-
Non-reciprocal anti-aligning active mixtures: deriving the exact Boltzmann collision operator
Authors:
Jakob Mihatsch,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
We consider the effect of non-reciprocity in a binary mixture of self-propelled particles with anti-aligning interactions, where a particle of type A reacts differently to a particle of type B than vice versa. Starting from a well-known microscopic Langevin-model for the particles, setting up the corresponding exact N-particle Fokker-Planck equation and making Boltzmann's assumptions of low densit…
▽ More
We consider the effect of non-reciprocity in a binary mixture of self-propelled particles with anti-aligning interactions, where a particle of type A reacts differently to a particle of type B than vice versa. Starting from a well-known microscopic Langevin-model for the particles, setting up the corresponding exact N-particle Fokker-Planck equation and making Boltzmann's assumptions of low density and one-sided molecular chaos, the non-linear active Boltzmann equation with the exact collision operator is derived. In this derivation, the effect of phase-space compression and the build-up of pair-correlations during binary interactions is explicitly taken into account, leading to a theoretical description beyond mean-field. This extends previous results for reciprocal interactions, where it was found that orientational order can emerge in a system with purely anti-aligning interactions. Although the equations of motion are more complex than in the reciprocal system, the theory still leads to analytical expressions and predictions. Comparisons with agent-based simulations show excellent quantitative agreement of the dynamic and static behavior in the low density and/or small coupling limit.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Hyperuniformity in deterministic anti-aligning active matter
Authors:
Horst-Holger Boltz,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
We highlight the importance of long-range correlations in active matter systems of dilute self-propelling particles even in the absence of global order by demonstrating that long-range density fluctuations are suppressed. We show this analytically for a one-dimensional lattice process employing Poisson representation. Numerically, we corroborate the relevance of these findings for off-lattice Vics…
▽ More
We highlight the importance of long-range correlations in active matter systems of dilute self-propelling particles even in the absence of global order by demonstrating that long-range density fluctuations are suppressed. We show this analytically for a one-dimensional lattice process employing Poisson representation. Numerically, we corroborate the relevance of these findings for off-lattice Vicsek-type models with anti-aligning interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Comment on "Steady-state distributions and nonsteady dynamics in nonequilibrium systems"
Authors:
Horst-Holger Boltz,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
We comment on a work by T. Liverpool (Phys. Rev. E 101 (2020)). We show that a theorem stated in that work is not correct. While this is inconsequential to the bulk of the work (and holds asymptotically as we show), it is instructive to highlight the importance of phase space compression in active systems with generalized dynamics.
We comment on a work by T. Liverpool (Phys. Rev. E 101 (2020)). We show that a theorem stated in that work is not correct. While this is inconsequential to the bulk of the work (and holds asymptotically as we show), it is instructive to highlight the importance of phase space compression in active systems with generalized dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Flocking in Binary Mixtures of Anti-aligning Self-propelled Particles
Authors:
Rüdiger Kürsten,
Jakob Mihatsch,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
We consider two species of self-propelled point particles: A-particles and B-particles. The orientations between nearby particles are subject to pair interactions of different strength for A-A-, A-B-(=B-A-) and B-B-interactions, respectively. Even if all interactions involved are repelling, that is, if they locally favor anti-alignment between each pair of particles, we find global polar order of…
▽ More
We consider two species of self-propelled point particles: A-particles and B-particles. The orientations between nearby particles are subject to pair interactions of different strength for A-A-, A-B-(=B-A-) and B-B-interactions, respectively. Even if all interactions involved are repelling, that is, if they locally favor anti-alignment between each pair of particles, we find global polar order of both A-particles and B-particles We find qualitative agreement between agent-based simulations and mean field theory. Beyond mean field, we develop a Boltzmann-scattering theory based on one-sided molecular chaos that yields excellent quantitative agreement with simulations for dilute systems. For large systems, we find, depending on parameters, either micro-phase-separation or static patterns with either patches or stripes that carry different polarization orientations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Asymptotically exact scattering theory of active particles with anti-alignment interactions
Authors:
Thomas Ihle,
Rüdiger Kürsten,
Benjamin Lindner
Abstract:
We consider a model of Non-Brownian self-propelled particles with anti-alignment interactions where particles try to avoid each other by attempting to turn into opposite directions. The particles undergo apparent Brownian motion, even though the particle's equations are fully deterministic. We show that the deterministic interactions lead to internal, dynamical noise. Starting from the N-particle…
▽ More
We consider a model of Non-Brownian self-propelled particles with anti-alignment interactions where particles try to avoid each other by attempting to turn into opposite directions. The particles undergo apparent Brownian motion, even though the particle's equations are fully deterministic. We show that the deterministic interactions lead to internal, dynamical noise. Starting from the N-particle Liouville equation, a kinetic equation for the one-particle distribution function is obtained. We show that the usual mean-field assumption of molecular chaos leads to qualitatively wrong predictions such as an infinite coefficient of self-diffusion. Going beyond mean-field and applying the refined assumption of ``one-sided molecular chaos'', we analytically calculate the scattering of particles in the limit of low density and obtain explicit expressions for the dynamical noise of an effective one-particle Langevin-equation and the corresponding self-diffusion. In this calculation, the so-called superposition principle of traditional kinetic theory was modified to handle a system with non-Hamiltonian dynamics involving phase-space compression. The predicted theoretical expressions for the relaxation of hydrodynamic modes and the self-diffusion coefficient are in excellent, quantitative agreement with agent-based simulations at small density and small anti-alignment strength. At large particle densities, a given particle is constantly approached and abandoned by different collision partners. Modelling this switching of partners by a random telegraph process and exactly solving a self-consistent integral equation, we obtain explicit expressions for the noise correlations of the effective one-particle Langevin-equation. Comparison with agent-based simulation show very good agreement.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Scattering theory of Non-Brownian active particles with social distancing
