-
Cosmic dipoles of active galactic nuclei at optical and radio wavelengths display much larger amplitudes than the cosmic microwave background dipole
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
Sky distributions of large samples of distant active galactic nuclei (AGNs) have shown dipoles significantly larger than the cosmic microwave background (CMB) dipole. However, a recent Bayesian analysis of the QUAIA sample, comprising 1.3 million quasars, has yielded a dipole that seems to be in tandem with the CMB dipole, in contravention of most previous studies of AGN dipoles. Since the questio…
▽ More
Sky distributions of large samples of distant active galactic nuclei (AGNs) have shown dipoles significantly larger than the cosmic microwave background (CMB) dipole. However, a recent Bayesian analysis of the QUAIA sample, comprising 1.3 million quasars, has yielded a dipole that seems to be in tandem with the CMB dipole, in contravention of most previous studies of AGN dipoles. Since the question has large cosmological implications, we investigate the QUAIA quasar sample afresh, by directly computing the dipole from asymmetries observed in the source number counts. We instead find a dipole 3-4 times as large as the CMB dipole though in the same direction. Further, it has been claimed elsewhere that the difference between the CMB dipole and the radio dipole estimated from the NRAO VLA Sky Survey (NVSS), the first large catalogue that showed an AGN dipole about four times larger than the CMB dipole, can be fully accounted for by incorporating the shot-noise and clustering contributions to the total NVSS dipole. A careful reinvestigation of the NVSS dipole, however, shows that the random phenomena like shot noise or clustering cannot account for the actually observed NVSS asymmetries, which show a systematic dipole pattern over the sky.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2024; v1 submitted 25 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Resolution of the incongruency of dipole asymmetries within various large radio surveys -- implications for the Cosmological Principle
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
We investigate dipole asymmetries in four large radio surveys, each spanning more than 80\% of the sky. Two of them, the Very Large Array Sky Survey (VLASS) and the Rapid ASKAP Continuum Survey (RACS), have recently yielded dipoles that appear incongruent with each other as well as seem inconsistent with previous radio survey dipoles and the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) dipole. Because these…
▽ More
We investigate dipole asymmetries in four large radio surveys, each spanning more than 80\% of the sky. Two of them, the Very Large Array Sky Survey (VLASS) and the Rapid ASKAP Continuum Survey (RACS), have recently yielded dipoles that appear incongruent with each other as well as seem inconsistent with previous radio survey dipoles and the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) dipole. Because these radio surveys have large overlaps in sky coverage, comprising hence large majority of common radio sources, one would not expect significant differences between their radio dipoles, irrespective of their underlying source of origin. We examine here in detail these radio dipoles, to ascertain the source of incongruency amongst them. We find the VLASS and RACS data to be containing some declination-dependent systematics, seemingly in the vicinity of the declination limit of each survey. We show that the effects of such systematics can be mitigated by restricting the declination limits of the respective survey during the dipole determination. A weighted mean of the sky coordinates of thus derived dipoles from the four radio surveys lies within $1.2σ$ of the CMB dipole direction. However, the amplitude appears significantly larger, $3.7\pm 0.6$ times or more than the CMB dipole. This puts in doubt not only the conventional wisdom that the genesis of all these dipoles, including that of the CMB dipole, is due to the Solar peculiar motion, it also raises uncomfortable questions about the Cosmological Principle (CP), the basis of the standard $Λ$CDM cosmological model.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2024; v1 submitted 20 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Discordance of dipole asymmetries seen in recent large radio surveys with the Cosmological Principle
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
In recent years, large radio surveys of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs), comprising millions of sources, have become available where one could investigate dipole asymmetries, assumedly arising due to a peculiar motion of the Solar system. Investigations of such dipoles have yielded in past much larger amplitudes than the cosmic microwave background (CMB) dipole, though their directions seem to lie c…
▽ More
In recent years, large radio surveys of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs), comprising millions of sources, have become available where one could investigate dipole asymmetries, assumedly arising due to a peculiar motion of the Solar system. Investigations of such dipoles have yielded in past much larger amplitudes than the cosmic microwave background (CMB) dipole, though their directions seem to lie close to the CMB dipole. Here we investigate dipole asymmetries in two recent large radio surveys, Very Large Array Sky Survey (VLASS) containing 1.9 million sources, covering the sky north of $-40^\circ$ declination, and the Rapid ASKAP Continuum Survey (RACS) containing 2.1 million sources, covering the sky south of $+30^\circ$ declination. We find dipoles determined from the VLASS and RACS surveys to be significantly larger than the CMB dipole. Dipole directions from the VLASS and RACS data differ significantly from each other. Nevertheless, along with a number of other previously determined dipoles, including the CMB, they all appear to lie in a narrow sky region, which argues for the various dipoles to be related somehow. However, significant differences in their derived peculiar velocities, including that of the CMB, cannot be explained by a peculiar motion of the Solar system, which should necessarily be a single value. Instead, their discordant peculiar velocities may be indicating that different cosmic reference frames are moving relative to each other or that the matter distribution on cosmic scales is not homogeneous and isotropic, either scenario being in contravention of what expected from the Cosmological Principle (CP).
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2023; v1 submitted 9 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Is the Observable Universe Consistent with the Cosmological Principle?
