Showing 1–50 of 64 results for author: Behringer, R

Dynamics of a grain-scale intruder in a two-dimensional granular medium with and without basal friction

Authors: Ryan Kozlowski, C. Manuel Carlevaro, Karen E. Daniels, Lou Kondic, Luis A. Pugnaloni, Joshua E. S. Socolar, Hu Zheng, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We report on a series of experiments in which a grain-sized intruder is pushed by a spring through a 2D granular material comprised of photoelastic disks in a Couette geometry. We study the intruder dynamics as a function of packing fraction for two types of supporting substrates: a frictional glass plate and a layer of water for which basal friction forces are negligible. We observe two dynamical… ▽ More We report on a series of experiments in which a grain-sized intruder is pushed by a spring through a 2D granular material comprised of photoelastic disks in a Couette geometry. We study the intruder dynamics as a function of packing fraction for two types of supporting substrates: a frictional glass plate and a layer of water for which basal friction forces are negligible. We observe two dynamical regimes: intermittent flow, in which the intruder moves freely most of the time but occasionally gets stuck, and stick-slip dynamics, in which the intruder advances via a sequence of distinct, rapid events. When basal friction is present, we observe a smooth crossover between the two regimes as a function of packing fraction, and we find that reducing the interparticle friction coefficient causes the stick-slip regime to shift to higher packing fractions. When basal friction is eliminated, we observe intermittent flow at all accessible packing fractions. For all cases, we present results for the statistics of stick events, the intruder velocity, and the force exerted on the intruder by the grains. Our results indicate the qualitative importance of basal friction at high packing fractions and suggest a possible connection between intruder dynamics in a static material and clogging dynamics in granular flows. △ Less

Submitted 8 October, 2019; v1 submitted 30 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 10 pages, 11 figures, 1 table. V2: What is now Fig. 5 was added to clarify the raw data measured. References [27] and [37] were updated since they were published only recently

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 100, 032905 (2019)

Dynamics of oblique impact in a photoelastic granular medium

Authors: Cacey Stevens Bester, Noah Cox, Hu Zheng, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: When a solid projectile impacts a granular target, it experiences a drag force and abruptly comes to rest as its momentum transfers to the grains. An empirical drag force law successfully describes the force experienced by the projectile, and the corresponding grain-scale mechanisms have been deciphered for normal impacts. However, there is little work exploring non-normal impacts. Accordingly, we… ▽ More When a solid projectile impacts a granular target, it experiences a drag force and abruptly comes to rest as its momentum transfers to the grains. An empirical drag force law successfully describes the force experienced by the projectile, and the corresponding grain-scale mechanisms have been deciphered for normal impacts. However, there is little work exploring non-normal impacts. Accordingly, we extend studies to explore oblique impact, in which a significant horizontal component of the drag force is present. In our experiments, a projectile impacts a quasi-two-dimensional bed of bidisperse photoelastic grains. We use high-speed imaging to measure high-resolution position data of the projectile trajectory and simultaneously visualize particle-scale force propagation in the granular medium. When the impact angle becomes important, the spatial structure of the stress response reveals relatively weak force chain propagation in the horizontal direction. Based on these observations, we describe the decrease of the inertial drag force with impact angle. △ Less

Submitted 24 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 7 pages, 6 figures

Shear jammed, fragile, and steady states in homogeneously strained granular materials

Authors: Yiqiu Zhao, Jonathan Barés, Hu Zheng, Joshua E. S. Socolar, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We study the jamming phase diagram of sheared granular material using a novel Couette shear set-up with multi-ring bottom. The set-up uses small basal friction forces to apply a volume-conserving linear shear with no shear band to a granular system composed of frictional photoelastic discs. The set-up can generate arbitrarily large shear strain due to its circular geometry, and the shear direction… ▽ More We study the jamming phase diagram of sheared granular material using a novel Couette shear set-up with multi-ring bottom. The set-up uses small basal friction forces to apply a volume-conserving linear shear with no shear band to a granular system composed of frictional photoelastic discs. The set-up can generate arbitrarily large shear strain due to its circular geometry, and the shear direction can be reversed, allowing us to measure a feature that distinguishes shear-jammed from fragile states. We report systematic measurements of the stress, strain and contact network structure at phase boundaries that have been difficult to access by traditional experimental techniques, including the yield stress curve and the jamming curve close to $φ_{SJ}\approx 0.74$, the smallest packing fraction supporting a shear-jammed state. We observe fragile states created under large shear strain over a range of $φ< φ_{SJ}$. We also find a transition in the character of the quasi-static steady flow centered around $φ_{SJ}$ on the yield curve as a function of packing fraction. Near $φ_{SJ}$, the average contact number, fabric anisotropy, and non-rattler fraction all show a change of slope. Above $φ_{F}\approx 0.7$ the steady flow shows measurable deviations from the basal linear shear profile, and above $φ_c\approx 0.78$ the flow is localized in a shear band. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2019; v1 submitted 22 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 158001 (2019)

Jamming transition in non-spherical particle systems: pentagons vs. disks

Authors: Yiqiu Zhao, Jonathan Barés, Hu Zheng, Cacey Stevens Bester, Yuanyuan Xu, Joshua E. S. Socolar, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We investigate the jamming transition in a quasi-2D granular material composed of regular pentagons or disks subjected to quasistatic uniaxial compression. We report six major findings based on experiments with monodisperse photoelastic particles with static friction coefficient $μ\approx 1$. (1) For both pentagons and disks, the onset of rigidity occurs when the average coordination number of non… ▽ More We investigate the jamming transition in a quasi-2D granular material composed of regular pentagons or disks subjected to quasistatic uniaxial compression. We report six major findings based on experiments with monodisperse photoelastic particles with static friction coefficient $μ\approx 1$. (1) For both pentagons and disks, the onset of rigidity occurs when the average coordination number of non-rattlers, $Z_{nr}$ , reaches 3, and the dependence of $Z_{nr}$ on the packing fraction $φ$ changes again when $Z_{nr}$ reaches 4. (2) Though the packing fractions $φ_{c1}$ and $φ_{c2}$ at these transitions differ from run to run, for both shapes the data from all runs with different initial configurations collapses when plotted as a function of the non-rattler fraction. (3) The averaged values of $φ_{c1}$ and $φ_{c2}$ for pentagons are around 1% smaller than those for disks. (4) Both jammed pentagons and disks show Gamma distribution of the Voronoi cell area with same parameters. (5) The jammed pentagons have similar translational order for particle centers but slightly less orientational order for contacting pairs comparing to jammed disks. (6) For jammed pentagons, the angle between edges at a face-to-vertex contact point shows a uniform distribution and the size of a cluster connected by face-to-face contacts shows a power-law distribution. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2019; v1 submitted 21 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Vibration can enhance stick-slip behavior for granular friction

Authors: Abram H. Clark, Robert P. Behringer, Jacqueline Krim

Abstract: We experimentally study the frictional behavior of a two-dimensional slider pulled slowly over a granular substrate comprised of photoelastic disks. The slider is vibrated at frequencies ranging from 0 to 30 Hz in a direction parallel to sliding. The applied vibrations have constant peak acceleration, which results in constant average friction levels. Surprisingly, we find that stick-slip behavior… ▽ More We experimentally study the frictional behavior of a two-dimensional slider pulled slowly over a granular substrate comprised of photoelastic disks. The slider is vibrated at frequencies ranging from 0 to 30 Hz in a direction parallel to sliding. The applied vibrations have constant peak acceleration, which results in constant average friction levels. Surprisingly, we find that stick-slip behavior, where stress slowly builds up and is released in intermittent slips, is enhanced as the frequency of vibration is increased. Our results suggest that increasing the frequency of vibration may help to combine many smaller rearrangements into fewer, but larger, avalanche-like slips, a mechanism unique to granular systems. We also examine the manner in which the self affine character of the force curves evolves with frequency, and we find additional support for this interpretation. △ Less

Submitted 16 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: Submitted to the special edition of Granular Matter, In Memoriam of Robert P. Behringer

