-
Glass-like dynamics of the strain-induced coil/helix transition on a permanent polymer network
Authors:
O. Ronsin,
C. Caroli,
T Baumberger
Abstract:
We study the stress response to a step strain of covalently bonded gelatin gels in the temperature range where triple helix reversible crosslink formation is prohibited. We observe slow stress relaxation towards a $T$-dependent finite asymptotic level. We show that this is assignable to the strain-induced coil $\rightarrow$ helix transition, previously evidenced by S. Courty, J.L. Gornall and E.M.…
▽ More
We study the stress response to a step strain of covalently bonded gelatin gels in the temperature range where triple helix reversible crosslink formation is prohibited. We observe slow stress relaxation towards a $T$-dependent finite asymptotic level. We show that this is assignable to the strain-induced coil $\rightarrow$ helix transition, previously evidenced by S. Courty, J.L. Gornall and E.M. Terentjev (PNAS, {\bf 102}, 13453 (2005)), of a fraction of the polymer strands. Relaxation proceeds, in a first stage, according to a stretched exponential dynamics, then crosses over to a terminal simple exponential decay. The respective characteristic times $τ_{K}$ and $τ_{f}$ exhibit an Arrhenius-like $T$-dependence with an associated energy $\cal E$ incompatibly larger than the activation barrier height for the isomerisation process which sets the clock for an elementary coil $\to$ helix transformation event. We tentatively assign this glass-like slowing down of the dynamics to the long-range couplings due to the mechanical noise generated by the local elementary events in this random elastic medium.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Two-step build-up of a thermoreversible polymer network: From early local to late collective dynamics
Authors:
H. Souguir,
O. Ronsin,
C. Caroli,
T. Baumberger
Abstract:
We probe the mechanisms at work in the build-up of thermoreversible gel networks, with the help of hybrid gelatin gels containing a controlled density of irreversible, covalent crosslinks (CL), which we quench below the physical gelation temperature. The detailed analysis of the dependence on covalent crosslink density of both the shear modulus and optical activity evolutions with time after quenc…
▽ More
We probe the mechanisms at work in the build-up of thermoreversible gel networks, with the help of hybrid gelatin gels containing a controlled density of irreversible, covalent crosslinks (CL), which we quench below the physical gelation temperature. The detailed analysis of the dependence on covalent crosslink density of both the shear modulus and optical activity evolutions with time after quench enables us to identify two stages of the physical gelation process, separated by a temperature dependent crossover modulus: (i) an early nucleation regime during which rearrangements of the triple-helix CL play a negligible role, (ii) a late, logarithmic aging one, which is preserved, though slowed down, in the presence of irreversible CL. We show that aging is fully controlled by rearrangements and discuss the implication of our results in terms of the switch from an early, local dynamics to a late, cooperative long-range one.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Crack front échelon instability in mixed mode fracture of a strongly nonlinear elastic solid
Authors:
O. Ronsin,
C. Caroli,
T. Baumberger
Abstract:
Mixed mode (I+III) loading induces segmented crack front échelon structures connected by steps. We study this instability in a highly deformable, strain-hardening material. We find that échelons develop beyond a finite, size-independent mode mixity threshold, markedly growing with energy release rate. They appear via nucleation of localized helical front distortions, and their emergence is the con…
▽ More
Mixed mode (I+III) loading induces segmented crack front échelon structures connected by steps. We study this instability in a highly deformable, strain-hardening material. We find that échelons develop beyond a finite, size-independent mode mixity threshold, markedly growing with energy release rate. They appear via nucleation of localized helical front distortions, and their emergence is the continuation of the mode I cross-hatching instability of gels and rubbers, shifted by the biasing effect of shear. This result, at odds with the direct bifurcation predicted by linear elastic fracture mechanics, can be assigned to the controlling role of elastic nonlinearity.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Interplay between shear loading and structural aging in a physical gel
Authors:
O. Ronsin,
C. Caroli,
T. Baumberger
Abstract:
We show that the aging of the mechanical relaxation of a gelatin gel exhibits the same scaling phenomenology as polymer and colloidal glasses. Besides, gelatin is known to exhibit logarithmic structural aging (stiffening). We find that stress accelerates this process. However, this effect is definitely irreducible to a mere age shift with respect to natural aging. We suggest that it is interpret…
▽ More
