-
Kinetic asymmetry versus dissipation in the evolution of chemical systems as exemplified by single enzyme chemotaxis
Authors:
Niladri Sekhar Mandal,
Ayusman Sen,
R. Dean Astumian
Abstract:
Single enzyme chemotaxis is a phenomenon by which a non-equilibrium spatial distribution of an enzyme is created and maintained by concentration gradients of the substrate and product of the catalyzed reaction. These gradients can arise either naturally through metabolism, or experimentally, e.g., by flow of materials through several channels or by use of diffusion chambers with semipermeable memb…
▽ More
Single enzyme chemotaxis is a phenomenon by which a non-equilibrium spatial distribution of an enzyme is created and maintained by concentration gradients of the substrate and product of the catalyzed reaction. These gradients can arise either naturally through metabolism, or experimentally, e.g., by flow of materials through several channels or by use of diffusion chambers with semipermeable membranes. Numerous hypotheses regarding the mechanism of this phenomenon have been proposed. Here we discuss a mechanism based solely on diffusion and chemical kinetics and show that kinetic asymmetry, a difference in the off rates for substrate and for product, and diffusion asymmetry, a difference in the diffusivities of the bound and free forms of the enzyme, are the sole determinates of the direction of chemotaxis. Exploration of these fundamental symmetries that govern nonequilibrium behavior helps to distinguish between possible mechanisms for the evolution of a chemical system from initial to the steady state, and whether the principle that determines the direction a system shifts when exposed to an external energy source is based on thermodynamics, or on kinetics, with the latter being supported by the results of the present paper. Our results show that while dissipation ineluctably accompanies non-equilibrium phenomena, including chemotaxis, systems do not evolve to maximize dissipation, but rather to attain greatest kinetic stability. Chemotactic response to the gradients formed by other enzymes provides a mechanism for forming loose associations known as metabolons. Significantly the direction of the effective force due to these gradients depends on the kinetic asymmetry of the enzyme, and so can be non-reciprocal, where one enzyme is attracted to another enzyme, but the other enzyme is repelled by the one, an important ingredient in the behavior of active matter.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Comment on the perspective article "Thermodynamic uncertainty relations constrain non-equilibrium fluctuations"
Authors:
R. Dean Astumian
Abstract:
In a recent perspective article, Horowitz and Gingrich discuss thermodynamic uncertainty relations that have been derived using "stochastic thermodynamics", a theory based on a hypothesis known as local detailed balance. The authors examined the foundations of this theory in their "Box 1: A brief primer on local detailed balance and stochastic thermodynamics", where a kinetic scheme for transport…
▽ More
In a recent perspective article, Horowitz and Gingrich discuss thermodynamic uncertainty relations that have been derived using "stochastic thermodynamics", a theory based on a hypothesis known as local detailed balance. The authors examined the foundations of this theory in their "Box 1: A brief primer on local detailed balance and stochastic thermodynamics", where a kinetic scheme for transport of particles between two reservoirs is presented. Horowitz and Gingrich arrive at a relationship between the probability to cycle through the states in one order vs. the probability to cycle in the reverse order. This relation bears on the extremely important question of what governs directionality when a system is driven away from equilibrium by contact with multiple reservoirs that are not in equilibrium with one another. In the original version of their paper the relation given for this ratio was obviously wrong and contrary to the second law of thermodynamics. Based on our private communications and on the recent paper authored by my colleagues and myself, Horowitz and Gingrich accepted the necessity of correcting the error in their Box 1. Unfortunately, in making the correction, the authors introduced an equally serious, if less transparent, mistake, and continue to base their theory on the thermodynamically impossible idea that transitions are mediated by only one of the two reservoirs. In this comment we illustrate how the principle of microscopic reversibility reveals that the true origin of directional cycling amongst a network of states is kinetic asymmetry. This understanding is important in guiding synthesis of molecular machines and other devices designed to exploit transport or catalysis to drive non-equilibrium processes.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Symmetry Relations for Trajectories of a Brownian Motor
