-
Stratorotational instability in MHD Taylor-Couette flows
Authors:
G. Ruediger,
D. A. Shalybkov
Abstract:
The stability of dissipative Taylor-Couette flows with an axial stable density stratification and a prescribed azimuthal magnetic field is considered. Global nonaxisymmetric solutions of the linearized MHD equations with toroidal magnetic field, axial density stratification and differential rotation are found for both insulating and conducting cylinder walls. Flat rotation laws such as the quasi…
▽ More
The stability of dissipative Taylor-Couette flows with an axial stable density stratification and a prescribed azimuthal magnetic field is considered. Global nonaxisymmetric solutions of the linearized MHD equations with toroidal magnetic field, axial density stratification and differential rotation are found for both insulating and conducting cylinder walls. Flat rotation laws such as the quasi-Kepler law are unstable against the nonaxisymmetric stratorotational instability (SRI). The influence of a current-free toroidal magnetic field depends on the magnetic Prandtl number Pm: SRI is supported by Pm > 1 and it is suppressed by Pm \lsim 1. For too flat rotation laws a smooth transition exists to the instability which the toroidal magnetic field produces in combination with the differential rotation. This nonaxisymmetric azimuthal magnetorotational instability (AMRI) has been computed under the presence of an axial density gradient. If the magnetic field between the cylinders is not current-free then also the Tayler instability occurs and the transition from the hydrodynamic SRI to the magnetic Tayler instability proves to be rather complex. Most spectacular is the `ballooning' of the stability domain by the density stratification: already a rather small rotation stabilizes magnetic fields against the Tayler instability. An azimuthal component of the resulting electromotive force only exists for density-stratified flows. The related alpha-effect for magnetic SRI of Kepler rotation appears to be positive for negative dρ/dz <0.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
The Tayler instability and the Hall effect in protoneutron stars
Authors:
Guenther Ruediger,
Manfred Schultz,
Michael Mond,
Dmitry A. Shalybkov
Abstract:
Collapse calculations indicate that the hot newly born protoneutron stars (PNS) rotate differentially so that strong toroidal magnetic field components should exist in the outer crust where also the Hall effect appears to be important when the Hall parameter \hatβ=ω_B τis of order unity. The amplitudes of the induced toroidal magnetic fields are limited from above by the Tayler instability. An i…
▽ More
Collapse calculations indicate that the hot newly born protoneutron stars (PNS) rotate differentially so that strong toroidal magnetic field components should exist in the outer crust where also the Hall effect appears to be important when the Hall parameter \hatβ=ω_B τis of order unity. The amplitudes of the induced toroidal magnetic fields are limited from above by the Tayler instability. An important characteristic of the Hall effect is its distinct dependence on the {\em sign} of the magnetic field. We find for fast rotation that positive (negative) Hall parameters essentially reduce (increase) the stability domain. It is thus concluded that the toroidal field belts in PNS induced by their differential rotation should have different amplitudes in both hemispheres which later are frozen in. Due to the effect of magnetic suppression of the heat conductivity also the brightness of the two hemispheres should be different. As a possible example for our scenario the isolated neutron star RBS 1223 is considered which has been found to exhibit different X-ray brightness at both hemispheres.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2008; v1 submitted 10 March, 2008;
originally announced March 2008.
-
Theory of current instability experiments in magnetic Taylor-Couette flows
Authors:
G. Ruediger,
M. Schultz,
D. Shalybkov,
R. Hollerbach
Abstract:
We consider the linear stability of dissipative MHD Taylor-Couette flow with imposed toroidal magnetic fields. The inner and outer cylinders can be either insulating or conducting; the inner one rotates, the outer one is stationary. The magnetic Prandtl number can be as small as 10-5, approaching realistic liquid-metal values. The magnetic field destabilizes the flow, except for radial profiles…
▽ More
We consider the linear stability of dissipative MHD Taylor-Couette flow with imposed toroidal magnetic fields. The inner and outer cylinders can be either insulating or conducting; the inner one rotates, the outer one is stationary. The magnetic Prandtl number can be as small as 10-5, approaching realistic liquid-metal values. The magnetic field destabilizes the flow, except for radial profiles of B$_φ$(R) close to the current-free solution. The profile with B$_{in}$=B$_{out}$ (the most uniform field) is considered in detail. For weak fields the TC-flow is stabilized, until for moderately strong fields the m=1 azimuthal mode dramatically destabilizes the flow again. There is thus a maximum value for the critical Reynolds number. For sufficiently strong fields (as measured by the Hartmann number) the toroidal field is always unstable, even for Re=0.