Authors:
Thomas Ihle,
Rüdiger Kürsten,
Benjamin Lindner
Abstract:
We consider deterministic self-propelled particles with anti-alignment interactions. An asymptotically exact kinetic theory for particle scattering at low densities is constructed by a non-local closure of the BBGKY-hierarchy, involving pair correlations. We show that the mean-field assumption of molecular chaos yields unphysical predictions, whereas the scattering theory shows excellent agreement…
▽ More
We consider deterministic self-propelled particles with anti-alignment interactions. An asymptotically exact kinetic theory for particle scattering at low densities is constructed by a non-local closure of the BBGKY-hierarchy, involving pair correlations. We show that the mean-field assumption of molecular chaos yields unphysical predictions, whereas the scattering theory shows excellent agreement with agent-based simulations. To extend the theory to high densities, a self-consistent mapping to a random-telegraph process is performed. The approach is used to derive a one-particle Langevin-equation and leads to analytical expressions for the correlations of its effective noise.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Phases and homogeneous ordered states in alignment-based self-propelled particle models
Authors:
Yinong Zhao,
Thomas Ihle,
Zhangang Han,
Cristián Huepe,
Pawel Romanczuk
Abstract:
We study a set of models of self-propelled particles that achieve collective motion through similar alignment-based dynamics, considering versions with and without repulsive interactions that do not affect the heading directions. We explore their phase space within a broad range of values of two nondimensional parameters (coupling strength and Peclet number), characterizing their polarization and…
▽ More
We study a set of models of self-propelled particles that achieve collective motion through similar alignment-based dynamics, considering versions with and without repulsive interactions that do not affect the heading directions. We explore their phase space within a broad range of values of two nondimensional parameters (coupling strength and Peclet number), characterizing their polarization and degree of clustering. The resulting phase diagrams display equivalent, similarly distributed regions for all models with repulsion. The diagrams without repulsion exhibit differences, in particular for high coupling strengths. We compare the boundaries and representative states of all regions, identifying various regimes that had not been previously characterized. We analyze in detail three types of homogeneous polarized states, comparing them to existing theoretical and numerical results by computing their velocity and density correlations, giant number fluctuations, and local order-density coupling. We find that they all deviate in one way or another from the theoretical predictions, attributing these differences either to the remaining inhomogeneities or to finite-size effects. We discuss our results in terms of the universal or specific features of each model, their thermodynamic limit, and the high mixing and low mixing regimes. Our study provides a broad, overarching perspective on the multiple phases and states found in alignment-based self-propelled particle models.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2021; v1 submitted 12 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
A Quantitative Kinetic Theory of Flocking with Three-Particle-Closure
Authors:
Rüdiger Kürsten,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
We consider aligning self-propelled particles in two dimensions. Their motion is given by generalized Langevin equations and includes non-additive N-particle interactions. The qualitative behavior is as for the famous Vicsek model. We develop a kinetic theory of flocking beyond mean field. In particular, we self-consistently take into account the full pair correlation function. We find excellent q…
▽ More
We consider aligning self-propelled particles in two dimensions. Their motion is given by generalized Langevin equations and includes non-additive N-particle interactions. The qualitative behavior is as for the famous Vicsek model. We develop a kinetic theory of flocking beyond mean field. In particular, we self-consistently take into account the full pair correlation function. We find excellent quantitative agreement of the pair correlations with direct agent-based simulations within the disordered regime. Furthermore we use a closure relation to incorporate spatial correlations of three particles. In that way we achieve good quantitative agreement of the onset of flocking with direct simulations. Compared to mean field theory, the flocking transition is shifted significantly towards lower noise because directional correlations favor disorder. We compare our theory with a recently developed Landau-kinetic theory.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Dry Active Matter exhibits a self-organized 'Cross Sea' Phase
Authors:
Rüdiger Kürsten,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
The Vicsek model of self-propelled particles is known in three different phases: (i) a polar ordered homogeneous phase also called Toner-Tu phase, (iii) a phase of polar ordered regularly arranged high density bands (waves) with surrounding low density regions without polar order and (iv) a homogeneous phase without polar order. It has been questioned whether the band phase (iii) should be divided…
▽ More
The Vicsek model of self-propelled particles is known in three different phases: (i) a polar ordered homogeneous phase also called Toner-Tu phase, (iii) a phase of polar ordered regularly arranged high density bands (waves) with surrounding low density regions without polar order and (iv) a homogeneous phase without polar order. It has been questioned whether the band phase (iii) should be divided into two parts [Chaté2020]: one with periodically arranged and one with strongly interacting but not ordered bands. We answer this question by showing that the standard Vicsek model has a fourth phase for large system sizes: (ii) a polar ordered cross sea phase. Close to the transition towards (i) this phase becomes unstable and looks like strongly interacting bands. We demonstrate that the cross sea phase is not just a superposition of two waves, but it is an independent complex pattern. Furthermore we show that there is a non-zero mass flow through the structure of the cross sea pattern within its co-moving frame.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Multiple Particle Correlation Analysis of Many-Particle Systems: Formalism and Application to Active Matter
Authors:
Rüdiger Kürsten,
Sven Stroteich,
Martín Zumaya Hérnandez,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
We introduce a fast spatial point pattern analysis technique which is suitable for systems of many identical particles giving rise to multi-particle correlations up to arbitrary order. The obtained correlation parameters allow to quantify the quality of mean field assumptions or theories that incorporate correlations of limited order. We study the Vicsek model of self-propelled particles and creat…
▽ More
