-
Semilocal approximations to the Kohn-Sham exchange potential as applied to a metal surface
Authors:
C. M. Horowitz,
C. R. Proetto,
J. M. Pitarke
Abstract:
Several semilocal exchange potentials usually employed in the framework of density-functional theory (DFT) are tested and compared with their exact counterpart, the exchange Optimized Effective Potential (OEP), as applied to the jellium-slab model of a metal-vacuum interface. Driven by their explicit dependence on the ground-state density, its gradient, and its kinetic-energy density, the three an…
▽ More
Several semilocal exchange potentials usually employed in the framework of density-functional theory (DFT) are tested and compared with their exact counterpart, the exchange Optimized Effective Potential (OEP), as applied to the jellium-slab model of a metal-vacuum interface. Driven by their explicit dependence on the ground-state density, its gradient, and its kinetic-energy density, the three analyzed semilocal exchange potentials approach their respective asymptotic limits faster than in the case of the OEP, all of them having an asymptotic scaling of the form $-α\,e^2/z + V_{\infty}$, with $α< 1$. Here we provide the leading analytic asymptotics of the three model potentials under study, and we find that none of them exhibits the exact OEP slab asymptotics $-\;e^2/z$. While the so-called Becke-Roussel potential's leading asymptote is close to its exact OEP counterpart, the other two model potentials under study approach a material-dependent positive constant value far into the vacuum, resulting in considerably overestimated ionization potentials.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Asymptotics of the metal-surface Kohn-Sham exact exchange potential revisited
Authors:
C. M. Horowitz,
C. R. Proetto,
J. M. Pitarke
Abstract:
The asymptotics of the Kohn-Sham (KS) exact exchange potential $V_x(z)$ of a jelliumlike semi-infinite metal is investigated, in the framework of the optimized-effective-potential formalism of density-functional theory. Our numerical calculations clearly show that deep into the vacuum side of the surface $V_x(z) \propto e^2 \ln(az) / z$, with $a$ being a system-dependent constant, thus confirming…
▽ More
The asymptotics of the Kohn-Sham (KS) exact exchange potential $V_x(z)$ of a jelliumlike semi-infinite metal is investigated, in the framework of the optimized-effective-potential formalism of density-functional theory. Our numerical calculations clearly show that deep into the vacuum side of the surface $V_x(z) \propto e^2 \ln(az) / z$, with $a$ being a system-dependent constant, thus confirming the analytical calculations reported in Phys. Rev. B {\bf 81}, 121106(R) (2010). A criticism of this work published in Phys. Rev. B {\bf 85}, 115124 (2012) is shown to be incorrect. Our rigorous exchange-only results provide strong constraints both for the building of approximate exchange functionals and for the determination of the still unknown KS correlation potential.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Localized versus extended systems in density-functional theory: some lessons from the Kohn-Sham exact exchange potential
Authors:
C. M. Horowitz,
C. R. Proetto,
J. M. Pitarke
Abstract:
A long-standing puzzle in density-functional theory is the issue of the long-range behavior of the Kohn-Sham exchange-correlation potential at metal surfaces. As an important step towards its solution, it is proved here, through a rigurouos asymptotic analysis and accurate numerical solution of the Optimized-Effective-Potential integral equation, that the Kohn-Sham exact exchange potential decays…
▽ More
A long-standing puzzle in density-functional theory is the issue of the long-range behavior of the Kohn-Sham exchange-correlation potential at metal surfaces. As an important step towards its solution, it is proved here, through a rigurouos asymptotic analysis and accurate numerical solution of the Optimized-Effective-Potential integral equation, that the Kohn-Sham exact exchange potential decays as $\ln(z)/z$ far into the vacuum side of an {\it extended} semi-infinite jellium. In contrast to the situation in {\it localized} systems, like atoms, molecules, and slabs, this dominant contribution does not arise from the so-called Slater potential. This exact-exchange result provides a strong constraint on the suitability of approximate correlation-energy functionals.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
Position-dependent exact-exchange energy for slabs and semi-infinite jellium
Authors:
C. M. Horowitz,
L. A. Constantin,
C. R. Proetto,
J. M. Pitarke
Abstract:
The position-dependent exact-exchange energy per particle $\varepsilon_x(z)$ (defined as the interaction between a given electron at $z$ and its exact-exchange hole) at metal surfaces is investigated, by using either jellium slabs or the semi-infinite (SI) jellium model. For jellium slabs, we prove analytically and numerically that in the vacuum region far away from the surface…
▽ More