Seismicity in sheared granular matter

Authors: Aghil Abed Zadeh, Jonathan Barés, Joshua Socolar, Robert Behringer

Abstract: We report on experiments investigating the dynamics of a slider that is pulled by a spring across a granular medium consisting of a vertical layer of photo-elastic disks. The motion proceeds through a sequence of discrete events, analogous to seismic shocks, in which elastic energy stored in the spring is rapidly released. We measure the statistics of several properties of the individual events: t… ▽ More We report on experiments investigating the dynamics of a slider that is pulled by a spring across a granular medium consisting of a vertical layer of photo-elastic disks. The motion proceeds through a sequence of discrete events, analogous to seismic shocks, in which elastic energy stored in the spring is rapidly released. We measure the statistics of several properties of the individual events: the energy loss in the spring, the duration of the movement, and the temporal profile of the slider motion. We also study certain conditional probabilities and the statistics of mainshock-aftershock sequences. At low driving rates, we observe crackling with Omori-Utsu, Bath, and waiting time laws similar to those observed in seismic dynamics. At higher driving rates, where the sequence of events shows strong periodicity, we observe scaling laws and asymmetrical event shapes that are clearly distinguishable from those in the crackling regime. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 99, 052902 (2019)

Crackling to periodic dynamics in sheared granular media

Authors: Aghil Abed Zadeh, Jonathan Barés, Robert Behringer

Abstract: The local and global dynamics of a sheared granular medium are studied in a model experiment as a function of several macroscopic parameters. We observe that by changing the shear rate or the loading stiffness, the system crackles, with intermittent slip avalanches, or exhibits periodic motion. By analyzing the global force, induced while shearing, we capture the transition from the crackling to t… ▽ More The local and global dynamics of a sheared granular medium are studied in a model experiment as a function of several macroscopic parameters. We observe that by changing the shear rate or the loading stiffness, the system crackles, with intermittent slip avalanches, or exhibits periodic motion. By analyzing the global force, induced while shearing, we capture the transition from the crackling to the periodic regime and associated scaling laws. We deduce a novel dynamic phase diagram as a function of the shear rate and the system's stiffness. Using photo-elasticimetry, we also capture the grain-scale stress evolution, and investigate the microscopic behavior in the different regimes. △ Less

Submitted 10 September, 2018; v1 submitted 15 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 99, 040901 (2019)

Characterizing Granular Networks Using Topological Metrics

Authors: Joshua A. Dijksman, Lenka Kovalcinova, Jie Ren, Robert P. Behringer, Miroslav Kramar, Konstantin Mischaikow, Lou Kondic

Abstract: We carry out a direct comparison of experimental and numerical realizations of the exact same granular system as it undergoes shear jamming. We adjust the numerical methods used to optimally represent the experimental settings and outcomes up to microscopic contact force dynamics. Measures presented here range form microscopic, through mesoscopic to system-wide characteristics of the system. Topol… ▽ More We carry out a direct comparison of experimental and numerical realizations of the exact same granular system as it undergoes shear jamming. We adjust the numerical methods used to optimally represent the experimental settings and outcomes up to microscopic contact force dynamics. Measures presented here range form microscopic, through mesoscopic to system-wide characteristics of the system. Topological properties of the mesoscopic force networks provide a key link between micro and macro scales. We report two main findings: the number of particles in the packing that have at least two contacts is a good predictor for the mechanical state of the system, regardless of strain history and packing density. All measures explored in both experiments and numerics, including stress tensor derived measures and contact numbers depend in a universal manner on the fraction of non-rattler particles, $f_{NR}$. The force network topology also tends to show this universality, yet the shape of the master curve depends much more on the details of the numerical simulations. In particular we show that adding force noise to the numerical data set can significantly alter the topological features in the data. We conclude that both $f_{NR}$ and topological metrics are useful measures to consider when quantifying the state of a granular system. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: 8 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 97, 042903 (2018)

`Sinking' in a bed of grains activated by shearing

Authors: Hu Zheng, Dong Wang, Jonathan Barés, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We show how a weak force, $f$, enables intruder motion through dense granular materials subject to external mechanical excitations, in the present case stepwise shearing. A force acts on a Teflon disc in a two dimensional system of photoelastic discs. This force is much smaller than the smallest force needed to move the disc without any external excitation. In a cycle, material + intruder are shea… ▽ More We show how a weak force, $f$, enables intruder motion through dense granular materials subject to external mechanical excitations, in the present case stepwise shearing. A force acts on a Teflon disc in a two dimensional system of photoelastic discs. This force is much smaller than the smallest force needed to move the disc without any external excitation. In a cycle, material + intruder are sheared quasi-statically from $γ= 0$ to $γ_{max}$, and then backwards to $γ= 0$. During various cycle phases, fragile and jammed states form. Net intruder motion, $δ$, occurs during fragile periods generated by shear reversals. $δ$ per cycle, e.g. the quasistatic rate $c$, is constant, linearly dependent on $γ_{max}$ and $f$. It vanishes as, $c \propto (φ_c - φ)^a$, with $a \simeq 3$ and $φ_c \simeq φ_J$, reflecting the stiffening of granular systems under shear as $φ\rightarrow φ_J$. The intruder motion induces large scale grain circulation. In the intruder frame, this motion is a granular analogue to fluid flow past a cylinder, where $f$ is the drag force exerted by the flow. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 4 pages, 5 figures letter with supplementaries

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 98, 010901 (2018)

Topology of Force Networks in Granular Media under Impact

Authors: Melody X. Lim, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We investigate the evolution of the force network in experimental systems of two-dimensional granular materials under impact. We use the first Betti number, $β_1$, and persistence diagrams, as measures of the topological properties of the force network. We show that the structure of the network has a complex, hysteretic dependence on both the intruder acceleration and the total force response of t… ▽ More We investigate the evolution of the force network in experimental systems of two-dimensional granular materials under impact. We use the first Betti number, $β_1$, and persistence diagrams, as measures of the topological properties of the force network. We show that the structure of the network has a complex, hysteretic dependence on both the intruder acceleration and the total force response of the granular material. $β_1$ can also distinguish between the nonlinear formation and relaxation of the force network. In addition, using the persistence diagram of the force network, we show that the size of the loops in the force network has a Poisson-like distribution, the characteristic size of which changes over the course of the impact. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Journal ref: EPL, 120 (2017) 44003

Local and global avalanches in a 2D sheared granular medium

Authors: Jonathan Barés, Dengming Wang, Dong Wang, Thibault Bertrand, Corey S. O'Hern, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We present the experimental and numerical studies of a 2D sheared amorphous material constituted of bidisperse photo-elastic disks. We analyze the statistics of avalanches during shear including the local and global fluctuations in energy and changes in particle positions and orientations. We find scale free distributions for these global and local avalanches denoted by power-laws whose cut-offs v… ▽ More We present the experimental and numerical studies of a 2D sheared amorphous material constituted of bidisperse photo-elastic disks. We analyze the statistics of avalanches during shear including the local and global fluctuations in energy and changes in particle positions and orientations. We find scale free distributions for these global and local avalanches denoted by power-laws whose cut-offs vary with inter-particle friction and packing fraction. Different exponents are found for these power-laws depending on the quantity from which variations are extracted. An asymmetry in time of the avalanche shapes is evidenced along with the fact that avalanches are mainly triggered from the shear bands. A simple relation independent from the intensity, is found between the number of local avalanches and the global avalanches they form. We also compare these experimental and numerical results for both local and global fluctuations to predictions from meanfield and depinning theories. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 96, 052902 (2017)

Force and Mass Dynamics in Non-Newtonian Suspensions

Authors: Melody X. Lim, Jonathan Barés, Hu Zheng, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: Above a certain solid fraction, dense granular suspensions in water exhibit non-Newtonian behavior, including impact-activated solidification. Although it has been suggested that solidification depends on boundary interactions, quantitative experiments on the boundary forces have not been reported. Using high-speed video, tracer particles, and photoelastic boundaries, we determine the impactor kin… ▽ More Above a certain solid fraction, dense granular suspensions in water exhibit non-Newtonian behavior, including impact-activated solidification. Although it has been suggested that solidification depends on boundary interactions, quantitative experiments on the boundary forces have not been reported. Using high-speed video, tracer particles, and photoelastic boundaries, we determine the impactor kinematics and the magnitude and timings of impactor-driven events in the body and at the boundaries of cornstarch suspensions. We observe mass shocks in the suspension during impact. The shockfront dynamics are strongly correlated to those of the intruder. However, the total momentum associated with this shock never approaches the initial impactor momentum. We also observe a faster second front, associated with the propagation of pressure to the boundaries of the suspension. The two fronts depend differently on the initial impactor speed, $v_0$, and the suspension packing fraction. The speed of the pressure wave is at least an order of magnitude smaller than (linear) ultrasound speeds obtained for much higher frequencies, pointing to complex amplitude and frequency response of cornstarch suspensions to compressive strains. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 2017; v1 submitted 4 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 184501 (2017)

