-
Interplay of edge fracture and shear banding in complex fluids
Authors:
Ewan J. Hemingway,
Suzanne M. Fielding
Abstract:
We explore theoretically the interplay between shear banding and edge fracture in complex fluids, by performing a detailed simulation study within two constitutive models: the Johnson-Segalman model and the Giesekus model. We consider separately parameter regimes in which the underlying constitutive curve is monotonic and non-monotonic, such that the bulk flow (in the absence of any edge effects)…
▽ More
We explore theoretically the interplay between shear banding and edge fracture in complex fluids, by performing a detailed simulation study within two constitutive models: the Johnson-Segalman model and the Giesekus model. We consider separately parameter regimes in which the underlying constitutive curve is monotonic and non-monotonic, such that the bulk flow (in the absence of any edge effects) is respectively homogeneous and shear banded. Phase diagrams of the levels of edge disturbance and of bulk (or quasi-bulk) shear banding are mapped as a function of the surface tension of the fluid-air interface, the wetting angle where this interface meets the walls of the flow cell, and the imposed shear rate. In particular, we explore in more detail the basic result recently announced in Hemingway et al. (2018): that precursors to edge fracture can induce quasi-bulk shear banding. We also appraise analytical predictions that shear banding can induce edge fracture, Skorski and Olmsted (2011). Although a study of remarkable early insight, that study made some strong assumptions about the nature of the "base state", which we examine using direct numerical simulation. The basic prediction that shear banding can cause edge fracture remains valid, but with qualitatively modified phase boundaries.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2020; v1 submitted 19 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Edge fracture instability in sheared complex fluids: onset criterion and possible mitigation strategy
Authors:
Ewan J. Hemingway,
Suzanne M. Fielding
Abstract:
We perform a detailed theoretical study of the edge fracture instability, which commonly destabilises the fluid-air interface during strong shear flows of entangled polymeric fluids, leading to unreliable rheological measurements. By means of direct nonlinear simulations, we map out phase diagrams showing the degree of edge fracture in the plane of the surface tension of the fluid-air interface an…
▽ More
We perform a detailed theoretical study of the edge fracture instability, which commonly destabilises the fluid-air interface during strong shear flows of entangled polymeric fluids, leading to unreliable rheological measurements. By means of direct nonlinear simulations, we map out phase diagrams showing the degree of edge fracture in the plane of the surface tension of the fluid-air interface and the imposed shear rate, within the Giesekus and Johnson-Segalman models, for different values of the nonlinear constitutive parameters that determine the dependencies on shear rate of the shear and normal stresses. The threshold for the onset of edge fracture is shown to be relatively robust against variations in the wetting angle where the fluid-air interface meets the hard walls of the flow cell, whereas the nonlinear dynamics depend strongly on wetting angle. We perform a linear stability calculation to derive an exact analytical expression for the onset of edge fracture, expressed in terms of the shear-rate derivative of the second normal stress difference, the shear-rate derivative of the shear stress (sometimes called the tangent viscosity), the jump in shear stress across the interface between the fluid and the outside air, the surface tension of that interface, and the rheometer gap size. Full agreement between our analytical calculation and nonlinear simulations is demonstrated. We also elucidate in detail the mechanism of edge fracture, and finally suggest a new way in which it might be mitigated in experimental practice. Some of the results in this paper were first announced in an earlier letter. The present manuscript provides additional simulation results, calculational details of the linear stability analysis, and more detailed discussion of the significance and limitations of our findings.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2019; v1 submitted 5 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Linear instability of shear thinning pressure driven channel flow
Authors:
Hugh J. Barlow,
Ewan J. Hemingway,
Andrew Clarke,
Suzanne M. Fielding
Abstract:
We study theoretically pressure driven planar channel flow of shear thinning viscoelastic fluids. Combining linear stability analysis and full nonlinear simulation, we study the instability of an initially one-dimensional base state to the growth of two-dimensional perturbations with wavevector in the flow direction. We do so within three widely used constitutive models: the microscopically motiva…
