-
Relativistically Magnetized Collisionless Shocks in Pair Plasma: I. Solitons, Chaos, and Thermalization
Authors:
Arno Vanthieghem,
Amir Levinson
Abstract:
In this paper, the first in a series, we present a new theoretical model for the global structure and dissipation of relativistically magnetized collisionless shock waves. Quite remarkably, we find that in contrast to unmagnetized shocks, the leading energy dissipation channel does not involve collective plasma interactions. Rather, it is a consequence of nonlinear particle dynamics. We demonstrat…
▽ More
In this paper, the first in a series, we present a new theoretical model for the global structure and dissipation of relativistically magnetized collisionless shock waves. Quite remarkably, we find that in contrast to unmagnetized shocks, the leading energy dissipation channel does not involve collective plasma interactions. Rather, it is a consequence of nonlinear particle dynamics. We demonstrate that the kinetic-scale shock transition can be modeled as a stationary system consisting of a large set of cold beams coupled through the magnetic field. The fundamental mechanism governing shock dissipation relies on the onset of chaos in orbital dynamics within quasiperiodic solitonic structures. We discuss the impact of upstream temperature and magnetization on the shock profile, recovering the magnetic field compression, downstream velocities, and heating expected from the Rankine-Hugoniot jump conditions. We deduce a rate of entropy generation from the spectrum of Lyapunov exponents and discuss the thermalization of the beam distribution. Our model provides a general framework to study magnetized collisionless shock structures.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2025; v1 submitted 25 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Generation of large-scale magnetic fields upstream of gamma-ray burst afterglow shocks
Authors:
Ryan Golant,
Arno Vanthieghem,
Daniel Groselj,
Lorenzo Sironi
Abstract:
The origins of the magnetic fields that power gamma-ray burst (GRB) afterglow emission are not fully understood. One possible channel for generating these fields involves the pre-conditioning of the circumburst medium: in the early afterglow phase, prompt photons streaming ahead of the GRB external shock can pair produce, seeding the upstream with drifting electron-positron pairs and triggering el…
▽ More
The origins of the magnetic fields that power gamma-ray burst (GRB) afterglow emission are not fully understood. One possible channel for generating these fields involves the pre-conditioning of the circumburst medium: in the early afterglow phase, prompt photons streaming ahead of the GRB external shock can pair produce, seeding the upstream with drifting electron-positron pairs and triggering electromagnetic microinstabilities. To study this process, we employ 2D periodic particle-in-cell simulations in which a cold electron-proton plasma is gradually enriched with warm electron-positron pairs injected at mildly relativistic speeds. We find that continuous pair injection drives the growth of large-scale magnetic fields via filamentation-like instabilities; the temporal evolution of the field is self-similar and depends on a single parameter, $\left[α/(t_f ω_{pi})\right]^{1/2} tω_{pi}$, where $α$ is the ratio of final pair beam density to background plasma density, $t_f$ is the duration of pair injection, and $ω_{pi}$ is the plasma frequency of background protons. Extrapolating our results to parameter regimes realistic for long GRBs, we find that upstream pair enrichment generates weak magnetic fields on scales much larger than the proton skin depth; for bright bursts, the extrapolated coherence scale at a shock radius of $R \sim 10^{17}$ cm is $\left<λ_y\right> \sim 100 c/ω_{pi}$ and the corresponding magnetization is $σ\sim 10^{-8}$ for typical circumburst parameters. These results may help explain the persistence of magnetic fields at large distances behind GRB shocks.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Fast radio bursts as precursor radio emission from monster shocks
Authors:
Arno Vanthieghem,
Amir Levinson
Abstract:
It has been proposed recently that the breaking of MHD waves in the inner magnetosphere of strongly magnetized neutron stars can power different types of high-energy transients. Motivated by these considerations, we study the steepening and dissipation of a strongly magnetized fast magnetosonic wave propagating in a declining background magnetic field, by means of particle-in-cell simulations that…
▽ More