Authors:
Pavan Kumar Aluri,
Paolo Cea,
Pravabati Chingangbam,
Ming-Chung Chu,
Roger G. Clowes,
Damien Hutsemékers,
Joby P. Kochappan,
Alexia M. Lopez,
Lang Liu,
Niels C. M. Martens,
C. J. A. P. Martins,
Konstantinos Migkas,
Eoin Ó Colgáin,
Pratyush Pranav,
Lior Shamir,
Ashok K. Singal,
M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari,
Jenny Wagner,
Shao-Jiang Wang,
David L. Wiltshire,
Shek Yeung,
Lu Yin,
Wen Zhao
Abstract:
The Cosmological Principle (CP) -- the notion that the Universe is spatially isotropic and homogeneous on large scales -- underlies a century of progress in cosmology. It is conventionally formulated through the Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) cosmologies as the spacetime metric, and culminates in the successful and highly predictive $Λ$-Cold-Dark-Matter ($Λ$CDM) model. Yet, tensions ha…
▽ More
The Cosmological Principle (CP) -- the notion that the Universe is spatially isotropic and homogeneous on large scales -- underlies a century of progress in cosmology. It is conventionally formulated through the Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) cosmologies as the spacetime metric, and culminates in the successful and highly predictive $Λ$-Cold-Dark-Matter ($Λ$CDM) model. Yet, tensions have emerged within the $Λ$CDM model, most notably a statistically significant discrepancy in the value of the Hubble constant, $H_0$. Since the notion of cosmic expansion determined by a single parameter is intimately tied to the CP, implications of the $H_0$ tension may extend beyond $Λ$CDM to the CP itself. This review surveys current observational hints for deviations from the expectations of the CP, highlighting synergies and disagreements that warrant further study. Setting aside the debate about individual large structures, potential deviations from the CP include variations of cosmological parameters on the sky, discrepancies in the cosmic dipoles, and mysterious alignments in quasar polarizations and galaxy spins. While it is possible that a host of observational systematics are impacting results, it is equally plausible that precision cosmology may have outgrown the FLRW paradigm, an extremely pragmatic but non-fundamental symmetry assumption.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2023; v1 submitted 12 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Solar system peculiar motion from the Hubble diagram of quasars and testing the Cosmological Principle
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
We determine here peculiar motion of the Solar system, first time from the $m-z$ Hubble diagram of quasars. Observer's peculiar motion causes a systematic shift in the $m-z$ plane between sources lying along the velocity vector and those in the opposite direction, providing a measure of the peculiar velocity. Accordingly, from a sample of $\sim 1.2 \times 10^5$ mid-infrared quasars with measured s…
▽ More
We determine here peculiar motion of the Solar system, first time from the $m-z$ Hubble diagram of quasars. Observer's peculiar motion causes a systematic shift in the $m-z$ plane between sources lying along the velocity vector and those in the opposite direction, providing a measure of the peculiar velocity. Accordingly, from a sample of $\sim 1.2 \times 10^5$ mid-infrared quasars with measured spectroscopic redshifts, we arrive at a peculiar velocity $\sim 22$ times larger than that from the CMBR dipole, but direction matching within $\sim 2σ$. Previous findings from number count, sky brightness or redshift dipoles observed in samples of distant AGNs or SNe Ia too had yielded values two to ten times larger than the CMBR value, %but this by far is the largest value arrived at for the peculiar motion, though the direction in all cases agreed with the CMBR dipole. Since a genuine solar peculiar velocity cannot vary from one dataset to the other, an order of magnitude, statistically significant, discordant dipoles, might imply that we may instead have to look for some other cause for the genesis of these dipole, including that of the CMBR. At the same time, a common direction for all these dipoles, determined from completely independent surveys by different groups employing different techniques, might indicate that these dipoles are not resulting from some systematics in the observations or in the data analysis, but could instead suggest a preferred direction in the Universe due to an inherent anisotropy, which, in turn, would be against the Cosmological Principle (CP), the most basic tenet of the modern cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2022; v1 submitted 20 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Peculiar motion of Solar system from the Hubble diagram of supernovae Ia and its implications for cosmology
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
Peculiar motion of the solar system, determined from the dipole anisotropy in the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR), has given a velocity $370$ km s$^{-1}$ along RA$=168^{\circ}$, Dec$=-7^{\circ}$. Subsequent peculiar motion determinations from the number counts, sky brightness or redshift dipoles observed in large samples of distant radio galaxies and quasars yielded peculiar velocitie…
▽ More
Peculiar motion of the solar system, determined from the dipole anisotropy in the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR), has given a velocity $370$ km s$^{-1}$ along RA$=168^{\circ}$, Dec$=-7^{\circ}$. Subsequent peculiar motion determinations from the number counts, sky brightness or redshift dipoles observed in large samples of distant radio galaxies and quasars yielded peculiar velocities two to ten times larger than CMBR, though in all cases the directions matched with the CMBR dipole. Here we introduce a novel technique for determining the peculiar motion from the magnitude-redshift ($m_{\rm B}-z$) Hubble diagram of Type Ia Supernovae (SN Ia), one of the best standard candles available. We find a peculiar velocity $1.6\pm 0.5 \times 10^3$ km s$^{-1}$, larger than the CMBR value roughly by a factor of four, along RA$=173^{\circ}\pm12^{\circ}$, Dec$=10^{\circ}\pm9^{\circ}$, the direction being within $\stackrel{<}{_{\sim}}2σ$ of the CMBR dipole. Since a genuine solar motion would not depend upon the method or the dataset employed, large discrepancies seen among various dipole amplitudes could imply that these dipoles, including the CMBR one, might not pertain to observer's peculiar motion. However, a common direction for various dipoles might indicate a preferred direction in the universe, implying an intrinsic anisotropy, in violation of the cosmological principle, a cornerstone of the modern cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2022; v1 submitted 22 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Our Peculiar Motion Inferred from Number Counts of Mid Infra Red AGNs and the Discordance Seen with the Cosmological Principle
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
The dipole anisotropy in the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) has given a peculiar velocity vector 370 km s$^{-1}$ along $l=264^\circ,b=48^\circ$. However, some other dipoles, for instance, from the number counts, sky brightness or redshift distributions in large samples of distant Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs), have yielded values of the peculiar velocity many times larger than that f…
