-
Photoelastic Grain Solver v2.0: An updated tool for analysis of force measurements in granular materials
Authors:
Carmen L. Lee,
Lori McCabe,
Ben McMillan,
Abrar Naseer,
Dong Xie,
Ted Brzinski,
Karen E. Daniels,
Tejas Murthy,
Kerstin Nordstrom
Abstract:
Photoelastic force imaging is an experimental technique whereby a birefringent granular material is imaged with a polariscope to characterize the internal stress state of a granular material. Photoelasticimetry is the only proven experimental technique that allows researchers to measure the shear and normal forces at every particle contact in a granular packing. In 2017, Kollmer et al. [Rev. Sci.…
▽ More
Photoelastic force imaging is an experimental technique whereby a birefringent granular material is imaged with a polariscope to characterize the internal stress state of a granular material. Photoelasticimetry is the only proven experimental technique that allows researchers to measure the shear and normal forces at every particle contact in a granular packing. In 2017, Kollmer et al. [Rev. Sci. Instrum. 88, 051808 (2017)] developed an open-source software to perform this analysis. Here, we present the next substantial update to this software package. The new version improves resolution and efficiency and substantially changes the software architecture. The structural changes better facilitate add-ons, modules, and future improvements to the performance, accessibility, and versatility of the tool. Besides updates to the core software, we introduce new infrastructure to support the ongoing development of software, documentation, and training materials. The full development team, software, and supporting resources are available at https://github.com/photoelasticity .
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
Properties of packings and dispersions of superellipse sector particles
Authors:
John Colt,
Lucas Nelson,
Sykes Cargile,
Ted Brzinski,
Scott V. Franklin
Abstract:
Superellipse sector particles (SeSPs) are segments of superelliptical curves that form a tunable set of hard-particle shapes for granular and colloidal systems. SeSPs allow for continuous parameterization of corner sharpness, aspect ratio, and particle curvature; rods, circles, rectangles, and staples are examples of shapes SeSPs can model. We compare three computational processes: pair-wise Monte…
▽ More
Superellipse sector particles (SeSPs) are segments of superelliptical curves that form a tunable set of hard-particle shapes for granular and colloidal systems. SeSPs allow for continuous parameterization of corner sharpness, aspect ratio, and particle curvature; rods, circles, rectangles, and staples are examples of shapes SeSPs can model. We compare three computational processes: pair-wise Monte Carlo simulations that look only at particle-particle geometric constraints, Monte Carlo simulations that look at how these geometric constraints play out over extended dispersions of many particles, and Molecular Dynamics simulations that allow particles to interact to form random loose and close packings. We investigate the dependence of critical random loose and close packing fractions on particle parameters, finding that both values tend to increase with opening aperture (as expected) and, in general, decrease with increasing corner sharpness. The identified packing fractions are compared with the mean-field prediction of the Random Contact Model. We find deviations from the model's prediction due to correlations between particle orientations. The complex interaction of spatial proximity and orientational alignment is explored using a generalized Spatio-Orientational Distribution Area (SODA) plot. Higher density packings are achieved through particles assuming a small number of preferred configurations which depend sensitively on particle shape and system preparation.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Jammed solids with pins: Thresholds, Force networks and Elasticity
Authors:
Andy L. Zhang,
Sean A. Ridout,
Celia Parts,
Aarushi Sachdeva,
Cacey S. Bester,
Katharina Vollmayr-Lee,
Brian C. Utter,
Ted Brzinski,
Amy L. Graves
Abstract:
The role of fixed degrees of freedom in soft/granular matter systems has broad applicability and theoretical interest. Here we address questions of the geometrical role that a scaffolding of fixed particles plays in tuning the threshold volume fraction and force network in the vicinity of jamming. Our 2d simulated system consists of soft particles and fixed "pins", both of which harmonically repel…
▽ More
