-
Detection asymmetry in solar energetic particle events
Authors:
S. Dalla,
A. Hutchinson,
R. A. Hyndman,
K. Kihara,
N. Nitta,
L. Rodriguez-Garcia,
T. Laitinen,
C. O. G. Waterfall,
D. S. Brown
Abstract:
Context. Solar energetic particles (SEPs) are detected in interplanetary space in association with solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs). The magnetic connection between the observing spacecraft and the solar active region (AR) source of the event is a key parameter in determining whether SEPs are observed and the particle event's properties. Aims. We investigate whether an east-west asym…
▽ More
Context. Solar energetic particles (SEPs) are detected in interplanetary space in association with solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs). The magnetic connection between the observing spacecraft and the solar active region (AR) source of the event is a key parameter in determining whether SEPs are observed and the particle event's properties. Aims. We investigate whether an east-west asymmetry in the detection of SEP events is present in observations and discuss its possible link to corotation of magnetic flux tubes with the Sun. Methods. We used a published dataset of 239 CMEs recorded between 2006 and 2017 and having source regions both on the Sun's front and far sides as seen from Earth. We produced distributions of occurrence of in-situ SEP intensity enhancements associated with the CME events, versus Δφ, the longitudinal separation between source active region and spacecraft magnetic footpoint based on the nominal Parker spiral. We focused on protons of energy >10 MeV measured by STEREO A, STEREO B and GOES at 1 au. We also considered occurrences of 71-112 keV electron events detected by MESSENGER between 0.31 and 0.47 au. Results. We find an east-west asymmetry with respect to the best magnetic connection (Δφ=0) in the detection of >10 MeV proton events and of 71-112 keV electron events. For protons, observers for which the source AR is on the east side of the spacecraft footpoint and not well connected (-180<Δφ<-40) are 93% more likely to detect an SEP event compared to observers with +40<Δφ<+180. The asymmetry may be a signature of corotation of magnetic flux tubes with the Sun, since for events with Δφ<0 corotation sweeps particle-filled flux tubes towards the observing spacecraft, while for Δφ>0 it takes them away from it. Alternatively it may be related to asymmetric acceleration or propagation effects.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2025; v1 submitted 12 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
The multi-spacecraft high-energy solar particle event of 28 October 2021
Authors:
A. Kouloumvakos,
A. Papaioannou,
C. O. G. Waterfall,
S. Dalla,
R. Vainio,
G. M. Mason,
B. Heber,
P. Kühl,
R. C. Allen,
C. M. S. Cohen,
G. Ho,
A. Anastasiadis,
A. P. Rouillard,
J. Rodríguez-Pacheco,
J. Guo,
X. Li,
M. Hörlöck,
R. F. Wimmer-Schweingruber
Abstract:
Aims. We studied the first multi-spacecraft high-energy solar energetic particle (SEP) event of solar cycle 25, which triggered a ground level enhancement (GLE) on 28 October 2021, using data from multiple observers that were widely distributed throughout the heliosphere.
Methods. We performed detail modelling of the shock wave and investigated the magnetic connectivity of each observer to the s…
▽ More
Aims. We studied the first multi-spacecraft high-energy solar energetic particle (SEP) event of solar cycle 25, which triggered a ground level enhancement (GLE) on 28 October 2021, using data from multiple observers that were widely distributed throughout the heliosphere.
Methods. We performed detail modelling of the shock wave and investigated the magnetic connectivity of each observer to the solar surface and examined the shock magnetic connection. We performed 3D SEP propagation simulations to investigate the role of particle transport in the distribution of SEPs to distant magnetically connected observers.
Results. Observations and modelling show that a strong shock wave formed promptly in the low corona. At the SEP release time windows, we find a connection with the shock for all the observers. PSP, STA, and Solar Orbiter were connected to strong shock regions with high Mach numbers, whereas the Earth and other observers were connected to lower Mach numbers. The SEP spectral properties near Earth demonstrate two power laws, with a harder (softer) spectrum in the low-energy (high-energy) range. Composition observations from SIS (and near-Earth instruments) show no serious enhancement of flare-accelerated material.