▽ More
The dipole anisotropy in the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) has given a peculiar velocity vector 370 km s$^{-1}$ along $l=264^\circ,b=48^\circ$. However, some other dipoles, for instance, from the number counts, sky brightness or redshift distributions in large samples of distant Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs), have yielded values of the peculiar velocity many times larger than that from the CMBR, though surprisingly, in all cases the directions agreed with the CMBR dipole. Here we determine our peculiar motion from a sample of ~0.28 million AGNs, selected from the Mid Infra Red Active Galactic Nuclei (MIRAGN) sample comprising more than a million sources. From this, we find a peculiar velocity, which is more than four times the CMBR value, although the direction seems to be within $\sim 2σ$ of the CMBR dipole. A genuine value of the solar peculiar velocity should be the same irrespective of the data or the technique employed to estimate it. Therefore, such discordant dipole amplitudes, might mean that the explanation for these dipoles, including that of the CMBR, might in fact be something else. But, the observed fact that the direction in all cases, is the same, though obtained from completely independent surveys using different instruments and techniques, by different sets of people employing different computing routines, might nonetheless indicate that these dipoles are not merely due to some systematics, otherwise why would they all be pointing along the same direction. It might instead suggest a preferred direction in the Universe, implying a genuine anisotropy, which would violate the Cosmological Principle, the core of the modern cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2021; v1 submitted 24 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Locating Planets in Sky Using Manual Calculations
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
In this article, we describe a very simple technique to locate naked-eye planets in the sky, to an accuracy of $\sim 1^{\circ}$. The procedure, comprising just three steps, involves very simple manual calculations for planetary orbits around the Sun; all one needs are the initial specifications of planetary positions for some standard epoch and the time periods of their revolutions. After applying…
▽ More
In this article, we describe a very simple technique to locate naked-eye planets in the sky, to an accuracy of $\sim 1^{\circ}$. The procedure, comprising just three steps, involves very simple manual calculations for planetary orbits around the Sun; all one needs are the initial specifications of planetary positions for some standard epoch and the time periods of their revolutions. After applying a small correction for the orbital ellipticity, appearance of a planet relative to Sun's position in sky, as seen by an observer from Earth, is found using a scale and a protractor (found inside a school geometry box).
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
GMRT observations of IC 711 -- The longest head-tail radio galaxy known
Authors:
Shweta Srivastava,
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
We present low-frequency, GMRT observations at 240, 610 and 1300 MHz of IC~711, a narrow angle tail (NAT) radio galaxy. The total angular extent of the radio emission, $\sim 22$ arcmin, corresponds to a projected linear size of $\sim 900$ kpc, making it the longest among the known head-tail radio galaxies. The objectives of the GMRT observations were to investigate the radio morphology, especially…
▽ More
We present low-frequency, GMRT observations at 240, 610 and 1300 MHz of IC~711, a narrow angle tail (NAT) radio galaxy. The total angular extent of the radio emission, $\sim 22$ arcmin, corresponds to a projected linear size of $\sim 900$ kpc, making it the longest among the known head-tail radio galaxies. The objectives of the GMRT observations were to investigate the radio morphology, especially of the long tail structure, at low frequencies. The radio structure, especially initial $\sim 10$ arcmin of tail being a long straight feature, does not seem to be consistent with a simple circular motion around the cluster centre, as previously suggested in the literature. Two sharp bends after the straight section of the tail cast doubt on the prevailing idea in the literature that the long narrow tails represent trails left behind by the fast moving parent optical galaxy with respect to the cluster medium, as the optical galaxy could not have undergone such sharp bends in its path, under any conceivable gravitational influence of some individual galaxy or of the overall cluster gravitational potential. In fact the tail does not seem to have been influenced by the gravitational field of any of the cluster-member galaxies. The radio spectrum of the head, coinciding with the optical galaxy, is flat ($α\stackrel{<}{_{\sim}}0.4$ for $S \propto ν^{-α}$), but steadily steepens along the radio tail, with the end part of the tail showing the steepest spectrum ($α\, {\sim}$ 4 -- 5) ever seen in any diffuse radio emission region.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2020; v1 submitted 25 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Relativistic Doppler beaming and misalignments in AGN jets
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
Radio maps of AGNs often show linear features, called jets, both on pc as well as kpc scales. These jets supposedly possess relativistic motion and are oriented close to the line of sight of the observer and accordingly the relativistic Doppler beaming makes them look much brighter than they really are in their respective rest-frames. The flux boosting due to the relativistic beaming is a very sen…
▽ More
Radio maps of AGNs often show linear features, called jets, both on pc as well as kpc scales. These jets supposedly possess relativistic motion and are oriented close to the line of sight of the observer and accordingly the relativistic Doppler beaming makes them look much brighter than they really are in their respective rest-frames. The flux boosting due to the relativistic beaming is a very sensitive factor of the jet orientation angle, as seen by the observer. Quite often large bends are seen in these jets, with misalignments being $90^\circ$ or more and might imply a change in the orientation angle that could cause a large change in the relativistic beaming factor. Such large bends should show high contrasts in the brightness of the jets, before and after the misalignments, if relativistic beaming does play an important role in these jets. It needs to be kept in mind that sometimes a small intrinsic change in the jet angle might appear as a much larger misalignment due to the geometrical projection effects, especially when seen close to the line of sight. Of course what really matters is the final orientation angle of the jet with respect to the observer's line of sight. Taking the geometrical projection effects properly into account, we calculate the consequences of the presumed relativistic beaming and demonstrate that there ought to be large brightness ratios in jets before and after the observed misalignments.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2016; v1 submitted 11 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Horizon, homogeneity and flatness problems -- do their resolutions really depend upon inflation?