We introduce a fast spatial point pattern analysis technique which is suitable for systems of many identical particles giving rise to multi-particle correlations up to arbitrary order. The obtained correlation parameters allow to quantify the quality of mean field assumptions or theories that incorporate correlations of limited order. We study the Vicsek model of self-propelled particles and create a correlation map marking the required correlation order for each point in phase space incorporating up to ten-particle correlations. We find that multi-particle correlations are important even in a large part of the disordered phase. Furthermore, the two-particle correlation parameter serves as an excellent order parameter to locate both phase transitions of the system, whereas two different order parameters were required before.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Transport coefficients of self-propelled particles. II. Numerics for vorticity fluctuations and the reverse perturbation method
Authors:
Arash Nikoubashman,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
In Part I of this two-part series, the reverse perturbation method for shearing simple liquids [Phys. Rev. E 59, 4894 (1999)] was extended to systems of interacting particles with time-discrete stochastic dynamics. For verification, in this paper (Part II) the reverse perturbation method is first applied to a simple momentum-conserving liquid, modeled through the Multi-Particle Collision Dynamics…
▽ More
In Part I of this two-part series, the reverse perturbation method for shearing simple liquids [Phys. Rev. E 59, 4894 (1999)] was extended to systems of interacting particles with time-discrete stochastic dynamics. For verification, in this paper (Part II) the reverse perturbation method is first applied to a simple momentum-conserving liquid, modeled through the Multi-Particle Collision Dynamics (MPCD) technique [J. Chem. Phys. 110, 8605 (1999)]. For MPCD, excellent agreement between the measured shear viscosity and its theoretical prediction is found. Furthermore, this paper contains applications of the reverse perturbation method to agent-based simulations of the Vicsek-model [Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1226 (1995)] and its metric-free version. The extracted transport coefficients, the kinematic viscosity $ν$ and the momentum amplification coefficient $λ$, were compared to theoretical predictions. To verify the transport coefficients, Green-Kubo relations were evaluated and transverse current correlations were measured in independent simulations. Not too far to the transition to collective motion, we find excellent agreement between the different measurements of the transport coefficients. However, the measured values of $ν$ and $1-λ$ are always slightly higher than the mean-field predictions, even at large mean free paths and at state points quite far from the threshold to collective motion, that is, far in the disordered phase. These findings seem to indicate that the mean-field assumption of molecular chaos is much less reliable in systems with velocity-alignment rules such as the Vicsek model, compared to models obeying detailed balance such as MPCD.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2019; v1 submitted 10 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Transport coefficients of self-propelled particles: Reverse perturbations and transverse current correlations
Authors:
Arash Nikoubashman,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
The reverse perturbation method [Phys. Rev. E 59, 4894 (1999)] for shearing simple liquids and measuring their viscosity is extended to the Vicsek-model (VM) of active particles [Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1226 (1995)] and its metric-free version. The sheared systems exhibit a phenomenon that is similar to the skin effect of an alternating electric current: momentum that is fed into the boundaries of a…
▽ More
The reverse perturbation method [Phys. Rev. E 59, 4894 (1999)] for shearing simple liquids and measuring their viscosity is extended to the Vicsek-model (VM) of active particles [Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1226 (1995)] and its metric-free version. The sheared systems exhibit a phenomenon that is similar to the skin effect of an alternating electric current: momentum that is fed into the boundaries of a layer decays mostly exponentially towards the center of the layer. It is shown how two transport coefficients, i.e. the shear viscosity $ν$ and the momentum amplification coefficient $λ$, can be obtained by fitting this decay with an analytical solution of the hydrodynamic equations for the VM. The viscosity of the VM consists of two parts, a kinetic and a collisional contribution. While analytical predictions already exist for the former, a novel expression for the collisional part is derived by an Enskog-like kinetic theory. To verify the predictions for the transport coefficients, Green-Kubo relations were evaluated and transverse current correlations were measured in independent simulations. Not too far to the transition to collective motion, we find excellent agreement between the different measurements of the transport coefficients. However, the measured values of $ν$ and $1-λ$ are always slightly higher than the mean-field predictions, even at large mean free paths and at state points quite far from the threshold to collective motion, that is, far in the disordered phase. These findings seem to indicate that the mean-field assumption of molecular chaos is much less reliable in systems with velocity-alignment rules such as the VM, compared to models obeying detailed balance such as Multi-Particle Collision Dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2019; v1 submitted 10 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Influence of Sensorial Delay on Clustering and Swarming
Authors:
Rafal Piwowarczyk,
Martin Selin,
Thomas Ihle,
Giovanni Volpe
Abstract:
We show that sensorial delay alters the collective motion of self-propelling agents with aligning interactions: In a two-dimensional Vicsek model, short delays enhance the emergence of clusters and swarms, while long or negative delays prevent their formation. In order to quantify this phenomenon, we introduce a global clustering parameter based on the Voronoi tessellation, which permits us to eff…
▽ More
We show that sensorial delay alters the collective motion of self-propelling agents with aligning interactions: In a two-dimensional Vicsek model, short delays enhance the emergence of clusters and swarms, while long or negative delays prevent their formation. In order to quantify this phenomenon, we introduce a global clustering parameter based on the Voronoi tessellation, which permits us to efficiently measure the formation of clusters. Thanks to its simplicity, sensorial delay might already play a role in the organization of living organisms and can provide a powerful tool to engineer and dynamically tune the behavior of large ensembles of autonomous robots.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Giant Kovacs-Like Memory Effect for Active Particles
Authors:
Rüdiger Kürsten,
Vladimir Sushkov,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
Dynamical properties of a Vicsek-like gas of self-propelled particles are investigated by means of kinetic theory and agent based simulations. While memory effects have been observed in disordered systems, we show that they also occur in active matter systems. In particular, we find that the system exhibits a giant Kovacs-like memory effect that is much larger than predicted by a generic linear th…
