-
Comment on "Electric conductivity of graphene: Kubo model versus a nonlocal quantum field theory model (arXiv:2403.02279v3)"
Authors:
M. Bordag,
N. Khusnutdinov,
G. L. Klimchitskaya,
V. M. Mostepanenko
Abstract:
Recently, Rodriguez-Lopez, Wang, and Antezza [arXiv:2403.02279v3; Phys. Rev. B v.111, 115428 (2025)] compared the theoretical descriptions of electric conductivity of graphene given by the Kubo model and quantum field theory in terms of the polarizationtensor. According to these authors, in the spatially nonlocal case, the quantum field theoretical description contains ``hard inconsistencies". To…
▽ More
Recently, Rodriguez-Lopez, Wang, and Antezza [arXiv:2403.02279v3; Phys. Rev. B v.111, 115428 (2025)] compared the theoretical descriptions of electric conductivity of graphene given by the Kubo model and quantum field theory in terms of the polarizationtensor. According to these authors, in the spatially nonlocal case, the quantum field theoretical description contains ``hard inconsistencies". To bring the predictions of quantum field theory in agreement with those following from the Kubo model, the modified expression was used which relates the conductivity and the polarization tensor. Here, it is shown that this modification violates the the requirement of gauge invariance and, thus, is unacceptable. By comparing both theoretical approaches, we demonstrate that all the results obtained within quantum field theory are physically well justified whereas an application of the modified expression for the conductivity of graphene leads to the consequences of nonphysical character.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
The polarization tensor approach for Casimir effect
Authors:
Nail Khusnutdinov,
Natalia Emelianova
Abstract:
This paper gives a brief overview of the polarization tensor approach to the Casimir effect. The fundamental principles of this approach are discussed, along with its various applications to both three-dimensional and two-dimensional systems, with a focus on its implications for graphene.
This paper gives a brief overview of the polarization tensor approach to the Casimir effect. The fundamental principles of this approach are discussed, along with its various applications to both three-dimensional and two-dimensional systems, with a focus on its implications for graphene.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2024; v1 submitted 21 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Impurities in graphene and their influence on the Casimir interaction
Authors:
N. Khusnutdinov,
D. Vassilevich
Abstract:
We study the influence of impurities in graphene described by a scattering rate $Γ$ on the Casimir interaction between graphene and an ideal conductor or between two identical sheets of graphene at zero temperature and chemical potential. To this end, we compute the polarization tensor of quasiparticles in graphene and corresponding conductivities for TE and TM channels. The Casimir energy density…
▽ More
We study the influence of impurities in graphene described by a scattering rate $Γ$ on the Casimir interaction between graphene and an ideal conductor or between two identical sheets of graphene at zero temperature and chemical potential. To this end, we compute the polarization tensor of quasiparticles in graphene and corresponding conductivities for TE and TM channels. The Casimir energy density is evaluated with the help of the Lifshitz formula. We find that depending on the value of mass gap parameter the presence of $Γ$ may lead to a slight damping or to a considerable enhancement of the Casimir interaction.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2024; v1 submitted 10 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The normal Casimir force for lateral moving planes with isotropic conductivities
Authors:
N. Emelianova,
N. Khusnutdinov
Abstract:
We consider the two planes at zero temperature with isotropic conductivity that are in relative lateral motion with velocity $v$ and inter-plane distance $a$. Two models of conductivity are taken into account -- the constant and frequency-dependent Drude models. The normal (perpendicular to planes) Casimir force is analysed in detail for two systems -- i) two planes with identical conductivity and…
▽ More
We consider the two planes at zero temperature with isotropic conductivity that are in relative lateral motion with velocity $v$ and inter-plane distance $a$. Two models of conductivity are taken into account -- the constant and frequency-dependent Drude models. The normal (perpendicular to planes) Casimir force is analysed in detail for two systems -- i) two planes with identical conductivity and ii) one of the planes is a perfect metal. The velocity correction to the Casimir energy $Δ_v\mathcal{E} \sim v^2$ for small velocity for all considered cases. In the case of the constant conductivity $η$, the energy correction is $ Δ_v\mathcal{E} \sim \fracη{a^3} \left(\frac{v}η\right)^2$for $v\ll η\ll 1$.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2024; v1 submitted 13 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
