Showing 1–50 of 102 results for author: Charbonneau, P

Rare Trajectories in a Prototypical Mean-field Disordered Model: Insights into Landscape and Instantons

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Giampaolo Folena, Enrico M. Malatesta, Tommaso Rizzo, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: For disordered systems within the random first-order transition (RFOT) universality class, such as structural glasses and certain spin glasses, the role played by activated relaxation processes is rich to the point of perplexity. Over the last decades, various efforts have attempted to formalize and systematize such processes in terms of instantons similar to the nucleation droplets of first- orde… ▽ More For disordered systems within the random first-order transition (RFOT) universality class, such as structural glasses and certain spin glasses, the role played by activated relaxation processes is rich to the point of perplexity. Over the last decades, various efforts have attempted to formalize and systematize such processes in terms of instantons similar to the nucleation droplets of first- order phase transitions. In particular, Kirkpatrick, Thirumalai, and Wolynes proposed in the late '80s an influential nucleation theory of relaxation in structural glasses. Already within this picture, however, the resulting structures are far from the compact objects expected from the classical droplet description. In addition, an altogether different type of single-particle hopping-like instantons has recently been isolated in molecular simulations. Landscape studies of mean-field spin glass models have further revealed that simple saddle crossing does not capture relaxation in these systems. We present here a landscape-agnostic study of rare dynamical events, which delineates the richness of instantons in these systems. Our work not only captures the structure of metastable states, but also identifies the point of irreversibility, beyond which activated relaxation processes become a fait accompli. An interpretation of the associated landscape features is articulated, thus charting a path toward a complete understanding of RFOT instantons. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2025; originally announced May 2025.

Comments: 30 pages, 16 figures

Jamming the Random Lorentz Gas: Configurational Entropy, Crunching Geometry, and Critical Universality

Authors: Giampaolo Folena, Patrick Charbonneau, Peter K. Morse, Rafael Díaz Hernández Rojas, Federico Ricci-Tersenghi

Abstract: Deterministic optimization algorithms unequivocally partition a complex energy landscape in inherent structures (ISs) and their respective basins of attraction. But can these basins be defined solely through geometric principles? This question is particularly important when examining the jamming of hard spheres. We here consider this issue by proposing a geometric class of gradient descent-like al… ▽ More Deterministic optimization algorithms unequivocally partition a complex energy landscape in inherent structures (ISs) and their respective basins of attraction. But can these basins be defined solely through geometric principles? This question is particularly important when examining the jamming of hard spheres. We here consider this issue by proposing a geometric class of gradient descent-like algorithms, which we use to study a system in the hard-sphere universality class, the random Lorentz gas. The statistics of the resulting IS is found to be strictly inherited from those of Poisson-Voronoi tessellations. The landscape roughness is further found to give rise to a hierarchical organization of ISs which various algorithms explore differently. In particular, greedy and reluctant schemes tend to favor ISs of markedly different densities. The resulting ISs nevertheless robustly exhibit a universal force distribution, thus confirming the geometric nature of the jamming universality class. △ Less

Submitted 8 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

Comments: 16 pages, 11 figures

Not-so-glass-like Caging and Fluctuations of an Active Matter Model

Authors: Mingyuan Zheng, Dmytro Khomenko, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: Simple active models of matter recapitulate complex biological phenomena. Their out-of-equilibrium nature, however, often makes these models beyond the reach of first-principle descriptions. This limitation is particularly perplexing when attempting to distinguish between different glass-forming mechanisms. We here consider a minimal active system in various spatial dimensions to identify the unde… ▽ More Simple active models of matter recapitulate complex biological phenomena. Their out-of-equilibrium nature, however, often makes these models beyond the reach of first-principle descriptions. This limitation is particularly perplexing when attempting to distinguish between different glass-forming mechanisms. We here consider a minimal active system in various spatial dimensions to identify the underlying processes at play. Activity is found to markedly impact cage escape processes and critical fluctuations, thus offering a distinct perspective on the role of activity sluggish dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2024; originally announced September 2024.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures

Simple fluctuations in simple glass formers

Authors: Corentin C. L. Laudicina, Patrick Charbonneau, Yi Hu, Liesbeth M. C. Janssen, Peter K. Morse, Ilian Pihlajamaa, Grzegorz Szamel

Abstract: Critical single-particle fluctuations associated with particle displacements are inherent to simple glass-forming liquids in the limit of large dimensions and leave a pseudo-critical trace across all finite dimensions. This characteristic could serve as a crucial test for distinguishing between theories of glass formation. We here examine these critical fluctuations, as captured by the well-establ… ▽ More Critical single-particle fluctuations associated with particle displacements are inherent to simple glass-forming liquids in the limit of large dimensions and leave a pseudo-critical trace across all finite dimensions. This characteristic could serve as a crucial test for distinguishing between theories of glass formation. We here examine these critical fluctuations, as captured by the well-established non-Gaussian parameter, within both mode-coupling theory (MCT) and dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) across dimensions for hard sphere liquids and for the minimally structured Mari--Kurchan model. We establish general scaling laws relevant to any liquid dynamics theory in large dimensions and show that the dimensional scalings predicted by MCT are inconsistent with those from DMFT. Simulation results for hard spheres in moderately high dimensions align with the DMFT scenario, reinforcing the relevance of mean-field theory for capturing glass physics in finite dimensions. We identify potential adjustments to MCT to account for certain mean-field physics. Our findings also highlight that local structure and spatial dimensionality can affect single-particle critical fluctuations in non-trivial ways. △ Less

Submitted 13 August, 2024; originally announced August 2024.

Comments: 42 pages, 9 figures

Dynamics and fluctuations of minimally-structured glass formers

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Yi Hu, Peter K. Morse

Abstract: The mean-field theory (MFT) of simple glasses, which is exact in the limit of infinite spatial dimensions, $d\rightarrow\infty$, offers theoretical insight as well as quantitative predictions about certain features of $d=3$ systems. In order to more systematically relate the behavior of physical systems to MFT, however, various finite-$d$ corrections need to be accounted for. Although some efforts… ▽ More The mean-field theory (MFT) of simple glasses, which is exact in the limit of infinite spatial dimensions, $d\rightarrow\infty$, offers theoretical insight as well as quantitative predictions about certain features of $d=3$ systems. In order to more systematically relate the behavior of physical systems to MFT, however, various finite-$d$ corrections need to be accounted for. Although some efforts along this direction have already been undertaken, theoretical and technical challenges hinder progress. A general approach to sidestep many of these difficulties consists of simulating minimally-structured models whose behavior smoothly converges to that described by the MFT as $d$ increases, so as to permit a dimensional extrapolation. Using this approach, we here extract the small fluctuations around the dynamical MFT captured by a standard liquid-state observable the non-Gaussian parameter $α_2$. The results provide insight into the physical origin of these fluctuations as well as a quantitative reference with which to compare observations in more realistic glass formers. △ Less

Submitted 12 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 10 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 109, 054905 (2024)

Glass-like Caging with Random Planes

Authors: Gilles Bonnet, Patrick Charbonneau, Giampaolo Folena

Abstract: The richness of the mean-field solution of simple glasses leaves many of its features challenging to interpret. A minimal model that illuminates glass physics the same way the random energy model clarifies spin glass behavior would therefore be beneficial. Here, we propose such a real-space model that is amenable to infinite-dimensional analysis and is exactly solvable at high and low densities in… ▽ More The richness of the mean-field solution of simple glasses leaves many of its features challenging to interpret. A minimal model that illuminates glass physics the same way the random energy model clarifies spin glass behavior would therefore be beneficial. Here, we propose such a real-space model that is amenable to infinite-dimensional analysis and is exactly solvable at high and low densities in finite dimension. By joining analysis with numerical simulations, we uncover geometrical signatures of the dynamical and jamming transitions and provides insight into the origin of activated processes. Translating these findings to the context of standard glass formers further reveals the role played by non-convexity in the emergence of Gardner physics. △ Less

Submitted 21 November, 2023; v1 submitted 3 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: Minor text revisions

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 109, 024125 (2024)

Colloidal Hard Spheres: Triumphs, Challenges and Mysteries

Authors: C. Patrick Royall, Patrick Charbonneau, Marjolein Dijkstra, John Russo, Frank Smallenburg, Thomas Speck, Chantal Valeriani

