-
Rotating quantum wave turbulence
Authors:
J. T. Mäkinen,
S. Autti,
P. J. Heikkinen,
J. J. Hosio,
R. Hänninen,
V. S. L'vov,
P. M. Walmsley,
V. V. Zavjalov,
V. B. Eltsov
Abstract:
Rotating turbulence is ubiquitous in nature. Previous works suggest that such turbulence could be described as an ensemble of interacting inertial waves across a wide range of length scales. For turbulence in macroscopic quantum condensates, the nature of the transition between the quasiclassical dynamics at large scales and the corresponding dynamics at small scales, where the quantization of vor…
▽ More
Rotating turbulence is ubiquitous in nature. Previous works suggest that such turbulence could be described as an ensemble of interacting inertial waves across a wide range of length scales. For turbulence in macroscopic quantum condensates, the nature of the transition between the quasiclassical dynamics at large scales and the corresponding dynamics at small scales, where the quantization of vorticity is essential, remains an outstanding unresolved question. Here we expand the paradigm of wave-driven turbulence to rotating quantum fluids where the spectrum of waves extends to microscopic scales as Kelvin waves on quantized vortices. We excite inertial waves at the largest scale by periodic modulation of the angular velocity and observe dissipation-independent transfer of energy to smaller scales and the eventual onset of the elusive Kelvin-wave cascade at the lowest temperatures. We further find that energy is pumped to the system through a boundary layer distinct from the classical Ekman layer and support our observations with numerical simulations. Our experiments demonstrate a new regime of turbulent motion in quantum fluids where the role of vortex reconnections can be neglected, thus stripping the transition between the classical and the quantum regimes of turbulence down to its bare bones.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
On the Transition from Potential Flow to Turbulence Around a Microsphere Oscillating in Superfluid ^4He
Authors:
Michael Niemetz,
Risto Hänninen,
Wilfried Schoepe
Abstract:
The flow of superfluid $^4$He around a translationally oscillating sphere, levitating without mechanical support, can either be laminar or turbulent, depending on the velocity amplitude. Below a critical velocity $v_c$ that scales as $ω^{1/2}$, and is temperature independent below 1 K, the flow is laminar (potential flow). Below 0.5 K the linear drag force is caused by ballistic phonon scattering…
▽ More
The flow of superfluid $^4$He around a translationally oscillating sphere, levitating without mechanical support, can either be laminar or turbulent, depending on the velocity amplitude. Below a critical velocity $v_c$ that scales as $ω^{1/2}$, and is temperature independent below 1 K, the flow is laminar (potential flow). Below 0.5 K the linear drag force is caused by ballistic phonon scattering that vanishes as T$^4$ until background damping, measured in the empty cell, becomes dominant for T $<$ 0.1 K. Increasing the velocity amplitude above $v_c$ leads to a transition from potential flow to turbulence, where the large turbulent drag force varies as $(v^2 - v_c^2)$. In a small velocity interval $Δv / v_c \le 3 \%$ above $v_c$, the flow is unstable below 0.5 K, switching intermittently between both patterns. From time series recorded at constant temperature and driving force, the lifetimes of both phases are analyzed statistically. We observe metastable states of potential flow which, after a mean lifetime of 25 minutes, ultimately break down due to vorticity created by natural background radioactivity. The lifetimes of the turbulent phases have an exponential distribution, and the mean increases exponentially with $Δv^2$. We investigate the frequency at which the vortex rings are shed from the sphere. Our results are compared with recent data of other authors on vortex shedding by moving a laser beam through a Bose-Einstein condensate. Finally, we show that our observed transition to turbulence belongs to the class of "supertransient chaos" where lifetimes of the turbulent states increase faster than exponentially. Peculiar results obtained in dilute $^3$He - $^4$He mixtures are presented in the Appendix.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2017; v1 submitted 20 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Helicity within the vortex filament model
Authors:
R. Hänninen,
N. Hietala,
H. Salman
Abstract:
Kinetic helicity is one of the invariants of the Euler equations that is associated with the topology of vortex lines within the fluid. In superfluids, the vorticity is concentrated along vortex filaments. In this setting, helicity would be expected to acquire its simplest form. However, the lack of a core structure for vortex filaments appears to result in a helicity that does not retain its key…
▽ More
Kinetic helicity is one of the invariants of the Euler equations that is associated with the topology of vortex lines within the fluid. In superfluids, the vorticity is concentrated along vortex filaments. In this setting, helicity would be expected to acquire its simplest form. However, the lack of a core structure for vortex filaments appears to result in a helicity that does not retain its key attribute as a quadratic invariant. By defining a spanwise vector to the vortex through the use of a Seifert framing, we are able to introduce twist and henceforth recover the key properties of helicity. We present several examples for calculating internal twist to illustrate why the centreline helicity alone will lead to ambiguous results if a twist contribution is not introduced. Our choice of the spanwise vector can be expressed in terms of the tangential component of velocity along the filament. Since the tangential velocity does not alter the configuration of the vortex at later times, we are able to recover a similar equation for the internal twist angle for classical vortex tubes. Our results allow us to explain how a quasi-classical limit of helicity emerges from helicity considerations for individual superfluid vortex filaments.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2016; v1 submitted 12 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Leapfrogging Kelvin waves
Authors:
N. Hietala,
R. Hänninen,
H. Salman,
C. F. Barenghi
Abstract:
Two vortex rings can form a localized configuration whereby they continually pass through one another in an alternating fashion. This phenomenon is called leapfrogging. Using parameters suitable for superfluid helium-4, we describe a recurrence phenomenon that is similar to leapfrogging, which occurs for two coaxial straight vortex filaments with the same Kelvin wave mode. For small-amplitude Kelv…
▽ More
Two vortex rings can form a localized configuration whereby they continually pass through one another in an alternating fashion. This phenomenon is called leapfrogging. Using parameters suitable for superfluid helium-4, we describe a recurrence phenomenon that is similar to leapfrogging, which occurs for two coaxial straight vortex filaments with the same Kelvin wave mode. For small-amplitude Kelvin waves we demonstrate that our full Biot-Savart simulations closely follow predictions obtained from a simpified model that provides an analytical approximation developed for nearly parallel vortices. Our results are also relevant to thin-cored helical vortices in classical fluids.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2016; v1 submitted 21 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Kelvin waves from vortex reconnection in superfluid helium at low temperatures
