. Messina,
B. Radiguet,
L. Malerba
Abstract:
The formation of nano-sized, coherent, solute-rich clusters (NSRC) is known to be an important factor causing the degradation of the macroscopic properties of steels under irradiation. The mechanisms driving their formation are still debated. This work focuses on low-Cu reactor pressure vessel (RPV) steels, where solute species are generally not expected to precipitate. We rationalize the processe…
▽ More
The formation of nano-sized, coherent, solute-rich clusters (NSRC) is known to be an important factor causing the degradation of the macroscopic properties of steels under irradiation. The mechanisms driving their formation are still debated. This work focuses on low-Cu reactor pressure vessel (RPV) steels, where solute species are generally not expected to precipitate. We rationalize the processes that take place at the nanometre scale under irradiation, relying on the latest theoretical and experimental evidence on atomic-level diffusion and transport processes. These are compiled in a new model, based on the object kinetic Monte Carlo (OKMC) technique. We evaluate the relevance of the underlying physical assumptions by applying the model to a large variety of irradiation experiments. Our model predictions are compared with new experimental data obtained with atom probe tomography and small angle neutron scattering, complemented with information from the literature. The results of this study reveal that the role of immobilized self-interstitial atoms (SIA) loops dominates the nucleation process of NSRC.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2025; v1 submitted 14 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
OKMC simulations of Fe-C systems under irradiation: sensitivity studies
Authors:
Ville Jansson,
Lorenzo Malerba
Abstract:
This paper continues our previous work on a nanostructural evolution model for Fe-C alloys under irradiation, using Object Kinetic Monte Carlo modeling techniques. We here present a number of sensitivity studies of parameters of the model, such as the carbon content in the material, represented by generic traps for point defects, the importance of traps, the size dependence of traps and the effect…
▽ More
This paper continues our previous work on a nanostructural evolution model for Fe-C alloys under irradiation, using Object Kinetic Monte Carlo modeling techniques. We here present a number of sensitivity studies of parameters of the model, such as the carbon content in the material, represented by generic traps for point defects, the importance of traps, the size dependence of traps and the effect of the dose rate.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Sink strength calculations of dislocations and loops using OKMC
Authors:
Ville Jansson,
Lorenzo Malerba,
Andrée De Backer,
Charlotte S. Becquart,
Christophe Domain
Abstract:
We calculate the sink strength of dislocations and toroidal absorbers using Object Kinetic Monte Carlo and compare with the theoretical expressions. We get good agreement for dislocations and loop-shaped absorbers of 3D migrating defects, provided that the volume fraction is low, and fair agreements for dislocations with 1D migrating defects. The master curve for the 3D to 1D transition is well re…
▽ More
We calculate the sink strength of dislocations and toroidal absorbers using Object Kinetic Monte Carlo and compare with the theoretical expressions. We get good agreement for dislocations and loop-shaped absorbers of 3D migrating defects, provided that the volume fraction is low, and fair agreements for dislocations with 1D migrating defects. The master curve for the 3D to 1D transition is well reproduced with loop-shaped absorbers and fairly well with dislocations. We conclude that, on the one hand, the master curve is correct for a wide range of sinks and that, on the other, OKMC techniques inherently take correctly into account the strengths of sinks of any shape, provided that an effective way of appropriately inserting the sinks to be studied can be found.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
The nanostructure evolution in Fe-C systems under irradiation at 560 K
Authors:
Ville Jansson,
Monica Chiapetto,
Lorenzo Malerba
Abstract:
This work extends our Object Kinetic Monte Carlo model for neutron irradiation-induced nanostructure evolution in Fe-C alloys to consider higher irradiation temperatures. The previous study concentrated on irradiation temperatures < 370 K. Here we study the evolution of vacancy and self-interstitial atom (SIA) cluster populations at the operational temperature of light water reactors, by simulatin…
▽ More
This work extends our Object Kinetic Monte Carlo model for neutron irradiation-induced nanostructure evolution in Fe-C alloys to consider higher irradiation temperatures. The previous study concentrated on irradiation temperatures < 370 K. Here we study the evolution of vacancy and self-interstitial atom (SIA) cluster populations at the operational temperature of light water reactors, by simulating specific reference irradiation experiments.
Following our previous study, the effect of carbon on radiation defect evolution can be described in terms of formation of immobile complexes with vacancies, that in turn act as traps for SIA clusters. This dynamics is simulated using generic traps for SIA and vacancy clusters. The traps have a binding energy that depends on the size and type of the clusters and is also chosen on the basis of previously performed atomistic studies. The model had to be adapted to account for the existence of two kinds of SIA clusters, <111> and <100>, as observed in electron microscopy examinations of Fe alloys neutron irradiated at the temperatures of technological interest.
The model, which is fully based on physical considerations and only uses a few parameters for calibration, is found to be capable of reproducing the experimental trends, thereby providing insight into the physical mechanisms of importance to determine the type of nanostructural evolution undergone by the material during irradiation.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Simulation of the nanostructure evolution under irradiation in Fe-C alloys
Authors:
Ville Jansson,
Lorenzo Malerba
Abstract:
Neutron irradiation induces in steels nanostructural changes, which are at the origin of the mechanical degradation that these materials experience during operation in nuclear power plants. Some of these effects can be studied by using as model alloy the iron-carbon system.
The Object Kinetic Monte Carlo technique has proven capable of simulating in a realistic and quantitatively reliable way a…
▽ More
Neutron irradiation induces in steels nanostructural changes, which are at the origin of the mechanical degradation that these materials experience during operation in nuclear power plants. Some of these effects can be studied by using as model alloy the iron-carbon system.
The Object Kinetic Monte Carlo technique has proven capable of simulating in a realistic and quantitatively reliable way a whole irradiation process. We have developed a model for simulating Fe-C systems using a physical description of the properties of vacancy and self-interstitial atom (SIA) clusters, based on a selection of the latest data from atomistic studies and other available experimental and theoretical work from the literature. Based on these data, the effect of carbon on radiation defect evolution has been largely understood in terms of formation of immobile complexes with vacancies that in turn act as traps for SIA clusters. It is found that this effect can be introduced using generic traps for SIA and vacancy clusters, with a binding energy that depends on the size of the clusters, also chosen on the basis on previously performed atomistic studies.
The model proved suitable to reproduce the results of low (<350 K) temperature neutron irradiation experiments, as well as the corresponding post-irradiation annealing up to 700 K, in terms of defect cluster densities and size distribution, when compared to available experimental data from the literature. The use of traps proved instrumental for our model.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