The role of fixed degrees of freedom in soft/granular matter systems has broad applicability and theoretical interest. Here we address questions of the geometrical role that a scaffolding of fixed particles plays in tuning the threshold volume fraction and force network in the vicinity of jamming. Our 2d simulated system consists of soft particles and fixed "pins", both of which harmonically repel overlaps. On one hand, we find that many of the critical scalings associated with jamming in the absence of pins continue to hold in the presence of even dense pin latices. On the other hand, the presence of pins lowers the jamming threshold, in a universal way at low pin densities and a geometry-dependent manner at high pin densities, producing packings with lower densities and fewer contacts between particles. The onset of strong lattice dependence coincides with the development of bond-orientational order. Furthermore, the presence of pins dramatically modifies the network of forces, with both unusually weak and unusually strong forces becoming more abundant. The spatial organization of this force network depends on pin geometry and is described in detail. Using persistent homology we demonstrate that pins modify the topology of the network. Finally, we observe clear signatures of this developing bond-orientational order and broad force distribution in the elastic moduli which characterize the linear response of these packings to strain.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2022; v1 submitted 29 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
The Excluded Area of Superellipse Sector Particles
Authors:
Kellianne Kornick,
Ted Brzinski,
Scott V. Franklin
Abstract:
Superellipse sector particles (SeSPs) are segments of superelliptical curves that form a tunable set of hard-particle shapes for granular and colloidal systems. SeSPs allow for continuous parameterization of corner sharpness, aspect ratio, and particle curvature; rods, circles, rectangles, and staples are examples of shapes SeSPs can model. We investigate the space of allowable (non-overlapping) c…
▽ More
Superellipse sector particles (SeSPs) are segments of superelliptical curves that form a tunable set of hard-particle shapes for granular and colloidal systems. SeSPs allow for continuous parameterization of corner sharpness, aspect ratio, and particle curvature; rods, circles, rectangles, and staples are examples of shapes SeSPs can model. We investigate the space of allowable (non-overlapping) configurations of two SeSPs, which depends on both the center-of-mass separation and relative orientation. Radial correlation plots of the allowed configurations reveal circular regions centered at each of the particle's two endpoints that indicate configurations of mutually-entangled particle interactions. Simultaneous entanglement with both endpoints is geometrically impossible; the overlap of these two regions therefore represents an excluded area in which no particles can be placed regardless of orientation. The regions' distinct boundaries indicates a translational frustration with implications for the dynamics of particle rearrangements (e.g. under shear). Representing translational and rotational degrees of freedom as a hypervolume, we find a topological change that suggests geometric frustration arises a phase transition in this space. The excluded area is a straightforward integration over excluded states; for arbitrary relative orientation this decreases sigmoidally with increasing opening aperture, with sharper SeSP corners resulting in a sharper decrease. Together, this work offers a path towards a unified theory for particle shape-control of bulk material properties.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2021; v1 submitted 13 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Enlightening force chains: a review of photoelasticimetry in granular matter
Authors:
Aghil Abed Zadeh,
Jonathan Barés,
Theodore A. Brzinski,
Karen E. Daniels,
Joshua Dijksman,
Nicolas Docquier,
Henry Everitt,
Jonathan E. Kollmer,
Olivier Lantsoght,
Dong Wang,
Marcel Workamp,
Yiqiu Zhao,
Hu Zheng
Abstract:
A photoelastic material will reveal its internal stresses when observed through polarizing filters. This eye-catching property has enlightened our understanding of granular materials for over half a century, whether in the service of art, education, or scientific research. In this review article in honor of Robert Behringer, we highlight both his pioneering use of the method in physics research, a…
▽ More
A photoelastic material will reveal its internal stresses when observed through polarizing filters. This eye-catching property has enlightened our understanding of granular materials for over half a century, whether in the service of art, education, or scientific research. In this review article in honor of Robert Behringer, we highlight both his pioneering use of the method in physics research, and its reach into the public sphere through museum exhibits and outreach programs. We aim to provide clear protocols for artists, exhibit-designers, educators, and scientists to use in their own endeavors. It is our hope that this will build awareness about the ubiquitous presence of granular matter in our lives, enlighten its puzzling behavior, and promote conversations about its importance in environmental and industrial contexts. To aid in this endeavor, this paper also serves as a front door to a detailed wiki containing open, community-curated guidance on putting these methods into practice.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