Refractive Index Matched Scanning and Detection of Soft Particle

Authors: Joshua A. Dijksman, Nicolas Brodu, R. P. Behringer

Abstract: We describe here how to apply the three dimensional imaging technique of refrecative index matched scanning to hydrogel spheres. Hydrogels are water based materials with a low refractive index, which allows for index matching with water-based solvent mixtures. We discuss here various experimental techniques required to handle specifically hydrogel spheres as opposed to other transparent materials.… ▽ More We describe here how to apply the three dimensional imaging technique of refrecative index matched scanning to hydrogel spheres. Hydrogels are water based materials with a low refractive index, which allows for index matching with water-based solvent mixtures. We discuss here various experimental techniques required to handle specifically hydrogel spheres as opposed to other transparent materials. The deformability of hydrogel spheres makes their identification in three dimensional images non-trivial. We will also discuss numerical techniques that can be used in general to detect contacting, non-spherical particles in a three dimensional image. The experimental and numerical techniques presented here give experimental access to the stress tensor of a packing of deformed particles. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: 9 pages, 9 figures, submitted to review of scientific instruments, Issue 18

Granular Impact: A Grain-scale Approach

Authors: Abram H. Clark, Alec Petersen, Lou Kondic, Corey O'Hern, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: This work summarizes a series of studies on two-dimensional granular impact, where an intruding object strikes a granular material at high speed. Many previous studies on granular impact have used a macroscopic force law, which is dominated by an inertial drag term proportional to the intruder velocity squared. The primary focus here is on the microscopic force response of the granular material, a… ▽ More This work summarizes a series of studies on two-dimensional granular impact, where an intruding object strikes a granular material at high speed. Many previous studies on granular impact have used a macroscopic force law, which is dominated by an inertial drag term proportional to the intruder velocity squared. The primary focus here is on the microscopic force response of the granular material, and how the grain-scale effects give rise to this inertial drag term. We show that the inertial drag arises from intermittent collisions with force-chain-like structures. We construct a simple collisional model to explain the inertial drag, as well as off-axis instability and rotations. Finally, we show how the granular response changes when the intruder speed approaches $d/t_c$, leading to a failure of the inertial drag description in this regime. Here, $d$ is the mean particle diameter and $t_c$ the characteristic momentum-transfer time between two grains. △ Less

Submitted 2 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: This is draft version of a book chapter appearing in "Rapid Penetration into Granular Media" (eds. Iskander et al.)

Journal ref: Chapter 10 - Granular Impact: A Grain-scale Approach, In Rapid Penetration into Granular Media, Elsevier, Oxford, 2015, Pages 319-351, ISBN 9780128008683

Collisional Model of Energy Dissipation in 3D Granular Impact

Authors: Cacey Stevens Bester, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We study the dynamic process occurring when a granular assembly is displaced by a solid impactor. The momentum transfer from the impactor to the target is shown to occur through sporadic, normal collisions of high force carrying grains at the intruder surface. We therefore describe the stopping force of the impact through a collisional based model. To verify the model in impact experiments, we det… ▽ More We study the dynamic process occurring when a granular assembly is displaced by a solid impactor. The momentum transfer from the impactor to the target is shown to occur through sporadic, normal collisions of high force carrying grains at the intruder surface. We therefore describe the stopping force of the impact through a collisional based model. To verify the model in impact experiments, we determine the forces acting on an intruder decelerating through a dense granular medium using high-speed imaging of its trajectory. By varying the intruder shape and granular target, intruder-grain interactions are inferred from the consequent path. As a result, we connect the drag to the effect of intruder shape and grain density based on a proposed collisional model. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 95, 032906 (2017)

Packings of 3D stars: Stability and structure

Authors: Yuchen Zhao, Kevin Liu, Matthew Zheng, Jonathan Barés, Karola Dierichs, Achim Menges, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We describe a series of experiments involving the creation of cylindrical packings of star-shaped particles, and an exploration of the stability of these packings. The stars cover a broad range of arm sizes and frictional properties. We carried out three different kinds of experiments, all of which involve columns that are prepared by raining star particles one-by-one into hollow cylinders. As an… ▽ More We describe a series of experiments involving the creation of cylindrical packings of star-shaped particles, and an exploration of the stability of these packings. The stars cover a broad range of arm sizes and frictional properties. We carried out three different kinds of experiments, all of which involve columns that are prepared by raining star particles one-by-one into hollow cylinders. As an additional part of the protocol, we sometimes vibrated the column before removing the confining cylinder. We rate stability in terms of r, the ratio of the mass of particles that fall off a pile when it collapsed, to the total particle mass. The first experiment involved the intrinsic stability of the pile when the confining cylinder was removed. The second kind of experiment involved adding a uniform load to the top of the column, and then determining the collapse properties. A third experiment involved testing stability to tipping of the piles. We find a stability diagram relating the pile height, h, vs. pile diameter, delta, where the stable and unstable regimes are separated by a boundary that is roughly a power-law in h vs. delta with an exponent that is less than one. Increasing friction and vibration both tend to stabilize piles, while increasing particle size can destabilize the system under certain conditions. △ Less

Submitted 18 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 9 Pages, 9 figures. Submitted to Granular Matter

Journal ref: Granular Matter 18, 24 (2016)

Self-organized magnetic particles to tune the mechanical behaviour of a granular system

Authors: Meredith Cox, Dong Wang, Jonathan Barés, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: Above a certain density a granular material jams. This property can be controlled by either tuning a global property, such as the packing fraction or by applying shear strain, or at the micro-scale by tuning grain shape, inter-particle friction or externally controlled organization. Here, we introduce a novel way to change a local granular property by adding a weak anisotropic magnetic interaction… ▽ More Above a certain density a granular material jams. This property can be controlled by either tuning a global property, such as the packing fraction or by applying shear strain, or at the micro-scale by tuning grain shape, inter-particle friction or externally controlled organization. Here, we introduce a novel way to change a local granular property by adding a weak anisotropic magnetic interaction between particles. We measure the evolution of the pressure, $P$, and coordination number, $Z$, for a packing of 2D photo-elastic disks, subject to uniaxial compression. Some of the particles have embedded cuboidal magnets. The strength of the magnetic interactions between particles are too weak to have a strong direct effect on $P$ or $Z$ when the system is jammed. However, the magnetic interactions play an important role in the evolution of latent force networks when systems containing a large enough fraction of the particles with magnets are driven through unjammed states. In this case, a statistically stable network of magnetic chains self-organizes and overlaps with force chains, strengthening the granular medium. We believe this property can be used to reversibly control mechanical properties of granular materials. △ Less

Submitted 6 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures

Orientation, Flow, and Clogging in a Two-Dimensional Hopper: Ellipses vs. Disks

Authors: Junyao Tang, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: Two-dimensional (2D) hopper flow of disks has been extensively studied. Here, we investigate hopper flow of ellipses with aspect ratio $α= 2$, and we contrast that behavior to the flow of disks. We use a quasi-2D hopper containing photoelastic particles to obtain stress/force information. We simultaneously measure the particle motion and stress. We determine several properties, including discharge… ▽ More Two-dimensional (2D) hopper flow of disks has been extensively studied. Here, we investigate hopper flow of ellipses with aspect ratio $α= 2$, and we contrast that behavior to the flow of disks. We use a quasi-2D hopper containing photoelastic particles to obtain stress/force information. We simultaneously measure the particle motion and stress. We determine several properties, including discharge rates, jamming probabilities, and the number of particles in clogging arches. For both particle types, the size of the opening, $D$, relative to the size of particles, $\ell$ is an important dimensionless measure. The orientation of the ellipses plays an important role in flow rheology and clogging. The alignment of contacting ellipses enhances the probability of forming stable arches. This study offers insight for applications involving the flow of granular materials consisting of ellipsoidal shapes, and possibly other non-spherical shapes. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2015; v1 submitted 27 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