Conclusions. A possible scenario consistent with the observations and our analysis indicates that high-energy SEPs at PSP, STA, and Solar Orbiter were dominated by particle acceleration and injection by the shock, whereas high-energy SEPs that reached near-Earth space were associated with a weaker shock; it is likely that efficient transport of particles from a wide injection source contributed to the observed high-energy SEPs. Our study cannot exclude a contribution from a flare-related process; however, composition observations show no evidence of an impulsive composition of suprathermals during the event, suggestive of a non-dominant flare-related process.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Forecasting >300 MeV SEP events: Extending SPARX to high energies
Authors:
Charlotte O. G. Waterfall,
Silvia Dalla,
Mike S. Marsh,
Timo Laitinen,
Adam Hutchinson
Abstract:
The forecasting of solar energetic particles (SEPs) is a prominent area of space weather research. Numerous forecasting models exist that predict SEP event properties at proton energies <100MeV. One of these models is the SPARX system, a physics-based forecasting tool that calculates >10MeV and >60MeV flux profiles within minutes of a flare being detected. This work describes SPARX-H, the extensio…
▽ More
The forecasting of solar energetic particles (SEPs) is a prominent area of space weather research. Numerous forecasting models exist that predict SEP event properties at proton energies <100MeV. One of these models is the SPARX system, a physics-based forecasting tool that calculates >10MeV and >60MeV flux profiles within minutes of a flare being detected. This work describes SPARX-H, the extension of SPARX to forecast SEP events above 300MeV . SPARX-H predicts fluxes in three high energy channels up to several hundred MeV. Correlations between SEP peak flux and peak intensity of the associated solar flare are seen to be weak at high energies, but improved when events are grouped based on the field polarity during the event. Initial results from this new high energy forecasting tool are presented here and the applications of high energy forecasts are discussed. Additionally, the new high energy version of SPARX is tested on a set of historic SEP events. We see that SPARX-H performs best when predicting peak fluxes from events with source locations in well-connected regions, where many large SEP events tend to originate.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
High Energy Solar Particle Events and Their Relationship to Associated Flare, CME and GLE Parameters
Authors:
Charlotte Waterfall,
Silvia Dalla,
Osku Raukunen,
Daniel Heynderickx,
Piers Jiggens,
Rami Vainio
Abstract:
Large solar eruptive events, including solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs), can lead to solar energetic particle (SEP) events. During these events, protons are accelerated up to several GeV and pose numerous space weather risks. These risks include, but are not limited to, radiation hazards to astronauts and disruption to satellites and electronics. The highest energy SEPs are capable o…
▽ More
Large solar eruptive events, including solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs), can lead to solar energetic particle (SEP) events. During these events, protons are accelerated up to several GeV and pose numerous space weather risks. These risks include, but are not limited to, radiation hazards to astronauts and disruption to satellites and electronics. The highest energy SEPs are capable of reaching Earth on timescales of minutes and can be detected in ground level enhancements (GLEs). Understanding and analyzing these events is critical to future forecasting models. However, the availability of high energy SEP data sets is limited, especially that which covers multiple solar cycles. The majority of analysis of SEP events considers data at energies <100 MeV. In this work, we use a newly calibrated data set using data from Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite-high energy proton and alpha detector between 1984 and 2017. Analysis of the SEP events in this time period over three high energy channels is performed, and SEP properties are compared to flare and CME parameters. In addition, neutron monitor (NM) observations are examined for the relevant GLE events. We find that correlations between SEP peak intensity and the CME speed are much weaker than for lower SEP energies. Correlations with flare intensity are broadly similar or weaker. Strong correlations are seen between >300 MeV data and GLE properties from NM data. The results of our work can be utilized in future forecasting models for both high energy SEP and GLE events.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Solar Energetic Particle event onsets at different heliolongitudes: The effect of turbulence in Parker Spiral Geometry
Authors:
T. Laitinen,
S. Dalla,
C. O. G. Waterfall,
A. Hutchinson
Abstract:
Solar energetic particles (SEPs), accelerated during solar eruptions, are observed to rapidly reach a wide heliolongitudinal range in the interplanetary space. To access these locations, the SEPs must have either been accelerated at a wide particle source, or propagated across the mean Parker spiral magnetic field. We study the propagation of SEPs in a new model of heliospheric turbulence which ta…
▽ More