Abstract: The simplicity of hard spheres as a model system is deceptive. Although the particles interact solely through volume exclusion, that nevertheless suffices for a wealth of static and dynamical phenomena to emerge, making the model an important target for achieving a comprehensive understanding of matter. In addition, while real colloidal suspensions are typically governed by complex interactions, P… ▽ More The simplicity of hard spheres as a model system is deceptive. Although the particles interact solely through volume exclusion, that nevertheless suffices for a wealth of static and dynamical phenomena to emerge, making the model an important target for achieving a comprehensive understanding of matter. In addition, while real colloidal suspensions are typically governed by complex interactions, Pusey and Van Megen [Nature 320 340--342 (1986)] demonstrated that suitably tuned suspensions result in hard-sphere like behavior, thus bringing a valuable experimental complement to the celebrated theoretical model. Colloidal hard spheres are thus both a material in their own right and a platform upon which phenomena exhibited by simple materials can be explored in great detail. These various purposes enable a particular synergy between experiment, theory and computer simulation. Here we review the extensive body of work on hard spheres, ranging from their equilibrium properties such as phase behavior, interfaces and confinement to some of the non--equilibrium phenomena they exhibit such as sedimentation, glass formation and nucleation. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2023; v1 submitted 3 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 97 pages

Journal ref: Rev. Mod. Phys. 96, 045003 (2024)

Jamming, relaxation, and memory in a structureless glass former

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Peter K. Morse

Abstract: Real structural glasses form through various out-of-equilibrium processes, including temperature quenches, rapid compression, shear, and aging. Each of these processes should be formally understandable within the recently formulated dynamical mean-field theory of glasses, but many of the numerical tools needed to solve the relevant equations for sufficiently long timescales do not yet exist. Numer… ▽ More Real structural glasses form through various out-of-equilibrium processes, including temperature quenches, rapid compression, shear, and aging. Each of these processes should be formally understandable within the recently formulated dynamical mean-field theory of glasses, but many of the numerical tools needed to solve the relevant equations for sufficiently long timescales do not yet exist. Numerical simulations of structureless (and therefore mean-field-like) model glass formers can nevertheless aid searching for and understanding such solutions, thanks to their ability to disentangle structural from dimensional effects. We here study the infinite-range Mari-Kurchan model under simple non-equilibrium processes and compare the results with those from the random Lorentz gas [J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 55 334001, (2022)], which are both mean-field-like and become formally equivalent in the limit of infinite spatial dimensions. Of particular interest are jamming from crunching and under instantaneous temperature quenches. The study allows for an algorithmic understanding of the jamming density and of its approach to the infinite-dimensional limit. The results provide important insight into the eventual solution of the dynamical mean-field theory, including onsets and anomalous relaxation, as well as into the various algorithmic schemes for jamming. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Comments: 13 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 108, 054102 (2023)

From the replica trick to the replica symmetry breaking technique

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: Among the various remarkable contributions of Giorgio Parisi to physics, his formulation of the replica symmetry breaking solution for the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model stands out. In this article, different historical sources are used to reconstruct the scientific and professional contexts of this prodigious advance. Among the various remarkable contributions of Giorgio Parisi to physics, his formulation of the replica symmetry breaking solution for the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model stands out. In this article, different historical sources are used to reconstruct the scientific and professional contexts of this prodigious advance. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 13 pages; 2 figures

Journal ref: IAMP News Bulletin 2022(October), 5-25 (2022)

Avoiding critical slowdown in models with SALR interactions

Authors: Mingyuan Zheng, Marco Tarzia, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: In systems with frustration, the critical slowdown of the dynamics severely impedes the numerical study of phase transitions for even the simplest of lattice models. In order to help sidestep the gelation-like sluggishness, a clearer understanding of the underlying physics is needed. Here, we first obtain generic insights into that phenomenon by studying one-dimensional and Bethe lattice versions… ▽ More In systems with frustration, the critical slowdown of the dynamics severely impedes the numerical study of phase transitions for even the simplest of lattice models. In order to help sidestep the gelation-like sluggishness, a clearer understanding of the underlying physics is needed. Here, we first obtain generic insights into that phenomenon by studying one-dimensional and Bethe lattice versions of a schematic frustrated model, the axial next-nearest neighbor Ising (ANNNI) model. Based on these findings, we formulate two cluster algorithms that speed up the simulations of the ANNNI model on a 2D square lattice. Although these schemes do not avoid the critical slowdown, speed-ups of factors up to 40 are achieved in some regimes. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. (2022)

Gardner-like transition from variable to persistent force contacts in granular crystals

Authors: Lars Kool, Patrick Charbonneau, Karen E. Daniels

Abstract: We report experimental evidence of a Gardner-like transition from variable to persistent force contacts in a two-dimensional, bidisperse granular crystal by analyzing the variability of both particle positions and force networks formed under uniaxial compression. Starting from densities just above the freezing transition, and for variable amounts of additional compression, we compare configuration… ▽ More We report experimental evidence of a Gardner-like transition from variable to persistent force contacts in a two-dimensional, bidisperse granular crystal by analyzing the variability of both particle positions and force networks formed under uniaxial compression. Starting from densities just above the freezing transition, and for variable amounts of additional compression, we compare configurations to both their own initial state, and to an ensemble of equivalent, reinitialized states. This protocol shows that force contacts are largely undetermined when the density is below a Gardner-like transition, after which they gradually transition to being persistent, being fully so only above the jamming point. We associate the disorder that underlies this effect to the size of the microscopic asperities of the photoelastic disks used, by analogy to other mechanisms that have been previously predicted theoretically. △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Equilibrium Fluctuations in Mean-field Disordered Models

Authors: Giampaolo Folena, Giulio Biroli, Patrick Charbonneau, Yi Hu, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: Mean-field models of glasses that present a random first order transition exhibit highly non-trivial fluctuations. Building on previous studies that focused on the critical scaling regime, we here obtain a fully quantitative framework for all equilibrium conditions. By means of the replica method we evaluate Gaussian fluctuations of the overlaps around the thermodynamic limit, decomposing them in… ▽ More Mean-field models of glasses that present a random first order transition exhibit highly non-trivial fluctuations. Building on previous studies that focused on the critical scaling regime, we here obtain a fully quantitative framework for all equilibrium conditions. By means of the replica method we evaluate Gaussian fluctuations of the overlaps around the thermodynamic limit, decomposing them in thermal fluctuations inside each state and heterogeneous fluctuations between different states. We first test and compare our analytical results with numerical simulation results for the p-spin spherical model and the random orthogonal model, and then analyze the random Lorentz gas. In all cases, a strong quantitative agreement is obtained. Our analysis thus provides a robust scheme for identifying the key finite-size (or finite-dimensional) corrections to the mean-field treatment of these paradigmatic glass models. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2022; v1 submitted 15 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 39 pages, 21 figures, major changes in the nomenclature and revision of the appendices

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 106, 024605 (2022)

A Mutation Threshold for Cooperative Takeover

Authors: Alexandre Champagne-Ruel, Paul Charbonneau

Abstract: One of the leading theories for the origin of life includes the hypothesis according to which life would have evolved as cooperative networks of molecules. Explaining cooperation$-$and particularly, its emergence in favoring the evolution of life-bearing molecules$-$is thus a key element in describing the transition from nonlife to life. Using agent-based modeling of the iterated prisoner's dilemm… ▽ More One of the leading theories for the origin of life includes the hypothesis according to which life would have evolved as cooperative networks of molecules. Explaining cooperation$-$and particularly, its emergence in favoring the evolution of life-bearing molecules$-$is thus a key element in describing the transition from nonlife to life. Using agent-based modeling of the iterated prisoner's dilemma, we investigate the emergence of cooperative behavior in a stochastic and spatially extended setting and characterize the effects of inheritance and variability. We demonstrate that there is a mutation threshold above which cooperation is$-$counterintuitively$-$selected, which drives a dramatic and robust cooperative takeover of the whole system sustained consistently up to the error catastrophe, in a manner reminiscent of typical phase transition phenomena in statistical physics. Moreover, our results also imply that one of the simplest conditional cooperative strategies, "Tit-for-Tat", plays a key role in the emergence of cooperative behavior required for the origin of life. △ Less

Submitted 9 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 11 pages, 7 figures, Accepted for publication in Life

Journal ref: Life 2022, 12, 254

Comment on "Explicit Analytical Solution for Random Close Packing in $d = 2$ and $d = 3$"