The Hindered Settling Function at Low Re Has Two Branches
Authors:
T. A. Brzinski III,
D. J. Durian
Abstract:
We analyze hindered settling speed versus volume fraction $φ$ for dispersions of monodisperse spherical particles sedimenting under gravity, using data from 15 different studies drawn from the literature, as well as 12 measurements of our own. We discuss and analyze the results in terms of popular empirical forms for the hindered settling function, and compare to the known limiting behaviors. A si…
▽ More
We analyze hindered settling speed versus volume fraction $φ$ for dispersions of monodisperse spherical particles sedimenting under gravity, using data from 15 different studies drawn from the literature, as well as 12 measurements of our own. We discuss and analyze the results in terms of popular empirical forms for the hindered settling function, and compare to the known limiting behaviors. A significant finding is that the data fall onto two distinct branches, both of which are well-described by a hindered settling function of the Richardson-Zaki form $H(φ)=(1-φ)^n$ but with different exponents: $n=5.6\pm0.1$ for Brownian systems with Péclet number ${\rm Pe}<{\rm Pe}_c$, and $n=4.48\pm0.04$ for non-Brownian systems with ${\rm Pe}>{\rm Pe}_c$. The crossover Péclet number is ${\rm Pe}_c\approx10^8$, which is surprisingly large.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2018; v1 submitted 25 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Sounds of Failure: Passive Acoustic Measurements of Excited Vibrational Modes
Authors:
Theodore A. Brzinski,
Karen E. Daniels
Abstract:
Granular materials can fail through spontaneous events like earthquakes or brittle fracture. However, measurements and analytic models which forecast failure in this class of materials, while of both fundamental and practical interest, remain elusive. Materials including numerical packings of spheres, colloidal glasses, and granular materials have been known to develop an excess of low-frequency v…
▽ More
Granular materials can fail through spontaneous events like earthquakes or brittle fracture. However, measurements and analytic models which forecast failure in this class of materials, while of both fundamental and practical interest, remain elusive. Materials including numerical packings of spheres, colloidal glasses, and granular materials have been known to develop an excess of low-frequency vibrational modes as the confining pressure is reduced. Here, we report experiments on sheared granular materials in which we monitor the evolving density of excited modes via passive monitoring of acoustic emissions. We observe a broadening of the distribution of excited modes coincident with both bulk and local plasticity, and clear evolution in the shape of the distribution before and after bulk failure. These results provide a new interpretation of the changing state of the material on its approach to stick-slip failure.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2018; v1 submitted 30 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Penetration depth scaling for impact into wet granular packings
Authors:
Theodore A. Brzinski III,
Jorin Schug,
Kelly Mao,
Douglas J. Durian
Abstract:
We present experimental measurements of penetration depths for the impact of spheres into wetted granular media. We observe that the penetration depth in the liquid saturated case scales with projectile density, size, and drop height in a fashion consistent with the scaling observed in the dry case, but that penetration depths into saturated packings tend to be smaller. This result suggests that,…
▽ More
We present experimental measurements of penetration depths for the impact of spheres into wetted granular media. We observe that the penetration depth in the liquid saturated case scales with projectile density, size, and drop height in a fashion consistent with the scaling observed in the dry case, but that penetration depths into saturated packings tend to be smaller. This result suggests that, for the range of impact energies observed, the stopping force is set by static contact forces between grains within the bed, and that the presence of liquid serves, primarily, to enhance these contact forces. The enhancement to the stopping force has a complicated dependence on liquid fraction, accompanied by a change in the drop-height dependence, that must be the consequence of accompanying changes in the conformation of the liquid phase in the interstices.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2015; v1 submitted 31 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Depth-dependent resistance of granular media to vertical penetration