The position-dependent exact-exchange energy per particle $\varepsilon_x(z)$ (defined as the interaction between a given electron at $z$ and its exact-exchange hole) at metal surfaces is investigated, by using either jellium slabs or the semi-infinite (SI) jellium model. For jellium slabs, we prove analytically and numerically that in the vacuum region far away from the surface $\varepsilon_{x}^{\text{Slab}}(z \to \infty) \to - e^{2}/2z$, {\it independent} of the bulk electron density, which is exactly half the corresponding exact-exchange potential $V_{x}(z \to \infty) \to - e^2/z$ [Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 97}, 026802 (2006)] of density-functional theory, as occurs in the case of finite systems. The fitting of $\varepsilon_{x}^{\text{Slab}}(z)$ to a physically motivated image-like expression is feasible, but the resulting location of the image plane shows strong finite-size oscillations every time a slab discrete energy level becomes occupied. For a semi-infinite jellium, the asymptotic behavior of $\varepsilon_{x}^{\text{SI}}(z)$ is somehow different. As in the case of jellium slabs $\varepsilon_{x}^{\text{SI}}(z \to \infty)$ has an image-like behavior of the form $\propto - e^2/z$, but now with a density-dependent coefficient that in general differs from the slab universal coefficient 1/2. Our numerical estimates for this coefficient agree with two previous analytical estimates for the same. For an arbitrary finite thickness of a jellium slab, we find that the asymptotic limits of $\varepsilon_{x}^{\text{Slab}}(z)$ and $\varepsilon_{x}^{\text{SI}}(z)$ only coincide in the low-density limit ($r_s \to \infty$), where the density-dependent coefficient of the semi-infinite jellium approaches the slab {\it universal} coefficient 1/2.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
Ballistic deposition on deterministic fractals: On the observation of discrete scale invariance
Authors:
Claudio M. Horowitz,
Federico Roma,
Ezequiel V. Albano
Abstract:
The growth of ballistic aggregates on deterministic fractal substrates is studied by means of numerical simulations. First, we attempt the description of the evolving interface of the aggregates by applying the well-established Family-Vicsek dynamic scaling approach. Systematic deviations from that standard scaling law are observed, suggesting that significant scaling corrections have to be intr…
▽ More
The growth of ballistic aggregates on deterministic fractal substrates is studied by means of numerical simulations. First, we attempt the description of the evolving interface of the aggregates by applying the well-established Family-Vicsek dynamic scaling approach. Systematic deviations from that standard scaling law are observed, suggesting that significant scaling corrections have to be introduced in order to achieve a more accurate understanding of the behavior of the interface. Subsequently, we study the internal structure of the growing aggregates that can be rationalized in terms of the scaling behavior of frozen trees, i.e., structures inhibited for further growth, lying below the growing interface. It is shown that the rms height ($h_{s}$) and width ($w_{s}$) of the trees of size $s$ obey power laws of the form $h_{s} \propto s^{ν_{\parallel}}$ and $w_{s} \propto s^{ν_{\perp}}$, respectively. Also, the tree-size distribution ($n_{s}$) behaves according to $n_{s}\sim s^{-τ}$. Here, $ν_{\parallel}$ and $ν_{\perp}$ are the correlation length exponents in the directions parallel and perpendicular to the interface, respectively. Also, $τ$ is a critical exponent. However, due to the interplay between the discrete scale invariance of the underlying fractal substrates and the dynamics of the growing process, all these power laws are modulated by logarithmic periodic oscillations. The fundamental scaling ratios, characteristic of these oscillations, can be linked to the (spatial) fundamental scaling ratio of the underlying fractal by means of relationships involving critical exponents.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
Exact-exchange Kohn-Sham potential, surface energy, and work function of jellium slabs
Authors:
C. M. Horowitz,
C. R. Proetto,
J. M. Pitarke
Abstract:
Exact-exchange self-consistent calculations of the Kohn-Sham potential, surface energy, and work function of jellium slabs are reported in the framework of the Optimized Effective Potential (OEP) scheme of Density Functional Theory. In the vacuum side of the jellium surface and at a distance $z$ that is larger than the slab thickness, the exchange-only Kohn-Sham potential is found to be image-li…
▽ More
Exact-exchange self-consistent calculations of the Kohn-Sham potential, surface energy, and work function of jellium slabs are reported in the framework of the Optimized Effective Potential (OEP) scheme of Density Functional Theory. In the vacuum side of the jellium surface and at a distance $z$ that is larger than the slab thickness, the exchange-only Kohn-Sham potential is found to be image-like ($\sim -e^2/z$) but with a coefficient that differs from that of the classical image potential $V_{im}(z)=-e^2/4z$. The three OEP contributions to the surface energy (kinetic, electrostatic, and exchange) are found to oscillate as a function of the slab thickness, as occurs in the case of the corresponding calculations based on the use of single-particle orbitals and energies obtained in the Local Density Approximation (LDA). The OEP work function presents large quantum size effects that are absent in the LDA and which reflect the intrinsic derivative discontinuity of the exact Kohn-Sham potential.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
Kohn-Sham Exchange Potential for a Metallic Surface
Authors:
C. M. Horowitz,
C. R. Proetto,
S. Rigamonti
Abstract:
The behavior of the surface barrier that forms at the metal-vacuum interface is important for several fields of surface science. Within the Density Functional Theory framework, this surface barrier has two non-trivial components: exchange and correlation. Exact results are provided for the exchange component, for a jellium metal-vacuum interface, in a slab geometry.
The Kohn-Sham exact-exchang…
▽ More
The behavior of the surface barrier that forms at the metal-vacuum interface is important for several fields of surface science. Within the Density Functional Theory framework, this surface barrier has two non-trivial components: exchange and correlation. Exact results are provided for the exchange component, for a jellium metal-vacuum interface, in a slab geometry.