Solar energetic particles (SEPs), accelerated during solar eruptions, are observed to rapidly reach a wide heliolongitudinal range in the interplanetary space. To access these locations, the SEPs must have either been accelerated at a wide particle source, or propagated across the mean Parker spiral magnetic field. We study the propagation of SEPs in a new model of heliospheric turbulence which takes the spiral geometry of the average magnetic field into account, to evaluate how this improved description affects the SEP path lengths and the overall evolution of SEP intensities at 1~au. We use full-orbit test particle simulations of 100-MeV protons in a turbulence model dominated by modes that are transverse and 2D with respect to the Parker spiral. We find that the SEPs spread along the meandering field lines to arrive at a 60$^\circ$ heliolongitudinal range at 1~au within an hour of their injection at the Sun, consistent with the extent of the meandering field lines. The SEP onset times are asymmetric with respect to the location connected to the source along the Parker spiral, with westward locations seeing earlier arrival and higher peak intensity. The inferred path length of the first-arriving SEPs is 1.5-1.7~au, 30-50\% longer than the Parker spiral, and 20\% longer than the length of the meandering field lines. Subsequently, the SEP distribution broadens, consistent with diffusive spreading of SEPs across the field lines. Our results indicate that SEPs can propagate rapidly across the mean Parker Spiral field to arrive at wide range of longitudes, even without a wide particle source. The modelled SEP onset times, the peak intensity and subsequent heliolongitudinal evolution replicate several observed SEP event features. Further studies are be required to investigate the relative importance of interplanetary transport and source size in different turbulence environments.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
An analytical model of turbulence in Parker spiral geometry and associated magnetic field line lengths
Authors:
T. Laitinen,
S. Dalla,
C. O. G. Waterfall,
A. Hutchinson
Abstract:
Understanding the magnetic connections from the Sun to interplanetary space is crucial for linking in situ particle observations with the solar source regions of the particles. A simple connection along the large-scale Parker spiral magnetic field is made complex by the turbulent random-walk of field lines. In this paper, we present the first analytical model of heliospheric magnetic fields where…
▽ More
Understanding the magnetic connections from the Sun to interplanetary space is crucial for linking in situ particle observations with the solar source regions of the particles. A simple connection along the large-scale Parker spiral magnetic field is made complex by the turbulent random-walk of field lines. In this paper, we present the first analytical model of heliospheric magnetic fields where the dominant 2D component of the turbulence is transverse to the Parker spiral. The 2D wave field is supplemented with a minor wave field component that has asymptotically slab geometry at small and large heliocentric distances. We show that turbulence spreads field lines from a small source region at the Sun to a 60$^\circ$ heliolongitudinal and -latitudinal range at 1~au, with standard deviation of the angular spread of the field lines $14^\circ$. Small source regions map to an intermittent range of longitudes and latitudes at 1~au, consistent with dropouts in solar energetic particle intensities. The lengths of the field lines are significantly extended from the nominal Parker spiral length of 1.17~au up to 1.6~au, with field lines from sources at and behind the west limb considerably longer than those closer to the solar disk centre. We discuss the implications of our findings on understanding charged particle propagation, and the importance of understanding the turbulence properties close to the Sun.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Modelling shock-like injections of solar energetic particles with 3D test particle simulations
Authors:
Adam Hutchinson,
Silvia Dalla,
Timo Laitinen,
Charlotte O. G. Waterfall
Abstract:
Solar Energetic Particle (SEP) acceleration and injection into interplanetary space during gradual SEP events is thought to take place at Coronal Mass Ejection (CME)-driven shocks. Features of measured intensity profiles at 1 au have been attributed to properties of the radial and longitudinal/latitudinal injections at the shock. Focussed transport models are typically used to model acceleration a…
▽ More