Authors:
R. Hänninen
Abstract:
We report on the analysis of the root mean square curvature as a function of the numerical resolution for a single reconnection of two quantized vortex rings in superfluid helium. We find a similar scaling relation as reported in the case of decaying thermal counterflow simulations by L. Kondaurova et al. There the scaling was related to the existence of a Kelvin-wave cascade which was suggested t…
▽ More
We report on the analysis of the root mean square curvature as a function of the numerical resolution for a single reconnection of two quantized vortex rings in superfluid helium. We find a similar scaling relation as reported in the case of decaying thermal counterflow simulations by L. Kondaurova et al. There the scaling was related to the existence of a Kelvin-wave cascade which was suggested to support the L'vov-Nazarenko spectrum. Here we provide an alternative explanation that does not involve the Kelvin-wave cascade but is due to the sharp cusp generated by a reconnection event in a situation where the maximum curvature is limited by the computational resolution. We also suggest a method for identifying the Kelvin spectrum based on the decay of the rms curvature by mutual friction. Our vortex filament simulation calculations show that the spectrum of Kelvin waves after the reconnection is not simply $n(k) \propto k^{-η}$ with constant $η$. At large scales the spectrum seems to be close to the Vinen prediction with $η$ = 3 but becomes steeper at smaller scales.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2015; v1 submitted 24 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Breakdown of Potential Flow to Turbulence around a Sphere Oscillating in Superfluid He-4 above the Critical Velocity
Authors:
W. Schoepe,
R. Hänninen,
M. Niemetz
Abstract:
The onset of turbulent flow around an oscillating sphere in superfluid $^4$He is known to occur at a critical velocity $v_c \sim \sqrt{κω}$ where $κ$ is the circulation quantum and $ω$ is the oscillation frequency. But it is also well known that initially in a first up-sweep of the oscillation amplitude, $v_c$ can be considerably exceeded before the transition occurs, thus leading to a strong hyst…
▽ More
The onset of turbulent flow around an oscillating sphere in superfluid $^4$He is known to occur at a critical velocity $v_c \sim \sqrt{κω}$ where $κ$ is the circulation quantum and $ω$ is the oscillation frequency. But it is also well known that initially in a first up-sweep of the oscillation amplitude, $v_c$ can be considerably exceeded before the transition occurs, thus leading to a strong hysteresis in the velocity sweeps. The velocity amplitude $v_c^*
> v_c$ where the transition finally occurs is related to the density $L_0$ of the remanent vortices in the superfluid. Moreover, at temperatures below ca. 0.5 K and in a small interval of velocity amplitudes between $v_c$ and a velocity that is about 2% larger, the flow pattern is found to be unstable, switching intermittently between potential flow and turbulence. From time series recorded at constant temperature and driving force the distribution of the excess velocities $Δv = v_c^* - v_c$ is obtained and from that the failure rate. Below 0.1 K we also can determine the distribution of the lifetimes of the phases of potential flow. Finally, the frequency dependence of these results is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Comment on "Reconnection of quantized vortex filaments and the Kolmogorov spectrum"
Authors:
R. Hänninen
Abstract:
In this Comment we would like to emphasize that in Phys. Rev. B 90, 104506 (2014) the calculated energy spectrum takes into account only the small interaction (cross) term and, additionally, this term is only calculated at the instant when the two vortices reconnect. The majority of the kinetic energy is contained in the self-energy term which has a characteristic spectrum of $1/k$. If this, and t…
▽ More
In this Comment we would like to emphasize that in Phys. Rev. B 90, 104506 (2014) the calculated energy spectrum takes into account only the small interaction (cross) term and, additionally, this term is only calculated at the instant when the two vortices reconnect. The majority of the kinetic energy is contained in the self-energy term which has a characteristic spectrum of $1/k$. If this, and the additional average over time, is taken into account the suggested Kolmogorov type $k^{-5/3}$ spectrum is likely not visible in the kinetic energy spectrum which contains both terms. Therefore, we find the suggestion misleading that the Kolmogorov spectrum in superfluids arises from the reconnection of vortices.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2015; v1 submitted 1 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Quantum turbulence in superfluids with wall-clamped normal component
Authors:
Vladimir Eltsov,
Risto Hänninen,
Matti Krusius
Abstract:
In Fermi superfluids, like superfluid 3He, the viscous normal component can be considered to be stationary with respect to the container. The normal component interacts with the superfluid component via mutual friction which damps the motion of quantized vortex lines and eventually couples the superfluid component to the container. With decreasing temperature and mutual friction the internal dynam…
▽ More
In Fermi superfluids, like superfluid 3He, the viscous normal component can be considered to be stationary with respect to the container. The normal component interacts with the superfluid component via mutual friction which damps the motion of quantized vortex lines and eventually couples the superfluid component to the container. With decreasing temperature and mutual friction the internal dynamics of the superfluid component becomes more important compared to the damping and coupling effects from the normal component. This causes profound changes in superfluid dynamics: the temperature-dependent transition from laminar to turbulent vortex motion and the decoupling from the reference frame of the container at even lower temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Comment on "Motion of a helical vortex filament in superfluid 4He under the extrinsic form of the local induction approximation"
Authors:
Niklas Hietala,
Risto Hänninen
Abstract:
We comment on the paper by Van Gorder ["Motion of a helical vortex filament in superfluid ${}^4$He under the extrinsic form of the local induction approximation", Phys. Fluids 25, 085101 (2013)]. We point out that the flow of the normal fluid component parallel to the vortex will often lead into the Donnelly-Glaberson instability, which will cause the amplification of the Kelvin wave. We explain w…
▽ More
