-
Intruder in a two-dimensional granular system: statics and dynamics of force networks in an experimental system experiencing stick-slip dynamics
Authors:
R. Basak,
R. Kozlowski,
L. A. Pugnaloni,
M. Kramar,
E. S. Socolar,
C. M. Carlevaro,
L. Kondic
Abstract:
In quasi-two-dimensional experiments with photoelastic particles confined to an annular region, an intruder constrained to move in a circular path halfway between the annular walls experiences stick-slip dynamics. We discuss the response of the granular medium to the driven intruder, focusing on the evolution of the force network during sticking periods. Because the available experimental data doe…
▽ More
In quasi-two-dimensional experiments with photoelastic particles confined to an annular region, an intruder constrained to move in a circular path halfway between the annular walls experiences stick-slip dynamics. We discuss the response of the granular medium to the driven intruder, focusing on the evolution of the force network during sticking periods. Because the available experimental data does not include precise information about individual contact forces, we use an approach developed in our previous work (Basak et al, J. Eng. Mechanics (2021)) based on networks constructed from measurements of the integrated strain magnitude on each particle. These networks are analyzed using topological measures based on persistence diagrams, revealing that force networks evolve smoothly but in a nontrivial manner throughout each sticking period, even though the intruder and granular particles are stationary. Characteristic features of persistence diagrams show identifiable changes as a slip is approaching, indicating the existence of slip precursors. Key features of the dynamics are similar for granular materials composed of disks or pentagons, but some details are consistently different. In particular, we find significantly larger fluctuations of the measures computed based on persistence diagrams, and therefore of the underlying networks, for systems of pentagonal particles.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Stochastic methods for slip prediction in a sheared granular system
Authors:
Philip Bretz,
Lou Kondic,
Miro Kramar
Abstract:
We consider a sheared granular system experiencing intermittent dynamics of stick-slip type via discrete element simulations. The considered setup consists of a two-dimensional system of soft frictional particles sandwiched between solid walls, one of which is exposed to a shearing force. The slip events are detected using stochastic state space models applied to various measures describing the sy…
▽ More
We consider a sheared granular system experiencing intermittent dynamics of stick-slip type via discrete element simulations. The considered setup consists of a two-dimensional system of soft frictional particles sandwiched between solid walls, one of which is exposed to a shearing force. The slip events are detected using stochastic state space models applied to various measures describing the system. We show that the measures describing the forces between the particles provide earlier detection of an upcoming slip event than the measures based solely on the wall movement. By comparing the detection times obtained from the considered measures, we observe that a typical slip event starts with a local change in the force network. However, some local changes do not spread globally over the force network. For the changes that become global, we find a sharp critical value for their size. If the size of a global change exceeds the critical value, then it triggers a slip event; if it does not, then a much weaker micro-slip follows. Quantification of the changes in the force network is made possible by formulating clear and precise measures describing their static and dynamic properties.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
On intermittency in sheared granular systems
Authors:
Miroslav Kramar,
Chao Cheng,
Rituparna Basak,
Lou Kondic
Abstract:
We consider a system of granular particles, modeled by two dimensional frictional elastic disks, that is exposed to externally applied time-dependent shear stress in a planar Couette geometry. We concentrate on the external forcing that produces intermittent dynamics of stick-slip type. In this regime, the top wall remains almost at rest until the applied stress becomes sufficiently large, and the…
▽ More
We consider a system of granular particles, modeled by two dimensional frictional elastic disks, that is exposed to externally applied time-dependent shear stress in a planar Couette geometry. We concentrate on the external forcing that produces intermittent dynamics of stick-slip type. In this regime, the top wall remains almost at rest until the applied stress becomes sufficiently large, and then it slips. We focus on the evolution of the system as it approaches a slip event. Our main finding is that there are two distinct groups of measures describing system behavior before a slip event. The first group consists of global measures defined as system-wide averages at a fixed time. Typical examples of measures in this group are averages of the normal or tangent forces acting between the particles, system size and number of contacts between the particles. These measures do not seem to be sensitive to an approaching slip event. On average, they tend to increase linearly with the force pulling the spring. The second group consists of the time-dependent measures that quantify the evolution of the system on a micro (particle) or mesoscale. Measures in this group first quantify the temporal differences between two states and only then aggregate them to a single number. For example, Wasserstein distance quantitatively measures the changes of the force network as it evolves in time while the number of broken contacts quantifies the evolution of the contact network. The behavior of the measures in the second group changes dramatically before a slip event starts. They increase rapidly as a slip event approaches, indicating a significant increase in fluctuations of the system before a slip event is triggered.