The electric currents needed to generate the required toroidal fields in laboratory experiments are a few kA if liquid sodium is used, somewhat more if gallium is used. Weaker currents are needed for wider gaps, so a wide-gap apparatus could succeed even with gallium. The critical Reynolds numbers are only somewhat larger than the nonmagnetic values, so such an experiment would require only modest rotation rates.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2006; v1 submitted 15 November, 2006;
originally announced November 2006.
-
The stability of MHD Taylor-Couette flow with current-free spiral magnetic fields between conducting cylinders
Authors:
G. Ruediger,
R. Hollerbach,
M. Schultz,
D. A. Shalybkov
Abstract:
We study the magnetorotational instability in cylindrical Taylor-Couette flow, with the (vertically unbounded) cylinders taken to be perfect conductors, and with externally imposed spiral magnetic fields. The azimuthal component of this field is generated by an axial current inside the inner cylinder, and may be slightly stronger than the axial field. We obtain an instability beyond the Rayleigh…
▽ More
We study the magnetorotational instability in cylindrical Taylor-Couette flow, with the (vertically unbounded) cylinders taken to be perfect conductors, and with externally imposed spiral magnetic fields. The azimuthal component of this field is generated by an axial current inside the inner cylinder, and may be slightly stronger than the axial field. We obtain an instability beyond the Rayleigh line, for Reynolds numbers of order 1000 and Hartmann numbers of order 10, and independent of the (small) magnetic Prandtl number. For experiments with R_out = 2 R_in = 10 cm and Omega_out = 0.27 Omega_in, the instability appears for liquid sodium for axial fields of ~20 Gauss and axial currents of \~1200 A. For gallium the numbers are ~50 Gauss and ~3200 A. The vertical cell size is about twice the cell size known for nonmagnetic experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2005;
originally announced July 2005.
-
Stability of density-stratified viscous Taylor-Couette flows
Authors:
D. Shalybkov,
G. Ruediger
Abstract:
The stability of density-stratified viscous Taylor-Couette flows is considered using the Boussinesq approximation but without any use of the short-wave approximation. The flows which are unstable after the Rayleigh criterion (\hat μ<\hat η^2, with \hat μ=Ω_{out}/Ω_{in} and \hat η= R_{in}/R_{out}) now develop overstable axisymmetric Taylor vortices. For the considered wide-gap container we find t…
▽ More
The stability of density-stratified viscous Taylor-Couette flows is considered using the Boussinesq approximation but without any use of the short-wave approximation. The flows which are unstable after the Rayleigh criterion (\hat μ<\hat η^2, with \hat μ=Ω_{out}/Ω_{in} and \hat η= R_{in}/R_{out}) now develop overstable axisymmetric Taylor vortices. For the considered wide-gap container we find the nonaxisymmetric modes as the most unstable ones. The nonaxisymmetric modes are unstable also beyond the Rayleigh line. For such modes the instability condition seems simply to be \hatμ<1 as stressed by Yavneh, McWilliams & Molemaker (2001). However, we never found unstable modes for too flat rotation laws fulfilling the condition \hat μ>\hat η. The Reynolds numbers rapidly grow to very high values if this limit is approached (see Figs. 3 and 4).
Also striking is that the marginal stability lines for the higher $m$ do less and less enter the region beyond the Rayleigh line so that we might have to consider the stratorotational instability as a 'low-$m$ instability'. The applicability of these results to the stability problem of accretion disks with their strong stratification and fast rotation is shortly discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2005; v1 submitted 10 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
The linear MHD Taylor-Couette instability for liquid sodium
Authors:
G. Rüdiger,
M. Schultz,
D. Shalybkov
Abstract:
The linear stability of MHD Taylor-Couette flow of infinite vertical extension is considered for liquid sodium with its small magnetic Prandtl number Pm of order of 10^-5 and an uniform axial magnetic field. The sign of the constant a in the basic rotation law Ω=a+b/R^2 strongly influences the presented results. It is negative for resting outer cylinder. The main point here is that the subcritic…
▽ More
The linear stability of MHD Taylor-Couette flow of infinite vertical extension is considered for liquid sodium with its small magnetic Prandtl number Pm of order of 10^-5 and an uniform axial magnetic field. The sign of the constant a in the basic rotation law Ω=a+b/R^2 strongly influences the presented results. It is negative for resting outer cylinder. The main point here is that the subcritical excitation which occurs for large Pm disappears for small Pm. This is the reason that the existence of the magnetorotational instability remained unknown over decades. For rotating outer cylinder the limiting case a=0 plays an exceptional role. The hydromagnetic instability exists with certain Reynolds numbers at certain Hartmann numbers of the magnetic field. These Reynolds numbers exactly scale with Pm^-1/2 resulting in moderate values of order 10^4 for Pm=10^-5. However, already for the smallest positive value of a the Reynolds numbers start to scale as 1/Pm leading to much higher values of order 10^6 for Pm=10^-5. Also nonaxisymmetric modes have been considered. With vacuum boundary conditions their excitation is always more difficult than the excitation of axisymmetric modes; we never observed a crossover of the lines of marginal stability. For conducting walls, however, such crossovers exist for both resting and rotating outer cylinders, and this might be essential for future dynamo experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2002;
originally announced December 2002.