We comment on the paper by Van Gorder ["Motion of a helical vortex filament in superfluid ${}^4$He under the extrinsic form of the local induction approximation", Phys. Fluids 25, 085101 (2013)]. We point out that the flow of the normal fluid component parallel to the vortex will often lead into the Donnelly-Glaberson instability, which will cause the amplification of the Kelvin wave. We explain why the comparison to local nonlinear equation is unreasonable, and remark that neglecting the motion in the $x$-direction is not reasonable for a Kelvin wave with an arbitrary wave length and amplitude. The correct equations in the general case are also derived.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Vortex filament method as a tool for computational visualization of quantum turbulence
Authors:
Risto Hänninen,
Andrew W. Baggaley
Abstract:
Vortex filament model has become a standard and powerful tool to visualize the motion of quantized vortices in helium superfluids. In this article, we present an overview of the method and highlight its impact in aiding our understanding of quantum turbulence, particularly superfluid helium. We present an analysis of the structure and arrangement of quantized vortices. Our results are in agreement…
▽ More
Vortex filament model has become a standard and powerful tool to visualize the motion of quantized vortices in helium superfluids. In this article, we present an overview of the method and highlight its impact in aiding our understanding of quantum turbulence, particularly superfluid helium. We present an analysis of the structure and arrangement of quantized vortices. Our results are in agreement with previous studies showing that under certain conditions, vortices form coherent bundles, which allows for classical vortex stretching, giving quantum turbulence a classical nature. We also offer an explanation for differences between the observed properties of counterflow and pure superflow turbulence in a pipe. Finally, we suggest a mechanism for the generation of coherent structures in the presence of normal fluid shear.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2014; v1 submitted 13 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Dissipation enhancement from a single vortex reconnection in superfluid helium
Authors:
R. Hänninen
Abstract:
We investigate a single vortex reconnection event in superfluid helium at finite temperatures using the vortex filament model. The reconnection induces Kelvin waves which strongly increase energy dissipation. We evaluate the mutual friction dissipation from the reconnection and show that the dissipation power has universal form, which is seen by scaling both time (measured from the reconnection ev…
▽ More
We investigate a single vortex reconnection event in superfluid helium at finite temperatures using the vortex filament model. The reconnection induces Kelvin waves which strongly increase energy dissipation. We evaluate the mutual friction dissipation from the reconnection and show that the dissipation power has universal form, which is seen by scaling both time (measured from the reconnection event) and power by the mutual friction parameter alpha. This observation allows us to conclude that the Kelvin-wave cascade is not important in the energy dissipation process within the range alpha > 0.001. Rather, the energy is directly transferred from Kelvin waves to the normal component. Moreover, while the excited Kelvin waves greatly enhance energy dissipation, no similar change is seen in angular momentum from the reconnection event. This result has similarities with recent 3He-B measurements. Our results also confirm another earlier observation that the minimum distance between vortices scales approximately as d ~ sqrt(|t-trec|), both before and after the reconnection event.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2013; v1 submitted 27 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
Identification of Kelvin waves: numerical challenges
Authors:
R. Hänninen,
N. Hietala
Abstract:
Kelvin waves are expected to play an essential role in the energy dissipation for quantized vortices. However, the identification of these helical distortions is not straightforward, especially in case of vortex tangle. Here we review several numerical methods that have been used to identify Kelvin waves within the vortex filament model. We test their validity using several examples and estimate…
▽ More
Kelvin waves are expected to play an essential role in the energy dissipation for quantized vortices. However, the identification of these helical distortions is not straightforward, especially in case of vortex tangle. Here we review several numerical methods that have been used to identify Kelvin waves within the vortex filament model. We test their validity using several examples and estimate whether these methods are accurate enough to verify the correct Kelvin spectrum. We also illustrate how the correlation dimension is related to different Kelvin spectra and remind that the 3D energy spectrum E(k) takes the form 1/k in the high-k region, even in the presence of Kelvin waves.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2012; v1 submitted 27 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Energy and angular momentum balance in wall-bounded superfluid turbulence
Authors:
J. J. Hosio,
V. B. Eltsov,
P. J. Heikkinen,
R. Hänninen,
M. Krusius,
V. S. L'vov
Abstract:
A superfluid in the absence of the viscous normal component should be the best realization of an ideal inviscid Euler fluid. As expressed by d'Alembert's famous paradox, an ideal fluid does not exert drag on bodies past which it flows, or in other words, it does not exchange momentum with them. Also, the flow of an ideal fluid does not dissipate kinetic energy. We study experimentally whether thes…
▽ More
A superfluid in the absence of the viscous normal component should be the best realization of an ideal inviscid Euler fluid. As expressed by d'Alembert's famous paradox, an ideal fluid does not exert drag on bodies past which it flows, or in other words, it does not exchange momentum with them. Also, the flow of an ideal fluid does not dissipate kinetic energy. We study experimentally whether these properties apply to the flow of superfluid 3He-B in a rotating cylinder at low temperatures. It is found that ideal behavior is broken by quantum turbulence, which leads to substantial energy dissipation, as observed also earlier. Here we show that remarkably, nearly ideal behavior is preserved with respect to the angular-momentum exchange between the superfluid and its container, i.e., the drag almost disappears in the zero-temperature limit. This mismatch between energy and angular-momentum transfer results in a new physical situation where the proper description of wall-bounded quantum turbulence requires two effective friction parameters, one for energy dissipation and another for momentum coupling, which become substantially different at very low temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2013; v1 submitted 13 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Asymptotic motion of a single vortex in a rotating cylinder
Authors:
J. M. Karimäki,
R. Hänninen,
E. V. Thuneberg
Abstract:
We study numerically the behavior of a single quantized vortex in a rotating cylinder. We study in particular the spiraling motion of a vortex in a cylinder that is parallel to the rotation axis. We determine the asymptotic form of the vortex and its axial and azimuthal propagation velocities under a wide range of parameters. We also study the stability of the vortex line and the effect of tilting…
▽ More
We study numerically the behavior of a single quantized vortex in a rotating cylinder. We study in particular the spiraling motion of a vortex in a cylinder that is parallel to the rotation axis. We determine the asymptotic form of the vortex and its axial and azimuthal propagation velocities under a wide range of parameters. We also study the stability of the vortex line and the effect of tilting the cylinder from the rotation axis.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2013; v1 submitted 30 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Turbulent Vortex Flow Responses at the AB Interface in Rotating Superfluid 3He-B
Authors:
P. M. Walmsley,
V. B. Eltsov,
P. J. Heikkinen,
J. J. Hosio,
R. Hanninen,
M. Krusius
Abstract:
In a rotating two-phase sample of 3He-B and magnetic-field stabilized 3He-A the large difference in mutual friction dissipation at 0.20 Tc gives rise to unusual vortex flow responses. We use noninvasive NMR techniques to monitor spin down and spin up of the B-phase superfluid component to a sudden change in the rotation velocity. Compared to measurements at low field with no A-phase, where these r…
▽ More
In a rotating two-phase sample of 3He-B and magnetic-field stabilized 3He-A the large difference in mutual friction dissipation at 0.20 Tc gives rise to unusual vortex flow responses. We use noninvasive NMR techniques to monitor spin down and spin up of the B-phase superfluid component to a sudden change in the rotation velocity. Compared to measurements at low field with no A-phase, where these responses are laminar in cylindrically symmetric flow, spin down with vortices extending across the AB interface is found to be faster, indicating enhanced dissipation from turbulence. Spin up in turn is slower, owing to rapid annihilation of remanent vortices before the rotation increase. As confirmed by both our NMR signal analysis and vortex filament calculations, these observations are explained by the additional force acting on the B-phase vortex ends at the AB interface.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Steady-state spectrum of Kelvin waves on a quantized vortex at finite temperatures
Authors:
R. Hänninen
Abstract:
We determine numerically the steady-state spectrum for Kelvin waves on a superfluid 4He vortex that is driven by shaking its end points and damped by mutual friction. The relaxation rate towards a steady state is determined by the mutual friction. We have reached the zero temperature limit where the steady-state spectrum and the vortex length become independent of the temperature. Our drive with p…
▽ More
We determine numerically the steady-state spectrum for Kelvin waves on a superfluid 4He vortex that is driven by shaking its end points and damped by mutual friction. The relaxation rate towards a steady state is determined by the mutual friction. We have reached the zero temperature limit where the steady-state spectrum and the vortex length become independent of the temperature. Our drive with pointlike pinning sites produces a characteristic spectrum with $|w_m|\propto m^{-η}$, where $η\approx$ 1.88. The spatially sharply peaked drive and the fact that we are fixing the oscillation amplitude, not the power, causes that there exists no high k cutoff from mutual friction even when mutual friction is large. This spectrum is generic to the pinned boundary conditions used. Without pinning the spectrum is sensitive to the drive. The spectrum even depends on the amplitude of the initial spectrum if vortex is allowed to relax on its own. Therefore, in real systems the Kelvin spectrum is not unique and depends on external conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2012; v1 submitted 26 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Dynamical scaling of the critical velocity for the onset of turbulence in oscillatory superflows
Authors:
R. Hänninen,
W. Schoepe
Abstract:
The critical velocity v_c for the onset of turbulence in oscillatory flows of superfluid helium is known to depend on the oscillation frequency omega, namely v_c ~ sqrt(kappa*omega) where kappa is the circulation quantum. Only the numerical prefactor may have some geometry dependence. This universal behaviour was described earlier qualitatively either by employing the superfluid Reynolds number or…
▽ More
The critical velocity v_c for the onset of turbulence in oscillatory flows of superfluid helium is known to depend on the oscillation frequency omega, namely v_c ~ sqrt(kappa*omega) where kappa is the circulation quantum. Only the numerical prefactor may have some geometry dependence. This universal behaviour was described earlier qualitatively either by employing the superfluid Reynolds number or by extending known dc vortex dynamics to ac flow. In our present work we emphasize that v_c(omega) ~ sqrt(omega) can also be derived rigorously by means of dynamical scaling of equations of vortex dynamics as pointed out by Kotsubo and Swift already two decades ago.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Superfluid vortex front at T -> 0: Decoupling from the reference frame
Authors:
J. J. Hosio,
V. B. Eltsov,
R. de Graaf,
P. J. Heikkinen,
R. Hanninen,
M. Krusius,
V. S. L'vov,
G. E. Volovik
Abstract:
Steady-state turbulent motion is created in superfluid 3He-B at low temperatures in the form of a turbulent vortex front, which moves axially along a rotating cylindrical container of 3He-B and replaces vortex-free flow with vortex lines at constant density. We present the first measurements on the thermal signal from dissipation as a function of time, recorded at 0.2 Tc during the front motion, w…
▽ More
Steady-state turbulent motion is created in superfluid 3He-B at low temperatures in the form of a turbulent vortex front, which moves axially along a rotating cylindrical container of 3He-B and replaces vortex-free flow with vortex lines at constant density. We present the first measurements on the thermal signal from dissipation as a function of time, recorded at 0.2 Tc during the front motion, which is monitored using NMR techniques. Both the measurements and the numerical calculations of the vortex dynamics show that at low temperatures the density of the propagating vortices falls well below the equilibrium value, i.e. the superfluid rotates at a smaller angular velocity than the container. This is the first evidence for the decoupling of the superfluid from the container reference frame in the zero-temperature limit.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2011; v1 submitted 21 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Super Stability of Laminar Vortex Flow in Superfluid 3He-B
Authors:
V. B. Eltsov,
R. de Graaf,
P. J. Heikkinen,
J. J. Hosio,
R. Hanninen,
M. Krusius,
V. S. L'vov
Abstract:
Vortex flow remains laminar up to large Reynolds numbers (Re~1000) in a cylinder filled with 3He-B. This is inferred from NMR measurements and numerical vortex filament calculations where we study the spin up and spin down responses of the superfluid component, after a sudden change in rotation velocity. In normal fluids and in superfluid 4He these responses are turbulent. In 3He-B the vortex core…
▽ More
Vortex flow remains laminar up to large Reynolds numbers (Re~1000) in a cylinder filled with 3He-B. This is inferred from NMR measurements and numerical vortex filament calculations where we study the spin up and spin down responses of the superfluid component, after a sudden change in rotation velocity. In normal fluids and in superfluid 4He these responses are turbulent. In 3He-B the vortex core radius is much larger which reduces both surface pinning and vortex reconnections, the phenomena, which enhance vortex bending and the creation of turbulent tangles. Thus the origin for the greater stability of vortex flow in 3He-B is a quantum phenomenon. Only large flow perturbations are found to make the responses turbulent, such as the walls of a cubic container or the presence of invasive measuring probes inside the container.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
Universal onset of quantum turbulence in oscillating flows and crossover to steady flows
Authors:
R. Hänninen,
W. Schoepe
Abstract:
The critical velocity v_c for the onset of quantum turbulence in oscillatory flows of superfluid helium is universal and scales as v_c \sim \sqrt{κω}, where κis the circulation quantum and ωis the oscillation frequency. This result can be derived from a general argument based on the "superfluid Reynolds number". Only the numerical prefactor may depend somewhat on the geometry of the oscillating…
▽ More
The critical velocity v_c for the onset of quantum turbulence in oscillatory flows of superfluid helium is universal and scales as v_c \sim \sqrt{κω}, where κis the circulation quantum and ωis the oscillation frequency. This result can be derived from a general argument based on the "superfluid Reynolds number". Only the numerical prefactor may depend somewhat on the geometry of the oscillating object because the flow velocity at the surface of the object may differ from the velocity amplitude of the body. A more detailed analysis derived from the dynamics of the turbulent state gives v_c \approx \sqrt{8κω/β}, where β\sim 1 depends on the mutual friction parameters. This universality is compared with the recently discovered universality of classical oscillatory flows. We also discuss the effect of remanent vorticity on the onset of quantum turbulence. Finally, by employing the "superfluid Reynolds number" again, we argue how v_c changes when the steady case ω= 0 is approached. In that case v_c scales as κ/R, where R is the size of the object.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Rotating inclined cylinder and the effect of the tilt angle on vortices
Authors:
R. Hänninen
Abstract:
We study numerically some possible vortex configurations in a rotating cylinder that is tilted with respect to the rotation axis and where different numbers of vortices can be present at given rotation velocity. In a long cylinder at small tilt angles the vortices tend to align along the cylinder axis and not along the rotation axis. We also show that the axial flow along the cylinder axis, caus…
▽ More
We study numerically some possible vortex configurations in a rotating cylinder that is tilted with respect to the rotation axis and where different numbers of vortices can be present at given rotation velocity. In a long cylinder at small tilt angles the vortices tend to align along the cylinder axis and not along the rotation axis. We also show that the axial flow along the cylinder axis, caused by the tilt, will result in the Ostermeier-Glaberson instability above some critical tilt angle. When the vortices become unstable the final state often appears to be a dynamical steady state, which may contain turbulent regions where new vortices are constantly created. These new vortices push other vortices in regions with laminar flow towards the top and bottom ends of the cylinder where they finally annihilate. Experimentally the inclined cylinder could be a convenient environment to create long lasting turbulence with a polarization which can be adjusted with the tilt angle.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
Universal Critical Velocity for the Onset of Turbulence of Oscillatory Superfluid Flow
Authors:
R. Hänninen,
W. Schoepe
Abstract:
The critical velocity vc for the onset of turbulent drag of small spheres oscillating in superfluid 4He is frequency dependent (omega/2pi from 100 Hz to 700 Hz) and is described by vc = 2.6sqrt(kappa*omega), where kappa is the circulation quantum. A qualitative analysis based on a recent theory of the onset of superfluid turbulence gives vc = sqrt(8*kappa*omega/beta), where beta is of order 1 an…
▽ More
The critical velocity vc for the onset of turbulent drag of small spheres oscillating in superfluid 4He is frequency dependent (omega/2pi from 100 Hz to 700 Hz) and is described by vc = 2.6sqrt(kappa*omega), where kappa is the circulation quantum. A qualitative analysis based on a recent theory of the onset of superfluid turbulence gives vc = sqrt(8*kappa*omega/beta), where beta is of order 1 and depends on the coefficients of mutual friction. This agrees well with the data and implies that vc is a universal critical velocity that is independent of geometry, size, and surface properties of the oscillating body. This is confirmed by comparing our data on spheres with vc obtained with other oscillating structures by other groups. Numerical simulations indicate somewhat larger critical velocity, above which a rapid increase in vortex length is observed.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
Turbulent dynamics in rotating helium superfluids
Authors:
V. B. Eltsov,
R. de Graaf,
R. Hanninen,
M. Krusius,
R. E. Solntsev,
V. S. L'vov,
A. I. Golov,
P. M. Walmsley
Abstract:
New techniques, both for generating and detecting turbulence in the helium superfluids 3He-B and 4He, have recently given insight in how turbulence is started, what the dissipation mechanisms are, and how turbulence decays when it appears as a transient state or when externally applied turbulent pumping is switched off. Important simplifications are obtained by using 3He-B as working fluid, wher…
▽ More
New techniques, both for generating and detecting turbulence in the helium superfluids 3He-B and 4He, have recently given insight in how turbulence is started, what the dissipation mechanisms are, and how turbulence decays when it appears as a transient state or when externally applied turbulent pumping is switched off. Important simplifications are obtained by using 3He-B as working fluid, where the highly viscous normal component is practically always in a state of laminar flow, or by cooling 4He to low temperatures where the normal fraction becomes vanishingly small. We describe recent studies from the low temperature regime, where mutual friction becomes small or practically vanishes. This allows us to elucidate the mechanisms at work in quantum turbulence on approaching the zero temperature limit.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2008; v1 submitted 23 March, 2008;
originally announced March 2008.
