-
Accelerating Combinatorial Electrocatalyst Discovery with Bayesian Optimization: A Case Study in the Quaternary System Ni-Pd-Pt-Ru for the Oxygen Evolution Reaction
Authors:
F. Thelen,
R. Zehl,
R. Zerdoumi,
J. L. Bürgel,
L. Banko,
W. Schuhmann,
A. Ludwig
Abstract:
The discovery of high-performance electrocatalysts is crucial for advancing sustainable energy technologies. Compositionally complex solid solutions comprising multiple metals offer promising catalytic properties, yet their exploration is challenging due to the combinatorial explosion of possible compositions. In this work, we combine combinatorial sputtering of thin-film materials libraries and t…
▽ More
The discovery of high-performance electrocatalysts is crucial for advancing sustainable energy technologies. Compositionally complex solid solutions comprising multiple metals offer promising catalytic properties, yet their exploration is challenging due to the combinatorial explosion of possible compositions. In this work, we combine combinatorial sputtering of thin-film materials libraries and their high-throughput characterization with Bayesian optimization to efficiently explore the quaternary composition space Ni-Pd-Pt-Ru for the oxygen evolution reaction in alkaline media. Using this method, the global activity optimum of pure Ru was identified after covering less than 20% of the complete composition space with six materials libraries. Six additional libraries were fabricated to validate the activity trend. The resulting dataset is used to formulate general guidelines for the efficient composition space exploration using combinatorial synthesis paired with Bayesian optimization.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Composition-property extrapolation for compositionally complex solid solutions based on word embeddings
Authors:
Lei Zhang,
Lars Banko,
Wolfgang Schuhmann,
Alfred Ludwig,
Markus Stricker
Abstract:
Mastering the challenge of predicting properties of unknown materials with multiple principal elements (high entropy alloys/compositionally complex solid solutions) is crucial for the speedup in materials discovery. We show and discuss three models, using property data from two ternary systems (Ag-Pd-Ru; Ag-Pd-Pt), to predict material performance in the shared quaternary system (Ag-Pd-Pt-Ru). Firs…
▽ More
Mastering the challenge of predicting properties of unknown materials with multiple principal elements (high entropy alloys/compositionally complex solid solutions) is crucial for the speedup in materials discovery. We show and discuss three models, using property data from two ternary systems (Ag-Pd-Ru; Ag-Pd-Pt), to predict material performance in the shared quaternary system (Ag-Pd-Pt-Ru). First, we apply Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) based on composition, which includes both Ag and Pd, achieving an initial correlation coefficient for the prediction ($r$) of 0.63 and a determination coefficient ($r^2$) of 0.08. Second, we present a version of the GPR model using word embedding-derived materials vectors as representations. Using materials-specific embedding vectors significantly improves the predictive capability, evident from an improved $r^2$ of 0.65. The third model is based on a `standard vector method' which synthesizes weighted vector representations of material properties, then creating a reference vector that results in a very good correlation with the quaternary system's material performance (resulting $r$ of 0.89). Our approach demonstrates that existing experimental data combined with latent knowledge of word embedding-based representations of materials can be used effectively for materials discovery where data is typically sparse.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
MatInf -- an Extensible Open-Source Solution for Research Digitalisation in Materials Science
Authors:
Victor Dudarev,
Lars Banko,
Alfred Ludwig
Abstract:
Information technology and data science development stimulate transformation in many fields of scientific knowledge. In recent years, a large number of specialized systems for information and knowledge management have been created in materials science. However, the development and deployment of open adaptive systems for research support in materials science based on the acquisition, storage, and p…
▽ More
Information technology and data science development stimulate transformation in many fields of scientific knowledge. In recent years, a large number of specialized systems for information and knowledge management have been created in materials science. However, the development and deployment of open adaptive systems for research support in materials science based on the acquisition, storage, and processing of different types of information remains unsolved. We propose MatInf - an extensible, open-source solution for research digitalisation in materials science based on an adaptive, flexible information management system for heterogeneous data sources. MatInf can be easily adapted to any materials science laboratory and is especially useful for collaborative projects between several labs. As an example, we demonstrate its application in high-throughput experimentation.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Speeding up high-throughput characterization of materials libraries by active learning: autonomous electrical resistance measurements