Comments: 6 pages, 11 figures

Steady Flow Dynamics during Granular Impact

Authors: Abram H. Clark, Lou Kondic, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We study experimentally and computationally the dynamics of granular flow during impacts, where intruders strike a collection of disks from above. In the regime where granular force dynamics are much more rapid than the intruder motion, we find that the particle flow near the intruder is proportional to the instantaneous intruder speed; it is essentially constant when normalized by that speed. The… ▽ More We study experimentally and computationally the dynamics of granular flow during impacts, where intruders strike a collection of disks from above. In the regime where granular force dynamics are much more rapid than the intruder motion, we find that the particle flow near the intruder is proportional to the instantaneous intruder speed; it is essentially constant when normalized by that speed. The granular flow is nearly divergence-free and remains in balance with the intruder, despite the latter's rapid deceleration. Simulations indicate that this observation is insensitive to grain properties, which can be explained by the separation of time scales between intergrain force dynamics and intruder dynamics. Assuming there is a comparable separation of time scales, we expect our results are applicable to a broad class of dynamic or transient granular flows. Our results suggest that descriptions of static-in-time granular flows might be extended or modified to describe these dynamic flows. Additionally, we find that accurate grain-grain interactions are not necessary to correctly capture the granular flow in this regime. △ Less

Submitted 28 April, 2016; v1 submitted 6 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 93, 050901 (2016)

Shear-induced rigidity of frictional particles: Analysis of emergent order in stress space

Authors: Sumantra Sarkar, Dapeng Bi, Jie Zhang, Jie Ren, R. P. Behringer, Bulbul Chakraborty

Abstract: Solids are distinguished from fluids by their ability to resist shear. In traditional solids, the resistance to shear is associated with the emergence of broken translational symmetry as exhibited by a non-uniform density pattern, which results from either minimizing the energy cost or maximizing the entropy or both. In this work, we focus on a class of systems, where this paradigm is challenged.… ▽ More Solids are distinguished from fluids by their ability to resist shear. In traditional solids, the resistance to shear is associated with the emergence of broken translational symmetry as exhibited by a non-uniform density pattern, which results from either minimizing the energy cost or maximizing the entropy or both. In this work, we focus on a class of systems, where this paradigm is challenged. We show that shear-driven jamming in dry granular materials is a collective process controlled solely by the constraints of mechanical equilibrium. We argue that these constraints lead to a broken translational symmetry in a dual space that encodes the statistics of contact forces and the topology of the contact network. The shear-jamming transition is marked by the appearance of this broken symmetry. We extend our earlier work, by comparing and contrasting real space measures of rheology with those obtained from the dual space. We investigate the structure and behavior of the dual space as the system evolves through the rigidity transition in two different shear protocols. We analyze the robustness of the shear-jamming scenario with respect to protocol and packing fraction, and demonstrate that it is possible to define a protocol-independent order parameter in this dual space, which signals the onset of rigidity. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2017; v1 submitted 2 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: 14 pages, 17 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 93, 042901 (2016)

Protocol dependence of the jamming transition

Authors: T. Bertrand, R. P. Behringer, B. Chakraborty, C. S. O'Hern, M. D. Shattuck

Abstract: We propose a theoretical framework for predicting the protocol dependence of the jamming transition for frictionless spherical particles that interact via purely repulsive contact forces. We study isostatic jammed disk packings obtained via two protocols: isotropic compression and simple shear. We show that for frictionless systems, all jammed packings can be obtained via either protocol. However,… ▽ More We propose a theoretical framework for predicting the protocol dependence of the jamming transition for frictionless spherical particles that interact via purely repulsive contact forces. We study isostatic jammed disk packings obtained via two protocols: isotropic compression and simple shear. We show that for frictionless systems, all jammed packings can be obtained via either protocol. However, the probability to obtain a particular jammed packing depends on the packing-generation protocol. We predict the average shear strain required to induce jamming in initially unjammed packings from the measured probability to jam at packing fraction $φ$ from isotropic compression. We compare our predictions to results from numerical simulations of jamming and find quantitative agreement. We also show that the packing fraction range, over which strain-induced jamming occurs, tends to zero in the large system limit for frictionless packings with overdamped dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2016; v1 submitted 16 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: 8 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 93, 012901 (2016)

MC-DEM: a novel simulation scheme for modeling dense granular media

Authors: Nicolas Brodu, Joshua A. Dijksman, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: This article presents a new force model for performing quantitative simulations of dense granular materials. Interactions between multiple contacts (MC) on the same grain are explicitly taken into account. Our readily applicable method retains all the advantages of discrete element method (DEM) simulations and does not require the use of costly finite element methods. The new model closely reprodu… ▽ More This article presents a new force model for performing quantitative simulations of dense granular materials. Interactions between multiple contacts (MC) on the same grain are explicitly taken into account. Our readily applicable method retains all the advantages of discrete element method (DEM) simulations and does not require the use of costly finite element methods. The new model closely reproduces our recent experimental measurements, including contact force distributions in full 3D, at all compression levels up to the experimental maximum limit of 13\%. Comparisons with traditional non-deformable spheres approach are provided, as well as with alternative models for interactions between multiple contacts. The success of our model compared to these alternatives demonstrates that interactions between multiple contacts on each grain must be included for dense granular packings. △ Less

Submitted 23 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Spanning the Scales of Granular Materials: Microscopic Force Imaging

Authors: Nicolas Brodu, Joshua A. Dijksman, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: If you walk on sand, it supports your weight. How do the disordered forces between particles in sand organize, to keep you from sinking? This simple question is surprisingly difficult to answer experimentally: measuring forces in three dimensions, between deeply buried grains, is challenging. We describe here experiments in which we have succeeded in measuring forces inside a granular packing subj… ▽ More If you walk on sand, it supports your weight. How do the disordered forces between particles in sand organize, to keep you from sinking? This simple question is surprisingly difficult to answer experimentally: measuring forces in three dimensions, between deeply buried grains, is challenging. We describe here experiments in which we have succeeded in measuring forces inside a granular packing subject to controlled deformations. We connect the measured micro-scale forces to the macro-scale packing force response with an averaging, mean field calculation. This calculation explains how the combination of packing structure and contact deformations produce the unexpected mechanical response of the packing, and reveals a surprising microscopic particle deformation enhancement mechanism. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 2014; originally announced August 2014.

Comments: Data and code available at http://www.phy.duke.edu/~nb108/

Nonlinear Force Propagation during Granular Impact

Authors: Abram H. Clark, Alec J. Petersen, Lou Kondic, R. P. Behringer

Abstract: We experimentally study nonlinear force propagation into granular material during impact from an intruder, and we explain our observations in terms of the nonlinear grain-scale force relation. Using high-speed video and photoelastic particles, we determine the speed and spatial structure of the force response just after impact. We show that these quantities depend on a dimensionless parameter,… ▽ More We experimentally study nonlinear force propagation into granular material during impact from an intruder, and we explain our observations in terms of the nonlinear grain-scale force relation. Using high-speed video and photoelastic particles, we determine the speed and spatial structure of the force response just after impact. We show that these quantities depend on a dimensionless parameter, $M'=t_c v_0/d$, where $v_0$ is the intruder speed at impact, $d$ is the particle diameter, and $t_c$ is the collision time for a pair of grains impacting at relative speed $v_0$. The experiments access a large range of $M'$ by using particles of three different materials. When $M' \ll 1$, force propagation is chain-like with a speed, $v_f$, satisfying $v_f \propto d/t_c$. For larger $M'$, the force response becomes spatially dense and the force propagation speed departs from $v_f\propto d/t_c$, corresponding to collective stiffening of a strongly compressed packing of grains. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2015; v1 submitted 8 August, 2014; originally announced August 2014.