-
Frequency Dependence of the Critical Velocity of a Sphere Oscillating in Superfluid Helium-4
Authors:
R. Hänninen,
W. Schoepe
Abstract:
It is shown that the critical velocity of a small sphere oscillating in superfluid helium increases with the square root of the oscillation frequency. This behavior can be described by a simple dimensional argument. The size of the sphere and the temperature of the superfluid are found to have no or only very little effect. Surface properties of the sphere and remanent vorticity may have an infl…
▽ More
It is shown that the critical velocity of a small sphere oscillating in superfluid helium increases with the square root of the oscillation frequency. This behavior can be described by a simple dimensional argument. The size of the sphere and the temperature of the superfluid are found to have no or only very little effect. Surface properties of the sphere and remanent vorticity may have an influence but have not been under systematic investigation in these measurements
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
The dynamics of vortex generation in superfluid 3He-B
Authors:
R. de Graaf,
R. Hanninen,
T. V. Chagovets,
V. B. Eltsov,
M. Krusius,
R. E. Solntsev
Abstract:
A profound change occurs in the stability of quantized vortices in externally applied flow of superfluid 3He-B at temperatures ~ 0.6 Tc, owing to the rapidly decreasing damping in vortex motion with decreasing temperature. At low damping an evolving vortex may become unstable and generate a new independent vortex loop. This single-vortex instability is the generic precursor to turbulence. We inv…
▽ More
A profound change occurs in the stability of quantized vortices in externally applied flow of superfluid 3He-B at temperatures ~ 0.6 Tc, owing to the rapidly decreasing damping in vortex motion with decreasing temperature. At low damping an evolving vortex may become unstable and generate a new independent vortex loop. This single-vortex instability is the generic precursor to turbulence. We investigate the instability with non-invasive NMR measurements on a rotating cylindrical sample in the intermediate temperature regime (0.3 - 0.6) Tc. From comparisons with numerical calculations we interpret that the instability occurs at the container wall, when the vortex end moves along the wall in applied flow.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2008; v1 submitted 22 August, 2007;
originally announced August 2007.
-
Experiments on the twisted vortex state in superfluid 3He-B
Authors:
V. B. Eltsov,
R. de Graaf,
R. Hanninen,
M. Krusius,
R. E. Solntsev
Abstract:
We have performed measurements and numerical simulations on a bundle of vortex lines which is expanding along a rotating column of initially vortex-free 3He-B. Expanding vortices form a propagating front: Within the front the superfluid is involved in rotation and behind the front the twisted vortex state forms, which eventually relaxes to the equilibrium vortex state. We have measured the magni…
▽ More
We have performed measurements and numerical simulations on a bundle of vortex lines which is expanding along a rotating column of initially vortex-free 3He-B. Expanding vortices form a propagating front: Within the front the superfluid is involved in rotation and behind the front the twisted vortex state forms, which eventually relaxes to the equilibrium vortex state. We have measured the magnitude of the twist and its relaxation rate as function of temperature above 0.3Tc. We also demonstrate that the integrity of the propagating vortex front results from axial superfluid flow, induced by the twist.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2007;
originally announced June 2007.
-
Precessing vortex motion and instability in a rotating column of superfluid 3He-B
Authors:
R. Hanninen,
V. B. Eltsov,
A. P. Finne,
R. de Graaf,
J. Kopu,
M. Krusius,
R. E. Solntsev
Abstract:
The flow of quantized vortex lines in superfluid 3He-B is laminar at high temperatures, but below 0.6 Tc turbulence becomes possible, owing to the rapidly decreasing mutual friction damping. In the turbulent regime a vortex evolving in applied flow may become unstable, create new vortices, and start turbulence. We monitor this single-vortex instability with NMR techniques in a rotating cylinder.…
▽ More
The flow of quantized vortex lines in superfluid 3He-B is laminar at high temperatures, but below 0.6 Tc turbulence becomes possible, owing to the rapidly decreasing mutual friction damping. In the turbulent regime a vortex evolving in applied flow may become unstable, create new vortices, and start turbulence. We monitor this single-vortex instability with NMR techniques in a rotating cylinder. Close to the onset temperature of turbulence, an oscillating component in NMR absorption has been observed, while the instability generates new vortices at a low rate ~ 1 vortex/s, before turbulence sets in. By comparison to numerical calculations, we associate the oscillations with spiral vortex motion, when evolving vortices expand to rectilinear lines.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2008; v1 submitted 26 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
The Generation of Turbulence by Oscillating Structures in Superfluid Helium at Very Low Temperatures
Authors:
R. Hänninen,
M. Tsubota,
W. F. Vinen
Abstract:
The paper is concerned with the interpretation of many experiments that have been reported recently on the production of quantum turbulence by oscillating spheres, wires and grids in both 4He and 3He-B at temperatures so low that there is a negligible fraction of normal fluid. The experimental results are compared with those obtained in analogous experiments with classical fluids and with prelim…
▽ More