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
We point out that the horizon problem encountered in standard text-books or review papers on cosmology is, in general, derived for world models based on Robertson-Walker line element where homogeneity and isotropy of the universe -- à la cosmological principle -- is assumed to begin with and is guaranteed for all epochs. Actually what all happens in that scenario is that in such a universe, whose…
▽ More
We point out that the horizon problem encountered in standard text-books or review papers on cosmology is, in general, derived for world models based on Robertson-Walker line element where homogeneity and isotropy of the universe -- à la cosmological principle -- is assumed to begin with and is guaranteed for all epochs. Actually what all happens in that scenario is that in such a universe, whose evolutionary behaviour is described by a single scale factor, which may be time dependent but is otherwise independent of spatial coordinates, the light signals in a finite time might not be covering all the available space. Further, the flatness problem, as it is posed, is not even falsifiable. The usual argument offered in the literature is that the present density of the universe is very close to the critical density value and that the universe must be flat since otherwise in past at $\sim10^{-35}$ second (near the epoch of inflation) there will be extremely low departures of density from the critical density value (of the order $\sim10^{-53}$), requiring a sort of fine tuning. We show that even if the present value of the density parameter were very different, still at $10^{-35}$ second it would differ from unity by the same fraction. Thus a use of fine tuning argument to promote $k = 0$ model amounts to {\em a priori} rejection of all models with $k \ne 0$. Without casting any aspersions on the inflationary theory, which after all is the most promising paradigm to explain the pattern of anisotropies observed in the cosmic microwave background, we argue that one cannot use homogeneity and flatness in support of inflation.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2022; v1 submitted 4 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
The pitch angle paradox and radiative life times in a synchrotron source
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
In synchrotron radiation there is a paradox whether or not the pitch angle of a radiating charge varies. The conventional wisdom is that the pitch angle does not change during the radiation process. The argument is based on Larmor's radiation formula, where in a synchrotron case the radiation power is along the instantaneous direction of motion of the charge. Then the momentum loss will also be pa…
▽ More
In synchrotron radiation there is a paradox whether or not the pitch angle of a radiating charge varies. The conventional wisdom is that the pitch angle does not change during the radiation process. The argument is based on Larmor's radiation formula, where in a synchrotron case the radiation power is along the instantaneous direction of motion of the charge. Then the momentum loss will also be parallel to that direction and therefore the pitch angle of the charge would remain unaffected. The accordingly derived formulas for energy losses of synchrotron electrons in radio galaxies are the standard text-book material for the last 50 years. However, if we use the momentum transformation laws from special relativity, then we find that the pitch angle of a radiating charge varies. While the velocity component parallel to the magnetic field remains unaffected, the perpendicular component does reduce in magnitude due to radiative losses, implying a change in the pitch angle. This apparent paradox is resolved when effects on the charge motion are calculated not from Larmor's formula but from Lorentz's radiation reaction formula. We derive the exact formulation by taking into account the change of the pitch angle due to radiative losses. From this we first time derive the characteristic decay time of synchrotron electrons over which they turn from highly relativistic into mildly relativistic ones.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Radiation reaction and the pitch angle changes for a charge undergoing synchrotron losses
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
In the derivation of synchrotron radiation formulas it has been assumed that the pitch angle of a charge remains constant during the radiation process. However from the radiation reaction formula, while the component of the velocity vector perpendicular to the magnetic field reduces in magnitude due to radiative losses, the parallel component does not undergo any change during radiation. Therefore…
▽ More
In the derivation of synchrotron radiation formulas it has been assumed that the pitch angle of a charge remains constant during the radiation process. However from the radiation reaction formula, while the component of the velocity vector perpendicular to the magnetic field reduces in magnitude due to radiative losses, the parallel component does not undergo any change during radiation. Therefore there is a change in the ratio of the two components, implying a change in the pitch angle. We derive the exact formula for the change in energy of radiating electrons by taking into account the change of the pitch angle due to radiative losses. From this we derive the characteristic decay time of synchrotron electrons over which they turn from highly relativistic into mildly relativistic ones.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2016; v1 submitted 30 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Comment on "Cosmic radio dipole from NVSS and WENSS"
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
We show that a recent purported correction to the effects of Doppler boosting of flux density in an erstwhile published formula for calculating the observer's motion from the cosmic radio dipole in sky brightness is erroneous. The thereby computed downward correction in the estimated magnitude for the observer's motion needs to be scrapped and the results derived therefore need to be reverted back…
▽ More
We show that a recent purported correction to the effects of Doppler boosting of flux density in an erstwhile published formula for calculating the observer's motion from the cosmic radio dipole in sky brightness is erroneous. The thereby computed downward correction in the estimated magnitude for the observer's motion needs to be scrapped and the results derived therefore need to be reverted back to their erstwhile values.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Peculiar motion of the solar system derived from a dipole anisotropy in the redshift distribution of distant quasars
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
An observer stationary with respect to comoving coordinates of the expanding universe should find the redshift distribution to be isotropic. However, a peculiar motion of the observer would introduce a dipole anisotropy in the observed redshift distribution. Conversely, a dipole anisotropy in observed redshift distribution could be exploited to infer our peculiar motion, or rather of our solar sys…
▽ More
An observer stationary with respect to comoving coordinates of the expanding universe should find the redshift distribution to be isotropic. However, a peculiar motion of the observer would introduce a dipole anisotropy in the observed redshift distribution. Conversely, a dipole anisotropy in observed redshift distribution could be exploited to infer our peculiar motion, or rather of our solar system. We determine here our peculiar velocity by studying the dipole anisotropy in the redshift distribution of a large sample of quasars. The magnitude of the peculiar velocity thus determined turns out to be $2350\pm280$ km s$^{-1}$, not only much larger than 370 km s$^{-1}$ determined from the dipole anisotropy in the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR), but also nearly in an opposite direction. Such large values for peculiar velocity have been found in a couple of radio surveys too, but with a direction along the CMBR dipole. Large genuine differences in the inferred motion, whether in magnitude or direction, are rather disconcerting since a solar peculiar velocity should not depend upon the method of its determination. Such discordant dipoles imply perhaps an anisotropic universe, violating the cosmological principle, a cornerstone of the modern cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2019; v1 submitted 19 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Fanaroff-Riley dichotomy of radio galaxies and the Malmquist bias