Solar Energetic Particle (SEP) acceleration and injection into interplanetary space during gradual SEP events is thought to take place at Coronal Mass Ejection (CME)-driven shocks. Features of measured intensity profiles at 1 au have been attributed to properties of the radial and longitudinal/latitudinal injections at the shock. Focussed transport models are typically used to model acceleration at a CME-shock and subsequent propagation. Test particle simulations are an alternative approach but so far they have been carried out only with instantaneous injection near the Sun. We develop the first temporally extended shock-like injection for our 3D test particle code and investigate how the spatial features of injection affect SEP intensity and anisotropy profiles for observers at 0.3 and 1.0 au. We conduct simulations of a monoenergetic population of 5 MeV protons considering three different radial injection functions and two longitudinal/latitudinal injection functions. We consider a range of scattering conditions with scattering mean free path values ranging from 0.1-1.0 au, and determine intensity and anisotropy profiles at six observers at different longitudinal locations. We find that the radial, longitudinal and latitudinal injection functions play a relatively minor role in shaping the SEP intensity profiles. The dependence of profiles on the value of the scattering mean free path is also weak, unlike what is found from 1D focussed transport models. Spatial factors, such as the time of observer-shock-connection/disconnection and time of shock passage have a much stronger influence on SEP intensities and anisotropies. Persistent anisotropies until shock passage are seen in our simulations. Comparing instantaneous and shock-like injections, we find that the link between duration of injection and of the SEP event is very weak, unlike what is commonly assumed.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2023; v1 submitted 27 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The impact of corotation on gradual solar energetic particle event intensity profiles
Authors:
Adam Hutchinson,
Silvia Dalla,
Timo Laitinen,
Charlotte O. G. Waterfall
Abstract:
Corotation of particle-filled magnetic flux tubes is generally thought to have a minor influence on the time-intensity profiles of gradual Solar Energetic Particle (SEP) events. For this reason many models solve the focussed transport equation within the corotating frame, thus neglecting corotation effects. We study the effects of corotation on gradual SEP intensity profiles at a range of observer…
▽ More
Corotation of particle-filled magnetic flux tubes is generally thought to have a minor influence on the time-intensity profiles of gradual Solar Energetic Particle (SEP) events. For this reason many models solve the focussed transport equation within the corotating frame, thus neglecting corotation effects. We study the effects of corotation on gradual SEP intensity profiles at a range of observer longitudinal positions relative to the solar source. We study how corotation affects the duration and decay time constant of SEP events and the variation of peak intensity with observer position. We use a 3D full-orbit test particle code with time-extended SEP injection via a shock-like source. Unlike with focussed transport models, the test particle approach enables us to switch corotation on and off easily. While shock acceleration is not modelled directly, our methodology allows us to study how corotation and the time-varying observer-shock magnetic connection influence intensity profiles detected at six observers. We find that corotation strongly affects SEP profiles, for a monoenergetic population of 5 MeV protons, being a dominant influence during the decay phase. Simulations including corotation display dramatically shortened durations for western events, compared to those which do not include it. When corotation is taken into account, for both eastern and western events the decay time constant is reduced and its dependence on the scattering mean free path becomes negligible. Corotation reduces the peak intensity for western events and enhances it for eastern ones, thus making the east-west asymmetry in peak intensity stronger, compared to the no-corotation case. Modelling SEP intensity profiles without carefully accounting for corotation leads to artificially extended decay phases during western events and profiles with a similar shape regardless of observer longitudinal position.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2023; v1 submitted 27 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Modelling the transport of relativistic solar protons along a heliospheric current sheet during historic GLE events
Authors:
Charlotte O. G. Waterfall,
Silvia Dalla,
Timo Laitinen,
Adam Hutchinson,
Mike Marsh
Abstract:
There are many difficulties associated with forecasting high-energy solar particle events at Earth. One issue is understanding why some large solar eruptive events trigger ground level enhancement (GLE) events and others do not. In this work we perform 3D test particle simulations of a set of historic GLEs to understand more about what causes these powerful events. Particular focus is given to stu…
▽ More
There are many difficulties associated with forecasting high-energy solar particle events at Earth. One issue is understanding why some large solar eruptive events trigger ground level enhancement (GLE) events and others do not. In this work we perform 3D test particle simulations of a set of historic GLEs to understand more about what causes these powerful events. Particular focus is given to studying how the heliospheric current sheet (HCS) affects high-energy proton transport through the heliosphere following an event. Analysis of $\geq$M7.0 flares between 1976$-$2020 shows that active regions located closer to the HCS ($<$10$^{\circ}$) are more likely to be associated with a GLE event. We found that modelled GLE events where the source region was close to the HCS also led to increased heliospheric transport in longitude and higher count rates (when the Earth was located in the drift direction). In a model that does not include perpendicular diffusion associated with turbulence, the HCS is the dominant mechanism affecting heliospheric particle transport for GLE 42 and 69, and varying other parameters (e.g. a narrow, 10$^{\circ}$, or wider, 60$^{\circ}$, injection width) causes little change. Overall in our model, the HCS is relevant in 71$\%$ of our analysed GLEs and including it more accurately reproduces observed intensities near Earth. Our simulations enable us to produce model profiles at Earth that can be compared to existing observations by the GOES satellites and neutron monitors, as well as for use in developing future forecasting models.