▽ More
Dynamical properties of a Vicsek-like gas of self-propelled particles are investigated by means of kinetic theory and agent based simulations. While memory effects have been observed in disordered systems, we show that they also occur in active matter systems. In particular, we find that the system exhibits a giant Kovacs-like memory effect that is much larger than predicted by a generic linear theory. Based on a separation of time scales we develop a nonlinear theory to explain this effect. We apply this theory to driven granular gases and propose further applications to spin glasses.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Critical assessment of von Mises distribution and an infinite series ansatz for self-propelled particles
Authors:
Rüdiger Kürsten,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
We consider a Vicsek model of self-propelled particles with bounded confidence, where each particle interacts only with neighbors that have a similar direction. Depending on parameters, the system exhibits a continuous or discontinuous polar phase transition from the isotropic phase to a phase with a preferred direction. In a recent paper [1] the von Mises distribution was proposed as an ansatz fo…
▽ More
We consider a Vicsek model of self-propelled particles with bounded confidence, where each particle interacts only with neighbors that have a similar direction. Depending on parameters, the system exhibits a continuous or discontinuous polar phase transition from the isotropic phase to a phase with a preferred direction. In a recent paper [1] the von Mises distribution was proposed as an ansatz for polar ordering. In the present system the time evolution of the angular distribution can be solved in Fourier space. We compare the results of the Fourier analysis with the ones obtained by using the von Mises distribution ansatz. In the latter case the qualitative behavior of the system is recovered correctly. However, quantitatively there are serious deviations. We introduce an extended von Mises distribution ansatz such that a second term takes care of the next two Fourier modes. With the extended ansatz we find much better quantitative agreement. As an alternative approach we also use a Gaussian and a geometric series ansatz in Fourier space. The geometric series ansatz is analytically handable but fails for very weak noise, the Gaussian ansatz yields better results but it is not analytically treatable.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Chapman-Enskog expansion for the Vicsek model of self-propelled particles
Authors:
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
Using the standard Vicsek model, I show how the macroscopic transport equations can be systematically derived from microscopic collision rules. The approach starts with the exact evolution equation for the N-particle probability distribution, and after making the mean-field assumption of Molecular Chaos leads to a multi-particle Enskog-type equation. This equation is treated by a non-standard Chap…
▽ More
Using the standard Vicsek model, I show how the macroscopic transport equations can be systematically derived from microscopic collision rules. The approach starts with the exact evolution equation for the N-particle probability distribution, and after making the mean-field assumption of Molecular Chaos leads to a multi-particle Enskog-type equation. This equation is treated by a non-standard Chapman-Enskog expansion to extract the macroscopic behavior. The expansion includes terms up to third order in a formal expansion parameter $ε$, and involves a fast time scale. A self-consistent closure of the moment equations is presented that leads to a continuity equation for the particle density and a Navier-Stokes-like equation for the momentum density. Expressions for all transport coefficients in these macroscopic equations are given explicitly in terms of microscopic parameters of the model. The transport coefficients depend on specific angular integrals which are evaluated asymptotically in the limit of infinitely many collision partners, using an analogy to a random walk. The consistency of the Chapman-Enskog approach is checked by an independent calculation of the shear viscosity using a Green-Kubo relation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2016; v1 submitted 12 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Large density expansion of a hydrodynamic theory for self-propelled particles
Authors:
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
Recently, an Enskog-type kinetic theory for Vicsek-type models for self-propelled particles has been proposed [T. Ihle, Phys. Rev. E 83, 030901 (2011)]. This theory is based on an exact equation for a Markov chain in phase space and is not limited to small density. Previously, the hydrodynamic equations were derived from this theory and its transport coefficients were given in terms of infinite se…
▽ More
Recently, an Enskog-type kinetic theory for Vicsek-type models for self-propelled particles has been proposed [T. Ihle, Phys. Rev. E 83, 030901 (2011)]. This theory is based on an exact equation for a Markov chain in phase space and is not limited to small density. Previously, the hydrodynamic equations were derived from this theory and its transport coefficients were given in terms of infinite series. Here, I show that the transport coefficients take a simple form in the large density limit. This allows me to analytically evaluate the well-known density instability of the polarly ordered phase near the flocking threshold at moderate and large densities. The growth rate of a longitudinal perturbation is calculated and several scaling regimes, including three different power laws, are identified. It is shown that at large densities, the restabilization of the ordered phase at smaller noise is analytically accessible within the range of validity of the hydrodynamic theory. Analytical predictions for the width of the unstable band, the maximum growth rate and for the wave number below which the instability occurs are given. In particular, the system size below which spatial perturbations of the homogeneous ordered state are stable is predicted to scale with $\sqrt{M}$ where $M$ is the average number of collision partners. The typical time scale until the instability becomes visible is calculated and is proportional to M.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Active matter beyond mean-field: Ring-kinetic theory for self-propelled particles
Authors:
Yen-Liang Chou,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
A ring-kinetic theory for Vicsek-style models of self-propelled agents is derived from the exact N-particle evolution equation in phase space. The theory goes beyond mean-field and does not rely on Boltzmann's approximation of molecular chaos. It can handle pre-collisional correlations and cluster formation which both seem important to understand the phase transition to collective motion. We propo…
▽ More