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Peter K. Morse

Abstract: A recent letter titled "Explicit Analytical Solution for Random Close Packing in d=2 and d=3" published in Physical Review Letters proposes a first-principle computation of the random close packing (RCP) density in spatial dimensions d=2 and d=3. This problem has a long history of such proposals, but none capture the full picture. This paper, in particular, once generalized to all d fails to descr… ▽ More A recent letter titled "Explicit Analytical Solution for Random Close Packing in d=2 and d=3" published in Physical Review Letters proposes a first-principle computation of the random close packing (RCP) density in spatial dimensions d=2 and d=3. This problem has a long history of such proposals, but none capture the full picture. This paper, in particular, once generalized to all d fails to describe the known behavior of jammed systems in d>4, thus suggesting that the low-dimensional agreement is largely fortuitous. △ Less

Submitted 19 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: 2 pages, 1 figure

The dimensional evolution of structure and dynamics in hard sphere liquids

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Yi Hu, Joyjit Kundu, Peter K. Morse

Abstract: The formulation of the mean-field, infinite-dimensional solution of hard sphere glasses is a significant milestone for theoretical physics. How relevant this description might be for understanding low-dimensional glass-forming liquids, however, remains unclear. These liquids indeed exhibit a complex interplay between structure and dynamics, and the importance of this interplay might only slowly di… ▽ More The formulation of the mean-field, infinite-dimensional solution of hard sphere glasses is a significant milestone for theoretical physics. How relevant this description might be for understanding low-dimensional glass-forming liquids, however, remains unclear. These liquids indeed exhibit a complex interplay between structure and dynamics, and the importance of this interplay might only slowly diminish as dimension $d$ increases. A careful numerical assessment of the matter has long been hindered by the exponential increase of computational costs with $d$. By revisiting a once common simulation technique involving the use of periodic boundary conditions modeled on $D_d$ lattices, we here partly sidestep this difficulty, thus allowing the study of hard sphere liquids up to $d=13$. Parallel efforts by Mangeat and Zamponi [Phys. Rev. E 93, 012609 (2016)] have expanded the mean-field description of glasses to finite $d$ by leveraging standard liquid-state theory, and thus help bridge the gap from the other direction. The relatively smooth evolution of both structure and dynamics across the $d$ gap allows us to relate the two approaches, and to identify some of the missing features that a finite-$d$ theory of glasses might hope to include to achieve near quantitative agreement. △ Less

Submitted 26 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 156, 134502 (2022)

Local dynamical heterogeneity in glass formers

Authors: Giulio Biroli, Patrick Charbonneau, Giampaolo Folena, Yi Hu, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: We study the local dynamical fluctuations in glass-forming models of particles embedded in $d$-dimensional space, in the mean-field limit of $d\to\infty$. Our analytical calculation reveals that single-particle observables, such as squared particle displacements, display divergent fluctuations around the dynamical (or mode-coupling) transition, due to the emergence of nontrivial correlations betwe… ▽ More We study the local dynamical fluctuations in glass-forming models of particles embedded in $d$-dimensional space, in the mean-field limit of $d\to\infty$. Our analytical calculation reveals that single-particle observables, such as squared particle displacements, display divergent fluctuations around the dynamical (or mode-coupling) transition, due to the emergence of nontrivial correlations between displacements along different directions. This effect notably gives rise to a divergent non-Gaussian parameter, $α_2$. The $d\to\infty$ local dynamics therefore becomes quite rich upon approaching the glass transition. The finite-$d$ remnant of this phenomenon further provides a long sought-after, first-principle explanation for the growth of $α_2$ around the glass transition that is \emph{not based on multi-particle correlations}. △ Less

Submitted 6 March, 2022; v1 submitted 24 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 175501 (2022)

Three simple scenarios for high-dimensional sphere packings

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Peter K. Morse, Will Perkins, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: Based on results from the physics and mathematics literature which suggest a series of clearly defined conjectures, we formulate three simple scenarios for the fate of hard sphere crystallization in high dimension: (A) crystallization is impeded and the glass phase constitutes the densest packing, (B) crystallization from the liquid is possible, but takes place much beyond the dynamical glass tran… ▽ More Based on results from the physics and mathematics literature which suggest a series of clearly defined conjectures, we formulate three simple scenarios for the fate of hard sphere crystallization in high dimension: (A) crystallization is impeded and the glass phase constitutes the densest packing, (B) crystallization from the liquid is possible, but takes place much beyond the dynamical glass transition and is thus dynamically implausible, or (C) crystallization is possible and takes place before (or just after) dynamical arrest, thus making it plausibly accessible from the liquid state. In order to assess the underlying conjectures and thus obtain insight into which scenario is most likely to be realized, we investigate the densest sphere packings in dimension $d=3$-$10$ using cell-cluster expansions as well as numerical simulations. These resulting estimates of the crystal entropy near close-packing tend to support scenario C. We additionally confirm that the crystal equation of state is dominated by the free volume expansion and that a meaningful polynomial correction can be formulated. △ Less

Submitted 28 December, 2021; v1 submitted 7 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 17 pages, 9 figures. Edits coincide with the published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 104, 064612 (2021)

Numerical transfer matrix study of frustrated next-nearest-neighbor Ising models on square lattices

Authors: Yi Hu, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: Ising models with frustrated next-nearest-neighbor interactions present a rich morphology of modulated phases. These phases, however, assemble and relax slowly, which hinders their computational study. In two dimensions, strong fluctuations further hamper determining their equilibrium phase behavior from theoretical approximations. The exact numerical transfer matrix (TM) method, which bypasses th… ▽ More Ising models with frustrated next-nearest-neighbor interactions present a rich morphology of modulated phases. These phases, however, assemble and relax slowly, which hinders their computational study. In two dimensions, strong fluctuations further hamper determining their equilibrium phase behavior from theoretical approximations. The exact numerical transfer matrix (TM) method, which bypasses these difficulties, can serve as a benchmark method once its own numerical challenges are surmounted. Building on our recent study [Hu and Charbonneau, Phys. Rev. B 103, 094441 (2021)], in which we evaluated the two-dimensional axial next-nearest-neighbor Ising (ANNNI) model with transfer matrices, we here extend the effective usage of the TM method into the Ising models with biaxial, diagonal, and third-nearest-neighbor frustrations (BNNNI, DNNI, and 3NNI models). Thanks to the high-accuracy numerics provided by the TM results, various physical ambiguities about these reference models are resolved and an overview of modulated phase formation is obtained. △ Less

Submitted 15 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 18 pages, 14 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 104, 144429 (2021)

High-dimensional percolation criticality and hints of mean-field-like caging of the random Lorentz gas

Authors: Benoit Charbonneau, Patrick Charbonneau, Yi Hu, Zhen Yang

Abstract: The random Lorentz gas (RLG) is a minimal model for transport in disordered media. Despite the broad relevance of the model, theoretical grasp over its properties remains weak. For instance, the scaling with dimension d of its localization transition at the void percolation threshold is not well controlled analytically nor computationally. A recent study [Biroli et al. Phys. Rev. E L030104 (2021)]… ▽ More The random Lorentz gas (RLG) is a minimal model for transport in disordered media. Despite the broad relevance of the model, theoretical grasp over its properties remains weak. For instance, the scaling with dimension d of its localization transition at the void percolation threshold is not well controlled analytically nor computationally. A recent study [Biroli et al. Phys. Rev. E L030104 (2021)] of the caging behavior of the RLG motivated by the mean-field theory of glasses has uncovered physical inconsistencies in that scaling that heighten the need for guidance. Here, we first extend analytical expectations for asymptotic high-d bounds on the void percolation threshold, and then computationally evaluate both the threshold and its criticality in various d. In high-d systems, we observe that the standard percolation physics is complemented by a dynamical slowdown of the tracer dynamics reminiscent of mean-field caging. A simple modification of the RLG is found to bring the interplay between percolation and mean-field-like caging down to d=3. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: 18 pages, 11 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 104, 024137 (2021)

Thermodynamic stability of hard sphere crystals in dimensions 3 through 10

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Caitlin M. Gish, Robert S. Hoy, Peter K. Morse

