Role of the plurality rule in multiple choices
Authors:
Angelo M. Calvão,
Marlon Ramos,
Celia Anteneodo
Abstract:
People are often challenged to select one among several alternatives. This situation is present not only in decisions about complex issues, e.g., political or academic choices, but also about trivial ones, as in daily purchases at a supermarket. We tackle this scenario by means of the tools of statistical mechanics. Following this approach, we introduce and analyze a model of opinion dynamics, usi…
▽ More
People are often challenged to select one among several alternatives. This situation is present not only in decisions about complex issues, e.g., political or academic choices, but also about trivial ones, as in daily purchases at a supermarket. We tackle this scenario by means of the tools of statistical mechanics. Following this approach, we introduce and analyze a model of opinion dynamics, using a Potts-like state variable to represent the multiple choices, including the ``undecided state'', that represents the individuals that do not make a choice. We investigate the dynamics over Erdös-Rényi and Barabási-Albert networks, two paradigmatic classes with the small-world property, and we show the impact of the type of network on the opinion dynamics. Depending on the number of available options $q$ and on the degree distribution of the network of contacts, different final steady states are accessible: from a wide distribution of choices to a state where a given option largely dominates. The abrupt transition between them is consistent with the sudden viral dominance of a given option over many similar ones. Moreover, the probability distributions produced by the model are validated by real data. Finally, we show that the model also contemplates the real situation of overchoice, where a large number of similar alternatives makes the choice process harder and indecision prevail.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
Stylized facts in Brazilian vote distributions
Authors:
Angelo Mondaini Calvão,
Nuno Crokidakis,
Celia Anteneodo
Abstract:
Elections, specially in countries such as Brazil with an electorate of the order of 100 million people, yield large-scale data-sets embodying valuable information on the dynamics through which individuals influence each other and make choices. In this work we perform an extensive analysis of data sets available for Brazilian proportional elections of legislators and city councillors throughout the…
▽ More
Elections, specially in countries such as Brazil with an electorate of the order of 100 million people, yield large-scale data-sets embodying valuable information on the dynamics through which individuals influence each other and make choices. In this work we perform an extensive analysis of data sets available for Brazilian proportional elections of legislators and city councillors throughout the period 1970-2012, which embraces two distinct political regimes: a military dictatorship and a democratic phase. Through the distribution $P(v)$ of the number of candidates receiving $v$ votes, we perform a comparative analysis of different elections in the same calendar and as a function of time. The distributions $P(v)$ present a scale-free regime with a power-law exponent $α$ which is not universal and appears to be characteristic of the electorate. Moreover, we observe that $α$ typically increases with time. We propose a multi-species model consisting in a system of nonlinear differential equations with stochastic parameters that allows to understand the empirical observations. We conclude that the power-law exponent $α$ constitutes a measure of the degree of feedback of the electorate interactions. To know the interactivity of the population is relevant beyond the context of elections, since a similar feedback may occur in other social contagion processes.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2015; v1 submitted 24 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
