-
Spinel nitride solid solutions: charting properties in the configurational space with explainable machine learning
Authors:
Pablo Sánchez-Palencia,
Said Hamad,
Pablo Palacios,
Ricardo Grau-Crespo,
Keith T. Butler
Abstract:
Ab initio prediction of the variation of properties in the configurational space of solid solutions is computationally very demanding. We present an approach to accelerate these predictions via a combination of density functional theory and machine learning, using the cubic spinel nitride GeSn$_2$N$_4$ as a case study, exploring how formation energy and electronic bandgap are affected by configura…
▽ More
Ab initio prediction of the variation of properties in the configurational space of solid solutions is computationally very demanding. We present an approach to accelerate these predictions via a combination of density functional theory and machine learning, using the cubic spinel nitride GeSn$_2$N$_4$ as a case study, exploring how formation energy and electronic bandgap are affected by configurational variations. Furthermore, we demonstrate the utility of applying explainable machine learning to understand the crystal chemistry origins of the trends that we observe. Different configuration descriptors (Coulomb matrix eigenspectrum, many-body tensor representation, and cluster correlation function vectors) are combined with different models (linear regression, gradient-boosted decision tree, and multi-layer perceptron) to extrapolate the calculation of ab initio properties from a small set of configurations to the full space with thousands of configurations. We discuss the performance of different descriptors and models. SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) analysis of the machine learning models highlights how values of formation energy are dominated by variations in local crystal structure (single polyhedral environments), while values of electronic bandgap are dominated by variations in more extended structural motifs. Finally, we demonstrate the usefulness of this approach by constructing structure-property maps, identifying important configurations of GeSn$_2$N$_4$ with extremal properties, as well as by calculating accurate equilibrium properties using configurational averaging.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Engineering the electronic and optical properties of 2D porphyrin paddlewheel metal-organic frameworks
Authors:
Victor Posligua,
Dimpy Pandya,
Alex Aziz,
Miguel Rivera,
Rachel Crespo-Otero,
Said Hamad,
Ricardo Grau-Crespo
Abstract:
Metal organic frameworks (MOFs) are promising photocatalytic materials due to their high surface area and tuneability of their electronic structure. We discuss here how to engineer the band structures and optical properties of a family of two-dimensional (2D) porphyrin-based MOFs, consisting of M tetrakis(4 carboxyphenyl)porphyrin structures (M TCPP, where M = Zn2+ or Co2+) and metal (Co2+, Ni2+,…
▽ More
Metal organic frameworks (MOFs) are promising photocatalytic materials due to their high surface area and tuneability of their electronic structure. We discuss here how to engineer the band structures and optical properties of a family of two-dimensional (2D) porphyrin-based MOFs, consisting of M tetrakis(4 carboxyphenyl)porphyrin structures (M TCPP, where M = Zn2+ or Co2+) and metal (Co2+, Ni2+, Cu2+ or Zn2+) paddlewheel clusters, with the aim of optimising their photocatalytic behaviour in solar fuel synthesis reactions (water splitting and/or CO2 reduction). Based on density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT simulations with a hybrid functional, we studied three types of composition/structural modifications: a) varying the metal centre at the paddlewheel or at the porphyrin centre to modify the band alignment; b) partially reducing the porphyrin unit to chlorin, which leads to stronger absorption of visible light; and c) substituting the benzene bridging between the porphyrin and paddlewheel, by ethyne or butadiyne bridges, with the aim of modifying the linker to metal charge transfer behaviour. Our work offers new insights on how to improve the photocatalytic behaviour of porphyrin- and paddlewheel-based MOFs.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
The Si-Ge substitutional series in the chiral STW Zeolite Structure Type
Authors:
Reus Tiago Rigo,
Salvador Rodríguez-Gómez Balestra,
Said Hamad,
Rocío Bueno-Pérez,
Ángel Rabdel Ruíz-Salvador,
Sofía Calero,
Miguel A. Camblor
Abstract:
The whole compositional range (Ge$_f$ = Ge/(Ge+Si)= 0 to 1) of zeolite STW has been synthesized and studied by a comprehensive combined experimental--theoretical approach. The yield of zeolite goes through a maximum and then drops at the GeO$_2$ side of the series, following the inverse of the calculated free energy curve. The unit cell generally expands, roughly linearly, as the Ge$_f$ increases,…
▽ More