Abstract: Although much is known about the metastable liquid branch of hard spheres--from low dimension $d$ up to ${d\to\infty}$--its crystal counterpart remains largely unexplored for $d>3$. In particular, it is unclear whether the crystal phase is thermodynamically stable in high dimensions and thus whether a mean-field theory of crystals can ever be exact. In order to determine the stability range of har… ▽ More Although much is known about the metastable liquid branch of hard spheres--from low dimension $d$ up to ${d\to\infty}$--its crystal counterpart remains largely unexplored for $d>3$. In particular, it is unclear whether the crystal phase is thermodynamically stable in high dimensions and thus whether a mean-field theory of crystals can ever be exact. In order to determine the stability range of hard sphere crystals, their equation of state is here estimated from numerical simulations, and fluid-crystal coexistence conditions are determined using a generalized Frenkel-Ladd scheme to compute absolute crystal free energies. The results show that the crystal phase is stable at least up to $d=10$, and the dimensional trends suggest that crystal stability likely persists well beyond that point. △ Less

Submitted 22 December, 2021; v1 submitted 29 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 12 pages, 7 figures. Edits are reflective of the published version and thus include results for d=10

Journal ref: Euro. Phys. J. E 44, 101 (2021)

Characterization and Efficient Monte Carlo Sampling of Disordered Microphases

Authors: Mingyuan Zheng, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: The disordered microphases that develop in the high-temperature phase of systems with competing short-range attractive and long-range repulsive (SALR) interactions result in a rich array of distinct morphologies, such as cluster, void cluster and percolated (gel-like) fluids. These different structural regimes exhibit complex relaxation dynamics with significant relaxation heterogeneity and slowdo… ▽ More The disordered microphases that develop in the high-temperature phase of systems with competing short-range attractive and long-range repulsive (SALR) interactions result in a rich array of distinct morphologies, such as cluster, void cluster and percolated (gel-like) fluids. These different structural regimes exhibit complex relaxation dynamics with significant relaxation heterogeneity and slowdown. The overall relationship between structure and configurational sampling schemes, however, remains largely uncharted. In this article, the disordered microphases of a schematic SALR model are thoroughly characterized, and structural relaxation functions adapted to each regime are devised. The sampling efficiency of various advanced Monte Carlo (MC) sampling schemes--Virtual-Move (VMMC), Aggregation-Volume-Bias (AVBMC) and Event-Chain (ECMC)--is then assessed. A combination of VMMC and AVBMC is found to be computationally most efficient for cluster fluids and ECMC to become relatively more efficient as density increases. These results offer a complete description of the equilibrium disordered phase of a simple microphase former as well as dynamical benchmarks for other sampling schemes. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 21 pages, 13 figures

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 154.24 (2021) 244506

Solution of Disordered Microphases in the Bethe approximation

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Marco Tarzia

Abstract: The periodic microphases that self-assemble in systems with competing short-range attractive and long-range repulsive interactions are structurally both rich and elegant. Significant theoretical and computational efforts have thus been dedicated to untangling their properties. By contrast, disordered microphases, which are structurally just as rich but nowhere near as elegant, have not been as car… ▽ More The periodic microphases that self-assemble in systems with competing short-range attractive and long-range repulsive interactions are structurally both rich and elegant. Significant theoretical and computational efforts have thus been dedicated to untangling their properties. By contrast, disordered microphases, which are structurally just as rich but nowhere near as elegant, have not been as carefully considered. Part of the difficulty is that simple mean-field descriptions make a homogeneity assumption that washes away all of their structural features. Here, we study disordered microphases by exactly solving a SALR model on the Bethe lattice. By sidestepping the homogenization assumption, this treatment recapitulates many of the key structural regimes of disordered microphases, including particle and void cluster fluids as well as gelation. This analysis also provides physical insight into the relationship between various structural and thermal observables, between criticality and physical percolation, as well as between glassiness and microphase ordering. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 15 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 155, 024501 (2021)

Mean-field caging in a random Lorentz gas

Authors: Giulio Biroli, Patrick Charbonneau, Yi Hu, Harukuni Ikeda, Grzegorz Szamel, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: The random Lorentz gas (RLG) is a minimal model of both percolation and glassiness, which leads to a paradox in the infinite-dimensional, $d\rightarrow\infty$ limit: the localization transition is then expected to be continuous for the former and discontinuous for the latter. As a putative resolution, we have recently suggested that as $d$ increases the behavior of the RLG converges to the glassy… ▽ More The random Lorentz gas (RLG) is a minimal model of both percolation and glassiness, which leads to a paradox in the infinite-dimensional, $d\rightarrow\infty$ limit: the localization transition is then expected to be continuous for the former and discontinuous for the latter. As a putative resolution, we have recently suggested that as $d$ increases the behavior of the RLG converges to the glassy description, and that percolation physics is recovered thanks to finite-$d$ perturbative and non-perturbative (instantonic) corrections [Biroli et al. arXiv:2003.11179]. Here, we expand on the $d\rightarrow\infty$ physics by considering a simpler static solution as well as the dynamical solution of the RLG. Comparing the $1/d$ correction of this solution with numerical results reveals that even perturbative corrections fall out of reach of existing theoretical descriptions. Comparing the dynamical solution with the mode-coupling theory (MCT) results further reveals that although key quantitative features of MCT are far off the mark, it does properly capture the discontinuous nature of the $d\rightarrow\infty$ RLG. These insights help chart a path toward a complete description of finite-dimensional glasses. △ Less

Submitted 23 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 12 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: J.Phys.Chem.B 125, 6244 (2021)

Percolation thresholds on high dimensional $D_n$ and dense packing lattices

Authors: Yi Hu, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: The site and bond percolation problems are conventionally studied on (hyper)cubic lattices, which afford straightforward numerical treatments. The recent implementation of efficient simulation algorithms for high-dimensional systems now also facilitates the study of $D_n$ root lattices in $n$ dimension as well as $E_8$-related dense packing lattices. Here, we consider the percolation problem on… ▽ More The site and bond percolation problems are conventionally studied on (hyper)cubic lattices, which afford straightforward numerical treatments. The recent implementation of efficient simulation algorithms for high-dimensional systems now also facilitates the study of $D_n$ root lattices in $n$ dimension as well as $E_8$-related dense packing lattices. Here, we consider the percolation problem on $D_n$ for $n=3$ to $13$ and on $E_8$ relatives for $n=6$ to 9. Precise estimates for both site and bond percolation thresholds obtained from invasion percolation simulations are compared with dimensional series expansion on $D_n$ lattices based on lattice animal enumeration. As expected, the bond percolation threshold rapidly approaches the Bethe lattice limit as $n$ increases for these high-connectivity lattices. Corrections, however, exhibit clear yet unexplained trends. Interestingly, the finite-size scaling exponent for invasion percolation is found to be lattice and percolation-type specific. △ Less

Submitted 18 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 103, 062115 (2021)

Resolving the two-dimensional ANNNI model using transfer matrices

Authors: Yi Hu, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: The phase diagram of the two-dimensional ANNNI model has long been theoretically debated. Extremely long structural correlations and relaxation times further result in numerical simulations making contradictory predictions. Here, we introduce a numerical transfer matrix treatment that bypasses these problems, and thus overcome various ambiguities in the phase diagram. In particular, we confirm the… ▽ More The phase diagram of the two-dimensional ANNNI model has long been theoretically debated. Extremely long structural correlations and relaxation times further result in numerical simulations making contradictory predictions. Here, we introduce a numerical transfer matrix treatment that bypasses these problems, and thus overcome various ambiguities in the phase diagram. In particular, we confirm the transition temperatures and clarify the order of the transition to the floating incommensurate phase. Our approach motivates considering transfer matrices for resolving long-standing problems in related statistical physics models. △ Less

Submitted 17 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. B 103, 094441 (2021)

Finite size effects in the microscopic critical properties of jammed configurations: A comprehensive study of the effects of different types of disorder

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Eric I. Corwin, R. Cameron Dennis, Rafael Díaz Hernández Rojas, Harukuni Ikeda, Giorgio Parisi, Federico Ricci-Tersenghi