We show that the aging of the mechanical relaxation of a gelatin gel exhibits the same scaling phenomenology as polymer and colloidal glasses. Besides, gelatin is known to exhibit logarithmic structural aging (stiffening). We find that stress accelerates this process. However, this effect is definitely irreducible to a mere age shift with respect to natural aging. We suggest that it is interpretable in terms of elastically-aided elementary (coil$\to$helix) local events whose dynamics gradually slows down as aging increases geometric frustration.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
A convective instability mechanism for quasistatic crack branching in a hydrogel
Authors:
T. Baumberger,
O. Ronsin
Abstract:
Experiments on quasistatic crack propagation in gelatin hydrogels reveal a new branching instability triggered by wetting the tip opening with a drop of aqueous solvent less viscous than the bulk one. We show that the emergence of unstable branches results from a balance between the rate of secondary crack growth and the rate of advection away from a non-linear elastic region of size…
▽ More
Experiments on quasistatic crack propagation in gelatin hydrogels reveal a new branching instability triggered by wetting the tip opening with a drop of aqueous solvent less viscous than the bulk one. We show that the emergence of unstable branches results from a balance between the rate of secondary crack growth and the rate of advection away from a non-linear elastic region of size $\mathcal G/E$ where $\mathcal G$ is the fracture energy and $E$ the small strain Young modulus. We build a minimal, predictive model that combines mechanical characteristics of this mesoscopic region and physical features of the process zone. It accounts for the details of the stability diagram and lends support to the idea that non-linear elasticity plays a critical role in crack front instabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2009; v1 submitted 27 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
From thermally activated to viscosity controlled fracture of biopolymer hydrogels
Authors:
T. Baumberger,
O. Ronsin
Abstract:
We report on rate-dependent fracture energy measurements over three decades of steady crack velocities in alginate and gelatin hydrogels. We evidence that, irrespective of gel thermo-reversibility, thermally activated "unzipping" of the non-covalent cross-link zones results in slow crack propagation, prevaling against the toughening effect of viscous solvent drag during chain pull-out, which bec…
▽ More
We report on rate-dependent fracture energy measurements over three decades of steady crack velocities in alginate and gelatin hydrogels. We evidence that, irrespective of gel thermo-reversibility, thermally activated "unzipping" of the non-covalent cross-link zones results in slow crack propagation, prevaling against the toughening effect of viscous solvent drag during chain pull-out, which becomes efficient above a few mm.s$^{-1}$. We extend a previous model [Baumberger {\it et al.} Nature Materials, {\bf 5}, 552 (2006)] to account for both mechanisms, and estimate the microscopic unzipping rates.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
Magic angles and cross-hatching instability in hydrogel fracture
Authors:
Tristan Baumberger,
Christiane Caroli,
David Martina,
Olivier Ronsin
Abstract:
The full 2D analysis of roughness profiles of fracture surfaces resulting from quasi-static crack propagation in gelatin gels reveals an original behavior characterized by (i) strong anisotropy with maximum roughness at $V$-independent symmetry-preserving angles, (ii) a sub-critical instability leading, below a critical velocity, to a cross-hatched regime due to straight macrosteps drifting at t…
▽ More
The full 2D analysis of roughness profiles of fracture surfaces resulting from quasi-static crack propagation in gelatin gels reveals an original behavior characterized by (i) strong anisotropy with maximum roughness at $V$-independent symmetry-preserving angles, (ii) a sub-critical instability leading, below a critical velocity, to a cross-hatched regime due to straight macrosteps drifting at the same magic angles and nucleated on crack-pinning network inhomogeneities. Step height values are determined by the width of the strain-hardened zone, governed by the elastic crack blunting characteristic of soft solids with breaking stresses much larger that low strain moduli.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2008; v1 submitted 10 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Frictional dissipation of polymeric solids vs interfacial glass transition
Authors:
Lionel Bureau,
Christiane Caroli,
Tristan Baumberger
Abstract:
We present single contact friction experiments between a glassy polymer and smooth silica substrates grafted with alkylsilane layers of different coverage densities and morphologies. This allows us to adjust the polymer/substrate interaction strength. We find that, when going from weak to strong interaction, the response of the interfacial junction where shear localizes evolves from that of a hi…
▽ More
We present single contact friction experiments between a glassy polymer and smooth silica substrates grafted with alkylsilane layers of different coverage densities and morphologies. This allows us to adjust the polymer/substrate interaction strength. We find that, when going from weak to strong interaction, the response of the interfacial junction where shear localizes evolves from that of a highly viscous threshold fluid to that of a plastically deformed glassy solid. This we analyse as resulting from an interaction-induced ``interfacial glass transition'' helped by pressure.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