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal,
Kamlesh Rajpurohit
Abstract:
We examine the possibility that a claimed dependence of the FR 1/2 break value in radio luminosity on the absolute magnitude of the optical host galaxy could be due to the Malmquist bias, where a redshift-luminosity correlation appears in a flux-limited sample because of an observational selection effect. In such a sample, the redshift dependence of a phenomenon could appear as a luminosity-depend…
▽ More
We examine the possibility that a claimed dependence of the FR 1/2 break value in radio luminosity on the absolute magnitude of the optical host galaxy could be due to the Malmquist bias, where a redshift-luminosity correlation appears in a flux-limited sample because of an observational selection effect. In such a sample, the redshift dependence of a phenomenon could appear as a luminosity-dependent effect and may not be really representing an intrinsic property of the radio sample. We test this on the radio complete MRC (Molonglo Reference Catalog) sample, where Spearman rank correlation and Kendall rank correlation tests show that the correlations are indeed stronger between the redshift and the optical luminosity than that between the radio luminosity and the optical luminosity, suggesting that the latter correlation perhaps arises because of the Malmquist Bias. We further show that similar effects of the Malmquist bias could also be present elsewhere in other correlations claimed in the literature between the radio luminosity and other observed properties of FR1 and FR2 sources.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Life on a tidally-locked planet
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
A tidally-locked planet in its orbit around a star keeps the same face towards the star. This happens when the rotation period of the planet around its own axis becomes equal to its revolution period around the star. Many questions then arise. What gives rise to a tidal locking? Are there any tidally-locked planets somewhere? What will be the atmospheric system of a tidally-locked planet? Could li…
▽ More
A tidally-locked planet in its orbit around a star keeps the same face towards the star. This happens when the rotation period of the planet around its own axis becomes equal to its revolution period around the star. Many questions then arise. What gives rise to a tidal locking? Are there any tidally-locked planets somewhere? What will be the atmospheric system of a tidally-locked planet? Could life be sustained on a tidally-locked planet? What will be a sort of DAY in the life of a denizen of a tidally-locked planet? We dwell on these questions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Incongruity of the unified scheme with a 3CRR-like equatorial strong-source sample
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal,
Raj Laxmi Singh
Abstract:
We examine the consistency of the unified scheme of the powerful extragalactic radio sources with the 408 MHz BRL sample from the equatorial sky region, selected at the same flux-density level as the 3CRR sample. We find that, unlike in the 3CRR sample, a foreshortening in the observed sizes of quasars, expected from the orientation-based unified scheme model, is not seen in the BRL sample, at lea…
▽ More
We examine the consistency of the unified scheme of the powerful extragalactic radio sources with the 408 MHz BRL sample from the equatorial sky region, selected at the same flux-density level as the 3CRR sample. We find that, unlike in the 3CRR sample, a foreshortening in the observed sizes of quasars, expected from the orientation-based unified scheme model, is not seen in the BRL sample, at least in different redshift bins up to z~1. Even the quasar fraction in individual redshift bins up to z~1 does not match with that expected from the unified scheme, where radio galaxies and quasars are supposed to belong to a common parent population at all redshifts. This not only casts strong doubts on the unified scheme, but also throws up an intriguing result that in a sample selected from the equatorial sky region, using almost the same criteria as in the 3CRR sample from the northern hemisphere, the relative distribution of radio galaxies and quasars differs qualitatively from the 3CRR sample.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2013; v1 submitted 18 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Discordance of the unified scheme with observed properties of quasars and high-excitation galaxies in the 3CRR sample
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
We examine the consistency of the unified scheme of FR II-type radio galaxies and quasars with their observed number and size distributions in the 3CRR sample. We separate the low-excitation galaxies from the high-excitation ones, as the former might not harbor a quasar within and thus may not be partaking in the unified scheme models. In the updated 3CRR sample, at low redshifts (z<0.5), the rela…
▽ More
We examine the consistency of the unified scheme of FR II-type radio galaxies and quasars with their observed number and size distributions in the 3CRR sample. We separate the low-excitation galaxies from the high-excitation ones, as the former might not harbor a quasar within and thus may not be partaking in the unified scheme models. In the updated 3CRR sample, at low redshifts (z<0.5), the relative number and luminosity distributions of high-excitation galaxies and quasars do roughly match the expectations from the orientation-based unified scheme model. However, a foreshortening in the observed sizes of quasars, a must in the orientation-based model, is not seen with respect to radio galaxies even when the low-excitation galaxies are excluded. This dashes the hope that the unified scheme might still work if one includes only the high-excitation galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2014; v1 submitted 9 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
A large anisotropy in the sky distribution of 3CRR quasars and other radio galaxies
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
We report the presence of large anisotropies in the sky distributions of powerful extended quasars as well as some other sub-classes of radio galaxies in the 3CRR survey, the most reliable and most intensively studied complete sample of strong steep-spectrum radio sources. The anisotropies lie about a plane passing through the equinoxes and the north celestial pole. Out of a total of 48 quasars in…
▽ More
We report the presence of large anisotropies in the sky distributions of powerful extended quasars as well as some other sub-classes of radio galaxies in the 3CRR survey, the most reliable and most intensively studied complete sample of strong steep-spectrum radio sources. The anisotropies lie about a plane passing through the equinoxes and the north celestial pole. Out of a total of 48 quasars in the sample, 33 of them lie in one half of the observed sky and the remaining 15 in the other half. The probability that in a random distribution of 3CRR quasars in the sky, statistical fluctuations could give rise to an asymmetry in observed numbers up to this level is only $\sim 1\%$. Also only about 1/4th of Fanaroff-Riley 1 (FR1) type of radio galaxies lie in the first half of the observed sky and the remainder in the second half. If we include all the observed asymmetries in the sky distributions of quasars and radio galaxies in the 3CRR sample, the probability of their occurrence by a chance combination reduces to $\sim 2 \times 10^{-5}$. Two pertinent but disturbing questions that could be raised here are -- firstly why should there be such large anisotropies present in the sky distribution of some of the strongest and most distant discrete sources, implying inhomogeneities in the universe at very large scales (covering a fraction of the universe)? Secondly why should such anisotropies lie about a great circle decided purely by the orientation of earth's rotation axis and/or the axis of its revolution around the sun? Are these alignments a mere coincidence or do they imply that these axes have a preferential placement in the larger scheme of things, implying an apparent breakdown of the Copernican principle or its more generalization, cosmological principle, upon which the standard cosmological model is based upon?
