-
Speedups in nonequilibrium thermal relaxation: Mpemba and related effects
Authors:
Gianluca Teza,
John Bechhoefer,
Antonio Lasanta,
Oren Raz,
Marija Vucelja
Abstract:
Most of our intuition about the behavior of physical systems is shaped by observations at or near thermal equilibrium. However, even a thermal quench can lead to states far from thermal equilibrium, where counterintuitive, anomalous effects can occur. A prime example of anomalous thermal relaxation is the Mpemba effect, in which a system prepared at a hot temperature cools down to the temperature…
▽ More
Most of our intuition about the behavior of physical systems is shaped by observations at or near thermal equilibrium. However, even a thermal quench can lead to states far from thermal equilibrium, where counterintuitive, anomalous effects can occur. A prime example of anomalous thermal relaxation is the Mpemba effect, in which a system prepared at a hot temperature cools down to the temperature of the cold environment faster than an identical system prepared at a warm temperature. Although reported for water more than 2000 years ago by Aristotle, the recent observations of analogous relaxation speedups in a variety of systems have motivated the search for general explanations. We review anomalous relaxation effects, which all share a nonmonotonic dependence of relaxation time versus initial ``distance" from the final state or from the phase transition. The final state can be an equilibrium or a nonequilibrium steady state. We first review the water experiments and classify the anomalous relaxation phenomena related to the Mpemba effect. We then provide a modern definition of the Mpemba effect, focusing on the theoretical frameworks of stochastic thermodynamics, kinetic theory, Markovian dynamics, and phase transitions. We discuss the recent experimental and numerical developments that followed these theoretical advances. These developments paved the way for the prediction and observation of novel phenomena, such as the inverse Mpemba effect. The review is self-contained and introduces anomalous relaxation phenomena in single- and many-body systems, both classical and quantum. We also discuss the broader relevance of the Mpemba effect, including its relation with phase transitions and its experimental implications. We end with perspectives that connect anomalous speedups to ideas for designing optimal heating/cooling protocols, heat engines, and efficient samplers.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2025; v1 submitted 3 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Asymmetries of thermal processes in open quantum systems
Authors:
Álvaro Tejero,
Rafael Sánchez,
Laiachi El Kaoutit,
Daniel Manzano,
Antonio Lasanta
Abstract:
An intriguing phenomenon in non-equilibrium quantum thermodynamics is the asymmetry of thermal processes. Relaxation to thermal equilibrium is the most important dissipative process, being a key concept for the design of heat engines and refrigerators, contributing to the study of foundational questions of thermodynamics, and being relevant for quantum computing through the process of algorithmic…
▽ More
An intriguing phenomenon in non-equilibrium quantum thermodynamics is the asymmetry of thermal processes. Relaxation to thermal equilibrium is the most important dissipative process, being a key concept for the design of heat engines and refrigerators, contributing to the study of foundational questions of thermodynamics, and being relevant for quantum computing through the process of algorithmic cooling. Despite their importance, the dynamics of these processes are far from being understood. We show that the free relaxation to thermal equilibrium follows intrinsically different paths depending on whether it involves the temperature of the system to increase or to decrease. Our theory is exemplified using the recently developed thermal kinematics based on information geometry theory, utilizing three prototypical examples: a two-level system, the quantum harmonic oscillator, and a trapped quantum Brownian particle, in all cases showing faster heating than cooling under the appropriate conditions. A general understanding is obtained based on the spectral decomposition of the Liouvillian and the spectral gap of reciprocal processes.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2025; v1 submitted 28 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Shortcuts of freely relaxing systems using equilibrium physical observables
Authors:
Isidoro González-Adalid Pemartín,
Emanuel Mompó,
Antonio Lasanta,
Víctor Martín-Mayor,
Jesús Salas
Abstract:
Many systems, when initially placed far from equilibrium, exhibit surprising behavior in their attempt to equilibrate. Striking examples are the Mpemba effect and the cooling-heating asymmetry. These anomalous behaviors can be exploited to shorten the time needed to cool down (or heat up) a system. Though, a strategy to design these effects in mesoscopic systems is missing. We bring forward a desc…
▽ More
Many systems, when initially placed far from equilibrium, exhibit surprising behavior in their attempt to equilibrate. Striking examples are the Mpemba effect and the cooling-heating asymmetry. These anomalous behaviors can be exploited to shorten the time needed to cool down (or heat up) a system. Though, a strategy to design these effects in mesoscopic systems is missing. We bring forward a description that allows us to formulate such strategies, and, along the way, makes natural these paradoxical behaviors. In particular, we study the evolution of macroscopic physical observables of systems freely relaxing under the influence of one or two instantaneous thermal quenches. The two crucial ingredients in our approach are timescale separation and a nonmonotonic temperature evolution of an important state function. We argue that both are generic features near a first-order transition. Our theory is exemplified with the one-dimensional Ising model in a magnetic field using analytic results and numerical experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2024; v1 submitted 8 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Heating and Cooling are Fundamentally Asymmetric and Evolve Along Distinct Pathways
Authors:
Miguel Ibáñez,
Cai Dieball,
Antonio Lasanta,
Aljaž Godec,
Raúl A. Rica
Abstract:
According to conventional wisdom, a system placed in an environment with a different temperature tends to relax to the temperature of the latter, mediated by the flows of heat and/or matter that are set solely by the temperature difference. It is becoming clear, however, that thermal relaxation is much more intricate when temperature changes push the system far from thermodynamic equilibrium. Inte…
▽ More
According to conventional wisdom, a system placed in an environment with a different temperature tends to relax to the temperature of the latter, mediated by the flows of heat and/or matter that are set solely by the temperature difference. It is becoming clear, however, that thermal relaxation is much more intricate when temperature changes push the system far from thermodynamic equilibrium. Interestingly, under such conditions heating was predicted to be faster than cooling, which we experimentally confirm using an optically trapped colloidal particle. More strikingly, we show with both experiments and theory that between any pair of temperatures, heating is not only faster than cooling but the respective processes in fact evolve along fundamentally distinct pathways, which we explain with a new theoretical framework we coin "thermal kinematics".