A ring-kinetic theory for Vicsek-style models of self-propelled agents is derived from the exact N-particle evolution equation in phase space. The theory goes beyond mean-field and does not rely on Boltzmann's approximation of molecular chaos. It can handle pre-collisional correlations and cluster formation which both seem important to understand the phase transition to collective motion. We propose a diagrammatic technique to perform a small density expansion of the collision operator and derive the first two equations of the BBGKY-hierarchy. An algorithm is presented that numerically solves the evolution equation for the two-particle correlations on a lattice. Agent-based simulations are performed and informative quantities such as orientational and density correlation functions are compared with those obtained by ring-kinetic theory. Excellent quantitative agreement between simulations and theory is found at not too small noises and mean free paths. This shows that there is parameter ranges in Vicsek-like models where the correlated closure of the BBGKY-hierarchy gives correct and nontrivial results. We calculate the dependence of the orientational correlations on distance in the disordered phase and find that it seems to be consistent with a power law with exponent around -1.8, followed by an exponential decay. General limitations of the kinetic theory and its numerical solution are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2015; v1 submitted 10 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Tricritical points in a Vicsek model of self-propelled particles with bounded confidence
Authors:
Maksym Romenskyy,
Vladimir Lobaskin,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
We study the orientational ordering in systems of self-propelled particles with selective interactions. To introduce the selectivity we augment the standard Vicsek model with a bounded-confidence collision rule: a given particle only aligns to neighbors who have directions quite similar to its own. Neighbors whose directions deviate more than a fixed restriction angle $α$ are ignored. The collecti…
▽ More
We study the orientational ordering in systems of self-propelled particles with selective interactions. To introduce the selectivity we augment the standard Vicsek model with a bounded-confidence collision rule: a given particle only aligns to neighbors who have directions quite similar to its own. Neighbors whose directions deviate more than a fixed restriction angle $α$ are ignored. The collective dynamics of this systems is studied by agent-based simulations and kinetic mean field theory. We demonstrate that the reduction of the restriction angle leads to a critical noise amplitude decreasing monotonically with that angle, turning into a power law with exponent 3/2 for small angles. Moreover, for small system sizes we show that upon decreasing the restriction angle, the kind of the transition to polar collective motion changes from continuous to discontinuous. Thus, an apparent tricritical point is identified and calculated analytically. We also find that at very small interaction angles the polar ordered phase becomes unstable with respect to the apolar phase. We show that the mean-field kinetic theory permits stationary nematic states below a restriction angle of $0.681 π$. We calculate the critical noise, at which the disordered state bifurcates to a nematic state, and find that it is always smaller than the threshold noise for the transition from disorder to polar order. The disordered-nematic transition features two tricritical points: At low and high restriction angle the transition is discontinuous but continuous at intermediate $α$. We generalize our results to systems that show fragmentation into more than two groups and obtain scaling laws for the transition lines and the corresponding tricritical points. A novel numerical method to evaluate the nonlinear Fredholm integral equation for the stationary distribution function is also presented.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2014; v1 submitted 26 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Reply to comment on "Towards a quantitative kinetic theory of polar active matter" by Bertin et al
Authors:
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
A reply on the comment of Bertin, Chate, Ginelli, Gregoire, Leonard and Peshkov, arxiv:1404.3950v1, in this special issue.
A reply on the comment of Bertin, Chate, Ginelli, Gregoire, Leonard and Peshkov, arxiv:1404.3950v1, in this special issue.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Discussion on Peshkov et al., "Boltzmann-Ginzburg-Landau approach for continuous descriptions of generic Vicsek-like models"
Authors:
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
A discussion on the contribution of Peshkov, Bertin, Ginelli and Chate, arxiv:1404.3275v1, in this special issue.
A discussion on the contribution of Peshkov, Bertin, Ginelli and Chate, arxiv:1404.3275v1, in this special issue.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Discussion on Ohta et al., "Traveling bands in self-propelled soft particles"
Authors:
Thomas Ihle,
Yen-Liang Chou
Abstract:
A discussion on the contribution of Ohta and Yamanaka in this special issue, supplemented by new agent-based simulations of band collisions within the standard Vicsek-model.
A discussion on the contribution of Ohta and Yamanaka in this special issue, supplemented by new agent-based simulations of band collisions within the standard Vicsek-model.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Towards a quantitative kinetic theory of polar active matter
Authors:
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
A recent kinetic approach for Vicsek-like models of active particles is reviewed. The theory is based on an exact Chapman-Kolmogorov equation in phase space. It can handle discrete time dynamics and "exotic" multi-particle interactions. A nonlocal mean-field theory for the one-particle distribution function is obtained by assuming molecular chaos. The Boltzmann approach of Bertin et al., Phys. Rev…
▽ More
A recent kinetic approach for Vicsek-like models of active particles is reviewed. The theory is based on an exact Chapman-Kolmogorov equation in phase space. It can handle discrete time dynamics and "exotic" multi-particle interactions. A nonlocal mean-field theory for the one-particle distribution function is obtained by assuming molecular chaos. The Boltzmann approach of Bertin et al., Phys. Rev. E 74, 022101 (2006) and J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 42, 445001 (2009), is critically assessed and compared to the current approach. In Boltzmann theory, a collision starts when two particles enter each others action spheres and is finished when their distance exceeds the interaction radius. The average duration of such a collision, $τ_0$, is measured for the Vicsek model with continuous time-evolution. If the noise is chosen to be close to the flocking threshold, the average time between collisions is found to be roughly equal to $τ_0$ at low densities. Thus, the continuous-time Vicsek-model near the flocking threshold cannot be accurately described by a Boltzmann equation, even at very small density because collisions take so long that typically other particles join in, rendering Boltzmann's binary collision assumption invalid. Hydrodynamic equations for the phase space approach are derived by means of a Chapman-Enskog expansion. The equations are compared to the Toner-Tu theory of polar active matter. New terms, absent in the Toner-Tu theory, are highlighted. Convergence problems of Chapman-Enskog and similar gradient expansions are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2014; v1 submitted 30 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Invasion-wave induced first-order phase transition in systems of active particles
Authors:
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
