-
Price of information in games of chance: a statistical physics approach
Authors:
Luca Gamberi,
Alessia Annibale,
Pierpaolo Vivo
Abstract:
Information in the form of data, which can be stored and transferred between users, can be viewed as an intangible commodity, which can be traded in exchange for money. Determining the fair price at which a string of data should be traded is an important and open problem in many settings. In this work we develop a statistical physics framework that allows to determine analytically the fair price o…
▽ More
Information in the form of data, which can be stored and transferred between users, can be viewed as an intangible commodity, which can be traded in exchange for money. Determining the fair price at which a string of data should be traded is an important and open problem in many settings. In this work we develop a statistical physics framework that allows to determine analytically the fair price of information exchanged between players in a game of chance. For definiteness, we consider a game where $N$ players bet on the binary outcome of a stochastic process and share the entry fees pot if successful. We assume that one player holds information about past outcomes of the game, which they may either use exclusively to improve their betting strategy or offer to sell to another player. We find a sharp transition as the number of players $N$ is tuned across a critical value, between a phase where the transaction is always profitable for the seller and one where it may not be. In both phases, different regimes are possible, depending on the "quality" of information being put up for sale: we observe symbiotic regimes, where both parties collude effectively to rig the game in their favor, competitive regimes, where the transaction is unappealing to the data holder as it overly favors a competitor for scarce resources, and even prey-predator regimes, where an exploitative data holder could be giving away bad-quality data to undercut a competitor. Our analytical framework can be generalized to more complex settings and constitutes a flexible tool to address the rich and timely problem of pricing information in games of chance.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2024; v1 submitted 26 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Rationalizing systematic discrepancies between election outcomes and opinion polls
Authors:
Luca Gamberi,
Pierpaolo Vivo,
Yanik-Pascal Förster,
Evan Tzanis,
Alessia Annibale
Abstract:
The Bradley effect concerns the discrepancy between opinion polls and actual election outcomes that emerges when candidates do not exhibit ideological, sexual or racial mainstream features. This effect was first observed during the 1982 election for the Governor of California that resulted in a significant loss for the black Democratic candidate, Tom Bradley, despite him being ahead in polls. It h…
▽ More
The Bradley effect concerns the discrepancy between opinion polls and actual election outcomes that emerges when candidates do not exhibit ideological, sexual or racial mainstream features. This effect was first observed during the 1982 election for the Governor of California that resulted in a significant loss for the black Democratic candidate, Tom Bradley, despite him being ahead in polls. It has been argued that poll respondents may tend to mask their true political preference in favour of what is generally considered more socially acceptable. We propose an exactly solvable statistical mechanical model, which allows for a quantitative exploration of this phenomenon. The model includes three main ingredients: (i) the tendency of individuals to align their real preference to the declared (public) opinions of others, (ii) a term accounting for an individual integrity factor, which induces voters to be consistent between their public and private opinions, and (iii) a self-monitoring component, which tunes the strength by which an individual is affected by and wishes to publicly conform to social norms. We observe the emergence of order in a wide range of parameters of the model and discuss the effect of noise on the correlation between hidden and public preference. Finally, we present an application of this model to the prediction of election outcomes.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Information retrieval and structural complexity of legal trees
Authors:
Yanik-Pascal Förster,
Alessia Annibale,
Luca Gamberi,
Evan Tzanis,
Pierpaolo Vivo
Abstract:
We introduce a model for the retrieval of information hidden in legal texts. These are typically organised in a hierarchical (tree) structure, which a reader interested in a given provision needs to explore down to the "deepest" level (articles, clauses,...). We assess the structural complexity of legal trees by computing the mean first-passage time a random reader takes to retrieve information pl…
▽ More
We introduce a model for the retrieval of information hidden in legal texts. These are typically organised in a hierarchical (tree) structure, which a reader interested in a given provision needs to explore down to the "deepest" level (articles, clauses,...). We assess the structural complexity of legal trees by computing the mean first-passage time a random reader takes to retrieve information planted in the leaves. The reader is assumed to skim through the content of a legal text based on their interests/keywords, and be drawn towards the sought information based on keywords affinity, i.e. how well the Chapters/Section headers of the hierarchy seem to match the informational content of the leaves. Using randomly generated keyword patterns, we investigate the effect of two main features of the text -- the horizontal and vertical coherence -- on the searching time, and consider ways to validate our results using real legal texts. We obtain numerical and analytical results, the latter based on a mean-field approximation on the level of patterns, which lead to an explicit expression for the complexity of legal trees as a function of the structural parameters of the model. Policy implications of our results are briefly discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Exact and Approximate Mean First Passage Times on Trees and other Necklace Structures: a Local Equilibrium Approach
Authors:
Yanik-Pascal Förster,
Luca Gamberi,
Evan Tzanis,
Pierpaolo Vivo,
Alessia Annibale
Abstract:
In this work we propose a novel method to calculate mean first-passage times (MFPTs) for random walks on graphs, based on a dimensionality reduction technique for Markov State Models, known as local-equilibrium (LE). We show that for a broad class of graphs, which includes trees, LE coarse-graining preserves the MFPTs between certain nodes, upon making a suitable choice of the coarse-grained state…
▽ More
In this work we propose a novel method to calculate mean first-passage times (MFPTs) for random walks on graphs, based on a dimensionality reduction technique for Markov State Models, known as local-equilibrium (LE). We show that for a broad class of graphs, which includes trees, LE coarse-graining preserves the MFPTs between certain nodes, upon making a suitable choice of the coarse-grained states (or clusters). We prove that this relation is exact for graphs that can be coarse-grained into a one-dimensional lattice where each cluster connects to the lattice only through a single node of the original graph. A side result of the proof generalises the well-known essential edge lemma (EEL), which is valid for reversible random walks, to irreversible walkers. Such a generalised EEL leads to explicit formulae for the MFPTs between certain nodes in this class of graphs. For graphs that do not fall in this class, the generalised EEL provides useful approximations if the graph allows a one-dimensional coarse-grained representation and the clusters are sparsely interconnected.
We first demonstrate our method for the simple random walk on the $c$-ary tree, then we consider other graph structures and more general random walks, including irreversible random walks.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2022; v1 submitted 5 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Maximal modularity and the optimal size of parliaments
Authors:
Luca Gamberi,
Yanik-Pascal Förster,
Evan Tzanis,
Alessia Annibale,
Pierpaolo Vivo
Abstract:
An important question in representative democracies is how to determine the optimal parliament size of a given country. According to an old conjecture, known as the cubic root law, there is a fairly universal power-law relation, with an exponent close to 1/3, between the size of an elected parliament and the country's population. Empirical data in modern European countries support such universalit…
▽ More
An important question in representative democracies is how to determine the optimal parliament size of a given country. According to an old conjecture, known as the cubic root law, there is a fairly universal power-law relation, with an exponent close to 1/3, between the size of an elected parliament and the country's population. Empirical data in modern European countries support such universality but are consistent with a larger exponent. In this work, we analyze this intriguing regularity using tools from complex networks theory. We model the population of a democratic country as a random network, drawn from a growth model, where each node is assigned a constituency membership sampled from an available set of size $D$. We calculate analytically the modularity of the population and find that its functional relation with the number of constituencies is strongly non-monotonic, exhibiting a maximum that depends on the population size. The criterion of maximal modularity allows us to predict that the number of representatives should scale as a power-law in the size of the population, a finding that is qualitatively confirmed by the empirical analysis of real-world data.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