Fracture of a biopolymer gel as a viscoplastic disentanglement process
Authors:
Tristan Baumberger,
Christiane Caroli,
David Martina
Abstract:
We present an extensive experimental study of mode-I, steady, slow crack dynamics in gelatin gels. Taking advantage of the sensitivity of the elastic stiffness to gel composition and history we confirm and extend the model for fracture of physical hydrogels which we proposed in a previous paper (Nature Materials, doi:10.1038/nmat1666 (2006)), which attributes decohesion to the viscoplastic pull-…
▽ More
We present an extensive experimental study of mode-I, steady, slow crack dynamics in gelatin gels. Taking advantage of the sensitivity of the elastic stiffness to gel composition and history we confirm and extend the model for fracture of physical hydrogels which we proposed in a previous paper (Nature Materials, doi:10.1038/nmat1666 (2006)), which attributes decohesion to the viscoplastic pull-out of the network-constituting chains. So, we propose that, in contrast with chemically cross-linked ones, reversible gels fracture without chain scission.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
Solvent control of crack dynamics in a reversible hydrogel
Authors:
Tristan Baumberger,
Christiane Caroli,
David Martina
Abstract:
The resistance to fracture of reversible biopolymer hydrogels is an important control factor of the cutting/slicing and eating characteristics of food gels. It is also critical for their utilization in tissue engineering, for which mechanical protection of encapsulated components is needed. Its dependence on loading rate and, recently, on the density and strength of cross-links has been investig…
▽ More
The resistance to fracture of reversible biopolymer hydrogels is an important control factor of the cutting/slicing and eating characteristics of food gels. It is also critical for their utilization in tissue engineering, for which mechanical protection of encapsulated components is needed. Its dependence on loading rate and, recently, on the density and strength of cross-links has been investigated. But no attention was paid so far to solvent nor to environment effects. Here we report a systematic study of crack dynamics in gels of gelatin in water/glycerol mixtures. We show on this model system that: (i) increasing solvent viscosity slows down cracks; (ii) soaking with solvent increases markedly gel fragility; (iii) tuning the viscosity of the (miscible) environmental liquid affects crack propagation via diffusive invasion of the crack tip vicinity. The results point toward the fact that fracture occurs by viscoplastic chain pull-out. This mechanism, as well as the related phenomenology, should be common to all reversibly cross-linked (physical) gels.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2006;
originally announced May 2006.
-
Non-Amontons behavior of friction in single contacts
Authors:
Lionel Bureau,
Tristan Baumberger,
Christiane Caroli
Abstract:
We report on the frictional properties of a single contact between a glassy polymer lens and a flat silica substrate covered either by a disordered or by a self-assembled alkylsilane monolayer. We find that, in contrast to common belief, the Amontons proportionality between frictional and normal stresses does not hold. Besides, we observe that the velocity dependence of the sliding stress is str…
▽ More
We report on the frictional properties of a single contact between a glassy polymer lens and a flat silica substrate covered either by a disordered or by a self-assembled alkylsilane monolayer. We find that, in contrast to common belief, the Amontons proportionality between frictional and normal stresses does not hold. Besides, we observe that the velocity dependence of the sliding stress is strongly sensitive to the structure of the silane layer. Analysis of the frictional rheology observed on both disordered and self-assembled monolayers suggests that dissipation is controlled by the plasticity of a glass-like interfacial layer in the former case, and by pinning of polymer chains on the substrate in the latter one.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.
-
Solid Friction from stick-slip to pinning and aging
Authors:
Tristan Baumberger,
Christiane Caroli
Abstract:
We review the present state of understanding of solid friction at low velocities and for systems with negligibly small wear effects.
We first analyze in detail the behavior of friction at interfaces between wacroscopic hard rough solids, whose main dynamical features are well described by the Rice-Ruina rate and state dependent constitutive law. We show that it results from two combined effect…
▽ More
We review the present state of understanding of solid friction at low velocities and for systems with negligibly small wear effects.
We first analyze in detail the behavior of friction at interfaces between wacroscopic hard rough solids, whose main dynamical features are well described by the Rice-Ruina rate and state dependent constitutive law. We show that it results from two combined effects : (i) the threshold rheology of nanometer-thick junctions jammed under confinement into a soft glassy structure (ii) geometric aging, i.e. slow growth of the real arrea of contact via asperity creep interrupted by sliding.