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2014; v1 submitted 17 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Unification scheme of radio galaxies and quasars falsified by their observed size distributions
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal,
Raj Laxmi Singh
Abstract:
In the currently popular orientation-based unified scheme, a radio galaxy appears as a quasar when its principal radio-axis happens to be oriented within a certain cone opening angle around the observer's line of sight. Due to geometrical projection, the observed sizes of quasars should therefore appear smaller than those of radio galaxies. We show that this simple, unambiguous prediction of the u…
▽ More
In the currently popular orientation-based unified scheme, a radio galaxy appears as a quasar when its principal radio-axis happens to be oriented within a certain cone opening angle around the observer's line of sight. Due to geometrical projection, the observed sizes of quasars should therefore appear smaller than those of radio galaxies. We show that this simple, unambiguous prediction of the unified scheme is not borne out by the actually observed angular sizes of radio galaxies and quasars. Except in the original 3CR sample, based on which the unified scheme was proposed, in other much larger samples no statistically significant difference is apparent in the size distributions of radio galaxies and quasars. The population of low-excitation radio galaxies with apparently no hidden quasars inside, which might explain the observed excess number of radio galaxies at low redshifts, cannot still account for the absence of any foreshortening of the sizes of quasars at large redshifts. On the other hand from infrared and X-ray studies there is evidence of hidden quasar within a dusty torus in many RGs, at $z>0.5$. It seems difficult how to reconcile this with the absence of foreshortening of quasar sizes at even these redshifts, and perhaps one has to allow that the major radio axis may not have anything to do with the optical axis of the torus. Otherwise to resolve the dichotomy of radio galaxies and quasars, a scheme quite different from the present might be required.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
Dependence of Fanaroff--Riley break of radio galaxies on luminosity and redshift
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal,
Kamlesh Rajpurohit
Abstract:
We investigate the dependence of the Fanaroff-Riley (FR) 1/2 dichotomy of radio galaxies on their luminosities and redshifts. Because of a very strong redshift-luminosity correlation (Malmquist bias) in a flux-limited sample, any redshift-dependent effect could appear as a luminosity related effect and vice versa. A question could then arise - do all the morphological differences seen in the two c…
▽ More
We investigate the dependence of the Fanaroff-Riley (FR) 1/2 dichotomy of radio galaxies on their luminosities and redshifts. Because of a very strong redshift-luminosity correlation (Malmquist bias) in a flux-limited sample, any redshift-dependent effect could appear as a luminosity related effect and vice versa. A question could then arise - do all the morphological differences seen in the two classes (FR 1 and 2 types) of sources, usually attributed to the differences in their luminosities, could as well be primarily a redshift-dependent effect? A sharp break in luminosity, seen among the two classes, could after all reflect a sharp redshift-dependence due to a rather critical ambient density value at some cosmic epoch. A doubt on these lines does not seem to have been raised in past and things have never been examined with this particular aspect in mind. We want to ascertain the customary prevalent view in the literature that the systematic differences in the two broad morphology types of FR 1 and 2 radio galaxies are indeed due to the differences in their luminosities, and not due to a change in redshift. Here we investigate the dependence of FR 1/2 dichotomy of radio galaxies on luminosity and redshift by using the 3CR sample, where the FR 1/2 dichotomy was first seen, supplemented by data from an additional sample (MRC), that goes about a factor of 5 or more deeper in flux-density than the original 3CR sample. This lets us compare sources with similar luminosities but at different redshifts as well as examine sources at similar redshifts but with different luminosities, thereby allowing us a successful separation of the otherwise two intricately entangled effects. We find that the morphology type is not directly related to redshift and the break between the two types of morphologies seems to depend only upon the radio luminosity.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2014; v1 submitted 4 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Giant pulse emission from PSR B0950+08
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal,
Hari Om Vats
Abstract:
We present here the detection of giant-pulse emission from PSR B0950+08, a normal-period pulsar. The observations, made at 103 MHz and lasting for about ten months, have shown on a number of days the frequency of occurrence of giant pulses to be the highest among the known pulsars. The flux--density level of successive giant pulses fluctuates rapidly and their occurrence rates within a day's obser…
▽ More
We present here the detection of giant-pulse emission from PSR B0950+08, a normal-period pulsar. The observations, made at 103 MHz and lasting for about ten months, have shown on a number of days the frequency of occurrence of giant pulses to be the highest among the known pulsars. The flux--density level of successive giant pulses fluctuates rapidly and their occurrence rates within a day's observations as well as between neighboring days show large variations. While on some days PSR B0950+08 shows a large number of giant pulses, there are other days when it shows only "quasi-nulls" with no detectable emission in the power spectrum or in the folded pulse data. The cumulative intensity distribution of these giant pulses appears to follow a power law, with index -2.2. After eliminating instrumental, ionospheric, interplanetary and interstellar diffractive and refractive scintillation effects as the cause, it appears that these intensity variations are intrinsic to the pulsar. We suggest that the giant pulse emission and nulling may be opposite manifestations of the same physical process, in the former case an enhanced number of charges partaking in the coherent radiation process giving rise to an extremely high intensity while in the latter case the coherence could be minimal.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Gyro-orbit size, brightness temperature limit and implausibility of coherent emission by bunching in synchrotron radio sources
