-
Dynamical tides in binaries: Inconsistencies in the implementation of Zahn's prescription
Authors:
Luca Sciarini,
Sylvia Ekström,
Patrick Eggenberger,
Georges Meynet,
Tassos Fragos,
Han Feng Song
Abstract:
Binary evolution codes are essential tools to help in understanding the evolution of binary systems. They contain a great deal of physics, for example stellar evolution, stellar interactions, mass transfer, tides, orbital evolution. Since many of these processes are difficult to account for in detail, we often rely on prescriptions obtained in earlier studies. We highlight that the impact of the d…
▽ More
Binary evolution codes are essential tools to help in understanding the evolution of binary systems. They contain a great deal of physics, for example stellar evolution, stellar interactions, mass transfer, tides, orbital evolution. Since many of these processes are difficult to account for in detail, we often rely on prescriptions obtained in earlier studies. We highlight that the impact of the dynamical tides with radiative damping has been implemented inconsistently with respect to its original theoretical formulation in many studies. We derive a new analytical solution for the evolution toward synchronization in the case of circular orbits and propose turnkey equations for the case of eccentric orbits that can be used in population synthesis studies. We compare the strength of the tidal torque obtained with this new formula with respect to that obtained with the formula generally used in literature by studying how the evolution toward synchronization of main sequence stellar models is affected. We conclude that by using an incorrect formula for the tidal torque, as has been done in many binary codes, the strength of the dynamical tides with radiative damping is over- or underestimated depending on whether the star is close to or far from synchronization.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Merging binary black holes formed through double-core evolution
Authors:
Y. Qin,
R. -C. Hu,
G. Meynet,
Y. Z. Wang,
J. -P. Zhu,
H. F. Song,
X. W. Shu,
S. C. Wu
Abstract:
To date, various formation channels of merging events have been heavily explored with the detection of nearly 100 double black hole (BH) merger events reported by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) Collaboration. We here systematically investigate an alternative formation scenario, i.e., binary BHs (BBHs) formed through double helium stars (hereafter double-core evolution channel). In this scenario, the t…
▽ More
To date, various formation channels of merging events have been heavily explored with the detection of nearly 100 double black hole (BH) merger events reported by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) Collaboration. We here systematically investigate an alternative formation scenario, i.e., binary BHs (BBHs) formed through double helium stars (hereafter double-core evolution channel). In this scenario, the two helium stars (He-rich stars) could be the outcome of the classical isolated binary evolution scenario involving with and without common-envelope phase (i.e., CE channel and stable mass transfer channel), or alternatively of massive close binaries evolving chemically homogeneously (i.e., CHE channel). We perform detailed stellar structure and binary evolution calculations that take into account internal differential rotation and mass loss of He-rich stars, as well as tidal interactions in binaries. For double He-rich stars with equal masses in binaries, we find that tides start to be at work on the Zero Age Helium Main Sequence (ZAHeMS: the time when a He-rich star starts to burn helium in the core, which is analogous to ZAMS for core hydrogen burning) for initial orbital periods not longer than 1.0 day, depending on the initial metallicities. Besides the stellar mass loss rate and tidal interactions in binaries, we find that the role of the angular momentum transport efficiency in determining the resulting BH spins, becomes stronger when considering BH progenitors originated from a higher metal-metallicity environment. We highlight that double-core evolution scenario does not always produce fast-spinning BBHs and compare the properties of the BBHs reported from the LVK with our modeling.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
News from Gaia on sigma Ori E: a case study for the wind magnetic braking process
Authors:
H. F. Song,
G. Meynet,
A. Maeder,
N. Mowlavi,
S. R. Stroud,
Z. Keszthelyi,
S. Ekstrom,
P. Eggenberger,
C. Georgy,
G. A. Wade,
Y. Qin
Abstract:
Sigma Ori E, a massive helium B-type star, shows a high surface rotation and a strong surface magnetic field potentially challenging the process of wind magnetic braking. The Gaia satellite provides an accurate distance to that star and confirms its membership to the sigma Ori cluster. We account for these two key pieces of information to investigate whether single star models can reproduce the ob…
▽ More