Closer analysis leads to identifying a second aging-rejuvenation process, at work within the junctions themselves. We compare the effects of structural aging at such multicontact, very highly confined, interfaces with those met under different confinement levels, namely boundary lubricated contacts and extended adhesive interfaces involving soft materials (hydrogels, elastomers). This leads us to propose a classification of frictional junctions in terms of the relative importance of jamming and adsoprtion-induced metastability.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
-
Self-healing slip pulses and the friction of gelatin gels
Authors:
Tristan Baumberger,
Christiane Caroli,
Olivier Ronsin
Abstract:
We present an extensive experimental study and scaling analysis of friction of gelatin gels on glass. At low driving velocities, sliding occurs via propagation of periodic self-healing slip pulses whose velocity is limited by collective diffusion of the gel network. Healing can be attributed to a frictional instability occurring at the slip velocity $v = V_c$. For $v > V_c$, sliding is homogeneo…
▽ More
We present an extensive experimental study and scaling analysis of friction of gelatin gels on glass. At low driving velocities, sliding occurs via propagation of periodic self-healing slip pulses whose velocity is limited by collective diffusion of the gel network. Healing can be attributed to a frictional instability occurring at the slip velocity $v = V_c$. For $v > V_c$, sliding is homogeneous and friction is ruled by the shear-thinning rheology of an interfacial layer of thickness of order the (nanometric) mesh size, containing a semi-dilute solution of polymer chain ends hanging from the network. Inspite of its high degree of confinement, the rheology of this system does not differ qualitatively from known bulk ones. The observed ageing of the static friction threshold reveals the slow increase of adhesive bonding between chain ends and glass. Such structural ageing is compatible with the existence of a velocity-weakening regime at velocities smaller than $V_c$, hence with the existence of the healing instability.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2003;
originally announced March 2003.
-
Elasticity and onset of frictional dissipation at a non-sliding multicontact interface
Authors:
L. Bureau,
C. Caroli,
T. Baumberger
Abstract:
We measure the elastic and dissipative responses of a multicontact interface, formed between the rough surfaces of two contacting macroscopic solids, submitted to a biased oscillating shear force. We evidence that beyond a linear viscoelastic regime, observed at low shear amplitude, the interface response exhibits a dissipative component which corresponds to the onset of frictional dissipation.…
▽ More
We measure the elastic and dissipative responses of a multicontact interface, formed between the rough surfaces of two contacting macroscopic solids, submitted to a biased oscillating shear force. We evidence that beyond a linear viscoelastic regime, observed at low shear amplitude, the interface response exhibits a dissipative component which corresponds to the onset of frictional dissipation. The latter regime exists whereas the tangential force applied, far from the nominal static threshold, does not provoke any sliding. This result, akin to that of Mindlin for a single contact, leads us to extend his model of `microslip' to the case of an interface composed of multiple microcontacts. While describing satisfactorily the elastic response, the model fails to account quantitatively for the observed energy dissipation, which, we believe, results from the fact that the key assumption of local Coulomb friction in Mindlin's model is not legitimate at the sub-micrometer scale of the microslip zones within microcontacts between surface asperities.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2002;
originally announced October 2002.
-
Rheological aging and rejuvenation in solid friction contacts
Authors:
L. Bureau,
T. Baumberger,
C. Caroli
Abstract:
We study the low-velocity (0.1--100 $μ$m.s$^{-1}$) frictional properties of interfaces between a rough glassy polymers and smooth silanized glass, a configuration which gives direct access to the rheology of the adhesive joints in which shear localizes. We show that these joints exhibit the full phenomenology expected for confined quasi 2D soft glasses: they strengthen logarithmically when aging…
▽ More
We study the low-velocity (0.1--100 $μ$m.s$^{-1}$) frictional properties of interfaces between a rough glassy polymers and smooth silanized glass, a configuration which gives direct access to the rheology of the adhesive joints in which shear localizes. We show that these joints exhibit the full phenomenology expected for confined quasi 2D soft glasses: they strengthen logarithmically when aging at rest, and weaken (rejuvenate) when sliding. Rejuvenation is found to saturate at large velocities. Moreover, aging at rest is shown to be strongly accelerated when waiting under finite stress below the static threshold.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2002;
originally announced February 2002.