The Casimir effect for stack of graphenes
Authors:
Natalia Emelianova,
Rashid Kashapov,
Nail Khusnutdinov
Abstract:
We consider a stack of parallel sheets composed of conducting planes with tensorial conductivities. Using the scattering matrix approach, we derive explicit formulas for the Casimir energy of two, three, and four planes, as well as a recurrence relation for arbitrary planes. Specifically, for a stack of graphene, we solve the recurrence relations and obtain formulas for the Casimir energy and forc…
▽ More
We consider a stack of parallel sheets composed of conducting planes with tensorial conductivities. Using the scattering matrix approach, we derive explicit formulas for the Casimir energy of two, three, and four planes, as well as a recurrence relation for arbitrary planes. Specifically, for a stack of graphene, we solve the recurrence relations and obtain formulas for the Casimir energy and force acting on the planes within the stack. Moreover, we calculate the binding energy in the graphene stack with graphite interplane separation, which amounts to $E_{ib} = 9.9$ meV/atom. Notably, the Casimir force on graphene sheets decreases rapidly for planes beyond the first one. In particular, for the second graphene layer in the stack, the force is $35$ times smaller than that experienced by the first layer.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Casimir-Lifshitz force for moving graphene
Authors:
Mauro Antezza,
Natalia Emelianova,
Nail Khusnutdinov
Abstract:
We consider the system of two parallel sheets of graphene which are moving with relative parallel velocity $\vec{v}$ and calculate the Casimir energy by using the scattering approach. The energy has real and imaginary parts. The real part contains a velocity contribution to the force perpendicular to the sheets. The imaginary part is related to a friction force parallel to the graphene sheets. We…
▽ More
We consider the system of two parallel sheets of graphene which are moving with relative parallel velocity $\vec{v}$ and calculate the Casimir energy by using the scattering approach. The energy has real and imaginary parts. The real part contains a velocity contribution to the force perpendicular to the sheets. The imaginary part is related to a friction force parallel to the graphene sheets. We prove that the friction appears if the relative velocity becomes greater than the velocity of Fermi and if the modulo of reflection coefficient is greater than the one which is significant for virtual photon production. We analyze in detail the real contribution to the Casimir energy for two systems -- graphene/graphene and ideal metal/graphene. In the non-relativistic case $v \ll v_F$, the relative correction to the Casimir energy $(\mathcal{E}_v - \mathcal{E}_0)/\mathcal{E}_0$ is proportional to the $(v/c)^2$ (the maximum value is $0.0033$ for the gapeless case and $v=v_F$) for the first system, and it is zero up to the Fermi velocity $v = v_F$ for system ideal metal/graphene.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Bulk contributions to the Casimir interaction of Dirac materials
Authors:
M. Bordag,
I. Fialkovsky,
N. Khusnutdinov,
D. Vassilevich
Abstract:
Exploiting methods of Quantum Field Theory we compute the bulk polarization tensor and bulk dielectric functions for Dirac materials in the presence of a mass gap, chemical potential, and finite temperature. Using these results (and neglecting eventual boundary effects), we study the Casimir interaction of Dirac materials. We describe in detail the characteristic features of the dielectric functio…
▽ More
Exploiting methods of Quantum Field Theory we compute the bulk polarization tensor and bulk dielectric functions for Dirac materials in the presence of a mass gap, chemical potential, and finite temperature. Using these results (and neglecting eventual boundary effects), we study the Casimir interaction of Dirac materials. We describe in detail the characteristic features of the dielectric functions and their influence on the Casimir pressure.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
The low-temperature expansion of the Casimir-Polder free energy of an atom with graphene
Authors:
Nail Khusnutdinov,
Natalia Emelianova
Abstract:
We consider the low-temperature expansion of the Casimir-Polder free energy for an atom and graphene by using the Poisson representation of the free energy. We extend our previous analysis on the different relations between chemical potential $μ$ and mass gap parameter $m$. The key role plays the dependence of graphene conductivities on the $μ$ and $m$. For simplicity, we made the manifest calcula…
