-
Stiffness of Probability Distributions of Work and Jarzynski Relation for Initial Microcanonical and Energy Eigenstates
Authors:
Lars Knipschild,
Andreas Engel,
Jochen Gemmer
Abstract:
We consider closed quantum systems (into which baths may be integrated) that are driven, i.e., subject to time-dependent Hamiltonians. As a starting point we assume that, for systems initialized in microcanonical states at some energies, the resulting probability densities of work (work-PDFs) are largely independent of these specific initial energies. We show analytically that this assumption of "…
▽ More
We consider closed quantum systems (into which baths may be integrated) that are driven, i.e., subject to time-dependent Hamiltonians. As a starting point we assume that, for systems initialized in microcanonical states at some energies, the resulting probability densities of work (work-PDFs) are largely independent of these specific initial energies. We show analytically that this assumption of "stiffness", together with the assumption of an exponentially growing density of energy eigenstates, is sufficient but not necessary for the validity of the Jarzynski relation (JR) for the above microcanonical initial states. This holds, even in the absence of microreversibility. To scrutinize the connection between stiffness and the JR for microcanonical initial states, we perform numerical analysis on systems comprising random matrices which may be tuned from stiff to nonstiff. In these examples we find the JR fulfilled in the presence of stiffness, and violated in its absence, which indicates a very close connection between stiffness and the JR. Remarkably, in the limit of large systems, we find the JR fulfilled, even for pure initial energy eigenstates. As this has no analogue in classical systems, we consider it a genuine quantum phenomenon.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Modern Concepts of Quantum Equilibration Do Not Rule Out Strange Relaxation Dynamics
Authors:
Lars Knipschild,
Jochen Gemmer
Abstract:
Numerous pivotal concepts have been introduced to clarify the puzzle of relaxation and/or equilibration in closed quantum systems. All of these concepts rely in some way on specific conditions on Hamiltonians $H$, observables $A$, and initial states $ρ$ or combinations thereof. We numerically demonstrate and analytically argue that there is a multitude of pairs $H,A$ that meet said conditions for…
▽ More
Numerous pivotal concepts have been introduced to clarify the puzzle of relaxation and/or equilibration in closed quantum systems. All of these concepts rely in some way on specific conditions on Hamiltonians $H$, observables $A$, and initial states $ρ$ or combinations thereof. We numerically demonstrate and analytically argue that there is a multitude of pairs $H,A$ that meet said conditions for equilibration and generate some "typical" expectation value dynamics which means, $\langle A(t)\rangle \propto f(t)$ approximately holds for the vast majority of all initial states. Remarkably we find that, while restrictions on the $f(t)$ exist, they do not at all exclude $f(t)$ that are rather adverse or "strange" regarding thermal relaxation.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Compelling Bounds on Equilibration Times -- the Issue with Fermi's Golden Rule
Authors:
Robin Heveling,
Lars Knipschild,
Jochen Gemmer
Abstract:
Putting a general, physically relevant upper bound on equilibration times in closed quantum systems is a recently much pursued endeavor. In PRX, 7, 031027 (2017) García-Pintos et al. suggest such a bound. We point out that the general assumptions which allow for an actual estimation of this bound are violated in cases in which Fermi's Golden Rule and related open quantum system theories apply. To…
▽ More
Putting a general, physically relevant upper bound on equilibration times in closed quantum systems is a recently much pursued endeavor. In PRX, 7, 031027 (2017) García-Pintos et al. suggest such a bound. We point out that the general assumptions which allow for an actual estimation of this bound are violated in cases in which Fermi's Golden Rule and related open quantum system theories apply. To probe the range of applicability of Fermi's Golden Rule for systems of the type addressed in the above work, we numerically solve the corresponding Schrödinger equation for some finite spin systems comprising up to 25 spins. These calculations shed light on the breakdown of standard quantum master equations in the "superweak" coupling limit, which occurs for finite sized baths.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Exponential damping induced by random and realistic perturbations
Authors:
Jonas Richter,
Fengping Jin,
Lars Knipschild,
Hans De Raedt,
Kristel Michielsen,
Jochen Gemmer,
Robin Steinigeweg
Abstract:
Given a quantum many-body system and the expectation-value dynamics of some operator, we study how this reference dynamics is altered due to a perturbation of the system's Hamiltonian. Based on projection operator techniques, we unveil that if the perturbation exhibits a random-matrix structure in the eigenbasis of the unperturbed Hamiltonian, then this perturbation effectively leads to an exponen…
▽ More
Given a quantum many-body system and the expectation-value dynamics of some operator, we study how this reference dynamics is altered due to a perturbation of the system's Hamiltonian. Based on projection operator techniques, we unveil that if the perturbation exhibits a random-matrix structure in the eigenbasis of the unperturbed Hamiltonian, then this perturbation effectively leads to an exponential damping of the original dynamics. Employing a combination of dynamical quantum typicality and numerical linked cluster expansions, we demonstrate that our theoretical findings for random matrices can, in some cases, be relevant for the dynamics of realistic quantum many-body models as well. Specifically, we study the decay of current autocorrelation functions in spin-$1/2$ ladder systems, where the rungs of the ladder are treated as a perturbation to the otherwise uncoupled legs. We find a convincing agreement between the exact dynamics and the lowest-order prediction over a wide range of interchain couplings.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2020; v1 submitted 21 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Magnetization and energy dynamics in spin ladders: Evidence of diffusion in time, frequency, position, and momentum