Sigma Ori E, a massive helium B-type star, shows a high surface rotation and a strong surface magnetic field potentially challenging the process of wind magnetic braking. The Gaia satellite provides an accurate distance to that star and confirms its membership to the sigma Ori cluster. We account for these two key pieces of information to investigate whether single star models can reproduce the observed properties of sigma Ori E and provide new estimates for its metallicity, mass, and age. We compute rotating stellar models accounting for wind magnetic braking and magnetic quenching of the mass loss. We obtain that sigma Ori E is a very young star (age less than 1 Myr) with an initial mass around 9 Msol, a surface equatorial magnetic field around 7 kG and having a metallicity Z (mass fraction of heavy elements) around 0.020. No solution is obtained with the present models for a metallicity Z=0.014. The initial rotation of the models fitting sigma Ori E is not much constrained and can be anywhere in the range studied in the present work. Because of its very young age, models predict no observable changes of the surface abundances due to rotational mixing. The simultaneous high surface rotation and high surface magnetic field of sigma Ori E may simply be a consequence of its young age. This young age implies that the processes responsible for producing the chemical inhomogeneities that are observed at its surface should be rapid. Thus for explaining the properties of sigma Ori E, there is no necessity to invoke a merging event although such a scenario cannot be discarded. Other stars (HR 5907, HR 7355, HR 345439, HD 2347, CPD -50^{o}3509$) showing similar properties as sigma Ori E (fast rotation and strong surface magnetic field) may also be very young stars, although determination of the braking timescales is needed to confirm such a conclusion.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
The spin of the second-born black hole in coalescing binary black holes
Authors:
Y. Qin,
T. Fragos,
G. Meynet,
J. Andrews,
M. Sørensen,
H. F. Song
Abstract:
Various binary black hole formation channels have been proposed since the first gravitational event GW150914 was discovered by the Advanced Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (AdLIGO). For all evolutionary channels based on the evolution of isolated binaries, the immediate progenitor of the binary black hole is a close binary system composed of a black hole and a helium star. We p…
▽ More
Various binary black hole formation channels have been proposed since the first gravitational event GW150914 was discovered by the Advanced Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (AdLIGO). For all evolutionary channels based on the evolution of isolated binaries, the immediate progenitor of the binary black hole is a close binary system composed of a black hole and a helium star. We perform detailed binary evolution and systematically explore the parameter space of initial binary properties, including initial black hole and helium star masses, initial rotation of the helium star as well as metallicity. We argue that the spin of the first-born black hole at its birth is negligible ($\lesssim 0.1$), hence the second-born black hole's spin dominates the measured effective spin, $χ_{\rm eff}$, from gravitational wave events of double black hole mergers. We find that tides can be important only when orbital periods are shorter than 2 days. Upon core collapse, the helium star produces a black hole (the second-born black hole in the system) with a spin that can span the entire range from zero to maximally spinning. We show that the bimodal distribution of the spin of the second-born black hole obtained in recent papers is mainly due to oversimplifying assumptions. We find an anti-correlation between the merging timescale of the two black holes, T$_{\rm merger}$, and the effective spin $χ_{\rm eff}$. Finally, we provide new prescriptions for the tidal coefficient E$_2$ for both H-rich and the helium-rich stars. We predict that, with future improvements to AdLIGO's sensitivity, the sample of merging binary black hole systems will show an overdensity of sources with positive but small $χ_{\rm eff}$. originating from lower mass black hole mergers born at low redshift.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Close binary evolution. III. Impact of tides, wind magnetic braking, and internal angular momentum transport
Authors:
H. F. Song,
G. Meynet,
A. Maeder,
S. Ekstrom,
P. Eggenberger,
C. Georgy,
Y. Qin,
T. Fragos,
M. Soerensen,
F. Barblan,
G. A. Wade
Abstract:
Massive stars with solar metallicity lose important amounts of rotational angular momentum through their winds. When a magnetic field is present at the surface of a star, efficient angular momentum losses can still be achieved even when the mass-loss rate is very modest, at lower metallicities, or for lower-initial-mass stars. In a close binary system, the effect of wind magnetic braking also inte…
▽ More