Abstract: Jamming criticality defines a universality class that includes systems as diverse as glasses, colloids, foams, amorphous solids, constraint satisfaction problems, neural networks, etc. A particularly interesting feature of this class is that small interparticle forces ($f$) and gaps ($h$) are distributed according to nontrivial power laws. A recently developed mean-field (MF) theory predicts the c… ▽ More Jamming criticality defines a universality class that includes systems as diverse as glasses, colloids, foams, amorphous solids, constraint satisfaction problems, neural networks, etc. A particularly interesting feature of this class is that small interparticle forces ($f$) and gaps ($h$) are distributed according to nontrivial power laws. A recently developed mean-field (MF) theory predicts the characteristic exponents of these distributions in the limit of very high spatial dimension, $d\rightarrow\infty$ and, remarkably, their values seemingly agree with numerical estimates in physically relevant dimensions, $d=2$ and $3$. These exponents are further connected through a pair of inequalities derived from stability conditions, and both theoretical predictions and previous numerical investigations suggest that these inequalities are saturated. Systems at the jamming point are thus only marginally stable. Despite the key physical role played by these exponents, their systematic evaluation has yet to be attempted. Here, we carefully test their value by analyzing the finite-size scaling of the distributions of $f$ and $h$ for various particle-based models for jamming. Both dimension and the direction of approach to the jamming point are also considered. We show that, in all models, finite-size effects are much more pronounced in the distribution of $h$ than in that of $f$. We thus conclude that gaps are correlated over considerably longer scales than forces. Additionally, remarkable agreement with MF predictions is obtained in all but one model, namely near-crystalline packings. Our results thus help to better delineate the domain of the jamming universality class. We furthermore uncover a secondary linear regime in the distribution tails of both $f$ and $h$. This surprisingly robust feature is understood to follow from the (near) isostaticity of our configurations. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 2021; v1 submitted 21 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: Version accepted for publication

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 104, 014102 (2021)

Comment on "Kosterlitz-Thouless-type caging-uncaging transition in a quasi-one-dimensional hard disk system" [Phys. Rev. Research 2, 033351 (2020)]

Authors: Yi Hu, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: Huerta et al. [Phys. Rev. Research 2, 033351 (2020)] report a power-law decay of positional order in numerical simulations of hard disks confined within hard parallel walls, which they interpret as a Kosterlitz-Thouless-type caging-uncaging transition. The proposed existence of such a transition in a quasi-one-dimensional (q1D) system, however, contradicts long-held physical expectations. To clari… ▽ More Huerta et al. [Phys. Rev. Research 2, 033351 (2020)] report a power-law decay of positional order in numerical simulations of hard disks confined within hard parallel walls, which they interpret as a Kosterlitz-Thouless-type caging-uncaging transition. The proposed existence of such a transition in a quasi-one-dimensional (q1D) system, however, contradicts long-held physical expectations. To clarify if the proposed ordering persists in the thermodynamic limit, we introduce an exact transfer matrix approach to expeditiously generate equilibrium configurations for systems of arbitrary size. The power-law decay of positional order is found to extend only over finite distances. We conclude that the numerical simulation results reported are associated with a crossover, and not a proper thermodynamic phase transition. △ Less

Submitted 23 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 3, 038001 (2021)

Memory formation in jammed hard spheres

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Peter Morse

Abstract: Liquids equilibrated below an onset density share similar inherent states, while above that density their inherent states markedly differ. Although this phenomenon was first reported in simulations over 20 years ago, the physical origin of this memory remains controversial. Its absence from mean-field descriptions, in particular, has long cast doubt on its thermodynamic relevance. Motivated by a r… ▽ More Liquids equilibrated below an onset density share similar inherent states, while above that density their inherent states markedly differ. Although this phenomenon was first reported in simulations over 20 years ago, the physical origin of this memory remains controversial. Its absence from mean-field descriptions, in particular, has long cast doubt on its thermodynamic relevance. Motivated by a recent theoretical proposal, we reassess the onset phenomenology in simulations using a fast hard sphere jamming algorithm and find it both thermodynamically and dimensionally robust. Remarkably, we also uncover a second type of memory associated with a Gardner-like change in behavior along the jamming algorithm. △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 088001 (2021)

Interplay between percolation and glassiness in the random Lorentz gas

Authors: Giulio Biroli, Patrick Charbonneau, Eric I. Corwin, Yi Hu, Harukuni Ikeda, Grzegorz Szamel, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: The random Lorentz gas (RLG) is a minimal model of transport in heterogeneous media. It also models the dynamics of a tracer in a glassy system. These two perspectives, however, are fundamentally inconsistent. Arrest in the former is related to percolation, and hence continuous, while glass-like arrest is discontinuous. In order to clarify the interplay between percolation and glassiness in the RL… ▽ More The random Lorentz gas (RLG) is a minimal model of transport in heterogeneous media. It also models the dynamics of a tracer in a glassy system. These two perspectives, however, are fundamentally inconsistent. Arrest in the former is related to percolation, and hence continuous, while glass-like arrest is discontinuous. In order to clarify the interplay between percolation and glassiness in the RLG, we consider its exact solution in the infinite-dimensional $d\rightarrow\infty$ limit, as well as numerics in $d=2\ldots 20$. We find that the mean field solutions of the RLG and glasses fall in the same universality class, and that instantonic corrections related to rare cage escapes destroy the glass transition in finite dimensions. This advance suggests that the RLG can be used as a toy model to develop a first-principle description of hopping in structural glasses. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 2021; v1 submitted 24 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 10 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 103, 030104 (2021)

Finite-dimensional vestige of spinodal criticality above the dynamical glass transition

Authors: Ludovic Berthier, Patrick Charbonneau, Joyjit Kundu

Abstract: Finite-dimensional signatures of spinodal criticality are notoriously difficult to come by. The dynamical transition of glass-forming liquids, first described by mode-coupling theory, is a spinodal instability preempted by thermally activated processes that also limit how close the instability can be approached. We combine numerical tools to directly observe vestiges of the spinodal criticality in… ▽ More Finite-dimensional signatures of spinodal criticality are notoriously difficult to come by. The dynamical transition of glass-forming liquids, first described by mode-coupling theory, is a spinodal instability preempted by thermally activated processes that also limit how close the instability can be approached. We combine numerical tools to directly observe vestiges of the spinodal criticality in finite-dimensional glass formers. We use the swap Monte Carlo algorithm to efficiently thermalise configurations beyond the mode-coupling crossover, and analyze their dynamics using a scheme to screen out activated processes, in spatial dimensions ranging from $d=3$ to $d=9$. We observe a strong softening of the mean-field square-root singularity in $d=3$ that is progressively restored as $d$ increases above $d=8$, in surprisingly good agreement with perturbation theory. △ Less

Submitted 24 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 6 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 108001 (2020)

Using schematic models to understand the microscopic basis for inverted solubility in $γ$D-crystallin

Authors: Irem Altan, Jennifer McManus, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: Inverted solubility--a crystal melting upon cooling--is observed in a handful of proteins, such as carbomonoxy hemoglobin and $γ$D-crystallin. In human $γ$D-crystallin, the phenomenon is associated with the mutation of the 23$^\mathrm{rd}$ residue, a proline, to a threonine, serine or valine. One proposed microscopic mechanism for this effect entails an increase in hydrophobicity upon mutagenesis.… ▽ More Inverted solubility--a crystal melting upon cooling--is observed in a handful of proteins, such as carbomonoxy hemoglobin and $γ$D-crystallin. In human $γ$D-crystallin, the phenomenon is associated with the mutation of the 23$^\mathrm{rd}$ residue, a proline, to a threonine, serine or valine. One proposed microscopic mechanism for this effect entails an increase in hydrophobicity upon mutagenesis. Recent crystal structures of a double mutant that includes the P23T mutation allows for a more careful investigation of this proposal. Here, we first measure the surface hydrophobicity of various mutant structures of this protein and determine that it does not discernibly increase upon the mutating the 23$^\mathrm{rd}$ residue. We then investigate the solubility inversion regime with a schematic patchy particle model that includes one of three models for temperature-dependent patch energies: two of the hydrophobic effect, and a more generic description. We conclude that while solubility inversion due to the hydrophobic effect may be possible, microscopic evidence to support it in $γ$D-crystallin is weak. More generally, we find that solubility inversion requires a fine balance between patch strengths and the temperature-dependent contribution, which may explain why inverted solubility is not commonly observed in proteins. In any event, we also find that the temperature-dependent interaction has only a negligible impact on the critical properties of the $γ$D-crystallin, in line with previous experimental observations. △ Less

Submitted 15 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Journal ref: The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2019 123 (47), 10061-10072