Comments: 3 figures, 5 pages

Shear Jamming in Granular Experiments without Basal Friction

Authors: Hu Zheng, Joshua A. Dijksman, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: Jammed states of frictional granular systems can be induced by shear strain at densities below the isostatic jamming density ($φ_c$). It remains unclear, however, how much friction affects this so-called shear-jamming. Friction appears in two ways in this type of experiment: friction between particles, and friction between particles and the base on which they rest. Here, we study how particle-bott… ▽ More Jammed states of frictional granular systems can be induced by shear strain at densities below the isostatic jamming density ($φ_c$). It remains unclear, however, how much friction affects this so-called shear-jamming. Friction appears in two ways in this type of experiment: friction between particles, and friction between particles and the base on which they rest. Here, we study how particle-bottom friction, or basal friction, affects shear jamming in quasi-two dimensional experiments. In order to study this issue experimentally, we apply simple shear to a disordered packing of photoelastic disks. We can tune the basal friction of the particles by immersing the particles in a density matched liquid, thus removing the normal force, hence the friction, between the particles and base. We record the overall shear stress, and particle motion, and the photoelastic response of the particles. We compare the shear response of dry and immersed samples, which enables us to determine how basal friction affects shear jamming. Our findings indicate that changing the basal friction shifts the point of shear jamming, but it does not change the basic phenomenon of shear jamming. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2014; v1 submitted 29 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: EPL 107, 34005 (2014)

Collisional Model for Granular Impact Dynamics

Authors: Abram H. Clark, Alec J. Petersen, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: When an intruder strikes a granular material from above, the grains exert a stopping force which decelerates and stops the intruder. Many previous studies have used a macroscopic force law, including a drag force which is quadratic in velocity, to characterize the decelerating force on the intruder. However, the microscopic origins of the force law terms are still a subject of debate. Here, drawin… ▽ More When an intruder strikes a granular material from above, the grains exert a stopping force which decelerates and stops the intruder. Many previous studies have used a macroscopic force law, including a drag force which is quadratic in velocity, to characterize the decelerating force on the intruder. However, the microscopic origins of the force law terms are still a subject of debate. Here, drawing from previous experiments with photoelastic particles, we present a model which describes the velocity-squared force in terms of repeated collisions with clusters of grains. From our high speed photoelastic data, we infer that `clusters' correspond to segments of the strong force network that are excited by the advancing intruder. The model predicts a scaling relation for the velocity-squared drag force that accounts for the intruder shape. Additionally, we show that the collisional model predicts an instability to rotations, which depends on the intruder shape. To test this model, we perform a comprehensive experimental study of the dynamics of two-dimensional granular impacts on beds of photoelastic disks, with different profiles for the leading edge of the intruder. We particularly focus on a simple and useful case for testing shape effects by using triangular-nosed intruders. We show that the collisional model effectively captures the dynamics of intruder deceleration and rotation; i.e., these two dynamical effects can be described as two different manifestations of the same grain-scale physical processes. △ Less

Submitted 16 December, 2013; v1 submitted 11 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 14 pages, 13 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 89, 012201 (2014)

Dynamics of Sheared Ellipses and Circular Disks: Effects of Particle Shape

Authors: Somayeh Farhadi, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: Much recent effort has focused on glassy and jamming properties of spherical particles. Very little is known about such phenomena for non-spherical particles, and we take a first step by studying ellipses. We find important differences between the dynamical and structural properties of disks and two-dimensional ellipses subject to continuous Couette shear. In particular, ellipses show slow dynamic… ▽ More Much recent effort has focused on glassy and jamming properties of spherical particles. Very little is known about such phenomena for non-spherical particles, and we take a first step by studying ellipses. We find important differences between the dynamical and structural properties of disks and two-dimensional ellipses subject to continuous Couette shear. In particular, ellipses show slow dynamical evolution, without a counterpart in disks, in the mean velocity, local density, orientational order, and local stress. starting from an unjammed state, ellipses can first jam under shear, and then slowly unjam. The slow unjamming process is understood as a result of gradual changes in their orientations, leading to a denser packing. For disks, the rotation of particles only contributes to relaxation of frictional forces, and hence, does not significantly cause structural changes. For the shear-jammed states, the global building up and relaxation of stress, which occurs in the form of stress avalanches, is qualitatively different for disks and ellipses, and is manifested by different forms of rate-dependence for ellipses vs. disks. Unlike the weak rate dependence typical for many granular systems, ellipses show power-law dependence on the shearing rate, Ω. △ Less

Submitted 17 February, 2014; v1 submitted 27 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: Submitted to Physical Review Letters

Stress relaxation for granular materials near Jamming under cyclic compression

Authors: Somayeh Farhadi, Robert P Behringer, Alex Z Zhu

Abstract: We have explored isotropically jammed states of semi-2D granular materials through cyclic compression. In each compression cycle, systems of either identical ellipses or bi-disperse disks, transition between jammed and unjammed states. We determine the evolution of the average pressure, P, and structure through consecutive jammed states. We observe a transition point, φm, above which P persists ov… ▽ More We have explored isotropically jammed states of semi-2D granular materials through cyclic compression. In each compression cycle, systems of either identical ellipses or bi-disperse disks, transition between jammed and unjammed states. We determine the evolution of the average pressure, P, and structure through consecutive jammed states. We observe a transition point, φm, above which P persists over many cycles; below φm, P relaxes slowly. The relaxation time scale associated with P increases with packing fraction, while the relaxation time scale for collective particle motion remains constant. The collective motion of the ellipses is hindered compared to disks, due to the rotational constraints on elliptical particles. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 5 pages

Jet-induced 2-D crater formation with horizontal symmetry breaking

Authors: Abram H. Clark, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We investigate the formation of a crater in a 2-D bed of granular material by a jet of impinging gas, motivated by the problem of a retrograde rocket landing on a planetary surface. The crater is characterized in terms of depth and shape as it evolves, as well as by the horizontal position of the bottom of the crater. The crater tends to grow logarithmically in time, a result which is common in re… ▽ More We investigate the formation of a crater in a 2-D bed of granular material by a jet of impinging gas, motivated by the problem of a retrograde rocket landing on a planetary surface. The crater is characterized in terms of depth and shape as it evolves, as well as by the horizontal position of the bottom of the crater. The crater tends to grow logarithmically in time, a result which is common in related experiments. We also observe a horizontal symmetry breaking at certain well-defined conditions which, as we will demonstrate, could be of considerable practical concern for lunar or planetary landers. We present data on the evolution of these asymmetric states and attempt to give insights into the mechanism behind the symmetry-breaking bifurcation. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 8 pages, 10 figures

Origin of Rigidity in Dry Granular Solids

Authors: Sumantra Sarkar, Dapeng Bi, Jie Zhang, R. P. Behringer, Bulbul Chakraborty

Abstract: Solids are distinguished from fluids by their ability to resist shear. In traditional solids, the resistance to shear is associated with the emergence of broken translational symmetry as exhibited by a non-uniform density pattern. In this work, we focus on the emergence of shear-rigidity in a class of solids where this paradigm is challenged. Dry granular materials have no energetically or entropi… ▽ More Solids are distinguished from fluids by their ability to resist shear. In traditional solids, the resistance to shear is associated with the emergence of broken translational symmetry as exhibited by a non-uniform density pattern. In this work, we focus on the emergence of shear-rigidity in a class of solids where this paradigm is challenged. Dry granular materials have no energetically or entropically preferred density modulations. We show that, in contrast to traditional solids, the emergence of shear rigidity in these granular solids is a collective process, which is controlled solely by boundary forces, the constraints of force and torque balance, and the positivity of the contact forces. We develop a theoretical framework based on these constraints, which connects rigidity to broken translational symmetry in the space of forces, not positions of grains. We apply our theory to experimentally generated shear-jammed (SJ) states and show that these states are indeed characterized by a persistent, non-uniform density modulation in force space, which emerges at the shear-jamming transition. △ Less

Submitted 29 July, 2013; v1 submitted 15 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures, To appear in Phys. Rev. Lett