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
We show that an upper limit on the maximum brightness temperature for a self-absorbed incoherent synchrotron radio source is obtained from the size of its gyro orbits, which in turn must lie well within the confines of the total source extent. These temperature limits are obtained without recourse to inverse Compton effects or the condition of equipartition of energy between magnetic fields and re…
▽ More
We show that an upper limit on the maximum brightness temperature for a self-absorbed incoherent synchrotron radio source is obtained from the size of its gyro orbits, which in turn must lie well within the confines of the total source extent. These temperature limits are obtained without recourse to inverse Compton effects or the condition of equipartition of energy between magnetic fields and relativistic particles. For radio variables, the intra-day variability (IDV) implies brightness temperatures $\sim 10^{19}$ K in the co-moving rest frame of the source. This, if interpreted purely due to an incoherent synchrotron emission, would imply gyro radii $>10^{28}$ cm, the size of the universe, while from the causality arguments the inferred maximum size of the source in such a case is $\stackrel{<}{_{\sim}} 10^{15}$ cm. Such high brightness temperatures are sometimes modeled in the literature as some coherent emission process where bunches of non-thermal particles are somehow formed that radiate in phase. We show that, unlike in case of curvature radiation models proposed in pulsars, in the synchrotron radiation mechanism the oppositely charged particles would contribute together to the coherent phenomenon without the need to form separate bunches of the opposite charges. At the same time we show that bunches would disperse over dimensions larger than a wavelength in time shorter than the gyro orbital period ($\stackrel{<}{_{\sim}}0.1$ sec). Therefore a coherent emission by bunches cannot be a plausible explanation of the high brightness temperatures inferred in extragalactic radio sources showing variability over a few hours or longer.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
Large peculiar motion of the solar system from the dipole anisotropy in sky brightness due to distant radio sources
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
According to the cosmological principle, the Universe should appear isotropic, without any preferred directions, to an observer whom we may consider to be fixed in the co-moving co-ordinate system of the expanding Universe. Such an observer is stationary with respect to the average distribution of the matter in the Universe and the sky brightness at any frequency should appear uniform in all direc…
▽ More
According to the cosmological principle, the Universe should appear isotropic, without any preferred directions, to an observer whom we may consider to be fixed in the co-moving co-ordinate system of the expanding Universe. Such an observer is stationary with respect to the average distribution of the matter in the Universe and the sky brightness at any frequency should appear uniform in all directions to such an observer. However a peculiar motion of such an observer, due to a combined effect of Doppler boosting and aberration, will introduce a dipole anisotropy in the observed sky brightness; in reverse an observed dipole anisotropy in the sky brightness could be used to infer the peculiar velocity of the observer with respect to the average Universe. We determine the peculiar velocity of the solar system relative to the frame of distant radio sources, by studying the anisotropy in the sky brightness from discrete radio sources, i.e., an integrated emission from discrete sources per unit solid angle. Our results give a direction of the velocity vector in agreement with the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) value, but the magnitude ($\sim 1600\pm 400$ km/s) is $\sim 4$ times the CMBR value ($369\pm 1$ km/s) at a statistically significant ($\sim 3σ$) level. A genuine difference between the two dipoles would imply anisotropic Universe, with the anisotropy changing with the epoch. This would violate the cosmological principle where the isotropy of the Universe is assumed for all epochs, and on which the whole modern cosmology is based upon.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
-
An ab initio derivation of the electromagnetic fields of a point charge in arbitrary motion
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
Electromagnetic fields of an accelerated charge are derived from the first principles using Coulomb's law and the relativistic transformations. The electric and magnetic fields are derived first for an instantaneous rest frame of the accelerated charge, without making explicit use of Gauss's law, an approach different from that available in the literature. Thereafter we calculate the electromagnet…
▽ More
Electromagnetic fields of an accelerated charge are derived from the first principles using Coulomb's law and the relativistic transformations. The electric and magnetic fields are derived first for an instantaneous rest frame of the accelerated charge, without making explicit use of Gauss's law, an approach different from that available in the literature. Thereafter we calculate the electromagnetic fields for an accelerated charge having a non-relativistic motion. The expressions for these fields, supposedly accurate only to a first order in velocity $β$, surprisingly yield all terms exactly for the acceleration fields, only missing a factor $1-β^2$ in the velocity fields. The derivation explicitly shows the genesis of various terms in the field expressions, when expressed with respect to the time retarded position of the charge. A straightforward transformation from the instantaneous rest frame, using relativistic Doppler factors, yields expressions of the electromagnetic fields for the charge moving with an arbitrary velocity. The field expressions are derived without using Liénard-Wiechert potentials, thereby avoiding evaluation of any spatial or temporal derivatives of these potentials at the retarded time.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2011; v1 submitted 24 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.