An Enskog-like kinetic equation for self-propelled particles is solved numerically. I study a density instability near the transition to collective motion and find that while hydrodynamics breaks down, the kinetic approach leads to soliton-like supersonic waves with steep leading kinks and Knudsen numbers of order one. These waves show hysteresis, modify the transition threshold and lead to an abr…
▽ More
An Enskog-like kinetic equation for self-propelled particles is solved numerically. I study a density instability near the transition to collective motion and find that while hydrodynamics breaks down, the kinetic approach leads to soliton-like supersonic waves with steep leading kinks and Knudsen numbers of order one. These waves show hysteresis, modify the transition threshold and lead to an abrupt jump of the global order parameter if the noise level is changed. Thus they provide a mechanism to change the second-order character of the phase transition to first order.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Kinetic theory for systems of self-propelled particles with metric-free interactions
Authors:
Yen-Liang Chou,
Rylan Wolfe,
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
A model of self-driven particles similar to the Vicsek model [Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 (1995) 1226] but with metric-free interactions is studied by means of a novel Enskog-type kinetic theory. In this model, N particles of constant speed v0 try to align their travel directions with the average direction of a fixed number of closest neighbors. At strong alignment a global flocking state forms. The align…
▽ More
A model of self-driven particles similar to the Vicsek model [Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 (1995) 1226] but with metric-free interactions is studied by means of a novel Enskog-type kinetic theory. In this model, N particles of constant speed v0 try to align their travel directions with the average direction of a fixed number of closest neighbors. At strong alignment a global flocking state forms. The alignment is defined by a stochastic rule, not by a Hamiltonian. The corresponding interactions are of genuine multi-body nature. The theory is based on a Master equation in 3N-dimensional phase space, which is made tractable by means of the molecular chaos approximation. The phase diagram for the transition to collective motion is calculated and compared to direct numerical simulations. A linear stability analysis of a homogeneous ordered state is performed using the kinetic but not the hydrodynamic equations in order to achieve high accuracy. In contrast to the regular metric Vicsek-model no instabilities occur. This confirms previous direct simulations that for Vicsek-like models with metric-free interactions, there is no formation of density bands and that the flocking transition is continuous.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2012; v1 submitted 3 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Kinetic Theory of Flocking: Derivation of Hydrodynamic Equations
Authors:
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
It is shown how to explicitly coarse-grain the microscopic dynamics of the Vicsek model for self-propelled agents. The macroscopic transport equations are derived by means of an Enskog-type kinetic theory. Expressions for all transport coefficients at large particle speed are given. The phase transition from a disordered to a flocking state is studied numerically and analytically.
It is shown how to explicitly coarse-grain the microscopic dynamics of the Vicsek model for self-propelled agents. The macroscopic transport equations are derived by means of an Enskog-type kinetic theory. Expressions for all transport coefficients at large particle speed are given. The phase transition from a disordered to a flocking state is studied numerically and analytically.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2010; v1 submitted 9 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
-
Multi-Particle Collision Dynamics -- a Particle-Based Mesoscale Simulation Approach to the Hydrodynamics of Complex Fluids
Authors:
G. Gompper,
T. Ihle,
D. M. Kroll,
R. G. Winkler
Abstract:
In this review, we describe and analyze a mesoscale simulation method for fluid flow, which was introduced by Malevanets and Kapral in 1999, and is now called multi-particle collision dynamics (MPC) or stochastic rotation dynamics (SRD). The method consists of alternating streaming and collision steps in an ensemble of point particles. The multi-particle collisions are performed by grouping part…
▽ More
In this review, we describe and analyze a mesoscale simulation method for fluid flow, which was introduced by Malevanets and Kapral in 1999, and is now called multi-particle collision dynamics (MPC) or stochastic rotation dynamics (SRD). The method consists of alternating streaming and collision steps in an ensemble of point particles. The multi-particle collisions are performed by grouping particles in collision cells, and mass, momentum, and energy are locally conserved. This simulation technique captures both full hydrodynamic interactions and thermal fluctuations. The first part of the review begins with a description of several widely used MPC algorithms and then discusses important features of the original SRD algorithm and frequently used variations. Two complementary approaches for deriving the hydrodynamic equations and evaluating the transport coefficients are reviewed. It is then shown how MPC algorithms can be generalized to model non-ideal fluids, and binary mixtures with a consolute point. The importance of angular-momentum conservation for systems like phase-separated liquids with different viscosities is discussed. The second part of the review describes a number of recent applications of MPC algorithms to study colloid and polymer dynamics, the behavior of vesicles and cells in hydrodynamic flows, and the dynamics of viscoelastic fluids.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
Transport coefficients of multi-particle collision algorithms with velocity-dependent collision rules
Authors:
Thomas Ihle
Abstract:
Detailed calculations of the transport coefficients of a recently introduced particle-based model for fluid dynamics with a non-ideal equation of state are presented. Excluded volume interactions are modeled by means of biased stochastic multiparticle collisions which depend on the local velocities and densities. Momentum and energy are exactly conserved locally. A general scheme to derive trans…
▽ More
Detailed calculations of the transport coefficients of a recently introduced particle-based model for fluid dynamics with a non-ideal equation of state are presented. Excluded volume interactions are modeled by means of biased stochastic multiparticle collisions which depend on the local velocities and densities. Momentum and energy are exactly conserved locally. A general scheme to derive transport coefficients for such biased, velocity dependent collision rules is developed. Analytic expressions for the self-diffusion coefficient and the shear viscosity are obtained, and very good agreement is found with numerical results at small and large mean free paths. The viscosity turns out to be proportional to the square root of temperature, as in a real gas. In addition, the theoretical framework is applied to a two-component version of the model, and expressions for the viscosity and the difference in diffusion of the two species are given.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.
