-
Dissipation Dilution-Driven Topology Optimization for Maximizing the $Q$ Factor of Nanomechanical Resonators
Authors:
Hendrik J. Algra,
Zichao Li,
Matthijs Langelaar,
Farbod Alijani,
Alejandro M. Aragón
Abstract:
The quality factor ($Q$ factor) of nanomechanical resonators is influenced by geometry and stress, a phenomenon called dissipation dilution. Studies have explored maximizing this effect, leading to softly-clamped resonator designs. This paper proposes a topology optimization methodology to design two-dimensional nanomechanical resonators with high $Q$ factors by maximizing dissipation dilution. A…
▽ More
The quality factor ($Q$ factor) of nanomechanical resonators is influenced by geometry and stress, a phenomenon called dissipation dilution. Studies have explored maximizing this effect, leading to softly-clamped resonator designs. This paper proposes a topology optimization methodology to design two-dimensional nanomechanical resonators with high $Q$ factors by maximizing dissipation dilution. A formulation based on the ratio of geometrically nonlinear to linear modal stiffnesses of a prestressed finite element model is used, with its corresponding adjoint sensitivity analysis formulation. Systematic design in square domains yields geometries with comparable $Q$ factors to literature. We analyze the trade-offs between resonance frequency and quality factor, and how these are reflected in the geometry of resonators. We further apply the methodology to optimize a resonator on a full hexagonal domain. By using the entire mesh -- i.e., without assuming any symmetries -- we find that the optimizer converges to a two-axis symmetric design comprised of four tethers.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Finite Element-based Nonlinear Dynamic Optimization of Nanomechanical Resonators
Authors:
Zichao Li,
Farbod Alijani,
Ali Sarafraz,
Minxing Xu,
Richard A. Norte,
Alejandro M. Aragon,
Peter G. Steeneken
Abstract:
Nonlinear dynamic simulations of mechanical resonators have been facilitated by the advent of computational techniques that generate nonlinear reduced order models (ROMs) using the finite element (FE) method. However, designing devices with specific nonlinear characteristics remains inefficient since it requires manual adjustment of the design parameters and can result in suboptimal designs. Here,…
▽ More
Nonlinear dynamic simulations of mechanical resonators have been facilitated by the advent of computational techniques that generate nonlinear reduced order models (ROMs) using the finite element (FE) method. However, designing devices with specific nonlinear characteristics remains inefficient since it requires manual adjustment of the design parameters and can result in suboptimal designs. Here, we integrate an FE-based nonlinear ROM technique with a derivative-free optimization algorithm to enable the design of nonlinear mechanical resonators. The resulting methodology is used to optimize the support design of high-stress nanomechanical Si3N4 string resonators, in the presence of conflicting objectives such as simultaneous enhancement of Q-factor and nonlinear Duffing constant. To that end, we generate Pareto frontiers that highlight the trade-offs between optimization objectives and validate the results both numerically and experimentally. To further demonstrate the capability of multi-objective optimization for practical design challenges, we simultaneously optimize the design of nanoresonators for three key figure-of-merits in resonant sensing: power consumption, sensitivity and response time. The presented methodology can facilitate and accelerate designing (nano)mechanical resonators with optimized performance for a wide variety of applications.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Fracture metamaterials with on-demand crack paths enabled by bending
Authors:
Lucie Domino,
Mariam Beaure d'Augères,
Jian Zhang,
Shahram Janbaz,
Alejandro M. Aragòn,
Corentin Coulais
Abstract:
In many scenarios -- when we bite food or during a crash -- fracture is inevitable. Finding solutions to steer fracture to mitigate its impact or turn it into a purposeful functionality, is therefore crucial. Strategies using composites, changes in chemical composition or crystal orientation, have proven to be very efficient, but the crack path control remains limited and has not been achieved in…
▽ More
In many scenarios -- when we bite food or during a crash -- fracture is inevitable. Finding solutions to steer fracture to mitigate its impact or turn it into a purposeful functionality, is therefore crucial. Strategies using composites, changes in chemical composition or crystal orientation, have proven to be very efficient, but the crack path control remains limited and has not been achieved in load-bearing structures. Here, we introduce fracture metamaterials consisting of slender elements whose bending enables large elastic deformation as fracture propagates. This interplay between bending and fracture enables tunable energy dissipation and the design of on-demand crack paths of arbitrary complexity. To this end, we use topology optimisation to create unit cells with anisotropic fracture energy, which we then tile up to realize fracture metamaterials with uniform density that we 3D-print. The thin ligaments that constitute the unit cells confer them a strikingly distinct response in tension and shear, and we show that by controlling the orientation and layout of the unit cells the sequential progress of the crack can be controlled, making the fracture path arbitrarily tortuous. This tortuosity increases the energy dissipation of the metamaterial without changing its stiffness. Using bespoke arrangements of unit cells, metamaterials can have on-demand fracture paths of arbitrary complexity. Our findings bring a new perspective on inelastic deformations in mechanical metamaterials, with potential applications in areas as diverse as the food industry, structural design, and for shock and impact damping.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Characterizing multi-mode nonlinear dynamics of nanomechanical resonators