The Jamming point street-lamp in the world of granular media

Authors: Corentin Coulais, Robert P. Behringer, Olivier Dauchot

Abstract: The Jamming of soft spheres at zero temperature, the J-point, has been extensively studied both numerically and theoretically and can now be considered as a safe location in the space of models, where a street lamp has been lit up. However, a recent work by Ikeda et al, 2013 reveals that, in the Temperature/Packing fraction parameter space, experiments on colloids are actually rather far away from… ▽ More The Jamming of soft spheres at zero temperature, the J-point, has been extensively studied both numerically and theoretically and can now be considered as a safe location in the space of models, where a street lamp has been lit up. However, a recent work by Ikeda et al, 2013 reveals that, in the Temperature/Packing fraction parameter space, experiments on colloids are actually rather far away from the scaling regime illuminated by this lamp. Is it that the J-point has little to say about real system? What about granular media? Such a-thermal, frictional, systems are a-priori even further away from the idealized case of thermal soft spheres. In the past ten years, we have systematically investigated horizontally shaken grains in the vicinity of the Jamming transition. We discuss the above issue in the light of very recent experimental results. First, we demonstrate that the contact network exhibits a remarkable dynamics, with strong heterogeneities, which are maximum at a packing fraction phi star, distinct and smaller than the packing fraction phi dagger, where the average number of contact per particle starts to increase. The two cross-overs converge at point J in the zero mechanical excitation limit. Second, a careful analysis of the dynamics on time scales ranging from a minute fraction of the vibration cycle to several thousands of cycles allows us to map the behaviors of this shaken granular system onto those observed for thermal soft spheres and demonstrate that some light of the J-point street-lamp indeed reaches the granular universe. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: 20 pages, 23 figures, submitted to Soft Matter

Journal ref: Soft Matter, 10, 1519-1536 (2014)

Fluctuations in Shear-Jammed States: A Statistical Ensemble Approach

Authors: Dapeng Bi, Jie Zhang, R. P. Behringer, Bulbul Chakraborty

Abstract: Granular matter exists out of thermal equilibrium, i.e. it is athermal. While conventional equilibrium statistical mechanics is not useful for characterizing granular materials, the idea of constructing a statistical ensemble analogous to its equilibrium counterpart to describe static granular matter was proposed by Edwards and Oakshott more than two decades ago. Recent years have seen several imp… ▽ More Granular matter exists out of thermal equilibrium, i.e. it is athermal. While conventional equilibrium statistical mechanics is not useful for characterizing granular materials, the idea of constructing a statistical ensemble analogous to its equilibrium counterpart to describe static granular matter was proposed by Edwards and Oakshott more than two decades ago. Recent years have seen several implementations of this idea. One of these is the stress ensemble, which is based on properties of the force moment tensor, and applies to frictional and frictionless grains. We demonstrate the full utility of this statistical framework in shear jammed (SJ) experimental states [1,2], a special class of granular solids created by pure shear, which is a strictly non-equilbrium protocol for creating solids. We demonstrate that the stress ensemble provides an excellent quantitative description of fluctuations in experimental SJ states. We show that the stress fluctuations are controlled by a single tensorial quantity: the angoricity of the system, which is a direct analog of the thermodynamic temperature. SJ states exhibit significant correlations in local stresses and are thus inherently different from density-driven, isotropically jammed (IJ) states. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures

Granular Impact Model as an Energy-Depth Relation

Authors: Abram H. Clark, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: Velocity-squared drag forces are common in describing an object moving through a granular material. The resulting force law is a nonlinear differential equation, and closed-form solutions of the dynamics are typically obtained by making simplifying assumptions. Here, we consider a generalized version of such a force law which has been used in many studies of granular impact. We show that recasting… ▽ More Velocity-squared drag forces are common in describing an object moving through a granular material. The resulting force law is a nonlinear differential equation, and closed-form solutions of the dynamics are typically obtained by making simplifying assumptions. Here, we consider a generalized version of such a force law which has been used in many studies of granular impact. We show that recasting the force law into an equation for the kinetic energy versus depth, K(z), yields a linear differential equation, and thus general closed-form solutions for the velocity versus depth. This approach also has several advantages in fitting such models to experimental data, which we demonstrate by applying it to data from 2D impact experiments. We also present new experimental results for this model, including shape and depth dependence of the velocity-squared drag force. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2013; v1 submitted 24 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Journal ref: A. H. Clark and R. P. Behringer 2013 EPL 101 64001

Granular Impact Dynamics: Acoustics and Fluctuations

Authors: Abram H. Clark, R. P. Behringer

Abstract: In the corresponding fluid dynamics video, created for the APS DFD 2012 Gallery of Fluid Motion, we show high-speed videos of 2D granular impact experiments, where an intruder strikes a collection of bidisperse photoelastic disks from above. We discuss the force beneath the intruder, which is strongly fluctuating in space and time. These fluctuations correspond to acoustic pulses which propagate i… ▽ More In the corresponding fluid dynamics video, created for the APS DFD 2012 Gallery of Fluid Motion, we show high-speed videos of 2D granular impact experiments, where an intruder strikes a collection of bidisperse photoelastic disks from above. We discuss the force beneath the intruder, which is strongly fluctuating in space and time. These fluctuations correspond to acoustic pulses which propagate into the medium. Analysis shows that this process, in our experiments, is dominated by collisions with grain clusters. The energy from these collisions is carried into the granular medium along networks of grains, where is it dissipated. △ Less

Submitted 12 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: Created for DFD 2012 Gallery of Fluid Dynamics

Particle Scale Dynamics in Granular Impact

Authors: Abram. H. Clark, Lou Kondic, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We perform an experimental study of granular impact, where intruders strike 2D beds of photoelastic disks from above. High-speed video captures the intruder dynamics and the local granular force response, allowing investigation of grain-scale mechanisms in this process. We observe rich acoustic behavior at the leading edge of the intruder, strongly fluctuating in space and time, and we show that t… ▽ More We perform an experimental study of granular impact, where intruders strike 2D beds of photoelastic disks from above. High-speed video captures the intruder dynamics and the local granular force response, allowing investigation of grain-scale mechanisms in this process. We observe rich acoustic behavior at the leading edge of the intruder, strongly fluctuating in space and time, and we show that this acoustic activity controls the intruder deceleration, including large force fluctuations at short time scales. The average intruder dynamics match previous studies using empirical force laws, suggesting a new microscopic picture, where acoustic energy is carried away and dissipated. △ Less

Submitted 5 December, 2012; v1 submitted 28 August, 2012; originally announced August 2012.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 238302 (2012)

Reynolds Pressure and Relaxation in a Sheared Granular System

Authors: Jie Ren, Joshua A. Dijksman, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We describe experiments that probe the evolution of shear jammed states, occurring for packing fractions $φ_S \leq φ\leq φ_J$, for frictional granular disks, where above $φ_J$ there are no stress-free static states. We use a novel shear apparatus that avoids the formation of inhomogeneities known as shear bands. This fixed $φ$ system exhibits coupling between the shear strain, $γ$, and the pressur… ▽ More We describe experiments that probe the evolution of shear jammed states, occurring for packing fractions $φ_S \leq φ\leq φ_J$, for frictional granular disks, where above $φ_J$ there are no stress-free static states. We use a novel shear apparatus that avoids the formation of inhomogeneities known as shear bands. This fixed $φ$ system exhibits coupling between the shear strain, $γ$, and the pressure, $P$, which we characterize by the `Reynolds pressure', and a `Reynolds coefficient', $R(φ) = (\partial ^2 P/\partial γ^2)/2$. $R$ depends only on $φ$, and diverges as $R \sim (φ_c - φ)^α$, where $φ_c \simeq φ_J$, and $α\simeq -3.3$. Under cyclic shear, this system evolves logarithmically slowly towards limit cycle dynamics, which we characterize in terms of pressure relaxation at cycle $n$: $ΔP \simeq -β\ln(n/n_0)$. $β$ depends only on the shear cycle amplitude, suggesting an activated process where $β$ plays a temperature-like role. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2013; v1 submitted 30 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures

Contacts Dynamics Reveals Widom Lines for Jamming

Authors: C. Coulais, R. P. Behringer, O. Dauchot

Abstract: We experimentally study the vicinity of the Jamming transition by investigating the statics and the dynamics of the contact network of an horizontally shaken bi-disperse packing of photo-elastic discs. Compressing the packing very slowly, while maintaining a mechanical excitation, yields a granular glass, namely a frozen structure of vibrating grains. In this glass phase, we observe a remarkable d… ▽ More We experimentally study the vicinity of the Jamming transition by investigating the statics and the dynamics of the contact network of an horizontally shaken bi-disperse packing of photo-elastic discs. Compressing the packing very slowly, while maintaining a mechanical excitation, yields a granular glass, namely a frozen structure of vibrating grains. In this glass phase, we observe a remarkable dynamics of the contact network, which exhibits strong dynamical heterogeneities. Such heterogeneities are maximum at a packing fraction $φ^*$, \emph{distinct} and smaller than the jamming packing fraction $φ_J$, which is indicated by the abrupt variation of the average number of contact per particle. We demonstrate that the two cross-overs, one for the maximum dynamical heterogeneity, and the other for static jamming, converge at point J in the zero mechanical excitation limit, a behavior reminiscent of the Widom lines in the supercritical phase of a second order critical point. Our findings are discussed in the light of recent numerical and theoretical studies of thermal soft spheres. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2012; v1 submitted 25 February, 2012; originally announced February 2012.