▽ More
We consider the low-temperature expansion of the Casimir-Polder free energy for an atom and graphene by using the Poisson representation of the free energy. We extend our previous analysis on the different relations between chemical potential $μ$ and mass gap parameter $m$. The key role plays the dependence of graphene conductivities on the $μ$ and $m$. For simplicity, we made the manifest calculations for zero values of the Fermi velocity. For $μ>m$ the thermal correction $\sim T^2$ and for $μ< m$ we confirm the recent result of Klimchitskaya and Mostepanenko, that the thermal correction $\sim T^5$. In the case of exact equality $μ=m$ the correction $\sim T$. This point is unstable and the system falls to the regime with $μ>m$ or $μ<m$. The analytical calculations are illustrated by numerical evaluations for the Hydrogen atom/graphene system.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Casimir-Polder force and torque for anisotropic molecules close to conducting planes and their effects on CO$_2$
Authors:
Mauro Antezza,
Ignat Fialkovsky,
Nail Khusnutdinov
Abstract:
We derive the Casimir-Polder force and Casimir torque expressions for an anisotropic molecule close to a conducting plane with a tensorial conductivity. We apply our general expressions to the case of a carbon dioxide CO$_2$ molecule close to a plane with pure Hall conductivity and to graphene. We show that the equilibrium position of this linear molecule is with its main axis perpendicular to the…
▽ More
We derive the Casimir-Polder force and Casimir torque expressions for an anisotropic molecule close to a conducting plane with a tensorial conductivity. We apply our general expressions to the case of a carbon dioxide CO$_2$ molecule close to a plane with pure Hall conductivity and to graphene. We show that the equilibrium position of this linear molecule is with its main axis perpendicular to the surface. We hence conjecture a possible way to exploit the Casimir torque to mechanically improve the performance of CO$_2$ separation membranes useful for an efficient atmospheric CO$_2$ reduction.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Signatures of Complex Optical Response in Casimir Interactions of Type I and II Weyl Semimetals
Authors:
Pablo Rodriguez-Lopez,
Adrian Popescu,
Ignat Fialkovsky,
Nail Khusnutdinov,
Lilia M. Woods
Abstract:
The Casimir interaction is induced by electromagnetic fluctuations between objects and it is strongly dependent upon the electronic and optical properties of the materials making up the objects. Here we investigate this ubiquitous interaction between Weyl semimetals, a class of 3D systems with low energy linear dispersion and nontrivial topology due to symmetry conditions and stemming from separat…
▽ More
The Casimir interaction is induced by electromagnetic fluctuations between objects and it is strongly dependent upon the electronic and optical properties of the materials making up the objects. Here we investigate this ubiquitous interaction between Weyl semimetals, a class of 3D systems with low energy linear dispersion and nontrivial topology due to symmetry conditions and stemming from separated energy cones. A comprehensive examination of all components of the bulk conductivity tensor as well as the surface conductivity due to the Fermi arc states in real and imaginary frequency domains is presented using the Kubo formalism for Weyl semimetals with different degree of tilting of their linear energy cones. The Casimir energy is calculated using a generalized Lifhsitz approach, for which electromagnetic boundary conditions for anisotropic materials were derived and used. We find that the Casimir interaction between Weyl semimetals is metallic-like and its magnitude and characteristic distance dependence can be modified by the degree of tilting and chemical potential. The nontrivial topology plays a secondary role in the Casimir interaction of these 3D materials and thermal fluctuations are expected to have similar effects as in metallic systems.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2019; v1 submitted 8 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Casimir effect for biaxial anisotropic plates with surface conductivity
Authors:
N. Emelianova,
I. V. Fialkovsky,
N. Khusnutdinov
Abstract:
The Casimir energy is constructed for a system consisting of two semi-infinite slabs of anisotropic material. Each of them is characterized by bulk complex dielectric permittivity tensor and surface conductivity on the free boundary. We found general form of the scattering matrix and Fresnel coefficients for each part of the system by solving Maxwell equations in the anisotropic media.