Authors:
Jonas Richter,
Fengping Jin,
Lars Knipschild,
Jacek Herbrych,
Hans De Raedt,
Kristel Michielsen,
Jochen Gemmer,
Robin Steinigeweg
Abstract:
The dynamics of magnetization and energy densities are studied in the two-leg spin-1/2 ladder. Using an efficient pure-state approach based on the concept of typicality, we calculate spatio-temporal correlation functions for large systems with up to 40 lattice sites. In addition, two subsequent Fourier transforms from real to momentum space as well as from time to frequency domain yield the respec…
▽ More
The dynamics of magnetization and energy densities are studied in the two-leg spin-1/2 ladder. Using an efficient pure-state approach based on the concept of typicality, we calculate spatio-temporal correlation functions for large systems with up to 40 lattice sites. In addition, two subsequent Fourier transforms from real to momentum space as well as from time to frequency domain yield the respective dynamic structure factors. Summarizing our main results, we unveil the existence of genuine diffusion both for spin and energy. In particular, this finding is based on four distinct signatures which can all be equally well detected: (i) Gaussian density profiles, (ii) time-independent diffusion coefficients, (iii) exponentially decaying density modes, and (iv) Lorentzian line shapes of the dynamic structure factor. The combination of (i) - (iv) provides a comprehensive picture of high-temperature dynamics in thisarchetypal nonintegrable quantum model.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2019; v1 submitted 7 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Stability of Quantum Dynamics under Constant Hamiltonian Perturbations
Authors:
Lars Knipschild,
Jochen Gemmer
Abstract:
Concepts like `typicality' and the `eigenstate thermalization hypothesis' aim at explaining the apparent equilibration of quantum systems, possibly after a very long time. However, these concepts are not concerned with the specific way in which this equilibrium is approached. Our point of departure is the (evident) observation that some forms of the approach to equilibrium, such as, e.g., exponent…
▽ More
Concepts like `typicality' and the `eigenstate thermalization hypothesis' aim at explaining the apparent equilibration of quantum systems, possibly after a very long time. However, these concepts are not concerned with the specific way in which this equilibrium is approached. Our point of departure is the (evident) observation that some forms of the approach to equilibrium, such as, e.g., exponential decay of observables, are much more common then others. We suggest to trace this dominance of certain decay dynamics back to a larger stability with respect to generic Hamiltonian perturbations. A numerical study of a number of examples in which both, the unperturbed Hamiltonians as well as the perturbations are modeled by partially random matrices is presented. We furthermore develop a simple heuristic, mathematical scheme that describes the result of the numerical investigations remarkably well. According to those investigations the exponential decay indeed appears to be most stable. Dynamics that are in a certain sense at odds with the arrow of time are found to be very unstable.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Comment on: "Fluctuation Theorem for Many-Body Pure Quantum States" and Reply to "arXiv:1712.05172"
Authors:
Jochen Gemmer,
Lars Knipschild,
Robin Steinigeweg
Abstract:
We comment on: E. Iyoda, K. Kaneko, and T. Sagawa, "Fluctuation Theorem for Many-Body Pure Quantum States", Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 100601 (2017). We also respond to the reply by the afore mentioned authors: "arXiv:1712.05172". The response at hand concludes our discussion of the subject on the arXiv.
We comment on: E. Iyoda, K. Kaneko, and T. Sagawa, "Fluctuation Theorem for Many-Body Pure Quantum States", Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 100601 (2017). We also respond to the reply by the afore mentioned authors: "arXiv:1712.05172". The response at hand concludes our discussion of the subject on the arXiv.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2018; v1 submitted 6 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Stiffness of Probability Distributions of Work and Jarzynski Relation for Non-Gibbsian Initial States
Authors:
Daniel Schmidtke,
Lars Knipschild,
Michele Campisi,
Robin Steinigeweg,
Jochen Gemmer
Abstract:
We consider closed quantum systems (into which baths may be integrated) that are driven, i.e., subject to time-dependent Hamiltonians. Our point of departure is the assumption that, if systems start in microcanonical states at some initial energies, the resulting probability distributions of work may be largely independent of the specific initial energies. It is demonstrated that this assumption h…
▽ More
We consider closed quantum systems (into which baths may be integrated) that are driven, i.e., subject to time-dependent Hamiltonians. Our point of departure is the assumption that, if systems start in microcanonical states at some initial energies, the resulting probability distributions of work may be largely independent of the specific initial energies. It is demonstrated that this assumption has some far-reaching consequences, e.g., it implies the validity of the Jarzynski relation for a large class of non-Gibbsian initial states. By performing numerical analysis on integrable and non-integrable spin systems, we find the above assumption fulfilled for all considered examples. Through an analysis based on Fermi's Golden Rule, we partially relate these findings to the applicability of the eigenstate thermalization ansatz to the respective driving operators.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