-
Nonaxisymmetric patterns in the linear theory of MHD Taylor-Couette instability
Authors:
D. A. Shalybkov,
G. Rüdiger,
M. Schultz
Abstract:
The linear stability of MHD Taylor-Couette flow of infinite vertical extension is considered for various magnetic Prandtl numbers Pm. The calculations are performed for a wide gap container with \hatη=0.5 with an axial uniform magnetic field excluding counterrotating cylinders. For both hydrodynamically stable and unstable flows the magnetorotational instability produces characteristic minima of…
▽ More
The linear stability of MHD Taylor-Couette flow of infinite vertical extension is considered for various magnetic Prandtl numbers Pm. The calculations are performed for a wide gap container with \hatη=0.5 with an axial uniform magnetic field excluding counterrotating cylinders. For both hydrodynamically stable and unstable flows the magnetorotational instability produces characteristic minima of the Reynolds number for certain (low) magnetic field amplitudes and Pm> 0.01. For Pm <~ 1 there is a characteristic magnetic field amplitude beyond which the instability sets in in form of nonaxisymmetric spirals with the azimuthal number m=1. Obviously, the magnetic field is able to excite nonaxisymmetric configurations despite of the tendency of differential rotation to favor axisymmetric magnetic fields which is known from the dynamo theory. If Pm is too big or too small, however, the axisymmetric mode with m=0 appears to be the most unstable one possessing the lowest Reynolds numbers -- as it is also true for hydrodynamic Taylor-Couette flow or for very weak fields. That the most unstable mode for modest Pm proves to be nonaxisymmetric must be considered as a strong indication for the possibility of dynamo processes in connection with the magnetorotational instability.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2002;
originally announced July 2002.
-
Hydrodynamic stability in accretion disks under the combined influence of shear and density stratification
Authors:
G. Rüdiger,
R. Arlt,
D. Shalybkov
Abstract:
The hydrodynamic stability of accretion disks is considered. The particular question is whether the combined action of a (stable) vertical density stratification and a (stable) radial differential rotation gives rise to a new instability for nonaxisymmetric modes of disturbances. The existence of such an instability is not suggested by the well-known Solberg-Hoiland criterion. It is also not sug…
▽ More
The hydrodynamic stability of accretion disks is considered. The particular question is whether the combined action of a (stable) vertical density stratification and a (stable) radial differential rotation gives rise to a new instability for nonaxisymmetric modes of disturbances. The existence of such an instability is not suggested by the well-known Solberg-Hoiland criterion. It is also not suggested by a local analysis for disturbances in general stratifications of entropy and angular momentum which is presented in our Section 2 confirming the results of the Solberg-Hoiland criterion also for nonaxisymmetric modes within the frame of ideal hydrodynamics but only in the frame of a short-wave approximation for small m. As a necessary condition for stability we find that only conservative external forces are allowed to influence the stable disk. As magnetic forces are never conservative, linear disk instabilities should only exist in the magnetohydrodynamical regime which indeed contains the magnetorotational instability as a much-promising candidate. To overcome some of the used approximations in a numerical approach,the equations of the compressible adiabatic hydrodynamics are integrated imposing initial nonaxisymmetric velocity perturbations with m=1 to m=200.
Only solutions with decaying kinetic energy are found. The system always settles in a vertical equilibrium stratification according to pressure balance with the gravitational potential of the central object. keywords: accretion disks -- hydrodynamic instabilities -- turbulence
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2002;
originally announced February 2002.