The Casimir energy is constructed for a system consisting of two semi-infinite slabs of anisotropic material. Each of them is characterized by bulk complex dielectric permittivity tensor and surface conductivity on the free boundary. We found general form of the scattering matrix and Fresnel coefficients for each part of the system by solving Maxwell equations in the anisotropic media.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
The low temperature behavior the Casimir-Polder energy for conductive plane
Authors:
Nail Khusnutdinov,
Natalia Emelianova
Abstract:
The low temperature expansion of the free energy of atom/plane system is considered for general symmetric form of tensor conductivity of the plane. It is shown that the first correction is proportional to second order of the temperature $\sim T^2$ and comes from TM mode. The agreement of the expansion and exact expressions for different models of conductivity is numerically demonstrated.
The low temperature expansion of the free energy of atom/plane system is considered for general symmetric form of tensor conductivity of the plane. It is shown that the first correction is proportional to second order of the temperature $\sim T^2$ and comes from TM mode. The agreement of the expansion and exact expressions for different models of conductivity is numerically demonstrated.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
The quest for Casimir repulsion between Chern-Simons surfaces
Authors:
Ignat Fialkovsky,
Nail Khusnutdinov,
Dmitri Vassilevich
Abstract:
In this paper we critically reconsider the Casimir repulsion between surfaces that carry the Chern-Simons interaction (corresponding to the Hall type conductivity). We present a derivation of the Lifshitz formula valid for arbitrary planar geometries and discuss its properties. This analysis allows us to resolve some contradictions in the previous literature. We compute the Casimir energy for two…
▽ More
In this paper we critically reconsider the Casimir repulsion between surfaces that carry the Chern-Simons interaction (corresponding to the Hall type conductivity). We present a derivation of the Lifshitz formula valid for arbitrary planar geometries and discuss its properties. This analysis allows us to resolve some contradictions in the previous literature. We compute the Casimir energy for two surfaces that have constant longitudinal and Hall conductivities. The repulsion is possible only if both surfaces have Hall conductivities of the same sign. However, there is a critical value of the longitudinal conductivity above which the repulsion disappears. We also consider a model where both parity odd and parity even terms in the conductivity are produced by the polarization tensor of surface modes. In contrast to the previous publications L. Chen and S.-L. Wan, Phys. Rev. B84, 075149 (2011); B85, 115102 (2012), we include the parity anomaly term. This term ensures that the conductivities vanish for infinitely massive surface modes. We find that at least for a single mode regardless of the sign and value of its mass, there is no Casimir repulsion.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2018; v1 submitted 19 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Thermal Casimir and Casimir-Polder interactions in $N$ parallel 2D Dirac materials
Authors:
Nail Khusnutdinov,
Rashid Kashapov,
Lilia M. Woods
Abstract:
The Casimir and Casimir-Polder interactions are investigated in a stack of equally spaced graphene layers. The optical response of the individual graphene is taken into account using gauge invariant components of the polarization tensor extended to the whole complex frequency plane. The planar symmetry for the electromagnetic boundary conditions is further used to obtain explicit forms for the Cas…
▽ More
The Casimir and Casimir-Polder interactions are investigated in a stack of equally spaced graphene layers. The optical response of the individual graphene is taken into account using gauge invariant components of the polarization tensor extended to the whole complex frequency plane. The planar symmetry for the electromagnetic boundary conditions is further used to obtain explicit forms for the Casimir energy stored in the stack and the Casimir-Polder energy between an atom above the stack. Our calculations show that these fluctuation induced interactions experience strong thermal effects due to the graphene Dirac-like energy spectrum. The spatial dispersion and temperature dependence in the optical response are also found to be important for enhancing the interactions especially at smaller separations. Analytical expressions for low and high temperature limits and their comparison with corresponding expressions for an infinitely conducting planar stack are further used to expand our understanding of Casimir and Casimir-Polder energies in Dirac materials. Our results may be useful to experimentalists as new ways to probe thermal effects at the nanoscale in such universal interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
The Casimir-Polder effect for a stack of conductive planes
Authors:
Nail Khusnutdinov,
Rashid Kashapov,
Lilia M. Woods
Abstract:
The Casimir-Polder interaction between an atom and a multilayered system composed of infinitely thin planes is considered using the zeta-function regularization approach with summation of the zero-point energies. As a prototype material, each plane is represented by a graphene sheet whose optical response is described by a constant conductivity or Drude-Lorentz model conductivity. Asymptotic expre…
▽ More
The Casimir-Polder interaction between an atom and a multilayered system composed of infinitely thin planes is considered using the zeta-function regularization approach with summation of the zero-point energies. As a prototype material, each plane is represented by a graphene sheet whose optical response is described by a constant conductivity or Drude-Lorentz model conductivity. Asymptotic expressions for various separations are derived and compared to numerical calculations. We distinguish between large atom/plane limit, where retardation effects are prominent, and small atom/plane limit, where the typical van der Waals coefficient is found to be dependent on the number of graphenes and characteristic distances. The calculated energies for different atoms and graphene conductivity models brings forward the basic science of the Casimir-Polder effect and suggests ways to manipulate this interaction experimentally.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
The Casimir effect for a stack of conductive planes
Authors:
Nail Khusnutdinov,
Rashid Kashapov,
Lilia M. Woods
Abstract:
The Casimir interaction in a stack of equally spaced infinitely thin layers is investigated within the zero-frequency mode summation method. The response properties are considered to be described by a constant conductivity or by a Drude-Lorentz model with a finite set of oscillators consistent with the optical characteristics for graphite. It is found that the asymptotic distance dependence is aff…
▽ More
The Casimir interaction in a stack of equally spaced infinitely thin layers is investigated within the zero-frequency mode summation method. The response properties are considered to be described by a constant conductivity or by a Drude-Lorentz model with a finite set of oscillators consistent with the optical characteristics for graphite. It is found that the asymptotic distance dependence is affected significantly by the specific response. While the energy is $\sim 1/d^3$ for the constant conductivity model, the energy exhibits fractional dependence $\sim 1/d^{5/2}$ for the Drude-Lorentz description. The Casimir force on a plane is also strongly dependent upon the particular plane location in the stack. Furthermore, the calculated Casimir energy within the Drude-Lorentz model yields results in good agreement with measured cohesion energy in graphite.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Van der Waals interaction between an atom with spherical plasma shell
Authors:
Nail R. Khusnutdinov
Abstract:
We consider the van der Waals energy of an atom near the infinitely thin sphere with finite conductivity which model the fullerene. We put the sphere into spherical cavity inside the infinite dielectric media, then calculate the energy of vacuum fluctuations in framework of the zeta-function approach. The energy for a single atom is obtained from this expression by consideration of the rare media.…
▽ More
We consider the van der Waals energy of an atom near the infinitely thin sphere with finite conductivity which model the fullerene. We put the sphere into spherical cavity inside the infinite dielectric media, then calculate the energy of vacuum fluctuations in framework of the zeta-function approach. The energy for a single atom is obtained from this expression by consideration of the rare media. In the limit of the infinite radius of the sphere the Casimir-Polder expression for an atom and plate is recovered. For finite radius of sphere the energy of an atom monotonously falls down as $d^{-3}$ close to the sphere and $d^{-7}$ far from the sphere. For hydrogen atom on the surface of the fullerene $C_{60}$ we obtain that the energy is $3.8 eV$. We obtain also that the polarizability of fullerene is merely cube of its radius.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2011; v1 submitted 25 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Dynamic Tsallis entropy for simple model systems
Authors:
Nail R. Khusnutdinov,
Renat M. Yulmetyev,
Natalya A. Emelyanova
Abstract:
In this paper we consider the dynamic Tsallis entropy and employ it for four model systems: (i) the motion of Brownian oscillator, (ii) the motion of Brownian oscillator with noise, (iii) the fluctuation of particle density in hydrodynamics limit as well as in (iv) ideal gas. We show that the small value of parameter nonextensivity $0<q<1$ works as non-linear magnifier for small values of the en…
▽ More
In this paper we consider the dynamic Tsallis entropy and employ it for four model systems: (i) the motion of Brownian oscillator, (ii) the motion of Brownian oscillator with noise, (iii) the fluctuation of particle density in hydrodynamics limit as well as in (iv) ideal gas. We show that the small value of parameter nonextensivity $0<q<1$ works as non-linear magnifier for small values of the entropy. The frequency spectra become more sharp and it is possible to extract useful information in the case of noise. We show that the ideal gas remains non-Markovian for arbitrary values of $q$.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