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Slow growth of magnetic domains helps fast evolution routes for out-of-equilibrium dynamics
Authors:
Isidoro González-Adalid Pemartín,
Emanuel Mompó,
Antonio Lasanta,
Víctor Martín-Mayor,
Jesús Salas
Abstract:
Cooling and heating faster a system is a crucial problem in science, technology and industry. Indeed, choosing the best thermal protocol to reach a desired temperature or energy is not a trivial task. Noticeably, we find that the phase transitions may speed up thermalization in systems where there are no conserved quantities. In particular, we show that the slow growth of magnetic domains shortens…
▽ More
Cooling and heating faster a system is a crucial problem in science, technology and industry. Indeed, choosing the best thermal protocol to reach a desired temperature or energy is not a trivial task. Noticeably, we find that the phase transitions may speed up thermalization in systems where there are no conserved quantities. In particular, we show that the slow growth of magnetic domains shortens the overall time that the system takes to reach a final desired state. To prove that statement, we use intensive numerical simulations of a prototypical many-body system, namely the 2D Ising model.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2021; v1 submitted 28 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Kovacs memory effect with an optically levitated nanoparticle
Authors:
Andrei Militaru,
Antonio Lasanta,
Martin Frimmer,
Luis L. Bonilla,
Lukas Novotny,
Raul A. Rica
Abstract:
The understanding of the dynamics of nonequilibrium cooling and heating processes at the nanoscale is still an open problem. These processes can follow surprising relaxation paths due to, e.g., memory effects, which significantly alter the expected equilibration routes. The Kovacs effect can take place when a thermalization process is suddenly interrupted by a change of the bath temperature, leadi…
▽ More
The understanding of the dynamics of nonequilibrium cooling and heating processes at the nanoscale is still an open problem. These processes can follow surprising relaxation paths due to, e.g., memory effects, which significantly alter the expected equilibration routes. The Kovacs effect can take place when a thermalization process is suddenly interrupted by a change of the bath temperature, leading to a non-monotonic dependence of the energy of the system. Here, we demonstrate that the Kovacs effect can be observed in the thermalization of the center of mass motion of a levitated nanoparticle. The temperature is controlled during the experiment through an external source of white gaussian noise. We describe our experiments in terms of the dynamics of a Brownian particle in a harmonic trap without any fitting parameter, suggesting that the Kovacs effect canappear in a large variety of systems.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Exponentially accelerated approach to stationarity in Markovian open quantum systems through the Mpemba effect
Authors:
Federico Carollo,
Antonio Lasanta,
Igor Lesanovsky
Abstract:
Ergodicity-breaking and slow relaxation are intriguing aspects of nonequilibrium dynamics both in classical and in quantum settings. These phenomena are typically associated with phase transitions, e.g. the emergence of metastable regimes near a first-order transition or scaling dynamics in the vicinity of critical points. Despite being of fundamental interest the associated divergent time scales…
▽ More
Ergodicity-breaking and slow relaxation are intriguing aspects of nonequilibrium dynamics both in classical and in quantum settings. These phenomena are typically associated with phase transitions, e.g. the emergence of metastable regimes near a first-order transition or scaling dynamics in the vicinity of critical points. Despite being of fundamental interest the associated divergent time scales are a hindrance when trying to explore steady-state properties. Here we show that the relaxation dynamics of Markovian open quantum systems can be accelerated exponentially by devising an optimal unitary transformation that is applied to the quantum system immediately before the actual dynamics. This initial "rotation" is engineered in such a way that the state of the quantum system becomes orthogonal to the slowest decaying dynamical mode. We illustrate our idea -- which is inspired by the so-called Mpemba effect, i.e., water freezing faster when initially heated up -- by showing how to achieve an exponential speed-up in the convergence to stationarity in Dicke models, and how to avoid metastable regimes in an all-to-all interacting spin system.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Memory effects in a gas of viscoelastic particles
Authors:
E. Mompó,
M. A. López-Castaño,
A. Torrente,
F. Vega Reyes,
A. Lasanta
Abstract:
We study a granular gas of viscoelastic particles (kinetic energy loss upon collision is a function of the particles' relative velocities at impact) subject to a stochastic thermostat. We show that the system displays anomalous cooling and heating rates during thermal relaxation processes, this causing the emergence of thermal memory. In particular, a significant \textit{Mpemba effect} is present;…
▽ More