Postponing the dynamical transition density using competing interactions

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Joyjit Kundu

Abstract: Systems of dense spheres interacting through very short-ranged attraction are known from theory, simulations and colloidal experiments to exhibit dynamical reentrance. The liquid state can thus be fluidized to higher densities than otherwise possible with interactions that are purely repulsive or long-ranged attractive. A recent mean-field, infinite-dimensional calculation predicts that the dynami… ▽ More Systems of dense spheres interacting through very short-ranged attraction are known from theory, simulations and colloidal experiments to exhibit dynamical reentrance. The liquid state can thus be fluidized to higher densities than otherwise possible with interactions that are purely repulsive or long-ranged attractive. A recent mean-field, infinite-dimensional calculation predicts that the dynamical arrest of the fluid can be further delayed by adding a longer-ranged repulsive contribution to the short-ranged attraction. We examine this proposal by performing extensive numerical simulations in a three-dimensional system. We first find the short-ranged attraction parameters necessary to achieve the densest liquid state, and then explore the parameters space for an additional longer-ranged repulsion that could enhance the effect. In the family of systems studied, no significant (within numerical accuracy) delay of the dynamical arrest is observed beyond what is already achieved by the short-ranged attraction. Possible explanations are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 5

Journal ref: Granular Matter 22, 55 (2020)

Front-mediated melting of ultrastable glasses

Authors: Elijah Flenner, Ludovic Berthier, Patrick Charbonneau, Christopher J. Fullerton

Abstract: Ultrastable vapor-deposited glasses display uncommon material properties. Most remarkably, upon heating they are believed to melt via a liquid front that originates at the free surface and propagates over a mesoscopic crossover length, before crossing over to bulk melting. We combine swap Monte Carlo with molecular dynamics simulations to prepare and melt isotropic amorphous films of unprecedendtl… ▽ More Ultrastable vapor-deposited glasses display uncommon material properties. Most remarkably, upon heating they are believed to melt via a liquid front that originates at the free surface and propagates over a mesoscopic crossover length, before crossing over to bulk melting. We combine swap Monte Carlo with molecular dynamics simulations to prepare and melt isotropic amorphous films of unprecedendtly high kinetic stability. We are able to directly observe both bulk and front melting, and the crossover between them. We measure the front velocity over a broad range of conditions, and a crossover length scale that grows to nearly $400$ particle diameters in the regime accessible to simulations. Our results disentangle the relative roles of kinetic stability and vapor deposition in the physical properties of stable glasses. △ Less

Submitted 3 October, 2019; v1 submitted 21 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 7 pages, 6 figures; accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. Lett

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 175501 (2019)

Perspective: Gardner Physics in Amorphous Solids and Beyond

Authors: Ludovic Berthier, Giulio Biroli, Patrick Charbonneau, Eric I. Corwin, Silvio Franz, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: One of the most remarkable predictions to emerge out of the exact infinite-dimensional solution of the glass problem is the Gardner transition. Although this transition was first theoretically proposed a generation ago for certain mean-field spin glass models, its materials relevance was only realized when a systematic effort to relate glass formation and jamming was undertaken. A number of nontri… ▽ More One of the most remarkable predictions to emerge out of the exact infinite-dimensional solution of the glass problem is the Gardner transition. Although this transition was first theoretically proposed a generation ago for certain mean-field spin glass models, its materials relevance was only realized when a systematic effort to relate glass formation and jamming was undertaken. A number of nontrivial physical signatures associated to the Gardner transition have since been considered in various areas, from models of structural glasses to constraint satisfaction problems. This Perspective surveys these recent advances and discusses the novel research opportunities that arise from them. △ Less

Submitted 28 May, 2019; v1 submitted 27 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 17 pages, 9 figures

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 151, 010901 (2019)

Temperature-dependent non-covalent protein-protein interactions explain normal and inverted solubility in a mutant of human gamma D-crystallin

Authors: Amir R. Khan, Susan James, Michelle K. Quinn, Irem Altan, Patrick Charbonneau, Jennifer J. McManus

Abstract: Protein crystal production is a major bottleneck for the structural characterisation of proteins. To advance beyond large-scale screening, rational strategies for protein crystallization are crucial. Understanding how chemical anisotropy (or patchiness) of the protein surface due to the variety of amino acid side chains in contact with solvent, contributes to protein protein contact formation in t… ▽ More Protein crystal production is a major bottleneck for the structural characterisation of proteins. To advance beyond large-scale screening, rational strategies for protein crystallization are crucial. Understanding how chemical anisotropy (or patchiness) of the protein surface due to the variety of amino acid side chains in contact with solvent, contributes to protein protein contact formation in the crystal lattice is a major obstacle to predicting and optimising crystallization. The relative scarcity of sophisticated theoretical models that include sufficient detail to link collective behaviour, captured in protein phase diagrams, and molecular level details, determined from high-resolution structural information is a further barrier. Here we present two crystals structures for the P23TR36S mutant of gamma D-crystallin, each with opposite solubility behaviour, one melts when heated, the other when cooled. When combined with the protein phase diagram and a tailored patchy particle model we show that a single temperature dependent interaction is sufficient to stabilise the inverted solubility crystal. This contact, at the P23T substitution site, relates to a genetic cataract and reveals at a molecular level, the origin of the lowered and retrograde solubility of the protein. Our results show that the approach employed here may present an alternative strategy for the rationalization of protein crystallization. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Journal ref: Biophys. J. 117, 930-937 (2019)

Dynamics around the Site Percolation Threshold on High-Dimensional Hypercubic Lattices

Authors: Giulio Biroli, Patrick Charbonneau, Yi Hu

Abstract: Recent advances on the glass problem motivate reexamining classical models of percolation. Here, we consider the displacement of an ant in a labyrinth near the percolation threshold on cubic lattices both below and above the upper critical dimension of simple percolation, d_u=6. Using theory and simulations, we consider the scaling regime part, and obtain that both caging and subdiffusion scale lo… ▽ More Recent advances on the glass problem motivate reexamining classical models of percolation. Here, we consider the displacement of an ant in a labyrinth near the percolation threshold on cubic lattices both below and above the upper critical dimension of simple percolation, d_u=6. Using theory and simulations, we consider the scaling regime part, and obtain that both caging and subdiffusion scale logarithmically for d >= d_u. The theoretical derivation considers Bethe lattices with generalized connectivity and a random graph model, and employs a scaling analysis to confirm that logarithmic scalings should persist in the infinite dimension limit. The computational validation employs accelerated random walk simulations with a transfer-matrix description of diffusion to evaluate directly the dynamical critical exponents below d_u as well as their logarithmic scaling above d_u. Our numerical results improve various earlier estimates and are fully consistent with our theoretical predictions. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 12 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 99, 022118 (2019)

Bypassing sluggishness: SWAP algorithm and glassiness in high dimensions

Authors: Ludovic Berthier, Patrick Charbonneau, Joyjit Kundu

Abstract: The recent implementation of a swap Monte Carlo algorithm (SWAP) for polydisperse mixtures fully bypasses computational sluggishness and closes the gap between experimental and simulation timescales in physical dimensions $d=2$ and $3$. Here, we consider suitably optimized systems in $d=2, 3,\dots, 8$, to obtain insights into the performance and underlying physics of SWAP. We show that the speedup… ▽ More The recent implementation of a swap Monte Carlo algorithm (SWAP) for polydisperse mixtures fully bypasses computational sluggishness and closes the gap between experimental and simulation timescales in physical dimensions $d=2$ and $3$. Here, we consider suitably optimized systems in $d=2, 3,\dots, 8$, to obtain insights into the performance and underlying physics of SWAP. We show that the speedup obtained decays rapidly with increasing the dimension. SWAP nonetheless delays systematically the onset of the activated dynamics by an amount that remains finite in the limit $d \to \infty$. This shows that the glassy dynamics in high dimensions $d>3$ is now computationally accessible using SWAP, thus opening the door for the systematic consideration of finite-dimensional deviations from the mean-field description. △ Less

Submitted 16 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 99, 031301 (2019)

Morphology of renormalization-group flow for the de Almeida-Thouless-Gardner universality class

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Yi Hu, Archishman Raju, James P. Sethna, Sho Yaida

Abstract: A replica-symmetry-breaking phase transition is predicted in a host of disordered media. The criticality of the transition has, however, long been questioned below its upper critical dimension, six, due to the absence of a critical fixed point in the renormalization-group flows at one-loop order. A recent two-loop analysis revealed a possible strong-coupling fixed point but, given the uncontrolled… ▽ More A replica-symmetry-breaking phase transition is predicted in a host of disordered media. The criticality of the transition has, however, long been questioned below its upper critical dimension, six, due to the absence of a critical fixed point in the renormalization-group flows at one-loop order. A recent two-loop analysis revealed a possible strong-coupling fixed point but, given the uncontrolled nature of perturbative analysis in the strong-coupling regime, debate persists. Here we examine the nature of the transition as a function of spatial dimension and show that the strong-coupling fixed point can go through a Hopf bifurcation, resulting in a critical limit cycle and a concomitant discrete scale invariance. We further investigate a different renormalization scheme and argue that the basin of attraction of the strong-coupling fixed point/limit cycle may thus stay finite for all dimensions. △ Less

