-
Describe, Transform, Machine Learning: Feature Engineering for Grain Boundaries and Other Variable-Sized Atom Clusters
Authors:
C. Braxton Owens,
Nithin Mathew,
Tyce W. Olaveson,
Jacob P. Tavenner,
Edward M. Kober,
Garritt J. Tucker,
Gus L. W. Hart,
Eric R. Homer
Abstract:
Obtaining microscopic structure-property relationships for grain boundaries are challenging because of the complex atomic structures that underlie their behavior. This has led to recent efforts to obtain these relationships with machine learning, but representing a grain boundary structure in a manner suitable for machine learning is not a trivial task. There are three key steps common to property…
▽ More
Obtaining microscopic structure-property relationships for grain boundaries are challenging because of the complex atomic structures that underlie their behavior. This has led to recent efforts to obtain these relationships with machine learning, but representing a grain boundary structure in a manner suitable for machine learning is not a trivial task. There are three key steps common to property prediction in grain boundaries and other variable-sized atom clustered structures. These are: (1) describe the atomic structure as a feature matrix, (2) transform the variable-sized feature matrices of different structures to a fixed length common to all structures, and (3) apply machine learning to predict properties from the transformed feature matrices. We examine these feature engineering steps to understand how they impact the accuracy of grain boundary energy predictions. A database of over 7000 grain boundaries serves to evaluate the different feature engineering combinations. We also examine how these combination of engineered features provide interpretability, or the ability to extract insightful physics from the obtained structure-property relationships.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Grain boundary solute segregation across the 5D space of crystallographic character
Authors:
Lydia Harris Serafin,
Ethan R. Cluff,
Gus L. W. Hart,
Eric R. Homer
Abstract:
Solute segregation in materials with grain boundaries (GBs) has emerged as a popular method to thermodynamically stabilize nanocrystalline structures. However, the impact of varied GB crystallographic character on solute segregation has never been thoroughly examined. This work examines Co solute segregation in a dataset of 7272 Al bicrystal GBs that span the 5D space of GB crystallographic charac…
▽ More
Solute segregation in materials with grain boundaries (GBs) has emerged as a popular method to thermodynamically stabilize nanocrystalline structures. However, the impact of varied GB crystallographic character on solute segregation has never been thoroughly examined. This work examines Co solute segregation in a dataset of 7272 Al bicrystal GBs that span the 5D space of GB crystallographic character. Considerable attention is paid to verification of the calculations in the diverse and large set of GBs. In addition, the results of this work are favorably validated against similar bicrystal and polycrystal simulations. As with other work, we show that Co atoms exhibit strong segregation to sites in Al GBs and that segregation correlates strongly with GB energy and GB excess volume. Segregation varies smoothly in the 5D crystallographic space but has a complex landscape without an obvious functional form.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Can we predict mixed grain boundaries from their tilt and twist components?
Authors:
Wei Wan,
Changxin Tang,
Eric R. Homer
Abstract:
One of the major challenges towards understanding and further utilizing the properties and functional behaviors of grain boundaries (GB) is the complexity of general GBs with mixed tilt and twist characters. Here, we report the correlations between mixed GBs and their tilt and twist components in terms of structure, energy and stress field by computationally examining 7040 silicon GBs. Such correl…
▽ More
One of the major challenges towards understanding and further utilizing the properties and functional behaviors of grain boundaries (GB) is the complexity of general GBs with mixed tilt and twist characters. Here, we report the correlations between mixed GBs and their tilt and twist components in terms of structure, energy and stress field by computationally examining 7040 silicon GBs. Such correlations indicate that low angle mixed GBs are formed through the reconstruction mechanisms between their superposed tilt and twist components, which are revealed as the energetically favorable dissociation, motion and reaction of dislocations and stacking faults. In addition, various complex disconnection network structures are discovered near the conventional twin and structural unit GBs, implying the role of disconnection superposition in forming high angle mixed GBs. By unveiling the energetic correlation, an extended Read-Shockley model that predicts the general trends of GB energy is proposed and confirmed in various GB structures across different lattices. Finally, this work is validated in comparison with experimental observations and first-principles calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2024; v1 submitted 4 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Facet and energy predictions in grain boundaries: lattice matching and molecular dynamics
Authors:
Bruno Dobrovolski,
C. Braxton Owens,
Gus L. W. Hart,
Eric R. Homer,
Brandon Runnels
Abstract:
Many material properties can be traced back to properties of their grain boundaries. Grain boundary energy (GBE), as a result, is a key quantity of interest in the analysis and modeling of microstructure. A standard method for calculating grain boundary energy is molecular dynamics (MD); however, on-the-fly MD calculations are not tenable due to the extensive computational time required. Lattice m…
▽ More