-
Stabilization of frictional sliding by normal load modulation: A bifurcation analysis
Authors:
A. Cochard,
L. Bureau,
T. Baumberger
Abstract:
This paper presents the stability analysis of a system sliding at low velocities ($< 100 μ$m.s$^{-1}$) under a periodically modulated normal load, preserving interfacial contact. Experiments clearly evidence that normal vibrations generally stabilize the system against stick-slip oscillations, at least for a modulation frequency much larger than the stick-slip one. The mechanical model of Bureau…
▽ More
This paper presents the stability analysis of a system sliding at low velocities ($< 100 μ$m.s$^{-1}$) under a periodically modulated normal load, preserving interfacial contact. Experiments clearly evidence that normal vibrations generally stabilize the system against stick-slip oscillations, at least for a modulation frequency much larger than the stick-slip one. The mechanical model of Bureau {\it et al.} (2000), validated on the steady-state response of the system, is used to map its stability diagram. The model takes explicitly into account the finite shear stiffness of the load-bearing asperities, in addition to a classical state- and rate-dependent friction force. The numerical results are in excellent quantitative agreement with the experimental data obtained from a multicontact frictional system between glassy polymer materials. Simulations at larger amplitude of modulation (typically 20% of the mean normal load) suggest that the non-linear coupling between normal and sliding motion could have a destabilizing effect in restricted regions of the parameter space.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2001;
originally announced November 2001.
-
Self healing slip pulses along a gel/glass interface
Authors:
Tristan Baumberger,
Christiane Caroli,
Olivier Ronsin
Abstract:
We present an experimental evidence of self-healing shear cracks at a gel/glass interface. This system exhibits two dynamical regimes depending on the driving velocity : steady sliding at high velocity (> Vc = 100-125 μm/s), caracterized by a shear-thinning rheology, and periodic stick-slip dynamics at low velocity. In this last regime, slip occurs by propagation of pulses that restick via a ``h…
▽ More
We present an experimental evidence of self-healing shear cracks at a gel/glass interface. This system exhibits two dynamical regimes depending on the driving velocity : steady sliding at high velocity (> Vc = 100-125 μm/s), caracterized by a shear-thinning rheology, and periodic stick-slip dynamics at low velocity. In this last regime, slip occurs by propagation of pulses that restick via a ``healing instability'' occuring when the local sliding velocity reaches the macroscopic transition velocity Vc. At driving velocities close below Vc, the system exhibits complex spatio-temporal behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2001;
originally announced October 2001.
-
Jamming creep of a frictional interface
Authors:
L. Bureau,
T. Baumberger,
C. Caroli
Abstract:
We measure the displacement response of a frictional multicontact interface between identical polymer glasses to a biased shear force oscillation. We evidence the existence, for maximum forces close below the nominal static threshold, of a jamming creep regime governed by an ageing-rejuvenation competition acting within the micrometer-sized contacting asperities. Quantitative analysis of the cre…
▽ More
We measure the displacement response of a frictional multicontact interface between identical polymer glasses to a biased shear force oscillation. We evidence the existence, for maximum forces close below the nominal static threshold, of a jamming creep regime governed by an ageing-rejuvenation competition acting within the micrometer-sized contacting asperities. Quantitative analysis of the creep curves suggests that another such mechanism might be at work within the nanometer-thick adhesive junctions.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2001;
originally announced January 2001.
-
Shear response of a frictional interface to a normal load modulation
Authors:
L. Bureau,
T. Baumberger,
C. Caroli
Abstract:
We study the shear response of a sliding multicontact interface submitted to a harmonically modulated normal load, without loss of contact. We measure, at low velocities ($V<100 μ$m.s$^{-1}$), the average value $\bar{F}$ of the friction force and the amplitude of its first and second harmonic components. The excitation frequency ($f=120$ Hz) is chosen much larger than the natural one, associated…
▽ More
We study the shear response of a sliding multicontact interface submitted to a harmonically modulated normal load, without loss of contact. We measure, at low velocities ($V<100 μ$m.s$^{-1}$), the average value $\bar{F}$ of the friction force and the amplitude of its first and second harmonic components. The excitation frequency ($f=120$ Hz) is chosen much larger than the natural one, associated to the dynamical ageing of the interface. We show that: (i) In agreement with the engineering thumb rule, even a modest modulation induces a substantial decrease of $\bar{F}$. (ii) The Rice-Ruina state and rate model, though appropriate to describe the slow frictional dynamics, must be extended when dealing with our ``high'' frequency regime. Namely, the rheology which controls the shear strength must explicitly account not only for the plastic response of the adhesive junctions between load-bearing asperities, but also for the elastic contribution of the asperities bodies. This ``elasto-plastic'' friction model leads to predictions in excellent quantitative agreement with all our experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2000;
originally announced May 2000.