Submitted 6 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 5+8 pages, 3 figures. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1607.04217

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 99, 022132 (2019)

Zero-temperature glass transition in two dimensions

Authors: Ludovic Berthier, Patrick Charbonneau, Andrea Ninarello, Misaki Ozawa, Sho Yaida

Abstract: The nature of the glass transition is theoretically understood in the mean-field limit of infinite spatial dimensions, but the problem remains totally open in physical dimensions. Nontrivial finite-dimensional fluctuations are hard to control analytically, and experiments fail to provide conclusive evidence regarding the nature of the glass transition. Here, we use Monte Carlo simulations that ful… ▽ More The nature of the glass transition is theoretically understood in the mean-field limit of infinite spatial dimensions, but the problem remains totally open in physical dimensions. Nontrivial finite-dimensional fluctuations are hard to control analytically, and experiments fail to provide conclusive evidence regarding the nature of the glass transition. Here, we use Monte Carlo simulations that fully bypass the glassy slowdown, and access equilibrium states in two-dimensional glass-forming liquids at low enough temperatures to directly probe the transition. We find that the liquid state terminates at a thermodynamic glass transition at zero temperature, which is associated with an entropy crisis and a diverging static correlation length. △ Less

Submitted 23 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 23 pages, 18 figures

Journal ref: Nat. Commun. 10, 1508 (2019)

Correlation lengths in quasi-one-dimensional systems via transfer matrices

Authors: Yi Hu, Lin Fu, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: Using transfer matrices up to next-nearest-neighbour (NNN) interactions, we examine the structural correlations of quasi-one-dimensional systems of hard disks confined by two parallel lines and hard spheres confined in cylinders. Simulations have shown that the non-monotonic and non-smooth growth of the correlation length in these systems accompanies structural crossovers (Fu et al., Soft Matter,… ▽ More Using transfer matrices up to next-nearest-neighbour (NNN) interactions, we examine the structural correlations of quasi-one-dimensional systems of hard disks confined by two parallel lines and hard spheres confined in cylinders. Simulations have shown that the non-monotonic and non-smooth growth of the correlation length in these systems accompanies structural crossovers (Fu et al., Soft Matter, 2017, 13, 3296). Here, we identify the theoretical basis for these behaviour. In particular, we associate kinks in the growth of correlation lengths with eigenvalue crossing and splitting. Understanding the origin of such structural crossovers answers questions raised by earlier studies, and thus bridges the gap between theory and simulations for these reference models. △ Less

Submitted 2 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: 9 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Mol. Phys. 116, 3345-3354 (2018)

A Microscopic Model of the Stokes-Einstein Relation in Arbitrary Dimension

Authors: Benoit Charbonneau, Patrick Charbonneau, Grzegorz Szamel

Abstract: The Stokes-Einstein relation (SER) is one of the most robust and widely employed results from the theory of liquids. Yet sizable deviations can be observed for self-solvation, which cannot be explained by the standard hydrodynamic derivation. Here, we revisit the work of Masters and Madden [J. Chem. Phys. 74, 2450-2459 (1981)], who first solved a statistical mechanics model of the SER using the pr… ▽ More The Stokes-Einstein relation (SER) is one of the most robust and widely employed results from the theory of liquids. Yet sizable deviations can be observed for self-solvation, which cannot be explained by the standard hydrodynamic derivation. Here, we revisit the work of Masters and Madden [J. Chem. Phys. 74, 2450-2459 (1981)], who first solved a statistical mechanics model of the SER using the projection operator formalism. By generalizing their analysis to all spatial dimensions and to partially structured solvents, we identify a potential microscopic origin of some of these deviations. We also reproduce the SER-like result from the exact dynamics of infinite-dimensional fluids. △ Less

Submitted 14 June, 2018; v1 submitted 6 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 20 pages

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 148, 224503 (2018)

Glassy, Gardner-like Phenomenology in Minimally Polydisperse Crystalline Systems

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Eric I. Corwin, Lin Fu, Georgios Tsekenis, Michael van der Naald

Abstract: We report on a non-equilibrium phase of matter, the minimally disordered crystal phase, which we find exists between the maximally amorphous glasses and the ideal crystal. Even though these near crystals appear highly ordered, they display glassy and jamming features akin to those observed in amorphous solids. Structurally, they exhibit a power-law scaling in their probability distribution of weak… ▽ More We report on a non-equilibrium phase of matter, the minimally disordered crystal phase, which we find exists between the maximally amorphous glasses and the ideal crystal. Even though these near crystals appear highly ordered, they display glassy and jamming features akin to those observed in amorphous solids. Structurally, they exhibit a power-law scaling in their probability distribution of weak forces and small interparticle gaps as well as a flat density of vibrational states. Dynamically, they display anomalous aging above a characteristic pressure. Quantitatively this disordered crystal phase has much in common with the Gardner-like phase seen in maximally disordered solids. Near crystals should be amenable to experimental realizations in commercially-available particulate systems and are to be indispensable in verifying the theory of amorphous materials. △ Less

Submitted 11 July, 2018; v1 submitted 20 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 99, 020901 (2019)

Clustering and assembly dynamics of a one-dimensional microphase former

Authors: Yi Hu, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: Both ordered and disordered microphases ubiquitously form in suspensions of particles that interact through competing short-range attraction and long-range repulsion (SALR). While ordered microphases are more appealing materials targets, understanding the rich structural and dynamical properties of their disordered counterparts is essential to controlling their mesoscale assembly. Here, we study t… ▽ More Both ordered and disordered microphases ubiquitously form in suspensions of particles that interact through competing short-range attraction and long-range repulsion (SALR). While ordered microphases are more appealing materials targets, understanding the rich structural and dynamical properties of their disordered counterparts is essential to controlling their mesoscale assembly. Here, we study the disordered regime of a one-dimensional (1D) SALR model, whose simplicity enables detailed analysis by transfer matrices and Monte Carlo simulations. We first characterize the signature of the clustering process on macroscopic observables, and then assess the equilibration dynamics of various simulation algorithms. We notably find that cluster moves markedly accelerate the mixing time, but that event chains are of limited help in the clustering regime. These insights will guide further study of three-dimensional microphase formers. △ Less

Submitted 15 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Journal ref: Soft Matter 14, 4101-4109 (2018)

Microphase Equilibrium and Assembly Dynamics

Authors: Yuan Zhuang, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: Despite many attempts, ordered equilibrium microphases have yet to be obtained in experimental colloidal suspensions. The recent computation of the equilibrium phase diagram of a microscopic, particle-based microphase former [Zhuang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 098301 (2016)] has nonetheless found such mesoscale assemblies to be thermodynamically stable. Here, we consider their equilibrium and as… ▽ More Despite many attempts, ordered equilibrium microphases have yet to be obtained in experimental colloidal suspensions. The recent computation of the equilibrium phase diagram of a microscopic, particle-based microphase former [Zhuang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 098301 (2016)] has nonetheless found such mesoscale assemblies to be thermodynamically stable. Here, we consider their equilibrium and assembly dynamics. At intermediate densities above the order-disorder transition, we identify four different dynamical regimes and the structural changes that underlie the dynamical crossovers from one disordered regime to the next. Below the order-disorder transition, we also find that periodic lamellae are the most dynamically accessible of the periodic microphases. Our analysis thus offers a comprehensive view of the disordered microphase dynamics and a route to the assembly of periodic microphases in a putative well-controlled, experimental system. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 147, 091102 (2017)

Cycle-expansion method for the Lyapunov exponent, susceptibility, and higher moments

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau, Yue Li, Henry D. Pfister, Sho Yaida