▽ More
We study theoretically pressure driven planar channel flow of shear thinning viscoelastic fluids. Combining linear stability analysis and full nonlinear simulation, we study the instability of an initially one-dimensional base state to the growth of two-dimensional perturbations with wavevector in the flow direction. We do so within three widely used constitutive models: the microscopically motivated Rolie-Poly model, and the phenomenological Johnson-Segalman and White-Metzner models. In each model, we find instability when the degree of shear thinning exceeds some level characterised by the logarithmic slope of the flow curve at its shallowest point. Specifically, we find instability for $n<n^*$, with $n^*\approx 0.21, 0.11$ and $0.30$ in the Rolie-Poly, Johnson-Segalman and White-Metzner models respectively. Within each model, we show that the critical pressure drop for the onset of instability obeys a criterion expressed in terms of this degree of shear thinning, $n$, together with the derivative of the first normal stress with respect to shear stress. Both shear thinning and rapid variations in first normal stress across the channel are therefore key ingredients driving the instability. In the Rolie-Poly and Johnson-Segalman models, the underlying mechanism appears to involve the destabilisation of a quasi-interface that exists in each half of the channel, across which the normal stress varies rapidly. In the White-Metzner model, no such quasi-interface exists, but the criterion for instability nonetheless appears to follow the same form as in the Rolie-Poly and Johnson-Segalman models. This presents an outstanding puzzle concerning any possibly generic nature of the instability mechanism. We finally make some briefly comments on the Giesekus model, which is rather different in its predictions from the other three.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2019; v1 submitted 5 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Edge-induced shear banding in entangled polymeric fluids
Authors:
Ewan J. Hemingway,
Suzanne M. Fielding
Abstract:
Despite decades of research, the question of whether solutions and melts of highly entangled polymers exhibit shear banding as their steady state response to a steadily imposed shear flow remains controversial. From a theoretical viewpoint, an important unanswered question is whether the underlying constitutive curve of shear stress $σ$ as a function of shear rate $\dotγ$ (for states of homogeneou…
▽ More
Despite decades of research, the question of whether solutions and melts of highly entangled polymers exhibit shear banding as their steady state response to a steadily imposed shear flow remains controversial. From a theoretical viewpoint, an important unanswered question is whether the underlying constitutive curve of shear stress $σ$ as a function of shear rate $\dotγ$ (for states of homogeneous shear) is monotonic, or has a region of negative slope, $dσ/d\dotγ<0$, which would trigger banding. Attempts to settle the question experimentally via velocimetry of the flow field inside the fluid are often confounded by an instability of the free surface where the sample meets the outside air, known as "edge fracture". Here we show by numerical simulation that in fact even only very modest edge disturbances - which are the precursor of full edge fracture but might well, in themselves, go unnoticed experimentally - can cause strong secondary flows in the form of shear bands that invade deep into the fluid bulk. Crucially, this is true even when the underlying constitutive curve is monotonically increasing, precluding true bulk shear banding in the absence of edge effects.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2018; v1 submitted 26 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Edge fracture in complex fluids
Authors:
Ewan J. Hemingway,
Halim Kusumaatmaja,
Suzanne M. Fielding
Abstract:
We study theoretically the edge fracture instability in sheared complex fluids, by means of linear stability analysis and direct nonlinear simulations. We derive an exact analytical expression for the onset of edge fracture in terms of the shear-rate derivative of the fluid's second normal stress difference, the shear-rate derivative of the shear stress, the jump in shear stress across the interfa…
▽ More