Many material properties can be traced back to properties of their grain boundaries. Grain boundary energy (GBE), as a result, is a key quantity of interest in the analysis and modeling of microstructure. A standard method for calculating grain boundary energy is molecular dynamics (MD); however, on-the-fly MD calculations are not tenable due to the extensive computational time required. Lattice matching (LM) is a reduced-order method for estimating GBE quickly; however, it has only been tested against a relatively limited set of data, and does not have a suitable means for assessing error. In this work, we use the recently published dataset of Homer et al. [1] to assess the performance of LM over the full range of GB space, and to equip LM with a metric for error estimation. LM is used to generate energy estimates, along with predictions of facet morphology, for each of the 7,304 boundaries in the Homer dataset. In keeping with prior work, it is observed that LM predictions of low energy boundaries matches well with MD results. Moreover, there is a good general agreement between LM and MD, and it is apparent that the error scales approximately linearly with the predicted energy value; this makes it possible to establish an empirical estimate on error for future LM calculations. An essential part of the LM method is the faceting relaxation, which corrects the expected energy by convexification across the compact space (S2) of boundary plane orientations. The original Homer dataset did not allow for faceting, but upon extended annealing, it was shown that facet patterns similar to those predicted by LM were emerging.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Relative Grain Boundary Energies from Triple Junction Geometry: Limitations to Assuming the Herring Condition in Nanocrystalline Thin Films
Authors:
Matthew J. Patrick,
Gregory S. Rohrer,
Ooraphan Chirayutthanasak,
Sutach Ratanaphan,
Eric R. Homer,
Gus L. W. Hart,
Yekaterina Epshteyn,
Katayun Barmak
Abstract:
Grain boundary character distributions (GBCD) are routinely measured from bulk microcrystalline samples by electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) and serial sectioning can be used to reconstruct relative grain boundary energy distributions (GBED) based on the 3D geometry of triple lines, assuming that the Herring condition of force balance is satisfied. These GBEDs correlate to those predicted fr…
▽ More
Grain boundary character distributions (GBCD) are routinely measured from bulk microcrystalline samples by electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) and serial sectioning can be used to reconstruct relative grain boundary energy distributions (GBED) based on the 3D geometry of triple lines, assuming that the Herring condition of force balance is satisfied. These GBEDs correlate to those predicted from molecular dynamics (MD); furthermore, the GBCD and GBED are found to be inversely correlated. For nanocrystalline thin films, orientation mapping via precession enhanced electron diffraction (PED) has proven effective in measuring the GBCD, but the GBED has not been extracted. Here, the established relative energy extraction technique is adapted to PED data from four sputter deposited samples: a 40 nm-thick tungsten film and a 100 nm aluminum film as-deposited, after 30 and after 150 minutes annealing at 400°C. These films have columnar grain structures, so serial sectioning is not required to determine boundary inclination. Excepting the most energetically anisotropic and highest population boundaries, i.e. aluminum Σ3 boundaries, the relative GBED extracted from these data do not correlate with energies calculated using MD nor do they inversely correlate with the experimentally determined GBCD for either the tungsten or aluminum films. Failure to reproduce predicted energetic trends implies that the conventional Herring equation cannot be applied to determine relative GBEDs and thus geometries at triple junctions in these films are not well described by this condition; additional geometric factors must contribute to determining triple junction geometry and boundary network structure in spatially constrained, polycrystalline materials.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2022; v1 submitted 5 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Examination of computed aluminum grain boundary structures and interface energies that span the 5D space of crystallographic character
Authors:
Eric R. Homer,
Gus L. W. Hart,
C. Braxton Owens,
Derek Hensley,
Jay Spendlove,
Lydia Harris Serafin
Abstract:
The space of possible grain boundary structures is vast, with 5 macroscopic, crystallographic degrees of freedom that define the character of a grain boundary. While numerous datasets of grain boundaries have examined this space in part or in full, we present a computed dataset of over 7304 unique aluminum grain boundaries in the 5D crystallographic space. Our sampling also includes a range of pos…
▽ More
The space of possible grain boundary structures is vast, with 5 macroscopic, crystallographic degrees of freedom that define the character of a grain boundary. While numerous datasets of grain boundaries have examined this space in part or in full, we present a computed dataset of over 7304 unique aluminum grain boundaries in the 5D crystallographic space. Our sampling also includes a range of possible microscopic, atomic configurations for each unique 5D crystallographic structure, which total over 43 million structures. We present an overview of the methods used to generate this dataset, an initial examination of the energy trends that follow the Read-Shockley relationship, hints at trends throughout the 5D space, variations in GB energy when non-minimum energy structures are examined, and insights gained in machine learning of grain boundary energy structure-property relationships. This dataset, which is available for download, has great potential for insight into GB structure-property relationships.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Five Degree-of-Freedom Property Interpolation of Arbitrary Grain Boundaries via Voronoi Fundamental Zone Octonion Framework
Authors:
Sterling G. Baird,
Eric R. Homer,
David T. Fullwood,
Oliver K. Johnson
Abstract:
We introduce the Voronoi fundamental zone octonion interpolation framework for grain boundary (GB) structure-property models and surrogates. The VFZO framework offers an advantage over other five degree-of-freedom based property interpolation methods because it is constructed as a point set in a manifold. This means that directly computed Euclidean distances approximate the original octonion dista…
▽ More