Authors:
T. A. Brzinski III,
P. Mayor,
D. J. Durian
Abstract:
We measure the quasi-static friction force acting on intruders moving downwards into a granular medium. By utilizing different intruder geometries, we demonstrate that the force acts locally normal to the intruder surface. By altering the hydrostatic loading of grain contacts by a sub-fluidizing airflow through the bed, we demonstrate that the relevant frictional contacts are loaded by gravity rat…
▽ More
We measure the quasi-static friction force acting on intruders moving downwards into a granular medium. By utilizing different intruder geometries, we demonstrate that the force acts locally normal to the intruder surface. By altering the hydrostatic loading of grain contacts by a sub-fluidizing airflow through the bed, we demonstrate that the relevant frictional contacts are loaded by gravity rather than by the motion of the intruder itself. Lastly, by measuring the final penetration depth versus airspeed and using an earlier result for inertial drag, we demonstrate that the same quasi-static friction force acts during impact. Altogether this force is set by a friction coefficient, hydrostatic pressure, projectile size and shape, and a dimensionless proportionality constant. The latter is the same in nearly all experiments, and is surprisingly greater than one.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2013; v1 submitted 17 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Affine and non-affine motions in sheared polydisperse jammed emulsions
Authors:
J. Clara-Rahola,
T. A. Brzinski,
D. Semwogerere,
K. Feitosa,
J. C. Crocker,
J. Sato,
V. Breedveld,
Eric R. Weeks
Abstract:
We study dense and highly polydisperse emulsions at droplet volume fractions φ>= 0.65. We apply oscillatory shear and observe droplet motion using confocal microscopy. The presence of droplets with sizes several times the mean size dramatically changes the motion of smaller droplets. Both affine and nonaffine droplet motions are observed, with the more nonaffine motion exhibited by the smaller dro…
▽ More
We study dense and highly polydisperse emulsions at droplet volume fractions φ>= 0.65. We apply oscillatory shear and observe droplet motion using confocal microscopy. The presence of droplets with sizes several times the mean size dramatically changes the motion of smaller droplets. Both affine and nonaffine droplet motions are observed, with the more nonaffine motion exhibited by the smaller droplets which are pushed around by the larger droplets. Droplet motions are correlated over length scales from one to four times the mean droplet diameter, with larger length scales corresponding to higher strain amplitudes (up to strains of about 6%).
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2014; v1 submitted 23 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
Characterization of the Drag Force in an Air-Moderated Granular Bed
Authors:
Theodore A Brzinski III,
Douglas J Durian
Abstract:
We measure the torque acting on a rod rotated perpendicular to its axis in a granular bed, through which an upflow of gas is utilized to tune the hydrostatic loading between grains. At low rotation rates the torque is independent of speed, but scales quadratically with rod-length and linearly with depth; the proportionality approaches zero linearly as the upflow of gas is increased towards a cri…
▽ More
We measure the torque acting on a rod rotated perpendicular to its axis in a granular bed, through which an upflow of gas is utilized to tune the hydrostatic loading between grains. At low rotation rates the torque is independent of speed, but scales quadratically with rod-length and linearly with depth; the proportionality approaches zero linearly as the upflow of gas is increased towards a critical value above which the grains are fluidized. At high rotation rates the torque exhibits quadratic rate- dependence and scales as the rod's length to the 4th power. The torque has no dependence on either depth or airflow at these higher rates. A model used to describe the stopping force experienced by a projectile impacting a granular bed can be shown to predict these behaviors for our system's geometry, indicating that the same mechanics dictate both steady-state and transient drag forces in granular systems, regardless of geometry or material properties of the grains.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