The paper is concerned with the interpretation of many experiments that have been reported recently on the production of quantum turbulence by oscillating spheres, wires and grids in both 4He and 3He-B at temperatures so low that there is a negligible fraction of normal fluid. The experimental results are compared with those obtained in analogous experiments with classical fluids and with preliminary simulations of the quantum turbulence. Particular attention is paid to observed values of drag coefficients and to the very different critical velocities observed in 4He and 3He. It is tentatively concluded that in the case of 4He behaviour may well be similar to that observed in the classical analogues, with relatively small changes when the characteristic size of the oscillating structure is not large compared with the quantized vortex spacing, but that in the case of 3He behaviour is very different and due perhaps to very rapid intrinsic nucleation of the quantized vortices.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Dynamic Remanent Vortices in Superfluid 3He-B
Authors:
R. E. Solntsev,
R. de Graaf,
V. B. Eltsov,
R. Hanninen,
M. Krusius
Abstract:
We investigate the decay of vortices in a rotating cylindrical sample of 3He-B, after rotation has been stopped. With decreasing temperature vortex annihilation slows down as the damping in vortex motion, the mutual friction dissipation α(T), decreases almost exponentially. Remanent vortices then survive for increasingly long periods, while they move towards annihilation in zero applied flow. Af…
▽ More
We investigate the decay of vortices in a rotating cylindrical sample of 3He-B, after rotation has been stopped. With decreasing temperature vortex annihilation slows down as the damping in vortex motion, the mutual friction dissipation α(T), decreases almost exponentially. Remanent vortices then survive for increasingly long periods, while they move towards annihilation in zero applied flow. After a waiting period Δt at zero flow, rotation is reapplied and the remnants evolve to rectilinear vortices. By counting these lines, we measure at temperatures above the transition to turbulence ~0.6T_c the number of remnants as a function of α(T) and Δt. At temperatures below the transition to turbulence T \lesssim 0.55 T_c, remnants expanding in applied flow become unstable and generate in a turbulent burst the equilibrium number of vortices. Here we measure the onset temperature T_on of turbulence as a function of Δt, applied flow velocity, and length of sample L.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2006; v1 submitted 13 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
Dynamics of vortices and interfaces in superfluid 3He
Authors:
A. P. Finne,
V. B. Eltsov,
R. Hanninen,
N. B. Kopnin,
J. Kopu,
M. Krusius,
M. Tsubota,
G. E. Volovik
Abstract:
Rapid new developments have occurred in superfluid hydrodynamics since the discovery of a host of unusual phenomena which arise from the diverse structure and dynamics of quantized vortices in 3He superfluids. These have been studied in rotating flow with NMR measurements which at best provide an accurate mapping of the different types of topological defects in the superfluid order parameter fie…
▽ More
Rapid new developments have occurred in superfluid hydrodynamics since the discovery of a host of unusual phenomena which arise from the diverse structure and dynamics of quantized vortices in 3He superfluids. These have been studied in rotating flow with NMR measurements which at best provide an accurate mapping of the different types of topological defects in the superfluid order parameter field. Four observations are reviewed here: (1) the interplay of different vortex structures at the first order interface between the two major superfluid 3He phases, 3He-A and 3He-B; (2) the shear flow instability of this phase boundary, which is now known as the superfluid Kelvin-Helmholtz instability; (3) the hydrodynamic transition from turbulent to regular vortex dynamics as a function of increasing dissipation in vortex motion; and (4) the peculiar propagation of vortex lines in a long rotating column which even in the turbulent regime occurs in the form of a helically twisted vortex state behind a well-developed vortex front. The consequences and implications of these observations are discussed, as inferred from measurements, numerical calculations, and analytical work.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2006; v1 submitted 23 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
Anomalous translational velocity of vortex ring with finite-amplitude Kelvin waves
Authors:
C. F. Barenghi,
R. Hänninen,
M. Tsubota
Abstract:
We consider finite-amplitude Kelvin waves on an inviscid vortex assuming that the vortex core has infinitesimal thickness. By numerically solving the governing Biot-Savart equation of motion, we study how the frequency of the Kelvin waves and the velocity of the perturbed ring depend on the Kelvin wave amplitude. In particular, we show that, if the amplitude of the Kelvin waves is sufficiently l…
▽ More
We consider finite-amplitude Kelvin waves on an inviscid vortex assuming that the vortex core has infinitesimal thickness. By numerically solving the governing Biot-Savart equation of motion, we study how the frequency of the Kelvin waves and the velocity of the perturbed ring depend on the Kelvin wave amplitude. In particular, we show that, if the amplitude of the Kelvin waves is sufficiently large, the perturbed vortex ring moves backwards.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2006; v1 submitted 3 April, 2006;
originally announced April 2006.
-
Twisted vortex state
Authors:
V. B. Eltsov,
A. P. Finne,
R. Hanninen,
J. Kopu,
M. Krusius,
M. Tsubota,
E. V. Thuneberg
Abstract:
We study a twisted vortex bundle where quantized vortices form helices circling around the axis of the bundle in a "force-free" configuration. Such a state is created by injecting vortices into rotating vortex-free superfluid. Using continuum theory we determine the structure and the relaxation of the twisted state. This is confirmed by numerical calculations. We also present experimental eviden…
▽ More
We study a twisted vortex bundle where quantized vortices form helices circling around the axis of the bundle in a "force-free" configuration. Such a state is created by injecting vortices into rotating vortex-free superfluid. Using continuum theory we determine the structure and the relaxation of the twisted state. This is confirmed by numerical calculations. We also present experimental evidence of the twisted vortex state in superfluid 3He-B.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2006; v1 submitted 28 February, 2006;
originally announced February 2006.