We study a granular gas of viscoelastic particles (kinetic energy loss upon collision is a function of the particles' relative velocities at impact) subject to a stochastic thermostat. We show that the system displays anomalous cooling and heating rates during thermal relaxation processes, this causing the emergence of thermal memory. In particular, a significant \textit{Mpemba effect} is present; i.e., an initially hotter/cooler granular gas can cool down/heat up faster than an in comparison cooler/hotter granular gas. Moreover, a \textit{Kovacs effect} is also observed; i.e., a non-monotonic relaxation of the granular temperature --if the gas undergoes certain sudden temperature changes before fixing its value. Our results show that both memory effects have distinct features, very different and eventually opposed to those reported in theory for granular fluids under simpler collisional models. We study our system via three independent methods: approximate solution of the kinetic equation time evolution and computer simulations (both molecular dynamics simulations and Direct Simulation Monte Carlo method), finding good agreement between them.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2021; v1 submitted 30 May, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Fluctuation-induced current from freestanding graphene: toward nanoscale energy harvesting
Authors:
P. M. Thibado,
P. Kumar,
Surendra Singh,
M. Ruiz-Garcia,
A. Lasanta,
L. L. Bonilla
Abstract:
At room temperature, micron-sized sheets of freestanding graphene are in constant motion even in the presence of an applied bias voltage. We quantify the out-of-plane movement by collecting the displacement current using a nearby small-area metal electrode and present a Langevin model for the motion coupled to a circuit containing diodes. The system reaches thermal equilibrium and the rates of hea…
▽ More
At room temperature, micron-sized sheets of freestanding graphene are in constant motion even in the presence of an applied bias voltage. We quantify the out-of-plane movement by collecting the displacement current using a nearby small-area metal electrode and present a Langevin model for the motion coupled to a circuit containing diodes. The system reaches thermal equilibrium and the rates of heat, work, and entropy production tend quickly to zero. However, there is power generated by graphene which is equal to the power dissipated by the load resistor. The exact power formula is similar to Nyquist's noise power formula, except that the rate of change of diode resistance significantly boosts the output power, and the movement of the graphene shifts the power spectrum to lower frequencies.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Paths towards equilibrium in molecular systems: a mesoscopic Mpemba-like effect in water
Authors:
A. Gijón,
A. Lasanta,
E. R. Hernández
Abstract:
The so-called Mpemba effect, i.e. the observation that the warmer of two otherwise identical systems cools faster when both are refrigerated in the same thermal reservoir, is a hotly debated topic in condensed mater physics and statistical mechanics. Although it has been found in several non-equilibrium model systems, its very existence in water, the system in which it has been historically report…
▽ More
The so-called Mpemba effect, i.e. the observation that the warmer of two otherwise identical systems cools faster when both are refrigerated in the same thermal reservoir, is a hotly debated topic in condensed mater physics and statistical mechanics. Although it has been found in several non-equilibrium model systems, its very existence in water, the system in which it has been historically reported, is still open to question. Here we show using numerical simulations that a Mpemba effect is indeed present in water. We find that the effect occurs when equipartition of energy is not present in the initial state. Interestingly, the effect is observed without the intervention of a phase transition, and it is therefore seen to be a purely non-equilibrium relaxation effect.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Induced correlations and rupture of molecular chaos by anisotropic dissipative Janus hard disks
Authors:
Antonio Lasanta,
Aurora Torrente,
Mariano Lopez de Haro
Abstract:
A system of smooth "frozen" Janus-type disks is studied. Such disks cannot rotate and are divided by their diameter into two sides of different inelasticities. Taking as a reference a system of colored elastic disks, we find differences in the behavior of the collisions once the anisotropy is included. A homogeneous state, akin to the homogeneous cooling state of granular gases, is seen to arise a…
▽ More
A system of smooth "frozen" Janus-type disks is studied. Such disks cannot rotate and are divided by their diameter into two sides of different inelasticities. Taking as a reference a system of colored elastic disks, we find differences in the behavior of the collisions once the anisotropy is included. A homogeneous state, akin to the homogeneous cooling state of granular gases, is seen to arise and the singular behavior of both the collisions and the precollisional correlations are highlighted.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Intruders in disguise: Mimicry effect in granular gases
Authors:
Antonio Lasanta,
Francisco Vega Reyes,
Vicente Garzó,
Andrés Santos
Abstract:
In general, the total kinetic energy in a multicomponent granular gas of inelastic and rough hard spheres is unequally partitioned among the different degrees of freedom. On the other hand, partial energy equipartition can be reached, in principle, under appropriate combinations of the mechanical parameters of the system. Assuming common values of the coefficients of restitution, we use kinetic-th…
▽ More