Authors:
Ata Keşkekler,
Vincent Bos,
Alejandro M. Aragón,
Peter G. Steeneken,
Farbod Alijani
Abstract:
Mechanical nonlinearities dominate the motion of nanoresonators already at relatively small oscillation amplitudes. Although single and coupled two-degrees-of-freedom models have been used to account for experimentally observed nonlinear effects, it is shown that these models quickly deviate from experimental findings when multiple modes influence the nonlinear response. Here, we present a nonline…
▽ More
Mechanical nonlinearities dominate the motion of nanoresonators already at relatively small oscillation amplitudes. Although single and coupled two-degrees-of-freedom models have been used to account for experimentally observed nonlinear effects, it is shown that these models quickly deviate from experimental findings when multiple modes influence the nonlinear response. Here, we present a nonlinear reduced-order modelling methodology based on FEM simulations for capturing the global nonlinear dynamics of nanomechanical resonators. Our physics-based approach obtains the quadratic and cubic nonlinearities of resonators over a wide frequency range that spans 70 MHz. To qualitatively validate our approach, we perform experiments on a graphene nanodrum driven opto-thermally and show that the model can replicate diverse ranges of nonlinear phenomena, including multi-stability, parametric resonance, and different internal resonances without considering any empirical nonlinear fitting parameters. By providing a direct link between microscopic geometry, material parameters, and nonlinear dynamic response, we clarify the physical significance of nonlinear parameters that are obtained from fitting the dynamics of nanomechanical systems, and provide a route for designing devices with desired nonlinear behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Sensitivity of viscoelastic characterization in multi-harmonic atomic force microscopy
Authors:
Abhilash Chandrashekar,
Arthur Givois,
Pierpaolo Belardinelli,
Casper L. Penning,
Alejandro M. Aragón,
Urs Staufer,
Farbod Alijani
Abstract:
Quantifying the nanomechanical properties of soft-matter using multi-frequency atomic force microscopy (AFM) is crucial for studying the performance of polymers, ultra-thin coatings, and biological systems. Such characterization processes often make use of cantilever's spectral components to discern nanomechanical properties within a multi-parameter optimization problem. This could inadvertently l…
▽ More
Quantifying the nanomechanical properties of soft-matter using multi-frequency atomic force microscopy (AFM) is crucial for studying the performance of polymers, ultra-thin coatings, and biological systems. Such characterization processes often make use of cantilever's spectral components to discern nanomechanical properties within a multi-parameter optimization problem. This could inadvertently lead to an over-determined parameter estimation with no clear relation between the identified parameters and their influence on the experimental data. In this work, we explore the sensitivity of viscoelastic characterization in polymeric samples to the experimental observables of multi-frequency intermodulation AFM. By performing simulations and experiments we show that surface viscoelasticity has negligible effect on the experimental data and can lead to inconsistent and often non-physical identified parameters. Our analysis reveals that this lack of influence of the surface parameters relates to a vanishing gradient and non-convexity while minimizing the objective function. By removing the surface dependency from the model, we show that the characterization of bulk properties can be achieved with ease and without any ambiguity. Our work sheds light on the sensitivity issues that can be faced when optimizing for a large number of parameters and observables in AFM operation, and calls for the development of new viscoelastic models at the nanoscale and improved computational methodologies for nanoscale mapping of viscoelasticity using AFM.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Edible meta-atoms
Authors:
André Souto,
Jian Zhang,
Alejandro M. Aragón,
Krassimir Velikov,
Corentin Coulais
Abstract:
Metamaterials are artificial structures with unusual and superior properties that come from their carefully designed building blocks -- also called meta-atoms. Metamaterials have permeated large swatches of science, including electromagnetics and mechanics. Although metamaterials hold the promise for realizing technological advances, their potential to enhance interactions between humans and mater…
▽ More
Metamaterials are artificial structures with unusual and superior properties that come from their carefully designed building blocks -- also called meta-atoms. Metamaterials have permeated large swatches of science, including electromagnetics and mechanics. Although metamaterials hold the promise for realizing technological advances, their potential to enhance interactions between humans and materials has remained unexplored. Here, we devise meta-atoms with tailored fracture properties to control mouthfeel sensory experience. Using chocolate as a model material, we first use meta-atoms to control the fracture anisotropy and the number of cracks and demonstrate that these properties are captured in mouthfeel experience. We further use topology optimization to rationally design edible meta-atoms with maximally anisotropic fracture strength. Our work opens avenues for the use of meta-atoms and metamaterials to control fracture and to enhance human-matter interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