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2022; v1 submitted 21 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Two approaches to quantification of force networks in particulate systems
Authors:
Rituparna Basak,
C. Manuel Carlevaro,
Ryan Kozlowski,
Chao Cheng,
Luis A. Pugnaloni,
Miroslav Kramar,
Hu Zheng,
Joshua E. S. Socolar,
Lou Kondic
Abstract:
The interactions between particles in particulate systems are organized in `force networks', mesoscale features that bridge between the particle scale and the scale of the system as a whole. While such networks are known to be crucial in determining the system wide response, extracting their properties, particularly from experimental systems, is difficult due to the need to measure the interpartic…
▽ More
The interactions between particles in particulate systems are organized in `force networks', mesoscale features that bridge between the particle scale and the scale of the system as a whole. While such networks are known to be crucial in determining the system wide response, extracting their properties, particularly from experimental systems, is difficult due to the need to measure the interparticle forces. In this work, we show by analysis of the data extracted from simulations that such detailed information about interparticle forces may not be necessary, as long as the focus is on extracting the most dominant features of these networks. The main finding is that a reasonable understanding of the time evolution of force networks can be obtained from incomplete information such as total force on the particles. To compare the evolution of the networks based on the completely known particle interactions and the networks based on incomplete information (total force each grain) we use tools of algebraic topology. In particular we will compare simple measures defined on persistence diagrams that provide useful summaries of the force network features.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Quantitative Measure of Memory Loss in Complex Spatio-Temporal Systems
Authors:
Miroslav Kramar,
Lenka Kovalcinova,
Konstantin Mischaikow,
Lou Kondic
Abstract:
To make progress in understanding the issue of memory loss and history dependence in evolving complex systems, we consider the mixing rate that specifies how fast the future states become independent of the initial condition. We propose a simple measure for assessing the mixing rate that can be directly applied to experimental data observed in any metric space $X$. For a compact phase space…
▽ More
To make progress in understanding the issue of memory loss and history dependence in evolving complex systems, we consider the mixing rate that specifies how fast the future states become independent of the initial condition. We propose a simple measure for assessing the mixing rate that can be directly applied to experimental data observed in any metric space $X$. For a compact phase space $X \subset R^M$, we prove the following statement. If the underlying dynamical system has a unique physical measure and its dynamics is strongly mixing with respect to this measure, then our method provides an upper bound of the mixing rate. We employ our method to analyze memory loss for the system of slowly sheared granular particles with a small inertial number $I$. The shear is induced by the moving walls as well as by the linear motion of the support surface that ensures approximately linear shear throughout the sample. We show that even if $I$ is kept fixed, the rate of memory loss (considered at the time scale given by the inverse shear rate) depends erratically on the shear rate. Our study suggests a presence of bifurcations at which the rate of memory loss increases with the shear rate while it decreases away from these points. We also find that the memory loss is not a smooth process. Its rate is closely related to frequency of the sudden transitions of the force network. The loss of memory, quantified by observing evolution of force networks, is found to be correlated with the loss of correlation of shear stress measured on the system scale. Thus, we have established a direct link between the evolution of force networks and macroscopic properties of the considered system.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Dynamics of silo deformation under granular discharge
Authors:
Claudia Colonnello,
Miroslav Kramar
Abstract:
We use Topological Data Analysis to study the post buckling behavior of laboratory scale cylindrical silos under gravity driven granular discharges. Thin walled silos buckle during the discharge if the initial height of the granular column is large enough. The deformation of the silo is reversible as long as the filling height does not exceed a critical value, $L_c$. Beyond this threshold the defo…
▽ More
We use Topological Data Analysis to study the post buckling behavior of laboratory scale cylindrical silos under gravity driven granular discharges. Thin walled silos buckle during the discharge if the initial height of the granular column is large enough. The deformation of the silo is reversible as long as the filling height does not exceed a critical value, $L_c$. Beyond this threshold the deformation becomes permanent and the silo often collapses. We study the dynamics of reversible and irreversible deformation processes, varying the initial filling height around $L_c$. We find that all reversible processes exhibit striking similarities and they alternate between regimes of slow and fast dynamics. The patterns that occur at the beginning of irreversible deformation processes are topologically very similar to those that arise during reversible processes. However, the dynamics of reversible and irreversible processes is significantly different. In particular, the evolution of irreversible processes is much faster. This allows us to make an early prediction of the collapse of the silo based solely on observations of the deformation patterns.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Characterizing Granular Networks Using Topological Metrics
Authors:
Joshua A. Dijksman,
Lenka Kovalcinova,
Jie Ren,
Robert P. Behringer,
Miroslav Kramar,
Konstantin Mischaikow,
Lou Kondic
Abstract:
We carry out a direct comparison of experimental and numerical realizations of the exact same granular system as it undergoes shear jamming. We adjust the numerical methods used to optimally represent the experimental settings and outcomes up to microscopic contact force dynamics. Measures presented here range form microscopic, through mesoscopic to system-wide characteristics of the system. Topol…
▽ More
We carry out a direct comparison of experimental and numerical realizations of the exact same granular system as it undergoes shear jamming. We adjust the numerical methods used to optimally represent the experimental settings and outcomes up to microscopic contact force dynamics. Measures presented here range form microscopic, through mesoscopic to system-wide characteristics of the system. Topological properties of the mesoscopic force networks provide a key link between micro and macro scales. We report two main findings: the number of particles in the packing that have at least two contacts is a good predictor for the mechanical state of the system, regardless of strain history and packing density. All measures explored in both experiments and numerics, including stress tensor derived measures and contact numbers depend in a universal manner on the fraction of non-rattler particles, $f_{NR}$. The force network topology also tends to show this universality, yet the shape of the master curve depends much more on the details of the numerical simulations. In particular we show that adding force noise to the numerical data set can significantly alter the topological features in the data. We conclude that both $f_{NR}$ and topological metrics are useful measures to consider when quantifying the state of a granular system.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Evolution of force networks in dense granular matter close to jamming
Authors:
Lou Kondic,
Miroslav Kramar,
Lenka Kovalcinova,
Konstantin Mischaikow
Abstract:
When dense granular systems are exposed to external forcing, they evolve on the time scale that is typically related to the externally imposed one (shear or compression rate, for example). This evolution could be characterized by observing temporal evolution of contact networks. However, it is not immediately clear whether the force networks, defined on contact networks by considering force intera…
▽ More
When dense granular systems are exposed to external forcing, they evolve on the time scale that is typically related to the externally imposed one (shear or compression rate, for example). This evolution could be characterized by observing temporal evolution of contact networks. However, it is not immediately clear whether the force networks, defined on contact networks by considering force interactions between the particles, evolve on a similar time scale. To analyze the evolution of these networks, we carry out discrete element simulations of a system of soft frictional disks exposed to compression that leads to jamming. By using the tools of computational topology, we show that close to jamming transition, the force networks evolve on the time scale which is much faster than the externally imposed one. The presentation will discuss the factors that determine this fast time scale.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Structure of force networks in tapped particulate systems of disks and pentagons (Part 1): Clusters and Loops
Authors:
L. A. Pugnaloni,
C. M. Carlevaro,
M. Kramar,
K. Mischaikow,
L. Kondic
Abstract:
The force network of a granular assembly, defined by the contact network and the corresponding contact forces, carries valuable information about the state of the packing. Simple analysis of these networks based on the distribution of force strengths is rather insensitive to the changes in preparation protocols or to the types of particles. In this paper we consider two dimensional simulations of…