In general, the total kinetic energy in a multicomponent granular gas of inelastic and rough hard spheres is unequally partitioned among the different degrees of freedom. On the other hand, partial energy equipartition can be reached, in principle, under appropriate combinations of the mechanical parameters of the system. Assuming common values of the coefficients of restitution, we use kinetic-theory tools to determine the conditions under which the components of a granular mixture in the homogeneous cooling state have the same translational and rotational temperatures as those of a one-component granular gas (``mimicry'' effect). Given the values of the concentrations and the size ratios, the mimicry effect requires the mass ratios to take specific values, the smaller spheres having a larger particle mass density than the bigger spheres. The theoretical predictions for the case of an impurity immersed in a host granular gas are compared against both DSMC and molecular dynamics simulations with a good agreement.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2019; v1 submitted 26 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Large Mpemba-like effect in a gas of inelastic rough hard spheres
Authors:
Aurora Torrente,
Miguel A. López-Castaño,
Antonio Lasanta,
Francisco Vega Reyes,
Antonio Prados,
Andrés Santos
Abstract:
We report the emergence of a giant Mpemba effect in the uniformly heated gas of inelastic rough hard spheres: The initially hotter sample may cool sooner than the colder one, even when the initial temperatures differ by more than one order of magnitude. In order to understand this behavior, it suffices to consider the simplest Maxwellian approximation for the velocity distribution in a kinetic app…
▽ More
We report the emergence of a giant Mpemba effect in the uniformly heated gas of inelastic rough hard spheres: The initially hotter sample may cool sooner than the colder one, even when the initial temperatures differ by more than one order of magnitude. In order to understand this behavior, it suffices to consider the simplest Maxwellian approximation for the velocity distribution in a kinetic approach. The largeness of the effect stems from the fact that the rotational and translational temperatures, which obey two coupled evolution equations, are comparable. Our theoretical predictions agree very well with molecular dynamics and direct simulation Monte Carlo data.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2019; v1 submitted 25 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
On the emergence of large and complex memory effects in nonequilibrium fluids
Authors:
Antonio Lasanta,
Francisco Vega Reyes,
Antonio Prados,
Andrés Santos
Abstract:
Control of cooling and heating processes is essential in many industrial and biological processes. In fact, the time evolution of an observable quantity may differ according to the previous history of the system. For example, a system that is being subject to cooling and then, at a given time $t_{w}$ for which the instantaneous temperature is $T(t_w)=T_{\mathrm{st}}$, is suddenly put in contact wi…
▽ More
Control of cooling and heating processes is essential in many industrial and biological processes. In fact, the time evolution of an observable quantity may differ according to the previous history of the system. For example, a system that is being subject to cooling and then, at a given time $t_{w}$ for which the instantaneous temperature is $T(t_w)=T_{\mathrm{st}}$, is suddenly put in contact with a temperature source at $T_{\mathrm{st}}$ may continue cooling down temporarily or, on the contrary, undergo a temperature rebound. According to current knowledge, there can be only one "spurious" and small peak/low. However, our results prove that, under certain conditions, more than one extremum may appear. Specifically, we have observed regions with two extrema and a critical point with three extrema. We have also detected cases where extraordinarily large extrema are observed, as large as the order of magnitude of the stationary value of the variable of interest. We show this by studying the thermal evolution of a low density set of macroscopic particles that do not preserve kinetic energy upon collision, i.e., a granular gas. We describe the mechanism that signals in this system the emergence of these complex and large memory effects, and explain why similar observations can be expected in a variety of systems.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2019; v1 submitted 25 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
The Mpemba effect in spin glasses is a persistent memory effect
Authors:
Janus collaboration,
M. Baity-Jesi,
E. Calore,
A. Cruz,
L. A. Fernandez,
J. M. Gil-Narvion,
A. Gordillo-Guerrero,
D. Iñiguez,
A. Lasanta,
A. Maiorano,
E. Marinari,
V. Martin-Mayor,
J. Moreno-Gordo,
A. Muñoz-Sudupe,
D. Navarro,
G. Parisi,
S. Perez-Gaviro,
F. Ricci-Tersenghi,
J. J. Ruiz-Lorenzo,
S. F. Schifano,
B. Seoane,
A. Tarancon,
R. Tripiccione,
D. Yllanes
Abstract:
The Mpemba effect occurs when a hot system cools faster than an initially colder one, when both are refrigerated in the same thermal reservoir. Using the custom built supercomputer Janus II, we study the Mpemba effect in spin glasses and show that it is a non-equilibrium process, governed by the coherence length ξof the system. The effect occurs when the bath temperature lies in the glassy phase,…
▽ More
The Mpemba effect occurs when a hot system cools faster than an initially colder one, when both are refrigerated in the same thermal reservoir. Using the custom built supercomputer Janus II, we study the Mpemba effect in spin glasses and show that it is a non-equilibrium process, governed by the coherence length ξof the system. The effect occurs when the bath temperature lies in the glassy phase, but it is not necessary for the thermal protocol to cross the critical temperature. In fact, the Mpemba effect follows from a strong relationship between the internal energy and ξthat turns out to be a sure-tell sign of being in the glassy phase. Thus, the Mpemba effect presents itself as an intriguing new avenue for the experimental study of the coherence length in supercooled liquids and other glass formers.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2019; v1 submitted 20 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Energy nonequipartition in gas mixtures of inelastic rough hard spheres: The tracer limit