It has been proposed recently that the breaking of MHD waves in the inner magnetosphere of strongly magnetized neutron stars can power different types of high-energy transients. Motivated by these considerations, we study the steepening and dissipation of a strongly magnetized fast magnetosonic wave propagating in a declining background magnetic field, by means of particle-in-cell simulations that encompass MHD scales. Our analysis confirms the formation of a monster shock as $B^2-E^2 \to 0$, that dissipates about half of the fast magnetosonic wave energy. It also reveals, for the first time, the generation of a high-frequency precursor wave by a synchrotron maser instability at the monster shock front, carrying a fraction of $\sim 10^{-3}$ of the total energy dissipated at the shock. The spectrum of the precursor wave exhibits several sharp harmonic peaks, with frequencies in the GHz band under conditions anticipated in magnetars. Such signals may appear as fast radio bursts.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2025; v1 submitted 21 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Electron-Ion Temperature Ratio in Transrelativistic Unmagnetized Shock Waves
Authors:
Arno Vanthieghem,
Vasileios Tsiolis,
Frederico Fiuza,
Kazuhiro Sekiguchi,
Anatoly Spitkovsky,
Yasushi Todo
Abstract:
Weakly magnetized shock waves are paramount to a large diversity of environments, including supernova remnants, blazars, and binary-neutron-star mergers. Understanding the distribution of energy between electrons and ions within these astrophysical shock waves spanning a wide spectrum of velocities is a long-standing challenge. In this study, we present a unified model for the downstream electron…
▽ More
Weakly magnetized shock waves are paramount to a large diversity of environments, including supernova remnants, blazars, and binary-neutron-star mergers. Understanding the distribution of energy between electrons and ions within these astrophysical shock waves spanning a wide spectrum of velocities is a long-standing challenge. In this study, we present a unified model for the downstream electron temperature within unmagnetized shock waves. Encompassing velocities from Newtonian to relativistic, we probe regimes representative of the gradual deceleration of the forward shock in the late gamma-ray burst afterglow phase, such as GRB 170817A. In our model, heating results from an ambipolar electric field generated by the difference in inertia between electrons and ions, coupled with rapid electron scattering in the decelerating turbulence. Our findings demonstrate that the electron temperature consistently represents $10\%$ of the incoming ion kinetic energy in the shock front frame over the full range of shock velocities.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Electron heating in high Mach number collisionless shocks
Authors:
Arno Vanthieghem,
Vasileios Tsiolis,
Anatoly Spitkovsky,
Yasushi Todo,
Kazuhiro Sekiguchi,
Frederico Fiuza
Abstract:
The energy partition in high Mach number collisionless shock waves is central to a wide range of high-energy astrophysical environments. We present a new theoretical model for electron heating that accounts for the energy exchange between electrons and ions at the shock. The fundamental mechanism relies on the difference in inertia between electrons and ions, resulting in differential scattering o…
▽ More
The energy partition in high Mach number collisionless shock waves is central to a wide range of high-energy astrophysical environments. We present a new theoretical model for electron heating that accounts for the energy exchange between electrons and ions at the shock. The fundamental mechanism relies on the difference in inertia between electrons and ions, resulting in differential scattering of the particles off a decelerating magnetically-dominated microturbulence across the shock transition. We show that the self-consistent interplay between the resulting ambipolar-type electric field and diffusive transport of electrons leads to efficient heating in the magnetic field produced by the Weibel instability in the high-Mach number regime and is consistent with fully kinetic simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Microphysics of Particle Reflection in Weibel-Mediated Shocks
Authors:
Jasmine Parsons,
Anatoly Spitkovsky,
Arno Vanthieghem
Abstract:
Particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations have shown that relativistic collisionless shocks mediated by the Weibel instability accelerate about 1% of incoming particles, while the majority are transmitted through the shock and become thermalized. The microphysical processes that determine whether an incoming particle will be transmitted or reflected are poorly understood. We study the microphysics of par…
▽ More
Particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations have shown that relativistic collisionless shocks mediated by the Weibel instability accelerate about 1% of incoming particles, while the majority are transmitted through the shock and become thermalized. The microphysical processes that determine whether an incoming particle will be transmitted or reflected are poorly understood. We study the microphysics of particle reflection in Weibel-mediated shocks by tracking a shell of test particles in a PIC simulation of a shock in pair plasma. We find that electrons in positron-dominated filaments and positrons in electron-dominated filaments efficiently reflect off of strong magnetic structures at the shock. These reflected particles headed towards the upstream must then find filaments of the same sign of current as the current carried by the reflected particles in order to successfully move with the shock and participate in diffusive shock acceleration (DSA). The final injection efficiency on the order of about 1% thus results from the effectiveness of the initial reflection at the shock and the reflected particles' probability of survival in the upstream post-reflection. We develop a model that predicts the fraction of high-energy particles as a function of the properties of Weibel filamentation.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Anomalous coupling in radiation mediated shocks}
Authors:
A. Levinson,
A. Granot,
A. Vanthieghem,
J. F. Mahlmann
Abstract:
We summarize recent attempts to unravel the role of plasma kinetic effects in radiation mediated shocks. Such shocks form in all strong stellar explosions and are responsible for the early electromagnetic emission released from these events. A key issue that has been overlooked in all previous works is the nature of the coupling between the charged leptons, that mediate the radiation force, and th…
▽ More
We summarize recent attempts to unravel the role of plasma kinetic effects in radiation mediated shocks. Such shocks form in all strong stellar explosions and are responsible for the early electromagnetic emission released from these events. A key issue that has been overlooked in all previous works is the nature of the coupling between the charged leptons, that mediate the radiation force, and the ions, which are the dominant carriers of the shock energy. Our preliminary investigation indicates that in the case of relativistic shocks, as well as Newtonian shocks in multi-ion plasma, this coupling is driven by either, transverse magnetic fields of a sufficiently magnetized upstream medium, or plasma micro-turbulence if strong enough magnetic fields are absent. We discuss the implications for the shock breakout signal, as well as abundance evolution and kilonova emission in binary neutron star mergers.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Magnetically driven coupling in relativistic radiation-mediated shocks
Authors:
J. F. Mahlmann,
A. Vanthieghem,
A. A. Philippov,
A. Levinson,
E. Nakar,
F. Fiuza
Abstract:
The radiation drag in photon-rich environments of cosmic explosions can seed kinetic instabilities by inducing velocity spreads between relativistically streaming plasma components. Such microturbulence is likely imprinted on the breakout signals of radiation-mediated shocks. However, large-scale, transverse magnetic fields in the deceleration region of the shock transition can suppress the domina…
▽ More
The radiation drag in photon-rich environments of cosmic explosions can seed kinetic instabilities by inducing velocity spreads between relativistically streaming plasma components. Such microturbulence is likely imprinted on the breakout signals of radiation-mediated shocks. However, large-scale, transverse magnetic fields in the deceleration region of the shock transition can suppress the dominant kinetic instabilities by preventing the development of velocity separations between electron-positron pairs and a heavy ion species. We use a one-dimensional (1D) five-fluid radiative transfer code to generate self-consistent profiles of the radiation drag force and plasma composition in the deceleration region. For increasing magnetization, our models predict rapidly growing pair multiplicities and a substantial radiative drag developing self-similarly throughout the deceleration region. We extract the critical magnetization parameter $σ_{c}$, determining the limiting magnetic field strength at which a three-species plasma can develop kinetic instabilities before reaching the isotropized downstream. For a relativistic, single ion plasma drifting with $γ_{u} = 10$ in the upstream of a relativistic radiation-mediated shock, we find the threshold $σ_{c}\approx 10^{-7}$ for the onset of microturbulence. Suppression of plasma instabilities in the case of multi-ion composition would likely require much higher values of $σ_{c}$. Identifying high-energy signatures of microturbulence in shock-breakout signals and combining them with the magnetization limits provided in this work will allow a deeper understanding of the magnetic environment of cosmic explosions like supernovae, gamma-ray bursts, and neutron star binary mergers.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2023; v1 submitted 14 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Origin of intense electron heating in relativistic blast waves