Abstract: Lyapunov exponents characterize the chaotic nature of dynamical systems by quantifying the growth rate of uncertainty associated with the imperfect measurement of initial conditions. Finite-time estimates of the exponent, however, experience fluctuations due to both the initial condition and the stochastic nature of the dynamical path. The scale of these fluctuations is governed by the Lyapunov su… ▽ More Lyapunov exponents characterize the chaotic nature of dynamical systems by quantifying the growth rate of uncertainty associated with the imperfect measurement of initial conditions. Finite-time estimates of the exponent, however, experience fluctuations due to both the initial condition and the stochastic nature of the dynamical path. The scale of these fluctuations is governed by the Lyapunov susceptibility, the finiteness of which typically provides a sufficient condition for the law of large numbers to apply. Here, we obtain a formally exact expression for this susceptibility in terms of the Ruelle dynamical zeta function for one-dimensional systems. We further show that, for systems governed by sequences of random matrices, the cycle expansion of the zeta function enables systematic computations of the Lyapunov susceptibility and of its higher-moment generalizations. The method is here applied to a class of dynamical models that maps to static disordered spin chains with interactions stretching over a varying distance, and is tested against Monte Carlo simulations. △ Less

Submitted 20 September, 2017; v1 submitted 3 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 9 pages, 4 figures; v2: minor revisions made. Data relevant to this work can be accessed at http://dx.doi.org/10.7924/G88050N6

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 96, 032129 (2017)

Origin of ultrastability in vapor-deposited glasses

Authors: Ludovic Berthier, Patrick Charbonneau, Elijah Flenner, Francesco Zamponi

Abstract: Glass films created by vapor-depositing molecules onto a substrate can exhibit properties similar to those of ordinary glasses aged for thousands of years. It is believed that enhanced surface mobility is the mechanism that allows vapor deposition to create such exceptional glasses, but it is unclear how this effect is related to the final state of the film. Here we use molecular dynamics simulati… ▽ More Glass films created by vapor-depositing molecules onto a substrate can exhibit properties similar to those of ordinary glasses aged for thousands of years. It is believed that enhanced surface mobility is the mechanism that allows vapor deposition to create such exceptional glasses, but it is unclear how this effect is related to the final state of the film. Here we use molecular dynamics simulations to model vapor deposition and an efficient Monte Carlo algorithm to determine the deposition rate needed to create ultra-stable glassy films. We obtain a scaling relation that quantitatively captures the efficiency gain of vapor deposition over bulk annealing, and demonstrates that surface relaxation plays the same role in the formation of vapor-deposited glasses as bulk relaxation does in ordinary glass formation. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2017; v1 submitted 8 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: Five pages and five figures. Data relevant to this work have been archived and can be accessed at https://doi.org/10.7924/G8P26W5G

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 188002 (2017)

Lecture Notes on the Statistical Mechanics of Disordered Systems

Authors: Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: This material complements David Chandler's Introduction to Modern Statistical Mechanics (Oxford University Press, 1987) in a graduate-level, one-semester course I teach in the Department of Chemistry at Duke University. Students enter this course with some knowledge of statistical thermodynamics and quantum mechanics, usually acquired from undergraduate physical chemistry at the level of D. A. McQ… ▽ More This material complements David Chandler's Introduction to Modern Statistical Mechanics (Oxford University Press, 1987) in a graduate-level, one-semester course I teach in the Department of Chemistry at Duke University. Students enter this course with some knowledge of statistical thermodynamics and quantum mechanics, usually acquired from undergraduate physical chemistry at the level of D. A. McQuarrie & J. D. Simon's Physical Chemistry: A Molecular Approach (University Science Books, 1997). These notes, which introduce students to a modern treatment of glassiness and to the replica method, build on the material and problems contained in the eight chapters of Chandler's textbook. △ Less

Submitted 19 May, 2017; originally announced May 2017.

Comments: 14 pages, 2 figures

Configurational entropy measurements in extremely supercooled liquids that break the glass ceiling

Authors: Ludovic Berthier, Patrick Charbonneau, Daniele Coslovich, Andrea Ninarello, Misaki Ozawa, Sho Yaida

Abstract: Liquids relax extremely slowly upon approaching the glass state. One explanation is that an entropy crisis, due to the rarefaction of available states, makes it increasingly arduous to reach equilibrium in that regime. Validating this scenario is challenging, because experiments offer limited resolution, while numerical studies lag more than eight orders of magnitude behind experimentally-relevant… ▽ More Liquids relax extremely slowly upon approaching the glass state. One explanation is that an entropy crisis, due to the rarefaction of available states, makes it increasingly arduous to reach equilibrium in that regime. Validating this scenario is challenging, because experiments offer limited resolution, while numerical studies lag more than eight orders of magnitude behind experimentally-relevant timescales. In this work we not only close the colossal gap between experiments and simulations but manage to create in-silico configurations that have no experimental analog yet. Deploying a range of computational tools, we obtain four estimates of their configurational entropy. These measurements consistently confirm that the steep entropy decrease observed in experiments is also found in simulations, even beyond the experimental glass transition. Our numerical results thus extend the new observational window into the physics of glasses and reinforce the relevance of an entropy crisis for understanding their formation. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2017; v1 submitted 26 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 4+23 pages, 3+12 figures; v2: final version, with various changes made. Data relevant to this work can be accessed at http://dx.doi.org/10.7924/G8ZG6Q9T

Journal ref: PNAS 114, 11356-11361 (2017)

Phase diagram and aggregation dynamics of a monolayer of paramagnetic colloids

Authors: An T. Pham, Yuan Zhuang, Paige Detwiler, Joshua E. S. Socolar, Patrick Charbonneau, Benjamin B. Yellen

Abstract: We have developed a tunable colloidal system and a corresponding simulation model for studying the phase behavior of particles assembling under the influence of long-range magnetic interactions. A monolayer of paramagnetic particles is subjected to a spatially uniform magnetic field with a static perpendicular component and rapidly rotating in-plane component. The sign and strength of the interact… ▽ More We have developed a tunable colloidal system and a corresponding simulation model for studying the phase behavior of particles assembling under the influence of long-range magnetic interactions. A monolayer of paramagnetic particles is subjected to a spatially uniform magnetic field with a static perpendicular component and rapidly rotating in-plane component. The sign and strength of the interactions vary with the tilt angle $θ$ of the rotating magnetic field. For a purely in-plane field, $θ=90^{\circ}$, interactions are attractive and the experimental results agree well with both equilibrium and out-of-equilibrium predictions based on a two-body interaction model. For tilt angles $50^{\circ}\lesssim θ\lesssim 55^{\circ}$, the two-body interaction gives a short-range attractive and long-range repulsive (SALR) interaction, which predicts the formation of equilibrium microphases. In experiments, however, a different type of assembly is observed. Inclusion of three-body (and higher-order) terms in the model does not resolve the discrepancy. We thus further characterize the anomalous behavior by measuring the time-dependent cluster size distribution. △ Less

Submitted 7 April, 2017; v1 submitted 5 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 12 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 95, 052607 (2017)

Assembly of hard spheres in a cylinder: a computational and experimental study

Authors: Lin Fu, Ce Bian, C. Wyatt Shields IV, Daniela F. Cruz, Gabriel P. López, Patrick Charbonneau

Abstract: Hard spheres are an important benchmark of our understanding of natural and synthetic systems. In this work, colloidal experiments and Monte Carlo simulations examine the equilibrium and out-of-equilibrium assembly of hard spheres of diameter $σ$ within cylinders of diameter $σ\leq D\leq 2.82σ$. Although in such a system phase transitions formally do not exist, marked structural crossovers are obs… ▽ More Hard spheres are an important benchmark of our understanding of natural and synthetic systems. In this work, colloidal experiments and Monte Carlo simulations examine the equilibrium and out-of-equilibrium assembly of hard spheres of diameter $σ$ within cylinders of diameter $σ\leq D\leq 2.82σ$. Although in such a system phase transitions formally do not exist, marked structural crossovers are observed. In simulations, we find that the resulting pressure-diameter structural diagram echoes the densest packing sequence obtained at infinite pressure in this range of $D$. We also observe that the out-of-equilibrium self-assembly depends on the compression rate. Slow compression approximates equilibrium results, while fast compression can skip intermediate structures. Crossovers for which no continuous line-slip exists are found to be dynamically unfavorable, which is the source of this difference. Results from colloidal sedimentation experiments at high Péclet number are found to be consistent with the results of fast compressions, as long as appropriate boundary conditions are used. The similitude between compression and sedimentation results suggests that the assembly pathway does not here sensitively depend on the nature of the out-of-equilibrium dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures and 63 references

Journal ref: Soft Matter 13, 3296-3306 (2017)