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Energetic Proton Back-Precipitation onto the Solar Atmosphere in Relation to Long-Duration Gamma-Ray Flares
Authors:
Adam Hutchinson,
Silvia Dalla,
Timo Laitinen,
Georgia A. de Nolfo,
Alessandro Bruno,
James M. Ryan,
Charlotte O. G. Waterfall
Abstract:
Gamma-ray emission during long-duration gamma-ray flare (LDGRF) events is thought to be caused mainly by $>$300 MeV protons interacting with the ambient plasma at or near the photosphere. Prolonged periods of the gamma-ray emission have prompted the suggestion that the source of the energetic protons is acceleration at a coronal mass ejection (CME)-driven shock, followed by particle back-precipita…
▽ More
Gamma-ray emission during long-duration gamma-ray flare (LDGRF) events is thought to be caused mainly by $>$300 MeV protons interacting with the ambient plasma at or near the photosphere. Prolonged periods of the gamma-ray emission have prompted the suggestion that the source of the energetic protons is acceleration at a coronal mass ejection (CME)-driven shock, followed by particle back-precipitation onto the solar atmosphere over extended times. We study the latter hypothesis using test particle simulations, which allow us to investigate whether scattering associated with turbulence aids particles in overcoming the effect of magnetic mirroring, which impedes back-precipitation by reflecting particles as they travel sunwards. The instantaneous precipitation fraction, $P$, the proportion of protons that successfully precipitate for injection at a fixed height, $r_i$, is studied as a function of scattering mean free path, $λ$ and $r_i$. Upper limits to the total precipitation fraction, $\overline{P}$, were calculated for eight LDGRF events for moderate scattering conditions ($λ$=0.1 au). We find that the presence of scattering helps back-precipitation compared to the scatter-free case, although at very low $λ$ values outward convection with the solar wind ultimately dominates. For eight LDGRF events, due to strong mirroring, $\overline{P}$ is very small, between 0.56 and 0.93% even in the presence of scattering. Time-extended acceleration and large total precipitation fractions, as seen in the observations, cannot be reconciled for a moving shock source according to our simulations. Therefore, it is not possible to obtain both long duration $γ$ ray emission and efficient precipitation within this scenario. These results challenge the CME shock source scenario as the main mechanism for $γ$ ray production in LDGRFs.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2021; v1 submitted 9 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Predicting the time variation of radio emission from MHD simulations of a flaring T-Tauri star
Authors:
C. O. G. Waterfall,
P. K. Browning,
G. A. Fuller,
M. Gordovskyy,
S. Orlando,
F. Reale
Abstract:
We model the time dependent radio emission from a disk accretion event in a T-Tauri star using 3D, ideal magnetohydrodynamic simulations combined with a gyrosynchrotron emission and radiative transfer model. We predict for the first time, the multi-frequency (1$-$1000 GHz) intensity and circular polarisation from a flaring T-Tauri star. A flux tube, connecting the star with its circumstellar disk,…
▽ More
We model the time dependent radio emission from a disk accretion event in a T-Tauri star using 3D, ideal magnetohydrodynamic simulations combined with a gyrosynchrotron emission and radiative transfer model. We predict for the first time, the multi-frequency (1$-$1000 GHz) intensity and circular polarisation from a flaring T-Tauri star. A flux tube, connecting the star with its circumstellar disk, is populated with a distribution of non-thermal electrons which is allowed to decay exponentially after a heating event in the disk and the system is allowed to evolve. The energy distribution of the electrons, as well as the non-thermal power law index and loss rate, are varied to see their effect on the overall flux. Spectra are generated from different lines of sight, giving different views of the flux tube and disk. The peak flux typically occurs around 20$-$30 GHz and the radio luminosity is consistent with that observed from T-Tauri stars. For all simulations, the peak flux is found to decrease and move to lower frequencies with elapsing time. The frequency-dependent circular polarisation can reach 10$-$30$\%$ but has a complex structure which evolves as the flare evolves. Our models show that observations of the evolution of the spectrum and its polarisation can provide important constraints on physical properties of the flaring environment and associated accretion event.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