▽ More
The force network of a granular assembly, defined by the contact network and the corresponding contact forces, carries valuable information about the state of the packing. Simple analysis of these networks based on the distribution of force strengths is rather insensitive to the changes in preparation protocols or to the types of particles. In this paper we consider two dimensional simulations of tapped systems built from frictional disks and pentagons, and study the structure of the force networks of granular packings by considering network's topology as force thresholds are varied. We show that the number of clusters and loops observed in the force networks as a function of the force threshold are markedly different for disks and pentagons if the tangential contact forces are considered, whereas they are surprisingly similar for the network defined by the normal forces. In particular, the results indicate that, overall, the force network is more heterogeneous for disks than for pentagons. Additionally, we show that the states obtained by tapping with different intensities that display similar packing fraction are difficult to distinguish based on simple topological invariants.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Evolution of Force Networks in Dense Particulate Media
Authors:
Miroslav Kramar,
Arnaud Goullet,
Lou Kondic,
Konstantin Mischaikow
Abstract:
We introduce novel sets of measures with the goal of describing dynamical properties of force networks in dense particulate systems. The presented approach is based on persistent homology and allows for extracting precise, quantitative measures that describe the evolution of geometric features of the interparticle forces, without necessarily considering the details related to individual contacts b…
▽ More
We introduce novel sets of measures with the goal of describing dynamical properties of force networks in dense particulate systems. The presented approach is based on persistent homology and allows for extracting precise, quantitative measures that describe the evolution of geometric features of the interparticle forces, without necessarily considering the details related to individual contacts between particles. The networks considered emerge from discrete element simulations of two dimensional particulate systems consisting of compressible frictional circular disks. We quantify the evolution of the networks for slowly compressed systems undergoing jamming transition. The main findings include uncovering significant but localized changes of force networks for unjammed systems, global (system-wide) changes as the systems evolve through jamming, to be followed by significantly less dramatic evolution for the jammed states. We consider both connected components, related in loose sense to force chains, and loops, and find that both measures provide a significant insight into the evolution of force networks. In addition to normal, we consider also tangential forces between the particles and find that they evolve in the consistent manner. Consideration of both frictional and frictionless systems leads us to the conclusion that friction plays a significant role in determining the dynamical properties of the considered networks. We find that the proposed approach describes the considered networks in a precise yet tractable manner, allowing to identify novel features which could be difficult or impossible to describe using other approaches.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Quantifying force networks in particulate systems
Authors:
M. Kramar,
A. Goullet,
L. Kondic,
K. Mischaikow
Abstract:
We present mathematical models based on persistent homology for analyzing force distributions in particulate systems. We define three distinct chain complexes: digital, position, and interaction, motivated by different capabilities of collecting experimental or numerical data, e.g. digital images, location of the particles, and normal forces between particles, respectively. We describe how algebra…
▽ More
We present mathematical models based on persistent homology for analyzing force distributions in particulate systems. We define three distinct chain complexes: digital, position, and interaction, motivated by different capabilities of collecting experimental or numerical data, e.g. digital images, location of the particles, and normal forces between particles, respectively. We describe how algebraic topology, in particular, homology allows one to obtain algebraic representations of the geometry captured by these complexes. To each complexes we define an associated force network from which persistent homology is computed. Using numerical data obtained from molecular dynamics simulations of a system of particles being slowly compressed we demonstrate how persistent homology can be used to compare the geometries of the force distributions in different granular systems. We also discuss the properties of force networks as a function of the underlying complexes, and hence, as a function of the type of experimental or numerical data provided.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2014; v1 submitted 2 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