Authors:
Arno Vanthieghem,
Martin Lemoine,
Laurent Gremillet
Abstract:
The modeling of gamma-ray burst afterglow emission bears witness to strong electron heating in the precursor of Weibel-mediated, relativistic collisionless shock waves propagating in unmagnetized electron-ion plasmas. In this Letter, we propose a theoretical model, which describes electron heating via a Joule-like process caused by pitch-angle scattering in the decelerating, self-induced microturb…
▽ More
The modeling of gamma-ray burst afterglow emission bears witness to strong electron heating in the precursor of Weibel-mediated, relativistic collisionless shock waves propagating in unmagnetized electron-ion plasmas. In this Letter, we propose a theoretical model, which describes electron heating via a Joule-like process caused by pitch-angle scattering in the decelerating, self-induced microturbulence and the coherent charge-separation field induced by the difference in inertia between electrons and ions. The emergence of this electric field across the precursor of electron-ion shocks is confirmed by large-scale particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations. Integrating the model using a Monte Carlo-Poisson method, we compare the main observables to the PIC simulations to conclude that the above mechanism can indeed account for the bulk of electron heating.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
The role of plasma instabilities in relativistic radiation mediated shocks: stability analysis and particle-in-cell simulations
Authors:
Arno Vanthieghem,
Jens F. Mahlmann,
Amir Levinson,
Alexander A. Philippov,
Ehud Nakar,
Frederico Fiuza
Abstract:
Relativistic radiation mediated shocks (RRMS) likely form in prodigious cosmic explosions. The structure and emission of such shocks is regulated by copious production of electron-positron pairs inside the shock transition layer. It has been pointed out recently that substantial abundance of positrons inside the shock leads to a velocity separation of the different plasma constituents, which is ex…
▽ More
Relativistic radiation mediated shocks (RRMS) likely form in prodigious cosmic explosions. The structure and emission of such shocks is regulated by copious production of electron-positron pairs inside the shock transition layer. It has been pointed out recently that substantial abundance of positrons inside the shock leads to a velocity separation of the different plasma constituents, which is expected to induce a rapid growth of plasma instabilities. In this paper, we study the hierarchy of plasma microinstabilities growing in an electron-ion plasma loaded with pairs and subject to a radiation force. Linear stability analysis indicates that such a system is unstable to the growth of various plasma modes which ultimately become dominated by a current filamentation instability driven by the relative drift between the ions and the pairs. These results are validated by particle-in-cell simulations that further probe the nonlinear regime of the instabilities, and the pair-ion coupling in the microturbulent electromagnetic field. Based on this analysis, we derive a reduced transport equation for the particles via pitch angle scattering in the microturbulence and demonstrate that it can couple the different species and lead to nonadiabatic compression via a Joule-like heating. The heating of the pairs and, conceivably, the formation of nonthermal distributions, arising from the microturbulence, can affect the observed shock breakout signal in ways unaccounted for by current single-fluid models.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Physics and phenomenology of weakly magnetized, relativistic astrophysical shock waves
Authors:
A. Vanthieghem,
M. Lemoine,
I. Plotnikov,
A. Grassi,
M. Grech,
L. Gremillet,
G. Pelletier
Abstract:
Weakly magnetized, relativistic collisionless shock waves are not only the natural offsprings of relativistic jets in high-energy astrophysical sources, they are also associated with some of the most outstanding displays of energy dissipation through particle acceleration and radiation. Perhaps their most peculiar and exciting feature is that the magnetized turbulence that sustains the acceleratio…
▽ More
