-
Collective Foraging and Behavioural Syndromes in Ants: First-Passage Statistics with Heterogeneous Walkers on a Honeycomb Lattice
Authors:
Daniel Marris,
Pol Fernández-López,
Frederic Bartumeus,
Luca Giuggioli
Abstract:
Behavioral heterogeneities in animals, also known as syndromes, play a crucial role in understanding how natural populations flexibly adapt to environmental changes. In ant species like \textit{Aphaenogaster senilis}, two key roles in collective foraging are commonly recognised: scouts, who discover food patches, and recruits, who exploit these patches and transport food back to the nest. These ro…
▽ More
Behavioral heterogeneities in animals, also known as syndromes, play a crucial role in understanding how natural populations flexibly adapt to environmental changes. In ant species like \textit{Aphaenogaster senilis}, two key roles in collective foraging are commonly recognised: scouts, who discover food patches, and recruits, who exploit these patches and transport food back to the nest. These roles involve distinct movement patterns and exploratory behaviours. In this chapter, we develop a correlated random walk model on a bounded honeycomb lattice to interpret and replicate empirical observations of foraging ants in an enclosed arena with honeycomb tiling. We do so by extending the theory of first-passage processes for $\mathcal{N}$ random walkers when individuals belong to a heterogeneous population. We apply this theory to examine how individual behavioural heterogeneity in ants affects collective foraging efficiency, focusing on first-passage time statistics for nest-to-patch and patch-to-patch movements. With the combined use of the mathematical model and the controlled experimental setup we evaluate (i) the impact of distinct movement strategies by scouts and recruits on finding food items and (ii) whether ants practice strict central place foraging or utilise previously discovered patches as starting points for further exploration.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2025; v1 submitted 5 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Comment on "Inverse Square Lévy Walks are not Optimal Search Strategies for d $\geq$ 2" [Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 080601 (2020)]
Authors:
S. V. Buldyrev,
E. P. Raposo,
F. Bartumeus,
S. Havlin,
F. R. Rusch,
M. G. E. da Luz,
G. M. Viswanathan
Abstract:
It is widely accepted that inverse square Lévy walks are optimal search strategies because they maximize the encounter rate with sparse, randomly distributed, replenishable targets when the search restarts in the vicinity of the previously visited target, which becomes revisitable again with high probability, i.e., non-destructive foraging [Nature 401, 911 (1999)]. The precise conditions for the v…
▽ More
It is widely accepted that inverse square Lévy walks are optimal search strategies because they maximize the encounter rate with sparse, randomly distributed, replenishable targets when the search restarts in the vicinity of the previously visited target, which becomes revisitable again with high probability, i.e., non-destructive foraging [Nature 401, 911 (1999)]. The precise conditions for the validity of this Lévy flight foraging hypothesis (LFH) have been widely described in the literature [Phys. Life Rev. 14, 94 (2015)]. Nevertheless, three objecting claims to the LFH have been raised recently for $d \geq 2$: (i) the capture rate $η$ has linear dependence on the target density $ρ$ for all values of the Lévy index $α$; (ii) "the gain $η_{max}/η$ achieved by varying $α$ is bounded even in the limit $ρ\to 0 $" so that "tuning $α$ can only yield a marginal gain"; (iii) depending on the values of the radius of detection $a$, the restarting distance $l_c$ and the scale parameter $s$, the optimum is realized for a range of $α$ [Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 080601 (2020)]. Here we answer each of these three criticisms in detail and show that claims (i)-(iii) do not actually invalidate the LFH. Our results and analyses restore the original result of the LFH for non-destructive foraging.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2021; v1 submitted 19 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
First-passage times in multi-scale random walks: the impact of movement scales on search efficiency
Authors:
Daniel Campos,
Frederic Bartumeus,
E. P. Raposo,
Vicenç Méndez
Abstract:
An efficient searcher needs to balance properly the tradeoff between the exploration of new spatial areas and the exploitation of nearby resources, an idea which is at the core of scale-free Lévy search strategies. Here we study multi-scale random walks as an approximation to the scale- free case and derive the exact expressions for their mean-first passage times in a one-dimensional finite domain…
▽ More
An efficient searcher needs to balance properly the tradeoff between the exploration of new spatial areas and the exploitation of nearby resources, an idea which is at the core of scale-free Lévy search strategies. Here we study multi-scale random walks as an approximation to the scale- free case and derive the exact expressions for their mean-first passage times in a one-dimensional finite domain. This allows us to provide a complete analytical description of the dynamics driving the asymmetric regime, in which both nearby and faraway targets are available to the searcher. For this regime, we prove that the combination of only two movement scales can be enough to outperform both balistic and Lévy strategies. This two-scale strategy involves an optimal discrimination between the nearby and faraway targets, which is only possible by adjusting the range of values of the two movement scales to the typical distances between encounters. So, this optimization necessarily requires some prior information (albeit crude) about targets distances or distributions. Furthermore, we found that the incorporation of additional (three, four, ...) movement scales and its adjustment to target distances does not improve further the search efficiency. This allows us to claim that optimal random search strategies in the asymmetric regime actually arise through the informed combination of only two walk scales (related to the exploitative and the explorative scale, respectively), expanding on the well-known result that optimal strategies in strictly uninformed scenarios are achieved through Lévy paths (or, equivalently, through a hierarchical combination of multiple scales).
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
The effects of spatially heterogeneous prey distributions on detection patterns in foraging seabirds
Authors:
Octavio Miramontes,
Denis Boyer,
Frederic Bartumeus
Abstract:
Many attempts to relate animal foraging patterns to landscape heterogeneity are focused on the analysis of foragers movements. Resource detection patterns in space and time are not commonly studied, yet they are tightly coupled to landscape properties and add relevant information on foraging behavior. By exploring simple foraging models in unpredictable environments we show that the distribution o…
▽ More
Many attempts to relate animal foraging patterns to landscape heterogeneity are focused on the analysis of foragers movements. Resource detection patterns in space and time are not commonly studied, yet they are tightly coupled to landscape properties and add relevant information on foraging behavior. By exploring simple foraging models in unpredictable environments we show that the distribution of intervals between detected prey (detection statistics)is mostly determined by the spatial structure of the prey field and essentially distinct from predator displacement statistics. Detections are expected to be Poissonian in uniform random environments for markedly different foraging movements (e.g. Lévy and ballistic). This prediction is supported by data on the time intervals between diving events on short-range foraging seabirds such as the thick-billed murre ({\it Uria lomvia}). However, Poissonian detection statistics is not observed in long-range seabirds such as the wandering albatross ({\it Diomedea exulans}) due to the fractal nature of the prey field, covering a wide range of spatial scales. For this scenario, models of fractal prey fields induce non-Poissonian patterns of detection in good agreement with two albatross data sets. We find that the specific shape of the distribution of time intervals between prey detection is mainly driven by meso and submeso-scale landscape structures and depends little on the forager strategy or behavioral responses.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2012; v1 submitted 16 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