Massive stars with solar metallicity lose important amounts of rotational angular momentum through their winds. When a magnetic field is present at the surface of a star, efficient angular momentum losses can still be achieved even when the mass-loss rate is very modest, at lower metallicities, or for lower-initial-mass stars. In a close binary system, the effect of wind magnetic braking also interacts with the influence of tides, resulting in a complex evolution of rotation. We study the interactions between the process of wind magnetic braking and tides in close binary systems. We discuss the evolution of a 10 M$_\odot$ star in a close binary system with a 7 M$_\odot$ companion using the Geneva stellar evolution code. The initial orbital period is 1.2 days. The 10 M$_\odot$ star has a surface magnetic field of 1 kG. Various initial rotations are considered. We use two different approaches for the internal angular momentum transport. In one of them, angular momentum is transported by shear and meridional currents. In the other, a strong internal magnetic field imposes nearly perfect solid-body rotation. The evolution of the primary is computed until the first mass-transfer episode occurs. The cases of different values for the magnetic fields and for various orbital periods and mass ratios are briefly discussed. We show that, independently of the initial rotation rate of the primary and the efficiency of the internal angular momentum transport, the surface rotation of the primary will converge, in a time that is short with respect to the main-sequence lifetime, towards a slowly evolving velocity that is different from the synchronization velocity. (abridged).
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Massive stars, successes and challenges
Authors:
Georges Meynet,
André Maeder,
Cyril Georgy,
Sylvia Ekström,
Patrick Eggenberger,
Fabio Barblan,
Han Feng Song
Abstract:
We give a brief overview of where we stand with respect to some old and new questions bearing on how massive stars evolve and end their lifetime. We focus on the following key points that are further discussed by other contributions during this conference: convection, mass losses, rotation, magnetic field and multiplicity. For purpose of clarity, each of these processes are discussed on its own bu…
▽ More
We give a brief overview of where we stand with respect to some old and new questions bearing on how massive stars evolve and end their lifetime. We focus on the following key points that are further discussed by other contributions during this conference: convection, mass losses, rotation, magnetic field and multiplicity. For purpose of clarity, each of these processes are discussed on its own but we have to keep in mind that they are all interacting between them offering a large variety of outputs, some of them still to be discovered.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Physics of massive stars relevant for the modeling of Wolf-Rayet populations
Authors:
G. Meynet,
C. Georgy,
A. Maeder,
S. Ekström,
J. H. Groh,
F. Barblan,
H. F. Song,
P. Eggenberger
Abstract:
Key physical ingredients governing the evolution of massive stars are mass losses, convection and mixing in radiative zones. These effects are important both in the frame of single and close binary evolution. The present paper addresses two points: 1) the differences between two families of rotating models, i.e. the family of models computed with and without an efficient transport of angular momen…
▽ More
Key physical ingredients governing the evolution of massive stars are mass losses, convection and mixing in radiative zones. These effects are important both in the frame of single and close binary evolution. The present paper addresses two points: 1) the differences between two families of rotating models, i.e. the family of models computed with and without an efficient transport of angular momentum in radiative zones; 2) The impact of the mass losses in single and in close binary models.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Massive star evolution in close binaries:conditions for homogeneous chemical evolution
Authors:
H. F. Song,
G. Meynet,
A. Maeder,
S. Ekstrom,
P. Eggenberger
Abstract:
We investigate the impact of tidal interactions, before any mass transfer, on various properties of the stellar models. We study the conditions for obtaining homogeneous evolution triggered by tidal interactions, and for avoiding any Roche lobe overflow during the Main-Sequence phase. We consider the case of rotating stars computed with a strong coupling mediated by an interior magnetic field. In…
▽ More