We study theoretically the edge fracture instability in sheared complex fluids, by means of linear stability analysis and direct nonlinear simulations. We derive an exact analytical expression for the onset of edge fracture in terms of the shear-rate derivative of the fluid's second normal stress difference, the shear-rate derivative of the shear stress, the jump in shear stress across the interface between the fluid and the outside medium (usually air), the surface tension of that interface, and the rheometer gap size. We provide a full mechanistic understanding of the edge fracture instability, carefully validated against our simulations. These findings, which are robust with respect to choice of rheological constitutive model, also suggest a possible route to mitigating edge fracture, potentially allowing experimentalists to achieve and accurately measure stronger flows than hitherto.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2017; v1 submitted 15 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Thickening of viscoelastic flow in a model porous medium
Authors:
E. J. Hemingway,
A. Clarke,
J. R. A. Pearson,
S. M. Fielding
Abstract:
We study numerically two-dimensional creeping viscoelastic flow past a biperiodic square array of cylinders within the Oldroyd B, FENE-CR and FENE-P constitutive models of dilute polymer solutions. Our results capture the initial mild decrease then dramatic upturn ('thickening') seen experimentally in the drag coefficient as a function of increasing Weissenberg number. By systematically varying th…
▽ More
We study numerically two-dimensional creeping viscoelastic flow past a biperiodic square array of cylinders within the Oldroyd B, FENE-CR and FENE-P constitutive models of dilute polymer solutions. Our results capture the initial mild decrease then dramatic upturn ('thickening') seen experimentally in the drag coefficient as a function of increasing Weissenberg number. By systematically varying the porosity of the flow geometry, we demonstrate two qualitatively different mechanisms underpinning this thickening effect: one that operates in the highly porous case of widely spaced obstacles, and another for more densely packed obstacles, with a crossover between these two mechanisms at intermediate porosities. We also briefly consider 2D creeping viscoelastic flow past a linear array of cylinders confined to a channel, where we find that the flow is steady for all Weissenberg numbers explored.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2017; v1 submitted 16 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Correlation lengths in hydrodynamic models of active nematics
Authors:
E. J. Hemingway,
P. Mishra,
M. C. Marchetti,
S. M. Fielding
Abstract:
We examine the scaling with activity of the emergent length scales that control the nonequilibrium dynamics of an active nematic liquid crystal, using two popular hydrodynamic models that have been employed in previous studies. In both models we find that the chaotic spatio-temporal dynamics in the regime of fully developed active turbulence is controlled by a single active scale determined by the…
▽ More
We examine the scaling with activity of the emergent length scales that control the nonequilibrium dynamics of an active nematic liquid crystal, using two popular hydrodynamic models that have been employed in previous studies. In both models we find that the chaotic spatio-temporal dynamics in the regime of fully developed active turbulence is controlled by a single active scale determined by the balance of active and elastic stresses, regardless of whether the active stress is extensile or contractile in nature. The observed scaling of the kinetic energy and enstropy with activity is consistent with our single-length scale argument and simple dimensional analysis. Our results provide a unified understanding of apparent discrepancies in the previous literature and demonstrate that the essential physics is robust to the choice of model.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2016; v1 submitted 5 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Viscoelastic and elastomeric active matter: Linear instability and nonlinear dynamics
Authors:
E. J. Hemingway,
M. E. Cates,
S. M. Fielding
Abstract:
We consider a continuum model of active viscoelastic matter, whereby an active nematic liquid-crystal is coupled to a minimal model of polymer dynamics with a viscoelastic relaxation time $τ_C$. To explore the resulting interplay between active and polymeric dynamics, we first generalise a linear stability analysis (from earlier studies without polymer) to derive criteria for the onset of spontane…
▽ More