Authors:
Felix Thelen,
Lars Banko,
Rico Zehl,
Sabrina Baha,
Alfred Ludwig
Abstract:
High-throughput experimentation enables efficient search space exploration for the discovery and optimization of new materials. However, large search spaces of, e.g., compositionally complex materials, require decreasing characterization times significantly. Here, an autonomous measurement algorithm was developed, which leverages active learning based on a Gaussian process model capable of iterati…
▽ More
High-throughput experimentation enables efficient search space exploration for the discovery and optimization of new materials. However, large search spaces of, e.g., compositionally complex materials, require decreasing characterization times significantly. Here, an autonomous measurement algorithm was developed, which leverages active learning based on a Gaussian process model capable of iteratively scanning a materials library based on the highest uncertainty. The algorithm is applied to a four-point probe electrical resistance measurement device, frequently used to obtain indications for regions of interest in materials libraries. Ten materials libraries with different complexities of composition and property trends are analyzed to validate the model. By stopping the process before the entire library is characterized and predicting the remaining measurement areas, the measurement efficiency can be improved drastically. As robustness is essential for autonomous measurements, intrinsic outlier handling is built into the model and a dynamic stopping criterion based on the mean predicted covariance is proposed. A measurement time reduction of about 70-90% was observed while still ensuring an accuracy of above 90%.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Combinatorial sputter synthesis of single-phase La(XYZ)O$_{3\pmσ}$ perovskite thin film libraries: a new platform for materials discovery
Authors:
Tobias H. Piotrowiak,
Rico Zehl,
Ellen Suhr,
Benedikt Kohnen,
Lars Banko,
Alfred Ludwig
Abstract:
Compositionally complex perovskites provide the opportunity to develop stable and active catalysts for electrochemical applications. The challenge lies in the identification of single-phase perovskites with optimized composition for high electrical conductivity. Leveraging a recently discovered effect of self-organized thin film growth during reactive sputtering, La-Co-Mn-O and La-Co-Mn-Fe-O perov…
▽ More
Compositionally complex perovskites provide the opportunity to develop stable and active catalysts for electrochemical applications. The challenge lies in the identification of single-phase perovskites with optimized composition for high electrical conductivity. Leveraging a recently discovered effect of self-organized thin film growth during reactive sputtering, La-Co-Mn-O and La-Co-Mn-Fe-O perovskite (ABO3) thin film materials libraries are synthesized. These show phase-pure La-perovskites over a wide range of chemical composition variation for the B-site elements for deposition temperatures equal to or higher than 300$^\circ$C. It is demonstrated that this approach enables the discovery and tailoring of chemical compositions for desired optical bandgap and electrical conductivity, and thereby opens the path for the targeted development of e.g. new high-performance electrocatalysts.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Computationally accelerated experimental materials characterization -- drawing inspiration from high-throughput simulation workflows
Authors:
Markus Stricker,
Lars Banko,
Nik Sarazin,
Niklas Siemer,
Jan Janssen,
Lei Zhang,
Jörg Neugebauer,
Alfred Ludwig
Abstract:
Computational materials science increasingly benefits from data management, automation, and algorithm-based decision-making for the simulation of material properties and behavior. Experimental materials science also changes rapidly by incorporation of `machine learning' in materials discovery campaigns. The obvious benefits which include automation, reproducibility, data provenance, and reusabilit…
▽ More
Computational materials science increasingly benefits from data management, automation, and algorithm-based decision-making for the simulation of material properties and behavior. Experimental materials science also changes rapidly by incorporation of `machine learning' in materials discovery campaigns. The obvious benefits which include automation, reproducibility, data provenance, and reusability of managed data, however, is not widely available in the experimental domain. We present an implementation of a Active Learning loop with a direct interface to an experimental measurement device in pyiron, a framework designed for high-throughput simulations, as demonstrator how to combine experimental and simulated data in one framework. Apart from the acceleration provided by the active learning approach, additional acceleration of the experimental characterization is achieved by using prior knowledge from density functional theory simulations as well as composition-property predictions from literature mining using correlations in word embeddings. With data from all domains in the same framework, a heretofore untapped and much-needed potential for the acceleration of materials characterization and materials discovery campaigns becomes available.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2025; v1 submitted 9 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Unusual phase formation in reactively sputtered La-Co-O perovskite thin films