-
The stability of axisymmetric Taylor-Couette flow in hydromagnetics
Authors:
G. Ruediger,
D. Shalybkov
Abstract:
The linear marginal instability of an axisymmetric MHD Taylor-Couette flow of infinite vertical extension is considered. The dependence of the flow stability on magnetic Prandtl number, Pm, and gap-width between rotating cylinders is investigated. There is an unstability for flows with resting outer cylinder even without a magnetic field. Nevertheless, there are solutions with smaller critical R…
▽ More
The linear marginal instability of an axisymmetric MHD Taylor-Couette flow of infinite vertical extension is considered. The dependence of the flow stability on magnetic Prandtl number, Pm, and gap-width between rotating cylinders is investigated. There is an unstability for flows with resting outer cylinder even without a magnetic field. Nevertheless, there are solutions with smaller critical Reynolds numbers for certain (weak) magnetic fields. These solutions, however, exist for not too small Pm or large enough gap. For hydrodynamically stable flow, we found that a magnetic field amplitude always exsits where the critical Reynolds number is minimal. In all calculated cases the minimal critical Reynolds numbers are running with 1/Pm for small Pm and the critical Reynolds numbers exceed value of 10^6 for Pm of sodium (10^{-5}) or gallium (10^{-6}).
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2001;
originally announced October 2001.
-
MHD Instability in cylindric Taylor-Couette flow
Authors:
G. Rüdiger,
D. A. Shalybkov
Abstract:
The linear marginal instability of an axisymmetric MHD Taylor-Couette flow of infinite vertical extension is considered. For flows with a resting outer cylinder there is a well-known characteristic Reynolds number even without magnetic field but for sufficiently weak magnetic fields there are solutions with smaller Reynolds numbers so that a characteristic minimum exists. The minimum only exists…
▽ More
The linear marginal instability of an axisymmetric MHD Taylor-Couette flow of infinite vertical extension is considered. For flows with a resting outer cylinder there is a well-known characteristic Reynolds number even without magnetic field but for sufficiently weak magnetic fields there are solutions with smaller Reynolds numbers so that a characteristic minimum exists. The minimum only exists, however, for not too small magnetic Prandtl numbers. For small magnetic Prandtl numbers one only finds the typical magnetic suppression of the instability.
We are here particularly interested in the case where the outer cylinder rotates so fast that the Rayleigh criterion for hydrodynamic stability is fulfilled. We find that for given magnetic Prandtl number now always a magnetic field amplitude exists where the characteristic Reynolds number is minimal. These critical values are computed for different magnetic Prandtl numbers. In all cases the Reynolds numbers are running with 1/Pm so that for the small magnetic Prandtl numbers of sodium (10^-5) or gallium (10^-6) the critical Reynolds numbers exceed values of 10^6 or 10^, resp.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2001;
originally announced August 2001.
-
Jet launching theory and the vertical structure of a magnetically-dominated thin accretion disc
Authors:
G. Rudiger,
D. A. Shalybkov
Abstract:
The presence of an imposed external magnetic field may drastically influence the structure of thin accretion discs. The magnetic field energy is here assumed to be in balance with the thermal energy of the accretion flow. The vertical magnetic field, its toroidal component B^tor at the disc surface (due to different rotation rates between disc and its magnetosphere), the turbulent magnetic Prand…
▽ More
The presence of an imposed external magnetic field may drastically influence the structure of thin accretion discs. The magnetic field energy is here assumed to be in balance with the thermal energy of the accretion flow. The vertical magnetic field, its toroidal component B^tor at the disc surface (due to different rotation rates between disc and its magnetosphere), the turbulent magnetic Prandtl number and the viscosity-alpha are the key parameters of our model. Inside the corotation radius for rather small B^tor the resulting inclination angle i of the magnetic field lines to the disc surface normal can exceed the critical value 30^\circ (required to launch cold jets) even for small magnetic Prandtl numbers of order unity. The self-consistent consideration of both magnetic field and accretion flow demonstrates a weak dependence of the inclination (``dragging'') angle on the magnetic Prandtl number for given surface density but a strong dependence on the toroidal field component at the disc surface.
A magnetic disc is thicker than a nonmagnetic one for typical parameter values. The accretion rate can be strongly amplified by large B^tor and small magnetic Prandtl number. On the other hand, for given accretion rate the magnetised disc is less massive than the standard-alpha disc. The surface values of the toroidal magnetic fields which are necessary to induce considerably high values for the inclination angle are much smaller than expected and are of order 10^-3 of the imposed vertical field. As the innermost part of the disc produces the largest B^tor, the largest radial inclination can be expected also there. The idea is therefore supported that the cold jets are launched only in the central disc area.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2001;
originally announced June 2001.