-
Mesoscopic model for the fluctuating hydrodynamics of binary and ternary mixtures
Authors:
Erkan Tuzel,
Guoai Pan,
Thomas Ihle,
Daniel M. Kroll
Abstract:
A recently introduced particle-based model for fluid dynamics with continuous velocities is generalized to model immiscible binary mixtures. Excluded volume interactions between the two components are modeled by stochastic multiparticle collisions which depend on the local velocities and densities. Momentum and energy are conserved locally, and entropically driven phase separation occurs for hig…
▽ More
A recently introduced particle-based model for fluid dynamics with continuous velocities is generalized to model immiscible binary mixtures. Excluded volume interactions between the two components are modeled by stochastic multiparticle collisions which depend on the local velocities and densities. Momentum and energy are conserved locally, and entropically driven phase separation occurs for high collision rates. An explicit expression for the equation of state is derived, and the concentration dependence of the bulk free energy is shown to be the same as that of the Widom-Rowlinson model. Analytic results for the phase diagram are in excellent agreement with simulation data. Results for the line tension obtained from the analysis of the capillary wave spectrum of a droplet agree with measurements based on the Laplace's equation. The introduction of "amphiphilic" dimers makes it possible to model the phase behavior and dynamics of ternary surfactant mixtures.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
Static and dynamic properties of a particle-based algorithm for non-ideal fluids and binary mixtures
Authors:
Thomas Ihle,
Erkan Tuzel
Abstract:
A recently introduced particle-based model for fluid dynamics with effective excluded volume interactions is analyzed in detail. The interactions are modeled by means of stochastic multiparticle collisions which are biased and depend on local velocities and densities. Momentum and energy are exactly conserved locally. The isotropy and relaxation to equilibrium are analyzed and measured. It is sh…
▽ More
A recently introduced particle-based model for fluid dynamics with effective excluded volume interactions is analyzed in detail. The interactions are modeled by means of stochastic multiparticle collisions which are biased and depend on local velocities and densities. Momentum and energy are exactly conserved locally. The isotropy and relaxation to equilibrium are analyzed and measured. It is shown how a discrete-time projection operator technique can be used to obtain Green-Kubo relations for the transport coefficients. Because of a large viscosity no long-time tails in the velocity auto-correlation and stress correlation functions were seen. Strongly reduced self-diffusion due to caging and an order/disorder transition is found at high collision frequency, where clouds consisting of at least four particles form a cubic phase. These structures were analyzed by measuring the pair-correlation function above and below the transition. Finally, the algorithm is extended to binary mixtures which phase-separate above a critical collision rate.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Dynamic correlations in stochastic rotation dynamics
Authors:
Erkan Tuzel,
Thomas Ihle,
Daniel M. Kroll
Abstract:
The dynamic structure factor, vorticity and entropy density dynamic correlation functions are measured for Stochastic Rotation Dynamics (SRD), a particle based algorithm for fluctuating fluids. This allows us to obtain unbiased values for the longitudinal transport coefficients such as thermal diffusivity and bulk viscosity. The results are in good agreement with earlier numerical and theoretica…
▽ More
The dynamic structure factor, vorticity and entropy density dynamic correlation functions are measured for Stochastic Rotation Dynamics (SRD), a particle based algorithm for fluctuating fluids. This allows us to obtain unbiased values for the longitudinal transport coefficients such as thermal diffusivity and bulk viscosity. The results are in good agreement with earlier numerical and theoretical results, and it is shown for the first time that the bulk viscosity is indeed zero for this algorithm. In addition, corrections to the self-diffusion coefficient and shear viscosity arising from the breakdown of the molecular chaos approximation at small mean free paths are analyzed. In addition to deriving the form of the leading correlation corrections to these transport coefficients, the probabilities that two and three particles remain collision partners for consecutive time steps are derived analytically in the limit of small mean free path. The results of this paper verify that we have an excellent understanding of the SRD algorithm at the kinetic level and that analytic expressions for the transport coefficients derived elsewhere do indeed provide a very accurate description of the SRD fluid.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
Constructing thermodynamically consistent models with a non-ideal equation of state
Authors:
Erkan Tuzel,
Thomas Ihle,
Daniel M. Kroll
Abstract:
A recently introduced particle-based model for fluid dynamics with continuous velocities is generalized to model fluids with excluded volume effects. This is achieved through the use of biased stochastic multi-particle collisions which depend on local velocities and densities and conserve momentum and kinetic energy. The equation of state is derived and criteria for the correct choice of collisi…
▽ More
A recently introduced particle-based model for fluid dynamics with continuous velocities is generalized to model fluids with excluded volume effects. This is achieved through the use of biased stochastic multi-particle collisions which depend on local velocities and densities and conserve momentum and kinetic energy. The equation of state is derived and criteria for the correct choice of collision probabilities are discussed. In particular, it is shown how a naive implementation can lead to inconsistent density fluctuations.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2005;
originally announced November 2005.