-
Cosmological Parallax--Distance Formula
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
The standard cosmological parallax--distance formula, as found in the literature, including text-books and reference books on cosmology, requires a correction. This correction stems from the fact that in the standard text-book derivation it has been ignored that any chosen baseline in a gravitationally bound system does not partake in the cosmological expansion. Though the correction is available…
▽ More
The standard cosmological parallax--distance formula, as found in the literature, including text-books and reference books on cosmology, requires a correction. This correction stems from the fact that in the standard text-book derivation it has been ignored that any chosen baseline in a gravitationally bound system does not partake in the cosmological expansion. Though the correction is available in the literature for some time, the text-books still continue to use the older, incorrect formula, and its full implications are not yet fully realized. Apart from providing an alternate correct, closed-form expression that is more suitable and convenient for computations for certain limiting cases of FRW ($Λ=0$) world models, we also demonstrate how one can compute parallax distance for the currently favored flat-space accelerating-universe ($Λ>0, k=0$) cosmologies. Further, we show that the correction in parallax distance at large redshifts could amount to a factor of three or even more. Moreover, even in an infinite universe the parallax distance does not increase indefinitely with redshift and that even the farthest possible observable point may have a finite parallax angle, a factor that needs to be carefully taken into account when using distant objects as the background field against which the parallax of a foreground object is to be measured. Some other complications that could arise in parallax measurements of a distant source, like that due to the deflection of incoming light by the gravitation field of the Sun and other planetary bodies in the solar system, are pointed out.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2015; v1 submitted 29 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
Determining planetary positions in the sky for $\pm 50$ years to an accuracy of $\stackrel{<}{_{\sim}} 1^{\circ}$ with a calculator}
Authors:
Tanmay Singal,
Ashok k. Singal
Abstract:
In this paper, we describe a very simple method to calculate the positions of the planets in the sky. The technique used enables us to calculate planetary positions to an accuracy of $\stackrel{<}{_{\sim}} 1^{\circ}$ for $\pm 50$ years from the starting epoch. Moreover, this involves very simple calculations and can be done using a calculator. All we need are the initial specifications of planetar…
▽ More
In this paper, we describe a very simple method to calculate the positions of the planets in the sky. The technique used enables us to calculate planetary positions to an accuracy of $\stackrel{<}{_{\sim}} 1^{\circ}$ for $\pm 50$ years from the starting epoch. Moreover, this involves very simple calculations and can be done using a calculator. All we need are the initial specifications of planetary orbits for some standard epoch and the time periods of their revolutions.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2020; v1 submitted 15 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
Maximum Brightness Temperature of an Incoherent Synchrotron Source : Inverse Compton Limit - a Misnomer
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
We show that an upper limit of ~ 10^{12} K on the peak brightness temperature for an incoherent synchrotron radio source, commonly referred to in the literature as an inverse Compton limit, may not really be due to inverse Compton effects. We show that a somewhat tighter limit T_{eq} ~ 10^{11} is actually obtained for the condition of equipartition of energy between radiating particles and magne…
▽ More
We show that an upper limit of ~ 10^{12} K on the peak brightness temperature for an incoherent synchrotron radio source, commonly referred to in the literature as an inverse Compton limit, may not really be due to inverse Compton effects. We show that a somewhat tighter limit T_{eq} ~ 10^{11} is actually obtained for the condition of equipartition of energy between radiating particles and magnetic fields which happens to be a configuration of minimum energy for a self-absorbed synchrotron radio source. An order of magnitude change in brightness temperature from T_{eq} in either direction would require departures from equipartition of about eight orders of magnitude, implying a change in total energy of the system up to ~ 10^{4} times the equipartition value. Constraints of such extreme energy variations imply that brightness temperatures may not depart much from T_{eq}. This is supported by the fact that at the spectral turnover, brightness temperatures much lower than ~ 10^{11} K are also not seen in VLBI observations. Higher brightness temperatures in particular, would require in the source not only many orders of magnitude higher additional energy for the relativistic particles but also many order of magnitude weaker magnetic fields. Diamagnetic effects do not allow such extreme conditions, keeping the brightness temperatures close to the equipartition value, which is well below the limit where inverse Compton effects become important.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Maximum brightness temperature for an incoherent synchrotron radio source
Authors:
Ashok K. Singal
Abstract:
We discuss here a limit on the maximum brightness temperature achievable for an incoherent synchrotron radio source. This limit, commonly referred to in the literature as an inverse Compton limit, prescribes that the brightness temperature for an incoherent synchrotron radio source may not exceed ~10^{12} K, a fact known from observations. However one gets a somewhat tighter limit on the brightn…
▽ More
We discuss here a limit on the maximum brightness temperature achievable for an incoherent synchrotron radio source. This limit, commonly referred to in the literature as an inverse Compton limit, prescribes that the brightness temperature for an incoherent synchrotron radio source may not exceed ~10^{12} K, a fact known from observations. However one gets a somewhat tighter limit on the brightness temperatures, T_{b}~10^{11.5} K, independent of the inverse Compton effects, if one employs the condition of equipartition of energy in magnetic fields and relativistic particles in a synchrotron radio source. Pros and cons of the two brightness temperature limits are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
J1432+158: the most distant giant quasar
Authors:
A. K. Singal,
C. Konar,
D. J. Saikia
Abstract:
We present low-frequency, GMRT (Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope) observations at 333 and 617 MHz of the most-distant giant quasar, J1432+158, which is at a redshift of 1.005. The radio source has a total angular extent of 168 arcsec, corresponding to a projected linear size of 1.35 Mpc. This makes it presently the largest single object observed beyond a redshift of one. The objectives of the GMR…
▽ More
We present low-frequency, GMRT (Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope) observations at 333 and 617 MHz of the most-distant giant quasar, J1432+158, which is at a redshift of 1.005. The radio source has a total angular extent of 168 arcsec, corresponding to a projected linear size of 1.35 Mpc. This makes it presently the largest single object observed beyond a redshift of one. The objectives of the GMRT observations were to investigate the possibility of detecting a bridge of emission at low frequencies, which may be suppressed due to inverse-Compton losses against the cosmic microwave background radiation. We detect a jet-like structure connecting the core to the western hotspot, while the eastern hotspot is found to be largely tail-less with no significant bridge emission. The estimated life-time for the radiating electrons in the tail of the western lobe appears smaller than the travel time of the radiating particles from the hotspot, suggesting either in-situ acceleration or dissipation of energy by the jet at this location. The pressure of the intergalactic medium at $z\sim1$ estimated from the minimum energy density calculations appears to be marginally lower than the value extrapolated from nearby giant radio galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2003;
originally announced December 2003.