Authors:
Francisco Vega Reyes,
Antonio Lasanta,
Andrés Santos,
Vicente Garzó
Abstract:
The dynamical properties of a tracer or impurity particle immersed in a host gas of inelastic and rough hard spheres in the homogeneous cooling state is studied. Specifically, the breakdown of energy equipartition as characterized by the tracer/host ratios of translational and rotational temperatures is analyzed by exploring a wide spectrum of values of the control parameters of the system (masses…
▽ More
The dynamical properties of a tracer or impurity particle immersed in a host gas of inelastic and rough hard spheres in the homogeneous cooling state is studied. Specifically, the breakdown of energy equipartition as characterized by the tracer/host ratios of translational and rotational temperatures is analyzed by exploring a wide spectrum of values of the control parameters of the system (masses, moments of inertia, sizes, and coefficients of restitution). Three complementary approaches are considered. On the theoretical side, the Boltzmann and Boltzmann--Lorentz equations (both assuming the molecular chaos ansatz) are solved by means of a multitemperature Maxwellian approximation for the velocity distribution functions. This allows us to obtain explicit analytical expressions for the temperature ratios. On the computational side, two different techniques are used. First, the kinetic equations are numerically solved by the direct simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) method. Second, molecular dynamics simulations for dilute gases are performed. Comparison between theory and simulations shows a general good agreement. This means that (i) the impact of the molecular chaos ansatz on the temperature ratios is not significant (except at high inelasticities and/or big impurities) and (ii) the simple Maxwellian approximation yields quite reliable predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2019; v1 submitted 1 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Hydrodynamics of a Granular Gas in a Heterogeneous Environment
Authors:
Francisco Vega Reyes,
Antonio Lasanta
Abstract:
We analyze the transport properties of a low density ensemble of identical macroscopic particles immersed in an active fluid. The particles are modeled as inelastic hard spheres (granular gas). The non-homogeneous active fluid is modeled by means of a non-uniform stochastic thermostat. The theoretical results are validated with a numerical solution of the corresponding the kinetic equation (direct…
▽ More
We analyze the transport properties of a low density ensemble of identical macroscopic particles immersed in an active fluid. The particles are modeled as inelastic hard spheres (granular gas). The non-homogeneous active fluid is modeled by means of a non-uniform stochastic thermostat. The theoretical results are validated with a numerical solution of the corresponding the kinetic equation (direct simulation Monte Carlo method). We show a steady flow in the system that is accurately described by Navier-Stokes (NS) hydrodynamics, even for high inelasticity. Surprisingly, we find that the deviations from NS hydrodynamics for this flow are stronger as the inelasticity decreases. The active fluid action is modeled here with a non-uniform fluctuating volume force. This is a relevant result given that hydrodynamics of particles in complex environments, such as biological crowded environments, is still a question under intense debate.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2017; v1 submitted 21 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
When the Hotter Cools More Quickly: Mpemba Effect in Granular Fluids
Authors:
Antonio Lasanta,
Francisco Vega Reyes,
Antonio Prados,
Andrés Santos
Abstract:
Under certain conditions, two samples of fluid at different initial temperatures present a counterintuitive behavior known as the Mpemba effect: it is the hotter system that cools sooner. Here, we show that the Mpemba effect is present in granular fluids, both in uniformly heated and in freely cooling systems. In both cases, the system remains homogeneous, and no phase transition is present. Analy…
▽ More
Under certain conditions, two samples of fluid at different initial temperatures present a counterintuitive behavior known as the Mpemba effect: it is the hotter system that cools sooner. Here, we show that the Mpemba effect is present in granular fluids, both in uniformly heated and in freely cooling systems. In both cases, the system remains homogeneous, and no phase transition is present. Analytical quantitative predictions are given for how differently the system must be initially prepared to observe the Mpemba effect, the theoretical predictions being confirmed by both molecular dynamics and Monte Carlo simulations. Possible implications of our analysis for other systems are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2017; v1 submitted 15 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Thermal properties of an impurity immersed in a granular gas of rough hard spheres
Authors:
Francisco Vega Reyes,
Antonio Lasanta,
Andrés Santos,
Vicente Garzó
Abstract:
We study in this work the dynamics of a granular impurity immersed in a low-density granular gas of identical particles. For description of the kinetics of the granular gas and the impurity particles we use the rough hard sphere collisional model. We take into account the effects of non-conservation of energy upon particle collision. We find an (approximate) analytical solution of the pertinent ki…
▽ More