Comments: 5 pages, 5 figures, to appear in EPL

Journal ref: EPL 100 (2012) 44005

Statistical Properties of a 2D Granular Material Subjected to Cyclic Shear

Authors: J. Zhang, T. S. Majmudar, A. Tordesillas, R. P. Behringer

Abstract: This work focuses on the evolution of structure and stress for an experimental system of 2D photoelastic particles that is subjected to multiple cycles of pure shear. Throughout this process, we determine the contact network and the contact forces using particle tracking and photoelastic techniques. These data yield the fabric and stress tensors and the distributions of contact forces in the nor… ▽ More This work focuses on the evolution of structure and stress for an experimental system of 2D photoelastic particles that is subjected to multiple cycles of pure shear. Throughout this process, we determine the contact network and the contact forces using particle tracking and photoelastic techniques. These data yield the fabric and stress tensors and the distributions of contact forces in the normal and tangential directions. We then find that there is, to a reasonable approximation, a functional relation between the system pressure, $P$, and the mean contact number, $Z$. This relationship applies to the shear stress $τ$, except for the strains in the immediate vicinity of the contact network reversal. By contrast, quantities such as $P$, $τ$ and $Z$ are strongly hysteretic functions of the strain, $ε$. We find that the distributions of normal and tangential forces, when expressed in terms of the appropriate means, are essentially independent of strain. We close by analyzing a subset of shear data in terms of strong and weak force networks. △ Less

Submitted 12 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 10 pages and 28 figures

Entropic origin of stress correlations in granular materials

Authors: Gregg Lois, Jie Zhang, Trushant S. Majmudar, Silke Henkes, Bulbul Chakraborty, Corey S. O'Hern, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We study the response of granular materials to external stress using experiment, simulation, and theory. We derive an entropic, Ginzburg-Landau functional that enforces mechanical stability and positivity of contact forces. In this framework, the elastic moduli depend only on the applied stress. A combination of this feature and the positivity constraint leads to stress correlations whose shape… ▽ More We study the response of granular materials to external stress using experiment, simulation, and theory. We derive an entropic, Ginzburg-Landau functional that enforces mechanical stability and positivity of contact forces. In this framework, the elastic moduli depend only on the applied stress. A combination of this feature and the positivity constraint leads to stress correlations whose shape and magnitude are extremely sensitive to the applied stress. The predictions from the theory describe the stress correlations for both simulations and experiments semiquantitatively. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 4 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 80, 060303(R) (2009).

Why Do Granular Materials Stiffen with Shear Rate? A Test of Novel Stress-Based Statistics

Authors: Robert P. Behringer, Dapeng Bi, Bulbul Chakraborty, Silke Henkes, Robert R. Hartley

Abstract: Recent experiments exhibit a rate-dependence for granular shear such that the stress grows linearly in the logarithm of the shear rate, \dotγ. Assuming a generalized activated process mechanism, we show that these observations are consistent with a recent proposal for a stress-based statistical ensemble. By contrast, predictions for rate-dependence using conventional energy-based statistical mec… ▽ More Recent experiments exhibit a rate-dependence for granular shear such that the stress grows linearly in the logarithm of the shear rate, \dotγ. Assuming a generalized activated process mechanism, we show that these observations are consistent with a recent proposal for a stress-based statistical ensemble. By contrast, predictions for rate-dependence using conventional energy-based statistical mechanics to describe activated processes, predicts a rate dependence that of (\ln (\dotγ))^{1/2}. △ Less

Submitted 27 October, 2008; originally announced October 2008.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures

Signal propagation through dense granular systems

Authors: L. Kondic, O. M. Dybenko, R. P. Behringer

Abstract: The manner in which signals propagate through dense granular systems in both space and time is not well understood. In order to learn more about this process, we carry out discrete element simulations of the system response to excitations where we control the driving frequency and wavelength independently. Fourier analysis shows that properties of the signal depend strongly on the spatial and te… ▽ More The manner in which signals propagate through dense granular systems in both space and time is not well understood. In order to learn more about this process, we carry out discrete element simulations of the system response to excitations where we control the driving frequency and wavelength independently. Fourier analysis shows that properties of the signal depend strongly on the spatial and temporal scales introduced by the perturbation. The features of the response provide a test-bed for any continuum theory attempting to predict signal properties. We illustrate this connection between micro-scale physics and macro-scale behavior by comparing the system response to a simple elastic model with damping. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 2008; originally announced May 2008.

Comments: 10 pages, 4 figures

Force networks and elasticity in granular silos

Authors: John F. Wambaugh, Robert R. Hartley, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We have made experimental observations of the force networks within a two-dimensional granular silo similar to the classical system of Janssen. Models like that of Janssen predict that pressure within a silo saturates with depth as the result of vertical forces being redirected to the walls of the silo where they can then be carried by friction. By averaging ensembles of experimentally-obtained… ▽ More We have made experimental observations of the force networks within a two-dimensional granular silo similar to the classical system of Janssen. Models like that of Janssen predict that pressure within a silo saturates with depth as the result of vertical forces being redirected to the walls of the silo where they can then be carried by friction. By averaging ensembles of experimentally-obtained force networks in different ways, we compare the observed behavior with various predictions for granular silos. We identify several differences between the mean behavior in our system and that predicted by Janssen-like models: We find that the redirection parameter describing how the force network transfers vertical forces to the walls varies with depth. We find that changes in the preparation of the material can cause the pressure within the silo to either saturate or to continue building with depth. Most strikingly, we observe a non-linear response to overloads applied to the top of the material in the silo. For larger overloads we observe the previously reported "giant overshoot" effect where overload pressure decays only after an initial increase [G. Ovarlez et al., Phys. Rev. E 67, 060302(R) (2003)]. For smaller overloads we find that additional pressure propagates to great depth. This effect depends on the particle stiffness, as given for instance by the Young's modulus, E, of the material from which the particles are made. Important measures include E, the unscreened hydrostatic pressure, and the applied load. These experiments suggest that when the load and the particle weight are comparable, particle elasticity acts to stabilize the force network, allowing non-linear network effects to be seen in the mean behavior. △ Less

Submitted 22 January, 2008; originally announced January 2008.

Comments: 12 pages, 17 figures

Experimental Measures of Affine and Non-affine Deformation in Granular Shear

Authors: Brian Utter, R. P. Behringer

Abstract: Through 2D granular Couette flow experiments, we probe failure and deformation of disordered solids under shear. Shear produces smooth affine deformations in such a solid and also irresversible so-called non-affine particle displacements. We examine both processes. We show that the non-affine part is associated with diffusion, and also can be used to define a granular temperature. Distributions… ▽ More Through 2D granular Couette flow experiments, we probe failure and deformation of disordered solids under shear. Shear produces smooth affine deformations in such a solid and also irresversible so-called non-affine particle displacements. We examine both processes. We show that the non-affine part is associated with diffusion, and also can be used to define a granular temperature. Distributions for single particle non-affine displacements, $\dri$, satisfy $P_1(\dri) \propto \exp [-|\dri/Δr|^α]$ ($α\stackrel{<}{\sim} 2$). We suggest that the shear band forms due to a radially outward diffusive flux/non-affine motion which is balanced in the steady state by inward diffusion due to density gradients. △ Less

Submitted 14 February, 2007; originally announced February 2007.