-
Consistent particle-based algorithm with a non-ideal equation of state
Authors:
Thomas Ihle,
Erkan Tuzel,
Daniel M. Kroll
Abstract:
A thermodynamically consistent particle-based model for fluid dynamics with continuous velocities and a non-ideal equation of state is presented. Excluded volume interactions are modeled by means of biased stochastic multiparticle collisions which depend on the local velocities and densities. Momentum and energy are exactly conserved locally. The equation of state is derived and compared to inde…
▽ More
A thermodynamically consistent particle-based model for fluid dynamics with continuous velocities and a non-ideal equation of state is presented. Excluded volume interactions are modeled by means of biased stochastic multiparticle collisions which depend on the local velocities and densities. Momentum and energy are exactly conserved locally. The equation of state is derived and compared to independent measurements of the pressure. Results for the kinematic shear viscosity and self-diffusion constants are presented. A caging and order/disorder transition is observed at high densities and large collision frequency.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2005;
originally announced September 2005.
-
Equilibrium calculation of transport coefficients for a fluid-particle model
Authors:
Thomas Ihle,
Erkan Tuzel,
Daniel M. Kroll
Abstract:
A recently introduced particle-based model for fluid flow, called Stochastic Rotation Dynamics, can be made Galilean invariant by introducing a random shift of the computational grid before collisions. In this paper, it is shown how the Green-Kubo relations derived previously can be resummed to obtain exact expressions for the collisional contributions to the transport coefficients. It is also s…
▽ More
A recently introduced particle-based model for fluid flow, called Stochastic Rotation Dynamics, can be made Galilean invariant by introducing a random shift of the computational grid before collisions. In this paper, it is shown how the Green-Kubo relations derived previously can be resummed to obtain exact expressions for the collisional contributions to the transport coefficients. It is also shown that the collisional contribution to the microscopic stress tensor is not symmetric, and that this leads to an additional viscosity. The resulting identification of the transport coefficients for the hydrodynamic modes is discussed in detail, and it is shown that this does not impose restrictions on the applicability of the model. The collisional contribution to the thermal conductivity, which becomes important for small mean free path and small average particle number per cell, is also derived.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2005; v1 submitted 17 May, 2005;
originally announced May 2005.
-
Simulation of Claylike Colloids
Authors:
Martin Hecht,
Jens Harting,
Thomas Ihle,
Hans J. Herrmann
Abstract:
We investigate properties of dense suspensions and sediments of small spherical silt particles by means of a combined Molecular Dynamics (MD) and Stochastic Rotation Dynamics (SRD) simulation. We include van der Waals and effective electrostatic interactions between the colloidal particles, as well as Brownian motion and hydrodynamic interactions which are calculated in the SRD-part. We present…
▽ More
We investigate properties of dense suspensions and sediments of small spherical silt particles by means of a combined Molecular Dynamics (MD) and Stochastic Rotation Dynamics (SRD) simulation. We include van der Waals and effective electrostatic interactions between the colloidal particles, as well as Brownian motion and hydrodynamic interactions which are calculated in the SRD-part. We present the simulation technique and first results. We have measured velocity distributions, diffusion coefficients, sedimentation velocity, spatial correlation functions and we have explored the phase diagram depending on the parameters of the potentials and on the volume fraction.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2005; v1 submitted 1 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
Resummed Green-Kubo relations for a fluctuating fluid-particle model
Authors:
Thomas Ihle,
Erkan Tuzel,
Daniel M. Kroll
Abstract:
A recently introduced stochastic model for fluid flow can be made Galilean invariant by introducing a random shift of the computational grid before collisions. This grid shifting procedure accelerates momentum transfer between cells and leads to a collisional contribution to transport coefficients. By resumming the Green-Kubo relations derived in a previous paper, it is shown that this collision…
▽ More
A recently introduced stochastic model for fluid flow can be made Galilean invariant by introducing a random shift of the computational grid before collisions. This grid shifting procedure accelerates momentum transfer between cells and leads to a collisional contribution to transport coefficients. By resumming the Green-Kubo relations derived in a previous paper, it is shown that this collisional contribution to the transport coefficients can be determined exactly. The resummed Green-Kubo relations also show that there are no mixed kinetic-collisional contributions to the transport coefficients. The leading correlation corrections to the transport coefficients are discussed, and explicit expressions for the transport coefficients are presented and compared with simulation data.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2004;
originally announced April 2004.
-
Transport Coefficients for Stochastic Rotation Dynamics in Three Dimensions
Authors:
Erkan Tuzel,
Martin Strauss,
Thomas Ihle,
Daniel M. Kroll
Abstract:
Explicit expressions for the transport coefficients of a recently introduced stochastic model for simulating fluctuating fluid dynamics are derived in three dimensions by means of Green-Kubo relations and simple kinetic arguments. The results are shown to be in excellent agreement with simulation data. Two collision rules are considered and their computational efficiency is compared.
Explicit expressions for the transport coefficients of a recently introduced stochastic model for simulating fluctuating fluid dynamics are derived in three dimensions by means of Green-Kubo relations and simple kinetic arguments. The results are shown to be in excellent agreement with simulation data. Two collision rules are considered and their computational efficiency is compared.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2003;
originally announced April 2003.
-
Multi-particle-collision dynamics: Flow around a circular and a square cylinder
Authors:
A. Lamura,
G. Gompper,
T. Ihle,
D. M. Kroll
Abstract:
A particle-based model for mesoscopic fluid dynamics is used to simulate steady and unsteady flows around a circular and a square cylinder in a two-dimensional channel for a range of Reynolds number between 10 and 130. Numerical results for the recirculation length, the drag coefficient, and the Strouhal number are reported and compared with previous experimental measurements and computational f…
▽ More
A particle-based model for mesoscopic fluid dynamics is used to simulate steady and unsteady flows around a circular and a square cylinder in a two-dimensional channel for a range of Reynolds number between 10 and 130. Numerical results for the recirculation length, the drag coefficient, and the Strouhal number are reported and compared with previous experimental measurements and computational fluid dynamics data. The good agreement demonstrates the potential of this method for the investigation of complex flows.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2001;
originally announced October 2001.