We study in this work the dynamics of a granular impurity immersed in a low-density granular gas of identical particles. For description of the kinetics of the granular gas and the impurity particles we use the rough hard sphere collisional model. We take into account the effects of non-conservation of energy upon particle collision. We find an (approximate) analytical solution of the pertinent kinetic equations for the single-particle velocity distribution functions that reproduces reasonably well the properties of translational/rotational energy non-equipartition. We assess the accuracy of the theoretical solution by comparing with computer simulations. For this, we use two independent computer data sets, from molecular dynamics (MD) and from Direct Simulation Monte Carlo method (DSMC). Both approach well, with different degrees, the kinetic theory within a reasonable range of parameter values.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2017; v1 submitted 28 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Unified rheology of vibro-fluidized dry granular media: From slow dense flows to fast gas-like regimes
Authors:
Andrea Gnoli,
Antonio Lasanta,
Alessandro Sarracino,
Andrea Puglisi
Abstract:
Granular media take on great importance in industry and geophysics, posing a severe challenge to materials science. Their response properties elude known soft rheological models, even when the yield-stress discontinuity is blurred by vibro-fluidization. Here we propose a broad rheological scenario where average stress sums up a frictional contribution, generalizing conventional $μ(I)$-rheology, an…
▽ More
Granular media take on great importance in industry and geophysics, posing a severe challenge to materials science. Their response properties elude known soft rheological models, even when the yield-stress discontinuity is blurred by vibro-fluidization. Here we propose a broad rheological scenario where average stress sums up a frictional contribution, generalizing conventional $μ(I)$-rheology, and a kinetic collisional term dominating at fast fluidization. Our conjecture fairly describes a wide series of experiments in a vibrofluidized vane setup, whose phenomenology includes velocity weakening, shear thinning, a discontinuous thinning transition, and gaseous shear thickening. The employed setup gives access to dynamic fluctuations, which exhibit a broad range of timescales. In the slow dense regime the frequency of cage-opening increases with stress and enhances, with respect to $μ(I)$-rheology, the decrease of viscosity. Diffusivity is exponential in the shear stress in both thinning and thickening regimes, with a huge growth near the transition.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Lattice models for granular-like velocity fields: Finite-size effects
Authors:
C. A. Plata,
A. Manacorda,
A. Lasanta,
A. Puglisi,
A. Prados
Abstract:
Long-range spatial correlations in the velocity and energy fields of a granular fluid are discussed in the framework of a 1d lattice model. The dynamics of the velocity field occurs through nearest-neighbour inelastic collisions that conserve momentum but dissipate energy. A set of equations for the fluctuating hydrodynamics of the velocity and energy mesoscopic fields give a first approximation f…
▽ More
Long-range spatial correlations in the velocity and energy fields of a granular fluid are discussed in the framework of a 1d lattice model. The dynamics of the velocity field occurs through nearest-neighbour inelastic collisions that conserve momentum but dissipate energy. A set of equations for the fluctuating hydrodynamics of the velocity and energy mesoscopic fields give a first approximation for (i) the velocity structure factor and (ii) the finite-size correction to the Haff law, both in the homogeneous cooling regime. At a more refined level, we have derived the equations for the two-site velocity correlations and the total energy fluctuations. First, we seek a perturbative solution thereof, in powers of the inverse of system size. On the one hand, when scaled with the granular temperature, the velocity correlations tend to a stationary value in the long time limit. On the other hand, the scaled standard deviation of the total energy diverges, that is, the system shows multiscaling. Second, we find an exact solution for the velocity correlations in terms of the spectrum of eigenvalues of a certain matrix. The results of numerical simulations of the microscopic model confirm our theoretical results, including the above described multiscaling phenomenon.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2016; v1 submitted 29 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Lattice models for granular-like velocity fields: Hydrodynamic limit
Authors:
Alessandro Manacorda,
Carlos A. Plata,
Antonio Lasanta,
Andrea Puglisi,
Antonio Prados
Abstract:
A recently introduced model describing -on a 1d lattice- the velocity field of a granular fluid is discussed in detail. The dynamics of the velocity field occurs through next-neighbours inelastic collisions which conserve momentum but dissipate energy. The dynamics can be described by a stochastic equation in full phase space, or through the corresponding Master Equation for the time evolution of…
▽ More
A recently introduced model describing -on a 1d lattice- the velocity field of a granular fluid is discussed in detail. The dynamics of the velocity field occurs through next-neighbours inelastic collisions which conserve momentum but dissipate energy. The dynamics can be described by a stochastic equation in full phase space, or through the corresponding Master Equation for the time evolution of the probability distribution. In the hydrodynamic limit, equations for the average velocity and temperature fields with fluctuating currents are derived, which are analogous to those of granular fluids when restricted to the shear modes. Therefore, the homogeneous cooling state, with its linear instability, and other relevant regimes such as the uniform shear flow and the Couette flow states are described. The evolution in time and space of the single particle probability distribution, in all those regimes, is also discussed, showing that the local equilibrium is not valid in general. The noise for the momentum and energy currents, which are correlated, are white and Gaussian. The same is true for the noise of the energy sink, which is usually negligible.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Statistics of the dissipated energy in driven diffusive systems