We consider a continuum model of active viscoelastic matter, whereby an active nematic liquid-crystal is coupled to a minimal model of polymer dynamics with a viscoelastic relaxation time $τ_C$. To explore the resulting interplay between active and polymeric dynamics, we first generalise a linear stability analysis (from earlier studies without polymer) to derive criteria for the onset of spontaneous heterogeneous flows (strain rate) and/or deformations (strain). We find two modes of instability. The first is a viscous mode, associated with strain rate perturbations. It dominates for relatively small values of $τ_C$ and is a simple generalisation of the instability known previously without polymer. The second is an elastomeric mode, associated with strain perturbations, which dominates at large $τ_C$ and persists even as $τ_C\to\infty$. We explore the novel dynamical states to which these instabilities lead by means of direct numerical simulations. These reveal oscillatory shear-banded states in 1D, and activity-driven turbulence in 2D even in the elastomeric limit $τ_C\to\infty$. Adding polymer can also have calming effects, increasing the net throughput of spontaneous flow along a channel in a new type of "drag-reduction". Finally the effect of including strong, antagonistic coupling between nematic and polymer is examined numerically, revealing a rich array of spontaneously flowing states.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2016; v1 submitted 14 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Moving contact line dynamics: from diffuse to sharp interfaces
Authors:
Halim Kusumaatmaja,
Ewan J. Hemingway,
Suzanne M. Fielding
Abstract:
We reconcile two scaling laws that have been proposed in the literature for the slip length associated with a moving contact line in diffuse interface models, by demonstrating each to apply in a different regime of the ratio of the microscopic interfacial width $l$ and the macroscopic diffusive length $l_D= (Mη)^{1/2}$, where $η$ is the fluid viscosity and $M$ the mobility governing intermolecular…
▽ More
We reconcile two scaling laws that have been proposed in the literature for the slip length associated with a moving contact line in diffuse interface models, by demonstrating each to apply in a different regime of the ratio of the microscopic interfacial width $l$ and the macroscopic diffusive length $l_D= (Mη)^{1/2}$, where $η$ is the fluid viscosity and $M$ the mobility governing intermolecular diffusion. For small $l_D/l$ we find a diffuse interface regime in which the slip length scales as $ξ\sim(l_Dl)^{1/2}$. For larger $l_D/l>1$ we find a sharp interface regime in which the slip length depends only on the diffusive length, $ξ\sim l_D \sim (Mη)^{1/2}$, and therefore only on the macroscopic variables $η$ and $M$, independent of the microscopic interfacial width $l$. We also give evidence that modifying the microscopic interfacial terms in the model's free energy functional appears to affect the value of the slip length only the diffuse interface regime, consistent with the slip length depending only on macroscopic variables in the sharp interface regime. Finally, we demonstrate the dependence of the dynamic contact angle on the capillary number to be in excellent agreement with the theoretical prediction of \cite{Cox1986}, provided we allow the slip length to be rescaled by a dimensionless prefactor. This prefactor appears to converge to unity in the sharp interface limit, but is smaller in the diffuse interface limit. The excellent agreement of results obtained using three independent numerical methods, across several decades of the relevant dimensionless variables, demonstrates our findings to be free of numerical artifacts.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2015; v1 submitted 31 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Active Viscoelastic Matter: from Bacterial Drag Reduction to Turbulent Solids
Authors:
E. J. Hemingway,
A. Maitra,
S. Banerjee,
M. C. Marchetti,
S. Ramaswamy,
S. M. Fielding,
M. E. Cates
Abstract:
A paradigm for internally driven matter is the active nematic liquid crystal, whereby the equations of a conventional nematic are supplemented by a minimal active stress that violates time reversal symmetry. In practice, active fluids may have not only liquid crystalline but also viscoelastic polymer degrees of freedom. Here we explore the resulting interplay by coupling an active nematic to a min…
▽ More
A paradigm for internally driven matter is the active nematic liquid crystal, whereby the equations of a conventional nematic are supplemented by a minimal active stress that violates time reversal symmetry. In practice, active fluids may have not only liquid crystalline but also viscoelastic polymer degrees of freedom. Here we explore the resulting interplay by coupling an active nematic to a minimal model of polymer rheology. We find that adding polymer can greatly increase the complexity of spontaneous flow, but can also have calming effects, thereby increasing the net throughput of spontaneous flow along a pipe (a 'drag-reduction' effect). Remarkably, active turbulence can also arise after switching on activity in a sufficiently soft elastomeric solid.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2015; v1 submitted 22 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