We investigate the impact of tidal interactions, before any mass transfer, on various properties of the stellar models. We study the conditions for obtaining homogeneous evolution triggered by tidal interactions, and for avoiding any Roche lobe overflow during the Main-Sequence phase. We consider the case of rotating stars computed with a strong coupling mediated by an interior magnetic field. In models without any tidal interaction (single stars and wide binaries), homogeneous evolution in solid body rotating models is obtained when two conditions are realized: the initial rotation must be high enough, the loss of angular momentum by stellar winds should be modest. This last point favors metal-poor fast rotating stars. In models with tidal interactions, homogeneous evolution is obtained when rotation imposed by synchronization is high enough (typically a time-averaged surface velocities during the Main-Sequence phase above 250 km s$^{-1}$), whatever the mass losses. In close binaries, mixing is stronger at higher than at lower metallicities. Homogeneous evolution is thus favored at higher metallicities. Roche lobe overflow avoidance is favored at lower metallicities due to the fact that stars with less metals remain more compact. We study also the impact of different processes for the angular momentum transport on the surface abundances and velocities in single and close binaries. In models where strong internal coupling is assumed, strong surface enrichments are always associated to high surface velocities in binary or single star models. In contrast, models computed with mild coupling may produce strong surface enrichments associated to low surface velocities. Close binary models may be of interest for explaining homogeneous massive stars, fast rotating Wolf-Rayet stars, and progenitors of long soft gamma ray bursts, even at high metallicities.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Close binary evolution I. The tidally induced shear mixing in rotating binaries
Authors:
H. F. Song,
A. Maeder,
G. Meynet,
R. Q. Huang,
S. Ekström,
A. Granada
Abstract:
We study how tides in a binary system induce some specific internal shear mixing, able to substantially modify the evolution of close binaries prior to mass transfer. We construct numerical models accounting for tidal interactions, meridional circulation, transport of angular momentum, shears and horizontal turbulence and consider a variety of orbital periods and initial rotation velocities. Depen…
▽ More
We study how tides in a binary system induce some specific internal shear mixing, able to substantially modify the evolution of close binaries prior to mass transfer. We construct numerical models accounting for tidal interactions, meridional circulation, transport of angular momentum, shears and horizontal turbulence and consider a variety of orbital periods and initial rotation velocities. Depending on orbital periods and rotation velocities, tidal effects may spin down (spin down Case) or spin up (spin up Case) the axial rotation. In both cases, tides may induce a large internal differential rotation. The resulting tidally induced shear mixing (TISM) is so efficient that the internal distributions of angular velocity and chemical elements are greatly influenced. The evolutionary tracks are modified, and in both cases of spin down and spin up, large amounts of nitrogen can be transported to the stellar surfaces before any binary mass transfer. Meridional circulation, when properly treated as an advection, always tends to counteract the tidal interaction, tending to spin up the surface when it is braked down and vice versa. As a consequence, the times needed for the axial angular velocity to become equal to the orbital angular velocity may be larger than given by typical synchronization timescales. Also, due to meridional circulation some differential rotation remains in tidally locked binary systems.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Structure and evolution of rotationally and tidally distorted stars
Authors:
H. F. Song,
Z. Zhong,
Y. Lu
Abstract:
This paper aims to study the configuration of two components caused by rotational and tidal distortions in the model of a binary system. The potentials of the two distorted components can be approximated to 2nd-degree harmonics. Furthermore, both the accretion luminosity ($σ_{i}$) and the irradiative luminosity are included in stellar structure equations. The equilibrium structure of rotationall…
▽ More
This paper aims to study the configuration of two components caused by rotational and tidal distortions in the model of a binary system. The potentials of the two distorted components can be approximated to 2nd-degree harmonics. Furthermore, both the accretion luminosity ($σ_{i}$) and the irradiative luminosity are included in stellar structure equations. The equilibrium structure of rotationally and tidally distorted star is exactly a triaxial ellipsoids. A formula describing the isobars is presented, and the rotational velocity and the gravitational acceleration at the primary surface simulated. The results show the distortion at the outer layers of the primary increases with temporal variation and system evolution. Besides, it was observed that the luminosity accretion is unstable, and the curve of the energy-generation rate fluctuates after the main sequence in rotation sequences. The luminosity in rotation sequences is slightly weaker than that in non-rotation sequences. As a result, the volume expands slowly. Polar ejection is intensified by the tidal effect. The ejection of an equatorial ring may be favoured by both the opacity effect and the $g_{e}(θ,\varphi)$-effect in the binary system.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