Authors:
R. Dean Astumian
Abstract:
A Brownian Motor is a nanoscale or molecular device that combines the effects of thermal noise, spatial or temporal asymmetry, and directionless input energy to drive directed motion. Because of the input energy, Brownian motors function away from thermodynamic equilibrium and concepts such as linear response theory, fluctuation dissipation relations, and detailed balance do not apply. The {\em…
▽ More
A Brownian Motor is a nanoscale or molecular device that combines the effects of thermal noise, spatial or temporal asymmetry, and directionless input energy to drive directed motion. Because of the input energy, Brownian motors function away from thermodynamic equilibrium and concepts such as linear response theory, fluctuation dissipation relations, and detailed balance do not apply. The {\em generalized} fluctuation-dissipation relation, however, states that even under strongly thermodynamically non-equilibrium conditions the ratio of the probability of a transition to the probability of the time-reverse of that transition is the exponent of the change in the internal energy of the system due to the transition. Here, we derive an extension of the generalized fluctuation dissipation theorem for a Brownian motor for the ratio between the probability for the motor to take a forward step and the probability to take a backward step.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2007; v1 submitted 1 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
Equilibrium Theory for a Particle Pulled by a Moving Optical Trap
Authors:
R. Dean Astumian
Abstract:
The viscous drag on a colloidal particle pulled through solution by an optical trap is large enough that on experimentally relavant time scales the mechanical force exerted by the trap is equal and op- posite the viscous drag force. The rapid mechanical equilibritation allows the system to be modeled using equilibrium theory, where the effects of the energy dissipation (thermodynamic disequilibr…
▽ More
The viscous drag on a colloidal particle pulled through solution by an optical trap is large enough that on experimentally relavant time scales the mechanical force exerted by the trap is equal and op- posite the viscous drag force. The rapid mechanical equilibritation allows the system to be modeled using equilibrium theory, where the effects of the energy dissipation (thermodynamic disequilibrium) show up only in the coordinate transformations that map the system from the laboratory frame of reference, relative to which the particle is moving, to a frame of reference in which the particle is, on average, stationary and on which the stochastic dynamics is governed by a canonical equilib- rium distribution function. The simple equations in the stationary frame can be analyzed using the Onsager-Machlup theory for stochastic systems and provide generalizations of equilibrium and near equilibrium concepts such as detailed balance and fluctuation-dissipation relations applicable to a wide range of systems including molecular motors, pumps, and other nano-scale machines.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2006;
originally announced August 2006.
-
The unreasonable effectiveness of equilibrium-like theory for interpreting non-equilibrium experiments
Authors:
R. Dean Astumian
Abstract:
There has been great interest in applying the results of statistical mechanics to single molecule experiements. Recent work has highlighted so-called non-equilibrium work-energy relations and Fluctuation Theorems which take on an equilibrium-like (time independent) form. Here I give a very simple heuristic example where an equilibrium result (the barometric law for colloidal particles) arises fr…
▽ More
There has been great interest in applying the results of statistical mechanics to single molecule experiements. Recent work has highlighted so-called non-equilibrium work-energy relations and Fluctuation Theorems which take on an equilibrium-like (time independent) form. Here I give a very simple heuristic example where an equilibrium result (the barometric law for colloidal particles) arises from theory describing the {\em thermodynamically} non-equilibrium phenomenon of a single colloidal particle falling through solution due to gravity. This simple result arises from the fact that the particle, even while falling, is in {\em mechanical} equilibrium (gravitational force equal the viscous drag force) at every instant. The results are generalized by appeal to the central limit theorem. The resulting time independent equations that hold for thermodynamically non-equilibrium (and even non-stationary) processes offer great possibilities for rapid determination of thermodynamic parameters from single molecule experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2005;
originally announced December 2005.