Weakly magnetized, relativistic collisionless shock waves are not only the natural offsprings of relativistic jets in high-energy astrophysical sources, they are also associated with some of the most outstanding displays of energy dissipation through particle acceleration and radiation. Perhaps their most peculiar and exciting feature is that the magnetized turbulence that sustains the acceleration process, and (possibly) the secondary radiation itself, is self-excited by the accelerated particles themselves, so that the phenomenology of these shock waves hinges strongly on the microphysics of the shock. In this review, we draw a status report of this microphysics, benchmarking analytical arguments with particle-in-cell simulations, and extract consequences of direct interest to the phenomenology, regarding in particular the so-called microphysical parameters used in phenomenological studies.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2020; v1 submitted 4 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Physics of relativistic collisionless shocks: III The suprathermal particles
Authors:
Martin Lemoine,
Guy Pelletier,
Arno Vanthieghem,
Laurent Gremillet
Abstract:
In this third paper of a series, we discuss the physics of the population of accelerated particles in the precursor of an unmagnetized, relativistic collisionless pair shock. In particular, we provide a theoretical estimate of their scattering length $l_{scatt}(p)$ in the self-generated electromagnetic turbulence, as well as an estimate of their distribution function. We obtain…
▽ More
In this third paper of a series, we discuss the physics of the population of accelerated particles in the precursor of an unmagnetized, relativistic collisionless pair shock. In particular, we provide a theoretical estimate of their scattering length $l_{scatt}(p)$ in the self-generated electromagnetic turbulence, as well as an estimate of their distribution function. We obtain $l_{scatt}(p) \simeq (γ_p /ε_B)(p/γ_{\infty} mc)^2 (c/ω_p)$, with p the particle momentum in the rest frame of the shock front, $ε_B$ the strength parameter of the microturbulence, $γ_p$ the Lorentz factor of the background plasma relative to the shock front and $γ_{\infty}$ its asymptotic value outside the precursor. We compare this scattering length to large-scale PIC simulations and find good agreement for the various dependencies.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2019; v1 submitted 24 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Physics of relativistic collisionless shocks: II Dynamics of the background plasma
Authors:
M. Lemoine,
A. Vanthieghem,
G. Pelletier,
L. Gremillet
Abstract:
In this second paper of a series, we discuss the dynamics of a plasma entering the precursor of an unmagnetized, relativistic collisionless pair shock. We discuss how this background plasma is decelerated and heated through its interaction with a microturbulence that results from the growth of a current filamentation instability (CFI) in the shock precursor. We make use, in particular, of the refe…
▽ More
In this second paper of a series, we discuss the dynamics of a plasma entering the precursor of an unmagnetized, relativistic collisionless pair shock. We discuss how this background plasma is decelerated and heated through its interaction with a microturbulence that results from the growth of a current filamentation instability (CFI) in the shock precursor. We make use, in particular, of the reference frame $\mathcal R_{\rm w}$ in which the turbulence is mostly magnetic. This frame moves at relativistic velocities towards the shock front at rest, decelerating gradually from the far to the near precursor. In a first part, we construct a fluid model to derive the deceleration law of the background plasma expected from the scattering of suprathermal particles off the microturbulence. This law leads to the relationship $γ_{\rm p}\,\sim\,ξ_{\rm b}^{-1/2}$ between the background plasma Lorentz factor $γ_{\rm p}$ and the normalized pressure of the beam $ξ_{\rm b}$; it is found to match nicely the spatial profiles observed in large-scale 2D3V particle-in-cell simulations. In a second part, we model the dynamics of the background plasma at the kinetic level, incorporating the inertial effects associated with the deceleration of $\mathcal R_{\rm w}$ into a Vlasov-Fokker-Planck equation for pitch-angle diffusion. We show how the effective gravity in $\mathcal R_{\rm w}$ drives the background plasma particles through friction on the microturbulence, leading to efficient plasma heating. Finally, we compare a Monte Carlo simulation of our model with dedicated PIC simulations and conclude that it can satisfactorily reproduce both the heating and the deceleration of the background plasma in the shock precursor, thereby providing a successful 1D description of the shock transition at the microscopic level.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2019; v1 submitted 18 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Physics of relativistic collisionless shocks: The scattering center frame
Authors:
G. Pelletier,
L. Gremillet,
A. Vanthieghem,
M. Lemoine
Abstract:
In this first paper of a series dedicated to the microphysics of unmagnetized, relativistic collisionless pair shocks, we discuss the physics of the Weibel-type transverse current filamentation instability (CFI) that develops in the shock precursor, through the interaction of an ultrarelativistic suprathermal particle beam with the background plasma. We introduce in particular the notion of "Weibe…
▽ More
In this first paper of a series dedicated to the microphysics of unmagnetized, relativistic collisionless pair shocks, we discuss the physics of the Weibel-type transverse current filamentation instability (CFI) that develops in the shock precursor, through the interaction of an ultrarelativistic suprathermal particle beam with the background plasma. We introduce in particular the notion of "Weibel frame", or scattering center frame, in which the microturbulence is of mostly magnetic nature. We calculate the properties of this frame, using first a kinetic formulation of the linear phase of the instability, relying on Maxwell-Jüttner distribution functions, then using a quasistatic model of the nonlinear stage of the instability. Both methods show that: (i) the Weibel frame moves at subrelativistic velocities relative to the background plasma, therefore at relativistic velocities relative to the shock front; (ii) the velocity of the Weibel frame relative to the background plasma scales with $ξ_{\rm b}$, i.e., the pressure of the suprathermal particle beam in units of the momentum flux density incoming into the shock; and (iii), the Weibel frame moves slightly less fast than the background plasma relative to the shock front. Our theoretical results are found to be in satisfactory agreement with the measurements carried out in dedicated large-scale 2D3V PIC simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2019; v1 submitted 17 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Physics of Weibel-mediated relativistic collisionless shocks
Authors:
M. Lemoine,
L. Gremillet,
G. Pelletier,
A. Vanthieghem
Abstract:
We develop a comprehensive theoretical model of relativistic collisionless pair shocks mediated by the current filamentation instability. We notably characterize the noninertial frame in which this instability is of a mostly magnetic nature, and describe at a microscopic level the deceleration and heating of the incoming background plasma through its collisionless interaction with the electromagne…
▽ More
We develop a comprehensive theoretical model of relativistic collisionless pair shocks mediated by the current filamentation instability. We notably characterize the noninertial frame in which this instability is of a mostly magnetic nature, and describe at a microscopic level the deceleration and heating of the incoming background plasma through its collisionless interaction with the electromagnetic turbulence. Our model compares well to large-scale 2D3V PIC simulations, and provides an important touchstone for the phenomenology of such plasma systems.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2019; v1 submitted 17 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Stability analysis of a periodic system of relativistic current filaments
Authors:
Arno Vanthieghem,
Martin Lemoine,
Laurent Gremillet
Abstract:
The nonlinear evolution of current filaments generated by the Weibel-type filamentation instability is a topic of prime interest in space and laboratory plasma physics. In this paper, we investigate the stability of a stationary periodic chain of nonlinear current filaments in counterstreaming pair plasmas. We make use of a relativistic four-fluid model and apply the Floquet theory to compute the…
▽ More
The nonlinear evolution of current filaments generated by the Weibel-type filamentation instability is a topic of prime interest in space and laboratory plasma physics. In this paper, we investigate the stability of a stationary periodic chain of nonlinear current filaments in counterstreaming pair plasmas. We make use of a relativistic four-fluid model and apply the Floquet theory to compute the two-dimensional unstable eigenmodes of the spatially periodic system. We examine three different cases, characterized by various levels of nonlinearity and asymmetry between the plasma streams: a weakly nonlinear symmetric system, prone to purely transverse merging modes; a strongly nonlinear symmetric system, dominated by coherent drift-kink modes whose transverse periodicity is equal to, or an integer fraction of the unperturbed filaments; a moderately nonlinear asymmetric system, subject to a mix of kink and bunching-type perturbations. The growth rates and profiles of the numerically computed eigenmodes agree with particle-in-cell simulation results. In addition, we derive an analytic criterion for the transition between dominant filament-merging and drift-kink instabilites in symmetric two-beam systems.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2018; v1 submitted 12 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