The whole compositional range (Ge$_f$ = Ge/(Ge+Si)= 0 to 1) of zeolite STW has been synthesized and studied by a comprehensive combined experimental--theoretical approach. The yield of zeolite goes through a maximum and then drops at the GeO$_2$ side of the series, following the inverse of the calculated free energy curve. The unit cell generally expands, roughly linearly, as the Ge$_f$ increases, but a notable resilience to expansion is observed at the high silica side. This can be attributed to the more rigid character of SiO$_2$ and the ability of Ge units to deform. Density functional theory calculations provide a new assignment of the previously controversial $^{19}$F MAS NMR resonances for occluded fluoride, which is based not only in the number of Ge atoms in the double-4-ring units but also on the way they are associated (namely, no Ge, isolated Ge, Ge pairs or closed Ge clusters). While we found an overall good agreement between the experimental and theoretical trends in preferential occupation by Ge of different crystallographic sites, the theoretical models show more sharp and abrupt tendencies, likely due both to limitations of the approach and to kinetic factors that allow metastable configurations to actually exist.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Atomic charges for modeling metal-organic frameworks: Why and how
Authors:
Said Hamad,
Salvador R. G. Balestra,
Rocio Bueno-Perez,
Sofia Calero,
A. Rabdel Ruiz-Salvador
Abstract:
Atomic partial charges are parameters of key importance in the simulation of Metal-Organic Frameworks (MOFs), since Coulombic interactions decrease with the distance more slowly than van der Waals interactions. But despite its relevance, there is no method to unambiguously assign charges to each atom, since atomic charges are not quantum observables. There are several methods that allow the calcul…
▽ More
Atomic partial charges are parameters of key importance in the simulation of Metal-Organic Frameworks (MOFs), since Coulombic interactions decrease with the distance more slowly than van der Waals interactions. But despite its relevance, there is no method to unambiguously assign charges to each atom, since atomic charges are not quantum observables. There are several methods that allow the calculation of atomic charges, most of them starting from the wavefunction or the electronic density or the system, as obtained with quantum mechanical calculations. In this work, we describe the most common methods employed to calculate atomic charges in MOFs. In order to show the influence that even small variations of structure have on atomic charges, we present the results that we obtained for DMOF-1. We also discuss the effect that small variations of atomic charges have on the predicted structural properties IRMOF-1.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Controlling Thermal Expansion: a Metal Organic Frameworks Route
Authors:
Salvador R. G. Balestra,
Rocío Bueno-Pérez,
Said Hamad,
David Dubbeldam,
A. Rabdel Ruiz-Salvador,
Sofia Calero
Abstract:
Controlling thermal expansion is an important, not yet resolved, and challenging problem in materials research. A conceptual design is introduced here for the first time, for the use of MOFs as platforms for controlling thermal expansion devices that can operate in the negative, zero and positive expansion regimes. A detailed computer simulation study, based on molecular dynamics, is presented to…
▽ More
Controlling thermal expansion is an important, not yet resolved, and challenging problem in materials research. A conceptual design is introduced here for the first time, for the use of MOFs as platforms for controlling thermal expansion devices that can operate in the negative, zero and positive expansion regimes. A detailed computer simulation study, based on molecular dynamics, is presented to support the targeted application. MOF-5 has been selected as model material along with three molecules of similar size and known differences in terms of the nature of host--guest interactions. It has been shown that adsorbate molecules can control, in a colligative way, the thermal expansion of the solid, so that changing the adsorbate molecules induces the solid to have positive, zero or negative thermal expansion. We analyze in-depth the distortion mechanisms, beyond the ligand metal junction to cover the ligand distortions, and the energetic and entropic effect on the thermo-structural behavior. We provide an unprecedented atomistic insight on the effect of adsorbates on the thermal expansion of MOFs, as a basic tool towards controlling the thermal expansion.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Understanding Nanopore Window Distortions in the Reversible Molecular Valve Zeolite RHO
Authors:
Salvador Rodríguez-Gómez Balestra,
Said Hamad,
A. Rabdel Ruiz-Salvador,
Virginia Domínguez-García,
Patrick J. Merkling,
David Dubbeldam,
Sofía Calero
Abstract:
Molecular valves are becoming popular for potential biomedical applications. However, little is known concerning their performance in energy and environmental areas. Zeolite RHO shows unique pore deformations upon changes in hydration, cation siting, cation type, or temperature-pressure conditions. By varying the level of distortion of double eight-rings, it is possible to control the adsorption p…
▽ More