Comments: 4 pages, 5 figures

Response to perturbations for granular flow in a hopper

Authors: John F. Wambaugh, John V. Matthews, Pierre A. Gremaud, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We experimentally investigate the response to perturbations of circular symmetry for dense granular flow inside a three-dimensional right-conical hopper. These experiments consist of particle tracking velocimetry for the flow at the outer boundary of the hopper. We are able to test commonly used constitutive relations and observe granular flow phenomena that we can model numerically. Unperturbed… ▽ More We experimentally investigate the response to perturbations of circular symmetry for dense granular flow inside a three-dimensional right-conical hopper. These experiments consist of particle tracking velocimetry for the flow at the outer boundary of the hopper. We are able to test commonly used constitutive relations and observe granular flow phenomena that we can model numerically. Unperturbed conical hopper flow has been described as a radial velocity field with no azimuthal component. Guided by numerical models based upon continuum descriptions, we find experimental evidence for secondary, azimuthal circulation in response to perturbation of the symmetry with respect to gravity by tilting. For small perturbations we can discriminate between constitutive relations, based upon the agreement between the numerical predictions they produce and our experimental results. We find that the secondary circulation can be suppressed as wall friction is varied, also in agreement with numerical predictions. For large tilt angles we observe the abrupt onset of circulation for parameters where circulation was previously suppressed. Finally, we observe that for large tilt angles the fluctuations in velocity grow, independent of the onset of circulation. △ Less

Submitted 15 November, 2007; v1 submitted 2 January, 2007; originally announced January 2007.

Comments: 10 pages, 11 figures (revised for publication)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 76, 051303 (2007)

The Jamming Transition in Granular Systems

Authors: T. S. Majmudar, M. Sperl, S. Luding, R. P. Behringer

Abstract: Recent simulations have predicted that near jamming for collections of spherical particles, there will be a discontinuous increase in the mean contact number, Z, at a critical volume fraction, phi_c. Above phi_c, Z and the pressure, P are predicted to increase as power laws in phi-phi_c. In experiments using photoelastic disks we corroborate a rapid increase in Z at phi_c and power-law behavior… ▽ More Recent simulations have predicted that near jamming for collections of spherical particles, there will be a discontinuous increase in the mean contact number, Z, at a critical volume fraction, phi_c. Above phi_c, Z and the pressure, P are predicted to increase as power laws in phi-phi_c. In experiments using photoelastic disks we corroborate a rapid increase in Z at phi_c and power-law behavior above phi_c for Z and P. Specifically we find power-law increase as a function of phi-phi_c for Z-Z_c with an exponent beta around 0.5, and for P with an exponent psi around 1.1. These exponents are in good agreement with simulations. We also find reasonable agreement with a recent mean-field theory for frictionless particles. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2006; v1 submitted 23 October, 2006; originally announced October 2006.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures, 2 pages supplement; minor changes and clarifications, 2 addtl. refs., accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. Lett

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 058001 (2007).

Instabilities in droplets spreading on gels

Authors: Karen E. Daniels, Shomeek Mukhopadhyay, Paul J. Houseworth, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We report a novel surface-tension driven instability observed for droplets spreading on a compliant substrate. When a droplet is released on the surface of an agar gel, it forms arms/cracks when the ratio of surface tension gradient to gel strength is sufficiently large. We explore a range of gel strengths and droplet surface tensions and find that the onset of the instability and the number of… ▽ More We report a novel surface-tension driven instability observed for droplets spreading on a compliant substrate. When a droplet is released on the surface of an agar gel, it forms arms/cracks when the ratio of surface tension gradient to gel strength is sufficiently large. We explore a range of gel strengths and droplet surface tensions and find that the onset of the instability and the number of arms depend on the ratio of surface tension to gel strength. However, the arm length grows with an apparently universal law L ~ t^{3/4}. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2007; v1 submitted 12 June, 2006; originally announced June 2006.

Characterization of a Freezing/Melting Transition in a Vibrated and Sheared Granular Medium

Authors: Karen E. Daniels, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: We describe experiments on monodisperse spherical particles in an annular cell geometry, vibrated from below and sheared from above. This system shows a freezing/melting transition such that under sufficient vibration a crystallized state is observed, which can be melted by sufficient shear. We characterize the hysteretic transition between these two states, and observe features reminiscent of b… ▽ More We describe experiments on monodisperse spherical particles in an annular cell geometry, vibrated from below and sheared from above. This system shows a freezing/melting transition such that under sufficient vibration a crystallized state is observed, which can be melted by sufficient shear. We characterize the hysteretic transition between these two states, and observe features reminiscent of both a jamming transition and critical phenomena. △ Less

Submitted 21 December, 2005; originally announced December 2005.

From the stress response function (back) to the sandpile `dip'

Authors: A. P. F. Atman, P. Brunet, J. Geng, G. Reydellet, P. Claudin, R. P. Behringer, E. Clément

Abstract: We relate the pressure `dip' observed at the bottom of a sandpile prepared by successive avalanches to the stress profile obtained on sheared granular layers in response to a localized vertical overload. We show that, within a simple anisotropic elastic analysis, the skewness and the tilt of the response profile caused by shearing provide a qualitative agreement with the sandpile dip effect. We… ▽ More We relate the pressure `dip' observed at the bottom of a sandpile prepared by successive avalanches to the stress profile obtained on sheared granular layers in response to a localized vertical overload. We show that, within a simple anisotropic elastic analysis, the skewness and the tilt of the response profile caused by shearing provide a qualitative agreement with the sandpile dip effect. We conclude that the texture anisotropy produced by the avalanches is in essence similar to that induced by a simple shearing -- albeit tilted by the angle of repose of the pile. This work also shows that this response function technique could be very well adapted to probe the texture of static granular packing. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2005; v1 submitted 6 January, 2005; originally announced January 2005.

Comments: 8 pages, 8 figures, accepted version to appear in Eur. Phys. J. E

Sensitivity of the stress response function to packing preparation

Authors: A. P. F. Atman, P. Brunet, J. Geng, G. Reydellet, G. Combe, P. Claudin, R. P. Behringer, E. Clément

Abstract: A granular assembly composed of a collection of identical grains may pack under different microscopic configurations with microscopic features that are sensitive to the preparation history. A given configuration may also change in response to external actions such as compression, shearing etc. We show using a mechanical response function method developed experimentally and numerically, that the… ▽ More A granular assembly composed of a collection of identical grains may pack under different microscopic configurations with microscopic features that are sensitive to the preparation history. A given configuration may also change in response to external actions such as compression, shearing etc. We show using a mechanical response function method developed experimentally and numerically, that the macroscopic stress profiles are strongly dependent on these preparation procedures. These results were obtained for both two and three dimensions. The method reveals that, under a given preparation history, the macroscopic symmetries of the granular material is affected and in most cases significant departures from isotropy should be observed. This suggests a new path toward a non-intrusive test of granular material constitutive properties. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2005; v1 submitted 29 November, 2004; originally announced November 2004.

Comments: 15 pages, 11 figures, some numerical data corrected, to appear in J. Phys. Cond. Mat. special issue on Granular Materials (M. Nicodemi Editor)

Hysteresis and competition between disorder and crystallization in sheared and vibrated granular flow

Authors: Karen E. Daniels, Robert P. Behringer

Abstract: Experiments on spherical particles in a 3D Couette cell vibrated from below and sheared from above show a hysteretic freezing/melting transition. Under sufficient vibration a crystallized state is observed, which can be melted by sufficient shear. The critical line for this transition coincides with equal kinetic energies for vibration and shear. The force distribution is double-peaked in the cr… ▽ More Experiments on spherical particles in a 3D Couette cell vibrated from below and sheared from above show a hysteretic freezing/melting transition. Under sufficient vibration a crystallized state is observed, which can be melted by sufficient shear. The critical line for this transition coincides with equal kinetic energies for vibration and shear. The force distribution is double-peaked in the crystalline state and single-peaked with an approximately exponential tail in the disordered state. A linear relation between pressure and volume ($dP/dV > 0$) exists for a continuum of partially and/or intermittently melted states over a range of parameters. △ Less

Submitted 4 October, 2004; originally announced October 2004.