Authors:
A. Lasanta,
Pablo I. Hurtado,
A. Prados
Abstract:
Understanding the physics of non-equilibrium systems remains as one of the major open questions in statistical physics. This problem can be partially handled by investigating macroscopic fluctuations of key magnitudes that characterise the non-equilibrium behaviour of the system of interest; their statistics, associated structures and microscopic origin. During the last years, some new general and…
▽ More
Understanding the physics of non-equilibrium systems remains as one of the major open questions in statistical physics. This problem can be partially handled by investigating macroscopic fluctuations of key magnitudes that characterise the non-equilibrium behaviour of the system of interest; their statistics, associated structures and microscopic origin. During the last years, some new general and powerful methods have appeared to delve into fluctuating behaviour that have drastically changed the way to address this problem in the realm of diffusive systems: macroscopic fluctuation theory (MFT) and a set of advanced computational techniques that make it possible to measure the probability of rare events. Notwithstanding, a satisfactory theory is still lacking in a particular case of intrinsically non-equilibrium systems, namely those in which energy is not conserved but dissipated continuously in the bulk of the system (e.g. granular media). In this work, we put forward the dissipated energy as a relevant quantity in this case and analyse in a pedagogical way its fluctuations, by making use of a suitable generalisation of macroscopic fluctuation theory to driven dissipative media.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2016; v1 submitted 30 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
An Itinerant Oscillator model with cage inertia for mesorheological granular experiments
Authors:
A. Lasanta,
A. Puglisi
Abstract:
Recent experiments with a rotating probe immersed in weakly fluidized granular materials show a complex behavior on a wide range of timescales. Viscous-like relaxation at high frequency is accom- panied by an almost harmonic dynamical trapping at intermediate times, with possibly anomalous long time behavior in the form of super-diffusion. Inspired by the Itinerant Oscillator model for dif- fusion…
▽ More
Recent experiments with a rotating probe immersed in weakly fluidized granular materials show a complex behavior on a wide range of timescales. Viscous-like relaxation at high frequency is accom- panied by an almost harmonic dynamical trapping at intermediate times, with possibly anomalous long time behavior in the form of super-diffusion. Inspired by the Itinerant Oscillator model for dif- fusion in molecular liquids, and other models with coupled thermostats acting at different timescales, here we discuss a new model able to account for fast viscous relaxation, dynamical trapping and super-diffusion at long times. The main difference with respect to liquids, is a non-negligible cage inertia for the surrounding (granular) fluid, which allows it to sustain a slow but persistent mo- tion for long times. The computed velocity power density spectra and mean-squared displacement qualitatively reproduce the experimental findings. We also discuss the linear response to external perturbations and the tail of the distribution of persistency time, which is associated with superdif- fusion, and whose cut-off time is determined by cage inertia.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Fluctuating hydrodynamics and mesoscopic effects of spatial correlations in dissipative systems with conserved momentum
Authors:
A. Lasanta,
A. Manacorda,
A. Prados,
A. Puglisi
Abstract:
We introduce a model described in terms of a scalar velocity field on a 1d lattice, evolving through collisions that conserve momentum but do not conserve energy. Such a system posseses some of the main ingredients of fluidized granular media and naturally models them. We deduce non-linear fluctuating hydrodynamics equations for the macroscopic velocity and temperature fields, which replicate the…
▽ More
We introduce a model described in terms of a scalar velocity field on a 1d lattice, evolving through collisions that conserve momentum but do not conserve energy. Such a system posseses some of the main ingredients of fluidized granular media and naturally models them. We deduce non-linear fluctuating hydrodynamics equations for the macroscopic velocity and temperature fields, which replicate the hydrody- namics of shear modes in a granular fluid. Moreover, this Landau-like fluctuating hydrodynamics predicts an essential part of the peculiar behaviour of granular flu- ids, like the instability of homogeneous cooling state at large size or inelasticity. We compute also the exact shape of long range spatial correlations which, even far from the instability, have the physical consequence of noticeably modifying the cooling rate. This effect, which stems from momentum conservation, has not been previously reported in the realm of granular fluids.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Typical and rare fluctuations in nonlinear driven diffusive systems with dissipation