Authors:
Tobias H. Piotrowiak,
Rico Zehl,
Ellen Suhr,
Lars Banko,
Benedikt Kohnen,
Detlef Rogalla,
Alfred Ludwig
Abstract:
La-based perovskites are a versatile class of materials that are of interest for solid oxide fuel cells and electrocatalytic water splitting. During fabrication of composition spread materials libraries of La-Co-based oxide systems for the discovery of new catalytic materials, an unusual phase formation phenomenon was observed: instead of the expected continuous composition gradient, regions with…
▽ More
La-based perovskites are a versatile class of materials that are of interest for solid oxide fuel cells and electrocatalytic water splitting. During fabrication of composition spread materials libraries of La-Co-based oxide systems for the discovery of new catalytic materials, an unusual phase formation phenomenon was observed: instead of the expected continuous composition gradient, regions with homogeneous composition and single-phase structure (La2O3 or stoichiometric La-perovskite) form. This phenomenon occurs during reactive co-sputtering and is dependent on O2-flux and substrate temperature, investigated from room temperature up to 700 C and is independent of the used substrate. It can be described as a self-organized growth, where excess transition metal cannot be incorporated into the growing film and the forming single-phase regions. It is hypothesized that due to the high reactivity of La and the significantly low formation energies of La2O3 and La-perovskites, the reactive sputter deposition of La-based oxide films can turn, regarding film growth, into a partial CVD-like process which results in the unusual self-organized growth of single-phase regions. This phenomenon can be leveraged for the exploration of multinary perovskite thin film libraries, where the B-site atoms of La-perovskites are systematically substituted.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Combinatorial materials discovery strategy for high entropy alloy electrocatalysts using deposition source permutations
Authors:
Lars Banko,
Olga A. Krysiak,
Bin Xiao,
Tobias Löffler,
Alan Savan,
Jack Kirk Pedersen,
Jan Rossmeisl,
Wolfgang Schuhmann,
Alfred Ludwig
Abstract:
High entropy alloys offer a huge search space for new electrocatalysts. Searching for a global property maximum in one quinary system could require, depending on compositional resolution, the synthesis of up to 10E6 samples which is impossible using conventional approaches. Co-sputtered materials libraries address this challenge by synthesis of controlled composition gradients of each element. How…
▽ More
High entropy alloys offer a huge search space for new electrocatalysts. Searching for a global property maximum in one quinary system could require, depending on compositional resolution, the synthesis of up to 10E6 samples which is impossible using conventional approaches. Co-sputtered materials libraries address this challenge by synthesis of controlled composition gradients of each element. However, even such a materials library covers less than 1% of the composition space of a quinary system. We present a new strategy using deposition source permutations optimized for highest improvement of the covered new compositions. Using this approach, the composition space can be sampled in different subsections allowing identification of the contribution of individual elements and their combinations on electrochemical activity. Unsupervised machine learning reveals that electrochemical activity is governed by the complex interplay of chemical and structural factors. Out of 2394 measured compositions, a new highly active composition for the oxygen reduction reaction around Ru17Rh5Pd19Ir29Pt30 was identified.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Bayesian Optimization of High-Entropy Alloy Compositions for Electrocatalytic Oxygen Reduction
Authors:
Jack K. Pedersen,
Christian M. Clausen,
Olga A. Krysiak,
Bin Xiao,
Thomas A. A. Batchelor,
Tobias Löffler,
Vladislav A. Mints,
Lars Banko,
Matthias Arenz,
Alan Savan,
Wolfgang Schuhmann,
Alfred Ludwig,
Jan Rossmeisl
Abstract:
Active, selective and stable catalysts are imperative for sustainable energy conversion, and engineering materials with such properties are highly desired. High-entropy alloys (HEAs) offer a vast compositional space for tuning such properties. Too vast, however, to traverse without the proper tools. Here, we report the use of Bayesian optimization on a model based on density functional theory (DFT…
▽ More
Active, selective and stable catalysts are imperative for sustainable energy conversion, and engineering materials with such properties are highly desired. High-entropy alloys (HEAs) offer a vast compositional space for tuning such properties. Too vast, however, to traverse without the proper tools. Here, we report the use of Bayesian optimization on a model based on density functional theory (DFT) to predict the most active compositions for the electrochemical oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) with the least possible number of sampled compositions for the two HEAs Ag-Ir-Pd-Pt-Ru and Ir-Pd-Pt-Rh-Ru. The discovered optima are then scrutinized with DFT and subjected to experimental validation where optimal catalytic activities are verified for Ag-Pd, Ir-Pt, and Pd-Ru binary systems. This study offers insight into the number of experiments needed for exploring the vast compositional space of multimetallic alloys which has been determined to be on the order of 50 for ORR on these HEAs.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Deep learning for visualization and novelty detection in large X-ray diffraction datasets