We introduce the Voronoi fundamental zone octonion interpolation framework for grain boundary (GB) structure-property models and surrogates. The VFZO framework offers an advantage over other five degree-of-freedom based property interpolation methods because it is constructed as a point set in a manifold. This means that directly computed Euclidean distances approximate the original octonion distance with significantly reduced computation runtime (~7 CPU minutes vs. 153 CPU days for a 50000x50000 pairwise-distance matrix). This increased efficiency facilitates lower interpolation error through the use of significantly more input data. We demonstrate grain boundary energy interpolation results for a non-smooth validation function and simulated bi-crystal datasets for Fe and Ni using four interpolation methods: barycentric interpolation, Gaussian process regression (GPR), inverse-distance weighting, and nearest-neighbor interpolation. These are evaluated for 50000 random input GBs and 10 000 random prediction GBs. The best performance was achieved with GPR, which resulted in a reduction of the root mean square error (RMSE) by 83.0% relative to RMSE of a constant, average model. Likewise, interpolation on a large, noisy, molecular statics Fe simulation dataset improves performance by 34.4% compared to 21.2% in prior work. Interpolation on a small, low-noise MS Ni simulation dataset is similar to interpolation results for the original octonion metric (57.6% vs. 56.4%). A vectorized, parallelized, MATLAB interpolation function (interp5DOF.m) and related routines are available in our VFZO repository (github.com/sgbaird-5dof/interp) which can be applied to other crystallographic point groups. The VFZO framework offers advantages for computing distances between GBs, estimating property values for arbitrary GBs, and modeling surrogates of computationally expensive 5DOF functions and simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Atomistic survey of grain boundary dislocation interactions in FCC Nickel
Authors:
Devin W Adams,
David T Fullwood,
Robert H Wagoner,
Eric R Homer
Abstract:
It is well known that grain boundaries (GBs) have a strong influence on mechanical properties of polycrystalline materials. Not as well-known is how different GBs interact with dislocations to influence dislocation movement. This work presents a molecular dynamics study of 33 different FCC Ni bicrystals, each subjected to four different strain states to induce incident dislocation-GB interactions…
▽ More
It is well known that grain boundaries (GBs) have a strong influence on mechanical properties of polycrystalline materials. Not as well-known is how different GBs interact with dislocations to influence dislocation movement. This work presents a molecular dynamics study of 33 different FCC Ni bicrystals, each subjected to four different strain states to induce incident dislocation-GB interactions for 132 unique configurations. The resulting simulations are analyzed to determine properties of the interaction that affect the likelihood of transmission of the dislocation through the GB in an effort to better inform mesoscale models of dislocation movement within polycrystals. It is found that the ability to predict the slip system of a transmitted dislocation using common geometric criteria is confirmed. Furthermore, machine learning processes are implemented revealing that geometric properties, such as the minimum potential residual Burgers vector (RBV) and the disorientation between the two grains, are stronger indicators of whether or not a dislocation would transmit than other properties, such as the resolved shear stress.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Structural Characterization of Grain Boundaries and Machine Learning of Grain Boundary Energy and Mobility
Authors:
Conrad W. Rosenbrock,
Jonathan L. Priedeman,
Gus L. W. Hart,
Eric R. Homer
Abstract:
Recent advances in the numerical representation of materials opened the way for successful machine learning of grain boundary (GB) energies and the classification of GB mobility and shear coupling. Two representations were needed for these machine learning applications: 1) the ASR representation, based on averaged local environment descriptors; and 2) the LER descriptor, based on fractions of glob…
▽ More
Recent advances in the numerical representation of materials opened the way for successful machine learning of grain boundary (GB) energies and the classification of GB mobility and shear coupling. Two representations were needed for these machine learning applications: 1) the ASR representation, based on averaged local environment descriptors; and 2) the LER descriptor, based on fractions of globally unique local environments within the entire GB system. We present a detailed tutorial on how to construct these two representations to learn energy, mobility and shear coupling. Additionally, we catalog some of the null results encountered along the way.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Discovering the Building Blocks of Atomic Systems using Machine Learning
Authors:
Conrad W. Rosenbrock,
Eric R. Homer,
Gábor Csányi,
Gus L. W. Hart
Abstract:
Machine learning has proven to be a valuable tool to approximate functions in high-dimensional spaces. Unfortunately, analysis of these models to extract the relevant physics is never as easy as applying machine learning to a large dataset in the first place. Here we present a description of atomic systems that generates machine learning representations with a direct path to physical interpretatio…
▽ More
Machine learning has proven to be a valuable tool to approximate functions in high-dimensional spaces. Unfortunately, analysis of these models to extract the relevant physics is never as easy as applying machine learning to a large dataset in the first place. Here we present a description of atomic systems that generates machine learning representations with a direct path to physical interpretation. As an example, we demonstrate its usefulness as a universal descriptor of grain boundary systems. Grain boundaries in crystalline materials are a quintessential example of a complex, high-dimensional system with broad impact on many physical properties including strength, ductility, corrosion resistance, crack resistance, and conductivity. In addition to modeling such properties, the method also provides insight into the physical "building blocks" that influence them. This opens the way to discover the underlying physics behind behaviors by understanding which building blocks map to particular properties. Once the structures are understood, they can then be optimized for desirable behaviors.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