Authors:
P. I. Hurtado,
A. Lasanta,
A. Prados
Abstract:
We consider fluctuations of the dissipated energy in nonlinear driven diffusive systems subject to bulk dissipation and boundary driving. With this aim, we extend the recently-introduced macroscopic fluctuation theory to nonlinear driven dissipative media, starting from the fluctuating hydrodynamic equations describing the system mesoscopic evolution. Interestingly, the action associated to a path…
▽ More
We consider fluctuations of the dissipated energy in nonlinear driven diffusive systems subject to bulk dissipation and boundary driving. With this aim, we extend the recently-introduced macroscopic fluctuation theory to nonlinear driven dissipative media, starting from the fluctuating hydrodynamic equations describing the system mesoscopic evolution. Interestingly, the action associated to a path in mesoscopic phase-space, from which large-deviation functions for macroscopic observables can be derived, has the same simple form as in non-dissipative systems. This is a consequence of the quasi-elasticity of microscopic dynamics, required in order to have a nontrivial competition between diffusion and dissipation at the mesoscale. Euler-Lagrange equations for the optimal density and current fields that sustain an arbitrary dissipation fluctuation are also derived. A perturbative solution thereof shows that the probability distribution of small fluctuations is always gaussian, as expected from the central limit theorem. On the other hand, strong separation from the gaussian behavior is observed for large fluctuations, with a distribution which shows no negative branch, thus violating the Gallavotti-Cohen fluctuation theorem as expected from the irreversibility of the dynamics. The dissipation large-deviation function exhibits simple and general scaling forms for weakly and strongly dissipative systems, with large fluctuations favored in the former case but heavily supressed in the latter. (...) [see complete abstract by downloading the paper]
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
Nonlinear driven diffusive systems with dissipation: fluctuating hydrodynamics
Authors:
A. Prados,
A. Lasanta,
Pablo I. Hurtado
Abstract:
We consider a general class of nonlinear diffusive models with bulk dissipation and boundary driving, and derive its hydrodynamic description in the large size limit. Both the average macroscopic behavior and the fluctuating properties of the hydrodynamic fields are obtained from the microscopic dynamics. This analysis yields a fluctuating balance equation for the local energy density at the mesos…
▽ More
We consider a general class of nonlinear diffusive models with bulk dissipation and boundary driving, and derive its hydrodynamic description in the large size limit. Both the average macroscopic behavior and the fluctuating properties of the hydrodynamic fields are obtained from the microscopic dynamics. This analysis yields a fluctuating balance equation for the local energy density at the mesoscopic level, characterized by two terms: (i) a diffusive term, with a current that fluctuates around its average behavior given by nonlinear Fourier's law, and (ii) a dissipation term which is a general function of the local energy density. The quasi-elasticity of microscopic dynamics, required in order to have a nontrivial competition between diffusion and dissipation in the macroscopic limit, implies a noiseless dissipation term in the balance equation, so dissipation fluctuations are enslaved to those of the density field. The microscopic complexity is thus condensed in just three transport coefficients, the diffusivity, the mobility and a new dissipation coefficient, which are explicitly calculated within a local equilibrium approximation. Interestingly, the diffusivity and mobility coefficients obey an Einstein relation despite the fully nonequilibrium character of the problem. The general theory here presented is applied to a particular albeit broad family of systems, the simplest nonlinear dissipative variant of the so-called KMP model for heat transport. The theoretical predictions are compared to extensive numerical simulations, and an excellent agreement is found.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Large Fluctuations in Driven Dissipative Media
Authors:
A. Prados,
A. Lasanta,
Pablo I. Hurtado
Abstract:
We analyze the fluctuations of the dissipated energy in a simple and general model where dissipation, diffusion and driving are the key ingredients. The large deviation function for the dissipation follows from hydrodynamic fluctuation theory and an additivity conjecture. This function is strongly non-Gaussian and has no negative branch, thus violating the fluctuation theorem as expected from the…
▽ More
We analyze the fluctuations of the dissipated energy in a simple and general model where dissipation, diffusion and driving are the key ingredients. The large deviation function for the dissipation follows from hydrodynamic fluctuation theory and an additivity conjecture. This function is strongly non-Gaussian and has no negative branch, thus violating the fluctuation theorem as expected from the irreversibility of the dynamics. It exhibits simple, universal scaling forms in the weak- and strong-dissipation limits, with large fluctuations favoured in the former case but strongly suppressed in the latter. The typical path associated to a given dissipation fluctuation is also analyzed in detail. Our results, confirmed in extensive simulations, strongly support the validity of hydrodynamic fluctuation theory to describe fluctuating behavior in driven dissipative media.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2011; v1 submitted 17 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