Authors:
Lars Banko,
Phillip M. Maffettone,
Dennis Naujoks,
Daniel Olds,
Alfred Ludwig
Abstract:
We apply variational autoencoders (VAE) to X-ray diffraction (XRD) data analysis on both simulated and experimental thin-film data. We show that crystal structure representations learned by a VAE reveal latent information, such as the structural similarity of textured diffraction patterns. While other artificial intelligence (AI) agents are effective at classifying XRD data into known phases, a si…
▽ More
We apply variational autoencoders (VAE) to X-ray diffraction (XRD) data analysis on both simulated and experimental thin-film data. We show that crystal structure representations learned by a VAE reveal latent information, such as the structural similarity of textured diffraction patterns. While other artificial intelligence (AI) agents are effective at classifying XRD data into known phases, a similarly conditioned VAE is uniquely effective at knowing what it does not know, rapidly identifying novel phases and mixtures. These capabilities demonstrate that a VAE is a valuable AI agent for materials discovery and understanding XRD measurements both on-the-fly and during post hoc analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Crystallography companion agent for high-throughput materials discovery
Authors:
Phillip M. Maffettone,
Lars Banko,
Peng Cui,
Yury Lysogorskiy,
Marc A. Little,
Daniel Olds,
Alfred Ludwig,
Andrew I. Cooper
Abstract:
The discovery of new structural and functional materials is driven by phase identification, often using X-ray diffraction (XRD). Automation has accelerated the rate of XRD measurements, greatly outpacing XRD analysis techniques that remain manual, time-consuming, error-prone, and impossible to scale. With the advent of autonomous robotic scientists or self-driving labs, contemporary techniques pro…
▽ More
The discovery of new structural and functional materials is driven by phase identification, often using X-ray diffraction (XRD). Automation has accelerated the rate of XRD measurements, greatly outpacing XRD analysis techniques that remain manual, time-consuming, error-prone, and impossible to scale. With the advent of autonomous robotic scientists or self-driving labs, contemporary techniques prohibit the integration of XRD. Here, we describe a computer program for the autonomous characterization of XRD data, driven by artificial intelligence (AI), for the discovery of new materials. Starting from structural databases, we train an ensemble model using a physically accurate synthetic dataset, which output probabilistic classifications -- rather than absolutes -- to overcome the overconfidence in traditional neural networks. This AI agent behaves as a companion to the researcher, improving accuracy and offering significant time savings. It was demonstrated on a diverse set of organic and inorganic materials characterization challenges. This innovation is directly applicable to inverse design approaches, robotic discovery systems, and can be immediately considered for other forms of characterization such as spectroscopy and the pair distribution function.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2021; v1 submitted 1 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Mastering processing-microstructure complexity through the prediction of thin film structure zone diagrams by generative machine learning models
Authors:
Lars Banko,
Yury Lysogorskiy,
Dario Grochla,
Dennis Naujoks,
Ralf Drautz,
Alfred Ludwig
Abstract:
Thin films are ubiquitous in modern technology and highly useful in materials discovery and design. For achieving optimal extrinsic properties their microstructure needs to be controlled in a multi-parameter space, which usually requires a too-high number of experiments to map. We propose to master thin film processing microstructure complexity and to reduce the cost of microstructure design by jo…
▽ More
Thin films are ubiquitous in modern technology and highly useful in materials discovery and design. For achieving optimal extrinsic properties their microstructure needs to be controlled in a multi-parameter space, which usually requires a too-high number of experiments to map. We propose to master thin film processing microstructure complexity and to reduce the cost of microstructure design by joining combinatorial experimentation with generative deep learning models to extract synthesis-composition-microstructure relations. A generative machine learning approach comprising a variational autoencoder and a conditional generative adversarial network predicts structure zone diagrams. We demonstrate that generative models provide a so far unseen level of quality of generated structure zone diagrams comprising chemical and processing complexity for the optimization of chemical composition and processing parameters to achieve a desired microstructure.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.