Molecular valves are becoming popular for potential biomedical applications. However, little is known concerning their performance in energy and environmental areas. Zeolite RHO shows unique pore deformations upon changes in hydration, cation siting, cation type, or temperature-pressure conditions. By varying the level of distortion of double eight-rings, it is possible to control the adsorption properties, which confer a molecular valve behavior to this material. We have employed interatomic potentials-based simulations to obtain a detailed atomistic view of the structural distortion mechanisms of zeolite RHO, in contrast with the averaged and space group restricted information provided by diffraction studies. We have modeled four aluminosilicate structures, containing Li$^+$, Na$^+$, K$^+$, Ca$^{2+}$, and Sr$^{2+}$ cations. The distortions of the three different zeolite rings are coupled, and the six- and eight-membered rings are largely flexible. A large dependence on the polarizing power of the extra-framework cations and with the loading of water has been found for the minimum aperture of the eight-membered rings that control the nanovalve effect. The calculated energy barriers for moving the cations across the eight-membered rings are very high, which explains the experimentally observed slow kinetics of the phase transition as well as the appearance of metastable phases.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
The symmetry-adapted configurational ensemble approach to the computer simulation of site-disordered solids
Authors:
Ricardo Grau-Crespo,
Said Hamad
Abstract:
Site-occupancy disorder, defined as the non-periodic occupation of lattice sites in a crystal structure, is a ubiquitous phenomenon in solid-state physics and chemistry. Examples are mineral solid solutions, synthetic non-stoichiometric compounds and metal alloys. The experimental investigation of these materials using diffraction techniques only provides averaged information of their structure. H…
▽ More
Site-occupancy disorder, defined as the non-periodic occupation of lattice sites in a crystal structure, is a ubiquitous phenomenon in solid-state physics and chemistry. Examples are mineral solid solutions, synthetic non-stoichiometric compounds and metal alloys. The experimental investigation of these materials using diffraction techniques only provides averaged information of their structure. However, many properties of interest in these solids are determined by the local geometry and degree of disorder, which escape an "average crystal" description, either from experiments or from theory. In this paper, we describe a methodology for the computer simulation of site-disordered solids, based on the consideration of configurational ensembles and statistical mechanics, where the number of occupancy configurations is reduced by taking advantage of the crystal symmetry of the lattice. Thermodynamics and non-thermodynamic properties are then defined from the statistics in the symmetry-adapted configurational ensemble. We will briefly summarize and discuss some recent applications of this methodology to problems in materials science.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Electronic structure of porphyrin-based metal-organic frameworks and their suitability for solar fuel production photocatalysis
Authors:
Said Hamad,
Norge C. Hernandez,
Alex G. Aziz,
A. Rabdel Ruiz-Salvador,
Sofia Calero,
Ricardo Grau-Crespo
Abstract:
Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) can be exceptionally good catalytic materials thanks to the presence of active metal centres and a porous structure that is advantageous for molecular adsorption and confinement. We present here a first-principles investigation of the electronic structure of a family of MOFs based on porphyrins connected through phenyl-carboxyl ligands and AlOH species, in order to…
▽ More
Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) can be exceptionally good catalytic materials thanks to the presence of active metal centres and a porous structure that is advantageous for molecular adsorption and confinement. We present here a first-principles investigation of the electronic structure of a family of MOFs based on porphyrins connected through phenyl-carboxyl ligands and AlOH species, in order to assess their suitability for the photocatalysis of fuel production reactions using sunlight.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Phase separation and surface segregation in ceria-zirconia solid solutions
Authors:
Ricardo Grau-Crespo,
Nora H. de Leeuw,
Said Hamad,
Umesh V. Waghmare
Abstract:
Using a combination of density functional theory calculations and statistical mechanics, we show that a wide range of intermediate compositions of ceria - zirconia solid solutions are thermodynamically metastable with respect to phase separation into Ce-rich and Zr-rich oxides. We estimate that the maximum equilibrium concentration of Zr in CeO2 at 1373 K is ~2%, and therefore equilibrated samples…
▽ More
Using a combination of density functional theory calculations and statistical mechanics, we show that a wide range of intermediate compositions of ceria - zirconia solid solutions are thermodynamically metastable with respect to phase separation into Ce-rich and Zr-rich oxides. We estimate that the maximum equilibrium concentration of Zr in CeO2 at 1373 K is ~2%, and therefore equilibrated samples with higher Zr content are expected to exhibit heterogeneity at the atomic scale. We also demonstrate that in the vicinity of the (111) surface, cation redistribution at high temperatures will occur with significant Ce enrichment of the surface, which we attribute to the more covalent character of Zr-O bonds compared to Ce-O bonds. Although the kinetic barriers for cation diffusion normally prevent the decomposition/segregation of ceria-zirconia solid solutions in typical catalytic applications, the separation behaviour described here can be expected to occur in modern three-way catalytic converters, where very high temperatures are reached.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
