-
Biases in particle localization algorithms
Authors:
Brian D. Leahy,
Matthew Bierbaum,
James Sethna,
Itai Cohen
Abstract:
Automated particle locating algorithms have revolutionized microscopy image analysis, enabling researchers to rapidly locate many particles to within a few pixels in a microscope image. The vast majority of these algorithms operate through heuristic approaches inspired by computer vision, such as identifying particles with a blob detection. While rapid, these algorithms are plagued by biases [4, 1…
▽ More
Automated particle locating algorithms have revolutionized microscopy image analysis, enabling researchers to rapidly locate many particles to within a few pixels in a microscope image. The vast majority of these algorithms operate through heuristic approaches inspired by computer vision, such as identifying particles with a blob detection. While rapid, these algorithms are plagued by biases [4, 15, 24], and many researchers still frequently ignore or understate these biases. In this paper, we examine sources of biases in particle localization. Rather than exhaustively examine all possible sources of bias, we illustrate their scale, the large number of sources, and the difficulty of correcting the biases with a heuristic method. We do this by generating a series of simple images, introducing sources of bias one at a time. Using these images, we examine the performance of two heuristic algorithms throughout the process: a centroid algorithm and a Gaussian fitting algorithm. We contrast the two heuristic methods with a new approach based on reconstructing an image with a generative model to fit the data (Parameter Extraction from Reconstructing Images, or PERI). While the heuristic approaches produce considerable biases even on unrealistically simple images, the reconstruction-based approach accurately measures particle positions even in complex, highly realistic images. We close by reiterating the fundamental reason that a reconstruction-based approach accurately extracts particle positions -- any imperfections in the fit both demonstrate which sources of systematic error are still present and provide a roadmap to incorporating them.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2018; v1 submitted 10 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
How Confinement-Induced Structures Alter the Contribution of Hydrodynamic and Short-Ranged Repulsion Forces to the Viscosity of Colloidal Suspensions
Authors:
Meera Ramaswamy,
Neil Y. C. Lin,
Brian D. Leahy,
Christopher Ness,
Andrew M. Fiore,
James W. Swan,
Itai Cohen
Abstract:
Understanding the correlation between structure and rheology in colloidal suspensions is important as these suspensions are crucial in industrial applications. Moreover, colloids exhibit a wide range of structures under confinement that could considerably alter the viscosity. Here, we use a combination of experiments and simulations to elucidate how confinement induced structures alter the relativ…
▽ More
Understanding the correlation between structure and rheology in colloidal suspensions is important as these suspensions are crucial in industrial applications. Moreover, colloids exhibit a wide range of structures under confinement that could considerably alter the viscosity. Here, we use a combination of experiments and simulations to elucidate how confinement induced structures alter the relative contributions of hydrodynamic and repulsive forces to produce up to a ten fold change in the viscosity. We use a custom built confocal rheoscope to image the particle configurations of a colloidal suspension while simultaneously measuring the viscosity. We find a non-monotonic trend to the viscosity under confinement that is strongly correlated with the microstructure. As the gap decreases below 15 particle diameters, the viscosity first decreases from its bulk value, shows fluctuations with the gap, and then sharply increases for gaps below three particle diameters. Further, we compare our experimental results to two simulations techniques that enables us to determine the relative contributions of hydrodynamic and short range repulsive stresses. The first method uses the lubrication approximation to find the hydrodynamic stress and includes a short range repulsive force between the particles and the second is a Stokesian dynamics simulation that calculates the full hydrodynamic stress in the suspension. We find that the decrease in the viscosity at moderate confinements has a significant contribution from both the hydrodynamic and repulsive forces whereas the increase in viscosity at gaps less than three particle diameters arises primarily from short range repulsive forces. These results provide new insights to the unique rheological behavior of confined suspensions and further enable us to tune the viscosity by changing properties such as the gap, polydispersity, and the volume fraction.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2017; v1 submitted 8 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Light Microscopy at Maximal Precision
Authors:
Matthew Bierbaum,
Brian D. Leahy,
Alexander A. Alemi,
Itai Cohen,
James P. Sethna
Abstract:
Microscopy is the workhorse of the physical and life sciences, producing crisp images of everything from atoms to cells well beyond the capabilities of the human eye. However, the analysis of these images is frequently little better than automated manual marking. Here, we revolutionize the analysis of microscopy images, extracting all the information theoretically contained in a complex microscope…
▽ More
Microscopy is the workhorse of the physical and life sciences, producing crisp images of everything from atoms to cells well beyond the capabilities of the human eye. However, the analysis of these images is frequently little better than automated manual marking. Here, we revolutionize the analysis of microscopy images, extracting all the information theoretically contained in a complex microscope image. Using a generic, methodological approach, we extract the information by fitting experimental images with a detailed optical model of the microscope, a method we call Parameter Extraction from Reconstructing Images (PERI). As a proof of principle, we demonstrate this approach with a confocal image of colloidal spheres, improving measurements of particle positions and radii by 100x over current methods and attaining the maximum possible accuracy. With this unprecedented resolution, we measure nanometer-scale colloidal interactions in dense suspensions solely with light microscopy, a previously impossible feat. Our approach is generic and applicable to imaging methods from brightfield to electron microscopy, where we expect accuracies of 1 nm and 0.1 pm, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Visualization, coarsening and flow dynamics of focal conic domains in simulated Smectic-A liquid crystals
Authors:
Danilo B. Liarte,
Matthew Bierbaum,
Muxin Zhang,
Brian D. Leahy,
Itai Cohen,
James P. Sethna
Abstract:
Smectic liquid crystals vividly illustrate the subtle interplay of broken translational and orientational symmetries, by exhibiting defect structures forming geometrically perfect confocal ellipses and hyperbolas. Here, we develop and numerically implement an effective theory to study the dynamics of focal conic domains in smectic-A liquid crystals. We use the information about the smectic's struc…
▽ More
Smectic liquid crystals vividly illustrate the subtle interplay of broken translational and orientational symmetries, by exhibiting defect structures forming geometrically perfect confocal ellipses and hyperbolas. Here, we develop and numerically implement an effective theory to study the dynamics of focal conic domains in smectic-A liquid crystals. We use the information about the smectic's structure and energy density provided by our simulations to develop several novel visualization tools for the focal conics. Our simulations accurately describe both simple and extensional shear, which we compare to experiments, and provide additional insight into the coarsening dynamics of focal conic domains.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2015; v1 submitted 29 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