-
Vortex Multiplication in Applied Flow: the Precursor to Superfluid Turbulence
Authors:
A. P. Finne,
V. B. Eltsov,
G. Eska,
R. Hanninen,
J. Kopu,
M. Krusius,
E. V. Thuneberg,
M. Tsubota
Abstract:
The dynamics of quantized vortices in rotating $^3$He-B is investigated in the low density (single-vortex) regime as a function of temperature. An abrupt transition is observed at $0.5 T_{\rm c}$. Above this temperature the number of vortex lines remains constant, as they evolve to their equilibrium positions. Below this temperature the number of vortices increases linearly in time until the vor…
▽ More
The dynamics of quantized vortices in rotating $^3$He-B is investigated in the low density (single-vortex) regime as a function of temperature. An abrupt transition is observed at $0.5 T_{\rm c}$. Above this temperature the number of vortex lines remains constant, as they evolve to their equilibrium positions. Below this temperature the number of vortices increases linearly in time until the vortex density has grown sufficiently for turbulence to switch on. On the basis of numerical calculations we suggest a mechanism responsible for vortex formation at low temperatures and identify the mutual friction parameter which governs its abrupt temperature dependence.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2005; v1 submitted 4 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
Structure of surface vortex sheet between two rotating 3He superfluids
Authors:
R. Hänninen,
R. Blaauwgeers,
V. B. Eltsov,
A. P. Finne,
M. Krusius,
E. V. Thuneberg,
G. E. Volovik
Abstract:
We study a two-phase sample of superfluid 3He where vorticity exists in one phase (3He-A) but cannot penetrate across the interfacial boundary to a second coherent phase (3He-B). We calculate the bending of the vorticity into a surface vortex sheet on the interface and solve the internal structure of this new type of vortex sheet. The compression of the vorticity from three to two dimensions enf…
▽ More
We study a two-phase sample of superfluid 3He where vorticity exists in one phase (3He-A) but cannot penetrate across the interfacial boundary to a second coherent phase (3He-B). We calculate the bending of the vorticity into a surface vortex sheet on the interface and solve the internal structure of this new type of vortex sheet. The compression of the vorticity from three to two dimensions enforces a structure which is made up of half-quantum units, independently of the structure of the source vorticity in the bulk. These results are consistent with our NMR measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2003;
originally announced March 2003.
-
Model of Inhomogeneous Impurity Distribution in Fermi Superfluids
Authors:
R. Hänninen,
E. V. Thuneberg
Abstract:
The standard treatment of impurities in metals assumes a homogeneous distribution of impurities. In this paper we study distributions that are inhomogeneous. We discuss in detail the "isotropic inhomogeneous scattering model" which takes into account the spatially varying scattering on the scale of the superfluid coherence length. On a large scale the model reduces to a homogeneous medium with r…
▽ More
The standard treatment of impurities in metals assumes a homogeneous distribution of impurities. In this paper we study distributions that are inhomogeneous. We discuss in detail the "isotropic inhomogeneous scattering model" which takes into account the spatially varying scattering on the scale of the superfluid coherence length. On a large scale the model reduces to a homogeneous medium with renormalized parameter values. We apply the model to superfluid 3He, where porous aerogel acts as the impurity. We calculate the transition temperature Tc, the order parameter, and the superfluid density. Both A- and B-like phases are considered. Two different types of behavior are identified for the temperature dependence of the order parameter. We compare the calculations with experiments on 3He in aerogel. We find that most of the differences between experiments and the homogeneous theory can be explained by the inhomogeneous model. All our calculations are based on the quasiclassical theory of Fermi liquids. The parameters of this theory for superfluid 3He in aerogel are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2003; v1 submitted 10 January, 2003;
originally announced January 2003.
-
Calculation of NMR Properties of Solitons in Superfluid 3He-A
Authors:
R. Hänninen,
E. V. Thuneberg
Abstract:
Superfluid 3He-A has domain-wall-like structures, which are called solitons. We calculate numerically the structure of a splay soliton. We study the effect of solitons on the nuclear-magnetic-resonance spectrum by calculating the frequency shifts and the amplitudes of the soliton peaks for both longitudinal and transverse oscillations of magnetization. The effect of dissipation caused by normal-…
▽ More
Superfluid 3He-A has domain-wall-like structures, which are called solitons. We calculate numerically the structure of a splay soliton. We study the effect of solitons on the nuclear-magnetic-resonance spectrum by calculating the frequency shifts and the amplitudes of the soliton peaks for both longitudinal and transverse oscillations of magnetization. The effect of dissipation caused by normal-superfluid conversion and spin diffusion is calculated. The calculations are in good agreement with experiments, except a problem in the transverse resonance frequency of the splay soliton or in magnetic-field dependence of reduced resonance frequencies.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2003; v1 submitted 2 March, 2001;
originally announced March 2001.
-
One-Dimensional Textures and Critical Velocity in Superfluid 3He-A
Authors:
J. Kopu,
R. Hänninen,
E. V. Thuneberg
Abstract:
We study theoretically the stability of flow in superfluid 3He-A. The calculations are done using a one-dimensional model where the order parameter depends only on the coordinate in the direction of the superfluid velocity v_s. We concentrate on the case that the external magnetic field H is perpendicular to v_s, where only few results are available analytically. We calculate the critical veloci…
▽ More
We study theoretically the stability of flow in superfluid 3He-A. The calculations are done using a one-dimensional model where the order parameter depends only on the coordinate in the direction of the superfluid velocity v_s. We concentrate on the case that the external magnetic field H is perpendicular to v_s, where only few results are available analytically. We calculate the critical velocity v_c at which the superflow becomes unstable against the formation of continuous vortices. The detailed dependence of v_c on the temperature and on the form of the underlying orbital texture l(r) is investigated. Both uniform and helical textures and two types of domain-wall structures are studied. The results are partially in agreement with experiments made in a rotating cylinder.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2000;
originally announced March 2000.