The Kohn-Sham exact-exchange potential $V_{x}(z)$ has been generated by using the Optimized Effective Potential method, through an accurate numerical solution, imposing the correct boundary condition. It has been proved analytically, and confirmed numerically, that $V_{x}(z\to \infty)\to - e^{2}/z$; this conclusion is not affected by the inclusion of correlation effects. Also, the exact-exchange potential develops a shoulder-like structure close to the interface, on the vacuum side. The issue of the classical image potential is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
Experimental evidence on the development of scale invariance in the internal structure of self-affine aggregates
Authors:
C. M. Horowitz,
M. A. Pasquale,
E. V. Albano,
A. J. Arvia
Abstract:
It is shown that an alternative approach for the characterization of growing branched patterns consists of the statistical analysis of frozen structures, which cannot be modified by further growth, that arise due to competitive processes among neighbor growing structures. Scaling relationships applied to these structures provide a method to evaluate relevant exponents and to characterize growing…
▽ More
It is shown that an alternative approach for the characterization of growing branched patterns consists of the statistical analysis of frozen structures, which cannot be modified by further growth, that arise due to competitive processes among neighbor growing structures. Scaling relationships applied to these structures provide a method to evaluate relevant exponents and to characterize growing systems into universality classes. The analysis is applied to quasi-two-dimensional electrochemically formed silver branched patterns showing that the size distribution of frozen structures exhibits scale invariance. The measured exponents, within the error bars, remind us those predicted by the Kardar-Parisi-Zhang equation.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
-
Dynamic properties in a family of competitive growing models
Authors:
Claudio M. Horowitz,
Ezequiel V. Albano
Abstract:
The properties of a wide variety of growing models, generically called $X/RD$, are studied by means of numerical simulations and analytic developments. The study comprises the following $X$ models: Ballistic Deposition, Random Deposition with Surface Relaxation, Das Sarma-Tamboronea, Kim-Kosterlitz, Lai-Das Sarma, Wolf-Villain, Large Curvature, and three additional models that are variants of th…
▽ More
The properties of a wide variety of growing models, generically called $X/RD$, are studied by means of numerical simulations and analytic developments. The study comprises the following $X$ models: Ballistic Deposition, Random Deposition with Surface Relaxation, Das Sarma-Tamboronea, Kim-Kosterlitz, Lai-Das Sarma, Wolf-Villain, Large Curvature, and three additional models that are variants of the Ballistic Deposition model.
It is shown that after a growing regime, the interface width becomes saturated at a crossover time ($t_{x2}$) that, by fixing the sample size, scales with $p$ according to $t_{x2}(p)\propto p^{-y}, \qquad (p > 0)$, where $y$ is an exponent. Also, the interface width at saturation ($W_{sat}$) scales as $W_{sat}(p)\propto p^{-δ}, \qquad (p > 0)$, where $δ$ is another exponent.
It is proved that, in any dimension, the exponents $δ$ and $y$ obey the following relationship: $δ= y β_{RD}$, where $β_{RD} = 1/2$ is the growing exponent for $RD$. Furthermore, both exponents exhibit universality in the $p \to 0$ limit.
By mapping the behaviour of the average height difference of two neighbouring sites in discrete models of type $X/RD$ and two kinds of random walks, we have determined the exact value of the exponent $δ$.
Finally, by linking four well-established universality classes (namely Edwards-Wilkinson, Kardar-Parisi-Zhang, Linear-MBE and Non-linear-MBE) with the properties of both random walks, eight different stochastic equations for all the competitive models studied are derived.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
-
A numerical study of the development of bulk scale-free structures upon growth of self-affine aggregates
Authors:
Federico Roma,
Claudio M. Horowitz,
Ezequiel V. Albano
Abstract:
During the last decade, self-affine geometrical properties of many growing aggregates, originated in a wide variety of processes, have been well characterized. However, little progress has been achieved in the search of a unified description of the underlying dynamics. Extensive numerical evidence has been given showing that the bulk of aggregates formed upon ballistic aggregation and random dep…
▽ More
During the last decade, self-affine geometrical properties of many growing aggregates, originated in a wide variety of processes, have been well characterized. However, little progress has been achieved in the search of a unified description of the underlying dynamics. Extensive numerical evidence has been given showing that the bulk of aggregates formed upon ballistic aggregation and random deposition with surface relaxation processes can be broken down into a set of infinite scale invariant structures called "trees". These two types of aggregates have been selected because it has been established that they belong to different universality classes: those of Kardar-Parisi-Zhang and Edward-Wilkinson, respectively. Exponents describing the spatial and temporal scale invariance of the trees can be related to the classical exponents describing the self-affine nature of the growing interface. Furthermore, those exponents allows us to distinguish either the compact or non-compact nature of the growing trees. Therefore, the measurement of the statistic of the process of growing trees may become a useful experimental technique for the evaluation of the self-affine properties of some aggregates.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2002;
originally announced October 2002.